The significance of intracompartmental pressures in diagnosing chronic exertional compartment syndrome – A metaanalysis of studies monitoring dynamic anterior compartment pressures during exercise

Summary Introduction: The chronic exertional compartment syndrome of the musculus tibialis anterior is thought to be responsible for a major part of complaints of the lower leg among active sportsmen. There is an important role of tissue pressure measurement in diagnosing chronic anterior compartment syndrome during muscular activity. However, there is a controversial debate about the relevant parameters. Methods: Metaanalysis of all the 21 studies (1979–1998) measuring intracompartmental pressures during muscular activity. Parameters of analysis: type of exercise, catheter technique, recommendations of diagnostic criteria. Results: Analysis of literature shows that there has been no standardisation concerning the type of muscular exertion (isometrics for 5–10 min, exercise on the treadmill between 3.2 and 12 km/h). In 8 of the 21 studies the results have been attained through the unsuitable Wick-catheter-technique. In the overall view none of the suggested criterions for diagnosis is taken up by other teams. There are considerable variations up to 500 % regarding the recommended parameters. Conclusions: From all studies no uniform recommendation for parameters of diagnostic relevance can be derived. On this background it should be demanded that future research is conducted by a uniform regimen for examination and modern technique of measuring with a high temporal resolution. Under these standardised conditions the investigated parameters of the intracompartmental pressure curve should be reconsidered once more regarding diagnostic predictability by calculations of specifity and sensitivity.      

The clinical diagnosis of compartment syndrome of the lower leg: are clinical findings predictive of the disorder?

OBJECTIVE: To assess whether published studies support basing the diagnosis of compartment syndrome of the lower leg on clinical findings. DATA SOURCES: A MEDLINE search of the English literature from 1966 to 2001 was performed using "compartment syndromes" as the subject. A manual search of the bibliographies of retrieved articles and of major orthopaedic texts was also performed. STUDY SELECTION AND EXTRACTION: Of 1,932 titles identified, 433 abstracts of potential relevance were reviewed, and 104 articles from relevant abstracts were examined in their entirety. Four studies met all eligibility criteria. Criteria for inclusion included the following: (a) target population, traumatic or iatrogenic tibia injuries; (b) diagnostic test, presence of data needed to calculate both the sensitivity and specificity of clinical findings; (c) outcome, the presence or absence of compartment syndrome; and (d) methodologic criteria, prospective study design. DATA SYNTHESIS: The likelihood ratio form of Bayes' theorem was used to assess the discriminatory ability of the clinical findings as tests for the compartment syndrome. CONCLUSIONS: There are limited data from which to define the usefulness of clinical findings for the diagnosis of compartment syndrome. Data from eligible studies suggest that the sensitivity of clinical findings for diagnosing compartment syndrome is low (13% to 19%). The positive predictive value of the clinical findings was 11% to 15%, and the specificity and negative predictive value were each 97% to 98%. These findings suggest that the clinical features of compartment syndrome of the lower leg are more useful by their absence in excluding the diagnosis than they are when present in confirming the diagnosis. Likelihood ratio calculations found that the probability of compartment syndrome with one clinical finding was approximately 25%, and the probability was 93% with 3 clinical findings present. However, these findings are based on limited information; because of the paucity of data available, the predictive value of the clinical findings for the diagnosis of compartment syndrome has yet to be defined.     

What is the effect of compartment syndrome and fasciotomies on fracture healing in tibial fractures?

Acute compartment syndrome (ACS) in tibial diaphyseal fractures has been associated with such complications as infection, delayed fracture healing or non-union, sensory and motor deficits, deformities, and poor functional outcome. Essential condition of an uncomplicated recovery is early diagnosis with prompt decompression. A comprehensive review of the literature was performed to evaluate the impact of compartment syndrome and leg fasciotomies on the time to fracture union and the incidence of delayed union and non-union in tibial diaphyseal fractures. A total of 16 articles, which included 245 tibial fractures complicated with compartment syndrome were analysed. There were statistically significant differences in the time to healing, being longer by 4.90 weeks (p < 0.001), and in the rates of delayed union or non-union (55% versus 17.8%) (p < 0.001) when these fractures were compared to tibial fractures without compartment syndrome. Patients with ACS of the tibia undergoing leg fasciotomies should be informed about the increased risk of impaired fracture healing and longer time to union.     

Does patient controlled analgesia delay the diagnosis of compartment syndrome following intramedullary nailing of the tibia?

We report on four cases in which the diagnosis of compartment syndrome was delayed by the administration of patient controlled analgesia (PCA) following intramedullary nailing of tibial shaft fractures. We believe that this poses a diagnostic problem and can lead to lasting sequelae as decompression is delayed. We recommend extra vigilance with the use of PCA in patients with intramedullary nailing following tibial shaft fractures.     

