Classification and quantification of the petrosal approach to the petroclival region

OBJECT: The petrosal approach to the petroclival region has been used by a variety of authors in various ways and the terminology has become quite confusing. A systematic assessment of the benefits and limitations of each approach is also lacking. The authors classify their approach to the middle and upper clivus, review the applications for each, and test their hypotheses on a cadaver model by using frameless stereotactic guidance. METHODS: The petrosal approach to the upper and middle clivus is divided into four increasingly morbidity-producing steps: retrolabyrinthine, transcrusal (partial labyrinthectomy), transotic, and transcochlear approaches. Four latex-injected cadaveric heads (eight sides) underwent dissection in which frameless stereotactic guidance was used. An area of exposure 10 cm superficial to a central target (working area) was calculated. The area and length of clival exposure with each subsequent dissection was also calculated. The retrolabyrinthine approach spares hearing and facial function but provides for only a small window of upper clival exposure. The view afforded by what we have called the transcrusal approach provides for up to four times this exposure. The transotic and transcochlear procedures, although producing more morbidity, add little in terms of a larger clival window. However, with each step, the surgical freedom for manipulation of instruments increases. CONCLUSIONS: The petrosal approach to the upper and middle clivus is useful but should be used judiciously, because levels of morbidity can be high. The retrolabyrinthine approach has limited utility. For tumors without bone invasion, the transcrusal approach provides a much more versatile exposure with an excellent chance of hearing and facial nerve preservation. The transotic approach provides for greater versatility in treating lesions but clival exposure is not greatly enhanced. Transcochlear exposure adds little in terms of intradural exposure and should be reserved for cases in which access to the petrous carotid artery is necessary.     

Combined petrosal approach to petroclival meningiomas

OBJECTIVE: To study the use and advantages of combining the posterior petrosal approach with the anterior petrosal approach to petroclival meningiomas. METHODS: Seven cases of petroclival meningiomas operated on via the combined petrosal approach were retrospectively analyzed. The basis on which this approach was selected was assessed, as were its benefits and risks. RESULTS: Gross total resection was achieved in five of the seven patients. No mortality or decrease in Karnofsky performance score was observed at the time of the last follow-up examination. Six of the seven patients had serviceable hearing before the operation. Only one patient lost hearing after the operation, and this hearing loss occurred in only one ear. Before the operation, six patients were House-Brackmann facial nerve function Grade I, and one patient was Grade II to III. At the last follow-up examination, facial nerve function was Grade I in five patients, Grade II in one patient, and Grade V in one patient. Tumors in all patients involved the cavernous sinus, Meckel's cave, petroclival junction, and middle clivus. All patients possessed a large posterior fossa component of tumor measuring an average of 3.6 x 3.5 x 4.2 cm. In four patients, the tumor was attached for the entire width of the clivus to the contralateral petroclival junction. Four patients displayed central brainstem compression. Four patients displayed bony changes at the petrous apex. All patients displayed total or partial encasement of the vertebrobasilar artery and its major branches. CONCLUSION: The combined petrosal approach should be considered for patients who have a large petroclival meningioma and serviceable hearing. This approach enhances petroclival exposure and the degree of tumor resection, especially in the area of the petroclival junction, middle clivus, apical petrous bone, posterior cavernous sinus, and Meckel's cave. The combined petrosal approach also allows better visualization of the contralateral side and the ventral brainstem, which facilitates safe dissection of the tumor from the brainstem, the basilar artery, and the perforators. If a patient has an early draining bridging vein to the tentorial sinus (before it reaches the transverse-sigmoid junction) or a prominent sigmoid sinus and jugular bulb, the combined petrosal approach provides significant working space.     

幕上下经岩骨乙状窦前入路切除巨大岩斜部肿瘤

目的 探讨幕上下经岩骨乙状窦前入路切除岩斜部肿瘤手术的技巧及并发症。方法 取颞枕游离骨瓣,分别于迷路前后将乳突及岩骨根部大部切除,但保留骨性半规管、耳蜗及鼓室的完整性;结扎并切断岩上窦,自乙状窦前方抵达岩斜部。结果 ４１例肿瘤包括脑膜瘤２０例,表皮样囊肿２０例,神经鞘瘤１例。手术全切肿瘤３４例,近全切除６例,大部切除１例。术后一过性失语１０例,脑水肿６例。脑干梗塞２例,第Ⅲ、Ⅵ、Ⅶ及后组颅神经损伤     

Anatomical variation of superior petrosal vein and its management during surgery for cerebellopontine angle meningiomas

