Comparison of the nuclear matrix protein 22 with voided urine cytology in the diagnosis of transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder

Several urinary markers for transitional cell carcinoma have been investigated, including urine cytology, bladder tumor antigen, autocrine motility factor receptor and fibrin degradation products. Unfortunately, they have poor overall sensitivity. The United States Food and Drug Administration have recently approved nuclear matrix protein (NMP 22) for the detection of occult or rapidly recurring disease after transurethral resection of bladder tumor. The objective of the current study was to assess the sensitivity of NMP 22 for the detection of bladder carcinoma, as well as to correlate the NMP 22 values with multiplicity of tumor, tumor size, configuration, stage and grade respectively. A total of 78 patients (38 with bladder cancer) provided a urine sample which was divided into appropriate aliquots for each of urine cytology and NMP 22. Comparative results demonstrate a clear superiority of NMP 22 in bladder cancer detection (52.6% vs 31.6% sensitivity), while specificity was in favor of urine cytology (100% vs 82.5%). For superficial tumors, sensitivity was 78.5% for NMP 22 and 41.6% for cytology and for invasive cancers, sensitivity was 90% for NMP 22 and 60% for cytology. Urinary NMP 22 levels were significantly correlated with tumor grade and were significantly higher in large tumors than small tumors. NMP 22 test results showed sufficient sensitivity in comparison with urine cytology for the detection of transitional cell carcinoma. However, we do not think that it is a useful tool as a substitute for endoscopic examination for the detection and surveillance in bladder cancer.     

核基质蛋白22检测与尿脱落细胞学检查在膀胱癌诊断中的价值

目的　探讨尿核基质蛋白 2 2 (NMP 2 2 )检测和尿脱落细胞学检查在膀胱移行细胞癌诊断中的价值。　方法　对 15 5例怀疑膀胱癌者进行尿NMP 2 2与尿细胞学检查 ,其中 95例经组织学证实为膀胱移行细胞癌。比较两者诊断膀胱癌的敏感性和特异性。　结果　尿NMP 2 2的敏感性为6 5 .3%、特异性为 70 .0 % ;尿细胞学的敏感性为 4 3.2 %、特异性为 83.3%。NMP 2 2在膀胱癌不同分级和分期中的敏感性优于尿细胞学 (P <0 .0 5 )。　结论　尿NMP 2 2检测在早期诊断膀胱癌方面优于尿细胞学检查 ,可以作为膀胱癌的早期检测指标。     

核基质蛋白22在膀胱移行上皮癌诊断中的价值(附48例报告)

目的:评价患者尿中核基质蛋白22(NMP 22)在泌尿系上皮肿瘤诊断中的意义。方法:采用ELISA法测定48例膀胱移行上皮肿瘤患者尿中NMP 22的值,并与尿脱落细胞学检查进行比较。结果:48例膀胱移行上皮肿瘤患者尿NMP 22的中位值为19.53 IU/L。以10 IU/L为临界值,NMP 22诊断膀胱移行上皮肿瘤的敏感性为86.96％,特异性为50％;尿脱落细胞学检查的敏感性为17.39％,特异性为100％。尿NMP 22在肿瘤的分期、分级间的差别无显著性意义(P>0.05)。结论:尿NMP 22检测比尿脱落细胞学检查更敏感,可以作为血尿患者和既往膀胱肿瘤患者的首选筛选方法。     

Risk stratification for bladder tumor recurrence, stage and grade by urinary nuclear matrix protein 22 and cytology

