Hemodynamic and pathologic evaluation of a unileaflet pericardial bioprosthetic valve

This study investigated the in vivo hemodynamics and pathologic changes of a unileaflet pericardial bioprosthetic valve 3 to 5 months after implantation in juvenile sheep. Group 1 had 10 sheep with tricuspid valve replacement. Group 2 had nine sheep with mitral valve replacement. Group 3 served as a control with 10 sheep that had tricuspid valve replacement with a trileaflet porcine bioprosthesis. Hemodynamic performance was satisfactory in all three groups despite prominent pathologic changes, particularly in unileaflet valves. Intrinsic cuspal calcification was present in 66% of the unileaflet tricuspid, 88% unileaflet mitral, and 25% porcine tricuspid valves. Neither cuspal tearing nor perforations were found. However, cuspal stretching and redundancy of the mobile cusp was present in six tricuspid, seven mitral unileaflet valves, and no porcine valves. Gross pericardial redundancy correlated with the microscopic appearance of distorted and separated collagen bundles. These findings suggest that multiple modes of primary tissue failure may limit the durability of this unileaflet pericardial valve.     

Failure of Hancock xenograft valve: importance of valve position (4- to 9-year follow-up)

To evaluate long-term durability of Hancock valves, we reviewed our results in 107 hospital survivors (120 valves) who were operated on during 1974 through mid-1979. Mitral valve replacement was done in 63 patients, aortic valve replacement in 20, and mitral valve replacement combined with other procedures in 24. The 7-year survival was 84 +/- 4% (standard error of the mean) for 91 patients and 97 valves. During a follow-up of 590 patient-years, 15 (12 mitral and 3 aortic) of 120 valves at risk (87 mitral, 32 aortic, 1 tricuspid) were removed from 14 patients. Six valves (3 mitral and 3 aortic) were removed because of bacterial endocarditis. One mitral valve was removed because of thromboembolism. Eight mitral valves were removed because of valve structural failure, which occurred at a mean follow-up of 42 months. These valves showed extensive calcification, leaflet perforation, or cusp tear. Structural failure was unrelated to valve size, year of implantation, or valve shelf-life. Structural failure was not seen after aortic valve replacement. Results show that structural failure of the Hancock xenograft valve in the mitral position is related primarily to valve position. After aortic valve replacement, valve failure is predominantly due to endocarditis. Although medium-term (mean, 6-year) durability of this xenograft valve compares satisfactorily with prosthetic valves, its high failure rate in the mitral position indicates the necessity for improvement in valve mounting, design, and preservation.     

Fate of left-sided cardiac bioprosthesis valves in children

To avoid anticoagulation and minimize thromboembolic phenomena, between 1975 and 1980 we used 18 porcine bioprosthetic valves (BPVs) to replace 11 aortic and seven mitral valves in 17 children ranging from 7 to 18 years of age (mean, 8.2 years). Ten BPVs (91%) in the aortic position had to be replaced one to six years (mean, 4.2 years) after insertion. Nine of these valves developed severe calcification with leaflet immobility and severe stenosis. The tenth valve became insufficient with a disrupted cusp. Six (86%) of seven BPVs inserted in the mitral position required replacement two to four years (mean, 3.1 years) after insertion. Massive mitral regurgitation developed in three, while in the other three mitral stenosis was prominent. All explanted BPVs exhibited calcification with disruption and loss of mobility of the leaflets. Hemodynamic deterioration often occurred catastrophically, with nine patients requiring emergency valve replacement. Elective valve replacement carried no hospital mortality, whereas emergency valve replacement carried a 33% mortality. The BPV failure rate of 94% within six years leads us to recommend against the use of biologic valves in the pediatric age group in the aortic or mitral position. Bioprosthetic valve failure may occur catastrophically and replacement should be carried out early to avoid the higher operative mortality associated with emergency surgery.     

Calcific stenosis of the porcine heterograft.

