Donor–Recipient Matching Based on Predicted Indirectly Recognizable HLA Epitopes Independently Predicts the Incidence of De Novo Donor‐Specific HLA Antibodies Following Renal Transplantation

De novo donor‐specific HLA antibodies (dnDSA) are recognized as a risk factor for premature allograft failure. Determinants of DSA specificity are generated via the indirect allorecognition pathway. Here, we present supportive data for the relevance of predicted indirectly recognizable HLA epitopes (PIRCHE) to predict dnDSA following kidney transplantation. A total of 2787 consecutive kidney transplants performed between 1995 and 2015 without preformed DSA have been analyzed. De novo DSA were detected by single antigen bead assay. HLA epitope mismatches were determined by the HLAMatchmaker and PIRCHE approach and correlated in uni‐ and multivariate analyses with 10‐year allograft survival and incidence of dnDSA. The PIRCHE‐II score moderately predicted allograft survival. However, the predictive value of elevated PIRCHE‐II scores >9 for the incidence of dnDSA was statistically significant (p < 0.001). In a multivariate Cox regression analysis adjusted for antigen mismatch and HLAMatchmaker epitopes, the PIRCHE‐II score could be identified as an independent risk factor for dnDSA. The PIRCHE‐II score independently from the antigen mismatch and HLAMatchmaker epitopes could be revealed as being a strong predictor for dnDSA. PIRCHE may help to identify acceptable mismatches with decreased risk of dnDSA and thus improve long‐term renal allograft survival.     

Hiding in Plain Sight—A New Look at HLA Epitopes: A Case Report

“Epitope matching” has become a buzz word in solid organ transplantation. Its goal is to improve matching between donor and recipient, to minimize risk for antibody‐mediated rejection and to reduce sensitization associated with graft failure. Current software allows identification and enumeration of amino acid sequence mismatches in the form of HLA eplets; however, “eplets” and “epitopes” are not interchangeable terms, and the understanding of what contributes to the antigenicity and immunogenicity of HLA B cell epitopes is still very limited and inadequate. In fact, we still do not know what constitutes an HLA epitope or how to define it in a clinically useful way. To allow for judicious implementation of epitope matching, it is critical to explore the full spectrum of factors that affect allorecognition. In exploring antibody‐binding patterns, we have uncovered a potential tool—currently hidden in plain sight—that may shed light on some aspects of epitope characteristics.     

Allo‐HLA Cross‐Reactivities of Cytomegalovirus‐, Influenza‐, and Varicella Zoster Virus–Specific Memory T Cells Are Shared by Different Healthy Individuals

Virus‐specific T cells can recognize allogeneic HLA (allo‐HLA) through TCR cross‐reactivity. The allospecificity often differs by individual (private cross‐reactivity) but also can be shared by multiple individuals (public cross‐reactivity); however, only a few examples of the latter have been described. Because these could facilitate alloreactivity prediction in transplantation, we aimed to identify novel public cross‐reactivities of human virus‐specific CD8⁺ T cells directed against allo‐HLA by assessing their reactivity in mixed‐lymphocyte reactions. Further characterization was done by studying TCR usage with primer‐based DNA sequencing, cytokine production with ELISAs, and cytotoxicity with ⁵¹chromium‐release assays. We identified three novel public allo‐HLA cross‐reactivities of human virus‐specific CD8⁺ T cells. CMV B35/IPS CD8⁺ T cells cross‐reacted with HLA‐B51 and/or HLA‐B58/B57 (23% of tetramer‐positive individuals), FLU A2/GIL (influenza IMP[58‐66] HLA‐A*02:01/GILGFVFTL) CD8⁺ T cells with HLA‐B38 (90% of tetramer‐positive individuals), and VZV A2/ALW (varicella zoster virus IE62[593‐601] HLA‐A*02:01/ALWALPHAA) CD8⁺ T cells with HLA‐B55 (two unrelated individuals). Cross‐reactivity was tested against different cell types including endothelial and epithelial cells. All cross‐reactive T cells expressed a memory phenotype, emphasizing the importance for transplantation. We conclude that public allo‐HLA cross‐reactivity of virus‐specific memory T cells is not uncommon and may create novel opportunities for alloreactivity prediction and risk estimation in transplantation.     

