Complement deposition in early cardiac transplant biopsies is associated with ischemic injury and subsequent rejection episodes.

BACKGROUND: Prolonged warm or cold ischemia is associated with poor survival of cardiac transplants, and ischemic changes in early posttransplantation endomyocardial biopsies correlate with the later development of chronic rejection. In animal models, tissue ischemia has been shown to activate complement. METHODS: To determine whether ischemic changes in endomyocardial biopsies were associated with complement deposition, biopsies obtained 1-3 weeks after transplantation from 33 patients were evaluated immunohistologically for C4d and C3d deposition as well as for IgM, IgG, and IgA. The histological changes associated with ischemic injury were scored independently, using previously reported criteria without knowledge of the immunohistochemical results. RESULTS: Diffuse capillary and pericapillary deposition of C4d or C3d were detected in endomyocardial biopsies of 14 of the 33 patients. The majority of biopsies (79%) with C4d or C3d deposits had histological evidence of ischemic injury, including eight of the nine biopsies containing both C4d and C3d deposition. In contrast, only 8 of 18 (45%) of the biopsies without C4d or C3d deposition had ischemic injury. Only trace amounts of IgM and no IgG or IgA were demonstrable in the biopsies. Only 2 of the 14 biopsies with C4d or C3d deposition had evidence of moderate acute rejection, whereas 5 of the 18 biopsies without C4d or C3d deposition had moderate acute rejection. However, C4d and C3d deposition did correlate with repeated acute rejection episodes on subsequent biopsies. CONCLUSIONS: Thus, ischemic changes are associated with the activation of complement. Complement activation may in turn promote tissue injury and provide a potential target for future treatment.     

Antibody-Mediated Rejection in Human Cardiac Allografts: Evaluation of Immunoglobulins and Complement Activation Products C4d and C3d as Markers

Antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) in human heart transplantation is an immunopathologic process in which injury to the graft is in part the result of activation of complement and it is poorly responsive to conventional therapy. We evaluated by immunofluorescence (IF), 665 consecutive endomyocardial biopsies from 165 patients for deposits of immunoglobulins and complement. Diffuse IF deposits in a linear capillary pattern greater than 2+ were considered significant. Clinical evidence of graft dysfunction was correlated with complement deposits. IF 2+ or higher was positive for IgG, 66%; IgM, 12%; IgA, 0.6%; C1q, 1.8%; C4d, 9% and C3d, 10%. In 3% of patients, concomitant C4d and C3d correlated with graft dysfunction or heart failure. In these 5 patients AMR occurred 56-163 months after transplantation, and they responded well to therapy for AMR but not to treatment with steroids. Systematic evaluation of endomyocardial biopsies is not improved by the use of antibodies for immunoglobulins or C1q. Concomitant use of C4d and C3d is very useful to diagnose AMR, when correlated with clinical parameters of graft function. AMR in heart transplant patients can occur many months or years after transplant.     

Complement activation in early protocol kidney graft biopsies after living-donor transplantation

BACKGROUND: To gain insight into complement activation in kidney grafts, we studied the deposition of components from all complement pathways in protocol biopsies from living-donor recipients that were taken 1 week (median 7 days) after transplantation. METHODS: Graft protocol biopsies (n=37) were taken consecutively and stained for two-color immunofluorescence, with antibodies to C4d, C3, C1q, factor B, C6, terminal C5b-9 complement complex, mannose-binding lectin (MBL), and MBL-associated serine protease-1, combined with an endothelial marker. Light and electron microscopy were performed in all cases. Clinical acute rejection (AR), graft loss, and long-term kidney function were recorded. Baseline biopsies from 15 of the patients served as controls. RESULTS: Endothelial C4d deposition was demonstrated in peritubular capillaries in 11 of 37 cases (30%), of which 9 of 11 (82%) experienced clinical AR but only 6 of 11 (55%) experienced AR as defined by histopathologic criteria. Biopsies from three patients, two with early graft loss, showed diffuse global C4d in the glomerular endothelium with codeposition of C3 in all patients and MBL-associated serine protease-1 in one patient. Focal peritubular capillary C3 deposition was found in two additional C4d-positive cases with AR. No posttransplant deposition was demonstrated for the other components. CONCLUSIONS: Early diffuse C4d deposition in the kidney graft capillaries is closely related to acute humoral rejection, whereas focal staining may occur with mild AR or, rarely, without rejection. Codeposition of C3 indicates early AR with a higher risk of graft loss. In most cases, activation was limited to C4d, indicating efficient in situ regulation of complement activation.     