PURPOSE: To test the hypothesis that voided urinary levels of nuclear matrix protein 22 (NMP22) would add to the predictive ability of urine cytology in the diagnosis, staging and grading of bladder transitional cell carcinoma (TCC), and to evaluate the diagnostic performance of different NMP22 cut-points. MATERIALS: NMP22 level and barbotage cytology were evaluated in voided urine specimens collected before cystoscopy from 302 subjects with a history of TCC, 32 subjects with benign urologic pathologies, and 10 healthy volunteers. RESULTS: 180 patients (52%) had bladder TCC. Higher levels of NMP22 and positive cytology were independently associated with an increased risk of TCC, invasive stage, and high grade. The NMP22 value with equal sensitivity and specificity for prediction of bladder cancer was 6.5U/ml; for prediction of grade 3 TCC it was 13.5U/ml; and for prediction of invasive tumor stage it was 17.4U/ml. The NMP22 cut-point of 6.5U/ml outperformed the 10U/ml cut-point in all pathologic stages and grades. The diagnostic sensitivity of the cytology and NMP22 combined was superior across all pathologic stages and grades to that of either marker alone. NMP22 and cytology stratified patients into groups with significantly different risk for TCC presence, invasive stage, and high grade. CONCLUSIONS: 6.5U/ml is a robust NMP22 cut-point for bladder cancer surveillance. The diagnostic sensitivities of the combined NMP22 and cytology for TCC presence, stage, and grade were significantly higher than those of single marker alone. The combination of urine cytology and NMP22 could be used to tailor the frequency of cystoscopic follow up.     

BTA quantitative assay and NMP22 testing compared with urine cytology in the detection of transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder

PURPOSE: Both BTA TRAK and NMP22 urine concentrations have shown a sensitivity superior to urine cytology in the detection of bladder cancer. We compared these tumor markers with urine cytology performed on 3 consecutive samples and evaluated by an expert cytopathologist. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The investigations were conducted on 94 patients undergoing a diagnostic cystoscopy for a high suspicion of bladder cancer (group 1) and on 102 patients with previous history of transitional cell carcinoma awaiting a follow-up cystoscopy (group 2). Biopsy specimens were obtained also from tumor negative patients. Immunoassays for BTA TRAK and NMP22 were carried out according to standard methods. The choice of the cut-off was based on the ground of sensitivity and specificity curves intersection. Urine cytology results were expressed as positive, negative and 'dubious'. RESULTS: Overall sensitivity was 56% for NMP22 (cut-off 11 U/ml) and 57% for BTA TRAK (cut-off 60 U/ml). When dubious results were considered as positive cases, urine cytology achieved a sensitivity of 73.3%. Assuming dubious cases as negative results, urine cytology sensitivity resulted 59.3%. When the 2 groups of patients were evaluated separately with different cut-off, there was no significant gain in sensitivity for BTA TRAK and NMP22 over urine cytology. CONCLUSIONS: Urine cytology performed on 3 samples showed the highest sensitivity and specificity. The diagnostic advantage of urine cytology over BTA TRAK and NMP22 was maintained when patients were stratified by tumor grade.     

影响尿核基质蛋白诊断膀胱癌的干扰因素

目的：探讨尿核基质蛋白(NMP22)在膀胱癌诊断中的特异性和阳性预测值价值。方法：对196例临床怀疑膀胱癌的患者，在膀胱镜检查前留取新鲜自排尿．每个尿标本均行尿细胞学、尿常规、尿培养和NMP22检测。所有患者均行膀胱镜检查。结果：196例中，病理检查证实膀胱癌41例，其他疾病155例。41例膀胱癌患者中，检测出NMP22 33例(80．5%)，而尿细胞学检测阳性仅为11例(26．8％)。在67例NMP22异常者中，除33例诊断为膀胱癌外，假阳性为34例，故特异性和阳性预测值分别为78．1％和49．3％。假阳性结果主要出现在泌尿系感染或炎症、泌尿系结石、泌尿系异物、肠道代膀胱、其他泌尿生殖系肿瘤和器械操作6种情况．排除这6种干扰因素后，NMP22检测的特异性和阳性预测值分别升高至96．2％和91．7％。结论：排除干扰因素能明显改善NMP22诊断膀胱癌的特异性和阳性预测值，提高其临床应用价值。     

A comparison of urinary nuclear matrix protein-22 and bladder tumour antigen tests with voided urinary cytology in detecting and following bladder cancer: the prognostic value of false-positive results

