Treatment of early stage squamous-cell carcinoma of the glottic larynx: endoscopic surgery or cricohyoidoepiglottopexy versus radiotherapy

BACKGROUND: Both surgery and radiotherapy are recognized treatments of T1-T2 squamous cell carcinoma of the larynx. We retrospectively analyze and compare the oncological outcome of patients treated in a single institution, either by endoscopic surgery or partial supracricoid laryngectomy versus radiation therapy. METHODS: The medical records of 156 patients treated between 1983 and 1996 with either surgery (n = 75) or radiotherapy (n = 81) were reviewed. Male to female ratio, median age, and T-stage distribution were comparable. RESULTS: With a median follow-up time of 59 months, the 5-year cause-specific survival rate of 93% was identical for both groups. The actuarial incidence of metachronous second primaries was 7% at 5 years. Local control at 5 years remained 84% after surgery and 77% after radiotherapy. Anterior commissure infiltration was shown to represent a negative predictive factor of local control for radiotherapy (p =.01). Salvage treatment brought ultimate local control to 96% of patients after surgery and 94% after radiation therapy with long-term laryngeal preservation rate altered significantly (p =.05) in the group of patients who received radiotherapy (90.1% vs 97.4%). CONCLUSION: The treatment of laryngeal cancer is always a compromise between oncological efficiency and preservation of function. Our data suggest that, assuming proper selection of patients, radiation therapy and surgery yield similar local control and survival rates. The functional disadvantages after surgery are moderate and clearly counterbalanced by a significant decrease in long-term laryngeal preservation rate after radiotherapeutic treatment.     

Elective treatment of the neck in squamous cell carcinoma of the larynx: clinical experience

BACKGROUND: In head and neck cancer, the best prophylactic treatment for the N0 neck is a subject of debate. Some authors propose lateral selective lymph node dissection (levels II-IV) on the basis of the probability of finding occult metastases in those lymph nodes. A more extensive procedure including Vth level is considered unnecessary because of the low incidence of metastases in the posterior triangle. METHODS: We retrospectively evaluated 346 N0 patients affected by laryngeal carcinoma and consecutively treated at the Department of Otorhinolaryngology of the Ospedale di Circolo, Varese, Italy. The patients underwent elective selective neck dissection (levels II-V) for a total of 602 dissected heminecks. RESULT: Seventy heminecks (11.6%) were pN+, and in 10 of 70 cases (14.3%) level V was involved; in 5 of 10 metastases were isolated. CONCLUSION: Our retrospective study confirms the probabilistic criteria of the incidence of occult metastasis by level in laryngeal cancer. On the basis of our data Vth level nodes, although very rarely, 10 of 604 (1.6%), are involved with laryngeal cancer. Our approach to routinely dissect Vth level nodes is discussed.     

Carcinoma of the skin with perineural invasion

PURPOSE: To evaluate the outcome and patterns of relapse in patients treated for skin carcinoma of the head and neck with either microscopic or clinical perineural invasion. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Radiotherapy alone or combined with surgery was used to treat 135 patients with microscopic or clinical evidence of perineural invasion of skin carcinoma. All patients had at least 2 years of follow-up. RESULTS: The 5-year local control rates without salvage therapy were 87% with microscopic perineural invasion and 55% with clinical perineural invasion. Overall, 88% of the local failures occurred in patients with positive margins. Almost half of the recurrences in patients with microscopic perineural invasion were limited to the first-echelon regional nodes. However, only 1 of 11 patients with basal cell carcinoma with microscopic perineural invasion had a nodal failure. Ninety percent of recurrences in patients with clinical perineural invasion occurred at the primary site. Cranial nerve deficits rarely improved after successful treatment of the primary disease. Radiographic abnormalities remained stable 30% of the time when patients had clinical evidence of progressive disease. CONCLUSIONS: Radiotherapy in patients with skin cancer with clinical perineural invasion should include treatment of the first-echelon regional lymphatics. The risk of regional node involvement is also relatively high for patients with squamous cell carcinoma with microscopic perineural invasion. In patients with clinical perineural invasion, the poor local control rates with conventional radiotherapy suggest a need for dose escalation with or without concomitant chemotherapy.     

