Diagnostic accuracy of cone-beam CT in the assessment of mandibular invasion of lower gingival carcinoma: Comparison with conventional panoramic radiography

Purpose

To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of cone-beam CT in assessing mandibular invasion by lower gingival carcinoma and compare it with that of panoramic radiography.

Patients and methods

Fifty patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the lower gingiva who were examined by both panoramic radiography and cone-beam CT before surgery were included in this study. Five radiologists used a 6-point rating scale to independently evaluate cone-beam CT and panoramic images for the presence or absence of alveolar bone and mandibular canal involvement by tumor. Using the histopathogical findings as the gold standard, we calculated and compared the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (Az value) and the sensitivity and specificity of the two imaging modalities.

Results

In evaluations of both alveolar bone and mandibular canal involvement, the mean Az value for cone-beam CT (0.918 and 0.977, respectively) was significantly higher than that for panoramic radiography (0.793 and 0.872, respectively). The mean sensitivity for cone-beam CT (89% and 99%, respectively) was significantly higher than that for panoramic radiography (73% and 56%, respectively). There was no significant difference in the mean specificity. While cone-beam CT could provide high-resolution three-dimensional images, the image quality around the alveolar crest was often hampered by severe dental artifacts and image noise, resulting in difficulties in detecting subtle alveolar invasion.

Conclusion

Cone-beam CT was significantly superior to panoramic radiography in evaluating mandibular invasion by lower gingival carcinoma. Its diagnostic value in detecting subtle alveolar invasion, however, may be limited by severe dental artifacts and image noise.     

Detection of bone invasion by gingival carcinoma of the mandible: a comparison of intraoral and panoramic radiography and computed tomography

OBJECTIVE: To assess the diagnostic accuracy of panoramic radiography (PR), panoramic radiography combined with intraoral radiography (PR+IR), and CT in detecting the supero-inferior extent of tumor invasion of the mandible by gingival carcinoma. METHOD: PR, PR+IR, and CT images of the mandible in 37 patients with gingival carcinoma were evaluated by five oral radiologists for the supero-inferior extent of bone invasion using ROC analysis. The mean ROC curve area (Az) of each observer for the different imaging modalities was analysed by nonparametric two-way ANOVA. P<0.05 was considered statistically significant. RESULTS: The mean Az for the detection of bone invasion were 0.88+/-0.03 for PR, 0.77+/-0.12 for PR+IR, and 0.87+/-0.03 for CT (P=0.0907). The mean Az for the detection of bone invasion beyond the alveolus was 0.89+/-0.07 for PR, 0.85+/-0.08 for PR+IR, and 0.83+/-0.06 for CT (P=0.5438). The mean Az for the detection of bone invasion beneath the mandibular canal were 0.94+/-0.04 for PR, 0.94+/-0.02 for PR+IR, and 0.91+/-0. 04 for CT (P=0.2466). No statistically significant differences were observed in Az between PR, PR+IR, and CT. CONCLUSION: We consider that PR+IR should be adopted as the initial imaging modality to determine the extent of supero-inferior invasion of the mandible in gingival carcinoma.     

Masticator space abnormalities associated with mandibular osteoradionecrosis: MR and CT findings in five patients

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Imaging of patients with a clinical diagnosis of mandibular osteoradionecrosis (ORN) is often performed to support that clinical suspicion, evaluate the extent of the disease, or exclude coexistent tumor recurrence. The purpose of our study was to describe the clinical, MR imaging, and CT features of five patients with mandibular ORN associated with prominent soft-tissue abnormality in the adjacent masticator muscles. METHODS: The MR and CT examinations of five patients with mandibular ORN associated with soft-tissue abnormalities in the adjacent masticator muscles were reviewed. All patients had received external beam radiotherapy for primary head and neck malignancies, with a total radiation dose range of 60 Gy to 69 Gy in 30 to 38 fractions. RESULTS: CT revealed the typical osseous findings of cortical disruption, trabecular disorganization, and fragmentation in all five patients. Abnormal diffuse enhancement of the adjacent masseter and pterygoid muscles was noted in all patients. Four patients had prominent mass-like thickening of these muscles adjacent to the osseous abnormality. Of the three patients who underwent MR imaging, all showed homogeneous abnormal T1 hypointensity, T2 hyperintensity, and intense enhancement of the bone marrow in the involved mandible. The masticator muscles adjacent to the osseous abnormality also showed abnormal T2 hyperintensity and intense diffuse enhancement on MR images. CONCLUSION: Mandibular ORN can be associated with prominent soft-tissue thickening and enhancement in the adjacent musculature. These changes can appear mass-like and are not related to tumor recurrence or metastatic disease.     

