EFNS guidelines on the use of skin biopsy in the diagnosis of peripheral neuropathy

Skin biopsy has become a widely used tool to investigate small calibre sensory nerves including somatic unmyelinated intraepidermal nerve fibres (IENF), dermal myelinated nerve fibres, and autonomic nerve fibres in peripheral neuropathies and other conditions. Different techniques for tissue processing and nerve fibre evaluation have been used. In March 2004, a Task Force was set up under the auspices of the European Federation of Neurological Societies (EFNS) with the aim of developing guidelines on the use of skin biopsy in the diagnosis of peripheral neuropathies. We searched the Medline database from 1989, the year of the first publication describing the innervation of human skin using immunostaining with anti-protein-gene-product 9.5 (PGP 9.5) antibodies, to 31 March 2005. All pertinent papers were rated according to the EFNS guidance. The final version of the guidelines was elaborated after consensus amongst members of the Task Force was reached. For diagnostic purposes in peripheral neuropathies, we recommend performing a 3-mm punch skin biopsy at the distal leg and quantifying the linear density of IENF in at least three 50-mum thick sections per biopsy, fixed in 2% PLP or Zamboni's solution, by bright-field immunohistochemistry or immunofluorescence with anti-PGP 9.5 antibodies (level A recommendation). Quantification of IENF density closely correlated with warm and heat-pain threshold, and appeared more sensitive than sensory nerve conduction study and sural nerve biopsy in diagnosing small-fibre sensory neuropathy. Diagnostic efficiency and predictive values of this technique were very high (level A recommendation). Confocal microscopy may be particularly useful to investigate myelinated nerve fibres, dermal receptors and dermal annex innervation. In future, the diagnostic yield of dermal myelinated nerve fibre quantification and of sweat gland innervation should be addressed. Longitudinal studies of IENF density and regeneration rate are warranted to correlate neuropathological changes with progression of neuropathy and to assess the potential usefulness of skin biopsy as an outcome measure in peripheral neuropathy trials (level B recommendation). In conclusion, punch skin biopsy is a safe and reliable technique (level A recommendation). Training in an established cutaneous nerve laboratory is recommended before using skin biopsy as a diagnostic tool in peripheral neuropathies. Quality control at all levels is mandatory.     

Small fibre neuropathies

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: To summarize the recent advances in aetiology, diagnostic assessment, and treatment of small fibre neuropathies. RECENT FINDINGS: New causes of small fibre neuropathy have been recognized and advances in neurophysiologic and neuropathologic techniques for investigating small fibres have been made, increasing the interest in this field. In particular, skin biopsy proved to be a sensitive method to diagnose small fibre neuropathy. It allows the detection of subclinical abnormalities of peripheral nerve function in patients with diabetes and tongue denervation in patients with burning mouth syndrome. This technique has also been used to demonstrate the neuroprotective effect of erythropoietin in experimental models of neuropathy. Among nonconventional neurophysiologic techniques for investigating small fibres, laser-evoked potential and contact heat-evoked potential stimulators have been developed and deserve particular interest. Several trials on neuropathic pain that is a typical feature of small fibre neuropathies have been performed and guidelines have recently been published. SUMMARY: Detection of small fibre impairment allows earlier diagnosis of neuropathy and could be used as an outcome measure in future regenerative neuropathy trials. Standardization of skin biopsy can have an important impact on clinical practice and research. Further studies are needed to assess the reliability of current neurophysiologic techniques for testing small fibre function in peripheral neuropathies and the correlation with well established neuropathologic examination.     

Skin biopsy as a diagnostic tool in peripheral neuropathy

Skin biopsy is a safe, minimally invasive, painless and cheap tool for providing diagnostic information on small nerve fibers, which are invisible to routine neurophysiological tests. Biopsy can be performed in hairy skin to investigate unmyelinated and thinly myelinated fibers and in glabrous skin to examine large myelinated fibers. Morphometric analysis of skin nerves is readily accomplished through the use of immunohistochemical techniques, and has proved to be reliable, reproducible and unaffected by the severity of neuropathy. One further advantage of skin biopsy over conventional nerve biopsy is that it allows somatic nerve fibers to be distinguished from autonomic nerve fibers. Morphological changes, axonal degeneration and abnormal regeneration occur in cutaneous nerves very early in the course of peripheral neuropathies, making skin biopsy a promising tool for investigating the progression of neuropathy and the effect of neuroprotective treatments in clinical practice and trials. This article reviews the techniques that are used to investigate the innervation of human skin, the possible uses of skin biopsy in diagnosing and monitoring peripheral neuropathies, and correlations between skin biopsy findings and those of other diagnostic methods.     

