Corneal reflex in normal and pathological subjects

The orbicularis oculi response can be evoked both by mechanical stimulation of the cornea (corneal reflex) and by electrical stimulation of the skin overlying the supraorbital nerve (blink reflex). Mechanical stimuli to the cornea activate A delta and C free nerve endings of the corneal mucosa. Electrical stimuli to the supraorbital nerve activate A beta, A delta and C fibers of the nerve trunk. Both reflexes present a bilateral late response, but the blink reflex shows in addition an early ipsilateral component (R1), which has never been observed with the corneal stimulation in man. We have developed a simple technique of electrical stimulation of the cornea which provides stable responses and allows precise measurements of threshold and latency of the reflex. In normal subjects, the threshold ranged from 50 to 350 microA, and the maximal stimulus that the subject could bear (tolerance level) ranged from 1000 to 2500 microA. The minimal latency to tolerance level stimuli was 39 +/- 3 msec. The latency difference between the direct responses evoked from the two opposite corneas never exceeded 8 msec and the difference between the direct and consensual responses elicited from the same cornea never exceeded 5 msec. An early ipsilateral component similar to the R1 response of the blink reflex was not observed, even with supramaximal stimulation. The electrically evoked corneal reflex was normal in 10 cases of essential trigeminal neuralgia, while the responses showed significant abnormalities in 18 subjects submitted to thermocoagulation of the Gasserian ganglion as a treatment of neuralgic pain, as well as in 2 cases of symptomatic neuralgia.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Analysis of the corneal reflex with air puff: normal controls and patient groups.

Though there are several reports published about the corneal reflex elicited by different methods, a standardized electrophysiologic study with air puff in man has not been published. The aim of this study is to standardize the corneal reflex elicited by air puff to cornea. The authors studied the corneal reflex with air puff and direct touch by using a standardized method in patients with thalamic hemorrhage (n = 15), hemispheric infarction (n = 9), brainstem infarction (n = 9), multiple sclerosis (n = 12), and Bell's palsy (n = 12) and in normal control subjects (n = 21). The conventional blink reflex (BR) was also studied. The reflex responses were recorded from both orbicularis oculi muscles by air puff and direct touch to cornea in addition to the electrical stimulation of the supraorbital nerve. No statistical difference could be detected between the responses elicited by air puff or direct touch to cornea (P > 0.05). Corneal reflex responses were statistically different from the R2 response of the BR (P < 0.005). Because the responses elicited by direct touch and air puff to cornea are identical, air puff to cornea can be used confidently to study the corneal reflex.     

The relationship of eyelid movement to the blink reflex

Although the blink reflex is a standard neurophysiological investigation its relationship with eyelid movement has not been clearly established. We studied normal subjects and patients with unilateral facial paralysis to define the pattern of eyelid movement following glabellar tap, supraorbital nerve stimulation, facial nerve stimulation and direct corneal stimulation. We found that eyelid closure did not necessarily occur in a single movement. Following glabellar tap the first component of a two-stage movement was initiated by levator palpebrae relaxation while with supraorbital nerve stimulation orbicularis oculi contraction produced the first movement. The compound muscle action potential following direct facial nerve stimulation produced only minimal eyelid movement, the major closure being associated with a longer latency orbicularis oculi reflex. Corneal stimulation elicited a single component eyelid movement. Thus, the pattern of eyelid movement differed for each stimulus reflecting variations in orbicularis oculi contraction and levator palpebrae inhibition.     

Long‐term depression‐like plasticity of the blink reflex for the treatment of blepharospasm

Our previous work showed a beneficial therapeutic effect on blepharospasm using slow repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation, which produces a long‐term depression (LTD)‐like effect. High‐frequency supraorbital electrical stimulation, asynchronous with the R2 component of the blink reflex, can also induce LTD‐like effects on the blink reflex circuit in healthy subjects. Patients with blepharospasm have reduced inhibition of their blink recovery curves; therefore, a LTD‐like intervention might normalize the blink reflex recovery (BRR) and have a favorable therapeutic effect. This is a randomized, sham‐controlled, observer‐blinded prospective study. In 14 blepharospasm patients, we evaluated the effects of high‐frequency supraorbital stimulation on three separate treatment days. We applied 28 trains of nine stimuli, 400 Hz, either before or after the R2 or used sham stimulation. The primary outcome was the blink rate, number of spasms rated by a blinded physician and patient rating before, immediately after and 1 hour after stimulation while resting, reading, and talking; secondary outcome was the BRR. Stimulation “before” and “after” the R2 both showed a similar improvement as sham stimulation in physician rating, but patients felt significantly better with the before condition. Improvement in recovery of the blink reflex was noted only in the before condition. Clinical symptoms differed in the three baseline conditions (resting, reading, and talking). Stimulation before R2 increased inhibition in trigeminal blink reflex circuits in blepharospasm toward normal values and produced subjective, but not objective, improvement. Inhibition of the blink reflex pathway by itself appeared to be insufficient for a useful therapeutic effect. © 2013 Movement Disorder Society     

