Radiographic follow-up of periapical status after endodontic treatment of teeth with and without apical periodontitis

Objectives

The aim was to assess objectively the rate of changes in periapical status after endodontic treatment in relation to preoperative radiographic status (Periapical Index Score, PAI) and to tooth type.

Material and methods

Radiographic data from a total of 1,410 teeth in seven prospective clinical studies was pooled. The periapical status was evaluated blindly using the PAI scoring system. The longest follow-up period was 4 years; intervals between controls varied from 3 months to 1 year.

Results

Teeth with preoperative PAI score 1 maintained excellent periapical health throughout. Teeth with preoperative PAI score 2 showed some impairment in health over the first 6 months, but improved to approach 95 % healthy teeth at 2 years of observation. Teeth with PAI 3–5 at the start showed significant improvement at 3 months; 27 % were considered healthy (PAI 1 or 2) increasing to 41 % after 1 year. Improvement of periapical status was slower in PAI groups 4 and 5 compared with PAI 3 during the first year. After 2 years, improvement continued similarly in all preoperative PAI 3–5 groups of teeth. Upper lateral incisors showed the poorest healing rate.

Conclusions

Healing of pre-existing periapical lesions is most pronounced from 3 months to 2 years. Teeth with initially healthy periapical structures predictably maintain good periapical health. Maxillary teeth, especially lateral incisors, showed poorer healing rates than mandibular teeth.

Clinical relevance

Radiographic healing rates may vary among tooth groups within the dentition. Periapically healthy teeth that are root filled may not need postoperative controls.     

Healing of apical periodontitis after endodontic treatment: a comparison between a silicone-based and a zinc oxide-eugenol-based sealer

AIM: To assess the treatment results up to 1 year after endodontic treatment of apical periodontitis using a silicone-based sealer in comparison with Grossman's sealer, and to compare the results at 3 months after treatment with the 12-month follow-up to assess the prognostic value of a 3-month control. METHODOLOGY: A total of 199 teeth were treated at three centres. The sealer was randomly chosen at the time of filling. Treatment results were evaluated clinically and radiographically 3 and 12 months after root-canal filling. The periapical status was evaluated using the periapical index (PAI). RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: Average PAI scores decreased from 3.43 at start to 2.21 at 12 months for Grossman's sealer and from 3.40 to 2.26 for the silicon-based material. No significant difference between the groups at start or any of the follow ups was seen. The 3-month control was adequate in establishing significant healing in both groups. The improvement of the periapical condition continued at the 12-month examination.     

Endodontic treatment of teeth with apical periodontitis: single vs. multivisit treatment.

This study was performed to evaluate radiographic healing of teeth with apical periodontitis, treated in one visit or in two visits (a) with or (b) without calcium hydroxide as an intracanal disinfecting medicament. The patients were assigned one of the three treatment groups by the throwing of a die. The Periapical Index (PAI) Scoring Method was used to compare differences in periapical status from the beginning of treatment to a 52-wk follow-up evaluation. Overall, the periapical status of the treated teeth improved significantly after 52 wk (p < 0.0001). A PAI score of 1 or 2 was considered as representing a "good" periapical status while 3, 4, or 5 was a "bad" status. When base line PAI scores were controlled for, the calcium hydroxide group showed the most improvement in PAI score (3, 4, or 5 to 1 or 2), followed by the one-step group (74% vs. 64%). The teeth that were left empty between visits had clearly inferior healing results. Power statistics were conducted to determine the numbers required for significant differences between the groups, and it was shown that large experimental groups on the order of hundreds of patients would be required to show significant differences.     

