4种粘接剂对非龋性硬化牙本质粘接强度的实验研究

目的：比较4种牙本质粘接剂对牙颈部非龋性硬化牙本质的粘接强度。方法：选择具有典型牙颈部非龋性硬化牙本质的新鲜离体牙32个，随机分为4组，分别用Prime＆Bond NT、Contax、Xeno Ⅲ及Clearfil TRI—S Bond4种粘接剂和复合树脂粘接，24h后制作微拉伸试件，测试微拉伸强度，扫描电镜观察断裂模式并进行分类。结果：4种粘接剂对非龋性硬化牙本质的微拉伸强度分别为：Prime＆Bond NT 38．81＋11．75MPa。Contax 37．82±11．74MPa，Xenom 29．55±10．25MPa，Clearfil TRI—S Bond 38．63±12．17MPa，试件断裂多为混和破坏。结论：4种粘接剂对硬化牙本质粘接强度存在差异，XenoⅢ最低（P〈0．01），其余3种粘接材料两两比较无显著差异（P〉0．05）。     

Effects of luting agent and thermocycling on bond strengths to root canal dentine

AIM: To investigate the effects of luting agent and thermocycling on bond strengths to root canal dentine. METHODOLOGY: Extracted maxillary canines (n =144) were root filled and divided into six groups of 24 teeth each. Fibre posts (FRC Postec) were inserted using six luting agents: Panavia F, Multilink, Variolink II, PermaFlo DC, RelyX Unicem and Clearfil Core. Each root was sliced into six discs (thickness 1 mm) representing the coronal, middle and apical part of the root canal. Push-out tests were performed 24 h after post insertion (n = 12) as well as after thermocycling (5000x; 5-55 degrees C, 30 s) (n = 12). Statistical analysis was conducted using analysis of variance (anova) followed by post-hoc comparisons (Tukey-B). The influence of thermocycling on bond strengths was investigated for each material and region separately using t-tests. RESULTS: The bond strengths were significantly affected by the luting agent (P < 0.001), the root position (P = 0.003) and thermocycling (P < 0.001; three-way anova). RelyX had significantly higher bond strengths compared with all other materials (P < 0.05; Tukey-B). The apical region of the root canal had significantly higher bond strengths compared with the middle and coronal region (P < 0.05; Tukey-B). After thermocycling for RelyX a significant increase in bond strengths was detected for the middle and apical region (P < 0.01; t-test, Bonferroni factor 18). CONCLUSIONS: Bond strengths were affected significantly by luting agent and root position. RelyX had higher bond strengths compared with other materials. The apical region of the canals was characterized by significantly higher bond strengths.     

冷热循环对龋坏内层和正常牙本质粘接强度的影响

目的评价冷热循环对正常和龋坏内层牙本质粘接强度的影响.方法18个近中(牙合)面中龋人离体磨牙,在龋检液监控下用慢速牙钻去龋,在远中(牙合)面健康牙本质上制备相同深度窝洞作为对照.随机分成3组用粘接剂粘接(Prime&Bond NT、Adper Prompt、Contax Bond),复合树脂(Chrisma A2)充填.制备测试微拉伸粘接强度的正常牙本质和龋坏内层牙本质条状试件,再随机分成3组,分别冷热循环0次、2000次、5000次,在拉力试验机上测定粘接强度.结果冷热循环0次、2000次、5000次时两种牙本质的粘接强度为正常牙本质Prime&BondNT(23.47±5.27 Mpa,25.69±4.52 Mpa,24.54±4.71 Mpa);Adper Prompt(21.29±5.05 Mpa,21.30±2.30Mpa,20.68±6.63 Mpa);Contax(25.78±4.70 Mpa,27.15±5.33 Mpa,24.40±5.93 Mpa);龋坏内层牙本质Prime&BondNT(19.55±3.28 Mpa,18.67±5.52 Mpa,16.07±6.96 Mpa);AdperPrompt(18.40±3.41 Mpa,18.23±3.42 Mpa,16.63±3.42 Mpa);Contax(23.98±3.55 Mpa,21.58±2.69 Mpa,15.34±6.03Mpa).结论冷热循环5000次对正常牙本质的粘接强度无显著影响;对龋坏内层牙本质有显著影响,Adper Prompt除外.未进行冷热循环时,龋坏内层牙本质的粘接强度与正常牙本质没有显著差异.冷热循环5000次后,龋坏内层牙本质的粘接强度显著小于正常牙本质.     

