Molecular pathology of inherited erythrocyte membrane disorders: hereditary spherocytosis and elliptocytosis.

Hereditary spherocytosis and elliptocytosis are common genetic defects of the red blood cell membrane skeleton. In recent years rapid advances have been made in the knowledge of the protein structure and assembly of the cytoskeleton. Thanks to the wide use of protein analysis methods several alterations have been discovered in functionally important domains of the different cytoskeletal proteins in these diseases. The cloning of cDNA for the majority of the cytoskeletal proteins allows us to begin elucidating some of these defects at the DNA level. This paper will review the effects of recent advances upon: cytoskeleton structure and assembly; molecular pathology of spherocytosis, elliptocytosis and pyropoikilocytosis.     

Increased erythrocyte adhesion in mice and humans with hereditary spherocytosis and hereditary elliptocytosis

Mice with disruptions of the red blood cell (RBC) cytoskeleton provide severe hemolytic anemia models in which to study multiorgan thrombosis and infarction. The incidence of cerebral infarction ranges from 70% to 100% in mice with alpha-spectrin deficiency. To determine whether mutant RBCs abnormally bind adhesive vascular components, we measured adhesion of mouse and human RBCs to immobilized human thrombospondin (TSP) and laminin (LM) under controlled flow conditions. Mutant RBCs had at least 10-fold higher adhesion to TSP compared with normal RBCs (P <.006). Mutant relative to unaffected RBC adhesion to LM was significantly (P <.01) increased as well. Treatment of RBCs with the anionic polysaccharide dextran sulfate inhibited mutant RBC adhesion to TSP (P <.001). Treatment of RBCs with antibodies to CD47 or the CD47-binding TSP peptide 4N1K did not inhibit TSP adhesion of RBCs. Previously, we have shown that infarcts in alpha-spectrin-deficient sph/sph mice become histologically evident beginning at 6 weeks of age. TSP adhesion of RBCs from 3- to 4- and 6- to 8-week-old sph/sph mice was significantly higher than RBCs from adult mice (> 12 weeks old; P <.005). While the mechanism of infarction in these mice is unknown, we speculate that changes in RBC adhesive characteristics contribute to this pathology.     

A variant of erythrocyte membrane skeletal protein band 4.1 associated with hereditary elliptocytosis

A family comprising three patients (a mother and two children) with mild hereditary elliptocytosis was studied. Each patient had prominent elliptocytosis, reduced red cell deformability, and normal erythrocyte thermal sensitivity. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) of the erythrocyte membranes in each patient showed decreased levels of band 4.1 (approximately half of the normal value) and the presence of an additional band migrating below protein band 4.2. This additional band was shown to derive from protein 4.1. Comparative partial proteolytic mapping of protein 4.1 and the additional band revealed a number of common peptides. Enzyme-linked immunoelectrotransfer blots of the patients' erythrocyte membranes using a monoclonal antibody to protein 4.1 revealed that, in addition to protein 4.1, two other bands below protein 4.2 were stained; one of these bands migrated in the same position as the additional band detected in the Coomassie Blue-stained gels. Immunoblotting of the patients' whole cells using the antibody to protein 4.1 revealed that this altered band 4.1 occurred as such in the intact red cell. SDS-PAGE of protein 4.1 purified from one patient showed the presence of two lower molecular weight bands below protein 4.1; the lower band migrated in the same position as the additional band found on SDS-PAGE of the patients' erythrocyte membranes. The patient's purified protein 4.1 displayed a decrease of about 40% in the binding activity with crude spectrin extracted from normal controls. Spectrin-spectrin interactions were normal in the three patients. The additional band present in the patients' red cell membranes probably represents a proteolytic degradation product. This alteration, present both in whole cells and isolated membranes, might affect the intact cells in vivo. We suggest that the patients' erythrocyte membrane instability may be related to the presence of an abnormal protein 4.1 whose modulatory influence on the spectrin-actin interaction in the skeleton is defective.     