牙髓血运重建治疗年轻恒牙根尖周病变的临床观察

目的 观察年轻恒牙进行牙髓血运重建术后牙根发育及根尖周病变愈合情况.方法 选取慢性根尖周炎或慢性根尖周炎急性发作的单根管年轻恒牙16例,要求牙根发育Nolla分期7～9期.行牙髓血运重建术治疗,随访观察2年,定期进行临床检查并拍摄X线片观察牙根发育及根尖周病变的愈合情况.结果 16例单根管年轻恒牙牙髓血运重建术后12例牙根继续发育.其中13例在定期复查时牙髓电活力测试结果表现为阳性;16例术后根尖周病变均完全愈合,愈合时间因病变大小而不同,平均愈合时间为4.1个月.疗效评价为成功12例,好转4例,失败0例.结论 牙髓血运重建术治疗年轻恒牙根尖周病变,取得良好的治疗效果.     

Periodontal healing in teeth with periapical lesions

Abstract The purpose of the present investigation was to compare clinical periodontal healing in periodontally involved teeth with and without pulpal pathosis. The investigation was conducted as a retrospective study on a consecutive referral population. The periapical conditions in endodontically involved single-rooted teeth from a selected patient sample were evaluated and correlated with their periodontal healing pattern. Multiple regression analysis of the registered variables showed that initial mean pocket depth and time elapsed after treatment significantly influenced change in pocket-depth. Non-surgical treatment of periodontal pockets exceeding 2.5 mm in teeth with horizontal marginal defects, over the observation period, showed significantly reduced mean pocket depth reduction in teeth with periapical pathology compared to teeth without periapical pathology. It was, furthermore, evident that proximal restorations, abutments for fixed bridges and root fillings with and without dowels did not significantly influence pocket depth reduction in the present material. It was concluded, based on the present results, that a root-canal infection, evident as a periapical radiolucency, if left untreated may in the long term perspective result in retarded or impaired periodontal healing following periodontal therapy and, consequently, should be given appropriate consideration when coordinating endodontic therapy and periodontal treatment.     

Resolution of maxillary sinus mucositis after endodontic treatment of maxillary teeth with apical periodontitis: a cone-beam computed tomography pilot study

Introduction

Apical periodontitis (AP) is an inflammatory response that can affect the maxillary sinus. This study characterized maxillary sinus mucositis adjacent to teeth with AP and assessed its resolution after endodontic treatment.

Methods

Thirty maxillary sinuses in subjects (n = 29) who had AP associated with maxillary posterior teeth were imaged with cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT). When mucositis was detected, its resolution was assessed with CBCT scanning 3 months after treatment, and periapical healing was assessed using the periapical index (PAI) after 6 months.

Results

Excluding 5 sinuses obscured by sinusitis, mucositis was detected in 14 of 25 sinuses (56%). Nonsignificant inverse association was observed between the mucosal lining thickness and the distance from the sinus to root apices with AP. Four noncompliant subjects were discontinued. Three months after treatment, mucositis was fully resolved in 3 of 10 subjects (30%), partially resolved in 3 of 10 subjects (30%), unchanged in 3 of 10 subjects (30%), and worsened in 1 subject (10%). Six months after treatment, 6 of 10 subjects (60%) had reduced PAI scores classified as healed or healing. The subject with expanded mucositis at 3 months was not healing at 6 months.

Conclusions

Within the limited sample of this pilot study, CBCT imaging revealed a lower-than-expected prevalence of mucositis adjacent to teeth with AP. Fully resolved mucositis was not common 3 months after endodontic treatment, suggesting that in specific cases it might linger beyond 3 months after the elimination of the endodontic infection. Because of the low statistical power, the association between the resolution of mucositis and periapical healing could not be explored.     