Pre-operative radiographic evaluation of lower third molars with computed tomography

OBJECTIVES: To report radiographic findings of examinations with computed tomography (CT) of impacted lower third molars with an intimate relation to the mandibular canal and to investigate how findings of a dark band across the roots of the lower third molar on panoramic views correspond to the CT findings. METHODS: CT images of 90 lower third molars (64 patients, mean age 34.6 years) in which plain radiography was insufficient to allow determination of the precise anatomical relations were reviewed retrospectively. Panoramic views of 88 teeth existed; these images were interpreted independent of the CT examinations with respect to presence of a dark band across the roots. RESULTS: In 31% of the CT images, the course of the mandibular canal was buccal, in 33% lingual, in 26% inferior, and in 10% inter-radicular. The tooth was in contact with the mandibular canal in 94% and with the lingual cortex in 86%. In 23%, grooving of the root by the canal was judged to be present. In 63% of the cases where a dark band across the roots was observed on panoramic radiographs, CT revealed grooving of the root. CONCLUSIONS: Pre-operative CT of lower third molars is motivated in selected cases when plain radiography is inconclusive. The finding of a dark band across the roots on panoramic radiographs is an indicator of grooving of the tooth by the canal and justifies a pre-operative CT examination. The absence of dark bands on panoramic views does not exclude grooving of the roots.     

Usefulness of cone beam computed tomography for odontogenic myxoma

A case of odontogenic myxoma is reported as showing a cyst-like pattern with a partially thick but vague and unclear radiopaque border between the left mandibular second premolar and first molar on rotational panoramic radiography. Internal structure of the lesion displayed radiolucency with a sparse and coarse trabecular pattern. No expansion of bucco-lingual cortical bone was apparent. The radiographic pattern of odontogenic myxoma did not resemble a tennis racket-like or straight, curved and coarse septal appearance on panoramic radiography, but characteristic findings were noted on cone beam CT. Cone beam CT may prove extremely useful in clarifying detailed internal structure and the state of margins.     

Unusual radiographic appearance of ossifying fibroma in the left mandibular angle

Ossifying fibroma is usually a unilocular lesion with a well-defined, thinly corticated margin radiographically, although various patterns have been noted. The patient was a 27-year-old woman with a painless radiolucent lesion demonstrated on panoramic radiography to involve the root-apex area of the left lower second and third molars. Radiographically, the lesion had some features of a benign tumour, such as an odontogenic myxoma. However, the deep invaginations towards the interalveolar septa suggested a simple bone cyst, whereas the irregular margin and lack of expansion or mandibular canal displacement were consistent with a malignant lesion. A hard tissue component was confirmed only by soft-tissue mode CT. Although this lesion was histopathologically diagnosed as ossifying fibroma, the conflicting imaging findings were challenging and very intriguing.     

A sequential approach to radiological interpretation

A case of large glandular odontogenic cyst of the mandible is presented in which the panoramic radiograph also demonstrated a soft tissue lesion consistent with carotid aneurysm. CT confirmed the bucco-lingual extent of the mandibular lesion and the presence of a soft tissue lesion consistent with an aneurysm of the internal carotid artery. CT angiography, MR angiography and US were used to rule out a carotid artery aneurysm prior to surgery of the mandibular lesion.     

Bifid mandibular canal: confirmation of limited cone beam CT findings by gross anatomical and histological investigations

Objectives

The aims of this study were (1) to assess the validity of limited cone beam CT (CBCT) in detecting the distribution of bifid mandibular canals in the retromolar region by comparing its findings with those of panoramic radiography and spiral CT imaging, and (2) to confirm the contents of such canals depicted on limited CBCT images by using gross anatomical and histological methods.