We have encountered two cases of late calcification of the porcine heterograft. A patient in chronic renal failure died of sepsis and endocarditis fifteen months after replacement of the mitral and tricuspid valves. At postmortem examination, both heterograft valves exhibited severe calcification and thrombosis. A second patient with rheumatic heart disease and sickle cell disease underwent mitral valve replacement for severe regurgitation. Thirty months later, cardiac catheterization revealed prosthetic valve stenosis. The valve was replaced successfully, and the excised heterograft exhibited severe calcification with restriction of leaflet motion. Although calcification of the porcine heterograft is known to occur in patients with infection or disorders of calcium metabolism, dysfunction of the heterograft is rare in our experience.     

An eight-year experience with porcine bioprosthetic cardiac valves

A total of 589 porcine bioprostheses were implanted in 509 patients from January, 1976, through December, 1983. Of the valves implanted, 390 were Hancock and 199 were Carpentier-Edwards. A total of 1,633 patient-years was accrued, with a mean follow-up of 38 months per patient. Two hundred eight patients had aortic valve replacement, 209 had mitral valve replacement, and 79 had multiple valve replacements, of which 46 were aortic and mitral replacements. The mortality for isolated aortic valve replacement was 5.8%; for isolated mitral replacement, 8.6%, and for all patients, 10.9%. Late mortality was 3.9% per patient-year. The actuarial survival rate at 5 years was 79% for aortic, 68% for mitral, and 76% for aortic-mitral valve replacement. There were 12 thromboembolic events (0.73% per patient-year). Two episodes occurred in patients with an aortic bioprosthesis, nine in patients with a porcine mitral valve, and one in a patient with mitral and tricuspid bioprosthetic valves. The probability of remaining free of thromboembolism at 5 years was 99% for the group having aortic valve replacement, 93% for those having mitral replacement, and 100% for the group having aortic-mitral valve replacements. Thirteen episodes of endocarditis occurred (0.8% per patient-year). Seven of the 13 patients died as a direct result of endocarditis. The probability of remaining free of prosthetic endocarditis at 5 years was 97% for the aortic valve replacement group, 95% for the mitral group, and 97% for the aortic-mitral group. There were 20 instances of xenograft failure (1.2% per patient-year). The probability of remaining free of valve failure at 5 years was 96% for the aortic valve replacement group, 93% for the mitral group, and 93% for the aortic-mitral replacement group. Primary tissue failure of a prosthesis occurred in seven patients, all with Hancock valves (0.43% per patient-year). As yet there has been no primary tissue failure of the Carpentier-Edwards prosthesis. There also appears to be a lower incidence of thromboembolism (Edwards, 0.3% per patient-year; Hancock, 0.8% per patient-year) and endocarditis (Edwards, 0.6% per patient-year; Hancock, 1.0% per patient-year). The low incidence of complications with the porcine bioprosthetic valve, especially the Carpentier-Edwards, encourages us to recommend its continued use, especially in situations in which anticoagulation is contraindicated.     

Clinical experience with a porcine aortic valve xenograft for mitral valve replacement

Between March, 1971, and July, 1973, 103 patients underwent mitral valve replacement with a glutaraldehyde-preserved porcine aortic valve mounted on a flexible polypropylene, Dacron-covered stent. Overall operative survival was 95.1%. Actuarial analysis of late postoperative results indicates 92% survival through 2 years, with functional improvement in nearly all patients. The rate of systemic thromboembolism has been approximately 1.7% per patient-year without anticoagulants. No valve failure has occurred. We conclude that this xenograft prosthesis provides a technically and functionally satisfactory valve substitute, the durability of which appears to significantly exceed that of previously available tissue valves for mitral replacement.     