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the diagnostic and prognostic value of the nuclear matrix protein-22 (NMP22) and bladder tumour antigen (BTAstat) tests compared with voided urinary cytology (VUC) in detecting and following bladder cancer, assessing particularly the prognostic value of false-positive test results in patients followed up for bladder cancer. PATIENTS AND METHODS: From 739 patients suspected of having bladder cancer, voided urine samples for the NMP22 and BTAstat tests, and for VUC and urine analysis, were collected before cystoscopy. All patients underwent transurethral resection of bladder lesions or mapping. and were followed for a mean (range) of 27.3 (3-65) months. RESULTS: In the 406 patients with bladder cancer, the overall sensitivity was 85% for NMP22, 70% for BTAstat and 62% for VUC. For histological grades 1-3 the sensitivity in detecting transitional cell carcinoma was 82%, 89% and 94% for NMP22, 53%, 76% and 90% for BTAstat, and 38%, 68% and 90% for VUC, respectively. Although the sensitivity in detecting invasive carcinoma was >85% for all the tests. NMP22 and BTAstat were statistically more sensitive than VUC for superficial tumours. The optimal threshold value for NMP22, calculated using the receiver operating characteristics curve was 8.25 U/mL. The specificity was 68% for NMP22, 67% for BTAstat, and 96% for VUC. The specificity of VUC remained >87% and was independent of benign histological findings. In contrast, in patients with no apparent genitourinary disease on histology, NMP22 and BTAstat had significantly higher specificity (94% and 92%, respectively: P=0.003) than in the group with chronic cystitis (52% for both tests). Forty patients having no bladder cancer at biopsy had a recurrence after a mean (range) follow-up of 7.7 (3-15) months: all had a previous history of bladder cancer. According to subsequent recurrence, the prognostic positive and negative predictive values were 18% and 91% for NMP22, 13% and 88% for BTAstat, and 79% and 91% for VUC. Both false-positive VUC and NMP22 tests predicted recurrence (log-rank test, P<0.001 and P=0.004, respectively), but the BTAstat test produced no similar correlation (P=0.778). CONCLUSION: The NMP22 and BTAstat tests are better than VUC for detecting superficial and low-grade bladder cancer but they have significantly lower specificity. After excluding diseases with the potential to interfere in these tests the overall specificity of both tests is increased considerably. False-positive results from NMP22 and VUC but not from BTAstat in patients followed up for bladder cancer correlate with future recurrences.     

Four bladder tumor markers have a disappointingly low sensitivity for small size and low grade recurrence.

PURPOSE: We determine the sensitivity and specificity of 3 bladder tumor markers in urine, including NMP22 assay (Matritech, Newton, Massachusetts), BTA stat test (Bion Diagnostic Sciences, Inc., Redmond, Washington) and UBC antigen (IDL Biotech, Sollentuna, Sweden), and bladder wash cytology for new and recurrent bladder cancer. We examine whether tumor size, grade, and stage influence sensitivity and specificity of the markers. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 304 samples in 250 patients were studied. There were 174 patients who had a history of bladder cancer, including 93 with and 81 without recurrent tumor at cystoscopy. The other group of patients consisted of 66 with newly diagnosed bladder tumor and 64 investigated for microscopic hematuria that was found to be idiopathic. BTA stat was assayed according to manufacturer instructions. NMP22 and UBC were measured in urine with an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. A cutoff level of 4 for NMP22 and 1 for UBC was chosen to get the same specificity for new tumors as BTA stat (75%) RESULTS: There was a highly significant difference (p <0.001) in all markers between patients with new bladder tumors and those without. The difference was less pronounced for tumor recurrence for NMP22, UBC and BTA stat (p=0.002, 0.016 and 0.244, respectively). The difference between new and recurrent tumors disappeared when corrected for tumor size, grade and stage. The sensitivity for new tumors was 65%, 75% and 60% for NMP22, BTA stat and UBC, respectively. Cytology had a sensitivity of 41% for new tumors at a specificity of 94%. The specificity for recurrence was 64% for NMP22, 54% BTA stat and 72% UBC. The sensitivity was 45% for NMP22, 55% BTA stat and 40% UBC. CONCLUSIONS: Tumor size, grade and stage have a strong impact on sensitivity, and specificity for all 3 tested tumor markers as well as bladder wash cytology. The tumor markers or any combination of them cannot replace followup cystoscopy, mainly because most recurrences are small. The role of the markers for screening high risk populations and as a complement to followup cystoscopy remains to be evaluated.     

