Have patients with early squamous carcinoma of the vulva been overtreated in the past? The Norwegian experience 1977-1991

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate different surgical approaches in early squamous vulvar cancer. METHODS: Review of clinical and histopathologic data and follow-up information of 216 patients with clinical FIGO stage I-II disease, primarily treated by surgery from 1977-1991. RESULTS: Eighty-nine patients underwent radical vulvectomy with bilateral groin dissection by en bloc excision, 60 by the triple incision technique, 20 individualized vulvar surgery with uni-or bilateral groin dissection, and 47 vulvar surgery only. Groin metastases occurred in 9% stage I and 25% stage II disease. Groin involvement was not seen in stage I tumors with invasion depth < or =/=1 mm. Bilateral metastases occurred in medially located tumors of both stages, and laterally located stage II. Metastases were ipsilateral in lateral stage 1. Separate groin dissection significantly reduced morbidity. Sixty-six patients relapsed, 14 after more than 5 years. Vulvar recurrence was related to tumor diameter and the condition of the resection borders. The single most important predictor of death from vulvar cancer was the presence of inguinal femoral lymph node metastases. Conservative and individualized surgery did not compromise 5-year survival. CONCLUSIONS: A careful selection of patients fitted for less radical surgery is essential to avoid undertreatment. Groin dissection can be omitted in tumors with diameters < or =/=2 cm and invasion depth < or =/=1 mm. At least ipsilateral groin dissection is needed in all other cases. Groin dissection should be performed through separate incisions. Modified vulvectomy is appropriate provided radicality can be obtained. Long-time follow-up is important as recurrences can be seen many years after primary therapy.     

Morbidity and recurrence with modifications of radical vulvectomy and groin dissection.

Vulvar carcinoma has been managed in recent years with modifications of radical vulvectomy and groin dissection. Separate groin incisions, superficial inguinal lymphadenectomy, unilateral groin dissection, and wide excision have been utilized to reduce the morbidity of treatment. In this study, the surgical management of 82 patients with vulvar squamous cell carcinoma was reviewed in order to assess morbidity and risk of recurrence. A modification of radical vulvectomy and groin dissection was employed in 67 patients, while 15 patients underwent classical en-bloc vulvar and groin dissection. Wound complications of the vulva occurred in 1 of 12 patients undergoing hemivulvectomy, in 8 of 55 undergoing radical vulvectomy, and in 7 of 15 who had en-bloc vulvar resection and groin dissection (P = 0.01). Among the 46 patients undergoing bilateral groin dissection through separate incisions, groin breakdown, lymphocyst, and lymphedema occurred in 10 (22%), 7 (15%), and 7 (15%), versus 0, 1 (7%), and 2 (13%) of the 15 who had unilateral groin dissection. Modification of vulvar resection did not increase the risk of local recurrence. Groin recurrence developed in 2 of 15 patients who underwent en-bloc groin dissection and in 1 of 46 who underwent bilateral groin dissection through separate incisions. Two of 15 who had a unilateral groin dissection recurred in the contralateral groin. The risk of recurrence as well as morbidity following modifications of radical vulvectomy with groin dissection should be considered when planning treatment.     

Radical wide excision and selective inguinal node dissection for squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva

Limited resection of some vulvar cancers may provide cure rates equivalent to those obtained with radical vulvectomy and bilateral inguinal node dissection. Rapid recovery, fewer complications, and better functional result have been described as advantages to less extensive procedures. Since 1978, 32 patients with invasive squamous cell cancer of the vulva (depth greater than 1 mm) and clinically negative inguinal lymph nodes underwent radical wide excisions as primary therapy. Mean age at diagnosis was 61 years. Seventeen patients had T1 and 15 had T2 tumors. Resection of the primary lesion was tailored to lesion location and size, and dissection was carried to the deep perineal fascia. Twenty-two patients had unilateral superficial inguinal lymph node dissections, five with midline lesions had bilateral superficial dissections, and five had node samplings which included deep inguinal nodes. Depth of invasion ranged from 1.5 to 13.0 mm. Mean largest lesion dimension was 23 mm. Five-year lifetable survival for the entire group was 84%. Univariate analysis of potential prognostic variables showed no significant recurrence or survival differences for patient age (P = 0.56), symptom duration (P = 0.57), FIGO stage (P = 0.67), tumor grade (P = 0.20), tumor location (P = 0.26), depth of invasion (P = 0.56), or resection margin status (P = 0.63). Thirty-one percent of patients had perioperative complications, and 16% developed delayed complications. Mean hospital stay was 10 days. Three patients (10%) developed new or recurrent vulvar disease and underwent additional therapy. None have died of disease, although one is alive with persistent tumor. Radical wide excision and selective inguinal lymphadenectomy constitute a reasonable alternative to radical vulvectomy with bilateral inguinal node dissections for squamous tumors clinically limited to the vulva. Outcome may not be strongly influenced by lesion size or depth of invasion.     

