Analysis of minimal promoter sequences for plus-strand synthesis by the Cucumber necrosis virus RNA-dependent RNA polymerase

Tombusviruses are small, plus-sense, single-stranded RNA viruses of plants. A partially purified RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) preparation of Cucumber necrosis virus (CNV), which is capable of de novo initiation of complementary RNA synthesis from either plus-strand or minus-strand templates, was used to dissect minimal promoter sequences for tombusviruses and their defective interfering (DI) RNAs. In vitro RdRp assay revealed that the core plus-strand initiation promoter included only the 3'-terminal 11 nucleotides. A hypothetical promoter-like sequence, which has been termed consensus sequence by Wu and White (1998, J. Virol. 72, 9897-9905), is recognized less efficiently by the CNV RdRp than the core plus-strand initiation promoter. The CNV RdRp can efficiently recognize the core plus-strand initiation promoter for a satellite RNA associated with the distantly related Turnip crinkle virus, while artificial AU- or GC-rich 3'-terminal sequences make poor templates in the in vitro assays. Comparison of the "strength" of minimal plus-strand and minus-strand initiation promoters reveals that the latter is almost twice as efficient in promoting complementary RNA synthesis. Template competition experiments, however, suggest that the minimal plus-strand initiation promoter makes an RNA template more competitive than the minimal minus-strand initiation promoter. Taken together, these results demonstrate that promoter recognition by the tombusvirus RdRp requires only short sequences present at the 3' end of templates.     

Internal initiation by the cucumber necrosis virus RNA-dependent RNA polymerase is facilitated by promoter-like sequences

Tombusviruses, small positive sense RNA viruses of plants, are replicated by the viral-coded RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) in infected cells. An unusual feature of the tombusvirus RdRp that is partially purified from cucumber necrosis virus (CNV)-infected plants is the ability to initiate complementary RNA synthesis from several internal positions on minus-strand templates derived from DI RNAs ( Nagy and Pogany, 2000 ). In this study, we used template deletion, mutagenesis, and oligo-based inhibition of RNA synthesis to map the internal initiation sites observed with the in vitro CNV RdRp system. Comparing sequences around the internal initiation sites reveals that they have either (i) similar sequences to the core minus-strand initiation promoter; or (ii) similar structures to the core plus-strand initiation promoter. In addition, we find similarities among the internal initiation sites and the subgenomic RNA initiation sites. These similarities suggest that the mechanism of internal initiation is similar to initiation from the terminal core promoters or the putative subgenomic promoter sequences. We propose that internal initiation on full-length RNA templates may be important in defective interfering (DI) RNA formation/evolution by producing intermediate templates for RNA recombination in tombusviruses. This may explain why tombusviruses are frequently associated with DI RNAs.     

Use of double-stranded RNA templates by the tombusvirus replicase in vitro: Implications for the mechanism of plus-strand initiation

Plus-stranded RNA viruses replicate efficiently in infected hosts producing numerous copies of the viral RNA. One of the long-standing mysteries in RNA virus replication is the occurrence and possible role of the double-stranded (ds)RNA formed between minus- and plus-strands. Using the partially purified Cucumber necrosis virus (CNV) replicase from plants and the recombinant RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) of Turnip crinkle virus (TCV), in this paper, we demonstrate that both CNV replicase and the related TCV RdRp can utilize dsRNA templates to produce viral plus-stranded RNA in vitro. Sequence and structure of the dsRNA around the plus-strand initiation site had a significant effect on initiation, suggesting that initiation on dsRNA templates is a rate-limiting step. In contrast, the CNV replicase could efficiently synthesize plus-strand RNA on partial dsRNAs that had the plus-strand initiation promoter "exposed", suggesting that the polymerase activity of CNV replicase is strong enough to unwind extended dsRNA regions in the template during RNA synthesis. Based on the in vitro data, we propose that dsRNA forms might have functional roles during tombus- and carmovirus replication and the AU-rich nature of the terminus could be important for opening the dsRNA structure around the plus-strand initiation promoter for tombus- and carmoviruses and possibly many other positive-strand RNA viruses.     