Outcome of one-visit and two-visit endodontic treatment of necrotic teeth with apical periodontitis: a randomized controlled trial with one-year evaluation

The choice of one-visit versus two-visit root canal therapy for necrotic teeth with apical periodontitis is a source of current debate. The primary objective of this randomized controlled clinical trial was to compare radiographic evidence of periapical healing after root canal therapy completed in one visit or two visits with an interim calcium hydroxide/chlorhexidine paste dressing. Ninety-seven patients met the inclusion criteria and consented to participate in this study. Patients were randomly assigned to either the one-visit or two-visit group, and root canal therapy was performed with a standardized protocol. Patients in the two-visit group received an intracanal dressing of calcium hydroxide/chlorhexidine paste. Sixty-three patients, 33 in the one-visit group and 30 in the two-visit group, were evaluated at 12 months. The primary outcome measure was change in apical bone density by using the periapical index (PAI). Secondary outcome measures were proportion of teeth healed or improved in each group. Both groups exhibited equally favorable periapical healing at 12 months, with no statistically significant differences between groups.     

Comparison between PAI and quantitative digital radiographic assessment of apical healing after endodontic treatment.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare both subjective (Periapical Index, PAI) and objective (densitometric) radiographic evaluation of healing after endodontic treatment for apical periodontitis. STUDY DESIGN: Standardized radiographs of 103 teeth taken at baseline (immediately after endodontic treatment) and at 1, 4, 12, 26, and 52 weeks were evaluated. Consensus PAI scores obtained from 7 calibrated observers served as "true scores." Densitometric estimates of periapical status were obtained from digitized radiographs as the ratio of mean gray value of an area of radiolucency (AR) to an adjacent and similar-sized normal (N) area (AR/N). The selected regions of interest on baseline images were automatically superimposed on postoperative images. All estimates of change were measured with respect to baseline. The subtraction estimate was expressed as AR(S)-N(S). Linear regression was used to analyze longitudinal changes against baseline and to assess the relationship of PAI and AR/N and of change in PAI with respect to baseline and AR(S)-N(S). RESULTS: Five hundred fifty-six PAI scores were generated, with 547 AR/N values and 444 subtraction estimates. PAI, AR/N, and AR(S)-N(S) demonstrated statistical significance for change (P < or = .05) starting at 12 weeks. PAI was significantly correlated with AR/N (P < .0001), as was CHPAI with AR(S)-N(S) (P < .024). CONCLUSION: The PAI and 2 densitometric estimates (AR/N and AR(S)-N(S)) detected healing of apical periodontitis at 12 weeks after treatment. No difference could be observed among the methods.     

CBCT在牙根尖周炎源性上颌窦黏膜炎根管治疗疗效评价中的应用

目的　通过CBCT检查患根尖周炎的上颌后牙,探讨牙根尖周源性上颌窦黏膜炎的特点及根管治疗后黏膜及骨质的改变。方法: 对25例患上颌后牙根尖周炎患者上颌窦进行CBCT扫描重建,确诊为黏膜炎后,根管治疗3个月后CBCT扫描明确黏膜炎消退程度,6个月后扫描通过根尖周指数评估根尖骨质愈合情况。结果: 剔除2例上颌窦炎,14例上颌窦表现为黏膜炎（61％),根管治疗3个月后,黏膜炎完全消退5例（35.7％）;部分消退6例（42.9％）;3例无明显改变（21.4％）。6个月后,3颗牙齿愈合（21.4％）,4颗牙齿好转（28.6％）,7颗牙齿未愈合（50％）。结论:上颌后牙根尖周炎易引发上颌窦黏膜炎,根管治疗是该疾病有效的治疗方法,CBCT影像能精确反映根管治疗前后上颌窦黏膜炎消退及骨质愈合情况,具有重要的临床参考价值。     

根管治疗慢性根尖周炎5年预后及影响因素分析

目的:探讨慢性根尖周炎经根管治疗后的牙生存率、拔除原因、根尖愈合率及预后影响因素.方法:回顾性队列研究纳入由同一名医师完成根管治疗的102例根尖周炎患者.主要预测变量为根管治疗难度系数(difficulty assessment of root canal therapy,DARCT),即根据牙根长度、牙根弯曲度、根管...     