NMP22 is a sensitive, cost-effective test in patients at risk for bladder cancer

PURPOSE: The early diagnosis of bladder cancer is central to its effective treatment. This study was designed to determine the clinical use of NMP22 as a urinary marker for the early detection of transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder in patients with hematuria or other indications at risk for malignancy. The sensitivity and specificity of the NMP22 test were compared with urinary cytology, and the results of both tests were then compared to cystoscopic findings. We also determined if NMP22 provided a cost advantage over our current modalities in our patient population. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Each patient submitted a single voided urine which was divided in 2 parts, of which 1 was stabilized with the NMP22 urine collection kit and 1 was preserved in the appropriate cytology medium for cytopathological testing. All patients provided the urine samples before cystoscopic examination. Of the 330 patients 114 (34.5%) presented with microscopic hematuria and 66 (20.4%) with gross hematuria. Other indications for cystoscopy included atypical cytology or unexplained voiding symptoms refractory to medical therapy. RESULTS: There were 18 patients with biopsy confirmed bladder cancer and 312 with benign conditions of the bladder. Median NMP22 value for the malignant bladder tumors was 31.6 units per ml. (95% confidence interval 13.4 to 90.9) and 4.3 units per ml. (3.8 to 4.8) for benign conditions of the bladder. The urinary NMP22 values in the bladder cancer group were significantly higher than those in the benign condition group (p <0.001). The sensitivity of NMP22 was 100% with a specificity of 85% at a reference value of 10.0 units per ml., while cytology had a sensitivity of only 33% and specificity of 100%. Given a negative predictive value of 100% for NMP22, a cost savings of $28,302 to $111,072 (depending on the type of insurance carrier) would have been achieved if it was used alone as the indication for cystoscopy. CONCLUSIONS: This study indicates that urinary NMP22 is a simple, noninvasive, cost-effective marker for the detection of bladder cancer.     

CAN URINE BOUND DIAGNOSTIC TESTS REPLACE CYSTOSCOPY IN THE MANAGEMENT OF BLADDER CANCER?

Purpose

We compare the diagnostic value of NMP22 [dagger] and BTA stat [double dagger] testing, and QUANTICYT [section] computer assisted dual parameter image analysis to cytology and cystoscopy in patients who had symptoms suggestive of transitional cell cancer or were being followed after treatment for that disease.[dagger] Matritech, Inc., Newton, Massachusetts.[double dagger] Bard Diagnostics, Redmond, Washington.[section] Gentian Scientific Software, Niawier, The Netherlands.

Materials and Methods

We prospectively evaluated voided urine and/or barbotage specimens from 291 patients a mean of 65.2 years old. All voided urine samples were evaluated by quick staining and standard cytology, the BTA stat 1-step qualitative assay (which detects a bladder tumor associated antigen) and the NMP22 test (which detects a nuclear mitotic apparatus protein). In addition, barbotage specimens were evaluated by QUANTICYT computer assisted dual parameter image analysis. All patients underwent subsequent cystoscopy and biopsy evaluation of any suspicious lesion. Sensitivity, specificity, and the predictive value of positive and negative results were determined in correlation with endoscopic and histological findings.

Results

In 91 patients with histologically proved transitional cell carcinoma overall sensitivity was 48, 57, 58, 59 and 59% for the NMP22 test, the BTA stat test, rapid staining cytology of barbotage samples, rapid staining cytology of voided urine specimens and image analysis, respectively. For histological grades 1 to 3 underlying transitional cell carcinoma sensitivity was 17, 61 and 90% for urinary cytology, 48, 58 and 63% for the BTA stat test, and 52, 45 and 50% for the NMP22 test, respectively. Specificity was 100% for cytology, 93% for image analysis, 70% for the NMP22 test and 68% for the BTA stat test.

