Medical faculty as humanistic physicians and teachers: the perceptions of students at innovative and traditional medical schools

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: The training of caring physicians represents an important goal of medical education. Little is known however, on whether medical faculty constitute good role models for teaching humanistic skills to medical students. In this study, we examined to what extent medical students at innovative and traditional schools perceived their teachers as humanistic physicians and teachers. We also explored whether pre-clinical and clinical students shared the same perceptions. METHODS: A mail survey was conducted in Canada of all second-year students and senior clerks at one innovative medical school (problem-based learning (PBL), patient-centred, community-oriented) and three traditional medical schools. Students were asked to what extent they agreed or disagreed that the majority of their teachers behaved as humanistic physicians and teachers; 10 statements were used. Overall, 65% of the 1039 students returned the questionnaire. RESULTS: Over 25% of second-year students and 40% of senior clerks did not agree that their teachers behaved as humanistic caregivers with patients or were good role models in teaching the doctor-patient relationship. More than half of second-year students and senior clerks did not agree that their teachers valued human contact with them or were supportive of students who had difficulties. There were few differences in the way medical students at innovative and traditional schools perceived their teachers' humanistic qualities. At the pre-clinical level however, there were more students from the innovative school than from the traditional schools (around 60% vs. 40%, P < 0.005) who agreed that their teachers valued human contact with them and were supportive of students. CONCLUSION: Our results indicate that the PBL curriculum fosters better teacher-student relationships during the pre-clinical years. They also suggest that an unacceptably large number of medical students are taught by physicians who seem to lack compassion and caring in their interactions with patients. This study questions the adequacy of medical faculty as role models for the acquisition of caring competence by medical students.     

Providing early clinical experience in primary care

Undergraduate courses in British medical schools are changing following recommendations from the General Medical Council. Increasing emphasis has been placed on teaching in the community. Nottingham Medical School has pioneered the teaching of basic clinical skills in primary care during the pre-clinical course to help produce an integrated curriculum. This qualitative study evaluated the first two years of the new early clinical experience course at Nottingham by using interviews with 19 students and their GP tutors. Students claimed to have gained confidence in talking to patients, their understanding of the role of the doctor and the importance of the doctor-patient relationship. Students were less confident about examining patients and some reported having had little opportunity to practice examination skills. Half the students thought that the early clinical visits had helped them to understand and be more motivated to learn their basic medical sciences course. The newly recruited GP teachers were highly motivated, very positive about the early clinical teaching and all wanted to continue to teach the pre-clinical students. Difficulties in providing the course included communication with students and staff, organization of student travel and variation in the quality of teaching. However, the Nottingham early clinical experience course has shown that basic clinical skills can be successfully taught to pre-clinical students in primary care.     

Teaching clinical skills to pre-clinical medical students: integration with basic science learning

Clinical skills are usually learned by pre-clinical students in a manner divorced from their basic science foundations. The value of previously learned basic sciences thus fails to be re-enforced. A clinical skills course was developed for an experimental curriculum of medical students in their first year. It was organized and taught by a team of basic and clinical scientists and emphasized the basic pathophysiological principles underlying clinical skills. Sessions were supported by related basic science audiovisual resources and a series of clinical problems with questions obliging the student to reason through basic-science mechanisms. Over the span of the course, Students' interest shifted dramatically from a focus on proficiency in motor skills to an understanding of basic pathophysiological mechanisms underlying observed phenomena. Compared to conventional curriculum students, those in the experimental curriculum failed to show a diminution in perceived value of basic sciences in their future career and, on cumulative, cognitive examinations, scored equally in basic science, but significantly higher in clinical science subjects. A clinical skills course integrating both teachers and concepts from basic, as well as clinical sciences can improve student attitudes toward the basic sciences.     

Variation in medical students'' approaches to diagnosis: a basis for initiating conceptual change among teachers and students

OBJECTIVES: This study examines Finnish medical students' approaches to diagnosis and investigates further how medical teachers can use information about variation in their students' approaches to diagnosis to foster teaching in medical school. DESIGN: The medical students responded to the Conceptions and Experiences of Diagnosis Inventory (CEDI). SETTING: Faculty of Medicine, University of Helsinki. SUBJECTS: Ninety medical students in their clinical years and eight clinical teachers from the same Faculty of Medicine. RESULTS: The 11 subscales of the CEDI formed two contrasting factors: the first reflecting variation in 'non-virtuously' labelled, and the second in 'virtuously' labelled, aspects of diagnosis. CONCLUSIONS: Cluster analyses revealed subgroup characteristics of students' diagnostic processes that are of potential benefit to both students and teachers. Teacher interviews indicated that, for students, the CEDI may act as a self-assessment tool to help develop their diagnostic and metacognitive skills. For teachers, the CEDI was seen to offer important information about their students' conceptions of diagnosis and diagnostic skills.     