Clinical impact of complement deposition findings on biopsies in acute rejection episodes of pediatric renal transplant patients

IntroductionRejection is the most important problem for renal graft function and survival. Complement system plays a key role in immune responses from host to graft. It was demonstrated that complement system activation is related with renal fibrosis. We evaluate clinical impact of complement deposition findings on biopsies in acute rejection episodes of pediatric renal transplant patients.MethodDemographics of the patients, graft functions, acute rejection episodes and graft loss were recorded from data files of 165 pediatric renal transplant patients. Findings of 98 renal biopsies were retrospectively evaluated.ResultsThirty three patients with kidney transplant had 44 acute rejection episodes (32 pure cellular acute rejection episodes / 1 pure humoral acute rejection episode / 11 combined acute cellular and acute humoral rejection episodes) proven by biopsy. C1q staining was positive in 7 biopsies, C3 staining in 15 biopsies and, C4d staining in 15 biopsies. 26 patients had graft fibrosis. All patients with a rejection history had a significant decrease in GFR value during follow-up. Patients who did not have fibrotic changes in first biopsy had same level of deterioration of GFR when compared with patients who had fibrotic changes in first biopsy.ConclusionWe could not demonstrate a significant relation between complement deposition and renal fibrosis, and between complement deposition and GFR values. Our data demonstrated that graft outcomes and graft loss after acute rejection episodes cannot be predicted only with complement deposition on graft or only with graft fibrosis.     

Use of C4d as a Diagnostic Adjunct in Lung Allograft Biopsies

PURPOSE: Humoral allograft rejection is a defined mechanism for cardiac and renal graft dysfunction; C4d deposition, a stable component of complement activation, inversely correlates with graft survival. With the recent recognition of humoral rejection in lung grafts, we examined C4d's role as a prognostic adjunct in lung allografts. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Twenty-three lung recipients underwent biopsies for deterioration in clinical status or routine surveillance. Clinically unwell patients possessed acute rejection or bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome (BOS). Biopsies attributable to infection were excluded from the study. In addition to routine light microscopy, an attempt was made to correlate the clinical status and morphologic findings with the pattern of C4d deposition and also to compare these clinical and morphologic parameters with the other assessed immunoreactants. Panel reactive antibody testing was also carried out at various points in their post transplantation course whereby in 6 of the cases the samples were procured at exactly the same time as the tissue samples. RESULTS: The patients were segregated into two groups: those patients with recurrent acute rejection and those with BOS. In those patients with symptomatic acute rejection, all biopsies showed light microscopic and immunofluorescent evidence of humoral allograft rejection. The level of C4d was positively correlated with the degree of parenchymal injury, the hallmark being one of septal capillary necrosis. In addition, high and intermediate levels of C4d correlated with a clinical diagnosis of acute rejection. C4d was the strongest predictor of parenchymal injury and of the clinical status (p <.0001) compared to other the immunoreactants C1q, C5b-9 and immunoglobulin. There was no specific correlation between C4d deposition and the presence of acute cellular rejection. In those patients fulfilling clinical criteria of BOS, deposits of C4d as well as other immunoreactants were found in the bronchial wall as opposed to the rarity of this finding in bon-BOS patients. However the only statistically significant predictor of BOS was bronchial wall deposition of C1q. In no case were panel reactive antibodies at significant levels discovered post transplantation. CONCLUSIONS: In the context of acute rejection, C4d deposition correlates with clinical evidence of rejection and the degree of humoral rejection assessed pathologically; there is no association with the presence of histocompatibility related antibodies. It is a more specific predictor of allograft status compared to other immunoreactants. C4d deposition within the bronchial wall is a feature of BOS and hence may be used as a marker of chronic graft dysfunction. The antigenic target resulting in C4d deposition may not be histocompatibility related.     

