Accuracy of automated software-guided detection of significant coronary artery stenosis by CT angiography: comparison with invasive catheterisation

Purpose

True automated detection of coronary artery stenoses might be useful whenever expert evaluation is not available, or as a “second reader” to enhance diagnostic confidence. We evaluated the accuracy of a PC-based stenosis detection tool alone and combined with expert interpretation.

Methods

One hundred coronary CT angiography datasets were evaluated with the automated software alone, by manual interpretation (axial images, multiplanar reformations and maximum intensity projections in free double-oblique planes), and by expert interpretation aware of the automated findings. Stenoses ≥?50 % were noted per-vessel and per-patient, and compared with invasive angiography.

Results

Automated post-processing was successful in 90 % of patients (88 % of vessels). When excluding uninterpretable datasets, per-patient sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) were 89 %, 79 %, 74 % and 92 % (per-vessel: 82 %, 85 %, 48 % and 96 %). All 100 datasets were evaluable by expert interpretation. Per-patient sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV were 95 %, 95 %, 93 % and 97 % (per-vessel: 89 %,98 %, 88 % and 98 %). Knowing the results of automated interpretation did not improve the performance of expert readers.

Conclusion

Automated off-line post-processing of coronary CT angiography shows adequate sensitivity, but relatively low specificity in coronary stenosis detection. It does not increase accuracy of expert interpretation. Failure of post-processing in 10 % of all patients necessitates additional manual image work-up.

Key Points

? Coronary CT angiography is increasingly used for detection of coronary artery stenosis ? Computer assisted diagnosis might facilitate and speed up interpretation ? Performance in properly segmented cases compared favourably with manual image interpretation ? However, automated segmentation failed in about 10 % of cases ? Manual reading is still mandatory; computer assisted diagnosis can provide a useful second read     

Facilitating coronary artery evaluation in MDCT using a 3D automatic vessel segmentation tool

The purpose of this study was to investigate a 3D coronary artery segmentation algorithm using 16-row MDCT data sets. Fifty patients underwent cardiac CT (Sensation 16, Siemens) and coronary angiography. Automatic and manual detection of coronary artery stenosis was performed. A 3D coronary artery segmentation algorithm (Fraunhofer Institute for Computer Graphics, Darmstadt) was used for automatic evaluation. All significant stenoses (>50%) in vessels >1.5 mm in diameter were protocoled. Each detection tool was used by one reader who was blinded to the results of the other detection method and the results of coronary angiography. Sensitivity and specificity were determined for automatic and manual detection as well as was the time for both CT-based evaluation methods. The overall sensitivity and specificity of the automatic and manual approach were 93.1 vs. 95.83% and 86.1 vs. 81.9%. The time required for automatic evaluation was significantly shorter than with the manual approach, i.e., 246.04±43.17 s for the automatic approach and 526.88±45.71 s for the manual approach (P<0.0001). In 94% of the coronary artery branches, automatic detection required less time than the manual approach. Automatic coronary vessel evaluation is feasible. It reduces the time required for cardiac CT evaluation with similar sensitivity and specificity as well as facilitates the evaluation of MDCT coronary angiography in a standardized fashion.     

Multislice computed tomography: angiographic emulation versus standard assessment for detection of coronary stenoses

The present study investigated angiographic emulation of multislice computed tomography (MSCT) (catheter-like visualization) as an alternative approach of analyzing and visualizing findings in comparison with standard assessment. Thirty patients (120 coronary arteries) were randomly selected from 90 prospectively investigated patients with suspected coronary artery disease who underwent MSCT (16-slice scanner, 0.5 mm collimation, 400 ms rotation time) prior to conventional coronary angiography for comparison of both approaches. Sensitivity and specificity of angiographic emulation [81% (26/32) and 93% (82/88)] were not significantly different from those of standard assessment [88% (28/32) and 99% (87/88)], while the per-case analysis time was significantly shorter for angiographic emulation than for standard assessment (3.4 ± 1.5 vs 7.0 ± 2.5 min, P < 0.001). Both interventional and referring cardiologists preferred angiographic emulation over standard curved multiplanar reformations of MSCT coronary angiography for illustration, mainly because of improved overall lucidity and depiction of sidebranches (P < 0.001). In conclusion, angiographic emulation of MSCT reduces analysis time, yields a diagnostic accuracy comparable to that of standard assessment, and is preferred by cardiologists for visualization of results.     

