Evaluation of rapid antigen point-of-care tests for detection of Giardia and Cryptosporidium species in human fecal specimens

In Bangladesh, a new parasite rapid antigen test was investigated demonstrating accuracy and feasibility. For Giardia species, it had a sensitivity and specificity of 94% and 100%, respectively. For Cryptosporidium species, it had a sensitivity and specificity of 100% and 100%, respectively. These are higher than or equal to the sensitivities and specificities of other tests on the market.     

Evaluation of seven commercial antigen detection tests for Giardia and Cryptosporidium in stool samples

Stool samples from patients with abdominal symptoms were used to evaluate different copro-diagnostic assays for the detection of Giardia and Cryptosporidium. Results from microscopical examination following conventional stool concentration and direct fluorescent-antibody methods were compared with various commercially available immunochromatographic and enzyme immunoassays. Of 220 samples, 45 were positive for Giardia and 17 for Cryptosporidium. For Giardia, the sensitivities obtained by Ridascreen Giardia, Rida Quick Giardia, Rida Quick Combi and Giardia-Strip were 82%, 80%, 80% and 44%, respectively. For Cryptosporidium, the sensitivities obtained by Rida Quick Cryptosporidium, Ridascreen Cryptosporidium, Rida Quick Combi and Cryptosporidium-Strip were 88%, 82%, 82% and 75%, respectively. The specificity of all tests was > or = 98%. Other intestinal parasites were present in 68 samples, but cross-reactions with other protozoan or helminthic parasites were not observed. Overall, the copro-antigen assays were less time-consuming and easier to perform, but were less sensitive than conventional microscopical methods. Thus, these tests might be a useful addition to, but not a substitute for microscopical methods in the diagnosis of travel-associated giardiasis and cryptosporidiosis.     

Evaluation of a new monoclonal antibody combination reagent for direct fluorescence detection of Giardia cysts and Cryptosporidium oocysts in human fecal specimens.

Giardia lamblia and Cryptosporidium parvum can cause severe symptoms in humans, particularly in the immunologically compromised. Monoclonal antibody reagents offer increased sensitivity and an excellent alternative to conventional staining methods. These reagents are helpful when screening large numbers of patients or those with minimal symptoms. Problems of false-positive and false-negative results with routine staining methods for stool parasites can be eliminated with monoclonal antibody reagents. Known positive formalinized specimens [Giardia sp. (n = 60), Cryptosporidium sp. (n = 55), and mixed Giardia-Cryptosporidium spp. (n = 10)] and negative formalinized specimens (n = 105), of which 46 contained other yeast or human cells or protozoa), were tested by the MERIFLUOR Cryptosporidium-Giardia direct immunofluorescence detection procedure. The MERIFLUOR reagent exhibited +/- to 4+ (majority, 2+ to 3+) on all Giardia cysts and 2+ to 4+ (majority, 3+ to 4+) on all Cryptosporidium oocysts. The cysts were generally oval (11 to 15 microns), while the oocysts were round (4 to 6 microns); both showed apple-green fluorescence against a background free of nonspecific fluorescence. All specimens positive for Giardia sp. and/or Cryptosporidium sp. showed fluorescence, and all specimens negative for the two organisms showed no fluorescence. There were eight specimens previously negative by the ova and parasite examination which were positive by the direct fluorescence method; four contained Giardia sp., and four contained Cryptosporidium sp. These positive results were confirmed after the examination of additional trichrome and modified acid-fast smears. The MERIFLUOR reagent was very easy to use, and even with a lower fluorescence intensity for Giardia sp. cysts, no false-negative or false-positive results among the specimens tested for either organism were found.     

Enzyme-linked immunoassay for detection of Cryptosporidium antigens in fecal specimens.

