Salvage surgery for a locally persistent or recurrent tumour in maxillary cancer patients who have undergone radiotherapy and concomitant intra-arterial cisplatin: implications for surgical margin assessment

Limited information about salvage surgery is available for locally persistent and recurrent maxillary sinus cancers after the completion of chemoradiation therapy. Seventy-six maxillary sinus cancer patients who had undergone chemoradioselection using initial radiotherapy and concomitant intra-arterial cisplatin were screened retrospectively. Twenty-four of these patients who had a locally persistent or recurrent tumour were investigated. The 2-year overall survival rate of patients with maxillary sinus cancer of all types was 39.0% for those who underwent salvage surgery and 10.0% for those who did not. The 2-year overall survival rate of patients with maxillary sinus squamous cell carcinoma was 45.8% for those who underwent salvage surgery and 11.1% for those who did not. Furthermore, the 2-year local control and overall survival rates of patients with positive and negative surgical margins were 14.3% and 83.3% and 14.3% and 66.7%, respectively. There were significant differences in local control (P = 0.004) and overall survival (P = 0.005) regarding surgical margin status. Although salvage surgery for a locally persistent or recurrent maxillary sinus cancer is a feasible treatment, patients with positive surgical margins are more prone to local relapse. Therefore, surgical safety margins should be assessed thoroughly.     

Clinical outcomes and prognostic factor analysis after salvage surgery for recurrent squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity

The purpose of this study was to analyze the oncological outcomes and predictive factors for successful curative salvage surgery after recurrent oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma. A retrospective study was conducted involving 73 patients who received surgery-based salvage treatment. The pattern of failure for primary treatment was local failure in 29 patients, regional failure in 29 patients, and loco-regional failure in 15 patients. The 5-year overall, loco-regional failure-free, and disease-free survival rates were 54.8%, 58.9% and 49.3%, respectively. Patients with an advanced initial N stage, previous treatment with combined modality therapy, loco-regional recurrence, advanced recurrent T stage, a disease-free survival of less than 8 months prior to salvage, and recurrence in a previously treated field had a significantly worse prognosis. Given the potential surgical morbidity, salvage surgery should be undertaken after careful consultation with patients who have factors for a poor prognosis.     

Surgical salvage for local and regional recurrence in oral cancer.

PURPOSE: To evaluate local and regional recurrence and the outcomes for salvage surgery in patients for oral cancer. PATIENTS AND METHODS: This study analyzed 354 consecutive patients with oral cancer treated primarily by surgery or surgery combined with adjuvant therapy by 1 surgeon (R.A.O.) between February 1991 and September 2001. RESULTS: Overall recurrence rate was 15.5%; with 5.4% local, 8.5% regional, and 1.4% locoregional. Overall salvage for local recurrence was 52.6% 3-year survival, and statistically significant favorable prognostic factors were salvaged by surgery alone and initial cancer staging of I/II. Overall salvage for regional recurrence was 50%, with recurrence in a previously untreated neck and salvage with radical neck dissection plus radiotherapy giving the best prognosis. No patients with locoregional recurrence were salvaged. CONCLUSIONS: Patients who were stage I/II and were treated initially by surgery alone were the best candidates for salvage if they recurred. Salvage was best achieved with surgery or surgery + adjuvant therapy, and patients recurring within 6 months had a worse survival. Patients with locoregional recurrence or treated with RT +/- chemotherapy alone have negligible survival.     

Relevance of positive margins in case of adjuvant therapy of oral cancer

Positive or clean surgical margins are of great prognostic interest in the surgical treatment of oral and oropharyngeal cancer with poor survival of patients burdened with positive margins. The impact of postoperative treatment modalities on the survival of these patients is debated. The relevance of positive margins was investigated in three patient populations (a group treated by surgery only, a group with postoperative polychemotherapy, and a group with a multi-modality treatment comprising postoperative radiation with concurrent chemotherapy) which were compared retrospectively. Patients treated with adjuvant regimens following resection in healthy margins had a survival advantage as compared to the surgery only group possibly due to less local relapses and longer relapse latencies. Overall disease-free survival was better in the groups with adjuvant therapy irrespective of free or positive margins. Survival rates following positive surgical margins were worse in all three groups as compared to the respective subgroups with healthy margins. A second resection in patients with positive margins, executed in the group with postoperative radiation with concurrent chemotherapy, did not result in survival improvement. Therefore, radical resection at initial surgery in healthy and clear margins remains indispensable in multi-modality treatment strategies involving surgery. The combination of healthy margins and adjuvant treatment seems to be most favorable for patient survival.     