Minimally invasive vulvar carcinoma: An indication for conservative surgical therapy

It has been proposed that squamous carcinoma of the vulva with 1 mm or less of stromal invasion can be treated with local resection without inguinal node dissection. A retrospective review of 255 cases of stages I and II vulvar carcinoma demonstrated 24 cases of minimally invasive carcinoma. All cases were subjected to detailed chart review and pathologic confirmation. Mean age at diagnosis was 60 years. Seven patients had a preoperative diagnosis of preinvasive disease, ten had stage I disease, and seven had stage II disease. Fifteen cases had associated vulvar carcinoma in situ. Treatment consisted of local excision in 2 patients, radical wide excision in 11, hemivulvectomy in 5, and radical vulvectomy in 6. Eleven patients had either unilateral or bilateral inguinal node dissection. Five-year life-table survival was 89%. Four patients (17%) developed recurrent dysplasia and four (17%) developed invasive recurrences. One invasive recurrence was in an inguinal node in a patient previously treated with a hemivulvectomy and negative ipsilateral superficial node dissection. Univariate analysis revealed no statistically significant associations between recurrence and age, symptom duration, margin status, location, FIGO stage, or coexisting VIN. Large areas of coexisting dysplasia and variable gross appearance make meaningful application of FIGO staging criteria difficult in lesions with minimal focal invasion. Wide excision or radical wide excision of lesions with "high-risk" VIN or those showing less than or equal to 1 mm of stromal invasion on biopsy is adequate therapy. If final pathologic review demonstrates deeper invasion, a selective lymph node dissection can be performed as a second procedure. Careful surveillance with liberal use of colposcopy and biopsies is indicated in these patients.     

Carcinoma of the vulva

The objective of this review is to summarize the published data about squamous carcinoma of the vulva and to identify promising areas for future investigation. Rather than the routine use of complete radical vulvectomy, a radical wide excision of the vulvar lesion to achieve at least a 1-cm gross margin appears sufficient to treat the primary lesion. A surgical assessment of the groin is required for all patients who have invasion greater than 1 mm. Ipsilateral groin node dissection can be performed through a separate incision. All the nodal tissue medial to the vessels and above the fascia should be removed. Sentinel node evaluation may be a significant step forward, but the false-negative rate is not well enough defined to consider this a standard. Patients with positive inguinal nodes at groin dissection should receive radiation therapy to the ipsilateral groin and hemipelvis. For those patients who have unresectable primary disease or if nodes are palpably suspicious, fixed, and/or ulcerated preoperatively, chemoradiation is the preferred option. Exenterative procedures may rarely be required. Chemotherapy for recurrent or metastatic disease has not been proven to be of value. Although survival rates are high for those with negative nodes, the morbidity associated with standard radical techniques has prompted innovation. Adequately powered trials aimed at further reducing morbidity without compromising survival are underway.     

Squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva stage IA: long-term results

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the risk of metastases to lymph nodes and long-term results of radical and modified radical surgery in patients with a T1 squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva and 相似文献   

外阴癌淋巴结切除适应证和争议

外阴局部广泛切除术+腹股沟淋巴结切除术是目前外阴癌的基本手术方式。FIGO和NCCN指南均推荐FIGOⅠA期可不行腹股沟淋巴结切除术,所有ⅠB期或Ⅱ期患者,应该行腹股沟淋巴结切除术。晚期外阴癌在确定总体治疗方案前,应先明确腹股沟淋巴结状态,再确定后续处理方案。如果术前未发现可疑转移淋巴结,行双侧腹股沟、股淋巴结切除术;术前已明确淋巴结阳性者,建议仅切除肿大的淋巴结,术后给予腹股沟和盆腔放疗,最好避免系统性淋巴结切除术。在有关淋巴结切除的争议中,切除腹股沟、股淋巴结及采用三切口腹股沟横切口技术、保留大隐静脉等被大多数学者认可;但对于靠近中线但不侵犯中线的病灶是否可不切除双侧腹股沟淋巴结及外阴黑色素瘤、前庭大腺癌等少见病理类型的淋巴结切除指征尚有争议。     

Granular cell myoblastoma of the vulva.