Conclusions

Immunological markers are superior to cytological evaluation and image analysis for detecting low grade transitional cell carcinoma but they have low specificity and sensitivity in grade 3 transitional cell carcinoma. Urine bound diagnostic tools cannot replace cystoscopy.     

NMP22与BTA stat检测在膀胱肿瘤诊断中的应用

目的评价NMP22和BTAstat诊断膀胱肿瘤的价值.方法对82例临床怀疑膀胱肿瘤的患者,在膀胱镜检查前将尿样分为3份,分别进行NMP22、BTAstat和脱落细胞学检测,分析比较3种方法的敏感性、特异性和阳性预测价值.结果82例中病理证实膀胱肿瘤32例,其他疾病50例.NMP22诊断膀胱肿瘤敏感性为87.5%,与BTAstat(65.6%)、细胞学(21.9%)比较,差别有显著性意义(P<0.05).3种方法诊断特异性分别为84.0%、64.0%和100.0%.阳性预测值分别为77.8%、53.9%和100.0%.结论NMP22是一种简单、敏感、非侵袭性的早期诊断膀胱肿瘤的肿瘤标记物.     

Urinary BTA-stat, BTA-trak and NMP22 in surveillance after TUR of recurrent superficial transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate NMP22, BTA-Stat and BTA-Trak tests in monitoring recurrent transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder. METHODS: The tests were performed in 179 selected patients being followed up for recurrent superficial bladder tumors: 55 patients had bladder recurrence and 124 patients were recurrence free. The NMP22 test was obtained in all patients; BTA-Stat and BTA-Trak in the last 96 and 74 patients, respectively. Sixty-four patients (51.6%) were undergoing adjuvant intravesical chemotherapy. RESULTS: Sensitivity was 74, 57 and 62% and specificity was 55, 62 and 79% for NMP22, BTA-Stat and BTA-Trak, respectively. A high percentage of patients submitted to intravesical chemotherapy had false-positive tests. Positive predictive values of the NMP22, BTA-Stat and BTA-Trak tests were 42.2, 40 and 45.4%, and negative predictive values were 82.9, 76.9 and 88.4%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: NMP22, BTA-Stat and BTA-Trak tests cannot replace cystoscopy and cannot be adopted as routine tools in surveillance after TUR in patients with superficial bladder cancer.     

Urinary NMP22 BladderChek test in the diagnosis of superficial bladder cancer

OBJECTIVE: To study the diagnostic efficacy of the NMP22 BladderChek test and to compare it to cytology in the detection of bladder cancer. METHODS: We evaluated 106 voided urinary specimens of patients with suspicion of bladder cancer. All voided urine samples were evaluated by the NMP22 BladderChek test, cytology, sediment and culture. The diagnostic value of the NMP22 BladderChek test was evaluated according to correlation with cystoscopic findings and, in case of tumour, histological findings. A negative test result in a pTaG1 tumour was not considered false-negative in this study. The results were compared to the diagnostic value of cytology. Moreover, the value of the combination of cytology and the NMP22 BladderChek test was determined. RESULTS: In total, 29 patients had histologically proven transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder. The NMP22 BladderChek test detected 40% of 15 pTa tumours and 83.3% of the 6 pT1 tumours. Cytology detected pTa in 33.3% and pT1 in 66.6%. The 1 CIS lesion was detected by cytology. In the group of patients in follow-up the sensitivity and specificity were 57.1% (CI 28.8-82.3) and 89.8% (CI 79.2-96.2) for the NMP22 BladderChek test and 42.9% (CI 17.7-71.7) and 93.2% (CI 83.5-98.1) for cytology. CONCLUSION: The NMP22 BladderChek test has a slightly higher sensitivity compared to cytology, without a relevant loss in specificity. Furthermore it is an easy test with instant result. However, no extra tumours were detected by adjunction of the NMP22 BladderChek test.     