Renal allograft C4d deposition in Chinese: Hong Kong perspective

Background: Acute rejection constitutes a significant proportion of renal allograft loss. Peritubular capillary deposition of C4d has been recognized as the footprint of humoral alloimmunity and proven to be a sensitive and specific marker for humoral rejection in the appropriate clinical context. Its presence in indication biopsies is the most important independent risk factor for graft failure. Data are, however, scarce among Chinese subjects. Methods: We retrospectively reviewed all renal graft biopsies performed from 1 April 2002 to 31 March 2006 for unexplained acute renal dysfunction or delayed graft function. Renal outcomes were assessed at the time of renal biopsy and at 1 month, 3 months, 6 months and 1 year afterwards. Survival was assessed by Kaplan–Meier analysis. Multivariate analysis was used to determine if C4d positivity is an independent risk factor for poor renal outcome. Results: Fifty‐two biopsies were included, of which 16 were positive for peritubular capillary C4d. Peritubular capillary C4d was associated with lower glomerular filtration rate and higher serum creatinine at 6 and 12 months after renal biopsies. The C4d‐positive group fares worse in terms of death‐censored graft failure, doubling of serum creatinine and reaching 50% of glomerular filtration rate at the end of the study. Peritubular capillary C4d deposition was the only significant risk factor that predicts graft failure in multivariate analysis. Conclusion: Our findings confirmed the independent prognostic value of peritubular capillary C4d staining on renal allograft survival in Chinese.     

Impact of humoral alloreactivity early after transplantation on the long-term survival of renal allografts

BACKGROUND: The contribution of humoral alloreactivity to the rejection of renal allografts is not well defined because humoral antigraft reactions are not easily detectable in transplant biopsies, and serial measurements of circulating allo-antibodies in the post-transplantation period are not routinely performed. We have developed diagnostic techniques that improve the assessment of humoral alloreactivity in vivo and in vitro. METHODS: Humoral alloreactivity in transplant biopsies derived from 218 single kidney grafts was detected by assessing the deposition of complement fragment C4d in interstitial capillaries. Circulating alloantibodies were determined in corresponding serum samples by flow cytometry using lymphoblastoid cell lines of donor DR-type as target cells and by a conventional microcytotoxicity test. The impact of capillary C4d and other selected variables on renal graft survival was calculated by univariate and multivariate analysis. RESULTS: Capillary C4d, present in 46% of biopsies from first grafts and 72% of regrafts, is related to circulating alloantibodies. Grafts with capillary C4d have a markedly shorter survival than grafts without capillary C4d (50% graft survival, 4 vs. 8 years, P = 0.0001). Among several risk factors, capillary C4d is the strongest predictor of subsequent graft loss in a multivariate analysis (relative risk, 2.1, 95% CI, 1.4 to 3.1). Humoral alloreactivity detectable within six months after transplantation has a much stronger impact on graft survival than alloreactivity detected beyond this period. CONCLUSIONS: Humoral alloreactivity, manifested by the capillary deposition of complement C4d in about 50% of biopsied renal grafts, exerts a strong impact on graft survival when it operates within six months after transplantation.     