Influence of Hemostatic Agents in the Prognosis of Periapical Surgery: A Randomized Study of Epinephrine versus Aluminum Chloride

Introduction

Several variables have been associated with a better prognosis of periapical surgery. The aim of this study was to evaluate the influence of 2 hemostatic agents on the prognosis of periapical surgery at 12 months.

Replacement of teeth exhibiting periapical pathology by immediate implants: a prospective, controlled clinical trial

OBJECTIVES: The aim of the present study was to test whether or not immediate implantation leads to more biological complications, when performed at extraction sockets of teeth exhibiting periapical pathology compared with teeth not exhibiting periapical pathology. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In 17 consecutively admitted patients, immediate implant placement was planned in order to replace single teeth exhibiting periapical pathology (test group). These teeth demonstrated pain, periapical radiolucency, fistula, suppuration or a combination of these findings. Another 17 consecutively admitted patients in need of single tooth replacement in the absence of periapical pathology served as the control group. Implant placement and accompanying bone regeneration were performed according to standard clinical procedures. Implants were loaded after a healing period of 3 months. Clinical and radiographical parameters were assessed at the time of implant placement (baseline) and at 12 months thereafter. RESULTS: Out of the 34 patients, four test and one control patient had to be withdrawn from the study due to the inability to obtain primary implant stability. The residual 29 implants revealed a survival rate of 100% 1 year after placement. Clinical and radiographical differences between 12 months and baseline comparing test and control groups showed no statistical significances for any of the parameters assessed. Within test and control groups there was a statistically significant loss of vertical bone height at the adjacent teeth (mesial test=0.4+/-0.6 mm, control=0.4+/-0.5 mm; distal test=0.3+/-0.2 mm, control=0.7+/-0.8 mm) as well as at the implant site (mesial test=1.9+/-1.4 mm, control=1.8+/-1.1 mm; distal test=1.7+/-1.4 mm, control=1.6+/-1.1 mm) and of buccal keratinized mucosa (test=-2.2+/-1.2 mm; control=-1.3+/-1.6 mm) between baseline and 12 months. During the first 13 weeks of healing, two sites of the test and one site of the control group showed signs of infection, which required intervention. Neither the incident of early exit nor of signs of infection was statistically significantly different between the test and the control group (Mann-Whitney U test). CONCLUSION: It is concluded that for those implants where primary stability was achieved, the immediate implant placement performed at extraction sockets exhibiting periapical pathology did not lead to an increased rate of complications and rendered an equally favorable type of tissue integration of the implants in both groups. Implant placement into such sites can, therefore, be successfully performed.     

Radiological assessment of periapical status using the periapical index: comparison of periapical radiography and digital panoramic radiography

AIM: To compare the use of periapical radiographs and digital panoramic images displayed on monitor and glossy paper in the assessment of the periapical status of the teeth using the periapical index (PAI). METHODOLOGY: A total of 86 subjects were examined. All participants underwent a full-mouth radiographic survey (14 periapical radiographs) and a panoramic radiography. The periapical status, using the PAI score, of all appraised teeth was assessed. RESULTS: Periapical radiographs allowed the assessment of the periapical status of 87% of teeth using the PAI. On the contrary, digital radiography had a significantly reduced potential to allow assessment of the periapical status (P<0.01). Only 57.6% and 34.1% of teeth could be appraised using digital panoramic images displayed on monitor and glossy paper respectively (P<0.01). The total percentage of teeth with periapical pathosis was five fold higher when assessed with digital panoramic images displayed on glossy paper compared with periapical radiographs (P<0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Teeth were best viewed on periapical radiographs except maxillary second and third molars, which were better viewed in orthopantomograms. Orthopantomograms on screen were scorable more often than when on printed images. Apical periodontitis was scored more often on paper than on screen, and more often on screen than in periapical radiographs.     

