Long-term evaluation of a calcium phosphate bone cement with carboxymethyl cellulose in a vertebral defect model

We investigated histological and compressive properties of a calcium phosphate bone cement (BoneSource (CPC); Stryker Orthopaedics, Mahwah, New Jersey) plus carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) using a sheep vertebral bone void model. Bone voids were surgically created in L3 and L5 in each of 40 sheep, and the voids were filled with the cement. Histological and radiographic evaluations were performed on one vertebral body from each animal at either: 0, 3, 6, 12, 24, or 36 months after surgery; mechanical testing was performed on operated and non-operated vertebral bodies from 35 sheep. Undecalcified sections were digitized, and the area of the original defect, new bone formation, empty space, fibrous tissue, and residual cement were quantified with histomorphometry. Decalcified sections were evaluated qualitatively. The cement was biocompatible, extremely osteoconductive and underwent steady resorption and replacement by bone and bone marrow. Histomorphometry showed variations in the rate of cement remodeling among animals in each time group, but on average, at 36 months the original defect area was occupied by approximately 14% bone, 82% cement, and 4% bone marrow. Even in animals that had greater resorption of cement, there was good bone ingrowth with no fibrous tissue. Compressive testing did not reveal a significant difference in the mechanical properties between vertebral bodies augmented with cement and non-augmented controls, irrespective of the postoperative time. BoneSource mixed with CMC had adequate osteoconductivity, biocompatibility, and adequate compressive strength. There was variability among animals, but histology suggests that considerable cement was still present in most samples after 36 months.     

Long-term implantation of zinc-releasing calcium phosphate ceramics in rabbit femora

Zinc is an essential trace element that has stimulatory effects on bone formation. Recently, we developed zinc-releasing calcium phosphate ceramics in order to add the pharmacologic effect of zinc to calcium phosphate ceramics. In our previous study, we showed that the optimum zinc content for promoting bone formation was 0.316 wt %. Therefore a zinc composite ceramic of zinc-containing beta-tricalcium phosphate and hydroxyapatite, with a zinc content of 0.316 wt %, was chosen for long-term implantation. Cylindrical rods of the zinc composite ceramic were implanted in rabbit femora for 2 to 60 weeks. Using computer-aided image analysis, a histomorphometric study was carried out to investigate bone formation and resorption around the implants. The control was a composite ceramic of beta-tricalcium phosphate and hydroxyapatite without zinc. The addition of zinc to the implant demonstrated both favorable and unfavorable effects on bone remodeling. The favorable effect was enhanced bone apposition to the implant surface, demonstrated by a significant increase in intramedullary bone apposition rate at 6 weeks and in cortical bone apposition rate at 24 and 60 weeks (p < 0.05). The unfavorable effect was increased bone resorption, demonstrated by a significant increase in medullary cavity area at 60 weeks (p < 0.05). In order to utilize the favorable effect and avoid the unfavorable effect of zinc, either a reduction in zinc content in the zinc composite ceramic or the selection of implantation sites that do not have excessive exposure to bone marrow are required.     

Influence of polymeric additives on the biological properties of brushite cements: an experimental study in rabbit

The resorbability and ability of calcium phosphate hydraulic cements to promote new bone formation was investigated in vivo. The effects of two hydrosoluble polymeric additives (hyaluronic acid, and xanthan gum,) on the biological response of two brushite cement formulations (BHC-A vs BHC-B) was investigated. The brushite cements differed in P/Ca (0.71 vs 0.98) and S/Ca (0.10 vs 0.005) atomic ratios and by the presence of calcium sulfate hemihydrate in BHC-A. Polymer-free cements were used as controls. Cement specimens were injected in cylindrical bone defects manually drilled in the distal condyle of rabbit femora. The implants were harvested at 12 and 24 weeks after implantation and subjected to quantitative histomorphometry. The study showed a significantly lower resorption rate for cement BHC-A, which induces the formation of well-mineralized bone in close apposition to the residual material. In contrast, cement BHC-B showed a significant increase of bone formation period and the formation of a thick layer of unmineralized osteoid tissue at the bone/residual cement interface. The presence of xanthan gum made the biological response even worse, particularly in the case of cement BHC-B. The presence of hyaluronic acid has little effect, except for a slight decrease in initial resorption rate, in the case of cement BHC-A.     