Assessment of epidermal nerve fibers: a new diagnostic and predictive tool for peripheral neuropathies

Today, skin biopsies can play an important role in the diagnosis of peripheral nerve disorders and have yielded another diagnostic tool for the neurologist. One of the commonly reported neuropathologic abnormalities observed in skin biopsies is a reduction of epidermal nerve density. Analyzing the changes in the morphology and density of epidermal nerves is of immense diagnostic and prognostic value in peripheral neuropathies. These changes also provide an assessment of disease progression and of tissue responses to regenerative treatments. Combined with immunohistochemical studies, newly evolved skin biopsy and epidermal count techniques have the potential to provide significant information about the pathogenesis of many peripheral nervous system diseases. They have great potential for impacts on both research and clinical approaches to treatment. Evolution of a standardized and validated counting methodology and significant advances in procuring skin biopsies have opened up a wide spectrum of applications that make the technology easy to apply in practice. The application of this technology may lead to early detection of many common peripheral nerve diseases and an enhanced understanding of disease onset and progression. In this article we review the state of current research and clinical practice in the use of skin biopsies and epidermal nerve densities.     

皮肤神经活检与神经电生理以及腓肠神经活检的初步对比观察

目的 对周围神经病的患者进行皮肤神经活检、临床特点、神经电生理和腓肠神经活检的对比观察。方法 观察7例周围神经病患者，进行皮肤神经活检、腓肠神经活检、神经电生理检查，并对这些检查的一致性进行比较。结果 7例患者的神经电生理检查均提示有周围神经损害，腓肠神经活检也有不同程度的神经病变。6例皮肤神经活检同时有远近端皮肤神经的异常，且与腓肠神经活检所见病变的严重程度相一致。此6例患者的皮肤神经异常远端重于近端，符合长度依赖性周围神经病变。结论 皮肤神经活检与临床特点、神经电生理以及腓肠神经活检的结果有高度一致性；皮肤神经活检可以反映长度依赖性周围神经病变。     

Nerve fibre studies in skin biopsies in peripheral neuropathies. I. Immunohistochemical analysis of neuropeptides in diabetes mellitus

Standardised skin biopsies followed by immunohistochemical examination for the presence of terminal nerve fibres reacting for neuropeptides substance P (SP) and calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP) were evaluated. Healthy subjects regularly displayed free nerve endings of both fibre types in the papillary and reticular dermis. Both fibre types were present close to blood vessels, while CGRP immunoreactive fibres were more often encountered near sweat gland acini compared to SP fibres. Diabetes mellitus complicated by polyneuropathy was accompanied by marked reduction of SP and CGRP reactive fibres in the dermis layers. Five type I diabetes patients without clinical or neurophysiological evidence of polyneuropathy also had reduced density of both fibre types, being significant for CGRP fibres when compared with controls. Skin biopsy with immunohistochemical staining for neuropeptides may represent a sensitive tool in evaluation of patients with peripheral neuropathies.     

Sensory neuropathies including painful and toxic neuropathies

In most peripheral neuropathies, dysfunction of motor and sensory nerve fibres is present. However, in some of them either pattern may predominate or be exclusively present. In this review we describe the clinical characteristics of sensory neuropathies, with emphasis on their possible causes. Guidelines are given for the diagnostic approach in these patients and, where possible, suggestions are given for treatment, including symptomatic treatment of painful neuropathies. Received: 1 November 1996ƒAccepted: 23 November 1996     

Uncompacted myelin lamellae in polyneuropathy,organomegaly, endocrinopathy,M-protein and skin changes syndrome

Mechanisms of peripheral neuropathies in polyneuropathy, organomegaly, endocrinopathy, M-protein and skin changes (POEMS) syndrome are poorly understood. A peripheral nerve biopsy was performed in 22 patients. Of these 9 had histological features of Castleman's disease on lymph node biopsies, and 19 had a monoclonal lambda light chain in their serum. Certain nerve fragments were paraffin embedded, others were frozen and studied by direct immuno-fluorescence, and others were fixed for ultrastructural examination. Paraffin-embedded fragments did not show any amyloid deposits, and at direct immunofluorescence there was no immunoglobulin fixation. At ultrastructural examination, features of uncompacted myelin lamellae (UML) were present in 19 patients, and their frequency varied from 1% to 16% of myelinated fibres. Up to now UML have been reported only in 7 patients with POEMS syndrome in the literature. UML have also been noticed in a few cases of inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuritis and inherited tendency to pressure palsy.     

