Diagnostic management and outcomes of pulmonary tuberculosis suspects admitted to a central hospital in Malawi

Setting:

Zomba Central Hospital, Malawi.

Objective:

To determine diagnostic management and outcomes of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) suspects admitted to adult wards.

Design:

A retrospective, cross-sectional review of medical records of patients admitted to hospital between July and September 2010.

Results:

There were 141 PTB suspects. Sputum examination was requested and performed in 67 (48%) suspects, but none were smear-positive. Chest X-ray (CXR) was requested and performed in 26 (39%) suspects whose sputum smears were negative. Eleven suspects had a CXR suggestive of PTB: two were started on TB treatment and eight died before treatment started. Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) status was known for 50 patients (35% of all suspects) on admission, all of whom were HIV-positive. HIV testing was requested for 37 patients, but was only performed in 12, five of whom were HIV-positive. Only one patient was referred for antiretroviral treatment. There were 41 (29%) deaths, eight of whom had probable TB and were not treated. In the remaining 33 patients who died, only nine (27%) had sputum smears examined and four (12%) had a CXR.

Conclusion:

The study shows inadequacies in the diagnostic management of PTB suspects in the Zomba Central Hospital, but suggests opportunities for improvement.     

Effectiveness of a community-based observation of anti-tuberculosis treatment in Bangalore City,India, 2010-2011

Setting:

The Revised National Tuberculosis Control Programme in an urban setting of Bangalore City, India.

Objectives:

To compare treatment outcomes and smear conversion rates among new smear-positive tuberculosis (TB) patients undergoing treatment administered by community directly observed treatment (DOT) providers with those undergoing treatment administered by institutional DOT providers in Bangalore City in 2010-2011.

Method:

Cohort study of routine data recorded from treatment cards of TB patients undergoing treatment under the public health services from 1 October 2010 to 30 September 2011.

Result:

Treatment records of 1864 new smear-positive TB patients registered during this period were evaluated. Among those evaluated, 604 (32%) had been administered treatment by community DOT providers and the remainder by institutional DOT providers. The treatment success rate in those undergoing community DOT was 93% (n = 564) and that of those undergoing institutional DOT was 75% (n = 951; RR 1.23, 95%CI 1.19-1.28). The sputum smear conversion rate of patients who underwent community DOT was 92% and that of those who underwent institutional DOT was 71% at the end of 2 months.

Conclusion:

We conclude that community DOT for treatment supervision of TB patients is more effective than institutional DOT and that it should be reinforced.     

Sputum smear examination and time to diagnosis in patients with smear-negative pulmonary tuberculosis in the Pacific

Setting:

National tuberculosis programmes (NTPs) in Kiribati and the Marshall Islands, 2006–2010.

Objective:

To determine the proportion of all tuberculosis (TB) cases that were pulmonary smear-negative, and for these patients to determine how many sputum smears were examined and the time from sputum smear examination to registration.

Design:

A retrospective cross-sectional study involving a record review of national TB and laboratory registers.

Results:

Of 2420 TB cases identified, 709 (29%) were registered as smear-negative pulmonary TB. Of the 695 (98%) with information on smear examination, 222 (32%) had no smear recorded, 61 (9%) had one smear, 86 (12%) two smears and 326 (47%) three smears. Among the 473 patients who had at least one smear, 238 (50%) were registered before sputum examination, 131 (28%) within 1 week, 72 (15%) between 1 and 4 weeks, and 34 (7%) >4 weeks after sputum examination.

Conclusion:

NTPs in Kiribati and the Marshall Islands are diagnosing 29% of all TB patients as smear-negative pulmonary TB. Many patients do not have smears done or are registered before undergoing smear examination. Corrective measures are needed.     

Number of sputum specimens during treatment follow-up of tuberculosis patients: two or one?

Setting:

National Institute for Research in Tuberculosis clinics in Chennai and Madurai, India.

Objective:

To examine the pattern of serial smears (negative-negative [NN], negative-positive [NP], positive-negative [PN], positive-positive [PP]) during treatment follow-up of culture-confirmed new smear-positive tuberculosis (TB) patients, and the proportion of culture-negatives in each category.