Unmasking of the trigemino-accessory reflex in accessory facial anastomosis

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the possible blink reflex responses in facial muscles reinnervated by the accessory nerve. METHOD: Eleven patients with a complete facial palsy were submitted to a surgical repair by an accessory facial nerve anastomosis (AFA). In this pathological group, blink reflex was studied by means of percutaneous electrical stimulation of the supraorbital nerve and recording from the orbicularis oculi muscle. A control group comprised seven normal people and seven patients with a complete Bell's facial palsy; in this group, responses on the sternocleidomastoideus (SCM) muscles were studied after supraorbital nerve stimulation. RESULTS: All the patients with AFA showed a consistent degree of facial reinnervation. Ten out of the 11 patients with AFA showed reflex responses; in six, responses were configured by a double component pattern, resembling the R1 and R2 components of the blink reflex; three patients had an R1-like response and one patient showed a unique R2 component. Mean values of latencies were 15.2 (SD 4.6) ms for the R1 and 85.3 (SD 9.6) ms for the R2. In the control group, eight out of 14 people had evidence of reflex responses in the SCM muscles; these were almost exclusively configured by a bilateral late component (mean latency 63.5 (SD15.9) ms) and only one of the subjects showed an early response at 11 ms. CONCLUSION: The trigemino-accessory reflex response in the pathological group was more complex and of a significantly higher incidence than in the control group. These differences could be tentatively explained by a mechanism of synaptic plasticity induced by the impairment of the efferent portion of the reflex. This could unmask the central linking between the trigeminal and the accessory limbs of the reflex. The findings described could be a demonstration of neurobionomic function in the repairing process of the nervous system.     

The orbicularis oculi response after hemispheral damage.

The corneal and blink reflexes were evaluated in 20 normal subjects and in 30 patients with motor deficits secondary to unilateral hemispheral lesions of vascular origin. In the normal population there were no differences between subjects below and subjects above 50 years of age. In the patients the reflex evoked by electrical stimulation of the cornea of the clinically affected side was depressed in 24 out of 30 cases. The depression mainly affected the afferent branch of the circuit, which triggers both homolateral and contralateral orbicularis oculi discharge (afferent abnormality). In three cases the depression was exerted concomitantly on the efferent branch (afferent and efferent abnormality) and only in one case was it limited to the efferent branch (efferent abnormality). The late R2 component of the blink reflex was depressed in 15 out of 30 patients. The early R1 component was slightly facilitated on the affected side. The changes of the corneal reflex and of the R2 component of blink reflex were similar, but the blink reflex had a greater safety factor. The patients with an abnormal corneal reflex had more extensive damage than had the patients with normal corneal response, as shown by computer tomography, but the site of the lesion was comparable in the two groups. Conduction through the brain stem circuits mediating the orbicularis oculi response is normally under pyramidal facilitatory influences while facial motoneurons are subjected to pyramidal inhibition. After pyramidal damage the transmission of impulses in the brain stem was slowed down, ultimately to a degree that abolished the reflex. Removal of pyramidal inhibition on facial motoneurons is probably the basis of the slight facilitation of the R1 component of the blink reflex.     

Blink reflex in facial-hypoglossal anastomosis

Summary The blink reflex was investigated in two patients after a facial-hypoglossal anastomosis had been performed. In each case the first component of the blink reflex could be demonstrated with normal latency on the operated side after ipsilateral supraorbital stimulation. These findings give further evidence that the first component of the blink reflex is not monosynaptic in nature. The second component of the blink reflex was distinctly retarded in the first case and was not seen at all in the second case. The second component of the blink reflex is influenced strongly by alteration of the intrabulbar and efferent part of the reflex circuits; it shows some correlation with voluntary motor activity.Stipendiary of the Humboldt Foundation.     