The quest to decipher HLA immunogenicity: Telling friend from foe

Molecular mismatch load analysis was recently introduced as a means for performing risk stratification following organ transplantation. However, although good correlation was demonstrated between molecular mismatch load and generation of de novo donor‐specific HLA antibody (DSA), quite a few exceptions exist, and the underlying factors that define HLA immunogenicity remain unclear. Herein, we present a new paradigm to interrogate differences between molecular mismatches that lead to the generation of de novo DSA and those that do not (the 2MM1DSA cohort). Specifically, patients transplanted across 2 HLA‐DQ mismatches, who formed de novo DSA only to one mismatch (foe) but not the other (friend), provide a unique environment in which patient‐specific factors that affect the immune response other than immunogenicity, such as infection and immunosuppression, can be controlled for. It further permits focusing on mismatches uniquely exhibited by the de novo DSA allele, rather than mismatches shared by both DSA and non‐DSA alleles. This concept paper illustrates several examples, highlights the need for center‐specific or population‐specific cutoff values for posttransplant risk stratification, and mostly argues that if there is no direct correlation between molecular mismatch load and immunogenicity, then molecular mismatch load must not be adopted as an approach for equitable organ allocation.     

Alloantibody Responses After Renal Transplant Failure Can Be Better Predicted by Donor–Recipient HLA Amino Acid Sequence and Physicochemical Disparities Than Conventional HLA Matching

We have assessed whether HLA immunogenicity as defined by differences in donor–recipient HLA amino‐acid sequence (amino‐acid mismatch score, AMS; and eplet mismatch score, EpMS) and physicochemical properties (electrostatic mismatch score, EMS) enables prediction of allosensitization to HLA, and also prediction of the risk of an individual donor–recipient HLA mismatch to induce donor‐specific antibody (DSA). HLA antibody screening was undertaken using single‐antigen beads in 131 kidney transplant recipients returning to the transplant waiting list following first graft failure. The effect of AMS, EpMS, and EMS on the development of allosensitization (calculated reaction frequency [cRF]) and DSA was determined. Multivariate analyses, adjusting for time on the waiting list, maintenance on immunosuppression after transplant failure, and graft nephrectomy, showed that AMS (odds ratio [OR]: 1.44 per 10 units, 95% CI: 1.02–2.10, p = 0.04) and EMS (OR: 1.27 per 10 units, 95% CI: 1.02–1.62, p = 0.04) were independently associated with the risk of developing sensitization to HLA (cRF > 15%). AMS, EpMS, and EMS were independently associated with the development of HLA‐DR and HLA‐DQ DSA, but only EMS correlated with the risk of HLA‐A and ‐B DSA development. Differences in donor–recipient HLA amino‐acid sequence and physicochemical properties enable better assessment of the risk of HLA‐specific sensitization than conventional HLA matching.     

CMV‐infected kidney grafts drive the expansion of blood‐borne CMV‐specific T cells restricted by shared class I HLA molecules via presentation on donor cells

We aimed to determine the role of cytomegalovirus (CMV)‐infected donor cells in the development of a CMV‐specific immune response in kidney transplant recipients. We assessed the CMV pp65‐specific immune response by using interferon‐? ELISPOT and dextramers in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 115 recipients (D+R? 31, D+R + 44, D?R + 40) late after transplantation (mean 59 ± 42 months). Receiving a kidney from a D+ donor resulted in a higher number of IFN‐?‐producing anti‐CMV T cells (P = .004). This effect disappeared with the absence of shared HLA class I specificities between donors and recipients (P = .430). To confirm the role of donor cells in stimulating the expansion of newly developed CMV‐specific CD8⁺ T cells after transplantation, we compared the number of HLA‐A2–restricted CMV‐specific CD8⁺ T cells in primo‐infected recipients who received an HLA‐A2 or non–HLA‐A2 graft. The median of anti‐CMV pp65 T cells restricted by HLA‐A2 was very low for patients who received a non–HLA‐A2 graft vs an HLA‐A2 graft (300 [0‐14638] vs. 17972 [222‐85594] anti‐CMV pp65 CD8⁺ T cells/million CD8⁺ T cells, P = .001). This adds new evidence that CMV‐infected kidney donor cells present CMV peptides and drive an inflation of memory CMV‐specific CD8⁺ T cells, likely because of frequent CMV replications within the graft.     