Axes of the legs in childhood. What is pathologic?

At birth the lower extremity is characterized by a varus axis in the lower leg and the knee joint in the frontal plane (bowleg) and an increased femoral antetorsion and a neutral or increased medial torsion of the lower leg in the transverse plane. By the time growth is complete a normal valgus axis of 5-9 degrees has developed in the lower limb and the femoral antetorsion has decreased to about 15 degrees. The lower leg will show a normal external rotation of 15 degrees on average. The evolution of the axis values in the lower extremity is influenced by changing compressive and propelling forces acting on the growth plates as the child adopts an upright posture. There is a wide range of normal values, but pathologic development of the leg axes is rare and mostly idiopathic. Secondary deviations of the axis from normal can occur. Careful clinical examinations are necessary to differentiate between pathologic and physiological variations. Further apparative diagnostic procedures help to elucidate the etiology and are essential for surgical planning. Nonoperative treatment alone is rarely sufficient to influence the deformity.     

The sublabral foramen: does it affect stress distribution on the anterior glenoid?

Even though it is believed that a sublabral foramen (SF) requires no treatment, no objective data are available to establish whether this condition bears a relationship to anterior-inferior glenohumeral instability. Therefore, the influence on glenoid subchondral bone mineralization of an isolated SF was investigated, because the individual distribution of subchondral bone mineralization may be used as an indirect parameter for long-term stress distribution of joints. Two age- and side-matched groups of healthy glenohumeral specimens with SF (n = 10, aged 37-85 years) and without SF (n = 10, aged 36-86 years) were examined by computed tomography osteoabsorptiometry. As variables for comparison, the anterior and posterior density maxima on the glenoid were measured in a standardized manner. No shift of the anterior density maximum [p(x1) = 0.353/p(y1) = 0.739] was found between both groups, which is in contrast to anterior glenohumeral instability. This indicates a long-term stress distribution in SF shoulders comparable to that in non-SF shoulders. The data suggest that an isolated SF is probably not disproportionately related to glenohumeral instability and support the general assumption that surgical treatment of SF is not required.     

Does the method of treatment affect the outcome in soft-tissue sarcomas of the adductor compartment?

We have investigated the significance of the method of treatment on the oncological and functional outcomes and on the complications in 184 patients with soft-tissue sarcomas of the adductor compartment managed at three international centres. The overall survival at five years was 65% and was related to the grade at diagnosis and the size of the tumour. There was no difference in overall survival between the three centres. There was, however, a significant difference in local control with a rate of 28% in Centre 1 compared with 10% in Centre 2 and 5% in Centre 3. The overall mean functional score using the Toronto Extremity Salvage Score in 70 patients was 77% but was significantly worse in patients with wound complications or high-grade tumours. The scores were not affected by the timing of radiotherapy or the use of muscle flaps. This large series of soft-tissue sarcomas of the adductor compartment has shown that factors influencing survival do not vary across the international boundaries studied, but that methods of treatment affect complications, local recurrence and function.     

Is external fixation needed for the treatment of tibial fractures with acute compartment syndrome?

Acute compartment syndrome (ACS) after tibial fracture carries a risk of various complications, including infection, delayed union, nonunion, nerve damage, and poor prognosis. For the treatment of fractures with ACS, fasciotomy is conducted, and the method to stabilise the fracture has to be considered. Thirty-five patients who underwent surgery for ACS with tibial shaft fractures were evaluated, and the results of initial internal fixation (Group I, 20 patients) and initial external fixation (Group II, 15 patients) were analysed. The mean age was 41 years. Five patients needed additional surgery for bone union. Complications occurred in 4 cases, but no deep infection was reported. The time to bone union, the need for additional surgery, and the incidence of complications in Group I and Group II were not statistically different. For the treatment of ACS with tibial fracture, immediate internal fixation and changing from external fixation to internal fixation did not affect the clinical course.     

Intraoperative hyperkalemia - initial sign of an incipient compartment syndrome?

We report the case of a 50 years old male patient who underwent an elective resection of the rectum in the Lloyd-Davis-position. During the surgery, first endoscopically and then by open laparatomy, which lasted 7.5 hours and the following postoperative time, plasma potassium concentration continuously increased up to 6.7 mval/l. On the first postoperative day, a compartment syndrome of the right lower limb was diagnosed.     

Reattachment of the endopelvic fascia to the apex during anterior colporrhaphy: does the type of suture matter?

Introduction and hypothesis

We aimed to determine if the use of permanent suture for the apical fixation during traditional anterior colporrhaphy results in improved outcomes compared to delayed absorbable suture.

