Notch receptor and Notch ligand expression in developing avian cartilage

The development of limb cartilage involves complex signalling pathways allowing the formation of distinct segments of cartilage that are maintained in the fully developed joint. In this study, we investigated the Notch signalling pathway and its role in cartilage development. The differential distribution of the Notch signalling family of receptors and their corresponding ligands in developing avian ( gallus gallus ) cartilage revealed expression of Notch 1, Delta 1, Jagged 1 and Jagged 2 in all limb mesenchyme cells at the early stages of cartilage anlagen development, which were subsequently restricted to the developing cartilage element. Expression of both Notch 1 and Jagged 1 became increasingly restricted to the surface cartilage once joint cavity formation had occurred. Delta 1 and Jagged 1 were restricted to a layer of cells underneath the surface cartilage and were also observed in the hypertrophic chondrocytes, where Notch 1 expression was evident in stage 40–44 limbs. Notch 2, Notch 3 and Notch 4 were not evident in early stage limbs but were present after cavitation, although expression was lost in late stage limbs (stage 40–44). We also demonstrated that inhibition of the Notch pathway leads to altered Notch receptor expression, disrupting cartilage differentiation. From these data it is clear that Notch signalling is a necessary and critical factor in regulating cell fate decisions allowing controlled chondrogenesis, elongation and subsequent maintenance of limb cartilage.     

Ectodermal Wnt3/beta-catenin signaling is required for the establishment and maintenance of the apical ectodermal ridge

The formation of the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) is critical for the distal outgrowth and patterning of the vertebrate limb. Recent work in the chick has demonstrated that interplay between the Wnt and Fgf signaling pathways is essential in the limb mesenchyme and ectoderm in the establishment and perhaps the maintenance of the AER. In the mouse, whereas a role for Fgfs for AER establishment and function has been clearly demonstrated, the role of Wnt/beta-catenin signaling, although known to be important, is obscure. In this study, we demonstrate that Wnt3, which is expressed ubiquitously throughout the limb ectoderm, is essential for normal limb development and plays a critical role in the establishment of the AER. We also show that the conditional removal of beta-catenin in the ventral ectodermal cells is sufficient to elicit the mutant limb phenotype. In addition, removing beta-catenin after the induction of the ridge results in the disappearance of the AER, demonstrating the requirement for continued beta-catenin signaling for the maintenance of this structure. Finally, we demonstrate that Wnt/beta-catenin signaling lies upstream of the Bmp signaling pathway in establishment of the AER and regulation of the dorsoventral polarity of the limb.     

Altered expression of insulin-like growth factor-1 and insulin like growth factor binding proteins-2 and 5 in the mouse mutant Hypodactyly (Hd) correlates with sites of apoptotic activity

Insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I) mediated signalling has been implicated to be of significant importance during vertebrate embryonic development. IGF-I signalling has also been shown to be modulated by a number of IGF binding proteins that are thought to act as either agonists or antagonists of IGF activity. IGF-I has been implicated in a number of cellular processes, including cell division and programmed cell death (apoptosis). We have used the mouse mutant Hypodactyly (Hd) as a tool to determine the role of IGF-I and two key IGF binding proteins (IGFBP-2 and IGFBP-5) during embryonic development. The Hd mutant is a good model with which to study developmental cascades, since it has a distinct phenotype in the limb where cellular and molecular circuits have been thoroughly investigated. The distinctive pointed limb buds observed in Hd mutant embryos have been shown to be the result of a massive increase in apoptosis. We show that all three genes, IGF-1, IGFBP-2 and IGFBP-5, display restricted expression patterns during limb development. Indeed, IGFBP-5 shows a remarkable similarity to the expression of Engrailed-1, which is the vertebrate homologue of the Drosophila selector gene Engrailed. We show that there is downregulation in the expression of IGFBP-2 in the entire apical ectodermal ridge (AER) in homozygous Hd/Hd limb buds, whereas IGFBP-5 is downregulated in specific regions in the mutant AER. IGF-I expression is downregulated in Hd limb buds in regions undergoing high levels of cell death, consistent with its proposed role as an anti-apoptotic factor, while IGFBP-5 is found at higher levels in regions of cell death, consistent with reports of its association with apoptosis in adult tissues. We propose that these three components of the IGF axis could be involved in the manifestation of the mutant phenotype in Hypodactyly, and that this is probably a result of their ability to regulate cell survival and cell death.     