Methods

Bilateral bifid mandibular canals of a Japanese cadaver were investigated. The canals depicted on panoramic radiography, spiral CT and limited CBCT images were compared. Cross-sectional limited CBCT images of these canals were compared with gross anatomical sections of the mandible and their contents were confirmed histologically.

Results

The spiral CT and limited CBCT images showed the bilateral bifid mandibular canals in the retromolar region whereas the panoramic radiographs indicated the presence of only the left bifid mandibular canal. The canal distribution was more distinct in the limited CBCT images than in the spiral CT images and the cross-sectional limited CBCT images were consistent with the gross anatomical sections. Histologically, the canals contained several nerve bundles and arteries among which the largest nerve and artery were of a similar size.

Conclusion

Limited CBCT is valuable for assessing the distribution of bifid mandibular canals. It is clinically significant to accurately localize a bifid mandibular canal of the retromolar region because it contains a nerve bundle and artery.     

Radiological features of osteogenic sarcoma of the jaws. A comparative study of different radiographic modalities

OBJECTION: To evaluate the clinical and radiological features of osteogenic sarcoma of the jaws with particular reference to the effectiveness of the radiographic modalities used. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A total of 66 cases (57 from the English-language literature and nine new cases) were critically evaluated for the features depicted with intra-oral and panoramic radiography and CT. RESULTS: The mean age of the patients was 36 years (median 31.5 years). There were no differences in gender distribution. A ratio of 1:1.6 between the maxilla and the mandible was found. Lesions had diffuse borders in 78% of cases and defined but not corticated borders in 22%. Twenty-nine per cent were radiolucent, 29% radiopaque and 41% mixed density. Widening of the periodontal ligament space (PDL) was seen in 14 of the 47 (28%) lesions associated with teeth and structural changes in the mandibular canal in 34% of the mandibular lesions. There was a periosteal reaction in 48% and soft tissue involvement in 33% of the lesions. CONCLUSIONS: Widening of the PDL space was best demonstrated on periapical radiographs. Structural changes in the mandibular canal were shown mainly with panoramic radiographs. Periosteal reaction was best demonstrated by occlusal radiographs and soft tissue involvement by CT. Thorough radiological examination using periapical, occlusal and panoramic radiography, and recognition of the radiological features of osteogenic sarcoma should lead to earlier diagnosis.     

Comparison between panoramic and periapical radiography in the diagnosis of periapical bone lesions

The diagnostic accuracy of panoramic and periapical radiography was compared by five oral radiologists who assessed the periapical status of 117 teeth evenly distributed throughout the jaws with a 50% probability that either an osteolytic or sclerotic lesion was present. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis demonstrated no overall significant difference between panoramic and periapical radiography. However, for sclerotic lesions and for all lesions on maxillary premolars and mandibular molars periapical radiography was significantly superior (P less than 0.001); it was also superior for osteolytic lesions in the maxilla as well as for the lesions on mandibular premolars but with a smaller significant difference (P less than 0.05).     

Bone scintigraphy in detection of bone invasion by oral carcinoma

Detecting osseous involvement is clinically important in the management of oral carcinoma. Thirtyone patients with osseous involvement due to oral carcinoma who underwent panoramic radiography and bone scintigraphy were evaluated retrospectively. Bone scintigraphy confirmed osseous involvement in all 31 (100%) of these patients. In 27 (87%) of 31 patients with osseous involvement, both the panoramic radiogram and bone scintigram were positive. In the remaining four patients (13%), bone scintigram was positive for mandibular or maxillary invasion, while panoramic radiogram was negative. There were no instances of an abnormal radiogram with a normal bone scintigram. These findings strongly suggest that bone scintigraphy is more sensitive than panoramic radiography in detecting osseous involvement of the mandible and maxilla due to oral carcinoma. Furthermore, bone scintigraphy was a critical pre-surgical tool in determining the extent of the osseous involvement.     

