Perceived self-motion in two visual contexts: dissociable mechanisms underlie perception

We evaluated the influence of moving visual scenes and knowledge of spatial and physical context on visually induced self-motion perception in an immersive virtual environment. A sinusoidal, vertically oscillating visual stimulus induced perceptions of self-motion that matched changes in visual acceleration. Subjects reported peaks of perceived self-motion in synchrony with peaks of visual acceleration and opposite in direction to visual scene motion. Spatial context was manipulated by testing subjects in the environment that matched the room in the visual scene or by testing them in a separate chamber. Physical context was manipulated by testing the subject while seated in a stable, earth-fixed desk chair or in an apparatus capable of large linear motions, however, in both conditions no actual motion occurred. The compellingness of perceived self-motion was increased significantly when the spatial context matched the visual input and actual body displacement was possible, however, the latency and amplitude of perceived self-motion were unaffected by the spatial or physical context. We propose that two dissociable processes are involved in self-motion perception: one process, primarily driven by visual input, affects vection latency and path integration, the other process, receiving cognitive input, drives the compellingness of perceived self-motion.     

Influence of visually induced self-motion on postural stability

CONCLUSION: Our results indicate that the illusion of self-motion is a significant factor leading to spatial disorientation. OBJECTIVE: Under normal circumstances, self-motion is perceived in response to motion of the head and body. However, under certain conditions, such as virtual reality environments, visually induced self-motion can be perceived even though the subject is not actually moving, a phenomenon known as "vection". The aim of this study was to examine the possible influence of illusory self-rotation (circular vection) on postural adjustments. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The subjects were 10 young females with no history of ocular or vestibular disease. Video-motion analysis was applied to measure postural movements during vertical optokinetic stimulation. RESULTS: For most subjects, movement of the visual surroundings induced head and body displacements in the same direction as that of the visual stimulus, regardless of the onset of self-motion perception. However, there was a significant increase in postural instability after the subjects began to perceive false self-motion in the opposite direction to that of the visual stimulus.     

Influence of visually induced self-motion on postural stability

Conclusion Our results indicate that the illusion of self-motion is a significant factor leading to spatial disorientation.

Objective Under normal circumstances, self-motion is perceived in response to motion of the head and body. However, under certain conditions, such as virtual reality environments, visually induced self-motion can be perceived even though the subject is not actually moving, a phenomenon known as “vection”. The aim of this study was to examine the possible influence of illusory self-rotation (circular vection) on postural adjustments.

Material and methods The subjects were 10 young females with no history of ocular or vestibular disease. Video-motion analysis was applied to measure postural movements during vertical optokinetic stimulation.

Results For most subjects, movement of the visual surroundings induced head and body displacements in the same direction as that of the visual stimulus, regardless of the onset of self-motion perception. However, there was a significant increase in postural instability after the subjects began to perceive false self-motion in the opposite direction to that of the visual stimulus.     

Effect of ethanol on dynamic visual acuity during vertical body oscillation in healthy volunteers

Visual orientation is the most important sensory input during locomotion (e.g. walking, driving a car, riding a bicycle). We investigated dynamic visual acuity (DVA) during vertical body-oscillations (amplitude 5 cm; frequency 1.5 Hz) in 12 healthy subjects before and twice after ethanol consumption. During oscillation, vertical eye movements were recorded under two test conditions: with eyes closed (EC) and during DVA testing. A significant increase in vertical eye-amplitude after ethanol ingestion occurred only during EC tests, as a possible sign of vestibular hyperreaction. During vestibular stimulation alone (EC), ethanol did not affect the phase shift between stimulus and eye movements. However, when the subjects were given an additional visual stimulus (DVA), the post-alcohol phase shift rose significantly. Surprisingly, the post-alcohol phase shift values for the two test conditions showed no significant differences. After ethanol ingestion we found no changes in static visual acuity but a significant loss of DVA. Volunteers with a change of DVA threshold (DVAT) showed significantly (P = 0.004) higher post-alcoholic changes in the phase shift. In summary, low doses of ethanol disturbed the visually guided oculomotor response during fixation of an earth-fixed target while the observer was subject to linear vertical acceleration. This effect led to an increasing delay between the beginning of body and eye movements. The consequence was an increasing phase shift and thus a decrease in DVA during whole-body oscillation which was comparable to movements during human locomotion. Received: 8 March 2000 / Accepted: 18 April 2000     

Postural responses exhibit multisensory dependencies with discordant visual and support surface motion