16层螺旋CT冠状动脉成像的伪影缺陷及处理对策

目的：探讨16层螺旋CT冠状动脉成像伪影和技术缺陷产生的原因与解决对策。方法：122例临床疑似或已确诊为冠心病的患者,以回顾性心电门控技术行16层螺旋CT冠状动脉成像检查,后处理行MIP、CPR、MPR及VR重建,由两名以上有经验的CT医师对冠状动脉成像的缺陷或伪影进行评估。结果：122例患者共显示冠状动脉节段1496段,存在伪影326段,占21．79％,大部分为轻度伪影275段（18．38％）,中重度伪影51段（3．41％）。结论：冠状动脉CTA的伪影和缺陷原因如下：心脏运动、呼吸运动、射线硬化、对比剂、重建时相、扫描和后处理技术等。认识并尽力排除这些伪影和技术缺陷,才能做出正确诊断。     

Comparison of quantitative atherosclerotic plaque burden from coronary CT angiography in patients with first acute coronary syndrome and stable coronary artery disease

BackgroundCoronary CTA allows characterization of non-calcified and calcified plaque and identification of high-risk plaque features.ObjectiveWe aimed to quantitatively characterize and compare coronary plaque burden from CTA in patients with a first acute coronary syndrome (ACS) and controls with stable coronary artery disease.Materials and methodsWe retrospectively analyzed consecutive patients with non-ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction (NSTEMI) or unstable angina with a first ACS, who underwent CTA as part of their initial workup before invasive coronary angiography and age- and gender-matched controls with stable chest pain; controls also underwent CTA with subsequent invasive angiography (total n = 28). Culprit arteries were identified in ACS patients. Coronary arteries were analyzed by automated software to quantify calcified plaque (CP), noncalcified plaque (NCP), and low-density NCP (LD-NCP, attenuation <30 Hounsfield units) volumes, and corresponding burden (plaque volume × 100%/vessel volume), stenosis, remodeling index, contrast density difference (maximum percent difference in attenuation/cross-sectional area from proximal cross-section), and plaque length.ResultsACS patients had fewer lesions (median, 1), with higher total NCP and LD-NCP burdens (NCP: 57.4% vs 41.5%; LD-NCP: 12.5% vs 8%; P ≤ .04), higher maximal stenoses (85.6% vs 53.0%; P = .003) and contrast density differences (46.1 vs 16.3%; P < .006). Per-patient CP burden was not different between ACS and controls. NCP and LD-NCP plaque burden was higher in culprit vs nonculprit arteries (NCP: 57.8% vs 9.5%; LD-NCP: 8.4% vs 0.6%; P ≤ .0003); CP was not significantly different. Culprit arteries had increased plaque lengths, remodeling indices, stenoses, and contrast density differences (46.1% vs 10.9%; P ≤ .001).ConclusionNoninvasive quantitative coronary artery analysis identified several differences for ACS, both on per-patient and per-vessel basis, including increased NCP, LD-NCP burden, and contrast density difference.     

Local staging of pancreatic carcinoma with multi-detector row CT: use of curved planar reformations initial experience