In vivo testing of a new in situ setting beta-tricalcium phosphate cement for osseous reconstruction

A new in situ setting tricalcium phosphate cement was implanted in 1.5-mm trepanation defects in rat femurs. Empty cavities and autologous bone grafts were used as controls. Cement resorption and new bone formation were evaluated in undecalcified sections with histologic examination, contact microradiographies, radiodensitometry, and scanning electron microscopy after 1 and 3 weeks. The mechanical integrity was tested in a three-point bending test. The amount of new bone formation over time was determined by intravital fluorescence staining. With the in situ setting substance, a good filling of the whole trepanation defect was achieved without leakage of the paste-like cement. Slow resorption of the cement and new bone formation beginning at the edge of the defect were seen after 1 week. After 3 weeks, resorption was advanced and there was ingrowth of new bone, with close contact between cement particles and bone, as shown in histologic sections and with a calcium/phosphorus analysis by quantitative line scans of an electron microanalysis (SEM-EPMA). This new self-hardening cement is bioactive, resorbable, and osteotransductive. It may be usable for the filling of stable defects, such as cysts or benign tumors, or for bone supplementation in revision arthroplasty.     

Transforming growth factor beta released from natural coral implant enhances bone growth at calvarium of mature rat.

Earlier studies have shown that transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) has the capability of enhancing bone formation after a single application to an orthotopic site. We investigated whether 1, 5, or 25 microg of recombinant human TGF-beta1 added to porous natural coral (NC) blocks could promote bone ingrowth in a critical size defect (CSD) model in nongrowing rats. A 6-mm CSD in the parietal bone of Wistar rats was filled with NC disks, which were retrieved at 3 and 8 weeks. We prepared undecalcified sections for microscopy and histomorphometry to study bone formation in the implants. The differences in the means of the measured variables were compared with a one-way analysis of variance and Tukey's Student range test, and p values smaller than 0.05 were considered statistically significant. Bone formation was enhanced in all the TGF-beta1-treated implants at 8 weeks in comparison with the controls, but none of the implants showed complete bridging across the defect. The number of macrophages and giant cells was reduced in the TGF-beta1 implants, which showed less resorption and more intact structure than the coral controls. Void areas without any fibrous tissue ingrowth were found only in the TGF-beta1-treated implants, which may partly explain the reduced resorption. The data suggested that TGF-beta1 induced enhanced but limited bone formation in mature rats and prevented resorption of the coral calcium carbonate matrix, possibly by hindering reactive cell formation and fibrous tissue ingrowth.     

Biocompatibility and resorption of a radiopaque premixed calcium phosphate cement

Calcium phosphate cements (CPC) are used as bone void filler in various orthopedic indications; however, there are some major drawbacks regarding mixing, transfer, and injection of traditional CPC. By using glycerol as mixing liquid, a premixed calcium phosphate cement (pCPC), some of these difficulties can be overcome. In the treatment of vertebral fractures the handling characteristics need to be excellent including a high radio-opacity for optimal control during injection. The aim of this study is to evaluate a radiopaque pCPC regarding its resorption behavior and biocompatibility in vivo. pCPC and a water-based CPC were injected into a ? 4-mm drilled femur defect in rabbits. The rabbits were sacrificed after 2 and 12 weeks. Cross sections of the defects were evaluated using histology, electron microscopy, and immunohistochemical analysis. Signs of inflammation were evaluated both locally and systemically. The results showed a higher bone formation in the pCPC compared to the water-based CPC after 2 weeks by expression of RUNX-2. After 12 weeks most of the cement had been resorbed in both groups. Both materials were considered to have a high biocompatibility since no marked immunological response was induced and extensive bone ingrowth was observed. The conclusion from the study was that pCPC with ZrO(2) radiopacifier is a promising alternative regarding bone replacement material and may be suggested for treatment of, for example, vertebral fractures based on its high biocompatibility, fast bone ingrowth, and good handling properties.     