The purpose of this study was to identify how the postural system weights coincident yet discordant disturbances of the visual and proprioceptive/vestibular systems. Eleven healthy subjects (25-38 yrs) received either fore-aft translations of an immersive, wide field-of-view visual environment (0.1 Hz, +/- 3.7 m/sec), or anterior-posterior translations of the support surface (0.25 Hz, +/- 15 cm/sec), or both concurrently. Kinematics of the head, trunk, and shank were collected with an Optotrak system and angular motion of each segment plotted across time. With only support surface translation, segmental responses were small (1 degrees -2 degrees ) and mostly opposed the direction of sled translation. When only the visual scene was moving, segmental responses increased as the trial progressed. When the inputs were presented coincidentally, response amplitudes were large even at the onset of the trial. Mean RMS values across subjects were significantly greater with combined stimuli than for either stimulus presented alone and areas under the power curve across subjects were significantly increased at the frequency of the visual input when both inputs were presented. Thus, intra-modality dependencies were observed, such that responses to the visual inputs significantly increased and responses to the somatosensory signals reflected the stimulus amplitude only when the two inputs were combined. We believe it unlikely that the role of any single pathway contributing to postural control can be accurately characterized in a static environment if the function of that pathway is context dependent.     

One second interval production task during post-rotatory sensation

Temporal intervals production of one second was found to be more variable during self-motion compared to no motion situations. Moreover, the temporal intervals production rhythm during self-motion deceleration decreased whereas it increased during self-motion acceleration, whatever the direction of motion. As somatosensory cues were not excluded in this previous experiment, we now examined whether the same temporal perturbation would occur without variable somatosensory information. In order to isolate the contribution of the vestibular system from that of the somatosensory system, the participants were required to perform a one second temporal interval production task (pressing a button each second) during the post-rotatory illusion following self-rotation. The intervals produced during the vestibular illusion were compared to those produced before the imposed rotation and during self-motion. The production regularity was affected as the temporal intervals were more variable with vestibular stimulation (real and illusory self-motion) than without. Furthermore, during post-rotatory illusion, the production rhythm decreased along the trial, as it was observed during self-motion deceleration. These findings suggest that vestibular stimulation (even vestibular illusion) impaired time estimation.     

How to use body tilt for the simulation of linear self motion

We examined to what extent body tilt may augment the perception of visually simulated linear self acceleration. Fourteen subjects judged visual motion profiles of fore-aft motion at four different frequencies between 0.04-0.33 Hz, and at three different acceleration amplitudes (0.44, 0.88 and 1.76 m/s(2)). Simultaneously, subjects were tilted backward and forward about their pitch axis. The amplitude of pitch tilt was systematically varied. Using a two-alternative-forced-choice paradigm, psychometric curves were calculated in order to determine: 1) the minimum tilt amplitude required to generate a linear self-motion percept in more than 50% of the cases, and 2) the maximum tilt amplitude at which rotation remains sub-threshold in more than 50% of the cases. The results showed that the simulation of linear self motion became more realistic with the application of whole body tilt, as long as the tilt rate remained under the detection threshold of about 3 deg/s. This value is in close agreement with the empirical rate limit commonly used in flight simulation. The minimum required motion cue was inversely proportional to stimulus frequency, and increased with the amplitude of the visual displacement (rather than acceleration). As a consequence, the range of useful tilt stimuli became more critical with increasing stimulus frequency. We conclude that this psychophysical approach reveals valid parameters for motion driving algorithms used in motion base simulators.     

The influence of an immersive virtual environment on the segmental organization of postural stabilizing responses

We examined the effect of a 3-dimensional stereoscopic scene on segmental stabilization. Eight subjects participated in static sway and locomotion experiments with a visual scene that moved sinusoidally or at constant velocity about the pitch or roll axes. Segmental displacements, Fast Fourier Transforms, and Root Mean Square values were calculated. In both pitch and roll, subjects exhibited greater magnitudes of motion in head and trunk than ankle. Smaller amplitudes and frequent phase reversals suggested control of the ankle by segmental proprioceptive inputs and ground reaction forces rather than by the visual-vestibular signals. Postural controllers may set limits of motion at each body segment rather than be governed solely by a perception of the visual vertical. Two locomotor strategies were also exhibited, implying that some subjects could override the effect of the roll axis optic flow field. Our results demonstrate task dependent differences that argue against using static postural responses to moving visual fields when assessing more dynamic tasks.     