Attitudes of medical students to medical ethics in their curriculum

One hundred and one students at different levels of their medical education were surveyed as to their views about inclusion of medical ethics in their curriculum. The results showed that 88% of the students feel that medical ethics has a place in their curriculum, and 84% rated medical ethics to be of High to Critical Importance to good medical care. They tended to read infrequently about medical ethics, which they would like integrated at all levels of the curriculum, particularly the clinical years. The more senior students were less sensitive to ethical issues. The students mentioned only dramatic issues in their accounts of encounters with cases involving ethical issues. It is felt that a wide gap is left in the education of these students if medical ethics is not included in a positive way in their curriculum.     

Medical students' perceptions of their learning about the doctor-patient relationship: a qualitative study

Objective To describe and discuss Year 5 medical students' perceptions of their own learning about the doctor?patient relationship. Methods We carried out a qualitative study of semi‐structured interviews with 16 Year 5 medical students using 3‐way analysis at the School of Medicine, Federal University of São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil. Results For experiences at the pre‐clinical stage, the subcategories were: positive aspects of the medical psychology course; great distance between theory and reality, and strong desire for clinical practice. For experiences at the clinical stage, the subcategories were: demand for opportunities to discuss the doctor?patient relationship; teachers as either role models or anti‐models; clinical situations favourable for developing empathic relationships, and clinical situations unfavourable for developing empathic relationships. For views about future experiences, the subcategories were: apprehension about ethical behaviour; anxiety about handling patients' psychosocial characteristics, and fear of professional ethics cases or legal action. Discussion To compensate for the lack of practical activities during the pre‐clinical stage, students search for extracurricular activities that often overload them. Because teachers function as professional role models, their attitudes towards patients have great importance. Students fear not being able to maintain their empathic capacity in the future because of work‐related issues. Knowledge of the psychological aspects of the doctor?patient relationship helps students to comprehend their experiences. Gradual contact between student and medical practice from the beginning of the course is advised. It should be followed by interdisciplinary discussions that deal with the technical aspects of cases and the doctor?patient relationship.     

Smoking patterns at a British and at an American medical school

Cigarette smoking among medical students at the University of Bristol (Bristol) and the New York University School of Medicine (NYU) was investigated and differences were subjected to statistical analysis.
At Bristol 34–6% and at NYU 14–3% of respondents classified themselves as regular smokers. Among students in the pre-clinical phase of training the difference between the number of smokers at Bristol and at NYU was not significant. At both schools more clinical students smoked than preclinical students, but only at Bristol did the difference between the number of smokers in the two grade levels reach statistical significance.
There are fewer heavy smokers (consumers of more than twenty cigarettes per day) among the pre-clinical students at Bristol than among preclinicals at NYU. In the clinical year, however, there were slightly (insignificantly) fewer heavy smokers at NYU while there were significantly more at Bristol.
Smokers at NYU acquired the habit at a somewhat earlier age than the smokers at Bristol.
The majority of students at both schools indicated that medical education had not influenced their decision to smoke or not to smoke.
Most smokers—more among the clinical than the pre-clinical students—reported that they were displeased with their habit and that they wished to give it up. Somewhat fewer smokers at Bristol gave that response than students at NYU.
Factors contributing, at least in part, to the differences between smoking patterns observed may be variables of age and years of education.
The widely held but untested belief that precept and example by medical school teachers may be a potent force for modifying the smoking behaviour of health professionals, is in need of research.     

