A pilot safety and immunogenicity study of the malaria vaccine SPf66 in Gambian infants

A pilot safety and immunogenicity trial of the malaria vaccine SPf66 has been undertaken in 150 Gambian infants. No significant systemic side effects were recorded but modest local reactions were seen after the administration of a third 1.0 mg dose. SPf66 produced in Colombia was more immunogenic than SPf66 produced in the USA and a 1.0 mg dose of each vaccine gave higher antibody levels than a 0.5 mg dose. However, antibody levels fell rapidly after administration of the third dose of vaccine and showed little change over the following malaria transmission season. The incidence of clinical malaria was higher among children who received SPf66 than among children who received inactivated polio vaccine, the effect being most marked among children who received 1.0 mg Colombian SPf66. As the trial was not designed to measure the effect of SPf66 on morbidity from malaria, the significance of this finding is uncertain.     

Serological responses of Gambian children to immunization with the malaria vaccine SPf66

Antibody responses to the malaria vaccine SPf66 and to its constituent peptides were measured over a period of 2 years in Gambian children who had been immunized with SPf66 or with a control vaccine (inactivated polio vaccine). Three hundred and six of 308 children (99%) who had received three doses of SPf66 vaccine had antibodies to SPf66 at a level above that found in European controls who had not been exposed to malaria. Responses to the constituent peptides derived from 35.1, 55.1 and 83.1-kDa proteins were found in 88%, 97% and 97% of children, respectively; 26% had an antibody response to the NANP repeat peptide of circumsporozoite protein which is also included in the SPf66 vaccine. A response to SPf66 was found in 22% of children who had received the control vaccine. Antibody responses to NANP, 35.1, 55.1 and 83.1-kDa peptide were found in 3%, 33%, 49% and 33% of these children. Overall, no significant correlation was found between the level of anti-SPf66 antibody at the beginning of the malaria transmission season following vaccination and the subsequent risk of malaria. However, further analysis showed that among the control children who had acquired antibodies to SPf66 as a result of natural exposure to malaria, those with high levels of anti-SPf66 were less at risk of malaria, perhaps reflecting their greater previous exposure and thus immunity. In contrast, among children who had received three doses of SPf66, those with high antibody levels were at greater risk of have malaria during the subsequent malaria transmission season.     

Evaluation of the SPf66 vaccine for malaria control when delivered through the EPI scheme in Tanzania

BACKGROUND: Malaria control programmes need to protect young children, who bear the brunt of malaria disease and death in Africa. The development of a vaccine is a priority if improved and sustained malaria control is to be achieved. The best use of a vaccine in Africa will be achieved if it can be delivered through the expanded programme of immunization (EPI). We conducted a trial designed to evaluate the efficacy of SPf66 vaccine for malaria control when delivered through the EPI scheme in Tanzania. METHODS: The study was a two-arm, double blind, individually randomized placebo controlled trial involving 1207 infants. The primary objective of the trial was to estimate the efficacy of three doses of SPf66 given at 1, 2 and 7 months of age in preventing clinical episodes of malaria. These were documented through a health facility-based passive case detection system. RESULTS: Among 1207 randomized children, overall compliance for third dose was 91%. SPf66 was safe, immunogenic and did not interfere with the humoral immune responses to EPI vaccines. There were 294 children among SPf66 recipients and 288 among placebo recipients with at least one malaria episode, yielding a vaccine efficacy estimate of 2% (95% CI: -16, 16; P = 0.84). CONCLUSION: This has been the first trial of a malaria vaccine among very young infants. It provides information on the safety of peptide vaccines administered at this early age as well as their capacity to induce immune responses without negatively interacting with EPI vaccines. Given the modest protection previously documented in older age groups and the lack of efficacy in younger infants, this vaccine in its current alum-based formulation does not appear to have a role in malaria control in sub-Saharan Africa. The lack of efficacy found in this trial also raises concerns about potential difficulties of inducing protective immune responses against malaria through immunization in infants.     