Molecular determinants of clinical expression of hereditary elliptocytosis and pyropoikilocytosis

The clinical severity of common hereditary elliptocytosis (HE) is highly variable, ranging from an asymptomatic carrier state to a severe hemolytic anemia. To elucidate the molecular basis of this variable clinical expression, we evaluated 56 subjects from 24 HE kindred, who carry alpha spectrin mutants characterized by a spectrin dimer (SpD) self-association defect related to a structural abnormality of the alpha I domain of spectrin. Twenty-nine subjects had common HE, 13 subjects have a closely related disorder, hereditary pyropoikilocytosis (HPP), and 14 are asymptomatic carriers. We compared the severity of hemolysis with the following biochemical parameters: (a) spectrin heterodimer self-association, as manifested by the percentage of SpD in the 4 degrees C low ionic strength spectrin extract; (b) spectrin structure, as examined by limited tryptic digestion of spectrin; and (c) spectrin content of the RBC membrane. Our analysis indicates that the severity of hemolysis may be correlated with quantitative differences in the percentage of SpD in the 4 degrees C spectrin extract, as well as the total spectrin content of the membrane. Thus, HPP subjects, who have the most severe hemolytic anemia, have the highest percentage of SpD as well as a decreased spectrin content. HE subjects and asymptomatic carriers, respectively, have a lower percentage of SpD and a normal spectrin content. Factors influencing these two determinants include functional differences between the individual spectrin mutants, the relative amounts of mutant spectrin present in the cells, the stability of mutant spectrin, and the possibility of a superimposed genetic defect involving spectrin synthesis.     

Elliptical erythrocyte membrane skeletons and heat-sensitive spectrin in hereditary elliptocytosis.

Erythrocyte membranes (ghosts) and membrane skeletons (submembranous reticula of spectrin, actin, and protein 4.1 prepared by extracting ghosts with Triton X-100) from 15 patients with hereditary elliptocytosis (HE) were elliptical, which indicates that the primary defect responsible for the abnormal shape of these cells resides in the skeleton. The protein composition of HE skeletons was normal, but in three kindreds purified spectrin heterodimer from 7/7 HE patients was heat sensitive and denatured at 48.0 +/- 0.1 degrees C instead of 49.0 +/- 0.3 degrees C (P less than 0.0005). Heat sensitivity was detected by precipitation and, in the spectrin from one patient, by changes in circular dichroism. In one other kindred spectrin dimer from 3/3 patients denatured at the normal temperature. In two of the three kindreds with heat-sensitive spectrin, intact erythrocytes exhibited budding and fragmentation at the temperature at which spectrin denatured. In the third kindred spectrin was heat sensitive, but erythrocytes were not. The symptoms in the latter kindred were clinically more severe (hemolytic HE with spherocytosis) than in the other three (mild HE). We conclude that defects in the erythrocyte membrane skeleton may be a common feature of HE. As judged by heat denaturation of erythrocytes and purified spectrin dimer, three phenotypically distinct forms of HE exist, two of which are characterized by defective, heat-sensitive spectrin. It remains to be determined whether the molecular defect in spectrin responsible for heat sensitivity is the primary genetic defect responsible for HE.     

Hereditary spherocytosis,elliptocytosis, and other red cell membrane disorders

Hereditary spherocytosis and elliptocytosis are the two most common inherited red cell membrane disorders resulting from mutations in genes encoding various red cell membrane and skeletal proteins. Red cell membrane, a composite structure composed of lipid bilayer linked to spectrin-based membrane skeleton is responsible for the unique features of flexibility and mechanical stability of the cell. Defects in various proteins involved in linking the lipid bilayer to membrane skeleton result in loss in membrane cohesion leading to surface area loss and hereditary spherocytosis while defects in proteins involved in lateral interactions of the spectrin-based skeleton lead to decreased mechanical stability, membrane fragmentation and hereditary elliptocytosis. The disease severity is primarily dependent on the extent of membrane surface area loss. Both these diseases can be readily diagnosed by various laboratory approaches that include red blood cell cytology, flow cytometry, ektacytometry, electrophoresis of the red cell membrane proteins, and mutational analysis of gene encoding red cell membrane proteins.     