Student discussion groups on doctor-patient relationships: a critical assessment

Regular discussion groups for all students were introduced at a new clinical medical school to enable students to discuss freely their responses to patients. The main aim was to prevent the alleged dehumanizing effect of medical education. The groups were monitored by attendance records, questionnaires and tape-recordings.
In fact, the majority of students stopped attending so that only two of the five groups survived longer than 6 months. Despite improvements in organization and styles of conducting the groups, a similar fall in attendance occurred in the next year's intake. Paradoxically, in most meetings there was a lively and apparently beneficial discussion on the students' reactions to their contacts with patients, so it was difficult to explain the overall drop in attendance.
It was concluded that, while organizational details and inappropriate styles of conducting the groups were partly responsible, the main problem was the apparent conflict in attitudes between the students medical teachers and their group conductors (who were mainly psychiatrists), i.e. between the concepts of modern technological medicine and those of psycho-social medicine. This induced a conflict of motivation in the students, who naturally need to identify with their teachers, which most of them resolved by avoiding the groups. It is suggested that more effective integration between general medical teachers and the organizers of such groups is needed, and that group conductors should include general practitioners and clinical supervisors as well as psychiatrists.     

Interns'' evaluation of their preparation for general practice: a comparison between the University of Tromsø and the University of Bergen

A total of 168 interns who have graduated from the Medical Schools of Bergen and Tromsø were asked about various aspects of the medical curriculum. In Bergen the curriculum has a traditional structure with a pre-clinical and a clinical part, but in Tromsø the pre-clinical and clinical subjects are integrated. In addition, the students in Tromsø spend long periods in municipal hospitals and in the primary health care service. We were interested in how the interns from the two universities evaluated their respective curricula and how prepared they felt for their current work. There was a response rate of 86% to the questionnaire. The results showed that the interns from Tromsø are more satisfied with their education and feel more confident in their practical skills than the interns from Bergen. They are also more motivated for future work in general practice. In our opinion the main reason for these results is the difference in curricula in the two medical schools. Other possible reasons are also discussed.     

The prematurity stereotype in Israeli health care providers

Research on the prematurity stereotype was extended by randomly assigning 158 Israeli medical and nursing students to view full-term infants labelled either 'full-term' (FTL) or 'premature' (PL). One-half of the students were additionally assigned to a goal condition in which they were informed that their judgements would be evaluated for their accuracy. Overall, students were found to show strong stereotyping effects, rating PL infants more negatively than FTL infants when asked questions about their expectations for the infants' growth and development as well as their expectations for how mothers of these infants might behave during a medically related contact concerning her infant. However, the content of the stereotype varied across type of health care provider when general perceptions of the infants' status characteristics were elicited, with pre-clinical medical students showing greater levels of stereotyping than upper level students. Only limited effects involving the goal condition were found. When communicating with mothers, upper level students reported that they would respond more time-expediently and pre-clinical students reported that they would show more empathy. The findings emphasize the important role stereotypes play in interpersonal processes, including caregiver-patient interactions. Implications for medical education and practice are discussed.     

Patients as teachers: a qualitative study of patients'' views on their role in a community-based undergraduate project

OBJECTIVES: Patients have been used in clinical medical education for many years with, traditionally, a relatively passive role. Following the General Medical Council recommendations for curricular change and the development of more community-based teaching, 'ordinary patients' in the community are increasingly being partnered with undergraduate students for particular projects. Very little research has been undertaken on patients' perceptions of this role. DESIGN: Semi-structured interviews were carried out with 20 people to explore the views of patients taking part in a community-based undergraduate medical student project (the 'patient study') at Newcastle Medical School about their role as teachers of medical students, what they felt they had gained from participating, any problems or concerns and suggestions for change or improvement. SETTING: Newcastle Medical School, UK. SUBJECTS: Second-year medical students. RESULTS: Two major themes emerged. First, patients saw themselves in active roles as teachers: as experts in their medical condition; as exemplars of their condition; and as facilitators of the development of students' professional skills and attitudes. Secondly, patients felt they had benefited from participation, through talking about their problems; learning more about themselves; the satisfaction of helping; and from receiving gifts. In addition, a number of other issues were identified including interpersonal dynamics, gender and ethnic differences, inadequate briefing of participants and whether such community-based patient involvement might, in some situations, be felt to be exploitative. CONCLUSIONS: The study has shown that patients see themselves clearly as having specific contributions to make to medical students' education and training. This has implications for the further development of community-based teaching.     

An assessment of priority and educational value in a medical curriculum

A randomly selected group of teachers, students, first-year graduates (junior doctors in the first year of postgraduate training after their final medical school examination), general practitioners and specialists responded to a postal questionnaire designed to assess their views on the priorities in medical curriculum and the educational value attributed to its content. Comparisons were made among the five participating groups and the outcome of the assessment was compared with the existing curriculum.     

