Procedural guidelines for performing immunophenotyping by flow cytometry

Flow cytometry is a rapidly expanding technology that is moving from the research laboratory into the clinical laboratory. Recent advances in availability and reproducibility of monoclonal antibody reagents specific for a wide range of cell types coupled with lower costs for increasingly automated flow cytometers with powerful and user friendly data analysis capabilities have made flow cytometry the method of choice for immunophenotyping in the clinical laboratory. However, there is great variability in the level and type of quality assurance procedures used from laboratory to laboratory. A subcommittee established by the National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards (NCCLS), composed of representatives from industry, academia, professional societies, and regulatory agencies, has drafted consensus procedures which address specific problems and suggested solutions for performance of immunophenotyping by flow cytometry. This paper is based on the authors' discussions with the NCCLS Committee but does not represent an official NCCLS position. The official NCCLS document on this subject (H42) is expected to be published in 1989.     

A relational database for diagnosis of hematopoietic neoplasms using immunophenotyping by flow cytometry

A relational database was developed to facilitate the diagnosis of hematopoietic neoplasms using results of immunophenotyping by flow cytometry. This database runs on personal computers and uses backward-chaining search to arrive at conclusions. Results of immunologic marker studies are processed by the database to obtain a set of differential diagnoses. The current version of this database includes diagnostic immunophenotyping pattern for 33 hematopoietic neoplasms. We tested this database using 92 clinical cases from 2 tertiary care medical centers. The database ranked the actual diagnosis as 1 of the top 5 differential diagnoses in 93% of the cases tested. The user can modify the database contents to suit individual needs. This database has been posted on the World Wide Web for direct access. We propose that this user-friendly database is a potential tool for computer-assisted diagnosis of hematopoietic neoplasms.     

A java-based application for differential diagnosis of hematopoietic neoplasms using immunophenotyping by flow cytometry

We describe the implementation of a Java-based application for differential diagnosis of hematopoietic neoplasms using immunophenotyping by flow cytometry. The current version of this Java applet includes the knowledge-base for 33 hematopoietic neoplasms and 43 diagnostic immunophenotyping markers. Java, a new object-oriented computing language, helps facilitate development of this applet, a platform-independent module that can be implemented on the World Wide Web. As the Web rapidly becomes more accessible to users around the world, Web-based software may eventually form the core of decision-support systems in clinical settings. Java-based applications, such as the one described in this paper, are expected to contribute significantly in this area.     

Validation and quality control of immunophenotyping in clinical flow cytometry

Clinical flow cytometry has evolved from two-parameter quantitative assessment of peripheral blood lymphocytes to six-parameter qualitative evaluation of bone marrow for hematopathology. Leukemia and lymphoma immunophenotyping represent an extremely important complement to morphology in the diagnosis and monitoring of hematopoietic malignancies. The complexity of five- and six-parameter analyses and the interpretation of the data rely on standardization and validation of the instrument, the reagents and the procedure. In addition, flow cytometry laboratories in the U.S. are required to document proficiency testing, sample preparation, method accuracy, specificity, sensitivity and precision. NCCLS and the U.S.-Canadian Consensus Conference have provided recommendations, but each laboratory is ultimately responsible for validating its own qualitative and quantitative procedures. This paper reviews procedures for validation and quality control of all aspects of the operation of a clinical flow cytometry service.     

Acute promyelocytic leukemia: four distinct patterns by flow cytometry immunophenotyping

