Cell Therapeutics in Parkinson’s Disease

The main pathology underlying motor symptoms in Parkinson’s disease (PD) is a rather selective degeneration of nigrostriatal dopamine (DA) neurons. Intrastriatal transplantation of immature DA neurons, which replace those neurons that have died, leads to functional restoration in animal models of PD. Here we describe how far the clinical translation of the DA neuron replacement strategy has advanced. We briefly summarize the lessons learned from the early clinical trials with grafts of human fetal mesencephalic tissue, and discuss recent findings suggesting susceptibility of these grafts to the disease process long-term after implantation. Mechanisms underlying graft-induced dyskinesias, which constitute the only significant adverse event observed after neural transplantation, and how they should be prevented and treated are described. We summarize the attempts to generate DA neurons from stem cells of various sources and patient-specific DA neurons from fully differentiated somatic cells, with particular emphasis on the requirements of these cells to be useful in the clinical setting. The rationale for the new clinical trial with transplantation of fetal mesencephalic tissue is described. Finally, we discuss the scientific and clinical advancements that will be necessary to develop a competitive cell therapy for PD patients.     

Neuromodulation for Parkinson's disease]

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a neurodegenerative disorder characterized by a progressive loss of midbrain dopaminergic (DA) neurons and a subsequent reduction in striatal dopamine. As a treatment for advanced Parkinson's disease, deep brain stimulation (DBS) of the thalamus was introduced in 1987 to treat tremor, and was applied in 1993 to the subthalamic nucleus. Now high-frequency stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus has become a surgical therapy of choice. Another surgical treatment is a cell replacement therapy. Transplantation of fetal dopaminergic (DA) neurons can produce symptomatic relief, however, the technical and ethical difficulties in obtaining sufficient and appropriate donor fetal brain tissue have limited the application of this therapy. Then, neural precursor cells and embryonic stem (ES) cells are expected to be candidates of potential donor cells for transplantation. We induced DA neurons from monkey ES cells, and analyzed the effect of transplantation of the DA neurons into MPTP-treated monkeys as a primate model of Parkinson's disease. Behavioral studies and functional imaging revealed that the transplanted cells functioned as DA neurons, attenuating the MPTP-induced neurological symptoms. DA neurons have also been generated from several human ES cell lines. Furthermore, functional recovery of rat PD models after transplantation was observed. One of the major problems in ES cell transplantation is tumor formation, which is caused by a small fraction of undifferentiated ES cells in the graft. So, it is essential for undifferentiated ES cells to be eliminated from the graft in order for transplantation to be feasible. These efforts will lead to clinical application of ES cell transplantation to the patients with PD.     

Current advances in the treatment of Parkinson's disease with stem cells

Stem cell replacement has emerged as the novel therapeutic strategy for Parkinson's disease (PD). Control of motor behavior is lost in PD due to the selective degeneration of mesencephalic dopamine neurons (DA) in the substantia nigra. This progressive loss of DA neurons results in devastating symptoms for which there is no cure. Debilitating side effects often result from chronic pharmacological treatment, hence current investigations into cell transplantation therapy as a substitute and/or adjuvant to other therapeutics. Clinical trials with fetal DA tissue have provided evidence that cell transplantation could be a viable alternative. Limited availability of fetal tissue, combined with variable outcome led to emphasis on other sources of cells, such as stem cells. This review focuses on three stem cell sources (embryonic, neural, and adult mesenchymal). Also discussed is the molecular differentiation into mature DA neurons, the various protocols that have been developed to generate DA neurons from various stem cells, and the current state of stem cell therapy for PD.     

Developing dopaminergic cell therapy for Parkinson's disease—give up or move forward?