Results of reoperation for primary tissue failure of porcine bioprostheses

Results of reoperation for primary tissue failure of porcine bioprostheses were evaluated in 574 patients discharged from the hospital from 1970 to 1981. A total of 413 had undergone isolated mitral valve replacement and 161 isolated aortic valve replacement. Through March, 1984, 88 patients (15%) had required reoperation: 59 had undergone mitral and 29, aortic valve replacement. Primary tissue failure was the main cause of bioprosthetic dysfunction; it occurred in 64 patients (46 mitral and 18 aortic) at a mean postoperative interval of 93 +/- 4 months (range 34 to 158). During the same period, 11 patients required reoperation for bioprosthetic endocarditis, 11 for paravalvular leak, and two for thrombosis. These patients are not included in this review. Reoperation for primary tissue failure was performed after a mean interval of 72 +/- 6 months (range 38 to 158) for patients with aortic bioprostheses and after 101 +/- 5 months (range 34 to 153) for those with mitral bioprostheses (p less than 0.05). Overall mortality at reoperation was 12.5%: 11% for the mitral group and 16% for the aortic group. In 62 patients (45 mitral and 17 aortic) primary tissue failure was caused by calcification of the cusps, associated with severe fibrous tissue overgrowth in seven. Bioprosthetic failure was caused by an intracuspal hematoma in one patient with mitral valve replacement and by lipid infiltration of the cusps in one patient with aortic valve replacement. Actuarial freedom from bioprosthetic primary tissue failure at 12 years is 61% +/- 5% for the mitral group and 69% +/- 7% for the aortic group. On the basis of our long-term follow-up of patients after mitral or aortic replacement with a porcine bioprosthesis, we conclude: primary tissue failure is the most frequent indication for reoperation in patients with a porcine bioprosthesis; calcification of the cusp tissue is the leading cause of primary tissue failure; reoperation for primary tissue failure may be a major concern, although mortality for elective cases is low; and the limited durability of porcine bioprostheses suggests their use be restricted to selected patients.     

Long-term results of bioprosthetic mitral valve replacement: the pericardial perspective

Pericardial valve bioprostheses were introduced in early 1970s and were widely used in the 1980s. The longterm results with the Ionescu-Shiley valve, the first commercially available pericardial valve, were disappointing because of high rate cusp tears during the first decade after implantation. The enthusiasm for this type of bioprosthetic valve was further hampered by the premature failure of the Hancock pericardial valve. The long-term results of aortic valve replacement with the Carpentier-Edwards pericardial valve, which was introduced in 1981, indicated that that valve was durable and the issue of cusp tears had been resolved by an appropriate design. This knowledge prompted surgeons to revisit the merits of pericardial valves for mitral valve replacement and several other pericardial valves are now commercially available. The largest data on long-term results are with the Carpentier-Edwards pericardial mitral valve. The reported freedom from structure valve failure ranged from 69% to 85% at 10 years in patient population with mean age of 60 to 70 years. Young age is a major determinant of valve failure, which is largely due to calcification. There are also long-term data, albeit more limited on the Sorin Pericarbon and Mitroflow valves used for mitral valve replacement. This paper review the published experience with various pericardial bioprosthetic valves used for mitral valve replacement during the past 3 decades.     

Severe aortic insufficiency after transapical aortic valve implantation

We report the dislocation of a stented aortic valve prosthesis two weeks after the uneventful transapical implantation in a female who had underwent mitral valve replacement and CABG six years before. The initial implantation of the Edwards Sapien aortic valve prosthesis (Edwards Lifesciences, Irvine, CA), as well as the postoperative recovery, was uneventfully. At the sixth postoperative day, the patient developed a progressive heart failure due to a severe aortic insufficiency. During conventional aortic valve replacement, the dislocated prosthesis was found in the left ventricle. After uncomplicated postoperative recovery, the patient could be discharged in a good physical condition. Preexisting mitral valve prosthesis seems to be an important, complicating goal for transcatheter aortic valve implantation.     

