Open trial of psychodynamic psychotherapy for panic disorder: a pilot study

OBJECTIVE: This report contains preliminary data from an open trial of brief psychodynamic psychotherapy for panic disorder. METHOD: Fourteen patients with primary DSM-IV panic disorder completed a 24-session, twice-weekly course of psychodynamic psychotherapy. Other psychiatric treatment was not permitted throughout the 12-week treatment period and the 6-month follow-up. Symptoms were assessed at baseline, treatment termination, and 6-month posttermination follow-up (40 weeks). RESULTS: Statistically significant, clinically meaningful improvements appeared in panic, depression, anxiety, and functional impairment both at treatment termination and at 6-month follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: Psychodynamic monotherapy can be used successfully to retain and treat patients with panic disorder. Psychodynamic interventions warrant further study for patients with panic disorder.     

A crossover study of focused cognitive therapy for panic disorder.

OBJECTIVE: This study sought to determine the short- and long-term effects of focused cognitive therapy for panic disorder. METHOD: Thirty-three psychiatric outpatients with the DSM-III diagnosis of panic disorder were randomly assigned to either 12 weeks of individual, focused cognitive therapy or 8 weeks of brief supportive psychotherapy based on principles of client-centered therapy. The patients who received supportive psychotherapy were subsequently given the opportunity to cross over to cognitive therapy for 12 weeks. Patients were rated for panic and depression before therapy, after 4 and 8 weeks of therapy, and at 6-month and 1-year follow-up. RESULTS: Clinician ratings and self-ratings of panic frequency and intensity indicated that the focused cognitive therapy group achieved significantly greater reductions in panic symptoms and general anxiety after 8 weeks of treatment than did the group that received brief supportive psychotherapy. At 8 weeks, 71% of the cognitive therapy group were panic free, compared to 25% of the psychotherapy group. Moreover, 94% of the psychotherapy patients elected to cross over to 12 weeks of cognitive therapy. At 1-year follow-up, 87% of the group that received cognitive therapy only and 79% of the group that crossed over into cognitive therapy remained free of panic attacks. CONCLUSIONS: Focused cognitive therapy offers a promising nonpharmacological alternative for the treatment of panic disorder.     

Differential diagnosis and treatment of panic disorder: a medical model perspective

The authors present a review of existing literature along with new data regarding the phenomenology, differential diagnosis, course and treatment of panic disorder and agoraphobia. Panic attacks are viewed as central to the development of these disorders, and individual cognitive frameworks contribute to the manner in which a patient's symptoms evolve. An apparent though unclear relation to depressive states is described. Substance abuse may also be a consequence of recurrent panic attacks. A scheme towards differential diagnosis of panic disorder from other psychiatric and medical disorders is proposed. Personality characteristics of these patients vary considerably, but certain factors, such as dependency, are common. Family relations are often strained and assume importance in treatment. Data on the longitudinal course of illness is presented implying a relationship of panic disorder to both depression and stressful life events in many patients. Treatments that thus far seem most effective are pharmacological and behavioural approaches. Imipramine, MAO inhibitors, and alprazolam currently appear to be the most useful medications employed, although other agents may at times be useful alternatives. Dietary interventions, family therapy, and group and individual psychotherapy are also reviewed and discussed as adjunctive therapies in the treatment of panic disorder.     

Koinzidenz von schizophrener Psychose und Panikstörung mit Agoraphobie

The coincidence between panic disorder and depression is a well known phenomenon. However, only few studies investigated the coincidence of panic disorder with schizophrenia. This may in part be explained by the fact that both positive and negative symptoms of schizophrenia may mask the clinical symptoms of a panic disorder. We report on a female patient suffering both from agoraphobia with panic disorder and paranoid schizophrenia according to ICD-10. The productive psychotic symptoms responded well to treatment with a low dose of zotepine, whereas the panic disorder was effectively treated with a combined therapy with imipramine and cognitive behavioral therapy. Although it has to be questioned whether the coincidence between panic disorder and schizophrenia reflects two different diagnostic entities, the occurrence of symptoms of a panic disorder in schizophrenia deserve further attention because these may be treated efficiently by a specific pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy.     

