Free-electron laser and heat-conducting templates: a study of reducing cutaneous lateral thermal damage

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: We developed novel heat-conducting templates, and tested whether they could effectively remove damaging heat from the tissue during laser ablation. The reduction of lateral thermal damage during cutaneous incisional laser procedures should decrease the time in wound healing. In addition, we selected various infrared wavelengths to determine whether the template effects would be influenced by the laser penetration depth and the particular chromophore absorbing the laser light. STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS: This study utilized the Free-Electron Laser at wavelengths of 3.0, 5.5, 6.45, 7.5, and 7.7 microm to produce 1.0 cm incisions on in vitro lightly pigmented human skin. At each of these wavelengths, copper, aluminum, glass, and Plexiglas heat conducting templates were tested. At wavelength 5.5 microm, the study was duplicated using in vitro darkly pigmented skin. Histological samples were evaluated using computerized morphometric analysis. RESULTS: The adjunct use of both the copper and aluminum templates provided a decrease in thermal damage at each wavelength. Using the copper template reduced lateral thermal damage an average of 67% with no apparent wavelength dependence. The aluminum template reduced thermal damage an average of 54% with no apparent wavelength dependence. The glass and Plexiglas templates did not reduce the lateral thermal damage. At 5.5 microm, no statistically significant difference in lateral thermal damage was observed between darkly and lightly pigmented tissues. CONCLUSIONS: Heat-conducting templates are an effective new method to reduce lateral thermal damage from thermal laser incisions.     

Controlling thermal damage of incisions using diamond, copper, and sapphire heat-conducting templates with and without cooling

INTRODUCTION: We investigated the reduction of thermal damage to the surrounding tissue when laser incisions were made with and without using thermal conducting templates at room temperature and cooled to 5 degrees C. STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS: We used the Vanderbilt free-electron laser (FEL) at 5.4, 6.1, 6.45, and 7.7 microns. We also used a conventional continuous wave (CW) carbon dioxide laser at 10.6 microns. Incisions were made on 5x10 mm pieces of human breast skin (in vitro) and analyzed with histology. Computer morphometrics were used to measure the amount of thermal damage. RESULTS: All templates produced a statistically significant reduction in the thermal damage. Additionally, we showed that cooling the templates made a statistically significant greater reduction in the thermal damage. The cooled diamond template reduced the thermal damage from the FEL to 28% of the damage observed without a template. The same cooled template reduced the thermal damage from the CO(2) laser to 56% of the damage observed without a template. Lesser reductions were observed with the copper template and even less with the sapphire template. The sapphire template reduced the thermal damage to 39 and 67% of the damage observed without a template for the FEL and the CO(2) laser, respectively. CONCLUSION: These results indicate that unwanted lateral thermal damage from laser incisions can be reduced with cooled thermally conductive templates with the best results obtained with the diamond template, which is also the best thermal conductor.     

Nd-YAG laser thermal effect: Comparative study of coagulation in rat liver in vivo by continuous wave and high power pulsed lasers

The coagulation effect of a continuous-wave neodymium-YAG (Nd-YAG) laser and of a high-power (500 W) pulsed (3–500 ms) microcomputer-controlled Nd-YAG laser are compared in rat liver in vivo. In a series of 68 animals, surface temperature was measured with an infrared camera, and necrosed volume was assessed histologically 24 h after laser irradiation. The high-power pulsed Nd-YAG laser presents two interesting features. First, it gives a better control of surface temperature. Second, a controlled sequence of high-power short pulses produces a predictable coagulated volume which can be comparable to that obtained with continuous-wave Nd-YAG or argon lasers.     

Combination treatment utilizing fractional ablative and continuous wave CO2 lasers for hypertrophic burn scars

BackgroundHypertrophic scars are devastating outcomes of severe burn injuries, producing physical and mental burdens. Adequate treatment is of benefit to relieve these burdens. Laser therapy has shown scar reducing effects. In this study, we compared outcomes after combination of two different lasers or single laser treatment to treat severe hypertrophic burn scars.MethodsForty patients with hypertrophic burn scars were included in one of two therapeutic groups: continuous wave CO₂ laser and fractional ablative CO₂ laser group (group 1, n = 20) or fractional ablative CO₂ laser alone group (group 2, n = 20). Hypertrophic scars were evaluated by the observer-rated Vancouver Scar Scale (VSS) before and after treatment and by patient-completed questionnaires after treatment. Comparative analyses were performed before and after treatment, and time-dependent improvement was also analyzed.ResultsForty patients (54 hypertrophic scars) completed the laser treatment protocols. Group 1 exhibited significantly more improvement in VSS vascularity, pliability, and height indices than group 2 (p < 0.05). Time-dependent analysis of total VSS scores suggested that group 1 experienced more improvement during a shorter treatment period (p < 0.05). For patient-reported outcomes, group 1 noted better grades than group 2 in four indices, namely scar appearance, scar thickness, pain, and pruritus (p < 0.05).ConclusionEffective scar reduction was achieved using combination laser treatment, with significant improvement in multiple observer- and patient-reported outcomes. The shorter treatment period of the combination method can be a merit, as prolonged hypertrophic scars may increase morbidity. Nonetheless, cautious treatment protocols are necessary to avoid undesirable sequelae related to laser application.     