Tissue responses of calcium phosphate cement: a study in dogs

The in vivo properties of a new kind of calcium phosphate cement were investigated in this study. Calcium phosphate cement was implanted as paste into femoral bone and dorsal muscle of dogs for 3 and 6 months, and as prehardened form into thigh muscles of dogs for 1, 2 and 6 months. Histology was performed on thin un-decalcified sections. No foreign body reaction, no inflammation and no necrosis were found both in bony site and in muscles. There was no connective tissue layer between the cement and bone when cement paste was implanted in the bone. A creeping substitution of cement by bone, in which osteoclast-like cells resorbed the cement as if the cement is a part of bone and new bone was formed directly on the resorption line of calcium phosphate cement, was found. Bone formation was found histomorphologically in pores and deep rugged surface of cement samples (both paste and prehardened form) implanted in muscles of dogs. The induced bone was also identified with backscattered scanning electron microscopy (BSE) and by energy-dispersive X-ray micro-analysis (EDX). The results suggest that the calcium phosphate cement used in this study is biocompatible, resorbable in a manner of creeping substitution, osteoconductive and osteoinductive. It seems that an ideal bone substitute can be developed by using this type of calcium phosphate cement.     

Synchrotron X-ray microtomography (on a micron scale) provides three-dimensional imaging representation of bone ingrowth in calcium phosphate biomaterials

This study used synchrotron X-ray microtomography on a micron scale to compare three-dimensional (3D) bone ingrowth after implantation of various calcium phosphate bone substitutes in a rabbit model. The advantage of using this new method for the study of biomaterials was then compared with histomorphometry for analysis of interconnection and bone ingrowth. The study focused on the newly formed bone-biomaterial interface. Macroporous Biphasic Calcium Phosphate (MBCP) ceramic blocks and two different injectable calcium phosphate biomaterials [an injectable bone substitute (IBS) consisting of a biphasic calcium phosphate granule suspension in hydrosoluble polymer and a calcium phosphate cement material (CPC)] were studied after in vivo implantation.Absorption or phase-contrast microtomography was performed with the dedicated set-up at beamline ID22. Experimental spatial resolution was between 1 and 1.4 microm, depending on experimental radiation. All calcium phosphates tested showed osteoconduction. IBS observations after 3D reconstruction showed interconnected bioactive biomaterial with total open macroporosity and complete bone ingrowth as early as 3 weeks after implantation. This experimentation was consistent with two-dimensional histomorphometric analysis, which confirmed its suitability for biomaterials. This 3D study relates the different types of bone substitution to biomaterial architecture. As porosity and interconnection increase, bone ingrowth becomes greater at the expense of the bone substitute: IBS>MBCP>CPC.     

骨形态计量学观察睾酮对雄性去势大鼠皮质骨的影响

目的通过骨形态计量方法观察雄激素替代疗法对去睾丸大鼠皮质骨代谢的影响。方法30只4月龄SD雄性大鼠,随机分成基础对照组(A组、实验开始时处死),年龄对照组(B组)、去睾丸组(C组)和去睾丸加睾丸酮组(D组),B组和C组生理盐水5ml·kg-1·d-1,D组甲基睾丸酮片1.8mg·kg-1·d-1,灌胃90d。实验结束,处死全部大鼠,取胫骨中段进行不脱钙骨制片,用计算机全自动图象分析系统进行骨组织形态计量学分析。结果去睾丸后皮质骨静态参数如截面总面积、髓腔面积等无明显变化,动态参数骨外膜骨形成降低(P<0.05),内膜骨形成和吸收均有增加趋势。睾酮则使去睾丸大鼠皮质骨的静态参数有增加趋势,促使骨外膜形成增加,减少内膜骨吸收(P<0.05),对内膜骨形成影响不大。结论睾酮补充治疗短期内能对抗去睾丸引起的大鼠皮质骨内外膜的代谢变化,维持正常的皮质骨结构。     

In vivo model for frontal sinus and calvarial bone defect obliteration with bioactive glass S53P4 and hydroxyapatite

An in vivo model was developed to investigate the usability of a frontal sinus and a calvarial bone defect obliteration with bioactive glass S53P4 (BG) and hydroxyapatite (HA) granules. Roofs of 21 Elco rabbit frontal sinuses were drilled open from 4 separate holes using a standard method, and the sinuses, located in pairs, in frontal bone were filled with BG on one side and with HA on the other side. Two parallel posterior defects were covered with a pedicled periosteum flap, and 2 anterior defects with a free flap. The stability of materials, new bone, and connective tissue formation were observed with histomorphometry, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), energy dispersive X-ray analysis (EDXA), and X-ray pictures at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months postoperatively. The results showed more rapid resorption of filling material (p = 0.019) and new bone formation (p = 0.0001) in the defects filled with BG than in the corresponding HA-filled defects studied by histomorphometry throughout the study. New bone formation and resorption of materials were faster in defects covered by a pedicled flap than by a free periosteum flap. The results were supported by SEM histomorphometric and radiologic analysis. Both bioactive materials studied were well tolerated in frontal sinuses and in calvarial bone defects. The experimental model showed the influence of early periosteum vascularization on accurate frontal sinus filling and the healing process in rabbit frontal sinuses.     