Dissociation between pain and the nociceptive blink reflex during psychological arousal.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the effect of psychological arousal on pain ratings and the R2 component of the electrically evoked blink reflex to a 'pure' noiciceptive stimulus. METHODS: Pain ratings and R2 to a noiciceptive stimulus (pulse width 0.3ms, 2mA, delivered from a concentric electrode attached to the supraorbital region of the forehead) were investigated in 16 healthy participants before and during a serial subtraction task, and in 16 control participants who sat quietly during nociceptive stimulation. RESULTS: Pain ratings decreased whereas R2 amplitude increased during the serial subtraction task. CONCLUSIONS: Supra-spinal rather than spinal mechanisms inhibited pain perception during psychological arousal. Moreover, psychological arousal facilitated the R2 component of the blink reflex to a nociception-specific stimulus. SIGNIFICANCE: Supra-spinal influences need to be considered during clinical evaluation of the trigeminal nociceptive blink reflex.     

Influences on blink reflex induced by IA afferents in human subjects

The effects induced by IA volleys, evoked with H reflex, on the blink reflex elicited upon electric activation of supraorbital nerves were investigated in 14 healthy subjects as well as in 4 cerebrovascular patients. In both groups a significant increase in amplitude of the early component (R1) of ipsilateral blink reflex has been observed. A brief discussion of possible neural systems which might be involved in these effects is given.     

Axon reflexes or ephaptic responses simulating blink reflex R1 after XII-VII nerve anastomosis

It has been claimed that functional recovery of the blink reflex occurs after hypoglossal-facial nerve anastomosis. This has been explained through central nervous system plasticity and reorganization of neuronal connections. In 5 patients with reinnervated facial muscles after hypoglossal-facial nerve anastomosis, we observed “R1-like” responses that fulfilled criteria for facial nerve axon reflexes or ephapses. First, displacement of the stimulating electrode from the supraorbital to the zygomatic area shortened the latency of the evoked response. Second, these responses were stable (jitter mean consecutive difference < 25 μs) and they had complex potential shapes unmodified by high-frequency stimulation. Finally, collision techniques demonstrated antidromic conduction of impulses in the facial nerve from supraorbital to zygomatic points. Therefore, these “R1-like” responses are not the early component of a functionally recovered blink reflex but motor axon reflexes or ephaptic responses similar to the short latency responses observed following facial nerve regeneration or from sutured nerves in human forearms. © 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Interaction between the blink reflex and the abnormal muscle response in patients with hemifacial spasm: results of intraoperative recordings

Patients with hemifacial spasm (HFS) have an abnormal muscle response (AMR) that can be elicited by stimulating one branch of the facial nerve and recording electromyographically from muscles innervated by other branches of the facial nerve. In addition, the R1 component of the blink reflex can be elicited from the affected side in patients with HFS who are undergoing microvascular decompression (MVD) operations under inhalation anesthesia. A synkinetic component of the blink reflex response that corresponds to the R1 component can be recorded from the mentalis muscle. In the present study we show that the blink reflex elicited by electrical stimulation of the supraorbital nerve can suppress the AMR elicited by electrical stimulation of the temporal branch of the facial nerve in patients with HFS when the interval between stimulation of the supraorbital nerve and stimulation of the temporal branch of the facial nerve (interstimulus interval, ISI) is such that the blink reflex response would appear later than the AMR if they had been elicited independently. Within a short range of ISIs the two responses suppress each other partially or totally. We find evidence that the suppression of the AMR is the result of an interaction in the facial motonucleus. We believe that the results of the present study support the hypothesis that the facial motonucleus is hyperactive in patients with HFS, and we suggest that the AMR is a result of backfiring from the facial motonucleus and that it may thus be an exaggerated F-response.     

Metaplasticity of the human trigeminal blink reflex

Although synaptic plasticity in the human cerebral cortex is governed by metaplasticity, whether a similar mechanism operates at brainstem level is unknown. In this study in healthy humans we examined the effects and interactions induced by pairing supraorbital nerve high-frequency electrical stimulation (HFS) protocols on the R2 component of the trigeminal blink reflex [Mao, J.B. & Evinger, C (2001) J Neurosci., 21:RC151(1-4)]. Changes in the R2 component were tested by pairing three different priming stimulation protocols inducing long-term potentiation (LTP)-like or long-term depression (LTD)-like effects (LTP-HFS and LTD-HFS), or no change (CONTROL-HFS) with a subsequent test LTP-HFS. Additionally, to examine changes in the R2 component induced by nonspecific factors, two CONTROL-HFS sessions were paired. Priming LTP-, LTD- or CONTROL-HFS potentiated, inhibited or left unchanged the area of the R2 component. Regardless of the type of priming LTP-, LTD- or CONTROL-HFS, the test LTP-HFS induced negligible differences in the R2 component. When two CONTROL-HFS sessions were paired, the test CONTROL-HFS increased the latency and markedly reduced the duration and area of the R2 component. The analysis of the normalized data across the first three experimental sessions, corrected for the inhibitory effects found in the fourth experiment, showed that the test LTP-HFS potentiated the R2 component area of the trigeminal blink reflex only when preceded by a priming LTD-HFS. We propose that homosynaptic metaplasticity might operate in the brainstem circuitry of the blink reflex.     