Foot pad skin biopsy in mouse models of hereditary neuropathy

Numerous transgenic and knockout mouse models of human hereditary neuropathies have become available over the past decade. We describe a simple, reproducible, and safe biopsy of mouse skin for histopathological evaluation of the peripheral nervous system (PNS) in models of hereditary neuropathies. We compared the diagnostic outcome between sciatic nerve and dermal nerves found in skin biopsy (SB) from the hind foot. A total of five animal models of different Charcot-Marie-Tooth neuropathies, and one model of congenital muscular dystrophy associated neuropathy were examined. In wild type mice, dermal nerve fibers were readily identified by immunohistochemistry, light, and electron microscopy and they appeared similar to myelinated fibers in sciatic nerve. In mutant mice, SB manifested myelin abnormalities similar to those observed in sciatic nerves, including hypomyelination, onion bulbs, myelin outfolding, redundant loops, and tomacula. In many strains, however, SB showed additional abnormalities--fiber loss, dense neurofilament packing with lower phosphorylation status, and axonal degeneration-undetected in sciatic nerve, possibly because SB samples distal nerves. SB, a reliable technique to investigate peripheral neuropathies in human beings, is also useful to investigate animal models of hereditary neuropathies. Our data indicate that SB may reveal distal axonal pathology in mouse models and permits sequential follow-up of the neuropathy in an individual mouse, thereby reducing the number of mice necessary to document pathology of the PNS.     

A micro-electrode study of peripheral neuropathy in man. Part 2. Responses to conditioning stimuli.

Surface, needle and micro-electrode recordings were obtained from sensory nerves of patients with various types of peripheral neuropathy. Changes in amplitude and conduction velocity of nerve action potentials were measured after a single conditioning stimulus and after tetanic stimulation for 2 min. In patients with hereditary forms of axonal degeneration (AD), recovery processes of nerve fibres of all conduction velocities were normal; in acquired forms of AD fibres with conduction velocity less than 30 m/sec had greater and more prolonged post-tetanic depression than control nerves of similar conduction velocity. Where neuropathy was associated with segmental demyelination (SD), fibres of all conduction velocities had prolonged recovery processes after both single and tetanic stimulation. The changes were especially marked at higher skin temperature, and were greater than the changes seen in nerves with acquired forms of AD. Finally, 2 sural nerves were studied during the process of Wallerian degeneration after a biopsy had been obtained proximally, and recovery processes did not change during the period of degeneration. Perceptual abnormalities were similar in AD and SD. It is suggested that changes in recovery processes of nerve fibres with segmental demyelination or regeneration after injury contribute to the perceptual abnormalities which occur in clinically encountered peripheral neuropathies.     

Immune neuropathies

Immunoneuropathies constitute but a small percentage of polyneuropathies, compared to metabolic or toxic neuropathies. However, refined techniques of immunochemistry and biopsy have increasingly improved the etiological characterisation of immunoneuropathies. This review deals with the present diagnostic tools for investigation of polyneuropathies in general and with special immunological means of diagnosis. After two short case reports from our department, the main groups of peripheral nerve diseases, in which immunologic pathomechanisms are postulated, are described regarding symptomatology, special diagnostics and therapy. These groups of diseases are listed with respect to scientific evidence of their immunologic etiology, ranging from acute and chronic Guillain-Barré-Syndrome to paraneoplastic and neuropathies in HIV infections. The conclusion gives a summary of general pathogenetic considerations in immunoneuropathies.     

Epidermal nerve fiber density and sural nerve morphometry in peripheral neuropathies

OBJECTIVE: To study intraepidermal nerve fiber (IENF) density in distal leg skin biopsies, sural nerve morphometry, electrophysiology, and clinical features in patients with peripheral neuropathies. METHODS: We studied 26 patients with neuropathic complaints who had undergone clinical evaluation, nerve conduction studies, distal leg skin biopsy, and sural nerve biopsy. We quantified densities of IENF and of myelinated and unmyelinated fibers in the sural nerve. Associations among skin and sural nerve morphometric measures and sensory nerve action potential (SNAP) amplitudes were examined nonparametrically. Morphometric measures were examined with respect to diagnostic category of neuropathy. RESULTS: IENF density correlated with the densities of sural nerve total myelinated (r = 0.57, p = 0.0011), small myelinated (r = 0.53, p = 0.0029), and large myelinated fibers (r = 0.49, p = 0.0054). There was a trend toward an association between IENF and sural nerve unmyelinated fiber densities (r = 0.32, p = 0.054). Sural SNAP amplitude and large myelinated fiber densities were highly correlated (r = 0.87, p < 0.0001). IENF density and sural nerve small fiber measures were concordant in 73% of patients. Reduced IENF density was the only indicator of small fiber depletion in 23% of cases. It was usually normal in acquired demyelinating neuropathies and where clinical suspicion for neuropathy was low. CONCLUSIONS: Distal leg Intraepidermal nerve (IENF) density may be more sensitive than sural nerve biopsy in identifying small fiber sensory neuropathies. Assessments of IENF density and large fiber measures on biopsy and electrophysiology are both useful for characterizing sensory and sensorimotor neuropathies.     