Bone growth on and resorption of calcium phosphate coatings obtained by pulsed laser deposition

Three different calcium phosphate coatings of crystalline hydroxyapatite (HA), alpha- and beta-tricalcium phosphate (alpha+beta-TCP), or amorphous calcium phosphate (ACP) obtained by pulsed laser deposition on Ti-6Al-4V were incubated in a potentially osteogenic primary cell culture (rat bone marrow) in order to evaluate the amount and mode of mineralized bone matrix formation after 2 weeks with special emphasis on the type of interfacial structure that was created. Evaluation techniques included fluorescence labeling and scanning electron microscopy. The resistance to cellular resorption by osteoclasts was also studied. Bone matrix delaminated from the ACP coatings, while it remained on the HA and the alpha+beta-TCP coatings even after fracturing. A cementlike line was seen as the immediate contiguous interface with the nondegrading dense HA surface and with the surface of the remaining porous beta-TCP coating. Highly dense and crystalline HA coatings do not dissolve but are capable of establishing a strong bond with the bone matrix grown on top. Chemical and mechanical bonding were considered in this case. Cellular resorption was practically not observed on the HA coatings, but it was observed on the alpha+beta-TCP coatings. Resorption took place as dissolution that was due to the acidic microenvironment.     

低钙饮食对雄性大鼠松质骨和密质骨影响的比较

目的　比较低钙饮食对大鼠胫骨上段松质骨和胫骨中段密质骨的影响。方法　实验用 3月龄SD雄性大鼠 2 0只 ,随机分为正常年龄对照组 (control)、极低钙组 (VLCD)、低钙组 (LDC)。Control组饲养正常饲料 ,VLCD组饲养 0 0 1%含钙饲料 ,LCD组饲养 0 3%含钙饲料。 3个月后取各组大鼠左侧胫骨近心端和中段 ,行不脱钙骨制片 ,进行骨组织形态计量学测量。结果　松质骨 :与对照组相比 ,VLCD组和LCD组的大鼠骨量减少 ,骨小粱面积百分率 (%Tb .Ar)分别减少 5 7% (P <0 0 1)和4 0 % (P <0 0 5 ) ,骨结构参数变差 ,代表骨形成指标荧光周长百分数 (L .Pm % )、矿化沉积率 (MAR)、骨形成率 (BFR/BV)有增加的趋势。VLCD组骨吸收参数骨小粱周长破骨细胞数量 (N .OC/Tb .Pm)有显著增加 ,呈现骨高转化的改变。密质骨 :与对照组相比 ,VLCD组和LCD组的骨量有减少的趋势 ,骨外膜面代表骨形成的参数增加 ,骨内膜代表骨形成的参数变化不大 ,骨内膜骨吸收增加。结论　低钙饮食使骨量减少 ,但不同的部位有不同的骨丢失速度     

Bone formation analysis: effect of quantification procedures on the study outcome

Quantification of the amount of newly formed bone is an essential part of bone regeneration studies. Histomorphometry, based on histological sections of plastic-embedded specimens, is the most frequently applied technique in this assessment. Before performing image analysis, a specific region of interest (ROI) has to be determined. Based on the histological procedure, different areas within the ROI can be discriminated and assigned to relevant tissue structures. However, in literature not much attention is paid to the effect of the histological procedures on the final outcome of the histomorphometrical measurements on bone regeneration. In this study, the histomorphometrical bone formation of the intramedullary cavity of the guinea pig tibia, filled with calcium phosphate cement, was quantified in plastic-embedded and paraffin-embedded specimens and in specimens analyzed with scanning electron microscopy in the backscattering mode (SEM-BS). The data showed that the histological procedure significantly affected the measured bone amount. Therefore, it is recommended that scaffold characteristics are carefully considered in selecting a proper technique for the analysis of bone formation in bone tissue engineering studies. The results of this study identified high-resolution SEM-BS and elastic van Gieson staining of decalcified histological sections as recommendable techniques for evaluating bone formation.     