C4d deposition in early renal allograft protocol biopsies

BACKGROUND: Deposition of the complement protein C4d in renal allograft biopsies obtained during graft dysfunction and rejection has been proposed to be a sensitive marker of antibody-mediated acute rejection. To determine the diagnostic specificity of C4d deposition, it is important to study biopsies from allografts with no evidence of dysfunction. In this study, we examined C4d deposition in protocol biopsies obtained irrespective of clinical status. METHODS: Immunohistochemistry for C4d was performed on routine protocol biopsies preimplantation and on day 7 posttransplantation from 48 unselected renal allografts. Serum samples obtained up to 1 month after transplantation were assayed for donor-reactive antibodies (DRA). Results were correlated with histopathology and clinical outcome measures. RESULTS: Diffuse C4d deposition was detected in the peritubular capillaries of 6 of 48 (13%) biopsies. C4d deposition was present in 5 of 15 (33%) biopsies that showed acute rejection (Banff 97, category 4) but only in 1 of 33 (3%) biopsies with no rejection (P=0.003, 97% specificity). Posttransplant DRAs were detected in 21 of 48 (44%) patients. All five recipients with C4d deposition and rejection had posttransplant DRA; the recipient whose biopsy showed C4d positivity, but not rejection, did not have detectable DRA. C4d deposition was not treated with plasmapheresis or intravenous immunoglobulin and was not associated with poor posttransplant graft outcome at 1-year follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: Our results show that in early posttransplant protocol biopsies, C4d is a specific marker for the presence of humoral rejection, as indicated by its association with DRA and acute histologic rejection.     

C3D deposition in peritubular capillaries indicates a variant of acute renal allograft rejection characterized by a worse clinical outcome

BACKGROUND: C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries (PTCs) is a sign of humoral renal allograft rejection and an independent predictor of graft survival. Few investigators have focused on the meaning of capillary C3 deposition in rejecting grafts. Because C3 production can result from both classic and alternative pathway activation of the complement cascade, it is not clear whether C3 deposition indicates a distinct entity of acute rejection (AR) or merely represents a separate form of C4d-positive AR. METHODS: We examined the deposition of C3d in the PTCs of recipients with AR in the first year posttransplantation (n=30). Clinical outcome variables and histology were compared with C3d-negative control patients (n=82). RESULTS: C3d-positive patients demonstrated more frequent preexisting T-cell antibodies (57%) and more re-transplants (37%), and they received more blood transfusions (mean 10.3 units). C3d-positive patients experienced more frequent multiple AR episodes (57%) and delayed graft function (36.7%). All nine C3d-positive recipients screened for posttransplantation donor-specific human leukocyte antigen antibodies demonstrated positive results. Graft failure occurred in 23% of C3d-positive recipients (7.3% in the control group) (P=0.03). C3d-positive biopsies showed significantly less tubulitis (P=0.03), whereas congestive PTCs with intraluminal accumulation of polymorphonuclear leukocytes were conspicuous. Thrombi, fibrinoid necrosis, and acute tubular necrosis were not more pronounced. In 19% of rejection biopsies, C3d deposition in PTCs was present without C4d deposition. In the remaining biopsies, C3d and C4d deposition was found simultaneously. CONCLUSIONS: The deposition of complement factor C3d in PTCs indicates a variant type of AR characterized by a worse clinical outcome.     

Peritubular capillary deposition of C4d complement fragment in ABO-incompatible renal transplantation with humoral rejection

In ABO-incompatible renal transplantation complement activation may be related to antibody-associated humoral rejection. However, immune deposits within the vasculature have been infrequently demonstrated in biopsy specimens. Whether deposition of complement fragment C4d is correlated with graft outcome and pathological findings (as measured by the severity of antibody-associated humoral rejection) is investigated in this study. Nineteen ABO-incompatible and 9 ABO-compatible renal graft biopsy specimens were selected. Four out of 19 ABO-incompatible patients lost their grafts within 1 yr. Ten out of 19 ABO-incompatible and just 1 out of 9 ABO-compatible patients, had prominent C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries. ABO-incompatible patients with predominant C4d deposition showed few tubulitis, accumulation of polymorphonuclear cells and thrombosis in peritubular and glomerular capillaries. The severity of the humoral rejection was correlated to C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries. Three out of four graft losses in ABO-incompatible renal transplantation showed severe humoral rejection and profuse deposition of C4d complement fragments in peritubular capillaries. Immunosuppression therapy was discontinued in the 4th patient, who lost his graft because of his lethal intestinal bleeding. C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries would be helpful for differential diagnosis between humoral rejection and drug-induced nephrotoxicity, and may serve as a sensitive marker of ABO-incompatible humoral rejection for patients with unsatisfactory (no glomeruli) biopsy specimens.     