Cryptosporidium sp. is a ubiquitous 4- to 6-micron protozoan parasite infecting the intestinal tract of humans. It causes mild to fulminant diarrhea in patients, especially immunocompromised persons, and it may be hard to detect by microscopic fecal examination. An indirect, double-antibody enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was developed using specifically produced goat and rabbit antisera to detect Cryptosporidium antigens in human feces. Of 62 frozen stools from patients with cryptosporidiosis, as detected by at least two microscopic diagnostic techniques, 51 were positive by ELISA; all ELISA-negative specimens came from patients with fewer than five oocysts per 0.01 ml of concentrated fecal sample examined after modified acid-fast or fluorescent monoclonal antibody staining. A total of 182 specimens from persons without Cryptosporidium infection were negative by ELISA in 176 instances; 3 ELISA-positive specimens came from patients with cryptosporidiosis diagnosed earlier. The sensitivity of the assay was 82.3%, and specificity was 96.7%. The predictive value of a positive ELISA was 89.5%, and the predictive value of a negative ELISA was 94.2%. The ELISA was not affected by the presence of eight other intestinal parasites but was sometimes affected by repeated freezing and thawing of fecal specimens. All fecal specimens were heated to 100 degrees C for 2 min to reduce proteolytic enzyme activity, although the necessity of this step needs further evaluation. This first-generation ELISA is a simple, rapid, easily standardized test for Cryptosporidium antigens in stool samples which will be useful for diagnosis and for large-scale epidemiologic studies.     

Commercial assay for detection of Giardia lamblia and Cryptosporidium parvum antigens in human fecal specimens by rapid solid-phase qualitative immunochromatography

The ImmunoCard STAT! Cryptosporidium/Giardia rapid assay (Meridian Bioscience, Inc.) is a solid-phase qualitative immunochromatographic assay that detects and distinguishes between Giardia lamblia and Cryptosporidium parvum in aqueous extracts of human fecal specimens (fresh, frozen, unfixed, or fixed in 5 or 10% formalin or sodium acetate-acetic acid-formalin). By using specific antibodies, antigens specific for these organisms are isolated and immobilized on a substrate. After the addition of appropriate reagents, a positive test is detected visually by the presence of a gray-black color bar (regardless of the intensity) next to the organism name printed on the test device. A control is included in the device. Steps include tube preparation (buffer, patient specimen, conjugates A and B), testing (addition of sample onto the test device), and visual reading (total time, 12 min). Test performance was evaluated with known positive and negative stool specimens (170 specimens positive for Giardia and 231 specimens negative for Giardia) (85 specimens positive for Cryptosporidium and 316 specimens negative for Cryptosporidium); they were tested with trichrome, iron-hematoxylin, or modified acid-fast stains or the Meridian Bioscience, Inc., Giardia/Cryptosporidium Merifluor combination reagent; specimens with discrepant results were retested by using the Merifluor combination reagent. On the basis of the results of the reference methods, the sensitivities, specificities, and positive and negative predictive values were as follows: for G. lamblia, 93.5, 100, 100, and 95.5%, respectively; for C. parvum, 98.8, 100, 100, and 99.7%, respectively. False-negative results for G. lamblia were obtained with specimens with low parasite numbers (n = 7) or specimens containing trophozoites only (n = 3); one specimen with a false-negative result contained numerous cysts. The one specimen false negative for C. parvum was confirmed to be positive by immunofluorescence. No cross-reactivity was seen with 10 different protozoa (152 challenges), nine different helminths (35 challenges), or human cells (4 challenges) found in fecal specimens. This rapid test system may be very beneficial in the absence of trained microscopists; however, for patients who remain symptomatic after a negative result, the ova and parasite examination and special stains for other coccidia and the microsporidia should always remain options.     

Evaluation of nine immunoassay kits (enzyme immunoassay and direct fluorescence) for detection of Giardia lamblia and Cryptosporidium parvum in human fecal specimens.