Despite 3 decades of basic and clinical studies, there is still no dopaminergic cell therapy for Parkinson's disease. Several arguments have been put forward why this approach, so far tested with transplantation of human fetal mesencephalic dopamine‐rich tissue, will never be of clinical use and should be abandoned: (1) Lack of efficacy in 2 sham surgery‐controlled trials; (2) occurrence of troublesome off‐medication dyskinesias in a subgroup of grafted patients; (3) disease process destroys grafted neurons; and (4) non‐motor symptoms will not be influenced by intrastriatal dopaminergic grafts. Here, the author argues that, based on recent scientific advancements, the development of a dopaminergic cell therapy for Parkinson's disease should continue. Factors influencing the outcome after transplantation have now been identified, and dopaminergic neurons can be generated in large numbers from stem cells. Mechanisms of graft‐induced dyskinesias are much better understood, and patients with well functioning grafts can exhibit long‐term motor recovery of therapeutic value even in the presence of non‐motor symptoms. © 2013 Movement Disorder Society     

Embryonic mesencephalic grafts increase levodopa-induced forelimb hyperkinesia in parkinsonian rats.

Recent observations from clinical trials of neural grafting for Parkinson's disease (PD) have demonstrated that grafted dopamine neurons can worsen dyskinesias in some graft recipients. This deleterious side effect reveals a new challenge for neural transplantation, that of elucidating mechanisms underlying these postgraft dyskinesias. One problem facing this challenge is the availability of a cost-effective and reliable animal model in which to pursue initial investigations. In the current study, we investigated the interaction of an embryonic ventral mesencephalic (VM) dopamine (DA) neuron graft on levodopa (LD)-induced dyskinetic movements in unilaterally 6-hydroxydopamine-lesioned rats. Rats were administered LD (levodopa-carbidopa, 50:5 mg/kg) twice daily for 6 weeks after either a sham graft or VM DA graft. Although a single solid graft of embryonic DA neurons can prevent progression of some lesioned-induced behavioral abnormalities such as LD-induced rotation and dystonia, it significantly increases hyperkinetic movements of the contralateral forelimb. This differential effect of grafted neurons on abnormal behavioral profiles is reminiscent of that reported in grafted patients with PD. Data from this study illustrate important similarities between this model of parkinsonism and PD in human patients that make it suitable for initial preclinical investigations into possible mechanisms underlying postgraft aggravation of dyskinetic movements.     

Cell implantation therapies for Parkinson's disease using neural stem, transgenic or xenogeneic donor cells

A new therapeutic neurological and neurosurgical methodology involves cell implantation into the living brain in order to replace intrinsic neuronal systems, that do not spontaneously regenerate after injury, such as the dopaminergic (DA) system affected in Parkinson's disease (PD) and aging. Current clinical data indicate proof of principle for this cell implantation therapy for PD. Furthermore, the disease process does not appear to negatively affect the transplanted cells, although the patient's endogenous DA system degeneration continues. However, the optimal cells for replacement, such as highly specialized human fetal dopaminergic cells capable of repairing an entire degenerated nigro-striatal system, cannot be reliably obtained or generated in sufficient numbers for a standardized medically effective intervention. Xenogeneic and transgenic cell sources of analogous DA cells have shown great utility in animal models and some promise in early pilot studies in PD patients. The cell implantation treatment discipline, using cell fate committed fetal allo- or xenogeneic dopamine neurons and glia, is currently complemented by research on potential stem cell derived DA neurons. Understanding the cell biological principles and developing methodology necessary to generate functional DA progenitors is currently our focus for obtaining DA cells in sufficient quantities for the unmet cell transplantation need for patients with PD and related disorders.     

Toward full restoration of synaptic and terminal function of the dopaminergic system in Parkinson's disease by stem cells

New therapeutic nonpharmacological methodology in Parkinson's disease (PD) involves cell and synaptic renewal or replacement to restore function of neuronal systems, including the dopaminergic (DA) system. Using fetal DA cell therapy in PD patients and laboratory models, it has been demonstrated that functional motor deficits associated with parkinsonism can be reduced. Similar results have been observed in animal models with stem cell-derived DA neurons. Evidence obtained from transplanted PD patients further shows that the underlying disease process does not destroy transplanted fetal DA cells, although degeneration of the host nigrostriatal system continues. The optimal DA cell regeneration system would reconstitute a normal neuronal network capable of restoring feedback-controlled release of DA in the nigrostriatal system. The success of cell therapy for PD is limited by access to preparation and development of highly specialized dopaminergic neurons found in the A9 and A10 region of the substantia nigra pars compacta as well as the technical and surgical steps associated with the transplantation procedure. Recent laboratory work has focused on using stem cells as a starting point for deriving the optimal DA cells to restore the nigrostriatal system. Ultimately, understanding the cell biological principles necessary for generating functional DA neurons can provide many new avenues for better treatment of patients with PD.     