Altered expression of insulin-like growth factor -1 and insulin like growth factor binding proteins-2 and 5 in the mouse mutant Hypodactyly (Hd) correlates with sites of apoptotic activity

Insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I) mediated signalling has been implicated to be of significant importance during vertebrate embryonic development. IGF-I signalling has also been shown to be modulated by a number of IGF binding proteins that are thought to act as either agonists or antagonists of IGF activity. IGF-I has been implicated in a number of cellular processes, including cell division and programmed cell death (apoptosis). We have used the mouse mutant Hypodactyly (Hd) as a tool to determine the role of IGF-I and two key IGF binding proteins (IGFBP-2 and IGFBP-5) during embryonic development. The Hd mutant is a good model with which to study developmental cascades, since it has a distinct phenotype in the limb where cellular and molecular circuits have been thoroughly investigated. The distinctive pointed limb buds observed in Hd mutant embryos have been shown to be the result of a massive increase in apoptosis. We show that all three genes, IGF-1, IGFBP-2 and IGFBP-5, display restricted expression patterns during limb development. Indeed, IGFBP-5 shows a remarkable similarity to the expression of Engrailed-1, which is the vertebrate homologue of the Drosophila selector gene Engrailed. We show that there is downregulation in the expression of IGFBP-2 in the entire apical ectodermal ridge (AER) in homozygous Hd/Hd limb buds, whereas IGFBP-5 is downregulated in specific regions in the mutant AER. IGF-I expression is downregulated in Hd limb buds in regions undergoing high levels of cell death, consistent with its proposed role as an anti-apoptotic factor, while IGFBP-5 is found at higher levels in regions of cell death, consistent with reports of its association with apoptosis in adult tissues. We propose that these three components of the IGF axis could be involved in the manifestation of the mutant phenotype in Hypodactyly, and that this is probably a result of their ability to regulate cell survival and cell death. Accepted: 1 February 2000     

The extracellular ATP receptor, cP2Y(1), inhibits cartilage formation in micromass cultures of chick limb mesenchyme.

We have investigated the function of the G protein-coupled receptor for extracellular ATP, chick P2Y(1) (cP2Y(1)) during development of the chick limb. cP2Y(1) is strongly expressed in undifferentiated limb mesenchyme cells but appears to be lost from cells as they differentiate, raising the possibility that the function of this receptor may be to inhibit cell differentiation. This pattern of expression was particularly striking surrounding areas of cartilage formation. We tested whether cP2Y(1) was able to regulate cartilage formation by using an in-vitro micromass model of chondrogenesis. Because limb cells in micromass culture lose expression of cP2Y(1), we have used a gain-of-function approach to demonstrate that cP2Y(1) expression can inhibit cartilage differentiation. We also demonstrate that early limb mesenchyme cells release ATP into the extracellular medium and have mechanisms to breakdown extracellular ATP. These results suggest that extracellular ATP, signaling through cP2Y(1), can modulate the differentiation of limb mesenchyme cells in vitro, and the expression pattern of cP2Y(1) suggests that this type of signaling could play a similar role in ovo.     

Premature regression of the leg apical ectodermal ridge in the Japanese chick wingless mutant

The autosomal dominant Japanese wingless mutant has varying degrees of wing and leg truncations. The wing defects range from complete loss to negligible defects, whereas leg abnormalities are usually restricted to loss of the phalanges. Further analyses of the mutant focusing on the leg, which has been relatively uncharacterized, were performed. The expression pattern of Fgf8, a marker gene for the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) that controls outgrowth of the limbs, revealed premature regression at stage 28. Electron microscopy study showed abnormalities in the basement membrane all through the AER in the same stage. In the mutant, cell death was observed in the mesenchyme underlying AER between stages 31 and 32, although in the wild-type leg, AER regression and cell death occurred almost simultaneously at stages 33–34. To know if the cell death and cessation of the outgrowth are common mechanisms of wild-type and the mutant, we removed the AER in wild-type embryos at stage 28 and followed the fate of the limb. This also resulted in premature cell death 48 h after AER removal (equivalent to stage 32) and limb truncations similar to those observed in mutant limbs. To confirm whether either AER or underlying mesenchyme is responsible for the truncation, transplantation of the AER between the wild-type and the mutant was performed. This revealed that AER is the defective tissue in this mutant.     