It is well known that Giardia lamblia and Cryptosporidium parvum can cause severe symptoms in humans, particularly those who are immunologically compromised. Immunoassay procedures offer both increased sensitivity and specificity compared to conventional staining methods. These reagents are also helpful when screening large numbers of patients, particularly in an outbreak situation or when screening patients with minimal symptoms. The data obtained by using 9 diagnostic kits were compared: direct fluorescent-antibody assay (DFA) kits (TechLab Giardia/Crypto IF kit, TechLab Crypto IF kit, and Meridian Merifluor Cryptosporidium/Giardia) and enzyme immunoassay (EIA) kits (Alexon ProSpecT Giardia EZ Microplate Assay, Alexon ProSpecT Cryptosporidium Microplate Assay, Cambridge Giardia lamblia Antigen Microwell ELISA, Meridian Premier Giardia lamblia, Meridian Premier Cryptosporidium, TechLab Giardia CELISA, Trend Giardia lamblia EIA). The test with the Meridian Merifluor Cryptosporidium/Giardia kit was used as the reference method. In various combinations, 60 specimens positive for Giardia, 60 specimens positive for Cryptosporidium, 40 specimens positive for a Giardia-Cryptosporidium mix, and 50 negative fecal specimens were tested. Different species (nine protozoa, three coccidia, one microsporidium, five nematodes, three cestodes, and one trematode) were included in the negative specimens. The sensitivity of EIA for Giardia ranged from 94% (Alexon) to 99% (Trend and Cambridge); the specificity was 100% with all EIA kits tested. The sensitivity of EIA for Cryptosporidium ranged from 98% (Alexon) to 99% (Meridian Premier); specificities were 100%. All DFA results were in agreement, with 100% sensitivity and specificity; however, the TechLab reagents resulted in fluorescence intensity that was generally one level below that seen with the reagents used in the reference method. In addition to sensitivity and specificity, factors such as cost, simplicity, ease of interpretation of results (color, intensity of fluorescence), equipment, available personnel, and number of tests ordered are also important considerations prior to kit selection.     

Evaluation of seven immunochromatographic assays for the rapid detection of human rotaviruses in fecal specimens

Seven commercially available immunochromatographic assays were tested for the rapid detection of group A rotaviruses in fecal samples compared to a enzyme immunoassay (Argene). Detection of rotaviruses in 80 ELISA positive frozen stool samples showed rates superior to 90% for three reagents (Rota Strip (Cypress Diagnostics), 98.8%; Rotascreen (Microgen), 95.0%; VIKIA Rota/Adeno (bioMérieux), 92.5%); from 82.5% to 88.8% for three others (Diarlex with centrifugation (Orion Diagnostica), 88.8%; Combo Rota/Adeno (All Diag), 87.5%; Rota/Adeno Combi Stick (bmd), 82.5%) and only 70.0% for Diarlex with filtration vial (Orion Diagnostica). The evaluation of the specificity, performed on one hundred fresh rotavirus negative stools, did not show any false positives with any assay. Analysis of the different technical features of these tests showed that they are quick and suitable for a clinical laboratory and do not require expensive equipment.     

Prospective comparison of direct immunofluorescence and conventional staining methods for detection of Giardia and Cryptosporidium spp. in human fecal specimens.

In a prospective comparative study, 2,696 consecutive fresh stool specimens over the course of 1 year were examined for Giardia lamblia and Cryptosporidium parvum by using a direct immunofluorescent-monoclonal antibody stain (for unspun specimens) and conventional staining methods (chlorazol black E for Giardia cysts and modified Kinyoun acid-fast for Cryptosporidium oocysts). The direct immunofluorescent-monoclonal antibody method resulted in a significantly increased detection rate for both giardia (118 versus 79 specimens, 49.4%; P = 0.006) and cryptosporidia (39 versus 23 specimens, 69.6%; P = 0.055).     

Evaluation of rapid commercial enzyme immunoassay for detection of Giardia lamblia in formalin-preserved stool specimens.