Granular cell myoblastoma is a rare tumor, generally benign, but also known to have a pleomorphic malignant variant. The gynecologist should be aware of this “innocuous” vulvar lesion which may also be located in other areas. Wide local excision is indicated for the benign form, but radical vulvectomy with bilateral groin and deep pelvic lymph node dissection is indicated for the malignant variant.     

Carcinoma of the vulva: a retrospective review of 37 cases at a regional cancer centre in South India.

A retrospective review of 37 cases of carcinoma of the vulva presenting between 1996 and 2000 has been carried out. Thirty-three cases were managed with curative intent and four cases with advanced loco-regional disease were managed with palliative intent. The surgical treatment consisted of wide excision in one case, radical vulvectomy (RV) in six cases, radical vulvectomy and bilateral groin node dissection (RV+BGND) in 25 cases and radical vulvectomy and unilateral groin node dissection in one case. Nine of these 33 women also received adjuvant chemotherapy preoperatively in the hope of achieving better tumour-free surgical margins. Eight cases had a partial response and one case achieved complete response; the surgical margins were free in all these patients. One case received neoadjuvant radiotherapy to the vulva and pelvis followed by RV+BGND, which revealed no residual tumour. Overall, 26/33 cases had groin/inguinal node dissection and 23 (88.4%) of them had groin wound dehiscence. Thirteen of these 26 patients (50%) had inguinal node metastases (Stage III, four patients; Stage IV, nine patients). All the patients with negative nodes were free of disease while three of four patients with Stage III and two of nine patients with Stage IV with nodal metastases remained free of disease. The only patient with Stage III disease plus inguinal node metastases who recurred had multiple positive nodes with extracapsular spread. It appears that although bilateral involvement of the inguinal lymph nodes carries a worse prognosis, unilateral involvement with or without vaginal involvement carries an excellent prognosis provided multiple nodes are not involved. The role of neoadjuvant chemotherapy as compared to neoadjuvant radiotherapy, in locally advanced tumours, needs to be explored further.     

Surgical management of invasive carcinoma of the vulva utilizing a lower abdominal midline incision

An approach to radical vulvectomy and bilateral lymphadenectomy utilizing a lower abdominal midline incision is presented. Nineteen patients were operated on for invasive vulvar carcinoma utilizing this technique, while fifteen patients were operated on with the more traditional transverse incision for groin dissection. When evaluated by intraoperative and postoperative parameters, the two techniques gave roughly identical results. The midline approach can be particularly valuable in those situations where celiotomy is to be performed at the time of radical vulvectomy.     

Outcomes for patients with T1 squamous cell cancer of the vulva undergoing sentinel node biopsy

OBJECTIVE: This retrospective review was undertaken to evaluate survival in patients with T1 squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva treated with radical local excision and sentinel node dissection. METHODS: Patients with T1 cancers underwent pre-operative lymphoscintigraphy and sentinel lymph node dissection using technetium sulfur colloid and isosulfan blue dye. The primary tumor was removed with radical local excision. Patients with negative sentinel nodes did not receive any additional treatment. Survival was calculated using life table analysis. RESULTS: There were 21 patients who underwent 27 sentinel node dissections. Three patients were found to have positive sentinel nodes. At a median follow-up of 4.6 years, two patients have died of cancer, and three patients have died of intercurrent illness. None of the patients with negative sentinel nodes has died of cancer. There were no groin or distant recurrences in patients with negative sentinel nodes. Three-year disease-free survival for all patients and for patients with negative sentinel nodes were 90% and 100% respectively. CONCLUSION: The survival for patients with early vulvar cancer treated with sentinel node dissection and radical local excision appears excellent.     

Isolated skin bridge metastasis following modified radical vulvectomy and bilateral inguinofemoral lymphadenectomy

Separate vulvar and groin incisions have significantly reduced the morbidity of vulvar cancer surgery. We describe a patient with FIGO stage II squamous vulvar cancer, who developed an ipsilateral tumor recurrence in the skin bridge between the vulva and the groin within 7 months of modified radical vulvectomy and bilateral inguinofemoral lymphadenectomy, using triple incisions. The recurrence was treated by wide local excision alone and she remains free of disease 2 years later. Although rare, the potential for failing to excise tumor emboli in the lymphatics of the skin bridge must be recognized when the triple incision technique is used in the surgical treatment of vulvar cancer.     