Effect of QMix as final irrigation protocol on periapical healing after single-visit root canal treatment: A randomised controlled clinical trial

The aim of this study was to evaluate radiographic periapical repair after endodontic treatment using QMix or NaOCl irrigation in single-rooted teeth with apical periodontitis. In this randomised clinical trial, 60 patients were selected and randomised into two groups (n = 30). After instrumentation of root canals, QMix or NaOCl was used as a final irrigation and the canals obturated with gutta-percha and AH Plus sealer. All the participants were recalled after 12 months and 15 patients were lost to the study so 45 patients were evaluated radiographically according to periapical index (PAI) scores. A significant decrease was seen in PAI scores after 1 year in all patients (p < 0.001). In the QMix and NaOCl group, absence or reduction of radiolucency was observed in 23 of 25 teeth (92%) and 20 of 20 teeth (100%), respectively. There was no significant difference between two groups according to the decrease in PAI score (p = 0.508). Root canal treatments with or without QMix irrigation contributed equally to periapical healing.     

The use of mineral trioxide aggregate in one-visit apexification treatment: a prospective study

AIM: To assess the outcome of apexification using mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA). METHODOLOGY: Fifty-seven teeth with open apices on 50 patients referred for root canal treatment received an apexification procedure in one appointment with MTA by the same operator. Patients were recalled at 6 months, 12 months and every year thereafter. Blind to the treatment record, two examiners assessed the pre-treatment, post-treatment and control radiographs of the study patients in a dark room using a magnifier. Each apex visible on the radiographs was scored with the periapical index (PAI), and the size of the apical lesion was measured. The presence of an apical bridge was also noted. Kappa-Cohen test was used for examiners calibration. The paired t-test was used for statistical analysis of apical healing. RESULTS: Forty-three cases were included with at least 12 months follow-up. When considering the PAI score and the decrease in size of the apical lesion, healing occurred in 81% of cases. CONCLUSION: Apexification in one step using an apical plug of MTA can be considered a predictable treatment, and may be an alternative to the use of calcium hydroxide.     

Clinical efficacy of treatment procedures in endodontic infection control and one year follow-up of periapical healing

The objective was to evaluate the clinical efficacy of chemomechanical preparation of the root canals with sodium hypochlorite and interappointment medication with calcium hydroxide in the control of root canal infection and healing of periapical lesions. Fifty teeth diagnosed with chronic apical periodontitis were randomly allocated to one of three treatments: Single visit (SV group, n = 20), calcium hydroxide for one week (CH group n = 18), or leaving the canal empty but sealed for one week (EC group, n = 12). Microbiological samples were taken to monitor the infection during treatment. Periapical healing was controlled radiographically following the change in the periapical index at 52 wk and analyzed using one-way ANOVA. All cases showed microbiological growth in the beginning of the treatment. After mechanical preparation and irrigation with sodium hypochlorite in the first appointment, 20 to 33% of the cases showed growth. At the second appointment 33% of the cases in the CH group revealed bacteria, whereas the EC group showed remarkably more culture positive cases (67%). Sodium hypochlorite was effective also at the second appointment and only two teeth remained culture positive. Only minor differences in periapical healing were observed between the treatment groups. However, bacterial growth at the second appointment had a significant negative impact on healing of the periapical lesion (p < 0.01). The present study indicates good clinical efficacy of sodium hypochlorite irrigation in the control of root canal infection. Calcium hydroxide dressing between the appointments did not show the expected effect in disinfection the root canal system and treatment outcome, indicating the need to develop more efficient inter-appointment dressings.     

Clinical and radiographic assessment of various predictors for healing outcome 1 year after periapical surgery

This clinical study prospectively evaluated the influence of various predictors on healing outcome 1 year after periapical surgery. The study cohort included 194 teeth in an equal number of patients. Three teeth were lost for the follow-up (1.5% drop-out rate). Clinical and radiographic measures were used to determine the healing outcome. For statistical analysis, results were dichotomized (healed versus nonhealed). The overall success rate was 83.8% (healed cases). The only individual predictors to prove significant for the outcome were pain at initial examination (p=0.030) and other clinical signs or symptoms at initial examination (p=0.042), meaning that such teeth had lower healing rates 1 year after periapical surgery compared with teeth without such signs or symptoms. Logistic regression revealed that pain at initial examination (odds ratio=2.59, confidence interval=1.2-5.6, p=0.04) was the only predictor reaching significance. Several predictors almost reached statistical significance: lesion size (p=0.06), retrofilling material (p=0.06), and postoperative healing course (p=0.06).     