Short- and long- term efficacy of cognitive behavioral therapy for DSM-IV panic disorder in patients with and without severe psychiatric comorbidity

Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and/or pharmacological therapy are considered to be effective in the treatment of anxiety disorders. Anxiety patients frequently suffer from comorbid psychiatric disorders such as depression or substance disorders. Ongoing substance disorders and/or severe depressive symptomatology often are the reason why patients are not treated by outpatient psychotherapy. The present study was designed to evaluate whether CBT is comparably effective both in anxiety patients with and without comorbid axis-I-diagnoses.In a 5-weeks standardized inpatient CBT program for anxiety disorders at the Center of Mental Health, Ingolstadt, 48 patients with panic disorder according to DSM-IV were included. 42% of the patients suffered from panic disorder only, 58% from at least one further mental disorder, mainly from affective and/or substance disorders. The severity of symptomatology was determined using psychometric scales at admission, at discharge and at the follow-up investigation.In general, therapy was highly effective. Panic symptoms as well as anxious cognitions and avoidance behavior were significantly reduced at discharge and results remained stable until the follow-up investigation. Therapy was equally effective in both groups, in patients with pure and patients with comorbid panic disorder at discharge as well as at the follow-up investigation. Thus, patients with comorbid affective or substance disorders should not be excluded from psychotherapeutic programs in future.     

Emotion-focused psychotherapy for patients with panic disorder.

OBJECTIVE: Recent studies have suggested that most patients treated for panic disorder receive forms of psychotherapy other than cognitive behavior therapy, even though there is little information about the efficacy of such treatments or how they compare to proven active treatments. The authors compared one of these other forms, emotion-focused psychotherapy (given to 30 patients with panic disorder), to results obtained with recommended standard treatment (either cognitive behavior therapy [N=36] or imipramine [N=22]). The authors also compared emotion-focused psychotherapy to results obtained in subjects given pill placebo (N=24). METHOD: Subjects met DSM-IV criteria for panic disorder with no more than mild agoraphobia. Treatment consisted of approximately 3 months of weekly visits followed by 6 monthly maintenance visits. Assessments were conducted after each treatment phase and at a follow-up visit after 6 months of no treatment. RESULTS: Emotion-focused psychotherapy was less effective for symptoms of panic disorder than treatment with either cognitive behavior therapy or imipramine; results obtained with emotion-focused psychotherapy after the acute and maintenance phases were similar to those seen with placebo. Treatment expectations were not different among the different groups. Patients receiving emotion-focused psychotherapy had the highest completion rate. CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest that emotion-focused psychotherapy (a supportive form of psychotherapy) has low efficacy for the treatment of panic disorder. However, emotion-focused psychotherapy may be superior to medical management in helping patients stay in treatment.     

Comorbidity of ictal fear and panic disorder

Purpose. We sought to determine the prevalence of psychiatric conditions, particularly panic disorder, in epilepsy patients with ictal fear.Methods. A consecutive series of 12 patients with ictal fear underwent psychiatric evaluation, via either formal consultation with a psychiatrist or standardized interview using the Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview; the latter was addended to create an instrument specifically for use in epilepsy patients (MINI-Epi).Results. Four of the twelve patients (33%) with ictal fear had a comorbid diagnosis of panic disorder. One of these developed panic attacks only after epilepsy surgery, and another worsened after surgery, while in the other two panic attacks were not related to any surgical procedure. Two patients had other anxiety disorders. Eight patients (67%) had current or past depression; this did not appear to be related to the presence of panic disorder.Conclusion. A specific comorbidity exists between focal epilepsy with ictal fear and panic disorder. Involvement of the amygdala in both temporal lobe epilepsy and panic disorder may underlie this. The predisposition to panic disorder in these patients may be exacerbated by anterior temporal lobectomy.     

Panic disorder among Cambodian refugees attending a psychiatric clinic. Prevalence and subtypes

This study surveys Khmer refugees attending two psychiatric clinics to determine both the prevalence of panic disorder as well as panic attack subtypes in those suffering panic disorder. A culturally valid adaptation of the SCID-panic module, the Cambodian Panic Disorder Survey (CPDS), was administered to 89 consecutive Cambodian refugees attending these psychiatric clinics. Utilizing culturally sensitive panic probes, the CPDS provides information regarding both the presence of panic disorder and panic-attack subtypes during the month prior to interview. Of 89 patients surveyed at two psychiatric clinics, 53 (60%) currently suffered panic disorder. Among the 53 patients suffering panic disorder, the most common panic attack subtypes during the previous month were the following: “sore neck” [51% of the 53 panic disorder patients (PDPs)], orthostatic dizziness (49% of PDPs), gastrointestinal distress (26% of PDPs), effort induced (21% of PDPs), olfactory induced (21% of PDPs), and “while-sitting dizziness” (16% of PDPs).     