Presence of cytosolic peroxiredoxin 2 in the erythrocyte membrane of patients with hereditary spherocytosis

We studied 82 Portuguese individuals, 57 with hereditary spherocytosis (HS) and 25 unaffected controls. We performed standardized diagnosis tests, including electrophoretic membrane protein analysis to identify and quantify protein deficiencies underlying HS. Membrane bound hemoglobin (MBH) and band 3 profiles were determined as oxidative stress and aging markers. A protein of about 22 kDa, present in 21 of 57 HS patients, but not in controls, was identified as peroxiredoxin 2 (Prx2), by mass-spectroscopy and by immunoblotting. Human erythrocyte Prx2 is a peroxiredoxin with thiol-specific antioxidant activity. The presence of Prx2 in erythrocyte membranes was linked to higher levels of oxidative stress, as reflected by significantly increased MBH in those HS patients. No relation with HS clinical severity was observed and Prx2 was detected in all types of membrane protein abnormalities. Prx2 membrane linkage is associated with a higher oxidative stress susceptibility of HS erythrocytes.     

Altered erythrocyte membrane protein phosphorylation in an unusual case of hereditary spherocytosis.

Membrane protein phosphorylation was examined in several members from a family with an unusual form of hereditary sperocytosis. After incubation of membrane ghosts with (gamma-32 P) ATP, the phosphorylation of spectrin component II was diminished both in the absence of cAMP. In the presence of this nucleotide, the phosphorylation of components IV5 and IV8 was also decreased. Along with a previously reported alteration of a membrane neutral phosphatase in this family, these abnormalities remove the present condition from the usual form of hereditary spherocytosis.     

Hereditary elliptocytosis, spherocytosis and related disorders: consequences of a deficiency or a mutation of membrane skeletal proteins

The membrane skeleton, a protein lattice that laminates the internal side of the red cell membrane, contains four major proteins: spectrin, actin, protein 4.1 and ankyrin. By mass, the most abundant of these proteins is spectrin, a fibre-like protein composed of two chains, alpha and beta, which are twisted along each other into a heterodimer. At their head region, spectrin heterodimers are assembled into tetramers. At their distal end, these tetramers are interconnected into a two dimensional network by their linkage to oligomers of actin. This interaction is greatly strengthened by protein 4.1. The skeleton is attached to the membrane by ankyrin, a protein that connects the spectrin beta chain to the major transmembrane protein band 3, the anion channel protein. Additional attachment sites are those of protein 4.1 with several glycoproteins, namely glycophorin A and C, as well as direct interactions between spectrin, protein 4.1 and the negatively charged lipids of the inner membrane lipid bilayer. Hereditary spherocytosis, elliptocytosis and pyropoikilocytosis represent a group of disorders that are due to deficiency or dysfunction of one of the membrane skeletal proteins (Fig. 1). Known deficiency states include that of spectrin, ankyrin and protein 4.1. Severe spectrin and ankyrin deficiencies (with decrease in spectrin and ankyrin contents to about 50% of the normal amount) are both rare disorders associated with severe autosomal recessive hereditary spherocytosis. On the other hand, mild spectrin deficiency is found in the majority of patients with autosomal dominant spherocytosis in which the degree of spectrin deficiency correlates with the clinical severity of the disease. Protein 4.1 deficiency, in contrast, is associated with hereditary elliptocytosis, which in certain populations constitutes about 20% of all such patients. Known skeletal protein dysfunctions include mutants of both alpha and beta spectrin that involve the spectrin heterodimer self-association site. These are clinically expressed as hereditary elliptocytosis (HE) and a closely related disorder, hereditary pyropoikilocytosis (HPP). At the level of protein function, this defect can be detected by analysis of the content of spectrin dimers and tetramers in 0 degrees C low ionic strength extracts of red cell membranes. Their structural identification is accomplished by limited proteolytic digestion of spectrin followed by two-dimensional tryptic peptide mapping.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Identification of the molecular defect in the erythrocyte membrane skeleton of some kindreds with hereditary spherocytosis