Determination of the immunization schedule for field trials with the synthetic malaria vaccine SPf 66

The synthetic malaria vaccine SPf 66 has been shown to be safe, immunogenic and effective in trials performed with controlled groups naturally and experimentally exposed to the disease. In order to continue the trials in open populations, it was necessary to standardize the vaccination characteristics. We have performed four field trials with soldier volunteers with the aim, among others, of defining the number of doses required, the intervals between applications, the protein concentration, and the adjuvant to be used. In these trials, the vaccinated individuals' immune responses were evaluated by assaying anti-SPf 66 antibody titres, in vitro growth inhibition of the P. falciparum parasite, and the vaccinees' capacity to recognize P. falciparum native proteins. From these results we conclude that the best vaccination schedule, for adults, is three doses administered subcutaneously on days 0, 30 and 180, each containing 2 mg of the synthetic polymerized petide SPf 66 adsorbed to alum hydroxide.     

Safety in infants of SPf66, a synthetic malaria vaccine, delivered alongside the EPI

The most likely mechanism to deliver a malaria vaccine in African countries is through the Expanded Program of Immunization (EPI). So far only SPf66, a multistage synthetic peptide, has shown any evidence of protection in Phase III field trials. In Tanzania, SPf66 reduced the risk of clinical malaria by 31% in children aged 1-5 years. In order to progress in the critical path of vaccine development and testing towards the implementation of a new vaccine in malaria control programs, we carried out a randomized double-blind placebo controlled efficacy trial of SPf66 when given alongside the EPI scheme. Monitoring of safety and reactogenicity during this trial included detailed clinical and laboratory assessments on 98 infants and assessment of adverse effects within 1 h of vaccination for all 1207 children vaccinated. Surveillance systems monitored attendances as outpatients, admissions to hospital and fatal events in the community. No serious adverse effects were detected more frequently amongst SPf66 recipients compared to placebo. This first assessment in very young infants of a synthetic vaccine provides evidence of a good safety profile.     

In human malaria protective antibodies are directed mainly against the Lys-Glu ion pair within the Lys-Glu-Lys motif of the synthetic vaccine SPf 66

The KEK (Lysine-Glutamic acid-Lysine) motif is frequently found in the primary structure of certain malaria proteins involved in invasion, and plays an important role in the interaction of these proteins with the erythrocyte. This motif is contained in a peptide which forms part of the polymeric synthetic malaria vaccine SPf 66, currently undergoing extensive human trials. Analysis of the antibody titres against the subunit peptides that comprise this vaccine has shown that protection is associated with high titres to the KEK-containing peptide. In this paper we examine the fine recognition of this motif by polyclonal sera from protected vaccinated individuals, demonstrating the critical role played by the interacting ion pair formed between the amino terminal lysine (K) and glutamic acid (E), which act as contact residues for an important proportion of the antibody population directed against this vaccine. This ion pair in the KEK motif constitutes perhaps one of the most important malaria epitopes involved in protection, and could explain the mechanism through which protective immunity is acquired.     

Humoral immune responses during a malaria vaccine trial in Tanzanian infants

The development of a malaria vaccine is a priority for improved and sustained malaria control. Optimal use of a vaccine in Africa will only be achieved if it can be delivered through the Expanded Programme of Immunization (EPI). We have completed a trial of the peptide vaccine SPf66 in Tanzanian infants, given alongside the EPI vaccines. This paper describes the humoral responses to SPf66 and the EPI vaccines. A total of 1207 infants were recruited into a two-arm, double-blind, individually randomized placebo-controlled trial of SPf66. The objectives of the trial were to determine the safety, immunogenicity and efficacy of SPf66 and to assess interactions with EPI vaccines when three doses of SPf66 were delivered alongside the EPI vaccines. Cross-sectional surveys were carried out to asses seroconversion rates to the EPI vaccines and the antibody response to SPf66 (NANP)50 and Plasmodium falciparum lysates. Seroconversion rates to EPI vaccines were high and no statistically significant differences in prevalence or titres were found between SPf66 and placebo recipients. IgG antibodies against SPf66 (NANP)50 and whole P. falciparum lysate were present in high titres in mothers of recruited children at the time of birth. Vaccination with SPf66 stimulated a good anti-SPf66 IgG response which declined to preimmunization levels by 2 years of age and which was not associated with protection against clinical malaria. The vaccine induced no IgG antibodies against (NANP)50 or P. falciparum lysates. SPf66 stimulated a humoral immune response when given to very young infants and did not interfere with seroconversion to EPI vaccines. The response to SPf66 was qualitatively different from that seen in older children, in whom SPf66 has been shown to be moderately efficacious. This difference raises concerns about the difficulties of immunizing very young infants who need to be targeted by antimalarial vaccination programs.     