Non-dopaminergic neurons in ventral mesencephalic transplants make widespread axonal connections in the host brain

Motor dysfunction in Parkinson's disease (PD) can be effectively alleviated through intra-striatal transplantation of fetal ventral mesencephalic tissue. The success of this approach is dependent on the survival, axonal outgrowth and synaptic integration of newly grafted dopamine neurons with the host striatum. The functional outcome of transplantation therapy has, however, been highly variable, particularly in PD patients, but also in animal models of PD, and thus there is a need for a deeper understanding of possible mechanisms underlying this variability such as graft composition and the resulting graft–host connectivity. Here we describe a series of transplantation experiments whereby mouse VM tissue has been grafted into the striatum of 6-hydroxydopamine lesioned rats. Six weeks after grafting immunohistochemical analysis using the mouse specific ‘M2M6’ antibodies revealed both dopaminergic and non-dopaminergic components of graft-derived fibre outgrowth into the host brain. We report here that while dopaminergic outgrowth was predominately confined to the striatum, there was also a significant degree of non-dopaminergic outgrowth to extra-striatal structures including the thalamus, cortex and midbrain. Retrograde tracing experiments showed that grafted neurons of GABAergic identity contribute to this non-dopaminergic outgrowth. In line with our recent findings on the function of serotonergic neurons in fetal VM grafts, these results further underscore the potential impact that non-dopaminergic neurons may have on the functional outcome of intrastriatal fetal VM grafts.     

Zuckerkandl's organ improves long-term survival and function of neural stem cell derived dopaminergic neurons in Parkinsonian rats

Transplantation of neural stem cells (NSC) derived dopamine (DA) neurons has emerged as an alternative approach to fetal neural cell transplantation in Parkinson's disease (PD). However, similar to fetal neural cell, survival of these neurons following transplantation is also limited due to limited striatal reinnervation (graft with dense neuronal core), limited host-graft interaction, poor axonal outgrowth, lack of continuous neurotrophic factors supply and principally an absence of cell adhesion molecules mediated appropriate developmental cues. In the present study, an attempt has been made to increase survival and function of NSC derived DA neurons, by co-grafting with Zuckerkandl's organ (a paraneural organ that expresses neurotrophic factors as well as cell adhesion molecules); to provide continuous NTF support and developmental cues to transplanted DA neurons in the rat model of PD. 24 weeks post transplantation, a significant number of surviving functional NSC derived DA neurons were observed in the co-transplanted group as evident by an increase in the number of tyrosine hydroxylase immunoreactive (TH-IR) neurons, TH-IR fiber density, TH-mRNA expression and TH-protein level at the transplantation site (striatum). Significant behavioral recovery (amphetamine induced stereotypy and locomotor activity) and neurochemical recovery (DA-D2 receptor binding and DA and DOPAC levels at the transplant site) were also observed in the NSC+ZKO co-transplanted group as compared to the NSC or ZKO alone transplanted group. In vivo results were further substantiated by in vitro studies, which suggest that ZKO increases the NSC derived DA neuronal survival, differentiation, DA release and neurite outgrowth as well as protects against 6-OHDA toxicity in co-culture condition. The present study suggests that long-term and continuous NTF support provided by ZKO to the transplanted NSC derived DA neurons, helped in their better survival, axonal arborization and integration with host cells, leading to long-term functional restoration in the rat model of PD.     

Development of stem cell-based therapies for Parkinson's disease

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a common neurodegenerative disorder characterized by the progressive loss of dopaminergic neurons of the substantia nigra pars compacta in the brain with an unknown cause. Current pharmacological treatments for PD are only symptomatic and there is still no cure for this disease nowadays. In fact, transplantation of human fetal ventral midbrain cells into PD brains has provided a proof of concept that cell replacement therapy can be used for some PD patients, beneficial for improving their symptoms. However, the ethical and practical issues of human fetal tissue will inevitably limit its widespread clinical use. Therefore, it is essential to find alternative cell sources for the future cell transplantation for PD patients. With recent development in stem cell technology, here, we review the different types of stem cells and their main properties currently explored, which could be developed as a possible cell therapy for PD treatment.     