Methods

A retrospective case-control study was performed in patients who underwent traditional non-grafted anterior colporrhaphy with reattachment of the anterior endopelvic fascia to the apex/cervix comparing permanent (group 1) or absorbable suture (group 2). Patients were matched based on age, body mass index, and presenting stage of prolapse. The primary outcome assessed was anterior wall vaginal prolapse recurrence defined as Pelvic Organ Prolapse Quantification (POP-Q) points Aa or Ba?≥??1 cm. Secondary outcome measures included overall prolapse stage, subjective reporting of satisfaction, and any healing abnormalities or complications resulting from suture type.

Results

A total of 230 patients were reviewed (80 in group 1 and 150 in group 2) and median follow-up was 52 (24–174) weeks. A statistically significant improvement in anterior wall anatomy was seen in group 1 compared to group 2 [(Aa ?2.70?±?0.6 cm vs ?2.5?±?0.75 cm, p?=?0.02) and Ba (?2.68?±?0.65 cm vs ?2.51?±?0.73 cm, p?=?0.03), respectively]. Comparing prolapse stage, there were no observed differences between the groups. Exposure of the permanent suture occurred in 12 patients (15 %) and 5 (6.5 %) required suture trimming to treat the exposure.

Conclusions

Reattachment of endopelvic fascia to the apex at the time of anterior colporrhaphy results in low recurrence rates. Use of permanent suture for apical fixation is associated with improved anatomic correction at the expense of increased suture exposures.     

The absence of a metal-on-metal bearing does not preclude the formation of a destructive pseudotumor in the hip—a case report

4 patients with a mean age of 20 years and isolated congenital radial head dislocation (1 unilateral anterior, 1 unilateral posterior and 2 bilateral anterior dislocations) were all pain-free and had almost normal elbow function.     

Tibial shaft fractures - to monitor or not? a multi-centre 2 year comparative study assessing the diagnosis of compartment syndrome in patients with tibial diaphyseal fractures

AimsThe aim of this study was to compare the outcome in patients who did and did not undergo continuous compartment pressure monitoring (CCPM) following a tibial diaphyseal fracture.Patients and methodsWe performed a retrospective cohort study of 287 patients with an acute tibial diaphyseal fractures who presented to three centres over a two-year period. Demographic data, diagnosis, management, wound closure, complications, and subsequent surgeries were recorded. The primary outcome measure was the rate of short-term complications. Secondary outcomes were time to fasciotomy and split-skin grafting rates.ResultsOf the 287 patients in the study cohort, 171 patients underwent CCPM (monitored group; MG) and 116 did not (non-monitored group; NMG). There were 21 patients who developed ACS and underwent fasciotomy, with comparable rates in both groups (n=13 in the MG vs n=8 in NMG; p=0.82). There was no difference in the rate of complications between groups (all p>0.05). The mean time from admission to fasciotomy was 22.1hrs, with a mean time of 19.8hrs in the MG and 25.8hrs in the NMG (mean difference, 6hrs; p=0.301). One patient in the NMG required a below-knee amputation. There was a trend towards a reduced requirement for split-skin grafting post decompression in the MG (15% vs 50%; p=0.14).ConclusionThis study found no difference in the short-term complication rates in those patients that underwent CCPM and those that did not following a fracture of the tibial diaphysis. CCPM does appear to be safe with no increase in the rate of fasciotomies performed. There was a trend towards a reduced time to fasciotomy and a reduced rate of split skin grafting for wound closure with CCPM.Level of evidenceLevel III (Diagnostic: Retrospective cohort study)     

Measurement of tissue hardness: can this be a method of diagnosing compartment syndrome noninvasively in children?

In order to assess the feasibility of using the measurement of tissue hardness as a method of diagnosing compartment syndrome noninvasively in children, a simple hand-held device to measure tissue hardness was fabricated. The relationship between hardness and compartmental pressure was studied in an experimental model and in three fresh amputated lower limbs. Normal tissue hardness of the forearm was measured in 189 children and 20 adults to identify the factors that influence normal tissue hardness. The reproducibility of measurement of tissue hardness was assessed on the experimental model, on the amputated limbs and in normal individuals. Experimental data from this study suggest that there is a nonlinear relationship between intracompartmental pressure and tissue hardness. The study also shows that tissue hardness can be measured reproducibly in the forearm of children with the device. Several factors influence tissue hardness such as the age of the child, the site of measurement on the limb, the hand dominance and active muscle contraction. These factors may affect the specificity of this measure as a screening tool for diagnosing compartment syndrome. Further refinement of the measuring device and well designed clinical trials are needed to establish whether compartmental syndrome can be diagnosed reliably by measuring tissue hardness noninvasively.