PURPOSE: To evaluate the utility of curved planar reformations compared with standard transverse images in the assessment of pancreatic tumors. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Forty-three patients suspected of having pancreatic tumors underwent contrast material-enhanced biphasic multi-detector row computed tomography (CT). Curved planar reformations were generated along the pancreatic duct, common bile duct, and major mesenteric vessels. Three blinded independent readers assessed the curved planar reformations and transverse images separately for the presence of tumor, resectability, and vascular involvement. The results were compared with those of a consensus panel who evaluated the curved planar reformations and transverse images together along with clinical data and surgical findings. RESULTS: Of 43 patients, 20 had pancreatic malignancies as judged by the consensus panel and proven at biopsy and/or clinical follow-up. For tumor detection, transverse images and curved planar reformations had an average sensitivity of 95.0% and 98.4% (P >.05), respectively, and an average specificity of 90.9% and 91.3% (P >.05), respectively. For tumor resectability, transverse images and curved planar reformations had an average sensitivity of 85.7% and 71.4% (P >.05), respectively, and an average specificity of 85.2% and 84.3% (P >.05), respectively. Average interpretation time was 6.4 minutes with transverse images and 4.1 minutes with curved planar reformations. CONCLUSION: Curved planar reformations are equivalent to transverse images in the detection of pancreatic tumors and determination of surgical resectability.     

Influence of observer experience and training on proficiency in coronary CT angiography interpretation

Purpose

To assess the influence of experience and training on the proficiency in coronary CT angiography (CCTA) interpretation of practitioners with different levels of experience.

Methods and materials

Nine radiologist and cardiologist observers with varying prior CCTA experience ranging from novice to expert independently analyzed two case series of 50 catheter-correlated CCTA studies for coronary artery stenosis (0%, ≤49%, 50–74%, 75–99%, or 100%). Results of the first case series were unblinded and presented along with catheter angiography results to each reader before proceeding to the second series. Diagnostic accuracy on a per-segment basis was compared for all readers and both case series, respectively.

Results

Correlation coefficients between CCTA and catheter angiography initially ranged between good (r = 0.87) and poor (r = 0.26), depending on reader experience, and significantly (p < 0.05) improved in the second case series (range: r = 0.42 to r = 0.91). Diagnostic accuracy was significantly (p < 0.05) higher for more experienced readers (range: 96.5–97.8%) as compared to less experienced observers (range: 90.7–93.6%). After completion of the second case series for less experienced readers sensitivity and PPV significantly (p < 0.05) improved (range: 62.7–67.8%/51.4–84.1%), but still remained significantly (p < 0.05) lower as compared to more experienced observers (range: 89.8–93.3%/80.6–93.3%).

Conclusion

The level of experience appears to be a strong determinant of proficiency in CCTA interpretation. Limited one-time training improves proficiency in novice readers, but not to clinically satisfactory levels.     

Automatic bone and plaque removal using dual energy CT for head and neck angiography: Feasibility and initial performance evaluation

Purpose

We sought to evaluate the feasibility and efficiency of dual energy (DE) bone and plaque removal in head and neck CT angiography.

Materials and methods

20 patients with suspected carotid stenoses received head and neck DE-CTA as part of their pre-interventional workup. Visual grading using multiplanar reformations (MPR), thick slab maximum intensity projections (MIP) and quantitative vessel analysis (QVA) of stenoses was performed prior and after DE bone removal. Results were evaluated for the detection of relevant stenoses (vessel area reduction >70%). Vessel segmentation errors were analyzed.

Results

Segmentation errors occurred in 19% of all vessel segments. Nevertheless, most post-bone removal artifacts could be recognized using the MPR technique for reading. Compared to MPR reading prior to bone removal, sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values after bone removal were 100%, 98%, 88% and 100% for MPR reading and 100%, 91%, 63% and 100% for exclusive MIP reading, respectively. There was a good agreement between the QVA results prior and post-DE plaque removal (r² = 0.8858).

Conclusion

DE bone and plaque removal for head and neck angiography is feasible and offers a rapid and highly sensitive overview over vascular head and neck studies. Due to a slightly limited specificity of the MIP technique due to segmentation errors, possible stenoses should be verified and graded using MPR techniques.     