Heterologous RNA replication enhancer stimulates in vitro RNA synthesis and template-switching by the carmovirus, but not by the tombusvirus, RNA-dependent RNA polymerase: implication for modular evolution of RNA viruses

The viral RNA plays multiple roles during replication of RNA viruses, serving as a template for complementary RNA synthesis and facilitating the assembly of the viral replicase complex. These roles are coordinated by cis-acting regulatory elements, such as promoters and replication enhancers (REN). To test if these RNA elements can be used by related viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerases (RdRp), we compared the potential stimulatory effects of homologous and heterologous REN elements on complementary RNA synthesis and template-switching by the tombus- (Cucumber necrosis virus, CNV), carmovirus (Turnip crinkle virus, TCV) and hepatitis C virus (HCV) RdRps in vitro. The CNV RdRp selectively utilized its cognate REN, while discriminating against the heterologous TCV REN. On the contrary, RNA synthesis by the TCV RdRp was stimulated by the TCV REN and the heterologous tombusvirus REN with comparable efficiency. The heterologous REN elements also promoted in vitro template-switching by the TCV and HCV RdRps. Based on these observations, we propose that REN elements could facilitate intervirus recombination and post-recombinational amplification of new recombinant viruses.     

A 5' RNA element promotes dengue virus RNA synthesis on a circular genome

The mechanisms of RNA replication of plus-strand RNA viruses are still unclear. Here, we identified the first promoter element for RNA synthesis described in a flavivirus. Using dengue virus as a model, we found that the viral RdRp discriminates the viral RNA by specific recognition of a 5' element named SLA. We demonstrated that RNA-RNA interactions between 5' and 3' end sequences of the viral genome enhance dengue virus RNA synthesis only in the presence of an intact SLA. We propose a novel mechanism for minus-strand RNA synthesis in which the viral polymerase binds SLA at the 5' end of the genome and reaches the site of initiation at the 3' end via long-range RNA-RNA interactions. These findings provide an explanation for the strict requirement of dengue virus genome cyclization during viral replication.     

3'-Terminal RNA secondary structures are important for accumulation of tomato bushy stunt virus DI RNAs

The plus-strand RNA genome of tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) contains a 351-nucleotide (nt)-long 3'-untranslated region. We investigated the role of the 3'-proximal 130 nt of this sequence in viral RNA accumulation within the context of a TBSV defective interfering (DI) RNA. Sequence comparisons between different tombusviruses revealed that the 3' portion of the 130-nt sequence is highly conserved and deletion analysis confirmed that this segment is required for accumulation of DI RNAs in protoplasts. Computer-aided sequence analysis and in vitro solution structure probing indicated that the conserved sequence consists of three stem-loop (SL) structures (5'-SL3-SL2-SL1-3'). The existence of SLs 1 and 3 was also supported by comparative secondary structure analysis of sequenced tombusvirus genomes. Formation of the stem regions in all three SLs was found to be very important, and modification of the terminal loop sequences of SL1 and SL2, but not SL3, decreased DI RNA accumulation in vivo. For SL3, alterations to an internal loop resulted in significantly reduced DI RNA levels. Collectively, these data indicate that all three SLs are functionally relevant and contribute substantially to DI RNA accumulation. In addition, secondary structure analysis of other tombusvirus replicons and related virus genera revealed that a TBSV satellite RNA and members of the closely related genus Aureusvirus (family Tombusviridae) share fundamental elements of this general structural arrangement. Thus, this secondary structure model appears to extend beyond tombusvirus genomes. These conserved 3'-terminal RNA elements likely function in vivo by promoting and/or regulating minus-strand synthesis.     