Variability in the performance of nuclear matrix protein 22 for the detection of bladder cancer

PURPOSE: We assessed variability in the diagnostic performance of NMP22 for detecting recurrence and progression in patients with Ta, T1, and/or CIS transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder in a large international cohort. MATERIALS AND METHODS: NMP22 voided urine levels were measured in 2,871 patients who underwent office cystoscopy for monitoring previous stage Ta, T1 and/or CIS transitional cell carcinoma at 12 participating institutions. RESULTS: Patient characteristics varied considerably among institutions. Overall 1,045 patients (36.4%) had recurrent transitional cell carcinoma (range across institutions 13.6% to 54.3%). Median NMP22 was 5.5 U/ml (range across institutions 2.5 to 18.8). Of the patients 33.5% had grade III tumors (range across institutions 20.6% to 54.0%) and 22.4% had muscle invasive tumors (range across institutions 3.2% to 38.2%). Area under the ROC curve for bladder TCC detection was 0.735 (95% CI 0.715 to 0.755, range across institutions 0.676 to 0.889). The manufacturer recommended cutoff of 10 U/ml detected 57% of cases with a 19% false-positive rate. AUC for grade III and stage T2 or greater disease was 0.806 (95% CI 0.780 to 831) and 0.864 (95% CI 0.839 to 0.890), respectively. For each NMP22 cutoff NMP22 had higher sensitivity for detecting grade III and stage T2 or greater bladder transitional cell carcinoma than for detecting any cancer. No optimal cutoffs for detecting any or aggressive bladder transitional cell carcinoma could be derived based on NMP22 values. CONCLUSIONS: There is a substantial degree of heterogeneity in the diagnostic performance of NMP22 applied to populations from different institutions. There is no clearly defined NMP22 cutoff but there is a continuum of risk for recurrence and progression.     

Comparison of the nuclear matrix protein 22 with voided urine cytology and BTA stat test in the diagnosis of transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder.

OBJECTIVE: To assess sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, positive predictive value and negative predictive value of nuclear matrix protein 22 (NMP22) test, BTA stat test and cytology in the urine of patients with a spectrum of urologic conditions, including bladder cancer. METHODS: A total of 140 patients (40 with bladder cancer) provided a urine sample which was divided into appropriate aliquots for each of the tests cited above. The endoscopist, pathologist, cytologist and the person performing BTA stat test and NMP22 test were blinded as to the results of the other tests. RESULTS: Receiver-operating characteristics curve interpretation determined that 12.0 U/ml was an optimal reference value for NMP22 to detect transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder in this patient group. Comparative results demonstrate a clear superiority of NMP22 and BTA stat tests in sensitivity in bladder cancer detection (p < 0.01), while cytology and NMP22 were better than BTA stat test in specificity (p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: NMP22 and BTA stat test results represented significant improvement over urinary cytology for detection of transitional cell carcinoma. The sensitivities of NMP22 and BTA stat tests for detection of transitional cell carcinoma in this group of patients were as much as twice that of cytology. When the cutoff value of urinary NMP22 was set at 12.0 U/ml, NMP22 was more accurate than the other tests (p < 0.05).     

Immunocyt test improves the diagnostic accuracy of urinary cytology: results of a French multicenter study