Computer awareness among medical students: a survey

The objective of the study was to assess the attitude of Edinburgh University medical students towards computers and to evaluate the effects of changes in the curriculum and intercalated BSc towards computer knowledge. During March to November 1995 a questionnaire was distributed in lectures, seminars and tutorials to all Edinburgh University medical students. Overall, 65% of students returned the questionnaire, divided equally between both genders. Only 2% of students had not used a computer in the previous year. The most frequent application used was E-mail and the most frequent site, the Greenfield suite micro lab, within the medical school. The average score for self-perceived computer knowledge on a scale of 0–10 was 4.19. This score was significantly higher for the students who own a computer and who have an intercalated BSc honours degree as well as the pre-clinical students compared to the clinical students. There is also a strong correlation between computer use and doing a second year special option module. With regards to attitude towards computers, 86% of students agreed that computer skills will be beneficial to them in their future career and 62% of all students wanted a structured course in computer use as part of the MB ChB course. There has been a general increase in computer literacy amongst the medical students in Edinburgh. This is specially so for the pre-clinical students who have had the brunt of the changes in the curriculum. The tendency for both the lower knowledge and use by the clinical students can, in part, be due to the accessibility of computers to these students.     

Evaluation of lectures on medical ethics through students' drawings

Summary. The authors have encouraged medical students to express their impressions of and reactions to lectures on medical ethics by drawing illustrations on their attendance cards. This gives students a sense of participation in the lecture, and also it provides teachers with useful feedback concerning students' understanding of and interest in the subject.     

Attitudes of medical students to the teaching of medical ethics

Summary. The teaching of ethics to medical students has recently become a topic of much importance to all concerned with medical education. However, those most involved, the students themselves, have been consulted very little. This paper reports the views of a sample of medical students at Oxford University on what ethics teaching they receive, of how much value they consider it to be and what form of teaching they would like to see included in their curriculum.     

The influence of gender and specialty on reporting of abusive and discriminatory behaviour by medical students, residents and physician teachers

INTRODUCTION: The perception of whether a given behaviour is abusive differs between students and teachers. We speculated that attitudes towards reporting abusive and discriminatory behaviour may vary by specialty as well as by gender. METHODS: We report a cross-sectional survey of incoming medical students, medical students, residents, and teaching faculty at one Canadian medical school. The discrimination and abuse questions were in the following domains: (i) psychological abuse, (ii) sexual abuse, (iii) physical abuse, (iv) gender discrimination, (v) racial discrimination, (vi) disability discrimination, (vii) derogatory remarks regarding homosexuality. The frequency of self-reported witnessed or experienced abusive and discriminatory behaviour was compared by gender, specialty choice and stage of training. RESULTS: The response rates varied by respondent group: 44/56 (79%) of incoming medical students, 177/218 (81%) of medical students, 134/206 (65%) of residents and 215/554 (38%) of physician teachers. The frequency of these behaviours was perceived to be low by both male and female respondents. Abusive and discriminatory behaviour by physician teachers was noted more frequently by residents (P < 0.001) and physician teachers themselves (P < 0.001) compared with incoming medical students. As well, in general, women noted more abusive and discriminatory behaviour by all teachers, compared with men (P < 0. 003). Each response to the abuse/discrimination questions was also modelled as the independent variable using stepwise multiple regression. The area of specialization (surgical versus non-surgical) altered the reporting of abusive and discriminatory behaviour by women. CONCLUSION: We conclude that female surgical residents and medical students undergo a process of acclimatization to the patriarchal surgical culture. As female surgeons become physician teachers they revert to a culture more similar to that of their female non-surgical colleagues. Although a process of deidealization occurs in medical training, these attitudes are not necessarily retained throughout the practising lifetime of physicians as they regain autonomy and more personal control.     

