Identification of a major surface protein on Neospora caninum tachyzoites

Neospora caninum is a recently identified coccidian parasite that is closely related to Toxoplasma gondii. Molecules associated with the surface of N. caninum tachyzoites are likely to be involved in the process of adhesion and invasion of host cells. They probably also participate in the interaction of the parasite with the immune system, and they could play an important role in the pathogenesis of the parasite. To identify such surface molecules, we performed subcellular fractionation studies of isolated N. caninum tachyzoites. Employing the nonionic detergent Triton-X-114, we prepared a membrane fraction. Immunoblot analysis of this fraction using polyclonal antisera directed against tachyzoites of N. caninum and T. gondii resulted in the identification of a protein of approximately 43 kDa (Nc-p43). This molecule was present in two isolates of Neospora (Nc-1 and Liverpool) but was absent in Toxoplasma (RH-strain) tachyzoites. Further immunofluorescence and immunogold transmission electron microscopy (TEM) studies using affinity-purified anti-Nc-p43 antibodies demonstrated the presence of this molecule on the surface of N. caninum tachyzoites.     

Neospora caninum Microneme Protein NcMIC3: Secretion, Subcellular Localization, and Functional Involvement in Host Cell Interaction

In apicomplexan parasites, host cell adhesion and subsequent invasion involve the sequential release of molecules originating from secretory organelles named micronemes, rhoptries, and dense granules. Microneme proteins have been shown to be released at the onset of the initial contact between the parasite and the host cell and thus mediate and establish the physical interaction between the parasite and the host cell surface. This interaction most likely involves adhesive domains found within the polypeptide sequences of most microneme proteins identified to date. NcMIC3 is a microneme-associated protein found in Neospora caninum tachyzoites and bradyzoites, and a large portion of this protein is comprised of a stretch of four consecutive epidermal growth factor (EGF)-like domains. We determined the subcellular localization of NcMIC3 prior to and following host cell invasion and found that NcMIC3 was secreted onto the tachyzoite surface immediately following host cell lysis in a temperature-dependent manner. Surface-exposed NcMIC3 could be detected up to 2 to 3 h following host cell invasion, and at later time points the distribution of the protein was again restricted to the micronemes. In vitro secretion assays using purified tachyzoites showed that following secretion onto the surface, NcMIC3 was largely translocated towards the posterior end of the parasite, employing a mechanism which requires a functional actin microfilament system. Following this, the protein remained bound to the parasite surface, since it could not be detected in a soluble form in respective culture supernatants. Secretion of NcMIC3 onto the surface resulted in an outward exposure of the EGF-like domains and coincided with an increased capacity of N. caninum tachyzoites to adhere to Vero cell monolayers in vitro, a capacity which could be inhibited by addition of antibodies directed against the EGF-like domains. NcMIC3 is a prominent component of Triton X-100 lysates of tachyzoites, and cosedimentation assays employing prefixed Vero cells showed that the protein binds to the Vero cell surface. In addition, the EGF-like domains, expressed as recombinant proteins in Escherichia coli, also interacted with the Vero cell surface, while binding of NcSRS2 and NcSAG1, the major immunodominant surface antigens, was not as efficient. Our data are indicative of a functional role of NcMIC3 in host cell infection.     

The differential protein expression profiles and immunogenicity of tachyzoites and bradyzoites of in vitro cultured <Emphasis Type="Italic">Neospora caninum</Emphasis>

We report a study on the variations in the protein expression profiles of tachyzoites and bradyzoites of Neospora caninum. The in vitro stage conversion of N. caninum-infected Vero cells was induced by continuous treatment of infected cultures with 70 muM sodium nitroprusside (SNP) for up to 9 days. The stage conversion indicated by the expression of the bradyzoite-specific antigen BAG1 was analyzed by immunofluoresence assay. Morphological changes between tachyzoites and bradyzoites and localization of nuclei were demonstrated by transmission electron microscopy. Notably, we showed the differential protein expression profiles of tachyzoites and bradyzoites of N. caninum upon treatment with SNP. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis analysis indicated different protein patterns between tachyzoites and bradyzoites. Furthermore, Western blotting using rabbit polyclonal antibodies directed against tachyzoites revealed several reactive bands, one of which represented a tachyzoite-specific antigen of approximately 40 kDa remarkably expressed in the tachyzoite stage, but was absent from bradyzoites. Moreover, rabbit polyclonal serum raised against bradyzoites recognized a significant increased expression of an antigen with a MW of approximately 25 kDa in bradyzoites by Western blotting, suggesting that this protein is specifically expressed at the bradyzoite stage. Taken together, our data showed that differential protein expression profiling is a useful tool for discriminating between the two stages during tachyzoite-bradyzoite interconversion in N. caninum infections.     