Anti-NKH-1 antibody specifically stains unmyelinated fibres and non-myelinating Schwann cell columns in humans

Anti-NKH-1 antibody recognizes an isoform of the neural cell adhesion molecule (N-CAM) that is involved in cell-cell interactions during embryonic stages and has been detected in skin autonomic nerves. The specificity of anti-NKH-1 antibody for human unmyelinated fibres (UF) and the distribution of the antigens recognized by this antibody at the ultrastructural level, were evaluated by immunohistochemistry and immunoelectron microscopy on nerve biopsy samples from patients with normal nerve biopsies and a variety of peripheral neuropathies. The anti-NKH-1 antibody strongly stained all unmyelinated fibres while no myelinated fibre was stained. Autonomic nerve fibres were visualized at the periphery of blood vessels. Immunoelectron microscopy showed that the antigen recognized by the antibody was located at Schwann cell-axon interfaces and in portions of joined Schwannian surfaces, i.e. along mesaxons of non-myelinating Schwann cells. Expression of NKH-1 was basically similar in normal and diseased nerves as expression of NKH-1 was similar at the level of apposed plate-like Schwann cell processes than along normal mesaxons. The extent of labelling of diseased nerves by the anti-NKH-1 antibody likely depended on the number of residual Schwann cell columns observed by light microscopy.     

Evaluation of dermal myelinated nerve fibers in diabetes mellitus

Skin biopsies have primarily been used to study the non‐myelinated nerve fibers of the epidermis in a variety of neuropathies. In this study, we have expanded the skin biopsy technique to glabrous, non‐hairy skin to evaluate myelinated nerve fibers in the most highly prevalent peripheral nerve disease, diabetic polyneuropathy (DPN). Twenty patients with DPN (Type I, n = 9; Type II, n = 11) and 16 age‐matched healthy controls (age 29–73) underwent skin biopsy of the index finger, nerve conduction studies (NCS), and composite neuropathy scoring. In patients with DPN, we found a statistically significant reduction of both mechanoreceptive Meissner corpuscles (MCs) and their afferent myelinated nerve fibers (p = 0.01). This myelinated nerve fiber loss was correlated with the decreased amplitudes of sensory/motor responses in NCS. This study supports the utilization of skin biopsy to quantitatively evaluate axonal loss of myelinated nerve fibers in patients with DPN.     

Clinical and neuropathological parameters affecting the diagnostic yield of nerve biopsy

The value of nerve biopsy in the investigation of peripheral neuropathies is an important and controversial issue, partially obscured by the large variations in the diagnostic yield routinely reported for this procedure. The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical and neuropathological parameters affecting the yield of nerve biopsy. We compared the experience of two independent neuropathology laboratories with different patient recruitment and neuropathological methods over 11 years (01/1987-12/1997). Clinicopathological correlations were studied retrospectively in 355 patients. Using the same criteria of evaluation, contributive biopsies accounted for 35.5% in one laboratory, and 47.3% in the other. Clinical parameters affecting the yield of nerve biopsy were: (a) the presumptive diagnosis at time of referral for biopsy; (b) the distribution of symptoms; and (c) the interval between disease onset and biopsy. Greater yield was associated with clinically suspected vasculitis, inflammatory demyelinating neuropathy or hereditary sensorimotor neuropathies. Contributive findings were more often reported with multifocal or asymmetrical presentations, and onset-to-biopsy interval of less than 6 months. The contribution of nerve biopsy varied according to neuropathological techniques: (a) serial sections on frozen. paraffin-embedded and resin-embedded material improved sensitivity for interstitial pathology: (b) combined muscle biopsy increased sensitivity in the detection of vasculitis; and (c) teasing of nerve fibers added critical information to other classical techniques in only 4/102 cases.     

Clinical application of laser evoked potentials using the Nd:YAG laser.