Three-year clinical evaluation of dentine bonding agents

Eighty Class V non-undercut cervical abrasion lesions were restored using four dentine bonding agents and composite resin. The restorations were examined over a three-year period, and the cumulative loss rate calculated each year. Marginal staining at each year was assessed using a standardized photographic method. The loss rate of restorations increased generally over the three-year period, reaching 30 to 60 per cent for the four products. Marginal staining also increased for all four products over the three-year period.     

Effect of bleaching agents on bonding to pulp chamber dentine

AIM: To determine the effect of intracoronal bleaching agents on adhesion of bonding agents to pulp chamber dentine. METHODOLOGY: Forty extracted human maxillary anterior teeth were randomly divided into four groups of 10 teeth each. Bleaching agents were sealed in pulp chambers for 7 days, as in clinical use. Group 1 (control): distilled water, group 2: 35% hydrogen peroxide, group 3: sodium perborate mixed with water, and group 4: sodium perborate mixed with 35% hydrogen peroxide. Teeth were stored in saline at 37 degrees C for 7 days. After the bleaching agent was removed, teeth were leached in water for a further 7 days prior to bonding. The crown was cut vertically from mesial to distal and the labial pulp chamber dentine was prepared for bonding with Clearfil SE-Bond and filled with resin composite (Clearfil AP-X). The bonded specimens were kept moist at 37 degrees C for 24 h. Microtensile bond strengths were determined using a universal testing machine. Additional teeth were prepared using the same bleaching procedures to investigate the scanning electron microscopic appearance of the dentine surface. RESULTS: Mean values (+/-SD) of microtensile bond strength for the experimental groups were: group 1: 5.29 +/- 2.21 MPa, group 2: 5.99 +/- 1.51 MPa, group 3: 9.17 +/- 1.65 MPa and group 4: 3.99 +/- 1.31 MPa. Dentine treated with sodium perborate in water (group 3) had significantly higher mean bond strength when compared with the other three groups (P < 0.05, Tukey's test). Mean bond strength was lowest when dentine was treated with sodium perborate plus hydrogen peroxide (group 4). CONCLUSIONS: In terms of subsequent bond strength during restoration, sodium perborate mixed with distilled water appears to be the best intracoronal bleaching agent.     

Microtensile bond strengths to caries-affected dentine treated with Carisolv

BACKGROUND: Little information is available regarding the bonding performance of adhesive restorative materials to caries-affected dentine after the use of Carisolv. The aim of this study was to compare the microtensile bond strengths of two resin-based adhesives, a conventional glass ionomer cement and resin modified glass ionomer cement to 'normal' dentine and caries-affected dentine after Carisolv treatment. METHODS: Specimens were prepared using molar teeth with small carious lesions. Caries was removed with the Carisolv solution and the whole surface was bonded with either SE Bond, One Coat Bond, Fuji IX or Fuji II LC. After 24 hours, specimens were prepared for the microtensile bond strength test and stressed in tension at 1 mm/min until rupture of the bond. Mean bond strengths and mode of failure were determined and analysed with the LSD test and chi square test respectively. RESULTS: The results showed no statistical difference for SE Bond, One Coat Bond or Fuji IX, but a difference was observed for the resin-modified GIC, Fuji II LC. CONCLUSIONS: It was concluded that carious dentine treated with Carisolv did not affect the adhesion of the adhesive restorative materials tested in this study with the exception of Fuji II LC.     