Apical membrane antigen 1 is a cross-reactive antigen between Neospora caninum and Toxoplasma gondii, and the anti-NcAMA1 antibody inhibits host cell invasion by both parasites

The cross-reactive antigens of Neospora caninum and Toxoplasma gondii are important in the exploration to determine the common mechanisms of parasite-host interaction. In this study, a gene encoding N. caninum apical membrane antigen 1 (NcAMA1) was identified by immunoscreening of a N. caninum tachyzoite cDNA expression library with antisera from mice immunized with recombinant T. gondii apical membrane antigen 1 (TgAMA1). NcAMA1 was encoded by an open reading frame of 1695 bp, which encoded a protein of 564 amino acids. The single-copy NcAMA1 gene was interrupted by seven introns. NcAMA1 showed 73.6% amino acid identity to TgAMA1. Mouse polyclonal antibodies raised against the recombinant NcAMA1 (rNcAMA1) recognized a 69-kDa native parasite protein by Western blotting. Immunofluorescence analysis showed that NcAMA1 was localized to the apical end of tachyzoites. Two-dimensional electrophoresis and Western blotting indicated that an approximately 57-kDa cleavage product was released into the excretory/secretory products of N. caninum. Preincubation of free tachyzoites with anti-rNcAMA1 IgG antibodies inhibited the invasion into host cells by N. caninum and T. gondii. These results indicated that AMA1 is a cross-reactive antigen between N. caninum and T. gondii and a potential common vaccine candidate to control two parasites.     

Application of Real-Time Fluorescent PCR for Quantitative Assessment of Neospora caninum Infections in Organotypic Slice Cultures of Rat Central Nervous System Tissue

The previously described Nc5-specific PCR test for the diagnosis of Neospora caninum infections was used to develop a quantitative PCR assay which allows the determination of infection intensities within different experimental and diagnostic sample groups. The quantitative PCR was performed by using a dual fluorescent hybridization probe system and the LightCycler Instrument for online detection of amplified DNA. This assay was successfully applied for demonstrating the parasite proliferation kinetics in organotypic slice cultures of rat brain which were infected in vitro with N. caninum tachyzoites. This PCR-based method of parasite quantitation with organotypic brain tissue samples can be regarded as a novel ex vivo approach for exploring different aspects of cerebral N. caninum infection.     

Identification of ribosomal phosphoprotein P0 of Neospora caninum as a potential common vaccine candidate for the control of both neosporosis and toxoplasmosis

The characterization of the cross-reactive antigens of two closely related apicomplexan parasites, Neospora caninum and Toxoplasma gondii, is important to elucidate the common mechanisms of parasite-host interactions. In this context, a gene encoding N. caninum ribosomal phosphoprotein P0 (NcP0) was identified by immunoscreening of a N. caninum tachyzoite cDNA expression library with antisera from mice immunized with T. gondii tachyzoites. The NcP0 was encoded by a gene with open reading frame of 936 bp, which encoded a protein of 311 amino acids. The NcP0 gene existed as a single copy in the genome and was interrupted by a 432 bp intron. The NcP0 showed 94.5% amino acid identity to T. gondii P0 (TgP0). Anti-recombinant NcP0 (rNcP0) sera recognized a native parasite protein with a molecular mass of 34 kDa in Western blot analysis. Immunofluorescence analysis showed that the NcP0 was localized to the surface of N. caninum tachyzoites. A purified anti-rNcP0 IgG antibody inhibited the growth of N. caninum and T. gondii in vitro in a concentration-dependent manner. These results indicate that P0 is a cross-reactive antigen between N. caninum and T. gondii and a potential common vaccine candidate to control both parasites.     