The clinical interest of a new type of laser evoked potentials (LEPs) using Nd:YAG laser was assessed in the diagnosis of peripheral neuropathies affecting the small-diameter nerve fibres, and of spinal cord lesions, affecting the spinothalamic tract. Twelve patients aged from 26 to 79 years with sensory neuropathies (n = 6) or spinal cord lesions (n = 6) underwent neurophysiological examination of the lower limbs comprising quantitative sensory testing, i.e., the determination of vibratory and thermal thresholds (VT and TT), somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) to electrical stimulation and Nd:YAG LEPs. VT and SEPs were used to assess large-diameter afferent nerve fibres and the lemniscal pathways while TT and LEPs were used to assess small-diameter afferent nerve fibres and the spinothalamic tract. In addition, patients with peripheral neuropathy underwent also standard nerve conduction studies to explore large fibres and the recording of sympathetic skin responses (SSRs) to explore small fibres, whereas motor evoked potentials were performed in patients with spinal cord lesion. LEPs were absent bilaterally in all patients with polyneuropathy, even when TT remained within the normal limits and SSRs were present. LEPs were absent after stimulation of the affected limb in all patients with a spinal cord lesion, and allowed to detect subclinical contralateral lesion in two cases. LEPs following Nd:YAG laser stimulation are sensitive in the diagnosis of peripheral and/or central nervous system disorders and they give complementary information as compared to routine electrophysiological tests.     

EFNS guidelines on neuropathic pain assessment: revised 2009

Background and purpose: We have revised the previous EFNS guidelines on neuropathic pain (NP) assessment, which aimed to provide recommendations for the diagnostic process, screening tools and questionnaires, quantitative sensory testing (QST), microneurography, pain‐related reflexes and evoked potentials, functional neuroimaging and skin biopsy. Methods: We have checked and rated the literature published in the period 2004–2009, according to the EFNS method of classification for diagnostic procedures. Results: Most of the previous recommendations were reinforced by the new studies. The main revisions relate to: (i) the new definition of NP and a diagnostic grading system; (ii) several new validated clinical screening tools that identify NP components, and questionnaires which assess the different types of NP; (iii) recent high‐quality studies on laser‐evoked potentials (LEPs) and skin biopsy. Conclusions: History and bedside examination are still fundamental to a correct diagnosis, whilst screening tools and questionnaires are useful in indicating probable NP; QST is also useful for indicating the latter, and to assess provoked pains and treatment response. Amongst laboratory tests, LEPs are the best tool for assessing Aδ pathway dysfunction, and skin biopsy for assessing neuropathies with distal loss of unmyelinated nerve fibres.     

Peripheral nervous system neuroimmunology seen by a neuro-pathologist

In most dysimmune neuropathies, historically the microscopical lesions were described prior to immunological studies. The latter along with neuropathological studies have found some immune, albeit incomplete, explanations of the mechanisms of these lesions which we will describe in two main syndromes: the primitive auto-immune inflammatory peripheral polyneuropathies (GBS and CIDP) and polyneuropathies induced by a monoclonal dysglobulinemia. In some patients who have to be discussed case by case pathology (nerve biopsy) will confirm the diagnosis, may help to delineate the molecular anomalies and identify lesional mechanisms. We will review the high variability of nerve lesions which is characteristic of dysimmune neuropathies. Pathological studies confirm that both humoral and cellular immune reactions against Schwann cell and/or axonal antigens are implicated in primitive dysimmune neuropathies due to a dysfunction or failure of immune tolerance mechanisms. In case of a polyneuropathy associated to a monoclonal dysglobulinemia, pathological and immunological studies have shown that in many patients, the dysglobulinemia did harm the peripheral nerve; knowledge of the pathological lesions and their mechanisms is of major interest for orienting specific treatments.     

Ultra–high‐frequency ultrasound imaging of sural nerve: A comparative study with nerve biopsy in progressive neuropathies

Introduction: Nerve ultrasound has been used increasingly in clinical practice as a complementary test for diagnostic assessment of neuropathies, but nerve biopsy remains invaluable in certain cases. The aim of this study was to compare ultra–high‐frequency ultrasound (UHF‐US) to histologic findings in progressive polyneuropathies. Methods: Ten patients with severe, progressive neuropathies underwent ultrasound evaluation of the sural nerve before nerve biopsy. Ultrasound data were compared with histologic results in a retrospective manner. Results: Sural nerves were easily identified on UHF‐US. Nerve hyperechogenicity correlated with inflammatory infiltrates on biopsy. Nerve fascicles could be identified and measured on ultrasound in the majority of patients. Discussion: Hyperechogenicity on UHF‐US may be a marker of nerve inflammation in neuropathies. Furthermore, the UHF‐US probe allows for evaluation of sensory nerves in spite of their small size, providing valuable information on their size and on their internal structure.