No systematic study is yet available that focuses on the surgical anatomy of the superior petrosal vein and its significance during surgery for cerebellopontine angle meningiomas. The aim of the present study was to examine the variation of the superior petrosal vein via the retrosigmoid suboccipital approach in relation to the tumor attachment of cerebellopontine angle meningiomas as well as postoperative complications related to venous occlusion. Forty-three patients with cerebellopontine angle meningiomas were analyzed retrospectively. Based on the operative findings, the tumors were classified into four subtypes: the petroclival type, tentorial type, anterior petrous type, and posterior petrous type. According to a previous anatomical report, the superior petrosal veins were divided into three groups: Type I which emptied into the superior petrosal sinus above and lateral to the internal acoustic meatus, Type II which emptied between the lateral limit of the trigeminal nerve at Meckel’s cave and the medial limit of the facial nerve at the internal acoustic meatus, and Type III which emptied into the superior petrosal sinus above and medial to Meckel’s cave. In both the petroclival and anterior petrous types, the most common vein was Type III which is the ideal vein for a retrosigmoid approach. In contrast, the Type II vein which is at high risk of being sacrificed during a suprameatal approach procedure was most frequent in posterior petrous type, in which the superior petrosal vein was not largely an obstacle. Intraoperative sacrificing of veins was associated with a significantly higher rate of venous-related phenomena, while venous complications occurred even in cases where the superior petrosal vein was absent or compressed by the tumor. The variation in the superior petrosal vein appeared to differ among the tumor attachment subtypes, which could permit a satisfactory surgical exposure without dividing the superior petrosal vein. In cases where the superior petrosal vein was previously occluded, other bridging veins could correspond with implications for the crucial venous drainage system, and should thus be identified and protected whenever possible.     

Transcrusal approach to the petroclival region with hearing preservation. Technical note and illustrative cases

As a term, the "petrosal approach" to the petroclival region has a variety of meanings. The authors define a common nomenclature based on historical contributions and add new terminology to describe a technique of hearing preservation that allows for greater exposure of the petroclival region. The degree of temporal bone dissection defines five stages of operation. The authors used the second or "transcrusal" stage, in which the posterior and superior semicircular canals are sacrificed while preserving hearing, in six consecutive cases. Use of a common terminology ensures better understanding among surgeons. In the authors' hands, hearing has been successfully preserved in six patients after partial labyrinthectomy.     

The middle fossa transpetrous approach for petroclival meningiomas

Seventeen patients with petroclival meningioma were operated on through a middle fossa transpetrous approach. This approach exposes the anterior cerebellopontine angle through a middle fossa craniotomy with removal of the petrous apex medial to the cochlea and petrous carotid artery. This approach may be enlarged by transection of the superior petrosal sinus and tentorium. The surgical technique and application of the middle fossa transpetrous approach for petroclival meningiomas is presented.     

The Middle Fossa Transpetrous Approach for Petroclival Meningiomas

Seventeen patients with petroclival meningioma were operated on through a middle fossa transpetrous approach. This approach exposes the anterior cerebellopontine angle through a middle fossa craniotomy with removal of the petrous apex medial to the cochlea and petrous carotid artery. This approach may be enlarged by transection of the superior petrosal sinus and tentorium. The surgical technique and application of the middle fossa transpetrous approach for petroclival meningiomas is presented.     

岩斜区肿瘤手术入路选择的探讨

目的 探讨岩斜区肿瘤的手术入路选择。对53例岩斜区肿瘤患者的手术治疗进行分析。方法患者采用颞底经天幕入路11例,枕下乙状窦后入路12例;（颧弓或眶颧）翼点入路12例;乙状窦前入路2例;颞底、乙状窦后幕上下联合入路7例;颞下前岩骨硬膜外入路7例;扩大的前颅底硬膜外入路2例。结果32例（61％）患者肿瘤全切除,9例（17％）次全切除,12例（22％）大部切除。术后新发生颅神经功能障碍16例（30％）,死亡2例（4％）。结论枕下乙状窦后入路、颞底经天幕入路等岩斜区手术入路均可以在熟练的显微操作技术及神经导航、神经内镜下进行。主体生长于硬膜外的岩斜肿瘤适合于采用硬膜外入路手术切除。幕上下联合入路对巨大岩斜区肿瘤是理想的手术入路。     

The combined petrosal approach. Anatomical principles, surgical technique and indications