Obstructive lesions of the central airways: evaluation by using spiral CT with multiplanar and three-dimensional reformations

The purpose of this study was to assess the accuracy of transverse CT scans as well as multiplanar (MPR) and three-dimensional (3D) reconstructions in the evaluation of obstructive lesions of the central airways. A total of 64 patients were evaluated for the presence of obstructive lesions of the central tracheobronchial tree with transverse spiral CT scans, multiplanar reformations (MPRs), 3D shaded surface displays (3D SSDs) and minimum intensity projections (MIPs). The findings of these modalities were then compared with those obtained at bronchoscopy. The severity, length, and shape of airway narrowing were analyzed comparatively on the four sets of images. Transverse CT scans and MPRs had a similar accuracy (99%) in detecting obstructive airway lesions. The accuracy of both was significantly higher than that of 3DSSDs (90%, p <0.05) and MIPs (81%; p < 0.01). There was no statistically significant difference between the four imaging modalities in the analysis of the morphology of airway stenoses. Symmetric stenoses were similarly analyzed on the four sets of images, whereas MPRs and MIPs failed to depict accurately simple and complex asymmetric stenoses. Transverse CT scans are accurate in the depiction of obstructive lesions of the central airways and may be complemented by MPRs and/or 3DSSDs in their morphologic evaluation.Correspondence to: M. Remy-Jardin     

CT coronary angiography: Coronary CT-flow quantification supplements morphological stenosis analysis

Background

Our rationale was to evaluate whether a 64-slice CT scanner allows accurate measurement of computed tomographic (CT) changes in coronary artery flow profiles and whether CT flow measurements are suitable for classifying the significance and hemodynamic relevance of a stenosis and thereby supplement as a functional parameter for morphological stenosis analysis.

Methods

A total of 50 patients prospectively underwent computed tomography coronary angiography (coronary CTA) in a multidetector CT scanner (Brilliance 64, Philips) ± 1 day before or after invasive coronary angiography (ICA). Immediately thereafter, 2 radiologists reviewed the imaging data to detect any vessel segments with morphology poorly evaluable by coronary CTA. A locally constant cyclical measurement was acquired in these coronary arteries in breath-hold technique during the passage of a 50 ml bolus of contrast media. For analysis, time–density curves of the bolus passage were registered in the coronary artery and the aorta (internal reference), the up-slopes were determined and correlated with each other. The results were compared with the ICA findings.

Results

47 of 50 CT flow measurements were evaluable. A good correlation was found between the degrees of stenosis and slope ratios in aorta and coronary artery (R² = 0.92). The threshold corridor was 0.55–0.77 for distinguishing hemodynamically (≥70%) from non-hemodynamically relevant stenoses.

Conclusions

CT-based coronary artery flow measurements (CTFM) correlate well with the angiographically determined degree of stenosis and can elevate by non-invasive means the diagnostic accuracy of coronary CTA. From both a clinically diagnostic and scientific standpoint, CTFM proves a suitable method for quantifying coronary blood flow.     

Improved coronary artery stent visualization and in-stent stenosis detection using 16-slice computed-tomography and dedicated image reconstruction technique

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to compare the visualization of different coronary artery stents and the detectability of in-stent stenoses during 4-slice and 16-slice computed tomography (CT) angiography in a vessel phantom. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Ten coronary stents were introduced in a coronary artery vessel phantom (plastic tubes with an inner diameter of 3 mm, filled with iodinated contrast material diluted to 220 Hounsfiled Units [HU], surrounded by oil [60 HU]). CT scans were obtained perpendicular to the stent axes on a 4-slice scanner (detector collimation 4x1 mm; table feed 1.5 mm/rotation, mAs 300, kV 120, medium-smooth kernel) and a 16-slice scanner (detector collimation 12x0.75 mm; table feed 2.8 mm/rotation, mAs 370, kV 120, reconstruction with a standard and an optimized sharp kernel). Longitudinal multiplanar reformations were evaluated regarding visible lumen diameters and intraluminal attenuation values. Additionally, the stents were scanned with the same parameters after implantation of 60% stenoses (HU 30). RESULTS: Using the same medium-smooth kernel reconstruction with 4-slice and 16-slice CT, there was a slight increase in the average visible lumen area (26% versus 31%) and less increase of average intraluminal attenuation values (380 HU versus 349 HU). Significant improvement of lumen visualization (54%, P<0.01) and attenuation values (250, P<0.01) was observed for the 16-slice scans using the sharp kernel reconstruction. In-stent stenoses could be more reliably identified (or ruled out) by 16-slice CT and sharp reconstruction kernel when compared with the other 2 methods. CONCLUSION: 16-slice CT using a dedicated sharp kernel for image reconstruction facilitates improved visualization of coronary artery stent lumen and detection of in-stent stenoses.     