Identification and characterization of a Neospora caninum microneme-associated protein (NcMIC4) that exhibits unique lactose-binding properties

Microneme proteins have been shown to play an important role in the early phase of host cell adhesion, by mediating the contact between the parasite and host cell surface receptors. In this study we have identified and characterized a lectin-like protein of Neospora caninum tachyzoites which was purified by alpha-lactose-agarose affinity chromatography. Upon separation by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, this lactose-binding protein migrated at 70 and 55 kDa under reducing and nonreducing conditions, respectively. Immunofluorescence and immunogold electron microscopy with affinity-purified antibodies showed that the protein was associated with the tachyzoite micronemes. Mass spectrometry analyses and expressed sequence tag database mining revealed that this protein is a member of the Neospora microneme protein family; the protein was named NcMIC4 (N. caninum microneme protein 4). Upon two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, NcMIC4 separated into seven distinct isoforms. Incubation of extracellular parasites at 37 degrees C resulted in the secretion of NcMIC4 into the medium as a soluble protein, and the secreted protein exhibited a slightly reduced M(r) but retained its lactose-binding properties. Immunofluorescence was used to investigate the temporal and spatial distribution of NcMIC4 in tachyzoites entering their host cells and showed that reexpression of NcMIC4 took place 30 min after entry into the host cell. Incubation of secreted fractions and purified NcMIC4 with Vero cells demonstrated binding of NcMIC4 to Vero cells as well as binding to chondroitin sulfate A glycosaminoglycans.     

Serological diagnosis of bovine neosporosis by Neospora caninum monoclonal antibody-based competitive inhibition enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.

Neospora caninum, a protozoan parasite closely related to Toxoplasma gondii, causes abortion and congenital infection in cattle. To investigate specific methods of antemortem diagnosis, the antibody responses of infected cows were evaluated by immunoblot assay and competitive inhibition enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (CI-ELISA) by using a monoclonal antibody (MAb), MAb 4A4-2, against N. caninum tachyzoites. MAb 4A4-2 bound diffusely to the exterior surface of N. caninum tachyzoites and recognized a single 65-kDa band in immunoblots. MAb 4A4-2 was unreactive to antigens of two closely related apicomplexan protozoa, Toxoplasma gondii and Sarcocystis cruzi. Binding of MAb 4A4-2 was inhibited by mild periodate treatment of N. caninum antigen, demonstrating the carbohydrate nature of the epitope. Immunoblot analysis of N. caninum tachyzoite antigens with sera from cows with confirmed Neospora-induced abortion revealed at minimum 14 major antigens ranging from 11 to 175 kDa. Although the recognized antigens varied from cow to cow, antigens of 116, 65, and 25 kDa were detected in all cows with abortion confirmed to be caused by N. caninum. The binding of MAb 4A4-2 to N. caninum tachyzoite antigen was consistently inhibited by sera from Neospora-infected cows in a CI-ELISA format and was not inhibited by sera from Neospora antibody-negative cows. Furthermore, sera from cattle experimentally infected with T. gondii, S. cruzi, Sarcocystis hominis, or Sarcocystis hirsuta, which had cross-reactive antibodies recognizing multiple N. caninum antigens by immunoblot assay, did not inhibit binding of MAb 4A4-2 in the CI-ELISA. Thus, MAb 4A4-2 binds a carbohydrate epitope on a single N. caninum tachyzoite surface antigen that is recognized consistently and specifically by Neospora-infected cattle.     

In vitro induction of Neospora caninum bradyzoites in vero cells reveals differential antigen expression, localization, and host-cell recognition of tachyzoites and bradyzoites

We report on an optimized method for the in vitro culture of tissue cyst-forming Neospora caninum bradyzoites in Vero cells and the separation of viable parasites from host cells. Treatment of tachyzoite-infected Vero cell cultures with 17 microM sodium nitroprusside for 8 days severely scaled down parasite proliferation, led to reduced expression of tachyzoite surface antigens, and induced the expression of the bradyzoite marker NcBAG1 and the cyst wall antigen recognized by the monoclonal antibody MAbCC2. Transmission electron microscopy demonstrated that intracellular parasites were located within parasitophorous vacuoles that were surrounded by a cyst wall-like structure, and the dense granule antigens NcGRA1, NcGRA2, and NcGRA7 were incorporated into the cyst wall. Adhesion-invasion assays employing purified tachyzoites and bradyzoites showed that tachyzoites adhered to, and invaded, Vero cells with higher efficiency than bradyzoites. However, removal of terminal sialic acid residues from either the host cell or the parasite surface increased the invasion of Vero cells by bradyzoites, but not tachyzoites.     