Importance of sequence and structural elements within a viral replication repressor

Efficient replication of plus-strand RNA viruses requires a 3' proximal core promoter and an increasingly diverse inventory of supporting elements such as enhancers, repressors, and 5' terminal sequences. While core promoters have been well characterized, much less is known about structure-functional relationships of these supporting elements. Members of the genus Carmovirus family Tombusviridae contain a hairpin (H5) proximal to the core promoter that functions as a repressor of minus-strand synthesis in vitro through an interaction between its large symmetrical internal loop (LSL) and 3' terminal bases. Turnip crinkle virus satellite RNA satC with the H5 of carmovirus Japanese iris necrosis virus or Cardamine chlorotic fleck virus (CCFV) did not accumulate to detectable levels even though 3' end base-pairing would be maintained. Replacement of portions of the satC H5 with analogous portions from CCFV revealed that the cognate LSL and lower stem were of greater importance for satC accumulation than the upper stem. In vivo selex of the H5 upper stem and terminal GNRA tetraloop revealed considerable plasticity in the upper stem, including the presence of three- to six-base terminal loops, allowed for H5 function. In vivo selex of the lower stem revealed that both a stable stem and specific base pairs contributed to satC fitness. Surprisingly, mutations in H5 had a disproportionate effect on plus-strand accumulation that was unrelated to the stability of the mutant plus-strands. In addition, fitness to accumulate in plants did not always correlate with enhanced ability to accumulate in protoplasts, suggesting that H5 may be multifunctional.     

The overlapping RNA-binding domains of p33 and p92 replicase proteins are essential for tombusvirus replication

Two of the five viral-coded proteins of tombusviruses, which are small, nonsegmented, plus-stranded RNA viruses of plants, are required for replication in infected cells. These replicase proteins, namely, p33 and p92, of cucumber necrosis virus are expressed directly from the genomic RNA via a readthrough mechanism. Their overlapping domains contain an arginine/proline-rich RNA-binding motif (termed RPR, which has the sequence RPRRRP). Site-directed mutagenesis of p33 expressed in Escherichia coli, followed by a gel shift assay, defined two of the four arginines as required for efficient RNA binding in vitro. In vivo testing of 19 RPR motif mutants revealed that the RPR motif, and therefore the ability to bind RNA, is important for the replication of tombusviruses and their associated defective interfering (DI) RNAs. Mutation within the RPR motif also affected the ratio of subgenomic versus genomic RNAs in infected cells. To test whether the RPR motif is essential for the function of either p33 or p92 in replication, we used a two-component system developed by, J. Virol. 5845-5851), in which p92 was expressed from the genomic RNA of a tombusvirus, while p33 was expressed from a DI RNA. The protoplast experiments with the two-component system revealed that the RPR motif is essential for the replication function of both proteins. Interestingly, mutations within the RPR motif of p33 and p92 had different effects on RNA replication, suggesting different roles for the RNA-binding motifs of these proteins in tombusvirus replication.     

The T12I mutation within the SP1 region of Gag restricts packaging of spliced viral RNA into human immunodeficiency virus type 1 with mutated RNA packaging signals and mutated nucleocapsid sequence

Specific packaging of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) RNA is attributable to the high affinity of nucleocapsid (NC) sequence of Gag for the cis-acting RNA packaging signals located within the 5' un-translated region (5' UTR). Interestingly, we have previously reported that the T12I mutation (named MP2) within SP1 of Gag prevented incorporation of spliced viral RNA into mutated viruses that lacked the stem-loop 1 (SL1) RNA element (also named dimerization initiation site, DIS), suggesting a role for the SP1 sequence in viral RNA packaging. In this study, we have further tested this activity of MP2 in the context of a variety of mutations that affect viral RNA incorporation. The results showed that MP2 was able to effectively restrict packaging of spliced viral RNA into viruses containing either NC mutations R10A and K11A or mutated 5' UTR sequence, such as DeltaGU3 that lacked the 112-GUCUGUUGUGUG-123 sequence of U5, D1 that was deleted of a 27 nt fragment immediately downstream of the primer binding site (PBS), Delta(306-325) that had the SL3 RNA element removed and MD2 that was missing the 328-GGAG-331 sequence. As a result, MP2 contributed increased infectivity to the related viruses. Therefore, the MP2 mutation demonstrates a distinct role in HIV-1 RNA packaging that is neither pertained to the specific viral RNA packaging signal nor to the NC sequence.     

Mutation analysis of cis-elements in the 3'- and 5'-untranslated regions of satellite tobacco necrosis virus strain C RNA.