Comparative study between pulsed and continuous wave lasers for Photofrin® photodynamic therapy

A study was conducted in the normal canine esophagus to compare continuous wave (CW) and pulsed laser light for photodynamic therapy with Photofrin® (4 mg/kg). Forty-eight hours postinjection, 630 nm laser light (CW light from an argon-pumped dye-laser and pulsed light from a KTP/532-pumped dye-laser) was delivered using a 24 mm diameter cylindrical esophageal PDT balloon positioned at either distal or proximal esophagus. A 1.0 cm cylindrical diffuser placed in the center of the balloon delivered 300 J/cm of light at an intensity of 400 mW/cm. Three dogs received CW light proximally and pulsed light distally. Four dogs received CW light distally and pulsed light proximally. The light dose delivered to the esophageal mucosa was measured using three isotropic probes placed on the balloon wall. laser–induced fluorescence technique was used to compare photosensitizer fluorescence intensities at distal and proximal locations. Similar mucosal light doses and drug fluorescence intensities were verified for sites receiving pulsed or CW laser light. Two days after light delivery, the dogs were endoscoped to evaluate the severity of the lesions. While some response variability was observed among different animals, endoscopic examination of the lesions revealed comparable injury from CW and pulsed light in each subject. The animals were then euthanized and necropsies were performed. Based on the gross and histological examination of the lesions, the CW and pulsed laser–induced injuries could not be distinguished. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Thermal damage produced by high-irradiance continuous wave CO2 laser cutting of tissue

Thermal damage produced by continuous wave (cw) CO2 laser ablation of tissue in vitro was measured for irradiances ranging from 360 W/cm2 to 740 kW/cm2 in order to investigate the extent to which ablative cooling can limit tissue damage. Damage zones thinner than 100 microns were readily produced using single pulses to cut guinea pig skin as well as bovine cornea, aorta, and myocardium. Multiple pulses can lead to increased damage. However, a systematic decrease in damage with irradiance, predicted theoretically by an evaporation model of ablation, was not observed. The damage-zone thickness was approximately constant around the periphery of the cut, consistent with the existence of a liquid layer which stores heat and leads to tissue damage, and with a model of damage and ablation recently proposed by Zweig et al.     

Wound healing and collagen thermal damage in 7.5-microsec pulsed CO(2) laser skin incisions

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Wound-healing delays caused by lateral thermal damage to tissue remain a drawback of CO(2) surgical lasers. This study compares the thermal damage and wound-healing properties of a 7.5-micros pulsed CO(2) laser with scalpel and continuous wave (CW) CO(2) laser incisions. STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS: We created incisions on the dorsal pelts of rats with a 7.5-micros pulsed CO(2) laser at 5-, 10-, or 15-Hz repetition rate, a conventional CW laser, or scalpel. Animals were euthanized at postoperative days 3, 7, 14, 21, and 80. Tissue was harvested and analyzed histologically and for wound tensile strength. In addition, tissue was harvested acutely and analyzed for acute thermal injury lateral to the incisions. RESULTS: Incisions made with the pulsed laser had significantly higher tensile strength and histologic rankings than did CW laser incisions at days 3-21, producing 118 microm of thermal damage to tissue as compared with 333 microm for CW laser. Pulsed laser incisions were not statistically different than scalpel incisions at days 3-14 of healing. Mathematical modeling showed the pulsed laser to produce a wound healing delay of 1.0 day by tensiometry and 1.9 days by histology, compared with 3.2 days by tensiometry and 6.0 days by histology for CW laser. There were no significant differences in wound healing when the pulsed laser was used at repetition rates of 5-15 Hz. CONCLUSIONS: Using a 7.5-micros pulse duration, CO(2) laser incisions healed at a rate similar to scalpel incisions and reduced the wound-healing delay seen with typical surgical CO(2) lasers.     