Bond strengths of nine current dentine adhesive systems to primary and permanent teeth

The aim of this study was to compare the shear bond strength (SBS) of nine dentine bonding systems (DBS) of different classes to human primary and permanent dentine. Flat dentine occlusal surfaces were produced on human molars (100 primary, 100 permanent) by wet grinding on a 800-grit SiC paper. Nine DBS were applied following the manufacturers' instructions: One total etch multi-step system: Scotchbond Multipurpose Plus (3M/ESPE); Four total etch one-bottle system: Prime &Bond 2.1 (Dentsply), One Step (Bisco), Scotchbond 1 (3M/ESPE), and OptibondSolo Plus (Kerr); Three two-step self-etching primer systems: Clearfil Liner Bond 2 (Kuraray), Clearfil SE Bond (Kuraray), and Prime &Bond NT with NRC (Dentsply); An 'all-in-one' self-etching system: Prompt L-Pop (3M/ESPE). Composite (Z100; 3M/ESPE) cylinders (2 mm diameter, 3 mm high) were polymerized on the treated dentine surfaces and the specimens were stored at 37 degrees C for 24 h prior to testing. Twenty experimental groups were produced and tested. Statistical analysis revealed both a substrate and a bonding system effect. Two adhesive systems (One Step, Prime &Bond NT) had significantly higher bond strengths on permanent than on primary dentine. There was an effect of dentine bonding system on the mode of fracture. Although eight of the 10 DBS tested exhibited higher median SBS values on permanent dentine than on primary dentine, the dependent pairwise comparison identified a significant difference only for two groups. The use of simplified bonding systems does not necessarily result in improved bond strength to primary or to permanent dentine.     

Bonding to and protecting worn palatal surfaces of teeth with dentine bonding agents

Dentine bonding resins may play a role in protecting dentine against acids for patients with erosion. Therefore, it is important to try and understand what potential difficulties may ensue when bonding to worn dentine. This paper reviews the literature on the changes between normal and worn dentine and the effect of this on the bonding to composite resins. A medline search was undertaken using the terms erosion, tooth wear and dentine bonding up until the spring of 2003. Although there are changes on the surface of worn dentine, there is little evidence that this may affect the bond.     

粘接处理剂对自粘接树脂水门汀和RMGIC的牙本质粘接强度的影响

目的:实验评价牙本质粘接处理剂对自粘接树脂水门汀和树脂加强型玻璃离子水门汀(RMGIC)的牙本质微拉伸粘接强度的影响.方法:选用离体人无龋第三恒磨牙24颗,用低速切片机垂直于牙体长轴方向将磨牙冠(牙合)中1/3交界线处切开待用.实验组牙本质表面涂布牙本质粘接处理剂,对照组不涂粘接处理剂.后将试样分别用自粘接树脂水门汀(Unicem,3M ESPE;seT PP,SDI)或树脂加强型玻璃离子水门汀(Fuji CEM,GC)原位对位粘接.水浴中储存24h后,用低速切片机把样本切割成约1mm×1mm×8mm条状,随后进行微拉伸测试.用扫描电镜观察粘接界面形貌.结果:无论是否使用粘接处理剂,Unicem的牙本质粘接强度显著高于seT PP 和Fuji CEM(P <0.01).与对照组相比,实验组的粘接强度显著提高(P <0.05).结论:粘接处理剂表面处理增强自粘接树脂水门汀及树脂加强型玻璃离子水门汀的牙本质粘接强度.     

3 种粘结剂对龋损内层牙本质粘结强度的研究

目的比较3 种粘结剂对正常和龋损内层牙本质的粘结强度.方法18 颗近中牙合面中龋人离体磨牙, 在龋检液监控下用慢速球钻去龋,在远中牙合面健康牙本质上制备相同深度窝洞作为对照组.按完全随机化的方法分成3 组,用3 种粘结剂粘接(Prime&Bond NT、Adper Prompt 、Contax)粘结,然后复合树脂(Chrisma A2)充填.制备用于测试微抗拉粘结强度的条状试件,在拉力试验机上测定粘结强度,扫描电镜观察断裂模式.结果3 种粘结剂对龋损内层牙本质和正常牙本质的粘结强度分别为Prime&Bond NT (16.26±4.73) MPa,(20.36±10.18) MPa;Adper Prompt (20.19±4.04) MPa,(23.01±7.34) MPa; Contax (27.73±8.82) MPa,(26.32±8.26) MPa,试件断裂以混合破坏为主.结论3 种粘结剂龋损内层牙本质的粘结强度与正常牙本质无显著差异.     