Radiation therapy versus pelvic node resection for carcinoma of the vulva with positive groin nodes

From 1977 to 1984, 114 eligible patients with invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva and positive groin nodes after radical vulvectomy and bilateral groin lymphadenectomy were randomized to receive either radiation therapy or pelvic node resection. Fifty-three of the 59 patients randomized to radiation therapy received a 4500- to 5000-rad tumor dose in five to 6.5 weeks bilaterally to the groins and to the midplane of the pelvis even if only unilateral positive groin nodes had been detected; no radiation was given to the central vulvar area. Fifty-three of the 55 patients randomized to further surgery had pelvic node resection performed on the side containing positive groin nodes either unilaterally or bilaterally. Acute and chronic morbidity was similar for both regimens. The two major poor prognostic factors were clinically suspicious or fixed ulcerated groin nodes and two or more positive groin nodes. The difference in survival for the 114 evaluable patients was significant, favoring the adjunctive radiation therapy group (P = .03). The estimated two-year survival rates were 68% for the radiation therapy group and 54% for pelvic node resection group. The most dramatic survival advantage for radiation therapy was in patients who had either of the two major poor prognostic factors present; at this time, the benefit of radiation therapy for the remaining patients is uncertain. In this randomized prospective study, the addition of adjunctive groin and pelvic irradiation therapy after radical vulvectomy and inguinal lymphadenectomy proved superior to pelvic node resection.     

Radical vulvectomy and bilateral groin lymphadenectomy utilizing separate groin incisions: report of a case with recurrence in the intervening skin bridge

Postoperative wound breakdown is very common following the en bloc dissection of the vulva and inguinal/femoral lymph nodes for carcinoma of the vulva. To decrease the incidence of wound morbidity, techniques have been described for performing the inguinal/femoral lymphadenectomy through separate groin incisions. This approach leaves a bridge of tissue between the vulvar excision and the lymph node dissection. A case of stage I squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva that was treated with a radical vulvectomy and bilateral inguinal/femoral lymphadenectomy utilizing separate groin incisions is presented. This patient later developed a recurrence in the tissue bridge between the vulvar and groin excisions. The mechanism for this recurrence is discussed.     

Malignant melanoma of the vulva

During the years 1969 to 1982, 16 patients with primary malignant melanoma of the vulva were entered into the Tumor Registry at the University of Miami Jackson Memorial Medical Center. The mean age was 55, with a range of 18 to 89 years. Treatment was primarily by radial vulvectomy with bilateral groin and pelvic node dissection. Survival was correlated to FIGO staging, Clark and Breslow classifications, and lymph node involvement. Survival correlated best to tumor thickness and Clark levels. Patients with Clark level 2 or less and less than 1.5 mm depth of penetration had the best prognosis. Lymph node involvement was present in 25% of the patients, and there were no survivors in this group. There were no instances of positive pelvic nodes when the groin nodes were negative, and routine pelvic lymphadenectomy is not recommended.     

Management of vulvar melanoma.

Considerable debate centers on the optimal treatment for vulvar melanoma, as well as those clinicopathological factors influencing prognosis. We reviewed 80 patients with vulvar melanoma seen between 1949 and 1990. Primary tumors were assessed according to Chung (47 patients) and Breslow (65 patients) microstaging systems. Fifty-nine patients (76%) underwent radical vulvectomy, ten patients (13%) had a partial vulvectomy, and nine patients (12%) had a wide local excision. Fifty-six also underwent inguinal node dissection. Median follow-up was 193 months. Median survival was 63 months. Ten-year survival by Chung level was as follows: I 100%; II, 81%; III, 87%; IV, 11%; V, 33%. Ten-year survival by tumor thickness was as follows: 0.75 mm, 48%; 0.75-1.5 mm, 68%; 1.51-3.0 mm, 44%; greater than 3.0 mm, 22%. Increased depth of invasion was associated with increased incidence of inguinal node metastasis. Cox regression analysis demonstrated prognostic significance for tumor thickness (P less than 0.001), inguinal node metastasis (P less than 0.001), and older age at diagnosis (P less than 0.001). Radical vulvectomy did not seem to improve survival over less radical procedures. Based on this experience, we recommend radical local excision for patients with malignant melanoma of the vulva. Patients who have more than a superficially invasive melanoma should also have inguinal lymph node dissection.     