Biochemical evidence of disturbed bone metabolism and calcium homeostasis in two types of autosomal dominant osteopetrosis

Biochemical markers of bone resorption and bone formation were measured in 14 patients with autosomal dominant osteopetrosis, and compared with age- and sex-matched controls. There were eight patients with the radiological type I characterized by diffuse, symmetrical osteosclerosis with pronounced sclerosis of the skull and enlarged thickness of the cranial vault, and six patients with type II characterized by diffuse, symmetrical osteosclerosis, "Rugger-Jersey spine" and "endobones" (bone within a bone) in the pelvis. Serum levels of alkaline phosphatase and osteocalcin in types I and II did not differ from controls indicating normal bone formation. However, a significantly decreased fasting renal excretion of phosphate and hydroxyproline in both types compared with normal controls, suggests a reduced bone resorption. Serum levels of parathyroid hormone (PTH), albumin-corrected calcium, phosphate, and acid phosphatase were normal in type I. In type II serum levels of albumin-corrected calcium and PTH were significantly increased (p less than 0.05 and p less than 0.01). The level of acid phosphatase was markedly increased in this type (p less than 0.01). These findings suggest differences between the two types in calcium homeostasis and bone metabolism, and thus corroborate the evidence that the two radiological types reflect two different disorders of bone resorption.     

Resorbability of bone substitute biomaterials by human osteoclasts

Third generation biomaterials are being designed with the aim that once implanted they will help the body to heal itself. One desirable characteristic of these materials in bone is their ability to be remodeled, i.e. that osteoclasts resorb the material and it is subsequently replaced by newly formed bone through osteoblastic activity. So far the only way to test this biological property of bone substitutes are animal experiments with all their limitations like ethics, costs and limited transferability to man. The present study was designed, to develop a human in vitro assay, allowing to generate human osteoclasts directly on the biomaterial. The assay was validated using calcium phosphate cement and PMMA as biomaterials. Quantification was performed by raster electron microscopy and computer assisted image analysis. Dentin was used as internal standard. Our assay shows iso-bone resorbability of calcium phosphate cement in comparison to unresorbable PMMA cement. Both current clinical orthopedic practice and future skeletal engineering may profit from the availability and use of a test system for the assessment of resorption quality. The assay presented here allows to address this question of resorbability and to select the best materials for the use as bone substitutes in specific patients.     

A new in vivo screening model for posterior spinal bone formation: comparison of ten calcium phosphate ceramic material treatments

This study presents a new screening model for evaluating the influence of multiple conditions on the initial process of bone formation in the posterior lumbar spine of a large animal. This model uses cages designed for placement on the decorticated transverse process of the goat lumbar spine. Five conduction channels per cage, each be defined by a different material treatment, are open to both the underlying bone and overlying soft tissue. The model was validated in ten adult Dutch milk goats, with each animal implanted with two cages containing a total of ten calcium phosphate material treatments according to a randomized complete block design. The ten calcium phosphate ceramic materials were created through a combination of material chemistry (BCP, TCP, HA), sintering temperature (low, medium, high), calcination and surface roughness treatments. To monitor the bone formation over time, fluorochrome markers were administered at 3, 5 and 7 weeks and the animals were sacrificed at 9 weeks after implantation. Bone formation in the conduction channels was investigated by histology and histomorphometry of non-decalcified sections using traditional light and epifluorescent microscopy. According to both observed and measured bone formation parameters, materials were ranked in order of increasing magnitude as follows: low sintering temperature BCP (rough and smooth) approximately medium sintering temperature BCP approximately = TCP > calcined low sintering temperature HA > non-calcined low sintering temperature HA > high sintering temperature BCP (rough and smooth) > high sintering temperature HA (calcined and non-calcined). These results agree closely with those obtained in previous studies of osteoconduction and bioactivity of ceramics thereby validating the screening model presented in this study.     

Resorption patterns of calcium-phosphate cements in bone

Two calcium phosphate cements, one monophasic and the other biphasic, have been used as bone void filler in a sheep model. The cements were injected into a slot defect in the proximal tibia and into a cylindrical defect in the distal femur. In this study, we focused on the resorption pattern of the two cement formulations and the subsequent biologic reaction. Bone remodeling occurred synchronously with the resorption of the implant material in a creeping substitution process. Cracks and pores in the monophasic cement were filled with osseous tissues. The biphasic cement showed faster resorption of the matrix. The more slowly resorbing granules were surrounded by newly grown bone, thus providing an inverse scaffold for cancellous bone regeneration. In highly loaded areas, the long-term support function of the fixation appears to be critical. Because cortical bridging of the defects was seen in only one case, it can be concluded that calcium-phosphate cements are preferentially suitable as cancellous bone substitute materials.     