Salvage operations for patients with persistent or recurrent cancer of the maxillary sinus after superselective intra-arterial infusion of cisplatin with concurrent radiotherapy

Our aim was to evaluate the feasibility of salvage operations for patients with persistent or recurrent cancer of the maxillary sinus after superselective intra-arterial infusion of cisplatin with concurrent radiotherapy. We retrospectively analysed the records of 61 patients with cancer of the maxillary sinus who were treated in this way. Chemotherapy comprised 100–120 mg/m² superselective intra-arterial infusions of cisplatin given a median of 4 times weekly (range 2–5). Concurrent radiotherapy was given in a median dose of 65 Gy (range 24–70 Gy). Persistent or recurrent cancer of the maxillary sinus was found in 17 patients, of whom 11 had salvage surgery. The disease was controlled in 8 of the 11, and 7 of the 11 survived with no evidence of disease. Their 5-year overall survival was 61%. Two of the 11 developed serious operative complications. Salvage surgery for patients with persistent or recurrent cancer of the maxillary sinus treated by superselective chemoradiotherapy is both safe and successful. Salvage surgery is a good option when this sort of persistent or recurrent cancer is followed up after the regimen of chemoradiotherapy described.     

Vascularized free tissue transfer for reconstruction of ablative defects in oral and oropharyngeal cancer patients undergoing salvage surgery following concomitant chemoradiation

The purpose of this study was to determine whether chemotherapy delivered concurrently with external beam radiation therapy for loco-regionally advanced head and neck cancer affects the rate or severity of postoperative complications in patients who underwent salvage surgery for recurrent or persistent disease with simultaneous microvascular free flap reconstruction. The primary study group consisted of patients with head and neck malignancies that had undergone surgical salvage with microvascular free flap reconstruction for persistent or recurrent disease following definitive radiation or concomitant chemoradiation treatment. A group of demographically matched patients who underwent microvascular free flap reconstruction for non-malignant and malignant conditions who never received radiation were randomly selected to serve as a control group. The study cohort was divided according to radiation treatment. The overall success rate of flap reconstruction was 92%, with an overall complication rate of 23%. Concurrently administered chemotherapy did not appear to affect the type of or the complication rate. The results of this investigation indicate that microvascular free flap reconstruction of head and neck defects is highly predictable, results in relatively few major complications, and suggests that neither radiation alone nor concomitant chemoradiation has a statistically significant effect on overall flap survival or complication rate.     

Audit of the rates of re-excision for close or involved margins in the management of oral cancer

The need for re-excision of close or involved margins after the resection of oral cancer is debatable. This audit comprised 640 consecutive patients over an 11-year period with at least five years’ follow up. A total of 213 patients (33%) had resection margins that were clear (5 mm or more), 314 (49%) were close (1 - 4.9 mm), and 113 (18%) were involved (0 - 0.9 mm). Re-excision rates were 7 (2.2%) in the close and 12 (10.6%) in the involved groups. No re-excised close margins contained residual cancer, but four patients had had re-excised involved margins. Local recurrence was 5.2% in clear margins, 10.7% in non-re-excised close margins, and 8.9% in involved margins. Our data suggested that there may be survival benefit in re-excision for patients who have had close and involved margins.     

Feasibility of a truncated surveillance schedule for patients following curative intent treatment for carcinoma of the oral cavity

The purpose of this study was to determine whether a regular follow-up schedule with examination by clinicians results in a better detection rate of disease recurrence and eventual better clinical outcomes when compared to patients who present with symptoms to the clinic and are subsequently detected to have a recurrence of oral squamous cell carcinoma. Retrospective data from 642 patients who underwent treatment for oral squamous cell carcinoma at a tertiary level cancer centre were analysed. Of the 642 patients, 197 had recurrences of which 108 were detected on regular follow-up and 87 were detected in patients presenting out of schedule with symptoms; two patients were detected to have recurrence at another centre, but their mode of detection could not be ascertained. There was no difference in the loco-regional recurrence-free survival or disease-free survival between the two groups. A strict follow-up schedule in the first year followed by a more flexible symptom-based schedule in the subsequent years, with supplementation of imaging if clinically indicated, should be an adequate surveillance plan for oral cancer patients.     

Outcome of tooth transplantation: survival and success rates 17-41 years posttreatment.