Assessment of the role of the humoral response to Plasmodium falciparum MSP2 compared to RESA and SPf66 in protecting Papua New Guinean children from clinical malaria

The prevalence and concentration of naturally acquired humoral response (IgG) to merozoite surface protein 2 (MSP2), RESA, SPf66 and crude schizont extract were measured in a population living in a malaria highly endemic area of Papua New Guinea. A prospective longitudinal study in 0–5–15 year old children was conducted for one year in order to examine the relationship between the humoral response to these antigens and subsequent susceptibility to clinical malaria using a series of clinical definitions. The prevalence and concentration of antibodies to all antigens increased with age. Such correlation with age was most marked for MSP2 recombinant proteins. When age and previous exposure were controlled for, only antibody levels to MSP2 recombinant proteins (3D7 andd3D7) and to RESA predicted a reduction in incidence rate of episodes of clinical malaria. Our results support the inclusion of the recombinant proteins of the 3D7 allelic family of merozoite surface antigen 2 and RESA into a subunit vaccine against malaria.,     

Safety and immunogenicity of the synthetic malaria vaccine SPf66 in a large field trial.

In the first field trial with synthetic malaria vaccine SPf66 in a large population naturally exposed to malaria, 9957 persons greater than 1 year old and residing on the Colombian Pacific coast received three doses of the vaccine. To evaluate vaccine safety, clinical observations were made 30 min and 48 h after each immunization. There were no adverse reactions in 95.7% of cases. In the 4.3% of cases with adverse reactions, local induration and erythema were the most frequent. In a randomly selected group of vaccinees, anti-SPf66 antibody titers were measured after the third dose: 93% of the vaccinees raised antibodies to SPf66. Among these, 55% had titers greater than 1:1600. These results demonstrate the safety and immunogenicity of the SPf66 vaccine in a large field trial.     

Improving the immunogenicity and protective efficacy of a whole-killed malaria blood-stage vaccine by chloroquine

A whole-killed malaria blood-stage vaccine (WKV) is promising in reducing the morbidity and mortality of malaria patients, but its efficacy needs to be improved. We found that the antimalarial drug chloroquine could augment the protective efficacy of the WKV of Plasmodium yoelii. The direct antimalarial effect of chloroquine on parasites during immunization could be excluded, as the administration of chloroquine or chloroquine plus alum every two weeks had a slight effect on parasitemia, and an immunization with NP-KLH (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenylacetyl Keyhole Limpet Hemocyanin) plus chloroquine could significantly promote the generation of NP-specific antibodies. Additionally, alum was required for chloroquine to augment the immunogenicity of the pRBC lysate. Chloroquine did not promote the parasite-specific CD4⁺ T-cell responses, but significantly enhanced the WKV-induced germinal centre B cell reactions, class-switch recombination and secretion of functionally protective antibodies to plasmodium. The elevated parasite-specific antibodies were demonstrated to largely contribute to the chloroquine-enhanced protective immunity. Thus, we report that chloroquine could be used as an adjuvant to enhance the protective immunity of WKVs through promoting humoral responses.     