Dentin and enamel bond strengths of dual-cure composite luting agents used with dual-cure dental adhesives

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this in vitro study was to evaluate and compare dentin and enamel bond strengths obtained with dual-cure composite luting agents when used with dual-cure dental adhesives. METHODS: Human molars were ground flat to expose enamel (n=80) or dentin (n=80). Specimens in each substrate group were randomly assigned to eight treatment sub-groups, according to four adhesive-luting agent combinations and two test conditions (with or without thermocycling). Pre-polymerized composite resin posts (TPH Spectrum) were luted to either the enamel or dentin surfaces with one of the following adhesive-luting agent combinations: (1) Xeno IV Dual Cure (dual-cure self-etch adhesive) and Calibra (dual-cure luting agent); (2) Prime & Bond NT Dual Cure (dual-cure total-etch adhesive) and Calibra; (3) OptiBond All-in-One Dual Cure (dual-cure self-etch adhesive) and Nexus 2 Dual Syringe (dual-cure luting agent); (4) OptiBond Solo Plus Dual Cure (dual-cure total-etch adhesive) and Nexus 2 Dual Syringe. For each treatment sub-group, half the specimens (n=10) were tested after 24h storage in water at 37 degrees C, and the other half (n=10) were tested after thermocycling for 1800 cycles between water baths held at 5 and 55 degrees C, with a dwell time in each bath of 30s, and a transfer time of 10s. Bond strengths were measured in shear mode, and expressed in MPa. The fracture mode (adhesive, cohesive, mixed) was examined. Data were analyzed for statistical significance with a factorial ANOVA and post hoc tests. RESULTS: Mean enamel bond strengths ranged from 8.4MPa for non-thermocycled OptiBond All-in-One|Nexus 2 to 35.5MPa for non-thermocycled Prime & Bond NT|Calibra. Mean dentin bond strengths ranged from 14.5MPa for non-thermocycled OptiBond Solo Plus|Nexus 2 to 30.9MPa for thermocycled Xeno IV|Calibra. The fracture mode was predominantly adhesive for all groups. CONCLUSIONS: On enamel, the total-etch adhesives performed better than their self-etch counterparts, while in dentin, the opposite was found, i.e., the self-etch adhesives performed better than their total-etch counterparts. Thermocycling for 1800 cycles did not affect the SBS of the materials tested to dentin and enamel.     

Effect of simulated pulpal pressure on all-in-one adhesive bond strengths to dentine

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the durability of all-in-one adhesive systems bonded to dentine with and without simulated hydrostatic pulpal pressure (PP). METHODS: Flat dentine surfaces of extracted human molars were prepared. Two all-in-one adhesive systems, One-Up Bond F (OBF) (Tokuyama Corp., Tokyo, Japan), and Fluoro Bond Shake One (FBS) (Shofu Co., Kyoto, Japan) were applied to the dentine surfaces under either a PP of 0 or 15cm H(2)O. Then, resin composite build-ups were made. The specimens bonded under pressure were stored in 37 degrees C water for 24h, 1 and 3 months under 15cm H(2)O PP. Specimens not bonded under pressure were stored under zero PP. After storage, the specimens were sectioned into slabs that were trimmed to hourglass shapes and subjected to micro-tensile bond testing (muTBS). The data were analysed using two-way ANOVA and Holm-Sidak HSD multiple comparison tests (alpha=0.05). RESULTS: The muTBS of OBF fell significantly (p<0.05) when PP was applied during bonding and storage, regardless of storage time. In contrast, although the muTBS of OBF specimens bonded and stored without hydrostatic pressure storage fell significantly over the 3 months period, the decrease was less than half as much as specimens stored under PP. In FBS bonded specimens, although there was no significant difference between the muTBS with and without hydrostatic pulpal pressure at 24h, by 1 and 3 months of storage under PP, significant reductions were seen compared with the control group without PP. CONCLUSION: The muTBS of OBF bonded specimens was lowered more by simulated PP than by storage time; specimens bonded with FBS were not sensitive to storage time in the absence of PP, but showed lower bond strengths at 1 and 3 months in the presence of PP.     