Design:

We reviewed the records and extracted follow-up smear (fluorescent microscopy) and culture (Löwenstein-Jensen) results of patients enrolled in clinical trials from January 2000 to August 2012 and treated with the Category I regimen (2EHRZ₃/4HR₃). Data entry and analysis were performed using EpiData.

Results:

Among 520 patients (176 infected with the human immunodeficiency virus), the proportions of culture-negative patients with NN, discordant (PN or NP) and PP patterns were approximately 98%, 80% and 40%, respectively. The smear-positive culture-negative phenomenon was more frequent in follow-up smear results graded 1+, followed by 2+ and 3+.

Conclusion:

There is justification for discontinuing the examination of second specimens during treatment follow-up among TB patients. However, a positive result on the first smear needs to be confirmed by a second positive result before making clinical management decisions. The World Health Organization may need to reconsider its recommendation on this issue.     

Comprehensiveness of primary services in the care of infectious tuberculosis patients in Rawalpindi,Pakistan

Setting:

All tuberculosis (TB) diagnostic centres of Rawalpindi District, Pakistan, including five tertiary care hospitals and 16 rural health centres.

Objective:

To identify among sputum smear-positive patients registered during 2009 in the laboratory register those who had not been recorded in a treatment register, defined in the study as ‘initial loss to follow-up’.

Design:

A retrospective record review of routine TB data.

Results:

There were 16 145 suspects screened for TB and recorded in the laboratory registers. Of 1698 smear-positive patients identified in the laboratory registers, 101 (6%) could not be identified in the treatment registers. Eighty-six (10%) of 842 patients in tertiary care hospitals and 15/856 (2%) in rural health centres were not recorded (OR 6.4, 95%CI 3.6–11.6, P < 0.01).

Conclusion:

The study shows a significant association between type of health facility and initial loss to follow-up. In rural health centres, the proportion lost to follow-up is low, reflecting more efficient care than in tertiary care hospitals. Strategies are urgently needed to improve the registration and follow-up of smear-positive cases in tertiary care institutions.     

Characteristics and treatment outcomes of tuberculosis retreatment cases in three regional hospitals,Uganda

Setting:

Three regional referral hospitals in Uganda with a high burden of tuberculosis (TB) and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) cases.

Objective:

To determine the treatment outcomes of TB retreatment cases and factors influencing these outcomes.

Design:

A retrospective cohort study of routinely collected National Tuberculosis Programme data between 1 January 2009 and 31 December 2010.

Results:

The study included 331 retreatment patients (68% males), with a median age of 36 years, 93 (28%) of whom were relapse smear-positive, 21 (6%) treatment after failure, 159 (48%) return after loss to follow-up, 26 (8%) relapse smear-negative and 32 (10%) relapse cases with no smear performed. Treatment success rates for all categories of retreatment cases ranged between 28% and 54%. Relapse smear-positive (P = 0.002) and treatment after failure (P = 0.038) cases were less likely to have a successful treatment outcome. Only 32% of the retreatment cases received a Category II treatment regimen; there was no difference in treatment success among patients who received Category II or Category I treatment regimens (P = 0.73).

Conclusion:

Management of TB retreatment cases and treatment success for all categories in three referral hospitals in Uganda was poor. Relapse smear-positive or treatment after failure cases were less likely to have a successful treatment outcome.     

Is physical access an impediment to tuberculosis diagnosis and treatment? A study from a rural district in North India

Setting:

All designated microscopy centres (DMCs) in Fatehgarh Sahib District, Punjab, India.

Objective:

To study the association of distance (physical access) to DMCs with loss to follow-up (LTFU) of presumptive tuberculosis (TB) cases while undergoing diagnostic sputum examination and failure to initiate treatment among smear-positive TB patients after diagnosis.

Design:

A cross-sectional, record-based study was undertaken to analyse patient records from routine laboratory registers in all DMCs from January to June 2012.