The putative, 3'-terminal stem-loop structure in satellite tobacco necrosis virus strain C (STNV-C) RNA constitutes an essential cis-acting structure for the promotion of negative-strand RNA synthesis and a single-stranded tail is also important. The putative, 5'-terminal stem-loop structure in STNV-C RNA is not essential for productive, plus-strand RNA accumulation but is required for optimal accumulation. Residues 2 and 3 are the minimal cis-acting sequences required for RNA synthesis. The RNA of chimeric mutants, which exchanged 3'- and 5'-untranslated regions between STNV-C and helper tobacco necrosis virus strain D RNAs, accumulated in protoplasts, implying similar replication mechanisms for both RNAs.     

Regulation of Semliki Forest virus RNA replication: a model for the control of alphavirus pathogenesis in invertebrate hosts

Alphavirus nonstructural proteins are translated as a polyprotein that is ultimately cleaved into four mature proteins called nsP1, nsP2, nsP3, and nsP4 from their order in the polyprotein. The role of this nonstructural polyprotein, of cleavage intermediates, and of mature proteins in synthesis of Semliki Forest virus (SFV) RNA has been studied using mutants unable to cleave one or more of the sites in the nonstructural polyprotein or that had the arginine sense codon between nsP3 and nsP4 changed to an opal termination codon. The results were compared with those obtained for Sindbis virus (SINV), which has a naturally occurring opal codon between nsP2 and nsP3. We found that (1) an active nonstructural protease in nsP2 is required for RNA synthesis. This protease is responsible for all three cleavages in the nonstructural polyprotein. (2) Cleavage between nsP3 and nsP4 (the viral RNA polymerase) is required for RNA synthesis by SFV. (3) SFV mutants that are able to produce only polyprotein P123 and nsP4 synthesize minus-strand RNA early after infection as efficiently as SF wild type but are defective in the synthesis of plus-strand RNA. The presence of sense or opal following nsP3 did not affect this result. At 30 degrees C, they give rise to low yields of virus after a delay, but at 39 degrees C, they are nonviable. (4) SFV mutants that produce nsP1, P23, nsP4, as well as the precursor P123 are viable but produce an order of magnitude less virus than wild type at 30 degrees C and two orders of magnitude less virus at 39 degrees C. The ratio of subgenomic mRNA to genomic RNA is much reduced in these mutants relative to the parental viruses. (5) At 30 degrees C, the variants containing an opal codon grow as well as or slightly better than the corresponding virus with a sense codon. At 39 degrees C, however, the opal variants produce significantly more virus. These results support the conclusion that SFV and SINV, and by extension all alphaviruses, regulate their RNA synthesis in the same fashion after infection. P123 and nsP4 form a minus-strand replicase that synthesizes plus-strand RNA only inefficiently, especially at the higher temperatures found in mammals and birds. A replicase containing nsP1, P23, and nsP4 can make both plus and minus strands, but prefers the promoter for genomic plus sense RNA to that for subgenomic mRNA. The fully cleaved replicase can make only plus-strand RNA, and prefers the promoter for subgenomic mRNA to that for genomic RNA. Alphaviruses alternate between infection of hematophagous arthropods and higher vertebrates. Although the infection of higher vertebrates is acute and often accompanied by disease, continuing transmission of the virus in nature requires that infection of arthropods be persistent and relatively asymptomatic. We propose that this mechanism for control of RNA synthesis evolved to moderate the pathogenicity of the viruses in their arthropod hosts.     

Repair of lost 5′ terminal sequences in tombusviruses: Rapid recovery of promoter- and enhancer-like sequences in recombinant RNAs

Maintenance of genome integrity is of major importance for plus-stranded RNA viruses that are vulnerable to degradation by host ribonucleases or to replicase errors. We demonstrate that short truncations at the 5′ end of a model Tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) RNA could be repaired during replication in yeast and plant cells. Although the truncations led to the loss of important cis-regulatory elements, the genome repair mechanisms led to the recovery of promoter and enhancer-like sequences in 92% of TBSV progeny. Using in vitro approaches, we demonstrate that the repaired TBSV RNAs are replication-competent. We propose three different mechanisms for genome repair: initiation of RNA synthesis from internal sequences and addition of nonviral nucleotides by the tombusvirus replicase; and via RNA recombination. The ability to repair cis-sequences makes the tombusvirus genome more flexible, which could be beneficial to increase the virus fitness and adaptation to new hosts.     