An in vitro investigation of penetration depth of dentine bonding agents into carious dentine

The aim of the present in vitro study was to determine the penetration depth of dentine bonding agents into carious dentine as a possible strategy in caries treatment of deep lesions. Forty-eight extracted carious teeth were used for the experiments and divided in four groups. In a split-tooth design, one half of each tooth was treated without caries excavation, and the second half after caries excavation. In group 1 the teeth were treated with Prime & Bond 2.0 without phosphoric acid etching, and in group 2 with phosphoric acid etching. In group 3, the teeth were treated with All-Bond 2 without phosphoric acid etching, and in group 4 with phosphoric acid etching. Bonding agents were marked with an orange dye prior to application. The composition of the bonding agents had no significant influence on penetration depths. The mean thickness of the outer, necrotic caries zone in unexcavated specimens was 117 microm (+/-126). Bonding agents penetrated significantly deeper into unexcavated carious dentine (mean 124 +/- 76 microm) compared with excavated dentine (11 +/- 14 microm) and sound dentine (3 +/- 4 microm). Acid etching significantly reduced the thickness of the outer caries zone, and the penetration depth of the bonding agents into unexcavated carious specimens by approximately 50%, and increased it into sound dentine. The results indicate that dentine bonding agents could completely penetrate the unexcavated outer carious dentine in 90% of specimens. Further studies are required to determine whether further caries activity is arrested after treatment with dentine bonding procedures.     

Clinical performance of dentine bonding agents in the enamel-etched Class V abrasion lesion

Ninety-three non-undercut cervical abrasion lesions were restored with one of five dentine bonding agents and composite resin, using enamel etching to supplement retention. The restorations were reviewed at approximately one, six, 12 and 24 months. The loss rate at one year ranged from zero to 50 per cent, and marginal staining became apparent over the one-year period. It is evident that even with enamel etching, some dentine bonding agents are not effective enough to reliably retain composite in Class V abrasion lesions.     

One-year clinical evaluation of three dentine bonding agents

One hundred and twenty-five composite restorations were placed in non-undercut, non-enamel-etched Class V abrasion lesions in 20 patients using the dentine bonding agents Scotchbond 2, Tripton, and Prisma Universal Bond 2. Patients were recalled at approximately 3 months, 6 months, and 1 year. After 1 year the cumulative per cent survival of restorations was Scotchbond 2, 8 per cent; Scotchbond 2 with dentine roughening, 16 per cent; Tripton, 16 per cent; Prisma Universal Bond 2, 75 per cent.     

自酸蚀树脂水门汀ResiCem牙本质粘结强度的评价

目的 评价自酸蚀树脂水门汀ResiCem的牙本质粘结强度并探讨酸蚀对其粘结强度的影响。方法 选择离体无龋第三恒磨牙15颗。沿垂直于牙体长轴方向将磨牙冠中1/3处切开,将牙本质面分别用自酸蚀树脂水门汀Panavia F和Resi-Cem原位对位粘结。其中ResiCem组牙本质面分别用磷酸酸蚀0、5、10、15 s。用低速切片机把样本切割成约1 mm×1 mm×8mm条块后进行微拉伸测试,并通过扫描电镜观察粘结界面。结果 ResiCem的牙本质微拉伸粘结强度[(16.9±5.3)MPa]与Panavia F[(17.0±5.2)MPa]间差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。磷酸酸蚀显著地降低ResiCem与牙本质间的粘结强度(P<0.05),并随着酸蚀时间的延长而降低。结论 ResiCem的牙本质微拉伸粘结强度与Panavia F相当,但酸蚀会降低ResiCem的牙本质粘结强度。     