Medical students' perceptions of racial diversity and gender equality

OBJECTIVES: To assess attitudes of medical students toward issues of racial diversity and gender equality and to ascertain changes in these attitudes during the pre-clinical curriculum. METHODS: Attitudes toward multiculturalism and gender equality were assessed using a 43-item questionnaire. The survey was completed by incoming Year 1 students in 2000 and 2001, and was completed again in 2002 by the students who had entered in 2000. Mean scores were analysed at baseline by gender, ethnic group and political affiliation using analysis of variance. The paired scores of the first and follow-up surveys of the 2000 entering class were compared using paired t-tests. RESULTS: Upon entry into medical school, women, minority group students and Democrats scored significantly higher on the cultural sensitivity scale than their comparison groups. No significant changes were seen overall in the matched data. However, minority groups showed a significant increase in scores, while Republicans and white men experienced a non-significant decline. In addition, incoming students judged cultural competency education to be important. The perceived need to increase the numbers of minority group doctors varied by gender, ethnic group and political affiliation. CONCLUSIONS: Among incoming medical students, perceptions of racial diversity and gender equality vary along ethnic, gender and political lines. Additionally, pre-clinical education was associated with increased cultural sensitivity by minority group students, but not by others. These findings demonstrate the continuing need for diversity in medical school and for medical students to recognise and address their personal and group biases.     

Does awarding a medical degree with honours act as a motivator or demotivator to student learning?

OBJECTIVES: To look at students' support for, and perception of, the effects of awarding a degree with honours. DESIGN: Questionnaires were given to all medical students from those entering year 1 to those graduating, i.e. six cohorts. We performed quantitative and qualitative analyses on the responses. SETTING: University of Manchester. SUBJECTS: Medical students. RESULTS: Of 1618 students, 1290 responded (80%). The majority of students thought that we should have a system to award a degree with honours (968/1290[75%]), but this support was related to a number of variables. When asked to rate their agreement to a series of statements, students from the later years were more likely to disagree that an honours system is a helpful motivator for students to learn (Kruskal-Wallis; P < 0.0001). In contrast, those students with 'points' counting towards an honours degree were more likely to agree that there should be an honours system (chi2[1]=18.7, P < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: Most students supported the honours system. However, there was less support from students in later years. The qualitative analysis showed a mixture of views. There was a relationship between the probability of being awarding a degree with honours and support of the system.     

Faculty opinions about a revised pre-clinical curriculum

INTRODUCTION: Medical schools having innovative curricula have been encouraged to ascertain the levels of satisfaction of faculty members with the curriculum. Faculty at schools that employ problem-based learning (PBL) have been shown to have positive perceptions, but not all schools are in a position to adopt PBL on a large scale. This study sought to determine faculty members' opinions about a new curriculum that is less ambitious than one utilizing true PBL. CONTEXT AND SETTING: Since 1997, the University of Otago Medical School (Dunedin, New Zealand) has had an integrated, modular pre-clinical curriculum that emphasizes clinical relevance. It has proved popular with students. This study focused on faculty members' impressions. METHODS: We surveyed faculty members' opinions with a questionnaire identical to one used in studies at PBL schools. Faculty compared the students and their own levels of satisfaction in the old and new curricula on 7 to 10 items. The overall response rate was 85.4% (152 of 178). RESULTS: Perceptions of the new curriculum were positive among teachers who taught during the pre-clinical years and those who taught the students only after they reached the clinical years. Results for individual questions were in the same direction and generally similar in magnitude to those reported on identical items for PBL. CONCLUSION: We conclude that a hybrid curriculum that is more acceptable to many traditional teachers and students than is PBL has almost as great a positive effect on faculty members' perceptions of students' abilities and of the curriculum as does PBL.     

Medical Students' attitudes toward basic sciences: influence of a primary care curriculum

The emerging popularity of family medicine and primary care among medical students with an attendant pressure for clinical relevance in pre-clinical coursework and early clinical exposure has raised questions in the minds of many academicians about the Students' perceived value of basic sciences in such an educational environment.
A comparison was made of attitudes toward the basic sciences between students in two, concurrent, pre-clinical medical school curricula at the University of New Mexico School of Medicine. The conventional curriculum offers a teacher-centered, 2-year curriculum of basic sciences taught predominantly by basic scientists in a lecture format. The experimental curriculum entitled the Primary Care Curriculum (PCC), offers a student-centered, 2-year curriculum in which pertinent basic and clinical science learning is derived primarily from common, primary care, patient problems, discussed in small group tutorials. There are no formal lectures. Half the tutors are primary care clinicians, half basic scientists.
Attitude scales were administered in two successive classes of students in both curricula at the beginning of the first and second terms of the first year. Increased cynicism toward the curriculum and its relevance to future practice was observed among conventional, but not among PCC students. This finding lends support to the hypothesis that modification in educational methods in general and relevant, primary care experience in particular can favourably influence Students' attitudes toward basic sciences.