Immune responses to Plasmodium falciparum antigens during a malaria vaccine trial in Tanzanian children

Among Tanzanian children living in an area of intense and perennial malaria transmission, prevalence of naturally acquired IgG antibodies that recognize SPf66, NANP, p190 and a 19 kDa fragment of the merozoite surface protein-1 (MSP-1) is high and increases with age. This possibly reflects the high level of natural exposure of the children to P. falciparum. The prevalences of IgG antibodies that recognize the three putative merozoite derived sequences contained in the malaria vaccine SPf66 (83.1, 55.1 and 35.1) is low but also show some age dependence. Three doses of the SPf66 vaccine induce a strong IgG antibody response against both the SPf66 construct, NANP and the three individual peptides. Vaccination with SPf66 did not result in an increase of anti19 kDa fragment antibodies. This reflects the specificity of the humoral immune response induced by the SPf66 construct. Among vaccinated children, antibody titres against SPf66 decreased over time following the third dose. However, 18 months after the third dose, SPf66 recipients still had significantly higher IgG titres and stimulation indices of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) than placebo recipients. Within the vaccine group, there is a trend for increasing anti-SPf66 IgG titre to be associated with decreasing risk of clinical malaria but this was not statistically significant. Results also show the difficulties of establishing whether antibody responses are related to protection in field trials in endemic areas .     

Safety and immunogenicity of the RTS,S/AS02A candidate malaria vaccine in children aged 1-4 in Mozambique

BACKGROUND: The development of a malaria vaccine remains a public health priority for sub-Saharan Africa. RTS,S/AS02A candidate malaria vaccine has been shown to be safe and immunogenic in previous studies in adults and staggered dose-escalation studies in children in The Gambia. However, genetic features and the intensity of malaria transmission may modify the safety and immune response of a vaccine. OBJECTIVE: We carried out a phase I, double-blind randomized controlled trial in 60 children aged 1-4 in Mozambique to evaluate the safety, reactogenicity and immunogenicity of the paediatric vaccine dose (fixed 25 microg RTS,S in 0.25 ml) of RTS,S/AS02A, prior to undertaking a planned larger phase IIb proof-of-concept of efficacy study in the same population. METHOD: Children were randomized to receive either RTS,S/AS02A or Engerix-B vaccine. Monitoring of safety and reactogenicity included detailed clinical and laboratory analyses and assessment of adverse events (AEs). RESULTS: The RTS,S/AS02A was found to be safe and well tolerated. Serious adverse events were balanced between both groups and none was related to vaccination. The frequency of adverse events reported with RTS, S/AS02A was comparable to previous studies in children. Grade 3 AEs were infrequent (one case of pain, one of fever in each group and some swelling greater than 20 mm in diameter), transient and resolved without sequelae. RTS,S/AS02A was highly immunogenic for anti-circumsporozoite protein antibody response and induced a strong anti-hepatitis-B surface antigen response.     

A specific T-cell receptor genotype preference in the immune response to a synthetic Plasmodium falciparum malaria vaccine

In recent studies with 63 and 122 volunteers vaccinated with the SPf 66 synthetic malaria vaccine, specific antibody patterns were classified as high or low responders. Using the Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR), a specific and selective preference was shown for the V beta arrangement of the T-cell receptor in the high responder group involving the V beta-8 gene. The low responder group showed the rearrangement of a different set of genes, and a particular association with V beta-10.     

A prospective evaluation of a clinical algorithm for the diagnosis of malaria in Gambian children

Diagnosis of clinical malaria remains difficult, especially in areas where a high proportion of the asymptomatic population have parasitaemia, for the symptoms and signs of malaria overlap with those of other common childhood diseases, such as acute lower respiratory tract infections. However, a study of symptoms and signs in a group of children who presented to Farafenni Health Centre, The Gambia with a history of recent fever identified a group of signs and symptoms which were strong predictors of malaria as opposed to other febrile illnesses. Using these predictors, an algorithm was developed which could be used by fieldworkers and which had a similar sensitivity and specificity for the diagnosis of malaria as that of an experienced paediatrician working without laboratory support. This algorithm has been validated prospectively on 518 children who presented to the Medical Research Council clinic at Basse, The Gambia with fever or a history of recent fever during a 10-month period. A fieldworker obtained a detailed history from the parent or guardian of each child and performed a clinical examination which included measurement of axillary temperature and respiratory rate. Packed cell volume was measured and a thick smear was examined for malaria parasites. A malaria score, based on the presence or absence of malaria-related signs and symptoms, was determined for 382 children who were seen at the clinic during the high transmission season. Using the cut-off score which was optimal during the previous retrospective study, a sensitivity of 70% and a specificity of 77% for a diagnosis of malaria was obtained. The optimal cut-off score for the Basse population was a score of 7; this gave a sensitivity of 88% and a specificity of 62%, figures comparable to those obtained by an experienced paediatrician without laboratory support.     