Management of large petroclival tumors requires the use of extensive surgical approaches that usually jeopardize the intrapetrous neuro-otologic structures. To confirm the interest of the combined petrosal approach in this indication, we describe the relevant anatomy and the surgical steps of this procedure. After making a periauricular skin incision and muscle elevation, an occipitotemporal bone flap is shaped. Then a retrolabyrinthine exposure is undertaken, with optimal skeletonization of the semicircular canals. Around the internal auditory canal, the retromeatal area and the petrous apex are resected. The retrosigmoid dura is opened followed by the incision of the subtemporal and posterior fossa dura along the superior petrosal sinus. The sinus is coagulated and divided. The tentorium is sectioned transversally toward its free edge behind the porus of the trochlear nerve. The combined petrosal approach is able to provide a wide multidirectional corridor toward the ventral surface of the pons, the basilary trunk and the ipislateral cranial nerves from the oculomotor to the lower cranial nerves. This study confirms that despite a significant extra time needed for proper achievement, the combined petrosal approach is a valuable conservative approach when the petroclival area, ventral brain stem and basilary trunk are targeted. This approach should be included in the panel of the transpetrous routes available by expert skull base teams.     

Postauricular, transpetrous, presigmoid approach for extensive skull base tumors in the petroclival region: the successes and the travails

Purpose  

Postauricular, transpetrous, presigmoid approach combines a supra/infratentorial exposure with partial petrosectomy to access third to the twelfth cranial nerves and extraaxial lesions situated anterolateral to brainstem. It provides a shorter working distance to large petrosal, petroclival, cerebellopontine, and cerebellomedullary cisternal lesions and their extensions to the subtemporal–infratemporal areas. This study reviews the surgical technique, corridors of extension, and complications encountered utilizing this approach for excising extensive lesions in these locations.     

Combined Pre- and Retrosigmoid Approach for Petroclival Meningiomas with the Aid of a Rotatable Head Frame: Peri-Auricular Three-Quarter Twist-Rotation Approach: Technical Note

We used the combined subtemporal presigmoid and suboccipital retrosigmoid multidirectional approach with the aid of a rotatable head frame (periauricular three-quarter twist-rotation approach) in 20 cases of petroclival meningiomas. Patients were placed in the lateral decubitus (park-bench) position. The head is twisted, rotated, and positioned 30 degrees face down in the Sugita rotatable head frame. By rotating this head frame, a 30- to 60-degree face-down position can be obtained when the suboccipital retrosigmoid route is used. Alternatively, the straight lateral or slightly brow-up position is obtained when the subtemporal presigmoid route is used. This twist-rotation approach provides multiple trajectories through the petroclival region with minimal drilling of the petrous bone, fatigue of the surgeon, and retraction of the brain.     

经岩骨乙状窦前入路显微外科治疗岩斜区肿瘤

目的 探讨岩斜区肿瘤经岩骨乙状窦前入路显微外科治疗的临床疗效。方法 回顾性研究经显微手术治疗的23例岩斜区肿瘤，对肿瘤病理类型、临床和影像学特征、手术入路、手术切除技巧及术后常见并发症的处理进行系统分析。结果 在手术显微镜下肿瘤全切除16例，近全切除4例，大部分切除3例，无手术死亡。结论 经岩骨乙状窦前入路可全切除岩斜区肿瘤。该手术入路对颞叶和小脑牵拉轻，可为岩斜区肿瘤手术切除提供良好的暴露。     

Meningovenous structures of the petroclival region: clinical importance for surgery and intravascular surgery

OBJECTIVE: The goals of this investigation were to perform a detailed analysis of petroclival microanatomic features, to investigate the course of the abducens nerve in the petroclival region, and to identify potential causes of injury to neurovascular structures when anterior transpetrosal or transvenous endovascular approaches are used to treat pathological lesions in the petroclival region. METHODS: Petroclival microanatomic features were studied bilaterally in seven cadaveric head specimens, which were injected with colored silicone before microdissection. Another cadaveric head was used for histological section analyses. RESULTS: A lateral or medial location of the abducens nerve dural entrance porus, relative to the midline, was correlated with the course and angulation of the abducens nerve in the petroclival region. The angulation of the abducens nerve was greater and the nerve was closer to the petrous ridge in the lateral type, compared with the medial type. The abducens nerve exhibited three changes in direction, which represented the angulations in the petroclival region, at the dural entrance porus, the petrous apex, and the lateral wall of the internal carotid artery. The abducens nerve was covered by the dural sleeve and the arachnoid membrane, which became attenuated between the second and third angulation points. The abducens nerve was anastomosed with the sympathetic plexus and fixed by connective tissue extensions to the lateral wall of the internal carotid artery and the medial wall of Meckel's cave at the third angulation point. There were two types of trabeculations inside the sinuses around the petroclival region (tough and delicate). CONCLUSION: The petroclival part of the abducens nerve was protected in a dural sleeve accompanied by the arachnoid membrane. Therefore, the risk of abducens nerve injury during petrous apex resection via the anterior transpetrosal approach, with the use of the transvenous route through the inferior petrosal sinus to the cavernous sinus, should be lower than expected. The presence of two anatomic variations in the course of the abducens nerve, in addition to findings regarding nerve angulation and tethering points, may explain the relationships between adjacent structures and the susceptibility to nerve injury with either surgical or endovascular approaches. Venous anatomic variations may account for previously reported cases of subarachnoid hemorrhage with the endovascular approach.     