Dosimetry in dental radiology: comparison of spiral computerized tomography and orthopantomography]

INTRODUCTION: Dental diagnosis still depends largely on diagnostic imaging for correct anatomical and radiological assessment. Many studies confirm the risk of ionizing radiations, especially if used in pediatric populations and with suboptimal control. We compared the doses absorbed by the dentomaxillary area in Spiral CT and panoramic radiography examinations. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Doses were measured at critical organs in neck, ocular and intracranial regions with lithium fluoride dosimeters calibrated on the national standard and then positioned on an anthropomorphic Rando phantom made of tissue-equivalent material covering a skeleton. Multiple measurements were made during Spiral CT with the Dentascan software and panoramic radiography, to calculate mean absorbed doses for both examinations. Acquisition technical parameters were similar to those used in vivo. RESULTS: The parotid, cerebellum and thyroid gland were the most irradiated organs with panoramic radiography, with the addition of the mandible with Spiral CT. The gonads did not receive major doses. CONCLUSIONS: Our dose measurements demonstrate that patients receive smaller doses with panoramic radiography than with Spiral CT with Dentascan. After allowing for some variations from instrumental differences, they are in substantial agreement with literature data. Further investigations are needed considering the radiobiological risk related to the growing spread of Dentascan examinations.     

Multidetector CT of the spine in multiple myeloma: comparison with MR imaging and radiography

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare multidetector CT (MDCT) of the thoracic and lumbar segments of the spine with MR imaging and conventional radiography for bone lesion detection and for evaluating the risk of vertebral fracture in multiple myeloma. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Eighteen patients with multiple myeloma stage III (according to the criteria of Durie and Salmon) underwent MDCT, conventional radiography, and MR imaging of the lumbar and thoracic spine. MDCT was performed using a standard protocol with no contrast material. Source images were reconstructed using an effective slice thickness of 3 mm with an overlapping reconstruction increment (0.8 mm). Secondary coronal and sagittal multiplanar reformations were exclusively used for establishing the diagnosis. Findings were compared with those of MR imaging and conventional radiography. RESULTS: In all patients, coronal and sagittal multiplanar reformations depicted the extent of osseous destruction and provided detailed information about osseous infiltration and potential bone instability. Compared with conventional radiography, an additional 24 affected vertebrae, 15 additional vertebral fractures, and six vertebrae at further risk of fracture were detected on MDCT. Compared with MR imaging, three additional endangered vertebrae were detected on MDCT. MR imaging alone would have lead to an understaging of five (27.8%) of 18 patients. Using combined radiography and MR imaging, disease in three (16.7%) of 18 patients would have been understaged. CONCLUSION: MDCT seems to be preferable to conventional radiography in evaluating bone destruction in multiple myeloma. In combination with MR imaging, detailed information for staging these tumors is obtained. For the initial staging in patients with multiple myeloma, MDCT in combination with MR imaging seems to be the method of choice.     

Bilateral bifid mandibular condyles diagnosed with three-dimensional reconstruction

Bifid mandibular condyles (BMCs) are rare anomalies. The overwhelming majority of prior reports described their predominantly unilateral occurrence diagnosed by panoramic radiography. We present an even rarer case of bilateral BMC initially identified by panoramic radiography and confirmed with colour-enhanced three-dimensional CT. These images substantiate the theory that the secondary condyles arise from the neck of the mandible (Lopez-Lopez et al. Bifid condyle: review of the literature of the last 10 years and report of two cases. Cianio 2010; 28: 136–140).     

Osteometry of the mandible performed using dental MR imaging.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: On cross-sectional and panoramic reformatted images from axial (dental) CT scans of the mandible it may be difficult to identify the inferior alveolar neurovascular bundle (IANB) in patients lacking a clear-cut bony delimitation of the mandibular canal. Dental MR images are comparable to dental CT scans, which directly show the IANB; however, measurements of length may not be reliable owing to susceptibility artifacts and field inhomogeneities in the oral cavity. Therefore, the accuracy of length measurements on dental MR images was compared with that on dental CT scans and direct osteometry. METHODS: Dental T1-weighted MR imaging using a high-resolution turbo gradient-echo sequence and dental CT were performed in six anatomic specimens. The axial scans were reformatted as panoramic and cross-sectional reconstructions on a workstation and characteristic cross sections were obtained from all mandibles. The longest axis in the bucco-lingual and apico-basal directions, the distances from the top of the mandibular canal to the top of the alveolar ridge and from the bottom of the mandibular canal to the base of the mandible, and the diameter of the bone cortex at the alveolar ridge were measured with direct osteometry on the cross sections and compared with measurements on corresponding MR and CT reformatted images. RESULTS: The correlation between direct osteometry and dental MR and CT was strong, except for the bone cortex diameter at the top of the alveolar ridge, where only a moderate correlation was found. Means of comparable length measurements were not significantly different among the three methods. CONCLUSION: The accuracy of length measurements in the jaw bones obtained using dental MR is comparable to that of dental CT and is not significantly different from direct osteometry. Thus, dental MR is a potential alternative to CT for dental imaging.     