Maternal and fetal immune responses of cattle inoculated with Neospora caninum at mid-gestation

The humoral and cell-mediated immune responses of pregnant cattle and their fetuses were examined at intervals after infection with Neospora caninum tachyzoites at mid-gestation (day 140). All cattle seroconverted and interferon gamma was detected in supernatants of peripheral blood mononuclear cells stimulated with specific antigen. At day 14 post-inoculation (pi), specific cell proliferation responses were detected in the lymph node draining the site of inoculation and in the uterine lymph node. The peak response was recorded in the majority of maternal lymph nodes by day 28 pi and cells from the maternal retropharyngeal lymph node, which in part drains the central nervous system, showed no specific activity to N. caninum until day 42 pi. This changing pattern of immune responsiveness may reflect parasite invasion and development within different host tissues. Fetal lymph node cells showed mitogen responsiveness from day 14 pi (day 154 of gestation) and also showed N. caninum-specific cell proliferation and interferon-gamma responses by day 28 pi (day 168 of gestation). At day 42 pi, specific cell-mediated immune responses were not apparent; however, N. caninum-specific fetal IgG and IgM antibodies were detected.     

The protozoan Neospora caninum directly triggers bovine NK cells to produce gamma interferon and to kill infected fibroblasts

Natural killer (NK) cells are considered to be key players in the early innate responses to protozoan infections, primarily indirectly by producing gamma interferon (IFN-gamma) in response to cytokines, like interleukin 12 (IL-12). We demonstrate that live, as well as heat-inactivated, tachyzoites of Neospora caninum, a Toxoplasma-like protozoan, directly trigger production of IFN-gamma from purified, IL-2-activated bovine NK cells. This response occurred independently of IL-12 but was increased by the addition of the cytokine. A similar IFN-gamma response was measured in cocultures of NK cells and N. caninum-infected autologous fibroblasts. However, no NK cell-derived IFN-gamma response was detected when cells were cultured with soluble antigens from the organism, indicating that intact tachyzoites or nonsoluble components are necessary for NK cell triggering. Furthermore, N. caninum-infected autologous fibroblasts had increased susceptibility to NK cell cytotoxicity compared to uninfected fibroblasts. This cytotoxicity was largely mediated by a perforin-mediated mechanism. The activating receptor NKp46 was involved in cytotoxicity against fibroblasts but could not explain the increased cytotoxicity against infected targets. Interestingly, N. caninum tachyzoites were able to infect cultured NK cells, in which tachyzoites proliferated inside parasitophorous vacuoles. Together, these findings underscore the role of NK cells as primary responders during a protozoan infection, describe intracellular protozoan infection of NK cells in vitro for the first time, and represent the first functional study of purified bovine NK cells in response to infection.     

Identification and characterization of Neospora caninum tachyzoite antigens useful for diagnosis of neosporosis.

The purpose of the present study was to identify antigens of the protozoan Neospora caninum that could be useful for the diagnosis of neosporosis in domestic animals. As revealed by immunoblotting, immune sera from a wide range of animal species exhibited a similar recognition pattern of four major and several minor N. caninum antigens. In contrast to preinoculation sera, all tested immune sera recognized nonreduced immunodominant 17-, 29-, 30-, and 27-kDa antigens. A 46-kDa protein which showed faint recognition by preimmune sera also exhibited a strong response by immune sera. Immunolocalization of the four immunodominant N. caninum antigens was investigated by immunogold electron microscopy using monospecific polyclonal antisera. The 17-kDa antigen appears to be associated with the body part of the rhoptries, while the 29- and 30-kDa antigens were associated with the dense granules, network, and limiting membrane of the parasitophorous vacuole. Studies were also conducted to compare antibody responses to N. caninum and the related protozoan Toxoplasma gondii. Although N. caninum and T. gondii (RH strain) tachyzoites shared a few cross-reacting antigens, the immunodominant antigens of both parasites were not recognized by heterologous sera. Also, immunogold staining with rabbit anti-Neospora hyperimmune serum exhibited almost no labeling of external membranes of Neospora tachyzoites compared with the very marked labeling seen when Toxoplasma tachyzoites (RH strain) were incubated with rabbit anti-Toxoplasma hyperimmune serum. These unique antigenic differences should be useful in developing a diagnostic assay for N. caninum.     