An open pilot study of interpersonal psychotherapy for panic disorder (IPT-PD)

Interpersonal psychotherapy (IPT) is a time-limited psychotherapy initially developed to treat depression. It has yet to be studied systematically for treatment of panic disorder. We modified IPT for the treatment of panic disorder and tested this treatment in an open clinical trial with 12 patients seeking treatment of DSM-IV panic disorder. Patients were assessed before during and after treatment. At completion of treatment, nine patients (75%) were independently categorized as responders (i.e., rated as much improved or very much improved on the Clinical Global Impression-Change Scale). Substantial improvement was found for panic symptoms, associated anxiety and depressive symptoms, and physical and emotional well-being. Degree of change in this sample approximated that obtained in studies using established treatments such as cognitive behavioral therapy. Results, though preliminary, suggest that IPT may have efficacy as a primary treatment of panic disorder. Further study is warranted.     

A randomized controlled clinical trial of psychoanalytic psychotherapy for panic disorder

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to determine the efficacy of panic-focused psychodynamic psychotherapy relative to applied relaxation training, a credible psychotherapy comparison condition. Despite the widespread clinical use of psychodynamic psychotherapies, randomized controlled clinical trials evaluating such psychotherapies for axis I disorders have lagged. To the authors' knowledge, this is the first efficacy randomized controlled clinical trial of panic-focused psychodynamic psychotherapy, a manualized psychoanalytical psychotherapy for patients with DSM-IV panic disorder. METHOD: This was a randomized controlled clinical trial of subjects with primary DSM-IV panic disorder. Participants were recruited over 5 years in the New York City metropolitan area. Subjects were 49 adults ages 18-55 with primary DSM-IV panic disorder. All subjects received assigned treatment, panic-focused psychodynamic psychotherapy or applied relaxation training in twice-weekly sessions for 12 weeks. The Panic Disorder Severity Scale, rated by blinded independent evaluators, was the primary outcome measure. RESULTS: Subjects in panic-focused psychodynamic psychotherapy had significantly greater reduction in severity of panic symptoms. Furthermore, those receiving panic-focused psychodynamic psychotherapy were significantly more likely to respond at treatment termination (73% versus 39%), using the Multicenter Panic Disorder Study response criteria. The secondary outcome, change in psychosocial functioning, mirrored these results. CONCLUSIONS: Despite the small cohort size of this trial, it has demonstrated preliminary efficacy of panic-focused psychodynamic psychotherapy for panic disorder.     

General Meeting Of The Association

Abstract

Selective mutism is a rare psychiatric disorder of unknown aetiology that usually has its onset in early childhood. It appears to be a childhood variant of social phobia, panic or separation anxiety disorder. While the cornerstones in the treatment of this disorder centre around cognitive behavioural and psychotherapy, recent evidence has hinted at the potential value of pharmacotherapy. Neurobiological studies have emphasized the critical role of serotonin (5HT) in anxiety disorders, including social phobia and panic with the selective 5HT reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) group of drugs showing the greatest efficacy in treating these conditions. On the basis of these scientific data, and supported by the two case reports described, which demonstrate the efficacy of the SSRI, fluoxetine (FLX), in children with severe unresponsive selective mutism, we propose a possible pharmacological rationale for the adjunctive use of 5HT selective agents in this disorder.     

Is panic disorder a distinct diagnostic entity? A critical review of the borders of a syndrome

The evidence supporting the existence of panic disorder as a distinct clinical entity is critically examined, as are the current criteria for panic disorder in DSM-III. It is argued that the current definition of a panic attack is imprecise and that the borders and overlap of panic disorder with other psychiatric disorders raise broader questions as to what is meant by a distinct psychiatric disorder. DSM-III "panic disorder" defines an ideal type that may be more relevant for research purposes than clinical. In defining fairly homogeneous "pure" cases, it overlooks the prevalence and importance of atypical "mixed" and subsyndromal cases.     