Laser flap delay: comparison of Erbium:YAG and CO2 lasers

The delay phenomenon has long been recognized as a powerful tool in reconstructive surgery. This phenomenon involves creating alterations in skin flap blood supply or microcirculation to increase the size of the surviving flap. In the past many reconstructive surgeons depended on surgical delay as an integral part of their surgical planning. Today surgical delay remains a reliable method for maximizing flap survival. Although surgical delay remains the gold standard many have searched for methods to create the same effect with less morbidity and reduced cost. The purpose of this study was to determine whether near-scarless delay can be performed with either the Erbium:YAG or CO2 laser using a standard McFarlane skin flap model. Four groups were identified. Surgical delay, Erbium laser delay, and CO2 laser delay groups were each compared with a nondelayed control. Each group consisted of ten Sprague-Dawley rats. On Day 0 all delay procedures were performed on the lateral periphery of the outlined dorsal skin flaps. Interruption of this lateral blood supply was accomplished by two parallel 10-cm incisions in the surgical delay group. Likewise blood supply and microcirculatory alterations were accomplished in the laser delay groups by two parallel 10-cm laser treatments. On Day 7 a 10 x 4-cm cranially based dorsal skin flap was elevated. On Day 14 flap survival was analyzed by calculating percentage flap survival. The Erbium:YAG laser delay of the McFarlane flaps resulted in an average of 32 per cent less flap loss compared with controls (P = 0.0001). The CO2 laser resulted in an average of 36 per cent less flap loss compared with controls (P = 0.0002), whereas the surgical delay group had a 23 per cent smaller flap loss (P = 0.009). There was no significant difference between any of the delay groups. These results indicated that CO2 and Erbium:YAG lasers are as effective as surgery for delay of skin flaps in the rat model. They may provide an effective and inexpensive method for near-scarless skin flap delay in humans.     

Differences between cytotoxicity in photodynamic therapy using a pulsed laser and a continuous wave laser: study of oxygen consumption and photobleaching

Oxygen consumption at the targeted site has a significant effect on dosimetry in photodynamic therapy (PDT). However, oxygen consumption in PDT using a pulsed laser as a light source has not been clarified. We therefore investigated the dependence of cytotoxicity on the oxygen consumption and the photosensitizer photobleaching of PDT using a pulsed laser by comparing with that using a continuous wave (CW) laser. Mouse renal carcinoma cells (Renca) were incubated with a second-generation photosensitizer, PAD-S31. The cells were then irradiated with either a 670-nm nanosecond pulsed light from the 3rd harmonics of a Nd:YAG laser-pumped optical parametric oscillator with a peak fluence rate of ~1 MW/cm² at 30 Hz or a 670-nm CW diode laser with a total light dose of 40 J/cm². Regardless of laser source, cytotoxic effects exhibited cumulative dose responses to the photosensitizer ranging from 12 to 96 g/ml. However, cytotoxic effect of PDT using the pulsed light was significantly less than that using the CW light with the photosensitizer concentrations of 24 and 48 g/ml under identical fluence rates. During PDT, the cells exposed to the pulsed light consumed oxygen more slowly, resulting in a lower amount of oxygen consumption when compared with PDT using CW light. In accordance with oxygen consumption, the pulsed light induced significantly less photobleaching of the photosensitizer than the CW light did. These results indicate that the efficiency of PDT using pulsed light is less when compared with CW light, probably being related to suppressed oxygen consumption during the pulsed light irradiation.     

Stented laser-welded vasovasostomy in the rat: comparison of Nd:YAG and CO2 lasers.

In 54 male Sprague-Dawley rats, 108 vasovasostomies were performed. Sutureless laser welding with the assistance of a removable stent was done using a CO2- and an Nd:YAG-laser system. Conventional two-layer microsurgical anastomoses served as controls. The Nd:YAG laser resulted in significantly lower patency rates, with a higher percentage of sperm granulomas; the CO2 laser produced results equivalent to conventional suturing. Sutureless laser welding utilizing a removable stent proved to be a time- and cost-saving procedure for vasovasostomies in the rat.     