The literature contains no follow-up studies of transplanted teeth with mean observation times exceeding 10 years. This article describes long-term outcomes, including gingival and periodontal conditions, and the patients' attitudes about treatment and outcome. The material comprised all accessible patients in the files of the Department of Orthodontics, University of Oslo, Norway, on whom treatment had been performed at least 17 years ago (n = 28). Established clinical criteria were used to assess tooth mobility, plaque and gingival indexes, and probing pocket depth. Standardized radiography was used to evaluate the presence of pathology, pulp obliteration, and root length. Similar recordings were obtained from the in situ tooth contralateral to the initial position of the grafted tooth. Criteria for determining treatment success were established. All patients responded to questions about their treatment using visual analogue scales. The mean age at surgery was 11.5 years, and the mean observation period was 26.4 years (range, 17-41 years). Of the 33 teeth transplanted in the 28 patients, 3 teeth were lost after 9, 10, and 29 years, respectively. Therefore, the 30 teeth in the 25 patients we examined yielded a survival rate of 90%. The success rate was 79% because 2 transplants had ankylosed, and 2 others failed to fulfill the proposed criteria. The patients generally responded very favorably regarding their perception of the treatment. Their only hesitation was related to some discomfort during surgery. It was concluded that survival and success rates for teeth autotransplanted when the root is partly developed compare favorably in a long-term perspective with other treatment modalities for substituting missing teeth.     

Can we reduce excision margins for head and neck melanoma? A 12-year retrospective study

Although wide local excision is the standard treatment for primary melanoma, the surgical margin remains controversial. Melanomas of the head and neck exhibit higher recurrence rates and worse prognosis than lesions in other body locations, and their close proximity to critical anatomical and functional structures means that wide excision margins are often not feasible. Surgeons must therefore achieve a balance of oncological safety and functional and aesthetic needs. The aim of this study was to retrospectively analyse melanoma data over a 12-year period at a large skin surgery unit to identify potential differences in outcomes in patients who had reduced wide local excision margins for primary head and neck melanoma. The study would provide further evidence for the need for large randomised prospective trials to reduce excision margins for head and neck melanoma. Local cancer network data were retrospectively analysed over a period of 12 years (2008-2019). Data included site, initial stage, multidisciplinary team (MDT) meeting recommendations for excision margins and the actual wide local excision margin taken, recurrence rate, and disease-specific and absolute survival. A total of 222/305 patients (73%) had the recommended excision margin, while in 27% margins were reduced due to anatomical or functional considerations. Recurrence rates were similar (recommended 11.7% vs narrow 13.3% excision margins) (p = 0.64). The mean follow-up time for all patients was 48.5 months. In aesthetically and functionally sensitive areas of the head and neck, wide local excision margins need to be carefully considered after MDT discussion and discussion with the patient. This study suggests the need for further multicentre trials to address the uniqueness of head and neck melanoma.     

Influence of close resection margins on local recurrence and disease-specific survival in oral and oropharyngeal carcinoma

There is a lack of consistency among published reports in the definition of what constitutes close resection margins (1-5mm) in the surgical treatment of oral and oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma (SCC). Our aim was to define what would constitute close resection margins in predicting local recurrence and disease-specific survival. The study comprised 192 previously untreated patients with oral and oropharyngeal SCC who were recruited at the Southern General Hospital, Glasgow, from 2001 to 2007 with a minimum follow-up of 2 years. Resection was the primary treatment and the surgical margins were recorded for all patients. Statistical analyses were aided by the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences, version 15.0, and MedCalc software. The status of the surgical margins was evaluated using a receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve to define the cut-off point. Cox's proportional hazard model was used to establish predictive factors for local recurrence and disease-specific survival. Of 192 patients, 23 (12%) had involved margins (<1.0mm), 107 (56%) had close margins (1.0-2.0mm (16.1%); 2.1-3.0mm (12%); 3.1-4.0mm (10.4%); 4.1-5.0mm (17.2%), and 62 (32.3%) had clear margins (>5mm). No predictive cut-off point was found that related close surgical margins to local recurrence. However, there was a significant adverse association between surgical margins ≤1.6mm and disease-specific survival. In recommending postoperative adjuvant treatment for oral and oropharyngeal SCC, we suggest that surgical margins within 2mm should be considered as the cut-off. However, other clinical and pathological prognostic factors should also be taken into consideration when recommending further treatment.     