The treatment of panic disorder

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The aim of this article is to provide an updated review of studies and recommendations published from August 2003 to August 2004 on the treatment of panic disorder. RECENT FINDINGS: Cognitive-behavioral psychotherapy remains the treatment of choice for panic disorder. Recent studies confirm selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors as the first-choice drugs in treating panic disorder. Recommendations for (adjunctive) high-potency benzodiazepines have been published. Psychoeducation and combined pharmacotherapy/psychotherapy improve treatment response. Optimal long-term treatment of panic disorder involves adequate medication and duration of treatment, since relapse is frequent. SUMMARY: Recent studies confirm that cognitive-behavioral therapy, alone or in combination with drug therapy, remains the treatment of choice for panic disorder. Long-term treatment is often necessary due to the chronicity of the illness.     

Editorial:Pediatric Bipolar Disorder

Psychiatric diagnosis is currently in the headlines, both in psychiatric scientific literature and in the popular press. Preliminary reports of the changes due with DSM-5 have generated immense controversy. The diagnosis of childhood bipolar disorder, however, has been in controversy for several years, well before the current debate about DSM-5. It is important to note that changes, even major changes, in psychiatric diagnosis are nothing new. One of us (RHB) was enrolled in a psychoanalytically oriented residency program at Duke in 1972 and had a new patient with discrete recurrent periods of extreme anxiety who was not responding to psychotherapy and it was decided to search the literature. There was an article by Donald Klein entitled "Delineation of two drug-responsive anxiety syndromes" (1). Based on that article the patient was given imipramine and observed the kind of results at a low dose with a dramatic therapeutic benefit that usually only happens when a new therapy is discovered. Later on it takes higher dose, larger samples and there are more modest effects. This syndrome was later defined as panic disorder but it is hard for young psychiatrists nowadays to realize that in 1971 the nomenclature did not include the concept of panic disorder. Not that it was given a different name: The basic concept simply did not exist.     

Valproate Adjuvant Cognitive Behavioral Therapy in Panic Disorder Patients With Comorbid Bipolar Disorder: Case Series and Review of the Literature

Anxiety disorders are the most common comorbid psychiatric disorders in patients with bipolar disorder. Managing anxiety symptoms in comorbid conditions is challenging and has received little research interest. The findings from preclinical research on fear conditioning, an animal model of anxiety disorder, have suggested that memory reconsolidation updating (exposure-based therapy) combined with valproate might facilitate the amelioration of fear memories. Here, three cases of successful amelioration of agoraphobia and panic symptoms through valproate adjuvant therapy for cognitive behavioral therapy in patients who failed to respond to two to three consecutive standard pharmacotherapy trials over several years are described. To the best of the author’s knowledge, this is the first attempt to combine CBT with valproate in patients with panic disorder, agoraphobia, and comorbid bipolar disorder. Additionally, the background preclinical research on this combination therapy based on the reconsolidation-updating mechanism, the inhibition of histone deacetylase 2, and critical period reopening, off-label use of valproate in panic disorder, plasticity-augmented psychotherapy, and how to combine valproate with CBT is discussed.     

Neurobiology and etiology of panic disorder

Panic disorder entered the psychiatric nomenclature a quarter-century ago, and an explosion of studies followed. Defining the core phenomenology of panic disorder can be advanced by an understanding of its pathophysiology and exploration of its etiology. The lessons learned can guide the delivery of treatments to enhance the likelihood of achieving remission and the discovery of novel treatments for panic disorder.     

Comorbid bipolar disorder and panic disorder in families with a high prevalence of bipolar disorder.