PURPOSE: The limitations of urinary cytology and the invasiveness of cystoscopy generate an increasing interest in noninvasive diagnostic tools for the management of transitional cell carcinoma. We assess the clinical performance of ImmunoCyt (DiagnoCure, Inc., Saint-Foy, Canada) in the detection of bladder cancer in a 10-center French trial. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From October 2000 to April 2001, 694 patients undergoing cystoscopy were prospectively included in the study. Of the patients 458 (66%) had been previously treated for superficial transitional cell carcinoma and 236 (34%) were referred for symptoms suggestive of bladder cancer. All patients underwent ImmunoCyt test and standard urinary cytology from voided urine as well as a complete evaluation including cystoscopy and transurethral resection or biopsy of suspicious lesions. Sensitivity and specificity values of urinary cytology and ImmunoCyt whether or not combined were calculated using cystoscopy as the gold standard and histopathology when available. RESULTS: A total of 85 recurrent and 58 newly diagnosed bladder tumors were diagnosed by cystoscopy and histologicaly confirmed. Overall sensitivity of urinary cytology was 17.9%, 46.3% and 63.8% respectively, for G1, G2 and G3 transitional cell carcinoma, whereas that of ImmunoCyt was 60.7%, 75.6% and 76.8%. Sensitivity of the combined tests was 66.7%, 78% and 87%, respectively. Moreover, 10 of 55 (18.2%) new pT1 and pT2 or greater tumors were diagnosed by ImmunoCyt alone. Specificity of urinary cytology was 94.5%, whereas that of ImmunoCyt was 84.2%. Specificity of the combined tests was 80.7%. Marked variations in urinary cytology sensitivity were observed among the different centers (27.3% to 66.7%), whereas combined assays (urinary cytology and ImmunoCyt) enhanced the overall sensitivity in the 80% range at most centers. CONCLUSIONS: This prospective multicenter series confirmed a marked increase in sensitivity without significant loss in specificity when including ImmunoCyt in standard urinary cytology protocol. This increased sensitivity was observed in high grade lesions (with 100% sensitivity for carcinoma in situ) as well in low grade, low stage tumors.     

Evaluation of the clinical value of urinary NMP22 as a marker in the screening and surveillance of transitional cell carcinoma of the urinary bladder.

PURPOSE: To prospectively evaluate the clinical role of urinary NMP22 as a marker for transitional cell carcinoma of the urinary bladder in screening and surveillance settings. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Single voided specimens were obtained from 211 consecutive patients who presented for flexible cystoscopy. Of these, 96 patients presented with haematuria or irritative symptoms (screening), the remaining 115 were patients with known transitional cell carcinoma on follow-up (surveillance). The urine sample was used for urine microscopy, cytology and for measuring NMP22 levels. RESULTS: Bladder tumours were found in 16 of 96 (16.6%) patients in the screening group and 17 of 115 (15.6%) patients on surveillance. The NMP22 levels were significantly lower in patients with lower stage (Ta vs. T1-3), low grade (G1, G2 vs. G3, CIS) and papillary morphology. The optimum threshold for NMP22 obtained from the ROC curve was 4.75 U/ml, providing a sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value and negative predictive value of 42.4, 85, 38.5 and 88.6%, respectively. Sensitivity and specificity were better in patients being screened than in those on surveillance. In both groups, urinary NMP22 had similar diagnostic characteristics as urinary cytology. CONCLUSIONS: Urinary NMP22 levels are significantly higher in patients with bladder tumour than in those negative for tumours, and test predictability improves with increasing stage and grade. The overall sensitivity for urinary NMP22 is similar to, but not superior to urine cytology. Our study suggests that the clinical role of urinary NMP22 as a diagnostic marker can be at best supportive only.     

Comparison of cytology and nuclear matrix protein 22 for the detection and follow-up of bladder cancer

OBJECTIVES: This study was designed to determine the clinical usefulness of the nuclear matrix METHODS: 84 patients suffering from bladder cancer or suspected bladder cancer, 25 patients with benign urological lesions and 60 healthy controls participated in a prospective study. Freshly voided spot urine samples were taken for cytological examination and determination of NMP 22 levels by enzyme-linked immunoassay. RESULTS: The sensitivity of the NMP 22 test according to the tumor grading was (results of cytology in brackets): G1 25.0% (20.0%); G2 68.2% (59.1%), and G3 100.0% (66.7); overall sensitivity was 62.5% (45.0%). The sensitivity for superficial bladder cancer was 46.7% (36.7%) and for invasive bladder cancer 90.0% (70.0%). The specificity was 65.9% (88.9%). CONCLUSIONS: NMP 22 is a reliable tool for detecting invasive bladder cancer. Results for the frequently occurring low grade superficial bladder cancer are as poor as those obtained with cytology. In addition benign lesions such as urolithiasis or urinary tract infection lead to false-positive results. Therefore cystoscopy has to be performed when trying to detect and follow-up bladder cancer.     