Surgical treatment of cervical node metastases from squamous carcinoma of the upper aerodigestive tract: evaluation of the evidence for modifications of neck dissection

BACKGROUND: This review article examines the role of the different types of neck dissection in the treatment of squamous carcinoma metastases to the cervical nodes. METHODS: A critical evaluation of the literature on the pathologic basis, oncologic effectiveness, and functional outcome of neck dissection. RESULTS: Pathologic data show preferential metastasis to different lymph node levels, in N0- and N+-staged disease, depending on the primary tumor site. Comparative studies on control of regional metastases suggest that modified radical is no less effective than radical neck dissection, but there is insufficient data to draw firm conclusions on the role of selective neck dissection. Selective and modified radical dissections result in less shoulder disability than radical neck dissection. CONCLUSIONS: Modified radical neck dissection is supported by pathologic and clinical evidence in N1- and 2-staged disease. There may be a role for selective dissection, but there is a need for more information on oncologic outcome. Prospective multicenter systematic data collection on the outcome of neck dissection is a pragmatic alternative to a trial.     

The distribution of lymph node metastases in supraglottic squamous cell carcinoma: therapeutic implications

BACKGROUND: The treatment of the neck in cancer of the upper aerodigestive tract is still a matter of controversy, even though nowadays there is a trend in the literature toward elective surgery in the N0 neck when the probability of occult lymph node metastasis is greater than 20%. In the elective setup, every effort is made for preservation of uninvolved nonlymphatic structures in positive neck. The aim of this study is to analyze in a large cohort of patients treated for supraglottic carcinoma the prevalence of lymph node metastases and their distribution through various neck levels to redefine our policy of neck treatment. METHODS: A retrospective review of 402 consecutive patients, who underwent surgery in the Department of Otolaryngology of the University of Brescia (Italy) for supraglottic squamous cell carcinoma in a 14-year period, has been performed. The prevalence of neck metastases was assessed by pT category and site (marginal vs vestibular) of the primary tumor. The side(s) of neck disease was related to the side of the primary tumor, whether lateral or central. The distribution of involved lymph nodes through the neck levels was determined. RESULTS: Overall lymph node metastases accounted for 40%; their prevalence rate increased with pT category from 10% to 57% (p =.0001). Occult metastases were found in 26% of N0 patients from 0% in pT1 to 40% in pT4 (p =.02). There was no difference in metastases rate between marginal vs vestibular, and central vs lateral neoplasms, whereas bilateral metastases were more frequent in central tumors (20% vs 5%; p <.0001). Level IV was involved only in association with level II and/or level III. Levels I and V were rarely involved when overt metastases were present and never by occult metastases. CONCLUSIONS: Elective lateral neck dissection (levels II-IV) is recommended in T2-T4 N0 supraglottic cancers; clearance of both sides of the neck is indicated whenever the lesion is not strictly lateral. We still perform a selective neck dissection including levels II-V whenever there is clinical, radiologic, or intraoperative evidence of metastases at any level.     

Carcinoma of the supraglottic larynx: a basis for comparing the results of radiotherapy and surgery

An analysis of 129 patients with 131 squamous cell carcinomas of the supraglottic larynx treated between October 1964 and April 1987 with radiotherapy alone or radiotherapy followed by neck dissection is presented. All patients had a minimum 2-year follow-up. Patients were excluded from analysis of disease control at the primary site and/or neck if they died within 2 years of treatment with the site(s) continuously disease-free. Local control rates with radiotherapy and ultimate local control rates, including patients successfully salvaged after a local recurrence, were as follows: T1, 13 of 13 and 13 of 13; T2, 34 of 42 (81%) and 37 of 42 (88%); T3, 25 of 41 (61%) and 34 of 41 (83%); and T4, 3 of 9 and 6 of 9. There was no significant difference in local control rates when comparing patients who were anatomically suitable for a supraglottic laryngectomy with those who would have required a total laryngectomy. Local control rates were slightly diminished in patients with T2-T3 lesions who had impaired or absent vocal cord mobility. The overall rates of ultimate local control with voice preservation for the entire series of 129 patients were as follows: T1, 100%; T2, 87%; T3, 69%; and T4, 57%. Cause-specific survival rates at 5 years by stage were I, 2 of 2; II, 10 of 12 (83%); III, 9 of 13 (69%); IVA, 4 of 6; and IVB, 7 of 22 (32%). The incidence of severe complications was 4 of 115 (3%) for T1-T3 lesions and 4 of 14 (29%) for T4 lesions.     