Coronary computed tomography and triple rule out CT in patients with acute chest pain and an intermediate cardiac risk for acute coronary syndrome: Part 2: Economic aspects

Objective

To evaluate the economic impact of integrating coronary CT angiography (cCTA) or whole chest “triple-rule-out” CTA (TRO-CTA) in the work-up of patients with acute chest pain.

Materials and methods

100 consecutive emergency department patients with acute chest pain and an intermediate cardiac risk for ACS underwent cCTA or TRO-CTA (cCTA group). Diagnostic performance, rate and length of hospitalization, hospital costs, hospital reimbursement and hospital profit were analyzed. All findings were compared to those of 100 different patients with acute chest pain that were evaluated with a standard of care (SOC) diagnostic algorithm (SOC group) that did not include cCTA. Diagnostic performance (“safety”) of both algorithms was defined as the absence of major adverse cardiac events (MACE) over a 90-day follow-up period.

Results

In the cCTA group 60/100 patients were safely discharged at the same day. 19/100 patients were hospitalized due to significant coronary stenosis on cCTA, which was confirmed by invasive coronary catheterization (ICC) in 17/19 patients. Relevant non-coronary disease that led to hospitalization were found in 21 patients of the cCTA group. In the SOC group all patients were hospitalized. 87 of these hospitalized patients underwent ICC for exclusion of coronary artery stenosis. A significant coronary artery stenosis was found in only 25 of these patients. Within the cCTA group no patient suffered from MACE over the 90-day follow-up period. In the SOC group 2 patients were rehospitalized during the 90-day follow-up period due to recurrent chest pain and 1 patient because of a pseudoaneurym of the left femoral artery after ICC. The median hospital costs per patient were significantly lower in the cCTA group than in the SOC group (428.9€ vs. 1575.0€, p < 0.001). The median reimbursement of the cCTA group was less compared to the SOC group (589.8€ vs. 2412.1€, p < 0.001) and patients in the cCTA group gained less profit than patients in the SOC group (57.0€ vs. 448.4€, p < 0.001).

Conclusion

Integrating cCTA or TRO-CTA in a SOC algorithm can safely reduce the number of hospitalized patients and reduce total health care costs.     

Imaging of coronary artery stents using multislice computed tomography: in vitro evaluation

The aim of this study was to evaluate imaging features of different coronary artery stents during multislice CT Angiography (MSCTA). Nineteen stents made of varying material (steel, nitinol, tantalum) and of varying stent design were implanted in plastic tubes with an inner diameter of 3 mm to simulate a coronary artery. The tubes were filled with iodinated contrast material diluted to 200 Hounsfield units (HU), closed at both ends and positioned in a plastic container filled with oil (–70 HU). The MSCT scans were obtained perpendicular to the stent axes (detector collimation 4×1 mm, table feed 2 mm/rotation, 300 mAs, 120 kV). Axial images and multiplanar reformations were evaluated regarding artifact size, lumen visibility, and intraluminal attenuation values. Artifacts characterized by artifactual thickening of the stent struts leading to apparent reduction in the lumen diameter and increased intraluminal attenuation values were observed in all cases. The stent lumen was totally obscured in the Wiktor stent, the Wallgraft stent, and the Nir Royal stent. Partial residual of the stent lumen could be visualized in all other utilized stent products (artificial lumen reductions ranged from 62% in the V-Flex stent to 94% in the Bx Velocity stent). Parts of the stent lumen can be visualized in most coronary artery stents; however, detectability of in-stent stenoses remains to be evaluated for each stent type. Electronic Publication     

The prevalence and characteristics of intra-atrial right coronary artery anomaly in 9,284 patients referred for coronary computed tomography angiography

Objective

To determine the prevalence, radiologic patterns and clinical characteristics of intra-atrial right coronary artery (IARCA) among adult coronary computed tomography angiography (CCTA) population.