A comparison of the latencies of visually induced postural change and self-motion perception.

This study compared the latencies of visually induced postural change and self-motion perception under identical visual conditions. The results showed that a visual roll stimulus elicits postural tilt in the direction of scene motion and an increase in postural instability several seconds before the subject begins to perceive illusory self-motion (vection) in the opposite direction. Postural and vection latencies correlate highly with one another, but bear little relationship with the magnitude of either sway or vection.     

Dynamic visual acuity during linear acceleration along the inter-aural axis

We investigated visual-vestibular interactions during linear acceleration along the inter-aural axis. Eighteen healthy volunteers and two patients with central neurological diseases were subjected to transaural linear acceleration in the direction of gravity force (frequency: 0.5–1.5 Hz; amplitude: 5 cm). During linear acceleration, eye movements were recorded under three test conditions: eyes closed (EC), while staring at an imaginary target (IT) and during the testing of dynamic visual acuity (DVA). As parameters of evaluation we used the amplitude of horizontal eye movements, phase shift and the decrease of DVA threshold (DVAT). Under all test conditions, eye amplitude increased with rising stimulus frequency and exceeded, especially in the higher frequency range, a hypothetically calculated eye amplitude for smooth pursuit. The combination of a visual and vestibular input (DVA and IT) led to a better compensation (lower phase shift) than under vestibular stimulation alone (EC). Eye movements during low-frequency stimulation depended more on the visual system while responses in the higher frequency range were mainly triggered by the otolith organ. At 1.5 Hz the compensatory function of the visual-vestibular system was limited (rising phase shift) and DVAT decreased even in a significant number of healthy subjects. Patients with diseases of the central nervous system showed a higher phase shift and thus a stronger decrease of DVAT (two levels) already at a stimulus frequency of 1.25 Hz. Received: 29 May 1999 / Accepted: 2 September 1999     

Human Visual and Vestibular Heading Perception in the Vertical Planes

Heading estimation has not previously been reported in the vertical planes. This is a potentially interesting issue because although distribution of neuronal direction sensitivities is near uniform for vertical headings, there is an overrepresentation of otolith organs sensitive to motion in the horizontal relative to the vertical plane. Furthermore, thresholds of horizontal motion perception are considerably lower than those of vertical motion which has the potential to bias heading perception. The current data from 14 human subjects (age 19 to 67) measured heading estimation in response to vestibular motion of 14 cm (28 cm/s) over a 360 ° of headings at 5 ° intervals. An analogous visual motion was tested in separate trials. In this study, earth and head vertical/horizontal were always aligned. Results demonstrated that the horizontal component of heading was overestimated relative to the vertical component for vestibular heading stimuli in the coronal (skew) and sagittal (elevation) planes. For visual headings, the bias was much smaller and in the opposite direction such that the vertical component of heading was overestimated. Subjects older than 50 had significantly worse precision and larger biases relative to that of younger subjects for the vestibular conditions, although visual heading estimates were similar. A vector addition model was fit to the data which explains the observed heading biases by the known distribution of otolith organs in humans. The greatly decreased precision with age is explained by the model with decreases in end organ numbers, and relatively greater loss of otoliths that are sensitive to vertical motion.     

Dynamic and static subjective visual vertical with aging

Objective: Our vestibular function is gradually deteriorating during aging, although, its behavioral consequences are not easily recognized due to a substitution process by other sensory modalities as visual or proprioceptive inputs. Methods: To reveal such a hidden substitution process by visual signals, the measurement of the static as well as the dynamic subjective visual vertical (SVV) was performed among 63 healthy subjects of different age. Results: The static SVV was found to be stable among all subjects, whereas the shift of the dynamic SVV during rotation of a background scene gradually increased with age. Conclusion: This result indicates that the substitution process identified as a function of age in a perceptual test may have its counterpart in postural stabilizing reflex.     

The human oculomotor response to simultaneous visual and physical movements at two different frequencies

In order to investigate interactions in the visual and vestibular systems' oculomotor response to linear movement, we developed a two-frequency stimulation technique. Thirteen subjects lay on their backs and were oscillated sinusoidally along their z-axes at between 0.31 and 0.81 Hz. During the oscillation subjects viewed a large, high-contrast, visual pattern oscillating in the same direction as the physical motion but at a different, non-harmonically related frequency. The evoked eye movements were measured by video-oculography and spectrally analysed. We found significant signal level at the sum and difference frequencies as well as at other frequencies not present in either stimulus. The emergence of new frequencies indicates non-linear processing consistent with an agreement-detector system that have previously proposed.     