A total of 97 acute promyelocytic leukemia (APL) patients with adequate flow cytometry (FC) data, bone marrow aspirates and presence of t(15;17)/PML-RARA by cytogenetics and/or FISH studies were analyzed for immunophenotypic pattern. Leukemic cells had the following phenotype: CD11b-, CD11c-, CD13+, CD33+, CD45+, CD64+/-, CD117+, and HLA-DR-. A subset of cases showed also an expression of CD2, CD4, CD34, and CD56. Based on the immunophenotype and side scatter properties (SSC), four FC patterns were recognized. The majority of cases represented classical (hypergranular) APL and were characterized by high SSC, positive CD117, lack of CD34, heterogeneous CD13, and bright CD33 (pattern 1). Second most common type, corresponding to the hypogranular (microgranular) variant of APL differed from classical APL by low SSC and frequent co-expression of CD2 and CD34 (pattern 2). Rare cases of APL (pattern 3) showed a mixture of neoplastic cells (low SSC/CD2+/CD13+/CD33+/CD34+/CD117+) and prominent population of benign granulocytes/maturing myeloid precursors (high SSC/CD10+/-/CD16+/-/ CD117-). One case showed two APL populations, one with hypogranular and one with hypergranular characteristics (pattern 4). Apart from a well-known FC pattern of hypergranular APL, we presented less common immunophenotypic variants of APL, which helps to identify an additional group of patients who would benefit from fast confirmatory FISH and/or PCR testing for t(15;17)/PML-RARA.     

An automated method to prepare cell suspensions from human biopsy samples for immunophenotyping by flow cytometry

A comparison was made between a manual and automated method for preparing single cell suspensions from various types of human biopsy samples. The automated method uses the shearing action of fluid movement generated by a reciprocating paddle system. When compared on 11 samples, the automated instrument always isolated cells in less time, usually requiring only 15-30 seconds in contrast to 10-15 minutes for the manual method. The time comparisons involved "set up" time of the required minor equipment as well as the time to make a complete single cell suspension from the portion of the biopsy sample sent to the Flow Cytometry Lab so extra cells could be used for other purposes and cryogenically stored for future reference. Cells isolated by the automated method from various B-lymphocytic and T-lymphocytic malignancies were still viable and could be successfully immunophenotyped by flow cytometry. The immunophenotyping results were compared for both cell isolation methods on seven of these samples, and the results were comparable. The automated technique has now been used to satisfactorily immunophenotype more than 50 biopsy samples. The automated method should represent a significant aid for clinical flow cytometry laboratories performing immunophenotyping tests by efficiently preparing single cell suspensions in a few seconds instead of minutes. Furthermore, the automated method uses a closed sterile bag system that helps minimize the exposure of personnel to potential infectious material present in biopsy samples and prevents external contamination of cell suspensions. The automated technique proven successful for immunophenotyping may also be helpful for related procedures involving hematopoietic malignancies such as DNA content analysis and cell functional assays by flow cytometry, as well as other assays such as tissue typing, gene probe, and in vitro chemosensitivity assays.     

Role of fine-needle aspirate immunophenotyping by flow cytometry in rapid diagnosis of lymphoproliferative disorders

Immunophenotyping is an essential component in the diagnostic work-up of lymphoproliferative disorders (LPD). As compared to immunohistochemistry, flow cytometric immunophenotyping (FCMI) is rapid, quantitative and a more objective technique. This study was designed to evaluate the utility of FCMI on fine needle aspirates (FNA) in rapid diagnosis of LPD in routine clinical practice. FNA from 31 consecutive cases clinically suggestive of LPD were subjected to FCMI. Representative material for FCMI was obtained in 28 (90%) cases and a definite diagnosis established in 27 cases. Histopathogical correlation was available in 22 cases and concordance with FCMI results was observed in 19 (86.4%) cases. FCMI analysis was inconclusive in 4 cases. The results of FCMI were available the same day and were crucial for therapeutic purpose in 3 patients with superior vena cava syndrome. FCMI combined with cytological examination of aspirate smears permits rapid diagnosis with high level of accuracy resulting in efficient treatment planning for critically ill patients and those from far-off rural areas.     

Critical analysis and diagnostic usefulness of limited immunophenotyping of B-cell non-Hodgkin lymphomas by flow cytometry

We report the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) of various immunophenotypes characteristic of each class of B-cell non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL) based on analysis of 352 morphologically well-characterized B-cell NHLs and 175 benign lymph nodes (LNs) using 2-color flow cytometry. All B-cell NHLs that exhibited a characteristic immunophenotype (except diffuse large B-cell lymphoma) had a high NPV. The immunophenotypes of small lymphocytic lymphoma and mantle cell lymphoma showed high specificity, but only small lymphocytic lymphoma also showed a high PPV. One third of follicular lymphomas coexpressed CD23 and CD10. Diffuse large B-cell NHL showed no consistent immunophenotype. About 90% of all benign LNs expressed no substantial amounts of CD5, CD10, or CD23. Most benign LNs also failed to express substantial amounts of immunoglobulin heavy chains. In contrast, about 90% of NHLs showed expression of 1 or 2 heavy chains. The expression pattern of immunoglobulin light chains was not found helpful in favoring one lymphoma type over another. The usefulness of each immunophenotype for each lymphoma group is of particular diagnostic importance in limited specimens, such as fine-needle aspiration biopsies, small core biopsies, body effusions, extranodal sites, and nodal tissues with various artifacts.     