A limited anterior petrosectomy with preoperative embolization of the inferior petrosal sinus for ventral brainstem tumor removal

BACKGROUND: The present study describes the use of a limited subtemporal extradural anterior petrosectomy with preoperative embolization of the inferior petrosal sinus for the management of tumors located behind the clivus and ventral to the brainstem. Details of the procedure and its application in five cases are presented. METHODS: This procedure consists of using the extradural route to approach the upper side of the petrosal pyramid so that it can be drilled medially, and to resect the apex to come out into the posterior fossa. This route gives a petrosectomy just medial to the horizontal segment of the petrous carotid artery in front of the cochlea. It goes around the labyrinthine mass and the internal auditory canal from above to expose the posterior fossa dura between the two petrosal sinuses. The dural opening exposes the ventral aspect of the pons from the trigeminal nerve to the origin of the abducens nerve, ventral to the facial nerve. Preoperative embolization of the inferior petrosal sinus allows its intraoperative section for a wider exposure along the lower clivus. This approach can easily be combined with an intradural approach to provide additional exposure above the trigeminal nerve. Patients who underwent this procedure had prepontine cisternal chordoma or epidermoid cyst of the petroclival region. RESULTS: One patient experienced a cranial nerve deficit as a direct result of the surgical procedure (VIth nerve palsy requiring surgery) but no other patient has had permanent neuromuscular compromise. Complications consisted of a wound infection in one case. Tumor removal was total in three cases and partial in two cases. CONCLUSION: Quite easy to master, the anterior petrosectomy with preoperative embolization of the inferior petrosal sinus is a time-conserving approach giving one of the best routes to reach the ventral brainstem while working in front of the cranial nerves and preserving hearing.     

The presigmoid retrolabyrinthine approach: Technical note

BackgroundThe retrolabyrinthine approach is classified among the posterior petrosectomies. Its goal is to achieve an enlarged mastoidectomy while sparing the intrapetrous neurotologic structures in order to offer maximal exposure of the posterior cerebellopontine angle compound.MethodsThe stages of the procedure are subsequently the skeletonization of the sigmoid sinus, wide opening of the mastoid antrum and exposure of the semicircular canals. We present herein the technique, indications and limitations of the retrolabyrinthine approach.ConclusionThe retrolabyrinthine approach is a demanding technique. Nowadays the retrolabyrinthine approach is routinely combined to additional resections of the petrous bone, so-called “combined petrosectomies”, to target the jugular foramen or the petroclival area.     

不同解剖入路显露颈静脉孔区的定量研究

目的定量研究枕下远外侧入路及耳后经颞入路对颈静脉孔区的显露程度,为临床个体化选择手术入路、保护重要结构功能提供可靠的解剖依据。方法选择经10％福尔马林固定的成人头颈湿标本各12具（24侧）,采用枕下远外侧入路及耳后经颞入路进行解剖学研究,用脑立体定向仪测定各步骤颈静脉孔区的显露面积,用游标卡尺测量斜坡和三叉神经的显露长度。结果在远外侧入路中,磨除颈静脉突、部分磨除枕髁后对颈静脉孔区显露程度显著增加;在耳后经颞入路中,迷路后入路、部分磨除迷路对颈静脉孔区的显露程度显著增加。结论磨除颈静脉突是枕下远外侧入路显露颈静脉孔的关键;迷路下入路和部分磨除迷路入路是自侧方显露颈静脉孔区的理想手术入路。     

Temporopolar epidural transcavernous transpetrous approach. Technique and indications