Induction of angiogenesis after TMR: a comparison of holmium: YAG, CO2, and excimer lasers

BACKGROUND: Transmyocardial laser revascularization (TMR) is an emerging treatment for end-stage coronary artery disease. A variety of lasers are currently available to perform the procedure, although their relative efficacy is unknown. The purpose of this study was to compare changes in myocardial blood flow and function 6 months after TMR with holmium:yttrium-aluminum-garnet (holmium:YAG), carbon dioxide (CO2), and xenon chloride excimer lasers in a model of chronic ischemia. METHODS: Miniswine underwent subtotal (90%) left circumflex coronary stenosis. Baseline positron emission tomography and dobutamine stress echocardiography were performed to document hibernating myocardium in the left circumflex coronary artery distribution. Animals were then randomized to sham redo-thoracotomy (n = 5) or TMR using a holmium:YAG (n = 5), CO2 (n = 5) or excimer (n = 5) laser. Six months postoperatively, the positron emission tomography and dobutamine stress echocardiography studies were repeated and the animals sacrificed. RESULTS: In animals undergoing TMR with holmium: YAG and CO2 lasers, a significant improvement in myocardial blood flow to the lased left circumflex regions was seen. No significant change in myocardial blood flow was seen in sham- or excimer-lased animals. There was a significant improvement in regional stress function of the lased segments 6 months postoperatively in animals undergoing holmium:YAG and CO2 laser TMR that was consistent with a reduction in ischemia. There was no change in wall motion in sham- or excimer-lased animals. Significantly greater neovascularization was observed in the holmium:YAG and CO2 lased regions than with either the sham procedure or excimer TMR. CONCLUSIONS: Transmyocardial laser revascularization with either holmium:YAG or CO2 laser improves myocardial blood flow and contractile reserve in lased regions 6 months postoperatively. These changes were not seen following excimer TMR or sham thoracotomy, suggesting that differences in laser energy or wavelength or both may be important in the induction of angiogenesis.     

Direct comparison of in-vitro and in-vivo Photofrin-II mediated photosensitization using a pulsed KTP pumped dye laser and a continuous wave argon ion pumped dye laser.

A pulsed KTP pumped dye laser (25 kHz repetition rate and 470 nsec pulse width) has been compared to a continuous wave argon ion pumped dye laser as the source of 630 nm light during in-vitro and in-vivo Photofrin-II mediated photosensitization studies. Individual experiments documented the effectiveness of each laser system on a) photosensitizer induced cytotoxicity and induction of stress protein synthesis using Chinese hamster fibroblasts; b) photobleaching of Photofrin-II in aqueous solution; c) Photofrin II mediated photosensitization of normal mouse skin; d) Photofrin II mediated photodynamic therapy of a mouse mammary carcinoma; and e) tumor temperature levels generated during laser exposure. Comparable results were obtained for both laser systems in all experiments.     

CO2 and Nd:YAG laser-assisted nerve repair: a study of bonding strength and thermal damage

To improve the laser welding procedure, a comparative study was undertaken to investigate the acute bonding strength and the thermal damage following CO2 and Nd:YAG laser-assisted nerve repair, performed with and without the use of blood and/or albumin as a solder. The strongest welds were produced with the CO2 laser using albumin as a solder. Thermal damage was minimal with the CO2 laser, whereas the damage with the Nd:YAG laser was substantial. The high bonding strength combined with minimal thermal damage of the nerve following repair with the CO2 laser with the use of albumin justify further investigations using this technique in in vivo studies.     

Laser-assisted microvascular anastomosis using CO2 and KTP/532 lasers.

The milliwatt carbon dioxide (CO2) laser has been shown to be an effective device for performing laser-assisted microvascular anastomosis (LAMA) with consistently high patency rates, minimal tissue disruption, and rapid surgical time as well as the potential for reduced inflammation due to fewer foreign bodies (sutures) in the wound. The purpose of this investigation was to determine the feasibility of using the potassium titanyl phosphate (KTP) laser to perform LAMA and to compare it to CO2 LAMA in both arteries and veins. Patency rates, inflammatory response, and course of healing were evaluated through histological analysis. Twenty-eight rats were divided into two groups, which underwent either CO2 or KTP LAMA and then were sacrificed at 3 days, and 1, 2, 4, 8, and 12 weeks postoperatively. Patency rates for arteries and veins were comparable for both wavelengths (CO2: 100% for arteries, 93% for veins; KTP: 93% for arteries, 93% for veins). Histological grading of inflammation and fibrosis showed no significant difference between the two groups. This study demonstrated the efficacy of using the KTP/532 laser in performing LAMA. We found the KTP and CO2 LAMA to have comparable patterns of tissue damage and course of healing. Although this experiment did not investigate the mechanism(s) of tissue welding, our results suggest that successful LAMA may be independent of wavelength.