Clinical applications of flow cytometry and cell immunophenotyping to companion animals (dog and cat)

Clinical applications of flow cytometry to certain diseases of the dog and cat are now possible. The utility of such applications for diagnosis, prognosis and follow-up are illustrated here by a number of examples: feline AIDS resulting from FIV infection, Leukocyte Adhesion Deficiency in Irish setters, deep pyoderma in German shepherds, Immune-mediated Thrombocytopenia, canine Systemic Lupus Erythematosus and Leishmaniasis, Leukemia and Lymphoma.     

Lymphocyte immunophenotyping in an elderly population: age, sex and medication effects--a flow cytometry study

Flow cytometry studies of 179 individuals aged 55-95 years reveal correlations of various hematological and immune cell measures (quantification of leukocytes, leukocyte subtypes, platelets, and erythrocytes) with age, sex, common medications (aspirin, ulcer therapy, estrogen replacement therapy), and health history variables (minor arthritis, allergy, smoking, stress and exercise). Possible reasons for some of these findings are discussed.     

Lymphoid and myeloid neoplasms involving cerebrospinal fluid: comparison of morphologic examination and immunophenotyping by flow cytometry

We studied 53 samples of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) by cytologic examination and immunophenotyping by flow cytometry. The samples were taken from 43 patients; 25 had a previous diagnosis of malignant lymphoma/leukemia and the remaining 18 a variety of other diseases involving the central nervous system (CNS). Lymphoma/leukemia was detected in 21 samples: 12 by morphologic examination and immunophenotyping and nine by immunophenotyping alone. There were two cases with a suspicious morphologic examination and negative immunophenotyping in which the final diagnosis were cryptococcal and viral meningitis. In the group of 18 patients, one was diagnosed as a primary malignant lymphoma of the CNS and was positive with cytology and immunophenotyping. The other 17 were negative with both methods and follow-up showed no evidence of lymphoma/leukemia. This study shows that morphologic examination combined with flow cytometry enhances the detection rate by 75% over morphologic examination alone in CSF samples.     

Utility of flow cytometry immunophenotyping for the diagnosis and classification of lymphoma in community hospital clinical needle aspiration/biopsies

CONTEXT: Flow cytometry immunophenotyping (FC) of needle aspiration/biopsy (NAB) samples has been reported to be useful for the diagnosis and classification of lymphoma in university and cancer center-based settings. Nevertheless, there is no agreement on the utility of these methods. OBJECTIVE: To further define the utility of adjunctive FC of clinical NAB for the diagnosis and classification of lymphoma, and to determine if this approach is practicable in a routine clinical practice setting. SETTING: A community-based hospital. METHODS: Clinical NABs were submitted for adjunctive FC between June 1996 and September 1999 if initial smears were suspicious for lymphoma. Smears and cell block or needle core tissues were routinely processed and paraffin-section immunostains were performed if indicated. The final diagnosis was determined by correlating clinical and pathologic data, and the revised European-American classification criteria were used to subtype lymphomas. RESULTS: Needle aspiration/biopsies from 60 different patients were submitted for FC. Final diagnoses were lymphoma (n = 38), other neoplasm (n = 15), benign (n = 6), or insufficient (n = 1). For 38 lymphomas (20 primary, 18 recurrent), patients ranged in age from 32 to 86 years (mean, 62 years); samples were obtained from the retroperitoneum (n = 11), lymph node (n = 9), abdomen (n = 8), mediastinum (n = 6), or other site (n = 4); and lymphoma subtypes were indolent B-cell (n = 20; 2 small lymphocytic, 14 follicle center, 4 not subtyped), aggressive B-cell (n = 14; 3 mantle cell, 10 large cell, 1 not subtyped), B-cell not further specified (n = 2), or Hodgkin disease (n = 2). For the diagnosis of these lymphomas, FC was necessary in 20 cases, useful in 14 cases, not useful in 2 cases, and misleading in 2 cases. Thirty-two of 36 lymphoma patients with follow-up data received antitumor therapy based on the results of NAB plus FC. CONCLUSIONS: Adjunctive FC of NABs is potentially practicable in a community hospital, is necessary or useful for the diagnosis and subtyping of most B-cell lymphomas, and can help direct lymphoma therapy. Repeated NAB or surgical biopsy is necessary for diagnosis or treatment in some cases.     