Emerging restorative treatments for Parkinson's disease: manipulation and inducement of dopaminergic neurons from adult stem cells

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a common neurodegenerative disease, characterized by a selective loss of midbrain Dopaminergic (DA) neurons. To address this problem, various types of stem cells that have potential to differentiate into DA neurons are being investigated as cellular therapies for PD, including cells derived from embryonic or adult donor tissue, and embryonic stem cells. These cell sources, however, have raised certain questions with regard to ethical and rejection issues. Recent progress in adult stems has further proved that the cells derived from adult tissue could be expanded and differentiated into DA precursor cells in vitro, and cell therapy with adult stem cells could produce a clear improvement for PD models. Using adult stem cells for clinic application may not only overcome the ethical problem inherent in using human fetal tissue or embryonic stem cells, but also open the possibility for autologous transplantation. The patient-specific adult stem cell is therefore a potential and prospective candidate for PD treatment.     

Birth dating of midbrain dopamine neurons identifies A9 enriched tissue for transplantation into parkinsonian mice

Clinical trials have provided proof of principle that new dopamine neurons isolated from the developing ventral midbrain and transplanted into the denervated striatum can functionally integrate and alleviate symptoms in Parkinson's disease patients. However, extensive variability across patients has been observed, ranging from long-term motor improvement to the absence of symptomatic relief and development of dyskinesias. Heterogeneity of the donor tissue is likely to be a contributing factor in the variable outcomes. Dissections of ventral midbrain used for transplantation will variously contain progenitors for different dopamine neuron subtypes as well as different neurotransmitter phenotypes. The overall impact of the resulting graft will be determined by the functional contribution from these different cell types. The A9 substantia nigra pars compacta dopamine neurons, for example, are known to be particularly important for motor recovery in animal models. Serotonergic neurons, on the other hand, have been implicated in unwanted dyskinesias. Currently little knowledge exists on how variables such as donor age, which have not been controlled for in clinical trials, will impact on the final neuronal composition of fetal grafts. Here we performed a birth dating study to identify the time-course of neurogenesis within the various ventral midbrain dopamine subpopulations in an effort to identify A9-enriched donor tissue for transplantation. The results show that A9 neurons precede the birth of A10 ventral tegmental area dopamine neurons. Subsequent grafting of younger ventral midbrain donor tissue revealed significantly larger grafts containing more mitotic dopamine neuroblasts compared to older donor grafts. These grafts were enriched with A9 neurons and showed significantly greater innervation of the target dorso-lateral striatum and DA release. Younger donor grafts also contained significantly less serotonergic neurons. These findings demonstrate the importance of standardized methods to improve cell therapy for Parkinson's disease and have significant implications for the generation and selectivity of dopamine neurons from stem cell based sources.     

Graft‐induced dyskinesias in Parkinson's disease: High striatal serotonin/dopamine transporter ratio

Graft‐induced dyskinesias are a serious complication after neural transplantation in Parkinson's disease. One patient with Parkinson's disease, treated with fetal grafts 14 years ago and deep brain stimulation 6 years ago, showed marked improvement of motor symptoms but continued to suffer from OFF‐medication graft‐induced dyskinesias. The patient received a series of clinical and imaging assessments. Positron emission tomography and single‐photon emission computed tomography 14 years posttransplantation revealed an elevated serotonin/dopamine transporter ratio in the grafted striatum compatible with serotonergic hyperinnervation. Inhibition of serotonin neuron activity by systemic administration of a 5‐HT_1A agonist suppressed graft‐induced dyskinesias. Our data provide further evidence that serotonergic neurons mediate graft‐induced dyskinesias in Parkinson's disease. Achieving a normal striatal serotonin/dopamine transporter ratio following transplantation of fetal tissue or stem cells should be necessary to avoid the development of graft‐induced dyskinesias. © 2011 Movement Disorder Society     