Clinical evaluation of EBS dentine bonding agent: one year results

There are numerous dentine bonding agents currently on the market, the majority of which adhere by means of infiltration of a hydrophilic polymerizable diacrylate into dentinal collagen exposed by acid treatment. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the clinical performance of one such product, EBS dentine bonding, in non-undercut caries-free cervical lesions. Forty cavities were restored in eight patients of mean age 53 years. The manufacturer's instructions were followed, which involved essentially etching the enamel and dentine for 20 seconds with 32 per cent phosphoric acid, application and evaporation of EBS Primer, followed by placement and curing of EBS Bond, and restoring the cavity with Pertac II (ESPE) hybrid resin composite. Restorations were photographed at base line and one year for evaluation of marginal discolouration on a continuous linear rating scale. At six months, one patient with four restorations was not available; the remaining 36 restorations were all present. At one year, one restoration was missing, giving a cumulative retention rate of over 97 per cent. One of the 36 restorations exhibited very mild marginal discolouration.     

Regional bond strengths of resins to human root dentine

Objectives: The demand for restoration of root dentine defects such as cervical erosion and root caries has significantly increased recently, but there is limited information on the performance of the adhesive resins to radicular dentine. The purpose of this study was to measure the regional tensile bond strength (TBS) of composite bonded to human root and coronal dentine, and to observe the interface between resin and root dentine by SEM.

Methods: Human extracted cuspid teeth were used to measure TBS with a new microtensile bond test. Enamel and cementum were removed from the labial tooth surfaces to form a long cavity preparation into dentine from the mid-crown to the apex of the root within the same tooth. All Bond 2 (all etch technique) or Imperva Bond (no etch) was bonded to dentine surfaces and covered with Protect Liner resin composite. The resin-bonded teeth were serially sliced into 16 sections at right angles to the long axis of the tooth, and the bonded surfaces were trimmed to give a bonded surface area of 1 mm² for TBS testing.

Results: All Bond 2 bond strengths to coronal and apical dentine showed high values (23.5 MPa) but the bond strength was significantly lower on cervical root dentine. Imperva Bond produced a relatively high tensile bond strength to all regional areas. SEM showed that the thickness of the resin-infiltrated layer formed by All Bond 2 in root dentine was less than coronal areas. Resin infiltration with Imperva Bond was always less than 0.5 μm. The results suggest that high TBS values can be obtained with minimal resin infiltration in root dentine.     

Influence of the pulpal components on human dentine permeability in vitro

AIM: To examine the influence of the retained pulpal components on permeability of human dentine by monitoring drug diffusion. METHODOLOGY: Twelve intact dentine discs were prepared from freshly extracted human third molars. The dentine surface on the enamel side was etched with 10% polyacrylic acid for 30 s. The drug diffusion test was carried out before and after removal of the retained pulpal components. Each dentine disc was inserted between two plastic chambers; enamel- and pulpal-side chambers, which were filled with 0.05 mol L(-1) naproxen sodium (NA) and phosphate-buffered saline (PBS), respectively. After 10 min, the solution on the pulpal-side chamber was collected to determine the concentration of NA using a spectrophotometer. To remove the retained pulpal components and residual NA, the pulp chamber of each disc was washed out with PBS and placed in an ultrasonic cleaner. After removal of these components and the residual NA, the drug diffusion test was repeated. The inner surface of the pulp chamber was observed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) before and after the removal of the retained pulpal components. RESULTS: The amount of NA that diffused through dentine into the pulp was significantly higher after the pulp chamber was washed out with PBS (paired t-test, P < 0.05). SEM observation demonstrated the presence of the retained pulpal components, odontoblastic layer and some parts of subodontoblastic zone, covering the surface of predentine. These components were removed after the pulp chamber was washed out with PBS followed by cleaning in an ultrasonic cleaner. CONCLUSIONS: The presence of retained pulpal components had a significant influence on drug diffusion through dentine discs.