OBJECTIVE: Panic attacks are a common complication of affective disorder, although the etiologic relationship of panic and affective symptoms has not been determined. Evidence from a family study suggests that panic attacks and panic disorder may be related genetically to bipolar disorder. This study used diagnostic data from the NIMH Bipolar Disorder Genetics Initiative to assess in a separate, larger family set the familiality of panic combined with bipolar disorder. METHOD: First-degree relatives (N=966) of probands with bipolar I disorder (N=192) and schizoaffective disorder, bipolar type, (N=11) were included in the study. All subjects were interviewed directly and were assigned best-estimate diagnoses for major affective and other psychiatric disorders. The risk of a family member being diagnosed with panic disorder if the proband with bipolar disorder had panic attacks or panic disorder was calculated with logistic regression analysis with generalized estimating equations that controlled for sex and affective disorder subdiagnosis. RESULTS: More than 90% of the probands and first-degree relatives with panic disorder also had an affective disorder diagnosis. Panic disorder was present in 17% of the relatives with recurrent major affective disorder and in 3% of the relatives without recurrent major affective disorder. Risk of panic disorder in relatives with bipolar disorder was increased significantly if the proband had panic attacks or panic disorder. CONCLUSIONS: Risk for panic disorder with familial bipolar disorder appears to be inherited. Inherited risk for panic disorder with bipolar disorder may indicate a shared genetic etiology for both disorders in some families. The patterns of bipolar disorder and panic disorder comorbidity observed in families imply a complex genetic etiology, which may be elucidated by using endophenotypes.     

Nonfearful panic disorder in neurology patients validated by lactate challenge

OBJECTIVE: Nonfearful panic disorder meets the DSM-III-R criteria for panic disorder but is not associated with subjective fear and anxiety. The authors determined its prevalence in a group of neurology patients and assessed its diagnostic validity as a panic disorder subtype by evaluating the response of the patients with nonfearful panic disorder to sodium lactate and antipanic pharmacotherapy. METHOD: The subjects were all neurology patients referred over 1 year to a university hospital's psychiatric consultation service because of negative medical workups for their symptoms (N = 48). Patients who met the DSM-III-R criteria for panic disorder but did not report subjective anxiety or fear during panic episodes were diagnosed as having nonfearful panic disorder. Afterward, each of those patients received a sodium lactate infusion and, 5 hours later, a sodium chloride infusion. They were then treated with antipanic medication and followed for at least 6 months. RESULTS: Of the 48 neurology patients referred for psychiatric evaluation, 11 (23%) met the criteria for panic disorder, and all 11 met the criteria for nonfearful panic disorder. All 11 responded positively to lactate but not to placebo, and they each experienced an at least 75% reduction in symptoms during the 6-month follow-up period. Detailed case reports of three of these patients are presented. CONCLUSIONS: These findings support the construct and predictive diagnostic validity of nonfearful panic disorder as a subtype of panic disorder and suggest that a lack of attention to this group leads to both the underestimation of the prevalence of panic disorder and to the withholding of potentially successful treatments for this group.     

Panic disorder and hyperventilation

Respiratory abnormalities are associated with anxiety, particularly with panic attacks. Symptoms such as shortness of breath, "empty-head" feeling, dizziness, paresthesias and tachypnea have been described in the psychiatric and respiratory physiology related to panic disorder. Panic disorder patients exhibit both behaviorally and physiologically abnormal responses to respiratory challenges tests. OBJECTIVE: We aim to observe the induction of panic attacks by hyperventilation in a group of panic disorder patients (DSM-IV). METHOD: 13 panic disorder patients and 11 normal volunteers were randomly selected. They were drug free for a week. They were induced to hyperventilate (30 breaths/min) for 3 minutes. Anxiety scales were taken before and after the test. RESULTS: 9 (69.2%) panic disorder patients and one (9.1%) of control subjects had a panic attack after hyperventilating (p < 0.05). CONCLUSION: The panic disorder group was more sensitive to hyperventilation than normal volunteers. The induction of panic attacks by voluntary hyperventilation may be a useful and simple test for validating the diagnosis in some specific panic disorder patients.     

Panic disorder on a child psychiatric consultation service

In a review of all cases seen from 1984 to 1988 by the psychiatric consultation-liaison service of a tertiary referral pediatric hospital, four cases of definite panic disorder meeting DSM-III-R criteria were identified. Three of these children were referred to the consultation service after intensive investigation of physical complaints had failed to yield a diagnosis. These cases of panic disorder differed from those previously reported in child psychiatric populations by their relative absence of psychiatric comorbidity. This suggests that uncomplicated panic disorder may present with primarily somatic symptoms in pediatric subspecialty clinics, while panic disorder, complicated by behavioral or emotional disturbance, is more likely to present directly to child psychiatric services. Children presenting with somatic symptoms are at risk for receiving nonproductive investigations while having delayed diagnosis and treatment of the panic disorder.