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Several selective approaches have been recommended for access to the petroclival region (PCR). However, locoregional extension of the tumor may necessitate more extensive procedures. Dissections from injected specimens allowed us to describe the different osteodural triangles that are exposed to provide an extensive access to the PCR. METHOD: The bony step included a temporopterional flap and exposure of the paraclinoid carotid after removal of the anterior clinoid process. The sphenoid wing was then extensively drilled, exposing the foramen rotundum and ovale. An anterior petrosectomy was subsequently performed. The dura propria of the cavernous sinus was elevated as far as the Meckel cave. The sylvian fissure was also opened. Then, the temporobasal dura and the dura from the posterior surface of the petrous bone were opened and the superior petrosal sinus was coagulated and divided. The tentorium was divided toward its free edge. RESULTS: Via this approach, cranial nerves from the olfactory tract to the acousticofacial bundle are exposed. In the same way, the ventral and lateral surface of the pons is identified. CONCLUSION: The epidural temporopolar transcavernous transpetrous approach is useful to expose during the same procedure, elements of the posterior and middle cranial fossa. It is of particular value when managing tumors simultaneously involving the PCR, the parasellar, and the suprasellar regions.     

Extradural middle fossa approach. Proposal of a learning method: the "rule of two fans." Technical note.

The extradural middle fossa approach is used to access lesions of the petroclival and cavernous sinus regions. It may be included in combined petrosal and anterolateral transcavernous approaches. Technically, it is a demanding exposure that provides a wide extradural corridor between the 5th, 7th, and 8th cranial nerves. Its major advantages are that it offers extradural dissection, limits temporal lobe retraction, and avoids the transposition of nerves or vessels. Its disadvantages are primarily related to the complicated anatomy of the petrous apex from the middle fossa trajectory, which can be unfamiliar to neurosurgeons. To facilitate the first attempts with this relatively uncommon approach during dissections of human cadaveric injected heads and isolated temporal bones, we developed a simple learning method useful for localizing all anatomical structures. Using this "rule of two fans," vascular, nervous, fibrous, and osseous structures are localized within two bordering fans with a 90-degree relationship to each other.     

Posterior fossa meningiomas: surgical experience in 161 cases

BACKGROUND: We report the clinical, radiological, and surgical findings of patients with posterior fossa meningiomas surgically treated at our institution over the last 6 years.METHODS: We reviewed 161 consecutive cases of posterior fossa meningiomas operated on between April 1993 and April 1999 at The George Washington University Medical Center.RESULTS: There were 128 female and 33 male patients (mean age 47 years, range of 10-81 years). Meningiomas were classified as petroclival (110 cases), foramen magnum (21 cases), cerebellar hemispheric, lateral tentorial (14 cases), cerebellopontine angle (9 cases), and jugular foramen (7 cases). Mean tumor equivalent diameter (TED) = (D1xD2xDE)(1/3) was 3.1 cm (range of 0.53-8.95). Head pain (50% of cases) and disturbance of gait (44%) were the most common presenting symptoms, and cranial neuropathies the most common neurological signs on admission. Mean preoperative performance status (Karnofsky scale) was 80.2 (range 40-100). Surgical approaches to these tumors included partial labyrinthectomy petrous apicectomy, fronto-temporal/fronto-temporal orbitozygomatic osteotomy, retrosigmoidal, extreme lateral, transpetrosal, and combined. In 38 cases a staged procedure was performed. Gross-total resection was achieved in 57% of patients, and subtotal/partial in 43%. Surgical mortality was 2.5% and complications were encountered in 41% of patients. Postoperative CSF leak occurred in 22 cases (13.6%). The mean follow-up was 19 months, ranging from 0.2 to 63.6, and the mean performance status of patients with a follow-up of at least 12 months was 77 (range of 40-100). Recurrence or progression of disease was found in 13.7% of cases (follow-up 2 years or more).CONCLUSION: Our experience suggests that although posterior fossa meningiomas represent a continuing challenge for contemporary neurosurgeons, such tumors may be completely or subtotally removed with low rate of mortality and acceptable morbidity, allowing most of these patients to achieve a good outcome in a long-term follow-up.     

经岩骨乙状窦前入路的创伤性及并发症

目的探讨经岩骨乙状窦前入路的创伤性及并发症，为岩斜区肿瘤寻求更合理的治疗手段。方法同顾分析28例采用经岩骨乙状窦前入路手术的岩斜区肿瘤病入的临床表现、影像学特征、手术方法和术后处理等。结果肿瘤全切16例，近全切9例，部份切除3例。术后颅神经疵状全缓解5例，症状同术前10例，症状加重10例，昏迷3例。脑脊液耳漏12例。结论经岩骨己状蜜前入路是目前处理岩斜区肿瘤较好的手术入路。但该手术入路创伤性大．并发症较多且严重。