Blink reflex in patients with hemifacial spasm. Observations during microvascular decompression operations

The blink reflex cannot normally be elicited during surgical anesthesia using inhalation anesthetics. However, in patients with hemifacial spasm (HFS) the early component of the reflex response (R1) can be elicited on the affected side but not on the unaffected side during such anesthesia. The electromyographic (EMG) response from the mentalis muscle to stimulation of the supraorbital nerve was recorded during microvascular decompression (MVD) of the facial nerve to relieve HFS and compared to the response from the same muscle to stimulation of the zygomatic branch of the facial nerve in four patients. During the operation before the facial nerve was decompressed, contractions in both the orbicularis oculi and the mentalis muscles could be elicited by stimulation of the supraorbital nerve (mean latencies 12.2 +/- 1.9 and 12.9 +/- 2.0 ms, respectively). When the facial nerve had been decompressed the blink reflex could no longer be elicited, and there was no response from the mentalis muscle to stimulation of the zygomatic branch of the facial nerve. Compound action potentials (CAP) recorded from the 7th cranial nerve in response to stimulation of the supraorbital nerve had latencies of 7.5 ms +/- 1.4 ms to the negative peak.     

Pain-evoked blink reflex

The electrically evoked blink reflex (BR) consists of an ipsilateral R1 component (R1) at 11 ms and two bilateral components R2 at 33 ms and R3 at 83 ms. It is still unclear whether the R2 is mediated by activation of tactile or nociceptive afferents. For testing the nociceptive hypothesis, nociceptors of the supraorbital nerve were selectively activated by infrared laser stimuli in 10 subjects. Only painful laser stimuli evoked a bilateral early polyphasic BR response (LR2) at 71 ms. Stimulation of infraorbital and mental nerve dermatomes was equally effective. A late bilateral reflex response at 130 ms was occasionally observed. Regarding the nociceptor activation time of about 40 ms, onset latencies were within the range of the electrically evoked R2 and R3, respectively. The good accordance of R2 and LR2 may be due to activation of identical nociceptive fibers or to convergence of electrically evoked tactile and laser-elicited nociceptive input onto common multireceptive neurons. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Muscle Nerve, 20, 265–270, 1997.     

The n10 component of the ocular vestibular-evoked myogenic potential (oVEMP) is distinct from the R1 component of the blink reflex

ObjectiveBone-conducted vibration (BCV) in the midline at the hairline (Fz), results in short latency potentials recorded by surface electrodes beneath the eyes – the ocular vestibular-evoked myogenic potential (oVEMP). The early negative component of the oVEMP, n10, is due to vestibular stimulation, however it is similar to the early R1 component of the blink reflex. Here we seek to dissociate n10 from R1.MethodsSurface potentials were recorded from the infraorbital electromyogram of 10 healthy subjects, 6 patients with bilateral vestibular loss, 2 with unilateral vestibular loss, 4 with facial palsy and 3 with facial and vestibular nerve lesions on the same side. BCV was delivered at Fz, the inion, the glabella or the supraorbital ridge using a tendon hammer or a bone-conduction vibrator.ResultsOnset latencies of the n10 evoked by taps at Fz or inion were significantly shorter than the R1 components of blink responses to supraorbital and glabellar stimuli. Upward gaze increased the amplitude of n10 but not R1. The n10 was absent bilaterally in patients with bilateral vestibular loss and beneath the contralesional eye in patients with unilateral vestibular loss, but in both these groups of patients R1 was preserved. In severe facial palsy the R1 component was absent or delayed and attenuated ipsilesionally, but n10 was preserved bilaterally. In subjects with unilateral facial and vestibular nerve lesions (Herpes Zoster of the facial and vestibulocochlear nerves) the dissociation was complete – the ipsilesional R1 was absent or attenuated whereas the ipsilesional n10 was preserved.Conclusionsn10 is distinguished from R1 by its earlier onset, laterality, modulation by gaze position and dissociation in patient groups.SignificanceThe n10 component evoked by BCV at Fz is not the R1 component of the blink reflex.     

Enhanced gain of blink reflex responses to ipsilateral supraorbital nerve afferent inputs in patients with facial nerve palsy.