Effect of the Anti‐C1s Humanized Antibody TNT009 and Its Parental Mouse Variant TNT003 on HLA Antibody–Induced Complement Activation—A Preclinical In Vitro Study

The classic pathway (CP) of complement is believed to significantly contribute to alloantibody‐mediated transplant injury, and targeted complement inhibition is currently considered to be a promising approach for preventing rejection. Here, we investigated the mode of action and efficacy of the humanized anti‐C1s monoclonal antibody TNT009 and its parental mouse variant, TNT003, in preclinical in vitro models of HLA antibody–triggered CP activation. In flow cytometric assays, we measured the attachment of C1 subcomponents and C4/C3 split products (C4b/d, C3b/d) to HLA antigen–coated flow beads or HLA‐mismatched aortic endothelial cells and splenic lymphocytes. Anti‐C1s antibodies profoundly inhibited C3 activation at concentrations >20 μg/mL, in both solid phase and cellular assays. While C4 activation was also prevented, this was not the case for C1 subcomponent attachment. Analysis of serum samples obtained from 68 sensitized transplant candidates revealed that the potency of inhibition was related to the extent of baseline CP activation. This study demonstrates that anti‐C1s antibodies TNT009 and TNT003 are highly effective in blocking HLA antibody–triggered complement activation downstream of C1. Our results provide the foundation for clinical studies designed to investigate the potential of TNT009 in the treatment or prevention of complement‐mediated tissue injury in sensitized transplant recipients.     

Discovery of non‐HLA antibodies associated with cardiac allograft rejection and development and validation of a non‐HLA antigen multiplex panel: From bench to bedside

We analyzed humoral immune responses to nonhuman leukocyte antigen (HLA) after cardiac transplantation to identify antibodies associated with allograft rejection. Protein microarray identified 366 non‐HLA antibodies (>1.5 fold, P < .5) from a discovery cohort of HLA antibody–negative, endothelial cell crossmatch–positive sera obtained from 12 cardiac allograft recipients at the time of biopsy‐proven rejection. From these, 19 plasma membrane proteins and 10 autoantigens identified from gene ontology analysis were combined with 48 proteins identified through literature search to generate a multiplex bead array. Longitudinal sera from a multicenter cohort of adult cardiac allograft recipients (samples: n = 477 no rejection; n = 69 rejection) identified 18 non‐HLA antibodies associated with rejection (P < .1) including 4 newly identified non‐HLA antigenic targets (DEXI, EMCN, LPHN1, and SSB). CART analysis showed 5/18 non‐HLA antibodies distinguished rejection vs nonrejection. Antibodies to 4/18 non‐HLA antigens synergize with HLA donor‐specific antibodies and significantly increase the odds of rejection (P < .1). The non‐HLA panel was validated using an independent adult cardiac transplant cohort (n = 21 no rejection; n = 42 rejection, >1R) with an area under the curve of 0.87 (P < .05) with 92.86% sensitivity and 66.67% specificity. We conclude that multiplex bead array assessment of non‐HLA antibodies identifies cardiac transplant recipients at risk of rejection.     

Donor‐targeted serotherapy as a rescue therapy for steroid‐resistant acute GVHD after HLA‐mismatched kidney transplantation

Acute graft‐versus‐host disease (GVHD) is a rare but frequently lethal complication after solid organ transplantation. GVHD occurs in unduly immunocompromised hosts but requires the escalation of immunosuppression, which does not discriminate between host and donor cells. In contrast, donor‐targeted therapy would ideally mitigate graft‐versus‐host reactivity while sparing recipient immune functions. We report two children with end‐stage renal disease and severe primary immune deficiency (Schimke syndrome) who developed severe steroid‐resistant acute GVHD along with full and sustained donor T cell chimerism after isolated kidney transplantation. Facing a therapeutic dead end, we used a novel strategy based on the adoptive transfer of anti‐HLA donor‐specific antibodies (DSAs) through the transfusion of highly selected plasma. After approval by the appropriate regulatory authority, an urgent nationwide search was launched among more than 3800 registered blood donors with known anti‐HLA sensitization. Adoptively transferred DSAs bound to and selectively depleted circulating donor T cells. The administration of DSA‐rich plasma was well tolerated and notably did not induce antibody‐mediated rejection of the renal allografts. Acute GVHD symptoms promptly resolved in one child. This report provides a proof of concept for a highly targeted novel therapeutic approach for solid organ transplantation–associated GVHD.     

Exosomes expressing the self‐antigens myosin and vimentin play an important role in syngeneic cardiac transplant rejection induced by antibodies to cardiac myosin