The path of malaria vaccine development: challenges and perspectives

Malaria is a life‐threatening disease caused by parasites of the Plasmodium genus. In many parts of the world, the parasites have developed resistance to a number of antimalarial agents. Key interventions to control malaria include prompt and effective treatment with artemisinin‐based combination therapies, use of insecticidal nets by individuals at risk and active research into malaria vaccines. Protection against malaria through vaccination was demonstrated more than 30 years ago when individuals were vaccinated via repeated bites by Plasmodium falciparum‐infected and irradiated but still metabolically active mosquitoes. However, vaccination with high doses of irradiated sporozoites injected into humans has long been considered impractical. Yet, following recent success using whole‐organism vaccines, the approach has received renewed interest; it was recently reported that repeated injections of irradiated sporozoites increased protection in 80 vaccinated individuals. Other approaches include subunit malaria vaccines, such as the current leading candidate RTS,S (consisting of fusion between a portion of the P. falciparum‐derived circumsporozoite protein and the hepatitis B surface antigen), which has been demonstrated to induce reasonably good protection. Although results have been encouraging, the level of protection is generally considered to be too low to achieve eradication of malaria. There is great interest in developing new and better formulations and stable delivery systems to improve immunogenicity. In this review, we will discuss recent strategies to develop efficient malaria vaccines.     

The development of the RTS,S malaria vaccine candidate: challenges and lessons

RTS,S is the world's most advanced malaria vaccine candidate and is intended to protect infants and young children living in malaria endemic areas of sub-Saharan Africa against clinical disease caused by Plasmodium falciparum . Recently, a pivotal Phase III efficacy trial of RTS,S began in Africa. The goal of the programme has been to develop a vaccine that will be safe and effective when administered via the Expanded Program for Immunization (EPI) and significantly reduce the risk of clinically important malaria disease during the first years of life. If a similar reduction in the risk of severe malaria and other important co-morbidities associated with malaria infection can be achieved, then the vaccine could become a major new tool for reducing the burden of malaria in sub-Saharan Africa. Encouraging data from the ongoing phase II programme suggest that these goals may indeed be achievable. This review discusses some of the unique challenges that were faced during the development of this vaccine, highlights the complexity of developing new vaccine technologies and illustrates the power of partnerships in the ongoing fight against this killer disease.     

A randomized trial of chloroquine, amodiaquine and pyrimethamine-sulphadoxine in Gambian children with uncomplicated malaria

The increasing occurrence of chloroquine-resistant Plasmodium falciparum in sub-Saharan Africa makes it essential to reconsider current recommendations for the treatment of uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria. In an open, randomized trial, we have compared chloroquine (CQ), amodiaquine (AQ), and pyrimethamine-sulphadoxine (PS) in rural Gambian children with uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria. Three hundred children were randomly assigned at the time of consultation (Do) to oral treatment with 25 mg/kg CQ, 25 mg/kg AQ (both given over 3 days), or 1.25/25 mg/kg PS. They were reviewed on day 7 (D7) and day 28 (D28) for symptoms, malaria parasitaemia, and packed cell volume (PCV). Significantly more children treated with PS compared to CQ (17 vs 7%, P=0.03) or AQ (17 vs 3%, P=0.001) returned with clinical complaints during the first 3 days after treatment. Five of these patients had a generalized convulsion (4 from the AQ group, 4 from the PS group), of whom 4 developed cerebral malaria. At D7, significantly more patients treated with CQ compared to AQ (25 vs 7%, P=0.0009) or PS (25 vs 4%, P=0.0001) were parasitaemic. By D28, the cumulative number of parasitological failures was significantly higher in the CQ group compared to the AQ group (65 vs 35%, P=0.0001), and significantly higher in the AQ group compared to the PS group (35 vs 14%, P=0.001). Overall, 91% of parasitological failures observed during the study period were symptomatic and were consequently treated with an alternative anti-malarial drug. Over the 28-day study period the mean PCV increased significantly less in the CQ group than in the PS group (1.2 vs 3.8%, P=0.016) and was lower in the CQ group than in the AQ group (1.2 vs 2.7%, P=0.12, not significant). These results suggest that PS acts more slowly than 4-aminoquinolines in controlling the clinical features of malaria, and that AQ can be considered as an interim alternative to CQ in the first-line therapy of uncomplicated malaria in African areas of high CQ resistance.     