Methods

We included 9,284 consecutive subjects who underwent CCTA at a single high-volume center. The presence of IARCA including the number, length and diameter of IARCA segments with accompanying atherosclerosis and coronary anomalies were evaluated. Additionally, clinical characteristics and midterm follow-up of IARCA patients were recorded.

Results

The IARCA prevalence was 0.15% (14/9,284) with 15 intra-atrial segments. The intra-atrial segment length ranged from 14 to 53 mm, and the mean diameter proximal to the entry site was 3.3 ± 0.7 mm. IARCA was more often associated with intramuscular course of the left anterior descending coronary artery (29% vs. 4%, p = 0.001) and anomalous origin of the left circumflex artery from the right aortic sinus (14% vs. 0.3%, p = 0.001) compared with non-IARCA cases. The majority of IARCA patients were women (86%) presenting with supraventricular arrhythmia (71%). Compared with computed tomographic population without IARCA, IARCA subjects were younger (60 ± 12 vs. 54 ± 14 years, p = 0.037) and more often women (51% vs. 86%, p = 0.013). At a mean of 20 months follow-up of IARCA patients there were no adverse cardiac events except for supraventricular tachycardia episodes occurring in 36% of subjects.

Conclusions

IARCA occurs rarely and is often associated with additional coronary anomalies. The clinical profile of IARCA patients is most often represented by middle-aged women with supraventricular arrhythmia showing favorable midterm prognosis.     

Analysis of 107 breast lesions with automated 3D ultrasound and comparison with mammography and manual ultrasound

Objectives

Our aim was to investigate the diagnostic potential of an automated ultrasound (US) breast scanner prototype and compare it with manual US and mammography.

Methods

Ninety-seven patients with a total of 107 breast lesions had mammograms, manual US and an automated breast US scan. Multiplanar reconstructions in coronal, axial and the sagittal view were reconstructed from the automated dataset and visualized. After biopsy, all lesions were confirmed histologically. The data were evaluated according to the BIRADS (Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System) classification. The sensitivity and specificity were analyzed.

Results

The BIRADS criterion “margin” was significantly related to the overall BIRADS classification, independently of the US method being used. The sensitivity of mammography was significantly lower than of each US method (Fisher's exact test with p < 0.05). There were no significant differences between the US methods.

Conclusions

The reconstructed third (axial) image plane of the whole breast, which corresponds to a craniocaudal mammogram, can give additional information about both, site and differential diagnosis of a lesion. Although image quality was sufficient, automated US is not good enough to replace manual US at this time.     

Incidence and classification of neointimal proliferation and in-stent restenosis in post-stenting patients at 1-year interval: Findings from non-invasive coronary computed tomography angiography

Objectives

To evaluate the incidence of coronary in-stent restenosis (ISR) and neointimal proliferation by coronary CT angiography (CCTA) at 1-year follow-up in asymptomatic patients.

Methods

234 patients (mean age: 67 ± 10.2 years, range 39–88 years, 180 males and 54 females) with 379 stents were prospectively enrolled in this study. Binary ISR was classified by CCTA into 4 types using Mehran classification. Neointimal proliferation was similarly classified into focal and diffuse types. All patients with CCTA-revealed ISR or neointimal proliferation underwent further invasive coronary angiography (ICA) for validation. Fisher's exact test was used for comparison.