C4d staining of perioperative renal transplant biopsies

BACKGROUND: Deposition of C4d in peritubular capillaries (PTCs) has been shown to be a sensitive marker for antibody-mediated (humoral) rejection in renal transplant biopsies. Some studies also suggest that C4d in PTCs is specific for humoral rejection or, at least, for the presence of donor-specific antibodies. However, in other studies, PTC C4d deposits were noted in more than 40% of renal transplant biopsies performed for graft dysfunction and capillary C4d deposition in heart transplants may result from ischemic injury. METHODS: To test the specificity of C4d staining as a marker for acute humoral rejection ACR in renal allografts, indirect immunofluorescence using a monoclonal anti-C4d antibody and a fluorescein-isothiocyanate-conjugated secondary antibody was performed on cryostat sections of 90 renal transplant biopsies, including 35 pairs of preimplantation and 1-hr postreperfusion biopsies of the same graft, postreperfusion biopsies of 12 additional grafts, and 8 positive controls (biopsies with known C4d-positive AHR). Eighteen grafts were cadaveric, 17 grafts were liviing-related, and 12 grafts were living-unrelated (excluding controls). Included in these grafts were 13 grafts that developed AHR 3 to 34 days posttransplantation. RESULTS: Only 2 of 82 perioperative biopsies showed C4d staining in PTCs. Both perioperative biopsies were postreperfusion biopsies of grafts diagnosed with AHR 5 and 34 days posttransplantation, respectively, and, in each case, the recipient had been treated with plasmapheresis before transplantation because of a positive crossmatch (cytotoxic and flow cytometric) and continued to have a weakly positive flow crossmatch at the time of transplantation. In one biopsy, C4d staining was focal, and in the other biopsy, it was diffuse; in both biopsies, C4d staining was relatively mild (1+ on a 0-4+ scale). No C4d staining was noted on preimplantation biopsies of each graft. All biopsies that contained glomeruli showed linear capillary loop or blotchy mesangial staining, or both, which was similar in prereperfusion and postreperfusion biopsies. All positive controls showed diffuse C4d staining in PTCs.CONCLUSIONS: C4d staining in PTCs may be seen as early as 1 hr posttransplantation in some recipients with low levels of antidonor antibodies. However, this was not observed as a feature of ischemic or ischemia-reperfusion injury in perioperative renal transplant biopsies, including those of cadaveric grafts with cold ischemia times of as long as 41 hr.     

Endothelial C4d deposition is associated with inferior kidney allograft outcome independently of cellular rejection.

BACKGROUND: Capillary deposition of complement split product C4d has been suggested to be a valuable marker for humoral rejection. In this retrospective study we evaluated the clinical impact of C4d deposition in renal allografts with special emphasis on associations between C4d staining patterns and histological features of acute rejection. METHODS: One hundred and two allograft biopsies obtained from 61 kidney transplants (1-532 days after transplantation; median 14 days) were examined by immunohistochemistry on routine paraffin sections using a novel anti-C4d polyclonal antibody (C4dpAb). RESULTS: Fourty-two of 102 biopsies showed endothelial C4d deposits in peritubular capillaries (PTC). Histopathological analysis revealed a significantly lower frequency of positive C4d staining in biopsies with rather than in those without acute cellular rejection defined by the Banff grading schema (P<0.01). For clinical evaluation, patients were classified according to C4d staining in allografts (C4d(PTC) positive in at least one biopsy, n=31 vs C4d(PTC) negative in all biopsies, n=30). C4d(PTC) positive patients had significantly higher serum creatinine levels than C4d negative patients. Even in the absence of morphological evidence for rejection, differences in serum creatinine levels between C4d(PTC) positive and negative recipients were significant (6 months: 2.01+/-0.75 vs 1.41+/-0.27 mg/dl; 12 months: 1.95+/-0.60 vs 1.36+/- 0.34 mg/dl; 18 months: 1.98+/-0.50 vs 1.47+/-0.31 mg/dl; P<0.05). All patients with rejection resistant to conventional therapy (n=4) were in the C4d(PTC) positive subgroup. All recipients with panel reactive antibodies (PRA) >50% (n=8) were C4d(PTC) positive. CONCLUSIONS: Our data indicate that endothelial C4d deposition is associated with inferior graft outcome. We provide evidence that this immunohistochemical finding and its clinical impact are not associated with morphological signs of cellular rejection.     