Salvage outcomes of free tissue transfer in Liverpool: trends over 18 years (1992-2009)

Reconstruction of surgical defects in the head and neck using microvascular free tissue transfer is reliable with success rates in excess of 95%. Our previous audit (1992-1998) showed that 16% of patients required an early return to theatre, and the overall free flap salvage rate was 73%. The medical records of 37 patients who had required early return to theatre (within 7 days) after free tissue transfer were analysed to ascertain the indication for reoperation, and whether surgical intervention had been successful, taking into account the timing and cause of compromise. The results of a retrospective re-audit (1999-2004 and 2005-2009) showed that the return to theatre rate had reduced to 4% overall because of a reduction in the number of cases: those that required evacuation of a neck haematoma, and venous compromise of fasciocutaneous or perforator free flaps. Salvage of flaps was most successful when done within the first 24h, and in cases of venous compromise. Three percent of free flaps failed without attempted salvage; most were late failures. Overall survival (1992-2009) for composite free flaps (93%) was lower than for fasciocutaneous or perforator free flaps (96%). Between 2005 and 2009 our overall free flap survival rate was 98%.     

Anatomical surgical planning for oral and oropharyngeal primary carcinoma combined with adjuvant treatment where indicated is associated with improved local control

We aimed to find out whether surgical tactics that lead to a reduction in tumour-involved surgical margins also improve local control. We retrospectively reviewed a consecutive case series (n = 162) of previously untreated patients who had operations for squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) of the oral cavity or oropharynx. Extensive use was made of computed tomographic multiplanar imaging to plan primary resections. Nine patients (6%) had tumour at the resection margin. Local control at 36 months was 96%, disease-specific survival (DSS) was 86%, and overall survival (OS) was 77%. Carefully planned primary operation for SCC of the oral cavity and oropharynx to minimise tumour-involved margins combined with conventional adjuvant treatment where indicated, is associated with a high probability of local control and disease-specific survival.     

Evaluation of bone resection margins of segmental mandibulectomy for oral squamous cell carcinoma

Resection margins are frequently studied in patients with oral squamous cell carcinoma and are accepted as a constant prognostic factor. While most evidence is based on soft tissue margins, reported data for bone resection margins are scarce. The aim of this retrospective study was to evaluate and determine the utility of surgical margins in bone resections for oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma (OCSCC). The status of bone resection margins and their impact on survival was investigated in patients who had undergone segmental mandibulectomy for OCSCC. Medical records were retrieved for the years 2000–2012; 127 patients were identified and included in the study. Tumour-positive bone resection margins were found in 21% of the patients. The 5-year overall survival was significantly lower in this group (P < 0.005). Therefore, there is a need for intraoperative feedback on the status of bone resection margins to enable immediate additional resection where necessary. Although the lack of intraoperative methods for the evaluation of bone tissue has been addressed by many authors, there is still no reliable method for widespread use. Future research should focus on an objective, accurate, and rapid method of intraoperative assessment for the entire bone resection margin to optimize patient outcomes.     

Clinical evaluation of Lugol's iodine staining in the treatment of stage I-II squamous cell carcinoma of the tongue

Oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC) is often surrounded by epithelial dysplasia; leaving it unresected can result in local recurrence. Staining with Lugol's iodine solution detects epithelial dysplasia in oral mucosa, but whether it decreases local recurrence after OSCC surgery is unknown. This study investigated local recurrence rates in patients with early tongue cancer who underwent surgery using Lugol's staining. 93 patients with T1-2N0 tongue SCC underwent partial glossectomy using Lugol's staining during surgery. Resection was performed at least 5 mm from the margin of the unstained area. Patients were investigated retrospectively for local recurrence status. Postoperative histology revealed negative surgical margins for SCC or epithelial dysplasia in 81 patients, close margins for SCC in 5, positive margins for mild epithelial dysplasia in 6, and a positive margin for SCC in one. Those with a positive or a close margin for SCC underwent additional resection 2-4 weeks after surgery; one was proved histologically to have residual SCC. No patients developed local recurrence, but 2 died of neck metastasis and 2 of distant metastasis. The 5-year disease specific survival rate was 93.8%. Lugol's staining during surgery can reduce local recurrence and improve survival in patients with early tongue SCC.     

Retrospective Outcome Analysis of 39 Patients Who Underwent Lip Surgery for Cutaneous Carcinoma

Purpose

The treatment of lip carcinomas needs tumor surgical resection with safety margins respect. The aim of this study was to report the oncologic and aesthetic/functional outcomes of a retrospective monocentric case series of 39 patients treated for cutaneous lip cancer.

Methods

This retrospective study assessed 56 patients who were treated for a lip carcinoma between 2008 and 2012 and included 39 patients with cutaneous lip basal cell carcinoma or squamous cell carcinoma. Clinical, surgical and pathological data were reviewed, and patients were interviewed for follow-up data. A comparison was made between the marked surgical margins and the margins observed under microscopy after histologic process.