Defects in limb, craniofacial, and thymic development in Jagged2 mutant mice

The Notch signaling pathway is a conserved intercellular signaling mechanism that is essential for proper embryonic development in numerous metazoan organisms. We have examined the in vivo role of the Jagged2 (Jag2) gene, which encodes a ligand for the Notch family of transmembrane receptors, by making a targeted mutation that removes a domain of the Jagged2 protein required for receptor interaction. Mice homozygous for this deletion die perinatally because of defects in craniofacial morphogenesis. The mutant homozygotes exhibit cleft palate and fusion of the tongue with the palatal shelves. The mutant mice also exhibit syndactyly (digit fusions) of the fore- and hindlimbs. The apical ectodermal ridge (AER) of the limb buds of the mutant homozygotes is hyperplastic, and we observe an expanded domain of Fgf8 expression in the AER. In the foot plates of the mutant homozygotes, both Bmp2 and Bmp7 expression and apoptotic interdigital cell death are reduced. Mutant homozygotes also display defects in thymic development, exhibiting altered thymic morphology and impaired differentiation of γδ lineage T cells. These results demonstrate that Notch signaling mediated by Jag2 plays an essential role during limb, craniofacial, and thymic development in mice.     

Retinoic acid is essential for Shh/Hoxd signaling during rat limb outgrowth but not for limb initiation.

Retinoids long have been implicated in limb development and their endogenous contributions to this process are finally being elucidated. Here we use an established model of retinoid depletion during specific gestational windows to investigate the role of endogenous retinoic acid (RA) in supporting limb outgrowth. Rat embryos were deprived of RA starting at days-postcoitum (dpc) 3.0, 5.5, or 7.0 and harvested at the 35-somite stage (dpc 12-12.5). Although embryos from all these windows possessed many characteristics of gestational retinoid deficiency (frontonasal hypoplasia, straight tail, reduced CRBPI and RAR beta), their limb buds emerged with only modest size reductions. Molecular analysis of RA-deficient limb buds revealed enhanced gli-3 and reduced hoxd-12, hoxd-13, shh, and fgf-4, while fgf-8, en-1, and wnt-7a expression remained unaltered. Occasional posterior truncations were observed at low incidence in the longest deficiency window; otherwise, the deficiency window length had no discernable impact on the severity of these changes. At the 45-somite stage, RA-deficient limbs had additional losses of hoxd-13 and fgf-8, accompanied by a flattened AER, suggestive of an ultimate failure in limb bud outgrowth. Results could not confirm a function for endogenous retinoids in limb initiation, but show they are required to maintain the signaling loops between the developing mesenchyme and AER that govern limb outgrowth after the initial emergence of limb bud.     

Premature regression of the leg apical ectodermal ridge in the Japanese chick <Emphasis Type="Italic">wingless</Emphasis> mutant

The autosomal dominant Japanese wingless mutant has varying degrees of wing and leg truncations. The wing defects range from complete loss to negligible defects, whereas leg abnormalities are usually restricted to loss of the phalanges. Further analyses of the mutant focusing on the leg, which has been relatively uncharacterized, were performed. The expression pattern of Fgf8, a marker gene for the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) that controls outgrowth of the limbs, revealed premature regression at stage 28. Electron microscopy study showed abnormalities in the basement membrane all through the AER in the same stage. In the mutant, cell death was observed in the mesenchyme underlying AER between stages 31 and 32, although in the wild-type leg, AER regression and cell death occurred almost simultaneously at stages 33–34. To know if the cell death and cessation of the outgrowth are common mechanisms of wild-type and the mutant, we removed the AER in wild-type embryos at stage 28 and followed the fate of the limb. This also resulted in premature cell death 48 h after AER removal (equivalent to stage 32) and limb truncations similar to those observed in mutant limbs. To confirm whether either AER or underlying mesenchyme is responsible for the truncation, transplantation of the AER between the wild-type and the mutant was performed. This revealed that AER is the defective tissue in this mutant.     

Notch inhibition by the ligand DELTA-LIKE 3 defines the mechanism of abnormal vertebral segmentation in spondylocostal dysostosis