C4D Immunostaining in Surveillance Endomyocardial Biopsies From Well-Functioning Heart Allografts

Objective

The meaning of biopsy C4d detection in heart allografts without dysfunction or morphologic changes suggesting antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) is not clear. The aim of this study was to search for an association between C4d detection in allograft biopsies of well-functioning hearts without changes suggestive of AMR, and clinical outcomes.

Methods

Endomyocardial protocol biopsies from 44 heart transplant patients with well-functioning grafts and without changes suggesting AMR were performed at 1 month and 1 year after transplantation and analyze the presence of C4d deposition using immunohistochemistry. Two-year follow-up was based on clinical parameters and echocardiographic information. Heart graft function was categorized as good vs. poor. The presence of C4d, using diverse schemes to graduate the extension of the deposition, was correlated with clinical graft outcomes.

Results

C4d deposition was observed in the capillary walls of 33 biopsies (37.5%; n = 25 patients; 56.8%). No biopsy had diffuse (>50%) immunostaining. Six patients presented with multifocal capillary C4d immunostaining in at least 1 biopsy. Capillary positivity for C4d (if focal or multifocal) showed no statistical association with cellular rejection or graft function. Perimyocytic C4d detection was neither associated with rejection nor graft outcome.

Conclusion

Our work failed to demonstrate an association between C4d detection in protocol biopsies of heart grafts and clinical outcomes. The clinical utility of C4d staining in solid organ transplantation may vary by organ. Our results suggest that C4d did not have clinical utility in surveillance biopsies of well-functioning heart grafts without morphological changes suggesting AMR.     

Capillary deposition of complement C4d and C3d in pediatric renal allograft biopsies

BACKGROUND: Peritubular capillary deposition of C4d (C4d(PTC)) is a marker of antibody-mediated alloresponse and is associated with poor graft survival in adults. C3d(PTC) has received less attention; its significance is unclear. To date no information has been gained in children. METHODS: The prevalence of C4d(PTC) and C3d(PTC) in pediatric renal allograft biopsies (n=77, 31 cadaveric kidneys) was analyzed retrospectively. Associations with histology, donor-specific antibodies (DSAs), and outcome were investigated. RESULTS: The overall prevalence of C4d(PTC) and C3d(PTC) was 52% and 48%, respectively. C3d(PTC) was associated with C4d(PTC) (P<0.0001). Thirty-six percent of acute rejections were cellular, 28% were humoral, and 36% were combined cellular and humoral. C3d(PTC) was found in 57% of acute rejection biopsies. C4d(PTC), but not C3d(PTC), was associated with accumulation of polymorphonuclear cells in peritubular capillaries (P=0.02). Fifty-one percent of late biopsies (>6 months posttransplantation) had features of chronic allograft nephropathy: 50% were C4d(PTC_ positive, and 50% were C3d(PTC) positive. C4d(PTC) positive chronic allograft nephropathy biopsies had more transplant glomerulopathy (P=0.020) and mesangial matrix increase (P=0.026). C3d(PTC) tended to be associated with transplant glomerulopathy (P=0.06), but not with mesangial matrix increase. C4d(PTC) was correlated with DSA (P=0.011). Excluding early nonrejection graft losses, more grafts were lost in the C4d(PTC) positive group (P=0.019). C3d(PTC) was not associated with DSA or graft outcome. CONCLUSIONS: Our results support C4d(PTC) being a hallmark of humoral rejection in pediatric renal transplantation; its presence was associated with DSA and poorer immunologic graft outcome. In contrast, C3d(PTC), although highly associated with C4d(PTC), did not correlate with DSA or outcome.     