Role of planned neck dissection for advanced metastatic disease in tongue base or tonsil squamous cell carcinoma treated with radiotherapy

OBJECTIVE: At the conclusion of this article, the reader should be able to discuss the need for planned neck dissection for advanced cervical diseases in the tongue base and tonsil cancer after treatment with radiotherapy. BACKGROUND: In the past 5 years, we have treated patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the tonsil and tongue base with radiotherapy as the primary therapeutic modality. A planned complete neck dissection was performed on all patients with N2 or greater cervical disease regardless of response to radiotherapy. Composite resection was performed when there was persistent disease at the primary site. Although the "radiation-first" therapeutic approach for tongue base and tonsil cancer is widely accepted, the planned neck dissection for neck metastases remans controversial. The objective of the study was to determine the validity of planned neck dissection after radiotherapy for N2 disease. METHODS: Medical records of patients with primary squamous cell carcinoma of the tongue base and tonsil with neck metastasis staged N2 or greater were reviewed. Between 1994 and 1999, 36 such patients were treated with curative radiation therapy. Response was assessed 6 to 8 weeks after completion of treatment with clinical examination and CT imaging. All patients underwent planned neck dissection. We reviewed the clinical and radiographic response of neck disease to radiotherapy as it correlated with the histopathologic findings. RESULTS: Of the 36 patients, 17 had clinical and CT evidence of persistent disease. In this group, 65% had pathologically confirmed diseases at surgery. Of the 9 patients with no evidence of disease on clinical examination, negative biopsy at the primary site, and a negative CT scan, 33% (three of nine) still had residual disease in the neck dissection specimen. CONCLUSIONS: Positive findings on clinical examination and CT can predict the presence of malignancy after radiation therapy. However, a negative CT and clinical examination are limited in predicting a complete response. These data lend support to the role of planned neck dissection after radiotherapy of N2 neck disease.     

Definitive radiotherapy in the management of chemodectomas arising in the temporal bone, carotid body, and glomus vagale

PURPOSE: To evaluate the results of treatment for 71 patients with 80 chemodectomas of the temporal bone, carotid body, or glomus vagale who were treated with radiation therapy (RT) alone (72 tumors in 71 patients) or subtotal resection and RT (8 tumors) at the University of Florida between 1968 and 1998. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Sixty-six lesions were previously untreated, whereas 14 had undergone prior treatment (surgery, 11 lesions; RT, 1 lesion; or both, 2 lesions) and were treated for locally recurrent disease. All three patients who received prior RT had been treated at other institutions. Patients had minimum follow-up times as follows: 2 years, 66 patients (93%); 5 years, 53 patients (75%); 10 years, 37 patients (52%); 15 years, 29 patients (41%); 20 years, 18 patients (25%); 25 years, 12 patients (17%); and 30 years, 4 patients (6%). RESULTS: There were five local recurrences at 2.6 years, 4.6 years, 5.3 years, 8.3 years, and 18.8 years, respectively. Four were in glomus jugulare tumors and one was a carotid body tumor. Two of the four patients with glomus jugulare failures were salvaged, one with stereotactic radiosurgery and one with surgery and postoperative RT at another institution. Two of the five recurrences had been treated previously at other institutions with RT and/or surgery. Treatment for a third recurrence was discontinued, against medical advice, before receiving the prescribed dose. There were, therefore, only 2 failures in 65 previously untreated lesions receiving the prescribed course of RT. The overall crude local control rate for all 80 lesions was 94%, with an ultimate local control rate of 96% after salvage treatment. The incidence of treatment-related complications was low. CONCLUSIONS: Irradiation offers a high probability of tumor control with relatively minimal risks for patients with chemodectomas of the temporal bone and neck. There were no severe treatment complications.     

Radiotherapy alone or combined with surgery for adenoid cystic carcinoma of the head and neck

BACKGROUND: The purpose of this study was to analyze the results of radiotherapy (RT) alone or combined with surgery for adenoid cystic carcinoma. METHODS: Between September 1966 and November 2001, 101 previously untreated patients were treated with curative intent with RT alone or combined with surgery. Follow-up ranged from 0.4 to 30.6 years (median, 6.6 years). All living patients had follow-up for at least 1 year. RESULTS: The 5- and 10-year rates of local control were as follows: RT alone, 56% and 43%; surgery and RT, 94% and 91%; and overall, 77% and 69%. Multivariate analysis of local control revealed that T stage (p=.0101) and treatment group (p=.0008) significantly influenced this endpoint. The 5- and 10-year rates of distant metastases-free survival were 80% and 73%. The 5- and 10-year absolute survival rates were as follows: RT alone, 57% and 42%; surgery and RT, 77% and 55%; and overall, 68% and 49%. Multivariate analysis of absolute survival revealed that T stage (p=.0043) and clinical nerve invasion (p=.0011) significantly influenced this endpoint. The 5- and 10-year cause-specific survival rates were as follows: RT alone, 65% and 48%; surgery and RT, 81% and 71%; and overall, 74% and 61%. Multivariate analysis revealed that T stage (p=.0008) and clinical nerve invasion (p=.0005) significantly influenced cause-specific survival. CONCLUSIONS: The optimal treatment for patients with adenoid cystic carcinoma is surgery and adjuvant RT. A significant proportion of patients with incompletely resectable disease are cured after RT alone. Improvements in locoregional control are offset, in part, by the relatively high incidence of distant metastases.     