Late results after Starr-Edwards valve replacement in children

Selection of types of prosthetic heart valves for children remains controversial. The case histories of 50 children surviving valve replacement with Starr-Edwards prostheses between 1963 and 1978 were reviewed to evaluate the long-term performance of mechanical valves. The 31 boys and 19 girls ranged from 6 months to 18 years in age (mean 10.4 years); 19 patients had had aortic valve replacement, 24 patients had had mitral valve replacement, and one patient had had both. Among the six patients who had had tricuspid valve replacement, four had corrected transposition, so that the tricuspid valve was the systemic atrioventricular valve. Mean (+/- standard deviation) follow-up interval was 7.9 +/- 4.9 years (maximum 17 years). For all patients, the 5 year survival rate was 86% +/- 6%. At 10 years postoperatively, the survival rate (+/- standard error) was 90% +/- 7% after aortic valve replacement and 76% +/- 8% after systemic atrioventricular valve replacement. At follow-up, 39 patients were alive, and 38 were in New York Heart Association Class I or II. Of the 11 deaths, four were valve-related. Seven patients had major (requiring hospitalization) thromboembolic events, and five patients had minor transient neurological symptoms suggesting thromboembolism; 50% of these patients were not taking warfarin (Coumadin) at the time of the thromboembolic event. The incidence of late (greater than 30 days) thromboembolism was 5.3 per 100 patient-years after aortic and 2.0 per 100 patient-years after systemic atrioventricular valve replacement. At 10 years postoperatively, 66% +/- 15% of patients who had had aortic valve replacement and 91% +/- 6% of those who had had systemic atrioventricular valve replacement were free of thromboembolism. The excellent long-term survival, absence of mechanical failure, and relatively low rate of thromboembolism with this prosthesis contrast with our experience with biological valves, in which 41% of children required reoperation in 5 years. Currently, mechanical valves, such as the Starr-Edwards prostheses, are our preferred valves for pediatric patients.     

Calcification characteristics of porcine stentless valves in juvenile sheep.

OBJECTIVE: To compare calcification characteristics of two porcine stentless valves (Toronto SPV and Freestyle) with different designs, fixation and antimineralization techniques using a juvenile sheep model of valve implantation inside the circulation. METHODS: The stentless valves (n = 2 x 6) were implanted in juvenile sheep in the pulmonary artery as an interposition, while the circulation was maintained with a right ventricular assist device. The model was validated by the implantation of, clinically well-known, porcine (Hancock II) and pericardial (Pericarbon) valves. Half of the valves were explanted after 3 months, the rest after 6 months. Valves were examined macroscopically, by X-ray, light microscopy (HE, Masson, Von Giesson, Von Kossa, PTAH stains), and transmission electron microscopy. Quantitative determination of the calcium content of the cusps was performed with atomic absorption spectrometry. RESULTS: After 3 months, the Freestyle had an extensively calcified aortic wall, most prominent at the outflow side of the porcine valve. After 6 months, calcification increased transmurally, but the valve cusps were free of calcification, and the inflow side was only slightly calcified. The Toronto SPV valve also started to calcify at the inflow side of the valve after 3 months with increased calcification after 6 months. The base of the Toronto SPV valve cusps showed slight calcification after 6 months of implantation. CONCLUSIONS: The pattern of calcification of the porcine aortic wall differs between the two studied stentless valves, with calcification located predominantly at the outflow side in the Freestyle valve, but also at the inflow side in the Toronto SPV valve. The cusps of the Freestyle valve were less prone to calcification than those from the Toronto SPV valve.     

Carbomedics® Valve in Congenital Heart Disease: Midterm follow-up study of 14 patients

In 14 patients aged 5–329 (mean 131) months a CarboMedics® valve was implanted because of congenital heart disease. The preoperative NYHA function class was III-IV in ten cases. Seven aortic and seven atrioventricular valves were replaced without early mortality. All patients were followed up, with mean observation time 27 months (total 384 months). One of the 14 patients died of heart failure 10 months postoperatively. Thrombosis occurred in four valves, three in tricuspid and one in mitral position. In all patients who received only warfarin, anticoagulation was demonstrably inadequate. Consequently we now recommend antiplatelet medication in addition to warfarin for children with atrioventricular mechanical valve replacement. In our experience the complication rate with CarboMedics prosthesis is acceptable, provided that anticoagulant therapy is adequate.     