C4d and/or immunoglobulins deposition in peritubular capillaries in perioperative graft biopsies in ABO-incompatible renal transplantation

Abstract:  We evaluated 0 h and/or 1 h graft biopsy specimens from 14 recipients in ABO-incompatible renal transplantation using immunofluorescence for C4d, IgG, and IgM. All 0 h biopsy specimens revealed negative C4d, IgG, and IgM deposition in peritubular capillaries (PTC). In contrast, 8 of 14 1 h biopsy specimens revealed a positive C4d deposition in PTC. Eight specimens revealed positive IgM staining and seven of them had both C4d and IgM depositions. Three specimens had C4d, IgM, and IgG depositions in PTC. Three of eight patients with C4d deposition and two of six patients without C4d deposition in the 1 h biopsy group suffered from acute rejection within 1 month of transplantation. These findings suggest that complement fragments and immunoglobulin deposition in PTC in ABO-incompatible renal grafts can start soon after reperfusion, although acute rejection may or may not develop.     

C4d deposition and cellular infiltrates as markers of acute rejection in rat models of orthotopic lung transplantation

BACKGROUND: C4d is a useful marker of antibody-mediated rejection in cardiac and renal transplants, but clinical studies examining correlations between circulating alloantibodies, C4d deposition, and rejection in lung transplants have yielded conflicting results. METHODS: We studied circulating alloantibody levels and C4d deposition in two rat models of lung transplantation: Brown Norway (BN) to Wistar-Kyoto (WKY) and PVG.R8 to PVG.1U lung allografts. The availability of C6 deficient (C6-) and C6 sufficient (C6+) PVG 1U rats allowed evaluation of the effects of the terminal complement components on graft injury and C4d deposition. RESULTS: The lung allografts had histologic features resembling human posttransplant capillaritis, characterized by neutrophilic infiltration of alveoli, edema, and hemorrhage. Immunoperoxidase stains on cross sections of allografts showed intense, diffuse, C4d deposition in a continuous linear pattern on the vascular endothelium. C4d deposits were found in both BN to WKY and PVG R8 to 1U allografts, whereas no staining was detectable in WKY to WKY isografts or native lungs. Complement deposition was associated with vascular disruption in C6+, but not in C6- recipients. The presence of circulating donor-specific alloantibodies was verified by flow cytometry. Cell-specific staining revealed perivascular accumulation of macrophages and T lymphocytes whereas neutrophils were sequestered in the intravascular and alveolar capillary compartments. CONCLUSIONS: The deposition of C4d on vascular endothelium as well as the coincident presence of alloantibodies is consistent with previous findings in antibody-mediated rejection of renal and cardiac transplants. Furthermore, the histological features of our allografts support the concept that posttransplant capillaritis is a form of humoral rejection.     

Diagnostic value of C4d in renal allograft biopsies in different clinical settings: absence of C4d in grafts from non-heart-beating donors