Delivery of Neospora caninum surface protein, NcSRS2 (Nc-p43), to mouse using recombinant vaccinia virus

In order to develop a vaccine against Neospora caninum in dogs and cattle, we constructed a recombinant vaccinia virus expressing the N. caninum surface protein, NcSRS2 (Nc-p43). Monoclonal antibodies to NcSRS2 and anti-N. caninum tachyzoite mouse serum recognized the NcSRS2 expressed by the recombinant vaccinia virus. In addition, recombinant NcSRS2 was transported to the cell surface. Mice infected with the recombinant virus predominantly produced IgG1 antibody (Ab) to N. caninum, rather than producing IgG2a Ab. Moreover, splenocytes from mice infected with the recombinant virus proliferated in the presence of the N. caninum antigen. Mice immunized with the recombinant virus gave rise to humoral and cellular immune responses to N. caninum tachyzoites. This study showed that a recombinant vaccinia virus expressing NcSRS2 might be useful for the production of a live vaccine against N. caninum infection. Received: 24 March 2000 / Accepted: 18 May 2000     

Comparative molecular investigation of Nc5-PCR amplicons from Neospora caninum NC-1 and Hammondia heydorni-Berlin-1996

The clinical relevance of Neospora caninum as a cyst-forming coccidian parasite is increasingly acknowledged within veterinary medicine, although the pathways of transmission are far from being solved. The parasite is well known for causing diaplacental infections in cows associated with abortion and/or severe damage of the fetus. In addition, it may cause neuromuscular disease in dogs, which thus apparently act as intermediate hosts as well as final hosts. In our previous studies, we have demonstrated that molecular diagnosis of N. caninum infections has a high performance when a highly sensitive polymerase chain reaction (PCR) targeted to the Nc5 region of the parasite is used. The present study indicates that the high sensitivity of the PCR is the consequence of a target dose effect which reflects a high redundancy of Nc5-type sequences within the genome of the parasite. The PCR was shown to amplify a set of DNA molecules exhibiting significant sequence differences. A complex composition of Nc5-type sequences was observed in the parasite isolate N. caninum NC-1 but also in another isolate, designated Hammondia heydorni-Berlin-1996. Investigation of the infection pattern of this parasite in its intermediate and final canine hosts showed it to be indistinguishable from N. caninum NC-1.     

Placental pathology associated with fetal death in cattle inoculated with Neospora caninum by two different routes in early pregnancy

Pregnant cattle were inoculated with N. caninum strain NC-1 tachyzoites intravenously (iv) (group 1, n = 8) or subcutaneously (sc) (group 2, n = 8) at 70 days' gestation. Control animals (group 3; n = 8) received uninfected Vero cells iv. Two animals from each group were killed at 14, 28, 42 and 56 days post-inoculation (dpi). Fetal mortality was 100% and 50%, respectively, in groups 1 and 2 from 28 dpi. In group 1 foci of degenerative fetal placental villi were observed at 14 dpi, with clusters of N. caninum tachyzoites in the affected mesenchyme. There was also inflammation of maternal septal tissues, with necrotic cell debris and serum exudate at the interstitium. At 28 dpi pregnancy had ended and the fetal cotyledons had become detached from the maternal caruncles. Immunohistochemically, particulate N. caninum antigen was detected in the cotyledons. At 42 and 56 dpi, fetal tissues had disappeared, the caruncles were greatly reduced in size, and the uterine epithelium had been largely restored. In group 2, lesions were either severe or absent ("all or nothing" response). In one animal carrying a dead fetus at 28 dpi, placentitis was much more severe than that seen in group 1 at 14 dpi. Lesions contained neutrophils, eosinophils and N. caninum antigen. In animals carrying dead fetuses at 42 and 56 dpi, fetal remains were found and the cotyledons contained N. caninum antigen. Antigen was also detected in fetal tissues. No significant pathological changes were detected in group 2 animals carrying live fetuses or any animal in group 3. Thus, N. caninum administered iv or sc in early pregnancy resulted in rapid fetal death, with parasite-associated lesions in the placenta and fetus. Of the two inoculation routes, the intravenous induced the more acute placental lesions and greater mortality.     