Two hundred twenty-three formalin-preserved stool specimens were evaluated by using ProSpecT Giardia Rapid Assay (membrane bound) (Alexon, Inc., Sunnyvale, Calif.). Enzyme immunoassay (EIA) results were compared with those by conventional microscopic examination. Two hundred four specimens were negative by both methods, and 13 (6.3%) were positive. Five specimens were negative by initial microscopic exam and positive by EIA; three of these specimens were found to be positive upon extensive microscopic reexamination. The remaining two specimens were from patients who previously tested positive and who had recurrent symptoms of or responded to therapy for giardia. Therefore, we consider both cases to be true positives. One specimen exhibited a single cyst by microscopic exam and was negative by EIA Resolved results yielded a relative sensitivity of 95%, a relative specificity of 100%, a positive predictive value of 99.6%, and a negative predictive value of 100%, compared with a sensitivity of 74% for conventional microscopy.     

Improved stool concentration procedure for detection of Cryptosporidium oocysts in fecal specimens.

Epidemiologic and laboratory data suggest that coprodiagnostic methods may fail to detect Cryptosporidium oocysts in stool specimens of infected patients. To improve the efficacy of stool concentration procedures, we modified different steps of the Formalin-ethyl acetate (FEA) stool concentration technique and evaluated these modifications by examining stool samples seeded with known numbers of Cryptosporidium oocysts. Because these modifications failed to improve oocyst detection, we developed a new stool concentration technique that includes FEA sedimentation followed by layering and flotation over hypertonic sodium chloride solution to separate parasites from stool debris. Compared with the standard FEA procedure, this technique improved Cryptosporidium oocyst detection. The sensitivities of the two concentration techniques were similar for diarrheal (watery) stool specimens (100% of watery stool specimens seeded with 5,000 oocysts per g of stool were identified as positive by the new technique, compared with 90% of stools processed by the standard FEA technique). However, the most significant improvement in diagnosis occurred with formed stool specimens that were not fatty; 70 to 90% of formed stool specimens seeded with 5,000 oocysts were identified as positive by the new technique, compared with 0% of specimens processed by the standard FEA technique. One hundred percent of formed specimens seeded with 10,000 oocysts were correctly diagnosed by using the new technique, while 0 to 60% of specimens processed by the standard FEA technique were found positive. Similarly, only 50 to 90% of stool specimens seeded with 50,000 oocysts were identified as positive by using the standard FEA technique, compared with a 100% positive rate by the new technique. The new stool concentration procedure provides enhanced detection of Cryptosporidium oocysts in all stool samples.     

Evaluation of new rapid commercial enzyme immunoassay for detection of Cryptosporidium oocysts in untreated stool specimens.

Sixty-six stool specimens were evaluated by the ProSpecTR Cryptosporidium rapid enzyme immunoassay (EIA) (Alexon, Sunnyvale, Calif.). Approximately 2 g of untreated stool suspended in buffer was filtered through membranes labelled with anti-Cryptosporidium-specific antigen antibody. Anti-Cryptosporidium-specific antigen antibody was labelled with biotin, horseradish peroxidase conjugated to streptavidin, and tetramethylbenzidine, and each labelled antibody was added in sequence to the membranes. Each membrane had a positive control and test area. EIA results were compared with those of the modified acid-fast procedure. Twenty-three specimens were positive by the initial acid-fast procedure and the EIA. Forty-two specimens were negative by the initial acid-fast test and the EIA. One specimen was negative by the initial acid-fast test and positive by the EIA (sensitivity, 100%; specificity, 98.5%). This technique is easy to use by comparison with the cumbersome, labor-intensive, and more subjective microscopic methods currently available, and its sensitivity equals that of current microscopic methods.     

Comparison of three commercial methods for rapid detection of Clostridium difficile toxins A and B from fecal specimens

Three rapid enzyme immunoassays (X/pect Clostridium difficile Toxin A/B test, Wampole Tox A/B Quik Chek, and ImmunoCard Toxins A&B) were compared for the diagnosis of Clostridium difficile infection. Of the 367 stool specimens tested, 102 (27.8%) were positive for toxigenic C. difficile when a combination of direct cytotoxicity assay and cytotoxic culture was used as the gold standard. Sensitivity/specificity values were 49.0%/95.8%, 54.9%/95.5%, and 66.7%/95.1%, respectively. The median times to test five stool specimens were 28, 30, and 24 min, respectively. The ImmunoCard test was the quickest and most sensitive test of the three enzyme immunoassays evaluated.     