We have localized the molecular alteration in the membrane skeleton of two of four kindreds with hereditary spherocytosis (HS) to an alteration in the spectrin-protein-4.1 interaction due to a defective spectrin molecule. The defective spectrin-protein-4.1 interaction in these kindreds (referred to as type I HS) leads to a weakened spectrin- protein-4.1-actin ternary complex, which in turn may lead to the friable membrane skeleton and suggested membrane instability related to this disorder. Type I HS spectrin binds approximately 63% as much protein-4.1 as normal spectrin (with equal affinity). This defect does not correlate with splenic function or erythrocyte age in the circulation. However, the approximately 37% reduction in binding of protein-4.1 to HS spectrin approaches the theoretical value of 50% expected in this autosomal dominant disorder. All other type I membrane skeletal interactions (spectrin-syndein, spectrin heterodimer- heterodimer, syndein-band-3) were found to be normal. It would appear therefore that the defective HS spectrin-protein-4.1 interaction in type I hereditary spherocytosis may be the primary molecular defect rather than a secondary phenomena.     

Analysis of erythrocyte membrane proteins in patients with hereditary spherocytosis and other types of haemolytic anaemia

ABSTRACT

Objectives: In order to investigate the pathophysiology of erythrocyte membrane proteins, 10 patients (6 pre- and 4 post-splenectomy) with hereditary spherocytosis (HS) and other patients with haemolytic anaemia were examined.

Methods: The membrane proteins were analysed by biochemical and mass spectrometry.

Results: Reductions in the extracellular membrane of band 3 protein by eosin-5'-maleimide (EMA) binding test were greater in patients with pre-splenectomy HS than in patients with post-splenectomy HS, other types of haemolytic anaemia, and controls. Compared to patients with haemolytic anaemia and healthy controls, the band 3 protein of patients with HS pre- or post-splenectomy was more easily decomposed with N-glycosidase F and by mass spectrometry interactions with degraded low-molecular-weight spectrin and ankyrin. The resulting fragments were observed more frequently in pre-splenectomy than post-splenectomy HS. Haemoglobin-derived peptides were present in patients with haemoglobinopathy (Hb Evans, Hb Sabine) but not in those with haemolytic anaemia and healthy controls.

Conclusion: Haemolysis in patients with HS occurred because the fragile proteins in erythrocytes (band 3, spectrin, and ankyrin) collapsed due to compression during blood circulation in the spleen. Further, haemolysis in patients with haemoglobinopathy occurred owing to membrane damage due to combined spectrin, band 3 with denatured haemoglobin in the vessel during blood circulation.     

Viscoelastic properties of red cell membrane in hereditary elliptocytosis

The viscoelastic properties of the RBC membrane are in part determined by a submembrane network of proteins consisting of spectrin alpha beta heterodimers (SpD) assembled head-to-head to form spectrin tetramers (SpT) and spectrin oligomers (SpO). SpT, in turn, are connected into a two-dimensional network by the linkage of distal ends of SpT to protein 4.1 and actin. With the micropipette technique, we determined the membrane viscoelastic properties of RBCs from a subset of patients with hereditary elliptocytosis (HE); these RBCs exhibit membrane skeletal instability, defective SpD self-association, and a molecular defect in the alpha I domain of spectrin, which is involved in the SpD-SpD contact (HE SpD alpha-SpD). The elastic modulus and viscosity of the membrane were significantly higher for the HE RBCs than for the control cells. Incubation of normal cells with N-ethyl-maleimide (NEM) produced a similar defective SpD self-association and a significant increase in the viscoelastic parameters of the membrane. The data provide evidence that the mode of assembly of membrane spectrin in the cytoskeletal protein network plays a major role in determining the rheologic behavior of erythrocyte membrane.     