Humoral mechanisms of rejection after kidney transplantation (TX) can be identified through the detection of diffuse complement C4d deposits in peritubular capillaries (PTC) in graft biopsies or donor-specific antibodies (DSA) in serum samples. It has been hypothesized that ischemic injury in the graft may facilitate humoral responses. Kidney grafts from non-heart-beating donors (NHBD) present more often severe ischemia lesions than grafts from heart-beating or living donors. METHODS: We reviewed kidney TX biopsies performed from May 2002 to November 2004 with special interest paid to recipients from NHBD. We checked corresponding frozen tissue for the detection of C4d in PTC using immunofluorescence with a monoclonal antibody against C4d. We also collected post-TX contemporaneous DSA data, either flow crossmatches or cytotoxic PRA. RESULTS: During this period, we performed 22 kidney TXs from NHBD of a total of 326 kidney TX (either single or combined with other grafts). Nine patients of this group underwent 12 biopsies for delayed graft function over 15 days or deteriorating scans. All biopsies showed acute tubular necrosis, but one also presented IA Banff acute rejection and another one had neutrophils in PTC. Frozen tissue from these 12 biopsies did not have diffuse C4d deposits in PTC. Serum samples of seven of nine patients were available: four had negative DSA flow crossmatches and three had 0% PRA within the same period. We diagnosed acute humoral rejection (AHR) in 13 patients-with acute renal dysfunction, C4d in biopsies and DSA after kidney TX-of 38 with high clinical suspicion for AHR. We detected C4d in seven biopsies of 30 patients performed more than 6 months after TX. CONCLUSIONS: Severe ischemic injury does not necessarily determine the activation of humoral mechanisms of rejection mediated through DSA. Therefore, C4d is extremely interesting for the identification of humoral rejection in any clinical setting after kidney TX.     

C4d—The Witness of Humoral Rejection

Objective

Acute antibody-mediated (humoral) rejection is a major cause of morbidity, graft loss, and mortality among heart transplant patients. Herein we have presented our experience using C4d to characterize humoral rejection.

Materials and Methods

All nonformalin-fixed cardiac graft biopsies (protocol or emergency) received between May 2007 and May 2008 were examined by immunofluorescence for C4d.

Results

One hundred twelve endomyocardial biopsies from 25 transplanted patients included 20 males and 5 females of ages ranging from 3 to 71 years. The number of biopsies per subject varied from 1 to 11; the timespan between transplantation and the diagnostic biopsies ranged from days to 8 years. Thirteen biopsies showed acute humoral rejection (intramyocardial capillaries positive for C4d); 31, acute cellular rejection (grades 1R, 2R); 7, both humoral and cellular rejection; and 1, acute humoral rejection and allograft vasculopathy. Some of the positive biopsies belonged to the same person, and some to transplanted individuals with signs and symptoms suggestive of rejection, while others did not. The persistence of humoral rejection, despite the disappearance of a cellular component, correlated with slower clinicoechocardiographic improvement.

Conclusions

C4d positivity is a morphologic sign of humoral rejection. It may hasten the appearance and/or worsening of allograft vasculopathy independent of patient age or posttransplantation time.     

Acute humoral rejection and C4d immunostaining in ABO blood type-incompatible liver transplantation.

Complement C4d deposition in graft capillaries has been reported to be associated with antibody-mediated rejection in kidney and other solid organ transplantation. The correlation of C4d deposits and humoral rejection in liver transplants, however, is not well understood. We investigated the C4d immunostaining pattern in 34 patients whose liver biopsy was taken within the first 3 postoperative weeks for suspected acute rejection after ABO blood type-incompatible liver transplantation. The staining pattern was classified as positive (portal stromal staining), indeterminate (endothelial staining only), and negative (no staining). Positive C4d immunostaining was seen in 17 (50%) patients and was significantly associated with high (x64 or more) postoperative antidonor A/B antibody (immunoglobulin M (IgM)) titers (88 vs. 35%, P = 0.002) and poorer overall survival rate (41 vs. 88%, P = 0.007). Ten of 11 (91%) cases with histological acute humoral rejection (periportal edema and necrosis (PEN) or portal hemorrhagic edema) were positive for C4d, all of which showed high postoperative antibody titers. The other histologies associated with C4d positivity was purulent cholangitis (n = 4), coagulative hepatocyte necrosis (n = 1), acute cellular rejection (n = 1), and hepatocanalicular cholestasis (n = 1). Full clinical recovery was observed in only 6 of 17 (35%) C4d-positive patients, and tended to be associated with a lower rejection activity index (RAI). In conclusion, our study indicates that C4d deposits in the portal stroma can be a hallmark of acute humoral rejection in ABO-incompatible liver transplantation, and allograft damage can be reversible in a minority of cases.