Result:

More than 50% of presumptive TB cases had to travel >7 km to reach the DMC, totalling >28 km for two sputum examinations for the evaluation of an episode. The distance (>10 km) to the diagnostic facility was found to be significantly associated (P < 0.01), both with LTFU during diagnosis and with a delay (>7 days) in initiating treatment after diagnosis. There was a significant correlation (r = 0.7) between distance to the DMC and time to initiate treatment among smear-positive TB cases.

Conclusion:

Distance from the nearest facility represents a significant risk for LTFU during diagnosis and delayed initiation of treatment after diagnosis. Further decentralisation of TB care services to the community level is required by expanding the network of DMCs or by organising sputum collection and transportation.     

Time to unsuccessful tuberculosis treatment outcome,Cambodia, China,and Viet Nam

Objective:

To determine the frequency and characteristics of patients with unsuccessful tuberculosis (TB) treatment.

Methods:

Random selection of TB case registers among all treatment units in Cambodia, two provinces in China, and Viet Nam. The data of two calendar years were analyzed to assess unsuccessful outcomes and their time of occurrence.

Results:

Among the 33 309 TB patients, treatment was unsuccessful in respectively 10.1%, 3.0% and 9.1% of patients in Cambodia, China and Viet Nam. The risk of death was highest in Cambodia, higher among males than females, increased with age, and was more common among retreatment cases than new cases, and among patients with a high than a low sputum smear microscopy grade. Half of all deaths occurred in the first 2 months in Cambodia and within 11 weeks in China and Viet Nam. Median time to default was 3 months in Cambodia and Viet Nam, and about 2 months in China.

Conclusions:

Treatment was highly successful in the three study countries, with a low proportion of death and default. As the majority of defaulting occurs at the beginning of treatment, all countries should critically review their current policy of treatment support in this period.     

The burden and outcomes of childhood tuberculosis in Cotonou,Benin

Setting:

The National Tuberculosis Programme (NTP) and the paediatric ward of the General Hospital (GH), Cotonou, Benin.

Objective:

To describe the burden of tuberculosis (TB), characteristics and outcomes among children treated in Cotonou from 2009 to 2011.

Design:

Cross-sectional cohort study consisting of a retrospective record review of all children with TB aged <15 years.

Results:

From 2009 to 2011, 182 children with TB were diagnosed and treated (4.5% of total cases), 153 (84%) by the NTP and 29 (16%) by the GH; the latter were not notified to the NTP. The incidence rate of notified TB cases was between 8 and 13 per 100 000 population, and was higher in children aged >5 years. Of 167 children tested, 29% were HIV-positive. Treatment success was 72% overall, with success rates of 86%, 62% and 74%, respectively, among sputum smear-positive, sputum smear-negative and extra-pulmonary patients. Treatment success rates were lower in children with sputum smear-negative TB (62%) and those with HIV infection (58%).

Conclusion:

The number of children being treated for TB is low, and younger children in particular are underdiagnosed. There is a need to improve the diagnosis of childhood TB, especially among younger children, and to improve treatment outcomes among HIV-TB infected children, with better follow-up and monitoring.     

Cross-sectional studies of tuberculosis prevalence in Cambodia between 2002 and 2011

Objective

To measure trends in the pulmonary tuberculosis burden between 2002 and 2011 and to assess the impact of the DOTS (directly observed treatment, short-course) strategy in Cambodia.

Methods

Cambodia’s first population-based nationwide tuberculosis survey, based on multistage cluster sampling, was conducted in 2002. The second tuberculosis survey, encompassing 62 clusters, followed in 2011. Participants aged 15 years or older were screened for active pulmonary tuberculosis with chest radiography and/or for tuberculosis symptoms. For diagnostic confirmation, sputum smear and culture were conducted on those whose screening results were positive.

Findings

Of the 40 423 eligible subjects, 37 417 (92.6%) participated in the survey; 103 smear-positive cases and 211 smear-negative, culture-positive cases were identified. The weighted prevalences of smear-positive tuberculosis and bacteriologically-positive tuberculosis were 271 (95% confidence interval, CI: 212–348) and 831 (95% CI: 707–977) per 100 000 population, respectively. Tuberculosis prevalence was higher in men than women and increased with age. A 38% decline in smear-positive tuberculosis (P = 0.0085) was observed with respect to the 2002 survey, after participants were matched by demographic and geographical characteristics. The prevalence of symptomatic, smear-positive tuberculosis decreased by 56% (P = 0.001), whereas the prevalence of asymptomatic, smear-positive tuberculosis decreased by only 7% (P = 0.7249).