Comparison of the sealing ability of mineral trioxide aggregate and Portland cement used as root-end filling materials

Inadequate apical seal is the major cause of surgical endodontic failure. The root-end filling material used should prevent egress of potential contaminants into periapical tissue. The purpose of this study was to compare the sealing ability of four root-end filling materials: white mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA), gray MTA, white Portland cement (PC) and gray PC by dye leakage test. Ninety-six human single-rooted teeth were instrumented, and obturated with gutta-percha. After resecting the apex, an apical cavity was prepared. The teeth were randomly divided into four experimental groups (A: white MTA, B: gray MTA, C: white PC and D: gray PC; n = 20) and two control groups (positive and negative control groups; n = 8). Root-end cavities in the experimental groups were filled with the experimental materials. The teeth were exposed to Indian ink for 72 hours. The extent of dye penetration was measured with a stereomicroscope at 16× magnification. The negative controls showed no dye penetration and dye penetration was seen in the entire root-end cavity of positive controls. However, there was no statistically significant difference among the four experimental groups (P > 0.05). All retrograde filling materials tested in this study showed the same microleakage in vitro. Given the low cost and apparently similar sealing ability of PC, PC could be considered as a substitute for MTA as a root-end filling material.     

Histological periapical repair after obturation of infected root canals in dogs.

Histological periapical healing of infected roots obturated in one-step or with prior calcium hydroxide (Ca(OH)2) disinfection was compared. Seventy-two roots of vital dog teeth were instrumented to ISO size 45. Sixty roots were infected with dental plaque and closed. Six weeks later, apical periodontitis was radiographically confirmed in the infected roots. The teeth were divided into the following groups: group 1, one-step (n = 24)-roots were irrigated with 10 ml of saline, obturated, and permanently restored; group 2, Ca(OH)2 (n = 24)-roots were treated as in group 1, except that after saline irrigation, Ca(OH)2 dressing was placed in the canal for 1 wk before obturation; group 3, positive control (n = 12)--the roots were irrigated with saline, but the canals were not obturated; and an additional group, group 4, served as a negative control (n = 12)--these teeth that were not infected with plaque were aseptically obturated. The dogs were sacrificed after 6 months. The roots and surrounding apical tissues were prepared and histologically examined by two independent evaluators blinded to the treatment groups. A two-way ANOVA test demonstrated that the four treatment groups were significantly different from one another. The positive control showed the most inflammation, the negative control the least, and the Ca(OH)2 group had significantly less inflammation than the one-step group (p < 0.05). It is concluded that Ca(OH)2 disinfection before obturation of infected root canals results in significantly less periapical inflammation than obturation alone.     

塑化治疗后牙慢性根尖周病10年后临床观察

通过临床观察和X线检查37例40颗患有慢性根尖周炎塑化治疗10年后的后牙,并利用根尖周指数(PAI)评定术前、术后X线片以评估塑化治疗后牙慢性根尖周病的远期疗效,结果表明:塑化治疗慢性根尖周炎10年后治愈率为72.5％,成功率为82.5％;根尖病变的纤维性愈合也是治疗成功的一种表现,不必重新做牙髓治疗;塑化治疗和根管治疗方法治疗后牙慢性根尖周炎远期疗效结果相似,统计学比较无显著性差异。本研究结果说明塑化治疗法治疗慢性根尖周炎远期疗效满意。用根尖周指数量化评定X线片结果值得临床推广使用。