Organ preservation with radiotherapy for T1-T2 carcinoma of the pyriform sinus

PURPOSE: To report long-term results using radiotherapy with or without a planned neck dissection for T1-T2 carcinoma of the pyriform sinus. METHODS: An analysis of 101 patients treated at the University of Florida with RT with or without a planned neck dissection for organ preservation. RESULTS: The 5-year local control rates after RT were 90% for T1 cancers and 80% for T2 lesions. The only parameter that significantly influenced local control in univariate analyses was apex involvement for T1 tumors. Multivariate analysis revealed no parameter that significantly affected local control. Cause-specific survival rates at 5 years were as follows: stage I-II, 96%; stage III, 62%; stage IVA, 49%; and stage IVB, 33%. The absolute survival rates were as follows: stage I, 57%; stage II, 61%; stage III, 41%; stage IVA, 29%; and stage IVB, 25%. Moderate to severe long-term complications developed in 12% of patients. CONCLUSIONS: RT alone or combined with a planned neck dissection resulted in local control with larynx preservation in a high proportion of patients. The chance of cure is comparable to that observed after conservation surgery, and the risk of major complications is lower. The addition of adjuvant chemotherapy is unlikely to improve the probability of organ preservation, but might improve locoregional control for patients with advanced nodal disease.     

Radiotherapy for carcinoma in situ of the true vocal cords

PURPOSE: To report long-term rates of tumor control after radiotherapy (RT) for carcinoma in situ (CIS) of the true vocal cords (TVC). A comprehensive literature review was performed, and outcomes with other modalities of treatment for CIS of the TVC were compared. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Thirty patients with CIS of the TVC were treated between July 1967 and May 1998 with curative intent using megavoltage RT. Most patients (28 of 30) were treated with cobalt-60 through small (usually 5 x 5 cm) fields. Median RT dose was 56.25 Gy (range, 56.25-75 Gy; mean dose, 59.15 Gy) at 2.25 Gy per fraction. One patient was treated for a synchronous head and neck primary malignancy with large fields to a total dose of 75 Gy at 1.8 Gy per fraction. Approximately two thirds of the patients (19 of 30) were referred for RT because of recurrence after at least one stripping procedure. RESULTS: With a mean follow-up of 7.1 years (range, 2-17 years), the 5-year rates of local control, local control with larynx preservation, and ultimate local control (including salvage surgery) were the following: 88%, 88%, and 100%, respectively. Invasive squamous cell carcinoma developed in three (10%) of the patients. Time to failure was 14 months, 34 months, and 48 months, respectively. All three patients were surgically salvaged with a total laryngectomy. Cause-specific survival at 5 years was 100%. There were no late complications. CONCLUSIONS: RT to approximately 60 Gy at 2.25 Gy per fraction using small (5 x 5 cm) fields produces excellent results with CIS of the TVC.     

Cordectomy by CO2 laser or radiotherapy for small T1a glottic carcinomas: costs, local control, survival, quality of life, and voice quality

BACKGROUND: The clinical results of radiotherapy and endoscopic cordectomy for T1a glottic carcinoma are reported to be similar, but costs of both treatments may differ. Therefore, we retrospectively evaluated the costs, voice quality, quality of life, and clinical results of both treatments. METHODS: Costs and effects from the first visit up to 2 years of follow-up were calculated, based on chart data of 35 and 54 patients who were treated with curative intent for T1a glottic carcinoma from 1995 to 1999 with radiotherapy and endoscopic cordectomy, respectively. Voice quality and quality of life were evaluated by means of patient questionnaires. RESULTS: Total costs (in Euros) of radiotherapy and CO(2)-laser cordectomy were 8322 euro and 4434 euro, respectively, including the costs of treating possible recurrences. The effects of both treatments were equal, including voice quality and quality of life. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that endoscopic cordectomy is an efficient alternative for radiotherapy for these patients.