Value of multi-parameter flow cytometry immunophenotyping in T/NK-cell neoplasms in cytology specimens: A retrospective study in Chinese patients

BackgroundInnate limitations of morphological diagnosis of T/NK-cell neoplasms mean that they can be misdiagnosed or missed, especially when mixed with a variety of benign and reactive conditions. The aim of this study was to investigate the application value of multiparameter flow cytometry immunophenotyping (MFCI) in screening and diagnosing T/NK-cell neoplasms with cytology specimens.Material and methodsThe clinical and pathological characteristics of 1028 newly diagnosed cases from Fudan University Shanghai Cancer Center who provided a cytology specimen between June 2010 and January 2016 with correlated histology diagnosis and clinical confirmation were retrospectively reviewed. MFCI was used for screening, diagnosis and typing. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) in diagnosis of T/NK-cell neoplasms were calculated.ResultsThere were 606 males and 422 females in 1028cases, with a mean age of 47.5 years (range 9–86 years). Specimens used for cytologic diagnosis included 996 FNAs, 2 US-FNAs, 13 EUS-FNAs and 17 effusions. Screening for types of lymphoma of MFCI, 139 (13.52 %) cases were T/NK cell lymphoma, 3 (0.29 %) cases were B cell lymphoma T-NHL and B-NHL coexist. A total of 146 suspected T/NK-cell neoplasms were screened out (sensitivity = 94.64 %, specificity = 95.63 % PPV = 72.60 %, NPV = 99.32 %) by MFCI, with 112 (76.71 %) histologically confirmed cases and 6 (4.11 %) false-negative cases identified (3 cases diagnosed as B-cell neoplasms and 1 case as T-cell neoplasm with B-cell neoplasm, which also were confirmed by gene rearrangement. 2 cases were suspicious T-cell–immunophenotypic abnormalities). When used at the diagnostic level, a total of 88 T/NK-cell neoplasms were identified (sensitivity = 68.75 %, specificity = 98.80 %, PPV = 87.50 %, NPV = 96.28 %) with 11 false-positive cases recognized, 9 of which showed typical immunophenotypic T-cell neoplasms features, and 2 exhibited aberrant T immunophenotype.ConclusionsMFCI has high sensitivity and specificity in the screening and diagnosis of T/NK-cell neoplasms and may be useful as an alternative diagnosis method in cytology specimens.     

A general method for bead-enhanced quantitation by flow cytometry

Flow cytometry provides accurate relative cellular quantitation (percent abundance) of cells from diverse samples, but technical limitations of most flow cytometers preclude accurate absolute quantitation. Several quantitation standards are now commercially available which, when added to samples, permit absolute quantitation of CD4+ T cells. However, these reagents are limited by their cost, technical complexity, requirement for additional software and/or limited applicability. Moreover, few studies have validated the use of such reagents in complex biological samples, especially for quantitation of non-T cells. Here we show that addition to samples of known quantities of polystyrene fluorescence standardization beads permits accurate quantitation of CD4+ T cells from complex cell samples. This procedure, here termed single bead-enhanced cytofluorimetry (SBEC), was equally capable of enumerating eosinophils as well as subcellular fragments of apoptotic cells, moieties with very different optical and fluorescent characteristics. Relative to other proprietary products, SBEC is simple, inexpensive and requires no special software, suggesting that the method is suitable for the routine quantitation of most cells and other particles by flow cytometry.