Effect of angular acceleration on the localization performance of a remembered target

Both the influence of a remembered "earth-fixed" target (RT) on the vestibulo-ocular reflex and the effect of "unilateral cold caloric vestibular stimulation" on the localization of a RT have previously been proved. As "unilateral caloric stimulation" is not a physiological stimulus, the aim of the present study was to analyze whether even physiological "bilateral vestibular stimulation" (rotation) is able to affect the RT position. The pointing error (PE) towards an RT both without and following angular acceleration was investigated in 24 healthy volunteers. Postrotatory nystagmus response was recorded by electronystagmography. Evaluation parameters were "nystagmus frequency", "total amplitude" and "velocity of the slow phase"; the horizontal and vertical PE. The fixation of an RT led to a significant reduction of about 28% in nystagmus amplitude compared to the test condition in darkness. "After rotatory stimulation" a systematic horizontal PE in the direction of the fast phase of the postrotatory nystagmus (direction of "illusory self-rotation") occurred and the magnitude of this PE increased significantly compared to the test situation "without vestibular stimulation", but showed only a non-uniform negative correlation with two of the nystagmus parameters. It has to be concluded that "after rotatory stimulation", in contrast to "unilateral cold caloric vestibular stimulation", the subjective sense of "illusory self-motion" leads to a horizontal PE in the direction of the nystagmus fast phases.     

Directional preponderance in pitch circular vection

We used optokinetic stimulation (OKS) in eighteen normal adults aged 18-30 years to investigate vertical self-motion perception. In order to induce self-rotation, either a stripe pattern or a random dot pattern was projected onto the inner wall of a hemispherical dome with a diameter of 150 cm. The pattern was rotated either about the subject's vertical axis (yaw) or about the subject's interaural axis (pitch) for 80 s at a constant acceleration of 1 deg/s2. Stimuli were randomly repeated three to four times in each direction. The latency of onset as well as the perceived intensity of circular vection (CV) was measured for each stimulus presentation. CV latencies for upward rotational stimulation were significantly longer than those for downward rotational stimulation under both types of stimulus conditions. There was no significant difference in CV latency between rightward and leftward rotational stimulation. For most subjects, the magnitudes of the perceived CV for rightward rotational stimulation were equal to those for leftward rotational stimulation, whereas the magnitudes of the perceived CV for vertical stimulation showed large intersubject variability. These results provide additional evidence that fundamental differences exist between different types of self-motion. Possible explanations for the directional asymmetry in vertical perception of self-motion will also be discussed.     

Computerized dynamic posturography and seasickness susceptibility

OBJECTIVE/HYPOTHESIS: The neural mismatch theory emphasizes the role of conflicting multimodal sensory interactions in producing both motion sickness and the rearrangement process that finally leads to habituation to the adverse motion conditions. If this theory is, indeed, correct, the patterns of the response to the integrated signal from simultaneous multisensory stimulation, characterized by unusual relationships between the senses responsible for spatial orientation, should differ according to motion sickness susceptibility. Computerized dynamic posturography (CDP) provides the opportunity to simultaneously change the interactions between visual, somatosensory, and vestibular inputs, thus giving an indication of the relative importance of these senses in maintaining balance. The objective was to investigate balance strategies in naval crew members with differing susceptibility to sea conditions using CDP. STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional, parallel-group design. METHODS: Twenty subjects susceptible to seasickness (SS) and 20 nonsusceptible subjects (NSS), healthy male volunteers aged 18 to 25, were tested using the EquiTest system (NeuroCom, Inc., Clackamas, OR). RESULTS: The SS group exhibited significantly less stability than the NSS group in condition 5 of the sensory organization test (SOT). The ratio of the SOT scores of conditions 5 to 1 (the vestibular organization pattern) was also found to be significantly lower in the SS group. CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest that SS might be more dependent on somatosensory and visual inputs and less on vestibular inputs for maintenance of balance compared with NSS. Higher susceptibility to seasickness might reflect abnormal weighting of sensory modalities during the integration process. This would result in disruption of the integration process required to maintain balance and a sense of orientation in space in conditions producing conflicting sensory inputs.     

Optokinetic and vestibular interactions with smooth pursuit: psychophysical responses.