Changing trends in the surgical treatment of invasive carcinoma of the vulva

Twenty-nine years experience with 346 patients with invasive carcinoma of the vulva is presented. More than 90 per cent had squamous carcinoma. The primary mode of treatment was surgical. Two hundred and ninety-six patients were treated primarily with surgical treatment, 120 underwent radical vulvectomy and bilateral groin and pelvic lymphadenectomy, 133 had radical vulvectomy with bilateral groin dissection and 390 receiving nonradical procedures. Thirteen patients had radical operations plus pelvic exenteration for advanced disease. There were no intraoperative deaths, but 16 (5.4 per cent) died within 28 days of the operation. The uncorrected over-all five year survival rate was 66 per cent. In the presence of negative nodes, it was 83 per cent and with positive nodes, it was 38 per cent. Fifty per cent of those treated with exenteration are alive and disease-free at five years or more. Since one-third of the patients presented with advanced disease (Stages III and IV), earlier diagnosis and prompt referral must be encouraged to improve surgical results.     

Prognostic variables in the treatment of squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva

Records of 98 patients undergoing surgery for squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva between 1960 and 1982 were analyzed to evaluate and develop treatment policy. There were 32, 34, 26, and 6 patients in FIGO stages I-IV, respectively. Eighty-six patients underwent radical vulvectomy, 8 patients underwent less extensive procedures, and 4 underwent more extensive procedures. Eighty-seven patients underwent inguinal node dissection, and 40 underwent pelvic node dissection as well. Eight patients received external beam irradiation. Actuarial 5-year survival was 57%. Age, tumor size, FIGO (clinical) stage, surgically determined T and N stages, tumor differentiation, lymph vessel invasion, extent of surgical procedure, and adjuvant irradiation were analyzed to determine their effects on local control, freedom from distant metastases, and survival, using single variable and multivariate analysis. Local control was significantly related to FIGO stage; freedom from distant metastasis was significantly related to surgical N stage, tumor size, and surgical T stage; survival was significantly related to surgical N stage, tumor size, surgical T stage, age, and lymph vessel invasion. Metastatic involvement of inguinal lymph nodes was significantly correlated with tumor size and differentiation. Of 87 evaluable patients, 33 had inguinal node involvement, and of these, 17 developed recurrent disease. All 7 patients with pelvic node metastases had positive inguinal nodes, and all died; the cause of death could be determined in 5, of whom 4 manifested distant metastases. Pelvic lymphadenectomy conferred no survival benefit in this series, even in the presence of positive inguinal nodes. Local vulvar recurrence is a significant problem in patients with positive inguinal nodes, and postoperative irradiation should be directed to this area in these patients. Patients with vulvar recurrences, especially those occurring at least 2 years after surgery, can be successfully salvaged, and should therefore be treated aggressively.     

Vulvar malignancy

Treatment of invasive vulvar malignancy has become more individualized during the past decade. In the past, radical vulvectomy with bilateral inguinofemoral lymphadenectomy was the standard therapy for invasive squamous cell carcinoma and melanoma of the vulva. This is no longer always the case. The treatment of stage I and stage II invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva has become more individualized. Less radical surgery appears to produce the same results as ultraradical surgery. Wide local excision of early lesions associated with ipsilateral lymph node dissection appears to be adequate therapy in many cases. Likewise, treatment of early melanoma (0.75 mm in thickness) can be managed by wide local excision with or without groin dissection of the ipsilateral side. This more conservative approach has resulted in significantly fewer postoperative complications and has improved the self-image of many women undergoing treatment for vulvar malignancy.     

外阴癌39例手术治疗及预后分析

目的 总结我院治疗外阴癌的手术方式,分析与外阴癌预后有关的因素。方法 回顾性分析我院１９７９－１９９７年收治的３９例侵袭性外阴癌的临床资料。其中外阴病灶局部切除术５例、部分外阴根治术１３例及全外阴根治术２１例。应用ＳＰＳＳ地不同的手术方式秀关预后因素进行比较分析。结果 ３９例中鳞癌３３例,占８４．６％,其中高、中、低分化分别为２６、５、２例。临床分期为Ⅰ期７例（１７．９％）Ⅱ期１７例（４３．６％）