Tumor marker tests in bladder cancer

The gold standard for detecting bladder cancer is cystoscopy which identifies nearly all papillary and sessile lesions. However, it is an invasive procedure causing some discomfort for patients. Urine cytology is the standard non-invasive marker with very high specificity, but unfavourable poor sensitivity for Ta, G1, and T1 bladder tumors. To improve early detection of bladder cancer as well as to monitor treatment response and tumor recurrence, bladder tumor markers are eligible. An ideal bladder cancer test would have the potential to replace or delay cystoscopy in the follow-up of bladder cancer patients. In recent years, the FDA approved non-invasive tumor marker tests ImmunoCyt / uCyt+, BTA TRAK, BTA stat, NMP22, NMP22 BladderChek, and UroVysion have been investigated. The tests demonstrated higher sensitivity for diagnosis of bladder cancer compared to urine cytology. Overall, the mean sensitivity and mean specificity was 64-80% and 71-95% and the mean positive and negative predictive values to detect malignancy were 49-84% and 79-95%, respectively. BTA TRAK, BTA stat, NMP22, and NMP22 BladderChek assays are limited by false-positive results in patients with benign urological diseases such as hematuria, urocystitis, renal calculi or urinary tract infections. Due to low specificity BTA TRAK, BTA stat, NMP22, and NMP22 BladderChek should not be used without first ruling out benign or malignant genitourinary disease other than bladder cancer. With the exception of UroVysion achieving 80% sensitivity and 94% specificity, none of these non-invasive tests revealed a high sensitivity and specificity at the same time, which is a main demand to be made on an ideal tumor marker. Insufficient sensitivity along with limited specificity does not allow replacing cystoscopy in diagnosis of bladder cancer or treatment decisions based on a positive test result.     

Immunocyt: a new tool for detecting transitional cell cancer of the urinary tract

PURPOSE: The limitations of cytology and the invasiveness of cystoscopy for detecting bladder cancer generate increasing interest in noninvasive, urine bound diagnostic tools. We assessed the diagnostic value of the newly developed immunocytochemical test, Immunocyt, which detects cellular markers specific for transitional cell cancer in the voided urine of patients with bladder cancer. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Participating in our prospective study were 264 consecutive patients with a mean age of 65.9 years, including 114 in whom symptoms were suggestive of bladder cancer and 150 who were being followed after complete transurethral resection of superficial transitional cell carcinoma. Voided urine specimens were evaluated by standard cytology and the Immunocyt test, which traces the monoclonal antibodies M344, LDQ10 and 19A211 against transitional cell carcinoma in exfoliated urothelial cells. In all cases cystoscopy was subsequently performed and any suspicious lesion was evaluated by biopsy. RESULTS: Histologically proved transitional cell carcinoma was found in 79 patients. Immunocyt with cytology had 89.9% sensitivity overall (84, 88 and 96.5% in grades 1 to 3 disease, respectively). A total of 34 (43%), 3 (3.8%) and 34 (43%) cases were positive on Immunocyt only, cytology only and both evaluations, respectively. In 8 cases (10.1%) both tests were negative. Overall Immunocyt only was 86.1% sensitive (84, 84 and 89.6% in grades 1 to 3 disease, respectively) and 79.4% specific. Overall cytology only was 46.8% sensitive (4, 52 and 79.3% in grades 1 to 3 disease, respectively) and 98.2% specific. CONCLUSIONS: Immunocyt is a noninvasive, highly sensitive test for detecting transitional cell carcinoma of all grades and stages. When combined with conventional urinary cytology, it may replace cystoscopy in select patients, especially in followup protocols of low grade transitional cell carcinoma.