Results

ICA revealed patent stents with neointimal proliferation in 39 patients (16.7%, 39/234) and binary ISR in 23 patients (9.8%, 23/234). Lesion-based analysis showed 12 type I ISR lesions, 4 type II ISR lesions, 1 type III ISR lesion and 7 type IV ISR lesions. Among cases with neointimal proliferation, 27 lesions were classified as focal type whereas 13 lesions were classified as diffuse type. Patients with diabetes mellitus were associated with higher incidence of CCTA-revealed neointimal proliferation (21/77 vs. 18/157, p = 0.002) as well as ISR (12/77 vs. 11/157, p = 0.038), compared to patients without diabetes. CCTA was found to have good diagnostic performance for neointimal proliferation and ISR detection as well as classification, with an overall accuracy of 84.4% (54/64).

Conclusions

Silent ISR as well as neointimal proliferation is not uncommon findings in asymptomatic post-stenting patients at 1-year interval, as revealed by CCTA. Patients with diabetes are prone to have higher incidence of neointimal proliferation.     

Diagnostic accuracy of image postprocessing methods for the detection of coronary artery stenoses by using multidetector CT

PURPOSE: To retrospectively evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of multidetector computed tomography (CT) coronary angiography for detection of hemodynamically significant (>or=50%) stenoses by using various image postprocessing methods, with conventional coronary angiography as the reference standard. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The analysis used data from previous studies, use of which had been approved by the Institutional Review Board. Sixteen-section multidetector CT data sets for 40 patients (30 men, 10 women; mean age 56 years +/- 8; mean heart rate, 61 beats per minute +/- 6) were evaluated. Six independent investigators evaluated the data sets for the presence of stenoses with diameter reduction of 50% or more, by using either exclusively transverse images, free oblique multiplanar reconstructions (MPRs), free oblique maximum intensity projections (MIPs, 5 mm thick), prerendered curved MPRs, prerendered curved MIPs, or prerendered three-dimensional volume rendered reconstructions (VRTs). Evaluation results were compared with conventional coronary angiography for each artery in a blinded fashion (chi(2) test). RESULTS: Overall, 35 coronary artery stenoses were present. Percentage of evaluable arteries and accuracy for detecting stenosis (percentages of accurately classified arteries were, respectively, 99% and 88% for transverse, 99% and 91% for oblique MPR, 94% and 86% for oblique MIP, 94% and 83% for curved MIP, 93% and 81% for curved MPR, and 91% and 73% for VRT). Accuracy was significantly higher for oblique MPR than for curved MPR (P=.01), curved MIP (P=.03), and VRT (P<.001). CONCLUSION: The evaluation of multidetector CT coronary angiography with interactive image display methods, especially interactive oblique MPRs, permits higher diagnostic accuracy than evaluation of prerendered images (curved MPR, curved MIP, or VRT images).     

Coronary artery disease: Which degree of coronary artery stenosis is indicative of ischemia?

Purpose

To prospectively determine the best cut-off value of stenosis degree for low-dose computed tomography coronary angiography (CTCA) to predict the hemodynamic significance of coronary artery stenoses compared to catheter angiography (CA) using a cardiac magnetic resonance based approach as standard of reference.

Materials and methods

Fifty-two patients (mean age, 64 ± 10 years) scheduled for CA underwent cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) at 1.5-T and dual-source CTCA using prospective ECG-triggering the same day. Diagnostic performance of CTCA and CA to detect myocardial ischemia was evaluated with CMR as the standard of reference. The diagnostic performance and best cut-off values to predict the hemodynamic significance of coronary were determined from receiver operating characteristics analysis (ROC).

Results

CA revealed >50% stenoses in 131/832 segments (15.7%) in 78/156 (50.0%) coronary arteries in 32/52 (62%) patients. CTCA revealed >50% stenoses in 148/807 (18.3%) segments, corresponding to 83/156 (53.2%) coronary arteries in 34/52 (65.4%) patients. CMR revealed ischemia in 118/832 (14.2%) myocardial segments corresponding to the territories of 60/156 (38.5%) coronary arteries in 29/52 (56%) patients. ROC analysis showed equal diagnostic performance for low-dose CTCA and CA with areas under the curve (AUC) of 0.82 and 0.83 (P = 0.64). The optimal cut-off value was determined at stenosis of >60% for the prediction of hemodynamically significant coronary stenosis by CTCA. Using this cut-off value, sensitivity, specificity, NPV and PPV to predict hemodynamic significance by CTCA were 100%, 83%, 100%, and 88% on a per-patient basis and 88%, 73%, 83% and 81% on a per-artery analysis, respectively.