OBJECTIVES: Patients with peripheral facial palsy (PFP) may present with transient hyperkinetic movement disorders in the side contralateral to the paralysis. One possible cause of such enhanced motor activity is sensitization of reflex responses to afferent inputs from the unprotected cornea. We hypothesized that if this sensitization occurs, the size of the orbicularis oculi (OOc) responses induced by afferents from the ophthalmic branch of the paralyzed side would be larger than those induced by afferents from the contralateral side. METHODS: In 68 patients with complete PFP and in a group of 30 age-matched control subjects we recorded the response of the OOc muscle of one side to electrical stimulation of the supraorbital nerve of both sides, and calculated the ratio between R2c and R2 (R2c/R2). RESULTS: The mean R2c/R2 ratio was significantly larger in patients than in control subjects (unpaired t test, P<0.05). Larger R2c than R2 responses were observed in 23.1% of control subjects and in 80.9% of patients (chi(2)=13.3, P<0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that patients with PFP have an enhanced blink reflex gain to inputs from the paralyzed side compared to those of the non-paralyzed side. Sensitization of the blink reflex polysynaptic pathways to inputs carried by afferent fibers from the ophthalmic branch of the paralyzed side can play a role in inducing an abnormal facial motor behavior after PFP.     

Blink reflex abnormalities in children with Tourette syndrome

Tourette syndrome (TS) is a common disorder which typically occurs during childhood or early adolescence. There is no definitive diagnostic test for TS. The objective of this study was to demonstrate whether neurophysiological abnormalities of the blink reflex can be observed in children with TS. We enrolled 15 children with TS, diagnosed according to DSM IV Diagnostic Criteria, and 15 controls. The blink reflex was elicited by stimulating the supraorbital nerve in order to measure the early response (R1), homolateral and contralateral R2 (late) responses, amplitude of R1 and duration of R2. The mean duration of R2 was significantly longer in TS patients than in the controls ( P  < 0.001, Student's t -test). An abnormal pattern of the blink reflex can be, even in childhood, an early neurophysiologic marker of TS, which is not related to the duration of TS or to the age of onset.     

Influences of dopaminergic systems on the blink reflex

The effect of the anti-dopaminergic drug haloperidol (6 mg/day i.m. for 2 days) on the blink reflex elicited by electric stimulation of supraorbital nerves was investigated in 12 adult volunteers. A significant increase in amplitude of the early component (R1) of the reflex was observed. This increase disappeared within 5 days of stopping the drug. Possible neural systems which might be involved in these effects are considered.

---

Sommario Su 12 volontari adulti, neurologicamente indenni, sono stati studiati gli effetti indotti dalla somministrazione di un farmaco dopaminolitico (aloperidolo, 6 mg/die × 2 giorni) sul riflesso di ammiccamento (blink reflex). Si è osservato un significativo aumento dell'ampiezza della componente precoce (R1) del riflesso, con un ritorno alla norma entro 5 giorni dalla cessazione della somministrazione del farmaco. Vengono discussi i possibili circuiti nervosi coinvolti negli effetti osservati.

     

The R3 component of the blink reflex in man: a reflex response induced by activation of high threshold cutaneous afferents

Ten successive experiments were carried out in 10 volunteers to compare the physiological properties of R2 and R3 components of the blink reflex. The electrical activation threshold of the R3 component was found to be significantly higher than that of the R2 response and was more susceptible to anaesthetic blocking of the peripheral afferents. This result suggests that the R3 component is induced by the activation of a different population of peripheral afferents from the R2 component. A recovery cycle study performed using a double stimulus showed that R3 is inhibited to a greater extent and for a longer time than R2. The temporal relationship of R3 to the voluntarily produced blink demonstrates that R3 is not a voluntary response to electrical stimulation. In conclusion, these experiments support the existence of an independent R3 component and its relationship with the activation of small diameter and higher threshold afferent fibres, perhaps nociceptive ones.     

Methodological considerations on the use of the blink reflex R3 component in the assessment of pain in man

We define the principal physiological properties of the nociceptive component R3 of the blink reflex (b.r.) on electrical stimulation of the supraorbital nerve, with the aim of supplying some rules for its use in the analysis of pain in man. We explore the relationship between the threshold (th) of R3 and that of pain on stimulation of the trigeminal nerve and the extent to which R3 is modulated by habituation and attentional levels. Both pain th and R3 th correlate significantly with age. The R3 th was always higher than the R2 th. Habituation definitely decreases the amplitude of R3, which easily disappears. Focusing of attention on the stimulus sharply inhibits R3 while distraction increases it. Our findings emphasize the need to take all these aspects into account when designing protocols for the study of pain mechanisms based on the R3 reflex component. This work was partly supported by a grant from the Italian Ministry for the Universities and for Scientific and Technological Research