Comparative analysis of long-term results with porcine-aortic, bovine pericardial and tilting disc valves

The three series with the first-generation valve prostheses were reviewed for long-term clinical evaluation in isolated aortic and mitral valve replacement. Hancock porcine xenograft was implanted in 71 patients from 1977 to 1979, ionescu-Shiley pericardial xenograft (standard model) in 271 patients from 1979 to 1983, and Bjork-Shiley tilting disc valve in 194 from 1978 to 1986. In aortic position, no any significant difference among three valve types could be demonstrated in the actuarial survival and freedom from thromboembolism and valve infection, while the actuarial freedom from valve dysfunction in lonescu-Shiley valve was significantly lower than that in other two valves. Bj?rk-Shiley valve in mitral position showed satisfactory clinical performance in terms of valve-related complications and survival in comparison with two types of bioprosthetic valves. In our conclusion at present time, Bj?rk-Shiley valve is suitable for the first choice of both aortic and mitral valve prostheses. In case of valve replacement with a bioprosthesis, however, porcine aortic valve is a better choice for aortic, and bovine pericardial valve likely for mitral replacement.     

Seven year experience with mounted porcine valves.

From March, 1969, through June 1976, 108 porcine aortic xenograft valves were used for mitral or aortic valve replacement in 95 patients. This experience provides one of the longest follow-ups available for evaluation of the porcine bioprosthesis. The first fifteen valves were locally mounted on Cutter stents and preserved in buffered formalin. Subsequent valves were prepared by the Edwards and Hancock Companies with glutaraldehyde preservation. Oral anticoagulation was routinely used for the first 6 weeks following surgery. Hospital mortality was unrelated to the valve type. All but four of the surviving patients with formalin preserved valves have required reoperation because of valve failure. There have been two valve failures in the patients who received gluteraldehyde valves, but there have been no embolic or thrombotic complications. Late cardiac catheterization has shown hemodynamic results equal to or better than prosthetic valves. The continuing long-term results indicate that the porcine xenograft is the valve of choice for cardiac valve replacement.     

Early structural deterioration with the mitroflow pericardial xenograft in the mitral position.

Early structural deterioration with the mitral Mitroflow pericardial valve requiring reoperation occurred in 6 patients. Clinical diagnosis of prosthetic failure was made 5 to 58 months after valve implantation (mean, 38 months). Re-replacement was carried out 22 to 80 months (mean, 55 months) after the initial operation. Mode of failures were cuspal tear without calcification in three valves and massive calcifications in the remaining bioprostheses. High incidence of early structural deterioration of the Mitroflow pericardial valve makes this new prosthesis an unsatisfactory alternative as a substitute in the mitral position.     

Preexisting mitral valve prosthesis in patients undergoing left ventricular assist device implantation

Experience with patients undergoing left ventricular assist device (LVAD) implantation with preexisting mitral valve prostheses is limited. Patients with mechanical heart valves might have an increased risk of thromboembolism; in patients with biologic valves, there might be a risk of structural deterioration of the leaflets. Out of 597 patients supported with a LVAD system between 2000 and 2009, 18 patients had mitral valve surgery prior to implantation. We excluded all patients below 18 years of age, those with postcardiotomy failure, and patients who had had mitral valve reconstruction. Only 1% of the studied patient population (n= 6) had mitral valve replacement. The mitral valve implantation has been performed 7.4 ± 9.4 years prior to LVAD insertion. None of the valves (one biologic, five mechanical) were exchanged or explanted. LVAD implantation was done either with left lateral thoracotomy (n= 5) or with midline resternotomy (n= 1). Temporary right ventricular assist device support was necessary in one case (16.6%); 30-day mortality was 16.6% (n= 1). Median support time was 14 ± 15 months. Two patients received heart transplantation after 6 and 26 months on the device; four patients died on mechanical circulatory support after 1, 2, 5, and 40 months. No valve or pump thrombosis or other clinically relevant thromboembolic events were observed. Only a small number of patients (1%) had a preexisting mitral valve prosthesis prior to LVAD implantation. No severe adverse events were observed when the prosthesis was left in place. Attention should be paid to the anticoagulation regime.     