Long‐term success of heart transplantation is hindered by humoral and cell‐mediated immune responses. We studied preexisting antibodies to cardiac self‐antigens, myosin and vimentin, and exosomes induced by antibodies to self‐antigens in eliciting immune responses to cardiac grafts. After syngeneic heterotopic murine heart transplantation, rabbit anti‐myosin or normal rabbit immunoglobulin was administered at day 0 or 7. Sera were collected after heartbeat cessation, cellular infiltration was analyzed, and exosomes were isolated from sera. Histopathologic examination of the controls' transplanted hearts demonstrated normal architecture, and their sera demonstrated neither antibodies to self‐antigens nor exosomes expressing self‐antigens. Administration of antibodies to cardiac myosin immediately posttransplantation (day 0) but not on day 7 triggered graft failure on day 7, and histopathologic examination revealed marked cellular infiltration with neutrophils and lymphocytes. Histopathologic examination of rejected hearts also demonstrated myocyte damage as sera had increased antibodies to myosin and vimentin and development of exosomes expressing self‐antigens. Administration of exosomes isolated from failed grafts containing self‐antigens induced graft dysfunction; exosomes isolated from stable mice did not induce graft failure. Antibodies to self‐antigens can induce exosomes containing self‐antigens, initiating an immune response and causing graft failure after cardiac transplantation.     

Role of Sphingosine‐1‐Phosphate in Transplant Vasculopathy Evoked by Anti‐HLA Antibody

Transplant vasculopathy (TV) represents the main cause of late graft failure and limits the long‐term success of organ transplantation. Cellular and humoral immune responses contribute to the pathogenesis of the concentric and diffuse intimal hyperplasia of arteries of the grafted organ. We recently reported that the mitogenic signaling, evoked in human vascular smooth muscle cells (hmSMC) by the anti‐HLA class I monoclonal antibody W6/32, implicates neutral sphingomyelinase‐2, suggesting a role for sphingolipids in intimal hyperplasia of TV. Here, we investigated whether the mitogenic sphingolipid, sphingosine‐1‐phosphate (S1P), is involved in intimal hyperplasia elicited by W6/32. Studies were done on cultured hmSMC and on an in vivo model of TV, consisting of human mesenteric arteries grafted into SCID/beige mice, injected weekly with W6/32. hmSMC migration and DNA synthesis elicited by W6/32 were inhibited by the sphingosine kinase‐1 (SK1) inhibitor dimethylsphingosine, the anti‐S1P antibody Sphingomab and the S1PR1/R3 inhibitor VPC23019. W6/32 stimulated SK1 activity, while siRNA silencing SK1, S1PR1 and S1PR3 inhibited hmSMC migration. In vivo, Sphingomab significantly reduced the intimal thickening induced by W6/32. These data emphasize the role of S1P in intimal hyperplasia elicited by the humoral immune response, and open perspectives for preventing TV with S1P inhibitors.     

First Report of a Successful Pregnancy in an Everolimus‐Treated Heart‐Transplanted Patient: Neonatal Disappearance of Immunosuppressive Drugs

The use of everolimus (EVL) as primary immunosuppression is steadily increasing in heart transplantation (HTx) patients. Limited data currently exist in kidney transplantation, but there is no report of EVL use during pregnancy after HTx and its pharmacokinetics in the newborn. We report a case of an unplanned pregnancy discovered at 21 weeks of gestation in a female HTx patient aged 40 years treated with EVL and cyclosporine (CyA). Because pregnancy was advanced, immunosuppression therapy was left unchanged. At 36 weeks, a healthy infant was delivered. At birth, CyA blood levels were lower in the neonate, but EVL concentrations in maternal and neonatal umbilical blood were similar. Amniotic fluid concentrations were undetectable for both drugs. In the newborn, EVL was measurable at 5 days after birth, whereas CyA disappeared within 2 days. Cord blood displayed a normal count of B and T cells and CD4, CD8 and natural killer cell populations. At birth, both mother and newborn displayed the same blood levels of EVL; therefore, a filter effect of the placenta may be hypothesized for CyA but not for EVL. No immediate complications were observed with this pregnancy.     

IL‐2 therapy preferentially expands adoptively transferred donor‐specific Tregs improving skin allograft survival

Regulatory T cells (Tregs) have unique immunosuppressive properties and are essential to ensure effective immunoregulation. In animal models, Tregs have been shown to prevent autoimmune disorders and establish transplantation tolerance. Therefore, the prospect of harnessing Tregs, either by increasing their frequency or by conferring allospecificity, has prompted a growing interest in the development of immunotherapies. Here, employing a well‐established skin transplant model with a single major histocompatibility complex mismatch, we compared the therapeutic efficacy of adoptively transfer Treg with or without donor specificity and the administration of IL‐2 to promote in vivo expansion of Treg. We showed that IL‐2 treatment preferentially enhances the proliferation of the allospecific Tregs adoptively transferred in an antigen‐dependent manner. In addition, donor‐specific Tregs significantly increased the expression of regulatory‐related marker, such as CTLA4 and inducible costimulator (ICOS), in the skin allograft and draining lymph nodes compared to endogenous and polyclonal transferred Tregs. Importantly, by combining IL‐2 with donor‐specific Tregs, but not with polyclonal Tregs, a synergistic effect in prolonging skin allograft survival was observed. Altogether, our data suggest that this combination therapy could provide the appropriate conditions to enhance the immunoregulation of alloimmune responses in clinical transplantation.     