A potential pitfall of MR imaging for assessing mandibular invasion of squamous cell carcinoma in the oral cavity

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Whether MR imaging is superior to CT in evaluating the presence and extent of mandibular invasion by squamous cell carcinoma remains controversial. The purpose of this study was to directly compare the diagnostic accuracy of MR imaging and that of CT. METHODS: MR and CT images in 51 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity were evaluated for the presence and extent of mandibular invasion. The results were correlated with histopathologic findings. RESULTS: Twenty-five of 51 patients had histopathologic evidence of mandibular cortical invasion. The tumor involved both the cortex and the bone marrow in all 25 patients and involved the inferior alveolar canal in 5 patients. The sensitivity and specificity for mandibular cortical invasion were 96% and 54% for MR imaging and 100% and 88% for CT, respectively. Those for inferior alveolar canal involvement were 100% and 70% for MR imaging and 100% and 96% for CT, respectively. In both evaluations, the specificity of MR imaging was significantly lower than that of CT (McNemar test, P = .004 in the former and P = .002 in the latter). Chemical shift artifact by bone marrow fat was postulated to be the source of most false-positive cases on MR imaging findings for mandibular cortical invasion. Those for inferior alveolar canal involvement were due to MR imaging visualization of the tumor and surrounding inflammation with similar signal intensity. CONCLUSION: In assessing the presence and extent of mandibular invasion by squamous cell carcinoma, the specificity of MR imaging was significantly lower than that of CT.     

Soft tissue lipoma with the radiographic appearance of a neoplasm within the mandibular canal

Lipomas and lipoma variants are common soft tissue tumours but are not commonly found in the oral and maxillofacial region. We report a case of a classic lipoma located on the medial aspect of the mandibular ramus, but not within bone, first seen by an oral and maxillofacial surgeon during treatment planning for routine extractions. Initial panoramic radiography indicated an expansive tumour in the area of the mandibular foramen and proximal end of the mandibular canal, apparently within the body of the mandible. Subsequent imaging with CT revealed a well-circumscribed soft tissue tumour on the medial aspect of the left mandibular ramus, not within the bone itself. Histological analysis of the operative specimen indicated a classic lipoma.     

上颌骨动静脉畸形的影像学特点

目的：研究上颌骨动静脉畸形（AVM）的X线、CT及MRI表现。方法对17例上颌骨AVM进行增强CT检查,其中3例行曲面断层X线检查,6例行增强MRI检查。结合血管造影（DSA）检查,分别观察病变部位、形态、边界、内部结构、邻近结构侵犯以及增强后密度／信号特征。结果病灶主要位于磨牙区（15／17）,临床以上颌牙龈反复渗血或急性出血者常见,其他表现包括脸部肿胀或搏动性肿物、脸部麻木。X线上主要表现为病灶部位的密度增高。增强CT上根据颌骨的改变可大致分为2类：Ⅰ类,膨胀性及溶骨性骨质破坏（n＝12）;Ⅱ类,弥漫性骨小梁增粗,类似“磨砂玻璃”样改变（n＝5）。17例患者均有不同程度的骨质破坏及周围软组织侵犯、可见供血动脉稍增粗或增粗迂曲的回流静脉、上颌窦腔不同程度抬高;14例患侧颈外静脉（或其他回流静脉）增宽或提前显影;牙根吸收者6例。M RI上Ⅰ类主要表现为不同程度流空效应,Ⅱ类主要表现为T1 WI等低信号,T2 WI高信号,增强后明显强化。结论增强CT扫描能显示颌骨AVM病灶范围及血管侵犯情况,可为首选检查。