Erythrocyte cellular and membrane deformability in hereditary spherocytosis

In order to determine whether the relative rigidity of the hereditary spherocytosis (HS) red cell is due to membrane rididity or merely to an altered surface/volume ratio, we investigated the deformability of resealed red cell membranes from patients with HS. Whereas the osmotic fragility of intact red cells of HS patients showed the expected increase, the osmotic fragility of resealed HS membranes was normal, thus indicating that their surface/volume ratio was normal. Measurements with an ektacytometer showed that deformability of intact HS cells was markedly diminished, whereas deformability of resealed HS membranes was normal. These findings indicate that the HS red cell membrane is not intrinsically abnormally rigid, as has been suggested, but that the lack of deformability of the erythrocyte is primarily a function of the altered surface/volume ratio.     

Erythrocyte membrane skeleton abnormalities in hereditary spherocytosis

Erythrocyte ghosts from eight individuals with hereditary spherocytosis have been compared with respect to their protein compositions as judged by SDS gel electrophoresis, their ease of spectrin extractability, and their freeze-etch electron microscopic appearance after incubation in condition designed to promote aggregation of the intramembrane particles. Four of these HS cases were unrelated, while the other four represented two generations from a single family, including a pair of identical twins, one of whom had not undergone splenectomy when this investigation was initiated. Of the four unrelated cases, one showed no departures from normal under the conditions of this investigation, whereas the other three exhibited features which suggested a membrane skeleton lesion. In one of these there was a reduced proportion of spectrin tetramers relative to dimers in 4 degrees C extracts, while the two remaining cases exhibited abnormal intramembrane particle aggregation. The four related cases had almost identical variations from normal. Spectrin was not extractable from their ghost membranes during a mild extraction incubation which removed spectrin from normal control ghosts. However, the intramembrane particle aggregation subsequently induced in these ghosts was of a degree unobtainable in normal ghosts without such spectrin extraction. In addition the ghosts from one twin, the only one of these patients who had not undergone splenectomy at the start of this investigation, showed a reduced amount of band 4.2. However, when this patient's blood was re-tested after splenectomy, this protein was found to be at normal levels. Our results support the view that hereditary spherocytosis is not a single disease, but is rather a term used to describe a variety of different molecular lesions of the erythrocyte membrane skeleton with similar clinical manifestations.     

Absence of phosphorylation-induced gelation of erythrocyte membrane skeletons: A diagnostic tool for hereditary spherocytosis

Summary As yet there is no single test specific for the diagnosis of hereditary spherocytosis. In the search for a specific test, a method described by Pinder et al. [14] using a cAMP-independent protein kinase extracted from normal erythrocyte membranes was used. Membrane skeletons were prepared from erythrocyte ghosts by extraction with a non-ionic detergent, i.e., Triton X-100. Upon phosphorylation with c-AMP-independent protein kinase the suspension of normal membrane skeletons set to a gelatinous mass. Membrane skeletons from patients with spherocytosis failed to show this phenomenon. In order to clarify whether this phenomenological difference can be used as a diagnostic tool for hereditary spherocytosis, a semiquantitative method of observing the gelation process was used under definite shear stress conditions. We investigated 33 patients with different hemolytic anemias (spherocytosis, hereditary elliptocytosis, hereditary stomatocytosis, homozygous -thalassemia and enzymopenic hemolytic anemias). With the exception of spherocytosis, all preparations of membrane skeletons showed gelation after 30–50 min. Spherocytosis membrane skeletons did not show a significant gelation even after 12 h of incubation. Thus, the failing gelation is specific for the diagnosis of hereditary spherocytosis. The gelation assay might be a valuable method for defining patients with hemolytic anemias due to erythrocyte membrane defects. Its molecular basis and the possible importance for the pathogenesis of spherocytosis require further investigations.Supported by Grant Eb 99/1-1 from theDeutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft     

A phenomenological difference between membrane skeletal protein complexes isolated from normal and hereditary spherocytosis erythrocytes