Performance of three enzyme immunoassays and two direct fluorescence assays for detection of Giardia lamblia in stool specimens preserved in ECOFIX

ECOFIX is a single-vial stool preservative that is both formalin- and mercury-free. We evaluated the abilities of three commercial Giardia lamblia-specific enzyme immunoassays (EIAs) (ProSpecT Giardia Microplate Assay [Alexon-Trend Inc.], Giardia Test [Techlab], and Premier Giardia lamblia [Meridian Diagnostics, Inc.]) and two commercial direct fluorescent-antibody (FA) assays for G. lamblia (Crypto/Giardia IF Test [Techlab] and Merifluor Cryptosporidium/Giardia [Meridian Diagnostics, Inc.]) to detect G. lamblia in 34 G. lamblia-positive and 44 G. lamblia-negative stool specimens (determined by traditional examination for ova and parasites) preserved in ECOFIX compared to their abilities to detect G. lamblia in the same specimens preserved in formalin as the "gold standard" for each assay. Of the 34 formalin-fixed positive specimens, the number detected by each assay was as follows:, Alexon EIA, 34; Meridian EIA, 27; Techlab EIA, 29; Meridian FA assay, 31; and Techlab FA assay, 28. Both FA tests and the Alexon EIA performed well with ECOFIX, but the other two EIAs detected fewer positive specimens (the difference was statistically significant with the Techlab EIA) when ECOFIX was the preservative. Use of G. lamblia cyst antigen from cultured organisms preserved in formalin and ECOFIX demonstrated that the Alexon EIA could detect smaller amounts of antigen in ECOFIX than the other two EIAs could and suggested that cyst antigen is more stable in formalin. We recommend that laboratories use an FA assay or the Alexon EIA if they plan to use ECOFIX as their stool preservative.     

Evaluation of an enzyme-linked immunoassay for the detection of Cryptosporidium antigen in fecal specimens of HIV/AIDS patients

Cryptosporidium parvum, a protozoan parasite, causes severe diarrhea in immunodeficient hosts like HIV/AIDS patients, leading to significant morbidity and mortality. Diagnosis of the Cryptosporidium oocyst in the stool of these patients by conventional microscopy is labor intensive and time consuming. Therefore, we planned to evaluate the usefulness of a stool ELISA test in detecting Cryptosporidial antigen. About 89 stool specimens obtained from HIV-seropositive patients with diarrhea were subjected to an ELISA test and modified acid-fast staining (gold standard), on both direct and formol ether-concentrated specimens. The prevalence of Cryptosporidial diarrhea was found to be 12.4% (11/89). Other enteric pathogens detected were Isospora belli (3), Giardial cyst (3), Entamoeba coli cyst (2), and Entamoeba histolytica cyst (1). Dual infection with Cryptosporidium and Isospora belli was seen in two patients. Concentration technique improved identification by microscopy. The sensitivity and specificity for stool ELISA were found to be 90.9% and 98.7% respectively. The results of stool ELISA indicate that this simple, rapid, reliable, and standardized immunoassay test is sensitive and specific for routine diagnosis and may be useful for large-scale epidemiological studies of Cryptosporidiosis.     

Evaluation of a combination rapid immunoassay for detection of Giardia and Cryptosporidium antigens

A combination cassette format nonenzymatic rapid immunoassay for detection of Giardia and Cryptosporidium antigens was evaluated by using 556 patient stool specimens from three clinical laboratories. This assay (Genzyme Diagnostics Contrast Giardia/Cryptosporidium), which can be used with fresh or formalin-fixed specimens, had unadjusted sensitivities and specificities of 96.1 and 98.5% for Giardia and 100 and 98.7% for Cryptosporidium, respectively, in this study.     