Conclusion

The tuberculosis burden in Cambodia has declined significantly, most probably because of the decentralization of DOTS to health centres. To further reduce the tuberculosis burden in Cambodia, tuberculosis control should be strengthened and should focus on identifying cases without symptoms and in the middle-aged and elderly population.     

Implementing rapid testing for tuberculosis in Mozambique

Problem

In Mozambique, pulmonary tuberculosis is primarily diagnosed with sputum smear microscopy. However this method has low sensitivity, especially in people infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Patients are seldom tested for drug-resistant tuberculosis.

Approach

The national tuberculosis programme and Health Alliance International introduced rapid testing of smear-negative sputum samples. Samples were tested using a polymerase-chain-reaction-based assay that detects Mycobacterium tuberculosis deoxyribonucleic acid and a mutation indicating rifampicin resistance; Xpert® MTB/RIF (Xpert®). Four machines were deployed in four public hospitals along with a sputum transportation system to transfer samples from selected health centres. Laboratory technicians were trained to operate the machines and clinicians taught to interpret the results.

Local setting

In 2012, Mozambique had an estimated 140 000 new tuberculosis cases, only 34% of which were diagnosed and treated. Of tuberculosis patients, 58% are HIV-infected.

Relevant changes

From 2012–2013, 1558 people were newly diagnosed with tuberculosis using sputum smears at intervention sites. Xpert® detected M. tuberculosis in an additional 1081 sputum smear-negative individuals, an increase of 69%. Rifampicin resistance was detected in 58/1081 (5%) of the samples. However, treatment was started in only 82% of patients diagnosed by microscopy and 67% of patients diagnosed with the rapid test. Twelve of 16 Xpert® modules failed calibration within 15 months of implementation.

Lessons learnt

Using rapid tests to diagnose tuberculosis is promising but logistically challenging. More affordable and durable platforms are needed. All patients diagnosed with tuberculosis need to start and complete treatment, including those who have drug resistant strains.     

Pre-treatment loss to follow-up among smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis cases: a 10-year audit of national data from Fiji

Setting:

All tuberculosis (TB) diagnostic and treatment centres in Fiji.

Objectives:

To report on pre-treatment loss to follow-up rates over a 10-year period (2001–2010) and to examine if patients’ age, sex and geographic origin are associated with the observed shortcomings in the health services.

Methods:

A retrospective review of routine programme data reconciling TB laboratory and treatment registers.

Results:

A total of 690 sputum smear-positive TB patients were diagnosed in the laboratory, of whom 579 (84%) were started on anti-tuberculosis treatment—an overall pre-treatment loss to follow-up of 111 (16%). Peak loss to follow-up rates were seen in 2003, 2004 and 2010. Pre-treatment losses were all aged ≥15 years. In the Western Division of Fiji, 33% of sputum-positive patients were declared pre-treatment loss to follow-up; this division had over five times the risk of such an adverse outcome compared to the Central Division (OR 5.2, 95%CI 3.1–8.9, P < 0.0001).

Conclusion:

This study has identified an important shortcoming in programme linkage, communication and feedback between TB diagnostic and treatment services, leading to high pre-treatment loss to follow-up rates. This negatively influences TB services, and ways to rectify this situation are discussed.     

Changes in tuberculosis notifications and treatment delay in Zambia when introducing a digital X-ray service

Setting:

In August 2009, a digital chest X-ray (CXR) machine was installed at a busy urban health centre in Lusaka, Zambia.

Objective:

To describe the changes in tuberculosis (TB) notifications and treatment delay ≥7 days in Zambia after introducing a digital X-ray service.

Design:

Operational retrospective research of TB notification, laboratory and CXR data for Q4 2008 (prior to digital CXR) compared to Q4 2009.