Target‐specific forebrain projections and appropriate synaptic inputs of hESC‐derived dopamine neurons grafted to the midbrain of parkinsonian rats

Dopamine (DA) neurons derived from human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) are a promising unlimited source of cells for cell replacement therapy in Parkinson's disease (PD). A number of studies have demonstrated functionality of DA neurons originating from hESCs when grafted to the striatum of rodent and non‐human primate models of PD. However, several questions remain in regard to their axonal outgrowth potential and capacity to integrate into host circuitry. Here, ventral midbrain (VM) patterned hESC‐derived progenitors were grafted into the midbrain of 6‐hydroxydopamine‐lesioned rats, and analyzed at 6, 18, and 24 weeks for a time‐course evaluation of specificity and extent of graft‐derived fiber outgrowth as well as potential for functional recovery. To investigate synaptic integration of the transplanted cells, we used rabies‐based monosynaptic tracing to reveal the origin and extent of host presynaptic inputs to grafts at 6 weeks. The results reveal the capacity of grafted neurons to extend axonal projections toward appropriate forebrain target structures progressively over 24 weeks. The timing and extent of graft‐derived dopaminergic fibers innervating the dorsolateral striatum matched reduction in amphetamine‐induced rotational asymmetry in the animals where recovery could be observed. Monosynaptic tracing demonstrated that grafted cells integrate with host circuitry 6 weeks after transplantation, in a manner that is comparable with endogenous midbrain connectivity. Thus, we demonstrate that VM patterned hESC‐derived progenitors grafted to midbrain have the capacity to extensively innervate appropriate forebrain targets, integrate into the host circuitry and that functional recovery can be achieved when grafting fetal or hESC‐derived DA neurons to the midbrain.     

Idiopathic Parkinson's disease patient‐derived induced pluripotent stem cells function as midbrain dopaminergic neurons in rodent brains

Patient‐specific induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) are a promising source for cell transplantation therapy. In Parkinson's disease (PD) patients, however, their vulnerability and the transmission of pathological α‐Synuclein are possible drawbacks that may prevent PD‐specific iPSCs (PDiPSCs) from being used in clinical settings. In this study, we generated iPSCs from idiopathic PD patients and found that there was no significant vulnerability between dopaminergic (DA) neurons generated from healthy individuals and idiopathic PD patients. PDiPSC‐derived DA neurons survived and functioned in the brains of PD model rats. In addition, in the brains of α‐Synuclein transgenic mice, PDiPSC‐derived DA neurons did not cause pathological α‐Synuclein accumulation in the host brain or in the grafts. These results suggested that iPSCs derived from idiopathic PD patients are feasible as donor cells for autologous transplantation to treat PD. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Stem cells may reshape the prospect of Parkinson's disease therapy

The concept of cell replacement to compensate for cell loss and restore functionality has entered several disease entities including neurodegenerative disorders. Recent clinical studies have shown that transplantation of fetal dopaminergic (DA) cells into the brain of Parkinson's disease (PD) patients can reduce disease-associated motor deficits. However, the use of fetal tissue is associated with practical and ethical problems including low efficiency, variability in the clinical outcome and controversy regarding the use of fetuses as donor. An alternative cell resource could be embryonic stem (ES) cells, which can be cultivated in unlimited amounts and which have the potential to differentiate into mature DA cells. Several differentiation protocols have been developed, and some progress has been made in understanding the mechanisms underlying DA specification in ES cell development, but the "holy grail" in this paradigm, which is the production of sufficient amounts of the "right" therapeutic DA cell, has not yet been accomplished. To achieve this goal, several criteria on the transplanted DA cells need to be fulfilled, mainly addressing cell survival, accurate integration in the brain circuitry, normal function, no tumor formation, and no immunogenicity. Here, we summarize the current state of ES cell-derived DA neurogenesis and discuss the aspects involved in generating an optimal cell source for cell replacement in PD.     