Histological picture of antibody‐mediated rejection without donor‐specific anti‐HLA antibodies: Clinical presentation and implications for outcome

In this cohort study (n = 935 transplantations), we investigated the phenotype and risk of graft failure in patients with histological criteria for antibody‐mediated rejection (ABMR) in the absence of circulating donor‐specific anti‐human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies (DSA), and compared this to patients with definite ABMR and HLA‐DSA‐positivity. The histological picture did not differ between HLA‐DSA‐positive (n = 85) and HLA‐DSA‐negative (n = 123) cases of ABMR histology, apart from increased complement split product 4d (C4d) deposition in the peritubular capillaries in HLA‐DSA‐positive cases. Histology of ABMR without HLA‐DSA was more transient than DSA‐positive ABMR, and patients with ABMR histology without HLA‐DSA had graft survival superior to that of HLA‐DSA‐positive patients, independent of concomitant T cell–mediated rejection (38.2%) or borderline changes (17.9%). Multivariate analysis showed that the risk of graft failure was not higher in patients with histological picture of ABMR (ABMR_h) in the absence of HLA‐DSA, compared to patients without ABMR_h. Despite an association between C4d deposition and HLA‐DSA‐positivity, using C4d deposition as alternative for the DSA criterion in the diagnosis of ABMR, as proposed in Banff 2017, did not contribute to the prognosis of graft function and graft failure. We concluded that biopsies with ABMR_h but without detectable HLA‐DSA represent a distinct, often transient phenotype with superior allograft survival.     

Pregnancy Outcomes Related to Mycophenolate Exposure in Female Kidney Transplant Recipients

In 2012, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration issued guidelines advising kidney transplant recipients (KTRs) to discontinue mycophenolate (MPA) in preparation for pregnancy. Little is known about how this guidance has affected pregnancy and graft outcomes. The purpose of this retrospective cohort study was to investigate any association between the discontinuation of MPA and KTR pregnancy and graft outcomes. Data from the National Transplantation Pregnancy Registry included 382 cases in which KTRs managed on MPA became pregnant. Overall, 22 variables, including the time in which a KTR discontinued MPA, were assessed across four end points: miscarriages, birth defects, and 2‐ and 5‐year postpartum graft loss. Birth defects and miscarriages were similar among KTRs who discontinued MPA >6 and <6 weeks prior to pregnancy and during the first trimester. In contrast, discontinuing MPA during the second trimester or later significantly increased the risk of miscarriages (odds ratio [OR] 9.35, 95% confidence interval [CI] 4.31–20.00, p < 0.001) and birth defects (OR 6.06, 95% CI 1.96–18.87, p = 0.002). Discontinuing MPA <6 weeks prior to pregnancy was associated with an increased risk of 5‐year graft loss. For the fetus, there is value to discontinuing MPA anytime prior to the second trimester. Adhering to current guidelines does not negatively affect graft survival.     

Donor‐Specific HLA Antibodies in Living Versus Deceased Donor Liver Transplant Recipients

With less ischemia, improved donor selection and controlled procedures, living donor liver transplantation (LDLT) might lead to less HLA donor‐specific antibody (DSA) formation or fewer adverse outcomes than deceased donor liver transplantation (DDLT). Using the multicenter A2ALL (Adult‐to‐Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation Cohort Study) biorepository, we compared the incidence and outcomes of preformed and de novo DSAs between LDLT and DDLT. In total, 129 LDLT and 66 DDLT recipients were identified as having serial samples. The prevalence of preformed and de novo DSAs was not different between DDLT and LDLT recipients (p = 0.93). There was no association between patient survival and the timing (preformed vs. de novo), class (I vs. II) and relative levels of DSA between the groups; however, preformed DSA was associated with higher graft failure only in DDLT recipients (p = 0.01). De novo DSA was associated with graft failure regardless of liver transplant type (p = 0.005) but with rejection only in DDLT (p = 0.0001). On multivariate analysis, DSA was an independent risk factor for graft failure regardless of liver transplant type (p = 0.017, preformed; p = 0.002, de novo). In conclusion, although similar in prevalence, DSA may have more impact in DDLT than LDLT recipients. Although our findings need further validation, future research should more robustly test the effect of donor type and strategies to mitigate the impact of DSA.