S ummary . Membrane skeletons may be obtained from human erythrocytes by extraction with non-ionic detergent. When treated under defined conditions with a cAMP-independent kinase preparation from normal membranes, a suspension of these membrane skeletons sets to a gelatinous mass. Membrane skeletons from the cells of hereditary spherocytosis patients fail to show this response. Those from subjects with some other haemolytic anaemias do not share the abnormality. The gelation process could be shown also to occur with normal membrane skeletons, extracted at high ionic strength, and containing essentially only the structural protein constituents, spectrin, actin, 4·1 and 4·9. It also occurred rapidly when a column-purified kinase preparation was used, so that no significant amounts of contaminating proteins were introduced. Added spectrin, 4·1 or actin in moderate amounts did not induce gelation in the presence of ATP. Cytochalasin E did not perturb the gelation process. Gelation required ATP as well as kinase, and did not occur when the non-hydrolysable analogue, AMP-PNP, was used instead. Gelation was accompanied by phosphorylation of the spectrin alone, and is thus evidently a consequence of the modification of its properties by this means. Inhibition of phosphorylation by added adenosine retarded gelation. It may be inferred that phosphorylation of spectrin generates new, probably weak, non-covalent interactions between cytoskeletal constituents that cause association of the isolated cytoskeletons. A semi-quantitative method of observing the gelation process, based on the time of incubation before the membrane skeleton suspension ceases to flow under gravity a t a low shear. is described.     

Heterogeneity of the molecular basis of hereditary pyropoikilocytosis and hereditary elliptocytosis associated with increased levels of the spectrin alpha I/74-kilodalton tryptic peptide

Hereditary pyropoikilocytosis (HPP) and hereditary elliptocytosis are closely related, congenital disorders of the red blood cell usually associated with defective spectrin self-association and abnormal limited tryptic digestion of the N-terminal of domain of spectrin. Enhanced cleavage by trypsin of spectrin from affected individuals at arginyl residue 45* and lysyl residue 48* frequently yields increased amounts of an alpha 1/74-Kd fragment at the expense of the normal alpha 1/80-Kd parent fragment. Limited tryptic digestion of three unrelated individuals with HPP showed the alpha 1/74 defect. To ascertain the molecular defect responsible for the abnormality, the structure of exon 2 of the alpha-spectrin gene was examined. Genomic DNA from the subjects was amplified by the polymerase chain reaction using primers flanking exon 2. Restriction endonuclease digestion of amplified products showed the loss of the HindIII site at codons 47 and 48 in one allele of subject 1 and abolished the AhaII site at codons 27 and 28 in one allele of subjects 2 and 3. Nucleotide sequence analysis of subcloned amplified DNA from the HPP subjects showed three novel amino acid substitutions. In subject 1 (a black individual), a single base substitution (AAG----AGG) at codon position 48 changes amino acid residue lysine to arginine. In subject 2 (a white individual), a single base substitution (CGT----AGT) at codon 28 changes arginine to serine. In subject 3 (a black individual), a different base substitution at position 28 (CGT----CTT) changes arginine to leucine. These mutations occur at positions of the alpha l domain where other mutations have also been described, indicating that the normal residues at these positions play an important role in spectrin dimer self-association and thus, in membrane stability.     

Pocked erythrocyte counts in patients with hereditary spherocytosis before and after splenectomy

The pocked (pitted or vacuolated) erythrocyte count has become increasingly utilized as a simple inexpensive test of splenic reticuloendothelial function. Values are less than 2.0% in normal subjects and 20 to 70% following splenectomy. Because scant and conflicting data are available about pocked erythrocyte measurements in hemolytic anemias other than the hemoglobinopathies, we performed pocked erythrocyte counts in 27 patients with hereditary spherocytosis. Prior to splenectomy patients often had elevated values (mean 4.9%). This unexpected observation suggests that hemolytic anemia may result in congestion of the red pulp and/or induced mild splenic reticuloendothelial blockade. As expected, but contrary to a previous report, pocked erythrocyte values following splenectomy were markedly increased (mean 54.9%).