A role for tumor necrosis factor alpha in death of dopaminergic neurons following neural transplantation

Poor survival of transplanted dopaminergic (DA) neurons remains a serious obstacle to the success of cell replacement therapy as an alternative to the current treatments for Parkinson's disease (PD). We have examined the temporal release profile of an inflammatory cytokine, tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNFalpha), following transplantation of fetal mesencephalic tissue into the rat striatum. The amounts of TNFalpha released in vivo when added to cultures of embryonic DA neurons, significantly reduced the survival of DA neurons in vitro, and this cell death could be prevented by the inclusion of an antibody to the TNFalpha receptor type 1. Inclusion of this antibody in cell suspensions during transplantation also increased the survival of transplanted fetal DA neurons by approximately 250%. Use of this therapeutic antibody approach may offer significant improvements to neural transplantation as a treatment for PD.     

Developmental perspectives on human midbrain-derived neural stem cells

Regeneration or restoration of lost or damaged neurons is very likely to profoundly alter the disability and needs of many patients. The replacement of dopaminergic (DA) neurons in patients with Parkinson's disease via implantation of embryonic midbrain tissue was taken from animal experiments to clinical applications. Ethical concerns related to the use of fetal tissue derived from abortions further argue for the search for alternative tissue sources. Today, it seems possible to generate functional DA neurons from a variety of stem cells, including embryonic and neural stem cells. Bone marrow stromal cells are another source for cell replacement. Neural stem cells derived from human fetal midbrain tissue maintain a considerable capacity to self-renew and to differentiate into DA neurons. Therefore, these cells may be a promising source to generate functional human DA neurons.     

Stem cell therapy for Parkinson's disease

Transplantation of human fetal dopamine (DA) neurons to patients with Parkinson's disease (PD) has given proof of the principle that new neurons can survive for at least a decade, and then functionally integrate and provide significant symptomatic relief. Unfortunately, the ethical, technical, and practical limitations of using fetal DA neurons as the source for cell transplantation in PD, in combination with the development of unwanted grafting-related side effects, have put a halt to the spread of this treatment into clinical practice. Hopefully, recent advances in the fields of stem cell biology and adult neurogenesis research will lead totamen in new exciting ways to better understand and control the biological parameters necessary for achieving safe and successful neuronal replacement in PD patients.     

Intranigral transplants of GABA-rich striatal tissue induce behavioral recovery in the rat Parkinson model and promote the effects obtained by intrastriatal dopaminergic transplants

Intrastriatal transplantation of fetal ventral mesencephalon (VM) is currently explored as a potential clinical therapy in Parkinson's disease (PD). Although providing substantial benefit for the patient, behavioral recovery so far obtained with intrastriatal VM grafts is not complete. Using the 6-hydroxydopamine lesion model of PD, we show here that near-complete restoration of the striatal dopamine (DA) innervation can be achieved by multiple intrastriatal microtransplants of fetal DA cells; nevertheless, complete recovery in complex sensorimotor behaviors was not obtained in these animals. In line with the current model of basal ganglia function, this suggests that the lesion-induced overactivity of the basal ganglia output structures, i.e., the substantia nigra (SN) and the entopeduncular nucleus, may not be completely reversed by intrastriatal VM grafts. In the present study, we have transplanted fetal VM tissue or fetal striatal tissue, as a source of DA and GABA neurons, respectively, into the SN of DA-depleted rats. Intranigral VM grafts induced behavioral recovery in some sensorimotor behaviors (forelimb akinesia and balance tests), but the effect did not exceed the recovery observed after intrastriatal VM grafts. Intranigral grafts of striatal tissue induced a pattern of functional recovery which was distinctly different from that observed after intranigral VM grafts, and recovery in coordinated forelimb use in the paw-reaching test was even more pronounced than after intrastriatal transplantation of VM cells. Combined transplantation of DA neurons into the striatum and GABA-rich striatal neurons into the SN induced additive effects of behavioral recovery observed in the forelimb akinesia test. We propose that intranigral striatal transplants, by a GABA-mediated inhibitory action, can reduce the overactivity of the host SN projection neurons and can induce significant recovery in complex motor behavior in the rat PD model and that such grafts may be used to increase the overall functional efficacy of intrastriatal VM grafts.