Considerations in Selection and Management of Patients Undergoing Valve Replacement with Glutaraldehyde-Fixed Porcine Bioprostheses

From November, 1973, through June, 1978, 428 operations in 425 patients were performed for replacement of aortic, mitral, or aortic plus mitral valves, utilizing 277 Hancock and 180 Carpentier-Edwards bioprostheses. Actuarially determined survival at 36 months was similar for all three groups and compared favorably with our experience with the Björk-Shiley prosthesis. Certain patient-related variables influencing late survival were identified by multivariate analysis and included previous operation for congenital heart disease, coronary artery bypass grafting in nonaortic valve replacement, race (black), age at operation, and New York Heart Association Functional Class. A small but definite incidence of thromboembolism occurred in all three groups, again similar to our experience with the Björk-Shiley prosthesis. Multivariate analysis identified four factors influencing risk of thromboembolism: previous cardiac operation, age, double-valve replacement, and rhythm at discharge. Valve degeneration occurred, primarily in children and young adults. Over the medium term, the porcine bioprosthesis compared favorably with mechanical prostheses in terms of survival, function, and thromboembolism. Certain patient-related variables affecting survival may be modified by earlier surgical intervention.     

Aortic Valve Replacement with Stentless Porcine Bioprostheses

The implantation of stentless porcine valves (SPVs) is technically more demanding than implantation of stented bioprosthetic valves. Implantation of the Toronto SPV bioprosthesis requires an,understanding of the relationships between the leaflets and the aortic annulus and sinotubular junction. In addition to proper alignment of the three commissures within the aortic root, the diameter of sinotubular junction should not exceed the external diameter of the porcine aortic valve after completion of the operation. The Medtronic Freestyle porcine aortic root bioprosthesis can be used for subcoronary implantation as well as for aortic root replacement. Degenerative calcification of a tricuspid aortic valve is the most common cause of aortic valve disease in older patients. Implantation of stentless valves in the subcoronary position is usually feasible because the geometry of the aortic root is well maintained in these patients. The bicuspid aortic valve is the second most common cause of aortic valve disease in older patients and the most common in younger patients. These patients frequently have dilated aortic root, and the Medtronic Freestyle bioprosthesis is ideal for implantation using the root inclusion technique. Stentless porcine bioprostheses are minimally obstructive and associated with low mean systolic gradients. In addition, they have better hemodynamic performance during exercise than stented bioprostheses. For these reasons, patient-prosthesis mismatch has not been described with stentless valves. Left ventricular function after aortic valve replacement appears to be better with stentless than with stented bioprostheses. Comparative, nonrandomized studies of aortic valve replacement with stented and stentless valves suggest that the risk of cardiac death is reduced with stentless valves and the rates of valve-related complications also appear to be lower. What remains unknown is whether stentless valves are more durable than stented ones.     

Unexpected durability of Smeloff-Cutter aortic ball valve prosthesis

We report a case in which replacement of a Smeloff-Cutter aortic ball prosthesis was required 28 years after initial implantation. A 57-year-old woman underwent aortic valve replacement with a 21-mm Smeloff-Cutter ball prosthesis and open mitral commissurotomy for aortic stenosis, aortic regurgitation, and mitral stenosis in 1973. Severe aortic regurgitation occurred in April 2001, and aortic valve reoperation combined with mitral valve replacement was successfully performed. The patient's aortic ball valve was nearly intact with perivalvular leakage probably causing the aortic regurgitation. Our experience documents longer durability for the Smeloff-Cutter prosthesis than has been reported to date.     

Emergency pulmonary autograft mitral valve replacement in a child

Mitral valve replacement in small children imposes significant clinical difficulties because of the relatively small mechanical prosthetic valves required and the need for lifelong anticoagulation therapy. A child weighing 10.4 kg presented with thrombosis of her 19-mm mechanical mitral prosthesis 4 weeks after implantation despite appropriate oral anticoagulation therapy. An emergency mitral valve replacement with a pulmonary autograft was successfully performed with encouraging short-term results.