The effect was evaluated in normal subjects of the subjective perception of motion of a small visual target (VT) when combined with the effect of vestibular stimulation produced by different magnitudes of constant angular accelerations in the dark or the effect of optokinetic stimulation produced by different constant velocities of rotation. The visual target appeared to the subject to travel more slowly and for a shorter duration when it moved in the direction of the body's angular acceleration or against that of the optokinetic drum. The perceived error in motion was: (i) in the same direction as the subject's motion sensation produced by either of the two stimuli, and (ii) quantitatively related, although differently, to the magnitude of each of the two stimulus modalities; an heuristic model is proposed to account for these observations.     

Perception of horizontal head and trunk rotation in patients with loss of vestibular functions.

In patients with loss of vestibular functions, we studied psychophysically the self-motion perception for 'trunk in space' and 'head in space' during various combinations of horizontal head and trunk rotation in the dark. The results were compared to those of normal subjects. For their 'trunk in space' perception, the subjects relied on their internal image of space, derived from the vestibular receptors in the head, and referred their trunk to this as a reference by adding to it a nuchal trunk-to-head signal. The patients, by contrast, always considered the trunk as stationary. Obviously because they were devoid of any space cues, they abandoned or suppressed a neck contribution to their 'trunk in space' perception, which, in fact, would yield an erroneous perception in almost all conditions in the dark. Both the patients and the subjects based their 'head in space' perception on their internal representation of 'trunk in space' and added to this a nuchal head-to-trunk signal. However, the patients' head-to-trunk signal, unlike that of the subjects, was considerably larger than the actual head-to-trunk rotation at low stimulus frequency. We relate this finding to some unconscious modification of their neck muscle activity during passive head rotation. It appears that the patients' gain of the neck input per se is not increased, but rather that subsets of this input are modified according to the particular function they serve.     

Contribution of the vestibular apparatus to postural control when rising from a chair

OBJECTIVE: The everyday act of rising from a chair is known to require the combined angular control of a number of the body's joints, especially those within the pitch plane. Precisely how this control is exerted, however, remains controversial. The aim of this study was to obtain a better understanding of the contribution made by the vestibular apparatus to postural control of the body and head when an individual rises from a chair. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A total of 24 healthy controls and 38 patients with varying degrees of vestibular dysfunction were examined. Electromagnetic motion sensors were used to analyze the angular control of the head and body as subjects rose from a chair with their eyes open or closed. RESULTS: We found that unilateral vestibular dysfunction caused fixation of the head with respect to the body, resulting in a loss of spatial stability of the head which was not compensated for by visual input. Visual input did appear to compensate for bilateral vestibular loss, enabling patients with bilateral vestibular apparatus impairment or central disorders to fix the position of their head in space. CONCLUSION: The act of rising from a chair is normally controlled by vestibular and proprioceptive input; the head is aligned according to the gravitational reference so as to obtain stable visual information. In patients with unilateral vestibular hypofunction, posture is still controlled by these two inputs, although the ability to align the head is diminished. In patients with bilateral vestibular hypofunction or a central disorder, head alignment is maintained using visual input, although it may not be the sole or predominant stabilizing force.     

Experimental study of the whole body response in rabbits by linear oscillatory acceleration and/or optokinetic stimulation

Motion sickness may be defined as an abnormal body response caused to certain kinds of motion in normal subjects. Although we know etiologic factors and symptoms of motion sickness, the mechanism of motion sickness remains unknown. To clarify some characteristics of motion sickness in rabbits, we observed responses of the autonomic nervous system consisting of a change in heart rate (HR), coefficient of variation of R-R interval (CV-RR), and serum adrenaline (AD) -and free fatty acid (FFA) concentrations during linear oscillatory acceleration and/or optokinetic stimulation. The following results were obtained as 1. Although transverse and vertical linear oscillatory accelerations affected little the body responses, longitudinal linear oscillatory acceleration diminished HR and increased CV-RR and FFA. 2. Since injection of atropine or labyrinthectomy reduced the changes of HR and CV-RR induced by longitudinal linear oscillatory acceleration the responses may originate from the vestibulo-parasympathetic nerve reflex. 3. An increase of FFA during longitudinal linear oscillatory acceleration indicates that sympathetic nerve as well as parasympathetic nerve activities are elevated. 4. In this study optokinetic stimulation was not so influential as linear oscillatory acceleration for provoking motion sickness in rabbits. 5. Concomitant stimulations of optokinetic and vestibular inputs enlarged variations of these responses.