Results:

Notifications for sputum smear-negative TB increased by 8.1%, from 370/527 (70.2%) in Q4 2008 to 425/544 (78.1%) in Q4 2009, despite a 6.7% decrease in sputum smear positivity in Q4 2009. TB treatment delay decreased from 75/412 (18.2%) in Q4 2008 to 52/394 (13.2%) in Q4 2009 (P = 0.05).

Conclusion:

In Q4 2009, sputum smear-negative TB notifications increased and treatment delay decreased. However, accurate diagnosis of TB is challenging in this setting, and misdiagnosis and overtreatment may occur. Moreover, other factors in addition to the introduction of the digital X-ray service could have contributed to these findings. Nonetheless, we found that the digital X-ray service had many advantages and that it may aid in more efficient TB diagnosis.     

Implementing a tuberculosis child contact register to quantify children at risk for tuberculosis and HIV in Eldoret,Kenya

Setting:

Tuberculosis (TB) clinic in Eldoret, Kenya.

Objective:

To identify TB exposed children through the implementation of a child contact register (CCR). To assess the demographics of children exposed to TB and the potential for initiation of isoniazid preventive therapy (IPT) in this cohort.

Methods:

A CCR was implemented in routine care with health care workers querying index cases regarding child contacts. Data were retrospectively analyzed.

Results:

In 12 months, the CCR revealed 580 children exposed to TB. Of these, 58% were exposed to smear-positive TB and 30% were aged <5 years. Of those exposed to smear-positive TB, 15% may have qualified for IPT initiation. Only 6 (1%) child contacts were screened for TB disease. More than 50% of the children with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) positive mothers had not been HIV tested.

Conclusion:

Implementation of a CCR is a possible first step in child contact identification and management, which requires minimal resources and identifies children at risk for TB and HIV. Child contact screening and IPT initiation remain a challenge, and additional strategies are urgently needed.     

Beyond drugs: tuberculosis patients in Bangladesh need nutritional support during convalescence

Settings:

All sputum microscopy laboratories under the BRAC Tuberculosis Programme in Dhaka City.

Objectives:

To study the nutritional status of tuberculosis (TB) patients attending microscopy laboratories during convalescence following DOTS.

Design:

The study included 1068 TB patients registered for treatment at 10 laboratories from May 2010 to December 2011, and 910 healthy neighbourhood controls. Weight (in kg), height (in cm) and mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC; in cm) were measured before, at 2 months and immediately after completion of treatment. Body mass index (BMI) < 18.5 kg/m² and MUAC < 22.0 cm were taken as cut-offs for defining malnourishment.

Results:

Two thirds of the patients (67%) had a low BMI (<18.5 kg/m²) before treatment, compared to only 23% among the healthy controls. At the end of treatment, 50% of the patients still had a low BMI, including 12% who had severe malnourishment (BMI ≤ 16 kg/m²). MUAC < 22.0 cm was higher among patients before (42%), at 2 months (39%) and immediately after completion of treatment (34%) compared to the control group (9%).

Conclusions:

Malnutrition is a serious problem among TB patients in peri-urban areas of Dhaka City. Under the circumstances, additional nutritional supplements, combined with education on nutrition, are expected to contribute to rapid and sustained recovery during DOTS-based treatment.     

Are sputum samples of retreatment tuberculosis reaching the reference laboratories? A 9-year audit in Tanzania

Setting:

One reference and three zonal laboratories and 500 health facilities managing retreatment tuberculosis (TB) patients in Tanzania.

Objectives:

The National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Programme (NTLP) requires that all notified cases of retreatment TB in Tanzania have sputum samples sent for culture and drug susceptibility testing (DST). This study determined 1) if the number of annually notified retreatment patients corresponded to the number of sputum samples received by the reference laboratories, and 2) the number of culture-positive samples and the number of cases undergoing DST.

Design:

Nine-year audit of country-wide programme data from 2002 to 2010.

Results:

Of the 40 940 retreatment TB patients notified by the NTLP, 3871 (10%) had their sputum samples received at the reference and zonal laboratories for culture and DST. A total of 3761 (97%) sputum samples were processed for culture, of which 1589 (42%) were found to be culture-positive and 1415 (89%) had DST performed.