Identification of the cross-reactive and species-specific antigens between Neospora caninum and Toxoplasma gondii tachyzoites by a proteomics approach

The characterization of the cross-reactive and species-specific antigens of Neospora caninum and Toxoplasma gondii is important in the exploration to determine the common mechanisms of parasite-host interaction and to improve the serological diagnosis; it is also useful for the selection of the cross-reactive antigens that could be used in the development of vaccines or drugs for controlling the diseases caused by these two parasites. In this study, cross-reactive and species-specific antigens between N. caninum and T. gondii tachyzoites were comprehensively investigated using a proteomics approach with the application of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, immunoblot analysis, matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS), and MALDI-TOF/TOF-MS analysis. Immunoblotting and mass spectrometry analysis revealed that at least 42 individual protein spots of N. caninum were reacted with the anti-N. caninum serum, among which at least 18 protein spots were cross-reacted with the anti-T. gondii serum. Moreover, at least 31 protein spots of T. gondii were reacted with the anti-T. gondii serum, among which at least 19 protein spots were cross-reacted with the anti-N. caninum serum. Furthermore, some new specific proteins were also identified in the N. caninum protein profile by searching Toxoplasma sequences or sequences from other organisms. This study substantiates the usefulness of proteomics in the immunoscreening of the cross-reactive or species-specific antigens of both parasites. In addition, the present study showed that there was significant homology in the antigenic proteome profiles between the two parasites. These observations have implications for the design of multicomponent common vaccines against both parasite infections.     

Identification and characterization of Neospora caninum cyclophilin that elicits gamma interferon production

Gamma interferon (IFN-gamma) response is essential to the development of a host protective immunity in response to infections by intracellular parasites. Neosporosis, an infection caused by the intracellular protozoan parasite Neospora caninum, is fatal when there is a complete lack of IFN-gamma in the infected host. However, the mechanism by which IFN-gamma is elicited by the invading parasite is unclear. This study has identified a microbial protein in the N. caninum tachyzoite N. caninum cyclophilin (NcCyP) as a major component of the parasite responsible for the induction of IFN-gamma production by bovine peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) and antigen-specific CD4(+) T cells. NcCyP has high sequence homology (86%) with Toxoplasma gondii 18-kDa CyP with a calculated molecular mass of 19.4 kDa. NcCyP is a secretory protein with a predicted signal peptide of 17 amino acids. Abundant NcCyP was detected in whole-cell N. caninum tachyzoite lysate antigen (NcAg) and N. caninum tachyzoite culture supernatant. In N. caninum tachyzoite culture supernatant, three NcCyP bands of 19, 22, and 24 kDa were identified. NcAg stimulated high levels of IFN-gamma production by PBMC and CD4(+) T cells. The IFN-gamma-inducing effect of NcAg was blocked by cyclosporine, a specific ligand for CyP, in a dose-dependent manner. Furthermore, cyclosporine abolished IFN-gamma production by PBMC from na?ve cows as well as PBMC and CD4(+) T cells from infected/immunized cows. These results indicate that the N. caninum tachyzoite naturally produces a potent IFN-gamma-inducing protein, NcCyP, which may be important for parasite survival as well as host protection.     

Electron microscopic study of in vitro cultures of<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Hammondia heydorni</Emphasis> (Berlin 1996) tachyzoites after passages through dogs,mice, rats,guinea pigs and jirds

This study describes the fine structure and reproduction of tachyzoites of Hammondia heydorni (isolate Berlin 1996) after in vitro cultivation of stages isolated from serial passages between dogs and various intermediate hosts such as mice, rats, guinea pigs, jirds, knock-out mice, goats and sheep. The tachyzoites are identical with respect to their ultrastructural features to the corresponding stages of the NC-1-strain of Neospora caninum. This fact conforms with other already published data and underlines our opinion that the recently redescribed N. caninum Dubey et al. 2002 is a synonym of the previously described H. heydorni (Tadros and Laarman 1976) Dubey 1977.