Results

The most frequent tumor type was basal cell carcinoma in 69.2 %. The measured surgical margins were superior to the histological margins in 24 cases (61.5 %) and were inferior in 13 cases (33.3 %). Overall survival and recurrence-free survival rates at 1 year were 97.5 and 95 % respectively.

Conclusion

Differences between the surgical margins and the final histologic margins were the main finding of this retrospective study. These differences were attributed to surgical practices and modification during the histological process. Nevertheless, we did not observe a higher rate of recurrence or death in our study than in literature.

     

Results of salvage therapy after failure of initial treatment for advanced olfactory neuroblastoma.

INTRODUCTION: Olfactory neuroblastoma is a very aggressive tumour with high rates of locoregional recurrence and distant metastasis. Therefore, salvage therapy plays an important role in control of these neoplasms. In this study, we present our experience and treatment outcomes for salvage therapy in patients with recurrent olfactory neuroblastoma. MATERIAL AND METHODS: We retrospectively analysed 17 patients treated for advanced olfactory neuroblastoma during the last 15 years. RESULTS: The disease-free 5-year survival rate was 48% in all patients and 42% in the 17 patients with recurrence or distant metastasis. Salvage therapy was performed in 6 of 8 patients with recurrence or metastasis and proved successful in 50% of them. In the patients with locoregional recurrence, the success rate of salvage radiotherapy plus neck dissection was superior to salvage chemotherapy alone. In addition, 17% of the patients with distant metastasis after initial treatment died after salvage therapy. In 15% of patients with a clinical stage N0 at initial diagnosis, nodal recurrence developed and was successfully treated with salvage therapy. CONCLUSION: Complete surgical resection, including craniofacial resection and postoperative radiotherapy without elective neck dissection, is the preferred approach in the treatment of advanced olfactory neuroblastoma. In locoregional recurrence, successful salvage therapy may include selective neck dissection and radiotherapy, but in cases of distant metastasis, the prognosis was poor.     

Clinicopathological parameters and outcome of 245 patients operated for oral squamous cell carcinoma.

INTRODUCTION: This report analysed the outcome of patients undergoing surgery for oral squamous cell carcinoma in order to identify the prognostic value of several factors. PATIENTS: A total of 245 patients were studied who had undergone surgery for oral squamous cell carcinoma between 1989 and 2002, of whom 109 had received postoperative radiation therapy. METHODS: For each patient, personal data, alcohol and tobacco consumption, symptoms, histological findings, treatment, and outcome were recorded and analysed statistically. Survival curves were calculated using the Kaplan-Meier algorithm, and the difference in survival among subgroups was examined. RESULTS: The overall 5-year survival rate in the 245 patients was 63% (72.5% at 3 years). The differences in the 5-year survival were significant (p<0.05) for the site of origin, N and pN status, TNM stage, grading, status of the resection margins, osseous infiltration, and perineural invasion. Vascular involvement as a discriminator was not statistically significant. In patients undergoing radiation therapy, only perineural invasion negatively influenced the 5-year survival prognosis (p<0.01). CONCLUSION: The overall survival rate was within the (previously) reported range. The prognostic value of many parameters is widely recognized; the combined evaluation of 'composite factors' is promising.     

Role of structures in the masticator space in selecting patients with resectable T4b oral cancer: findings from a survival analysis

Oral squamous cell cancers involving the masticatory space are staged as unresectable cancers and their treatment is difficult. Curative treatment with extensive surgery followed by adjuvant therapy is one of the treatment options. In this retrospective study, the survival of 123 patients (93 with T4a cancers, 30 with T4b cancers), treated during the period August 2009 to August 2015, was evaluated. The majority had bucco-alveolar cancers (62.6%), were male (61.8%), and were tobacco users (76.4%). The select group of T4b oral cancer patients were treated with surgery, which included infratemporal fossa clearance in all 30 patients, followed by adjuvant therapy. The masseter was the most commonly involved masticatory muscle, and 24 patients had fewer than three involved structures. Free margins were obtained in 90.2% of cases; 41.5% of cases were node-positive. One hundred and four patients (84.6%) completed adjuvant treatment. The median follow-up was 42 months. For node-negative patients with T4a and T4b cancers, the 5-year overall survival was 59% and 50.2%, respectively (P =  0.62), and 5-year disease-free survival was 64.6% and 53.5%, respectively (P =  0.01). In conclusion, the select group of patients with T4b oral cancers and less than three masticatory space structures involved had comparable outcomes to those with T4a cancers after treatment with surgery and adjuvant radiotherapy.