Conclusions:

There is a >90% shortfall between notified retreatment cases and numbers of sputum samples received, cultured and assessed for DST at reference and zonal laboratories. Steps needed to address this problem are discussed.     

Mobilising elementary and secondary school students for tuberculosis case finding in Anhui,China

Objectives:

To evaluate the implementation of a FIDELIS (Fund for Innovative DOTS Expansion through Local Initiatives to Stop TB) project in Anhui Province, China.

Design:

A survey card was designed for students to identify individuals who might have tuberculosis (TB) in their family. Teachers provided health education on TB before distributing the survey cards. Survey cards identifying individuals with respiratory symptoms for ≥3 weeks were sent by the teachers to village doctors who were trained to visit symptomatic individuals and advise them to undergo sputum examination. Data were routinely collected in the implementation of the FIDELIS project, and quarterly reports from the National Tuberculosis Programme were analysed. The detection of new smear-positive TB cases before and after FIDELIS, as well as with and without FIDELIS, were compared.

Results:

In the first year, a total of 2 387 405 students were involved and 23 079 symptomatic individuals were examined, among whom 2307 (10.3%) were diagnosed with smear-positive TB. Case detection in FIDELIS counties increased by a factor of 3.5 during the FIDELIS period compared with before FIDELIS, and that in non-FIDELIS counties by a factor of 3.1 (P = 0.001).

Conclusion:

It was feasible to massively mobilise students for TB case finding through collaboration between the health care and education systems.     

Timing of antiretroviral therapy and effects on tuberculosis treatment outcomes in HIV-co-infected patients in Malawi

Setting:

Queen Elizabeth Central Hospital, Blantyre, Malawi.

Objectives:

To determine 1) the proportion of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infected tuberculosis (TB) patients started on antiretroviral therapy (ART), 2) the timing of ART and 3) the effect of the timing on TB treatment outcomes.

Design:

A retrospective record review of HIV-infected TB patients registered from January to December 2009.

Results:

A total of 3376 TB patients were registered, of whom 2665 (79%) were HIV-tested and 2042 (77%) were HIV-infected. A total of 1190 HIV-infected TB patients who were not on ART at the time of starting TB treatment were studied. Of 688 (58%) who started ART, 61% started therapy within 2 months of anti-tuberculosis treatment and 39% started later (≥2 months). Treatment success for patients with TB who started ART within 2 months was higher than for those starting ART later (RR 1.6, 95%CI 1.4–1.8), and death rates were lower (RR 0.25, 95%CI 0.19–0.35).

Conclusion:

Under routine programme conditions in Malawi, a higher proportion of HIV-infected TB patients who started ART did so within 2 months of starting TB treatment, and early ART intervention was associated with better treatment outcomes. This confirms recommendations that co-infected TB patients should start ART early.     

Treatment outcomes of new adult tuberculosis patients in relation to HIV status in Zimbabwe

Setting:

All public health facilities in Chitungwiza District, Zimbabwe.

Objective:

To determine, in new tuberculosis (TB) patients registered in 2009, 1) the proportion of persons human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) tested, stratified by age, sex and type of TB, and 2) treatment outcomes in relation to type of TB and HIV status.

Design:

Retrospective cohort study.

Results:

Of 1800 TB patients, 1100 (61%) were tested, of whom 877 (80%) were HIV-positive and 75 (9%) were documented as receiving antiretroviral treatment (ART). HIV testing and HIV positivity were similar between patients with different types of TB. Overall, the treatment success rate was 70%, and 17% had transferred out. Being HIV-positive on ART was associated with better treatment success and lower transfer out; age ≥55 years was associated with poor treatment success and higher death rates. Defaulting was more common in those who did not undergo smear testing or in extra-pulmonary TB patients, while deaths were higher in males.

Conclusion:

In a Zimbabwe district, less than two thirds of TB patients were tested. Better treatment success was observed in patients documented as HIV-positive and on ART. Important lessons for improved TB control include increasing HIV testing uptake for better access to ART, more comprehensive recording practices on ART and better reporting on true outcomes of transfer-out patients.