Mutations in the DELTA-LIKE 3 (DLL3) gene cause the congenital abnormal vertebral segmentation syndrome, spondylocostal dysostosis (SCD). DLL3 is a divergent member of the DSL family of Notch ligands that does not activate signalling in adjacent cells, but instead inhibits signalling when expressed in the same cell as the Notch receptor. Targeted deletion of Dll3 in the mouse causes a developmental defect in somite segmentation, and consequently vertebral formation is severely disrupted, closely resembling human SCD. In contrast to the canonical Notch signalling pathway, very little is known about the mechanism of cis-inhibition by DSL ligands. Here, we report that Dll3 is not presented on the surface of presomitic mesoderm (PSM) cells in vivo, but instead interacts with Notch1 in the late endocytic compartment. This suggests for the first time a mechanism for Dll3-mediated cis-inhibition of Notch signalling, with Dll3 targeting newly synthesized Notch1 for lysosomal degradation prior to post-translational processing and cell surface presentation of the receptor. An inhibitory role for Dll3 in vivo is further supported by the juxtaposition of Dll3 protein and Notch1 signalling in the PSM. Defining a mechanism for cis-inhibition of Notch signalling by Dll3 not only contributes greatly to our understanding of this ligand's function during the formation of the vertebral column, but also provides a paradigm for understanding how other ligands of Notch cis-inhibit signalling.     

Dichotomy of Notch signalling in regulating tumour immune surveillance

Notch signalling is an evolutionarily conserved multifaceted pathway that controls diverse cellular processes. Its role in regulating development and tissue homeostasis is well established. Aberrant activation of the Notch pathway has been implicated in the initiation and progression of many types of cancers. However, although in some cancers Notch signalling acts as a tumour‐promoter, in others it is reported to suppress tumour growth and progression. Accumulating evidence suggests the involvement of both the innate and adaptive immune system in the development of various tumours. Currently, extensive studies on investigating the effects of Notch signalling in tumour immune surveillance are being carried out. Interestingly, recent literature shows how the changing expression of Notch genes in different T cell subsets like CD4 and CD8 helps in controlling anti‐tumour immune responses. In this review, we discuss in depth the roles of Notch signalling molecules and different immune cells in the context of the tumour microenvironment. We also outline how current knowledge can be exploited to develop novel therapies in order to control the propagation of cancer stem cells.     

Connexin expression and gap junction communication compartments in the developing mouse limb.

Fundamental to the understanding of mouse limb morphogenesis and pattern formation is the need to elucidate the spatial and temporal distribution of gap junction proteins (connexins, Cx) and cell-cell communication compartments. To this end, we used immunofluorescence and confocal microscopy together with 3-dimensional reconstruction software to map the distribution of Cx43 and Cx32 in 11-14.5 days postcoitum (dpc) mouse limbs. Cx43 was strictly localized to the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) and nonridge ectoderm throughout all stages of mouse limb development studied. Cx32, on the other hand, was abundant in the mesenchyme with only low levels of expression in the 11-13.5 dpc ectoderm. However, at 14-14.5 dpc there was a clear increase in Cx32 expression in the ectoderm. Double labeling for connexins and confocal microscopy revealed Cx43 and Cx32 in the same optical section of the basal cells of the ectoderm but in separate plaques. Lucifer yellow dye injections showed that the cells of the AER were in direct communication with the nonridge ectoderm but dye was never observed to spread to the mesenchyme. Cells of the mesenchyme were coupled to each other but to a much lesser extent than cells of the ectoderm. Finally, although there was an increase in Cx32 expression in the ectoderm at 14-14.5 dpc, this was not correlated with any detectable change in communication compartments. Thus, the lack of dye transfer between the ectoderm and underlying mesenchyme from the peak of AER height through its decline suggests that bulk transfer of morphogens between these two layers is not necessary for mouse limb development.     

Wnt10a is involved in AER formation during chick limb development.

The apical ectodermal ridge (AER) is indispensable for vertebrate limb development and requires Wnt/beta-catenin signaling for induction and maintenance. We report identification and involvement of Wnt10a in AER formation during chick limb development. Chicken Wnt10a has 82% identity with mouse Wnt10a in the amino acid sequence. The Wnt10a gene was expressed broadly in the surface ectoderm from as early as stage 10. By stage 15, the expression was restricted to the surface ectoderm overlying the lateral plate mesoderm. Wnt10a expression became intensified in the presumptive limb ectoderm during AER formation, and subsequently intense expression signals persisted in the AER. Wnt10a misexpression led to ectopic Fgf8 expression in the developing limb ectoderm and induced translocation of beta-catenin in chick embryo fibroblasts. These results suggest that Wnt10a is involved in AER formation in the chick limb bud through the Wnt/beta-catenin signaling pathway.     

Defining boundaries during joint cavity formation: going out on a limb

Whilst factors controlling the site at which joints form within the developing limb are recognised, the mechanisms by which articular element separation occurs during the formation of the joint cavity have not been determined. Herein, we review the relationships between early limb patterning, embryonic movement, extracellular matrix composition, local signalling events and the process of joint cavity formation. We speculate that a pivotal event in this process involves the demarcation of signalling boundaries, established by local mechano-dependent modifications in glycosaminoglycan synthesis. In our opinion, studies that examine early patterning and also focus on local developmental alterations in tissue architecture are required in order to help elucidate the fundamental principals regulating joint formation.     