Evaluation of ColorPAC Giardia/Cryptosporidium Rapid Assay and ProSpecT Giardia/Cryptosporidium Microplate Assay for Detection of Giardia and Cryptosporidium in Fecal Specimens

Detection of Giardia and Cryptosporidium in clinical stool specimens using the ColorPAC and ProSpecT enzyme immunoassays revealed 98.7% agreement for Giardia detection and 98.1% agreement for Cryptosporidium detection. Sensitivities were uniformly 100%. The specificities of the ColorPAC immunoassay for Giardia and Cryptosporidium detection were 100 and 99.5%, respectively, and those for the ProSpecT assay were 98.4 and 98.6%, respectively. The false-positive reactions with the ProSpecT assay occurred with specimens that were grossly bloody.     

Comparison of nine commercial immunoassays for the detection of rotavirus in fecal specimens.

One hundred fecal specimens obtained from patients with acute gastroenteritis were tested for rotavirus with nine commercial immunoassays to evaluate the sensitivity, specificity, predictive value, and diagnostic accuracy of these assays. Kits evaluated included two monoclonal antibody-based enzyme immunoassays (EIAs) (Rotaclone and Pathfinder Rotavirus), three polyclonal antibody-based EIAs (Rotavirus Immunoassay, Rotazyme II, and Wellcozyme Rotavirus), and four latex agglutination assays (Rotastat, Virogen Rotatest, Meritec-Rotavirus, and The Wellcome Latex Test). Thirty-eight of the 100 specimens were found to contain rotavirus by a reference microplate EIA. The accuracy of the reference assay was determined by RNA electrophoresis and a blocking assay on discordant specimens. The two monoclonal antibody EIAs had superior sensitivities (100%) and identified two positive specimens which were negative by the reference method but positive by the blocking assay. Among the polyclonal EIAs, all had sensitivities of greater than 90%, but specificities were variable; Rotazyme II, with a specificity of 50%, showed considerable discrepancy from other polyclonal EIAs. The latex tests had sensitivities ranging from 70 to 90% and specificities of 80 to 100%. Latex agglutination tests were more rapid than EIAs and did not require expensive equipment. The final choice of assay system will depend on the cost, speed, and accuracy requirements of the clinical laboratory.     

Fluorescence detection of Cryptosporidium oocysts in human fecal specimens by using monoclonal antibodies.

With the discovery that the coccidian parasite Cryptosporidium sp. can cause severe symptoms in humans, implementation of many diagnostic techniques rapidly followed. The infection is self-limiting in patients with normal immune systems but chronic in the immunosuppressed patient. With the eventual development and use of therapeutic agents, it will become very important to find Cryptosporidium sp., even in low numbers, in fecal specimens. Production of a highly specific and sensitive antibody by use of cloning techniques has provided another diagnostic tool. Formalinized positive human fecal specimens (n = 99) and negative specimens (n = 198), of which 115 contained yeastlike fungi and other organisms, were tested in blind trials by use of a monoclonal antibody. Sensitivity was 100% with 3- to 4+ fluorescence on all cryptosporidial oocysts, both in light and heavy infections. The organisms were round and easily visible (4 to 6 micron), showing apple-green to yellow fluorescence against a dark background free of nonspecific fluorescence. Specificity was also 100% with all 99 positive Cryptosporidium sp. specimens exhibiting fluorescence and all 198 negative specimens showing no fluorescence. All positive and negative specimens were previously confirmed by the hot modified acid-fast technique. However, seven specimens previously considered negative by this acid-fast method were positive by the monoclonal antibody technique. These specimens were confirmed as positive, after extensive examination of additional smears prepared by the modified hot acid-fast method revealed rare organisms, emphasizing the increased sensitivity of the monoclonal antibody technique. Since acid-fast stains do not always consistently stain all oocysts, the increased sensitivity of the monoclonal reagent provides an excellent screening method.