Conclusion

By considering coronary stenosis >60%, diagnostic performance for predicting the hemodynamic significance of coronary stenosis by CTCA is optimal and equals that of CA.     

Dobutamine 99mTc-MIBI single-photon emission tomography: non-exercise-dependent detection of haemodynamically significant coronary artery stenoses

Dobutamine pharmacological stress testing in conjunction with technetium-99m methoxyisobutylisonitrile single-photon emission tomography (MIBI SPET) may be a useful alternative to convential exercise stress MIBI SPET for the detection and localisation of coronary artery stenoses. Therefore, 35 patients with stenoses ( 50% diameter reduction) of one or more coronary arteries were selected for dobutamine MIBI SPET. Each patient underwent MIBI injection at rest and during dobutamine infusion with incremental doses (5, 10, 15 and 20 g kg^–1 min^–1). A conventional exercise stress test (EST) was performed in all patients. Peak double product during steady-state dobutamine infusion (18 200 ± 4200 mmHg min^–1) was lower (P = 0.0001) than during EST (21 700 ± 4900 mmHg min^–1). Image quality was good in all but one patient, who had to be excluded from data analysis due to excessive hepatobiliary MIBI activity. Dobutamine-induced perfusion abnormalities were observed in 30/34 MIBI SPET studies, resulting in an overall detection rate for coronary artery disease of 88%. A pathological EST was observed in 23/34 patients (68%). The detection rate of individual coronary artery stenoses was 85% (28/33) for stenosess with a severe diameter reduction (>70%) and 50% (12/24) for stenoses with a moderate diameter reduction ( 50–70%). In particular, sensitivity and specificity for the detection of moderate and severe stenoses ( 50%) were 75%/100% for left anterior descending, 67%/95% for left circumflex and 67%/69% for right coronary artery stenoses. Dobutamine MIBI SPET is a well-tolerated, non-exercise-dependent test for detection and localisation of haemodynamically significant coronary artery stenoses. The use of dobutamine allows a stepwise increase in pharmacological stress similar to EST and is especially useful in patients who are unable to exercise. Correspondence to: E. Voth     

Three-dimensional, navigator-echo MR coronary angiography in detecting stenoses of the major epicardial vessels, with conventional coronary angiography as the standard of reference

PURPOSE: To test three-dimensional (3D), navigator-echo magnetic resonance (MR) coronary angiography in detecting stenoses of the coronary arteries. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Forty-two patients (age range, 50-79 years) underwent MR coronary angiography (1.5 T). A navigator-echo sequence was used. Two or three 15% overlapped transverse slabs were acquired. Data were analyzed by readers blinded to conventional coronary angiographic results. On conventional coronary angiograms, coronary arterial stenoses of 50% or greater narrowing were considered significant. On MR coronary angiograms, the major coronary vessels were subdivided into proximal (within 5 cm) and distal (beyond 5 cm) segments, except for the left main vessel. Stenoses of 50% or greater were identified on reformatted multiplanar MR coronary angiograms. RESULTS: Three MR coronary angiographic examinations were aborted because of patient claustrophobia; 39 of 39 left main, 117 of 117 proximal, and 78 of 117 distal segments were visualized. MR coronary angiography showed a sensitivity of 82% (95% CI: 73%, 91%) and a specificity of 89% (95% CI: 85%, 94%) in overall stenoses identification, of 90% (95% CI: 81%, 99%) and 90% (95% CI: 83%, 96%) for proximal segments, and of 68% (95% CI: 50%, 86%) and 81% (95% CI: 71%, 92%) for distal segments, respectively. CONCLUSION: Navigator-echo, 3D MR coronary angiography is a promising sequence for assessing coronary arterial stenoses, but further improvements are required for distal segments.