In vivo inhibition of programmed cell death by local administration of FGF-2 and FGF-4 in the interdigital areas of the embryonic chick leg bud

The formation of the digits in amniote vertebrates is accompanied by a massive degeneration process that accounts for the disappearance of the interdigital mesenchyme. The establishment of these areas of interdigital cell death (INZs) is concomitant with the flattening of the apical ectodermal ridge (AER), but a possible causal relationship between these processes has not been demonstrated. Recent studies have shown that the function of the AER can be substituted for by implantation of beads bearing either FGF-2 or FGF-4 into the apical mesoderm of the early limb bud. According to these observations, if the onset of INZs is triggered by the cessation of the AER function, local administration of FGFs to the interdigital tissue prior to cell death should delay or inhibit interdigit degeneration. In the present study we have confirmed this prediction. Implanting Affi-gel blue or heparin beads pre-absorbed with either FGF-2 or FGF-4 into the interdigital tissue of the chick leg bud in the stages prior to cell death stimulates cell proliferation and causes the formation of webbed digits. Vital staining with neutral red confirmed an intense temporal inhibition of interdigital cell death after FGF treatment. This inhibition of interdigital cell death was not accompanied by modifications in the pattern of expression of Msx-1 or Msx-2 genes, which in normal development display a domain of expression in the interdigital tissue preceding the onset of degeneration.     

Constitutive Notch signalling promotes CD4 CD8 thymocyte differentiation in the absence of the pre-TCR complex, by mimicking pre-TCR signals

Notch1 signalling is essential for the commitment of multipotent lymphocyte precursors towards the alphabeta T-cell lineage and plays an important role in regulating beta-selection in CD4(-)CD8(-) double-negative (DN) thymocytes. However, the role played by Notch in promoting the development of CD4(+)CD8(+) double-positive (DP) thymocytes is poorly characterized. Here, we demonstrate that the introduction of a constitutively active Notch1 (ICN1) construct into RAG(-/-) lymphocyte precursors resulted in the generation of DP thymocytes in in vitro T-cell culture systems. Notably, developmental rescue was dependent not only on the presence of an intact Notch1 RAM domain but also on Delta-like signals, as ICN1-induced DP development in RAG(-/-) thymocytes occurred within an intact thymus or in OP9-DL1 co-cultures, but not in OP9-control co-cultures. Interestingly, ICN1 expression in SLP-76(-/-) precursors resulted in only a minimal developmental rescue to the immature CD8(+) single-positive stage, suggesting that Notch is utilizing the same signalling pathway as the pre-TCR complex. In support of this, ICN1 introduction resulted in the activation of the ERK-MAPK-signalling cascade in RAG(-/-) thymocytes. Taken together, these studies demonstrate that constitutive Notch signalling can bypass beta-selection during early T-cell development by inducing pre-TCR-like signals within a T-cell-promoting environment.     

Two lineage boundaries coordinate vertebrate apical ectodermal ridge formation

Proximal-distal outgrowth of the vertebrate limb bud is regulated by the apical ectodermal ridge (AER), which forms at an invariant position along the dorsal-ventral (D/V) axis of the embryo. We have studied the genetic and cellular events that regulate AER formation in the mouse. In contrast to implications from previous studies in chick, we identified two distinct lineage boundaries in mouse ectoderm prior to limb bud outgrowth using a Cre/loxP-based fate-mapping approach and a novel retroviral cell-labeling technique. One border is transient and at the limit of expression of the ventral gene En1, which corresponds to the D/V midline of the AER, and the second border corresponds to the dorsal AER margin. Labeling of AER precursors using an inducible Cre showed that not all cells that initially express AER genes form the AER, indicating that signaling is required to maintain an AER phenotype. Misexpression of En1 at moderate levels specifically in the dorsal AER of transgenic mice was found to produce dorsally shifted AER fragments, whereas high levels of En1 abolished AER formation. In both cases, the dorsal gene Wnt7a was repressed in cells adjacent to the En1-expressing cells, demonstrating that signaling regulated by EN1 occurs across the D/V border. Finally, fate mapping of AER domains in these mutants showed that En1 plays a part in positioning and maintaining the two lineage borders.