Long-term immunogenicity and safety of an inactivated hepatitis A vaccine in haemophilic patients

Summary. As a consequence of recent outbreaks of HAV infection by blood products, 91 patients, haemophiliacs and subjects with bleeding disorders (10 of whom were also anti-HIV positive) susceptible to HAV infection received a formalin-inactivated hepatitis A vaccine (HAVRIX 720 Elisa Units, SmithKline Beecham). Subcutaneous injections were given in the deltoid region at 0, 1 and 6 months. The seroconversion rates and litres, expressed in GMT IU/1, were determined at 1, 2, 6, 7, 12, 18 and 24 months. No adverse reactions to the vaccine were observed. The highest percentage of responders observed was 98.7% in anti-HIV negative and 71.4% in anti-HIV positive patients. The anti-HAV GMT titres were higher in anti-HIV negative than in anti-HIV positive patients. The inactivated hepatitis A vaccine is safe, clinically well tolerated, and provides long-term protection against HAV infection.     

Review: Intermittent preventive treatment--a new approach to the prevention of malaria in children in areas with seasonal malaria transmission

Intermittent preventive treatment, the administration of a full course of an anti-malarial treatment to a population at risk at specified time points regardless of whether or not they are known to be infected, is now a recommended approach to the prevention of malaria in pregnancy and is being explored as a potential way of preventing malaria in infants. However, in many malaria endemic areas, the main burden of malaria is in older children and increasing use of insecticide treated bednets is likely to increase further the proportion of episodes of malaria that occur in older children. Recently, it has been shown in Senegal and in Mali that intermittent preventive treatment given to older children during the malaria transmission season can be remarkably effective in preventing malaria. This approach to malaria control is likely to be most effective in areas with a high level of malaria transmission concentrated in a short period of the year. However, several issues need to be addressed before intermittent preventive treatment in children can be advocated for use in malaria control programmes. These include: (1) determination of whether intermittent preventive treatment adds to the protection afforded by other control measures such as insecticide-treated bednets; (2) whether an effective and sustainable delivery system can be found; (3) choice of drug to be used; (4) optimum timing of drug administration; (5) the requisite interval between treatments. The potential benefits of intermittent preventive treatment in children are substantial; more research is needed to determine if this is a practical approach to malaria control.     

A study to assess the immunogenicity, reactogenicity and safety of hepatitis A vaccine administered subcutaneously to patients with congenital coagulation disorders

Summary. The objective was to compare the immunogenicity, reactogenicity and safety of an inactivated hepatitis A vaccine administered subcutaneously to patients with congenital coagulation disorders. Subjects, 97 patients with congenital coagulation disorders (67 men aged > 16 and 30 children aged ≤ 16 years), received hepatitis A vaccine administered at 1440 ELISA (enzyme linked immunosorbent assay) units (ELU) to the adult group and at 720 ELU to the child group at 0 and 6 months by the subcutaneous route. The vaccine was well tolerated, with the incidence of adverse events decreasing with subsequent administration of vaccine. Overall, 90% of subjects seroconverted 1 month after the booster (95% confidence interval 76–97%), with 100% seroconversion occurring in the child group compared with 85% in the adult group. There was a corresponding progressive rise in geometric mean titres in each group and no significant difference in the geometric mean titres was found between the two groups. Of the subjects, 29% were HIV positive, 3% of children compared with 40% of adults. A lower rate of seroconversion was observed in subjects with low CD4 counts. Administration of two doses of an inactivated hepatitis A vaccine at 1440 ELU in adults and 720 ELU in children is safe and highly immunogenic when given by the subcutaneous route.