Histological and mechanical evaluation of self-setting calcium phosphate cements in a sheep vertebral bone void model

We investigated the histological and compressive properties of three different calcium phosphate cements (CPCs) using a sheep vertebral bone void model. One of the CPCs contained barium sulfate to enhance its radiopacity. Bone voids were surgically created in the lumbar region of 23 ovine spines - L3, L4, and L5 (n = 69 total vertebral bodies) - and the voids were filled with one of the three CPCs. A fourth group consisted of whole intact vertebrae. Histologic evaluation was performed for 30 of the 69 vertebrae 2 or 4 months after surgery along with radiographic evaluation. Compressive testing was performed on 39 vertebrae 4 months after surgery along with micro-CT analysis. All three CPCs were biocompatible and extremely osteoconductive. Osteoclasts associated with adjacent bone formation suggest that each cement can undergo slow resorption and replacement by bone and bone marrow. Compressive testing did not reveal a significant difference in the ultimate strength, ultimate strain, and structural modulus, among the three CPCs and intact whole vertebrae. Micro-CT analysis revealed good osseointegration between all three CPCs and adjacent bone. The barium sulfate did not affect the CPCs biocompatibility or mechanical properties. These results suggest that CPC might be a good alternative to polymethylmethacrylate for selected indications.     

Osteoclast resorption of beta-tricalcium phosphate controlled by surface architecture

A resorbable bone graft substitute should mimic native bone in its capacity to support bone formation and be remodeled by osteoclasts (OCl) or other multinucleated cells such as foreign body giant cells (FBGC). We hypothesize that by changing the scale of surface architecture of beta-tricalcium phosphate (TCP), cellular resorption can be influenced. CD14⁺ monocyte precursors were isolated from human peripheral blood (n = 4 independent donors) and differentiated into OCl or FBGC on the surface of TCP discs comprising either submicron- or micron-scale surface topographical features (TCPs and TCPb, respectively). On submicrostructured TCPs, OCl survived, fused, differentiated, and extensively resorbed the substrate; however, on microstructured TCPb, OCl survival, TRAP activation, and fusion were attenuated. Importantly, no resorption was observed on microstructured TCPb. By confocal microscopy, OCl formed on TCPs contained numerous actin rings allowing for resorption, but not on TCPb. In comparison, FBGC could not resorb either TCP material, suggesting that osteoclast-specific machinery is necessary to resorb TCP. By tuning surface architecture, it appears possible to control osteoclast resorption of calcium phosphate. This approach presents a useful strategy in the design of resorbable bone graft substitutes.     

Histological evaluation of an impacted bone graft substitute composed of a combination of mineralized and demineralized allograft in a sheep vertebral bone defect

Demineralized bone matrix (DBMs) preparations are a potential alternative or supplement to autogenous bone graft, but many DBMs have not been adequately tested in clinically relevant animal models. The aim of current study was to compare the efficacy of a new bone graft substitute composed of a combination of mineralized and demineralized allograft, along with hyaluronic acid (AFT Bone Void Filler) with several other bone graft materials in a sheep vertebral bone void model. A drilled defect in the sheep vertebral body was filled with either the new DBM preparation, calcium sulfate (OsteoSet), autologous bone graft, or left empty. The sheep were euthanized after 6 or 12 weeks, and the defects were examined by histology and quantitative histomorphometry. The morphometry data were analyzed by one-way analysis of variance with the post hoc Tukey-Kramer test or the Student's t-test. All of the bone defects in the AFT DBM preparation group showed good new bone formation with variable amounts of residual DBM and mineralized bone graft. The DBM preparation group at 12 weeks contained significantly more new bone than the defects treated with calcium sulfate or left empty (respectively, p < 0.05, p < 0.01). There was no significant difference between the DBM and autograft groups. No adverse inflammatory reactions were associated with any of the three graft materials. The AFT preparation of a mixture of mineralized and demineralized allograft appears to be an effective autograft substitute as tested in this sheep vertebral bone void model.