Subgenomic messenger RNAs: mastering regulation of (+)-strand RNA virus life cycle

Many (+)-strand RNA viruses use subgenomic (SG) RNAs as messengers for protein expression, or to regulate their viral life cycle. Three different mechanisms have been described for the synthesis of SG RNAs. The first mechanism involves internal initiation on a (−)-strand RNA template and requires an internal SGP promoter. The second mechanism makes a prematurely terminated (−)-strand RNA which is used as template to make the SG RNA. The third mechanism uses discontinuous RNA synthesis while making the (−)-strand RNA templates. Most SG RNAs are translated into structural proteins or proteins related to pathogenesis: however other SG RNAs regulate the transition between translation and replication, function as riboregulators of replication or translation, or support RNA-RNA recombination. In this review we discuss these functions of SG RNAs and how they influence viral replication, translation and recombination.     

RNA-based viral immunity initiated by the Dicer family of host immune receptors

Summary:  Suppression of viral infection by RNA in a nucleotide sequence homology-dependent manner was first reported in plants in early 1990s. Studies in the past 15 years have established a completely new RNA-based immune system against viruses that is mechanistically related to RNA silencing or RNA interference (RNAi). This viral immunity begins with recognition of viral double-stranded or structured RNA by the Dicer nuclease family of host immune receptors. In fungi, plants and invertebrates, the viral RNA trigger is processed into small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) to direct specific silencing of the homologous viral genomic and/or messenger RNAs by an RNaseH-like Argonaute protein. Deep sequencing of virus-derived siRNAs indicates that the immunity against viruses with a positive-strand RNA genome is induced by Dicer recognition of dsRNA formed during the initiation of viral progeny (+)RNA synthesis. The RNA-based immune pathway in these organisms overlaps the canonical dsRNA-siRNA pathway of RNAi and may require amplification of viral siRNAs by host RNA-dependent RNA polymerase in plants and nematodes. Production of virus-derived small RNAs is undetectable in mammalian cells infected with RNA viruses. However, infection of mammals with several nucleus-replicating DNA viruses induces production of virus-derived microRNAs capable of silencing host and viral mRNAs as found for viral siRNAs. Remarkably, recent studies indicate that prokaryotes also produce virus-derived small RNAs known as CRISPR RNAs to guide antiviral defense in a manner that has yet to be defined. In this article, we review the recent progress on the identification and mechanism of the key components including viral sensors, viral triggers, effectors, and amplifiers, of the small RNA-directed viral immunity. We also highlight some of the many unresolved questions.     

The 3' end of hepatitis E virus (HEV) genome binds specifically to the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp)

Hepatitis E virus (HEV) is the major cause of acute epidemic and sporadic hepatitis in the developing world. It is a positive-strand RNA virus with a genome length of about 7.2 kb. The replication mechanism of this virus is virtually unexplored. Identification of the regulatory elements involved in initiation of replication may help in designing specific inhibitors for therapy. In the positive-stranded RNA viruses the initiation of replication requires interaction of the 3' end of genome with its RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) and possibly host-derived cofactors for synthesis of the minus-strand replicative intermediate. Secondary structure prediction of the conserved 3' end of the infectious HEV genome was carried out to identify possible stem-loop structures necessary for RNA-protein interaction and the model was confirmed by structure probing experiments. Electrophoretic mobility-shift assays showed specific binding of purified and refolded recombinant HEV RdRp protein to the 3' end of its RNA genome containing the poly(A) stretch. Mutations at the 3' end, in which the stem-loop structures were partially or completely destroyed or recreated revealed that the two stem-loop structures SL1 and SL2 at the 3' end and the poly(A) stretch are necessary for this binding. The interacting nucleotides in such an interaction were further identified by generating footprints of the complex by Pb(II)-induced hydrolysis. This specific binding of viral RdRp to the 3' end of HEV RNA directs the synthesis of complementary-strand RNA and thus such a binding domain might assume the role of a possible cis-acting element as a potential site for the initiation of replication.