Effects of Initial Cell Seeding in Self Assembly of Articular Cartilage

Current forays into tissue engineering of articular cartilage in vitro using the self-assembling method have produced constructs possessing significant extracellular matrix and resulting mechanical properties. However, large numbers of native articular chondrocytes are necessary to produce functional engineered cartilage; all previous work with the self-assembling process has used 5.5 × 10⁶ cells/construct. In this study, the effects of initial cell seeding (0.25–11 × 10⁶ cells/construct) on tissue quality were investigated. Results showed that tissue engineered articular cartilage was formed, when using at least 2 million cells/construct, possessing dimensional, compositional, and compressive properties approaching those of native tissue. It was noted that higher seeding contributed to thicker constructs with larger diameters and had a significant effect on resulting biochemical and biomechanical properties. It was further observed that aggregate modulus increased with increased seeding. By combining gross morphological, histological, biochemical, and biomechanical results, an optimal initial seeding for the self-assembling process of 3.75 × 10⁶ cells/construct was identified. This finding enhances the translatability of this tissue engineering process by reducing the number of cells needed for tissue engineering of articular cartilage by 32% while maintaining essential tissue properties.     

A self-assembling process in articular cartilage tissue engineering

Current therapies for articular cartilage defects often result in fibrocartilaginous tissue. To achieve regeneration with hyaline articular cartilage, tissue-engineering approaches employing cell-seeded scaffolds have been investigated. However, limitations of scaffolds include phenotypic alteration of cells, stress-shielding, hindrance of neotissue organization, and degradation product toxicity. This study employs a self-assembling process to produce tissue-engineered constructs over agarose in vitro without using a scaffold. Compared to past studies using various meshes and gels as scaffolding materials, the self-assembly method yielded constructs with comparable GAG and collagen content. By 12 weeks, the self-assembling process resulted in tissue-engineered constructs that were hyaline- like in appearance with histological, biochemical, and biomechanical properties approaching those of native articular cartilage. Overall, constructs contained two thirds more GAG per dry weight than calf articular cartilage. Collagen per dry weight reached more than one third the level of native tissue. IHC and gel electrophoresis showed collagen type II production and absence of collagen type I. More importantly, self-assembled constructs reached well over one third the stiffness of native tissue.     

关节软骨体外构建力学环境的研究进展

很多物理因素都影响软骨组织的生长和发育,其中力学因素起主要作用。软骨的生长、发育是力学调控的适应过程。当前采用多种力学条件应用于软骨生物反应器,如流体剪应力、液体压力、直接压缩等,或其中部分组合,但这些条件还没有构建出与活体软骨结构-功能相匹配的人工软骨。如果一种载荷能适合构建软骨,那么这种载荷首先能保证培养物内部信号分子、营养和废物的有效运输;其次,能对支架内种子细胞特定的力学刺激;第三,能促进培养物结构-功能的发展。本文回顾、分析当前多种力学条件的作用效果,其中流体剪应力、液体压力、拉伸、直接压缩或变形剪应力都是软骨受力状态的部分体现。作者认为滚压载荷是软骨培养的合适力学环境,它是当前多种力学条件的一个综合指标,对软骨培养物可以形成纵向的动态压缩和横向的动态变形剪应力,并且有利于细胞新陈代谢物质的运输,因此,滚压环境可能是人工软骨结构-功能构建的发展方向。     

Chondrocyte response to high regimens of cyclic hydrostatic pressure in 3-dimensional engineered constructs

PURPOSE: Despite widespread use of 3-dimensional (3D) micro-porous scaffolds to promote their potential application in cartilage tissue engineering, only a few studies have examined the response to hydrostatic pressure of engineered constructs. A high cyclic pressurization, currently believed to be the predominant mechanical signal perceived by cells in articular cartilage, was used here to stimulate bovine articular chondrocytes cultured in a synthetic 3D porous scaffold (DegraPol). METHODS: Construct cultivation lasted 3 days with applied pressurization cycles of amplitude 10 MPa, frequency 0.33 Hz, and stimulation sessions of 4 hours/day. RESULTS: At 3 days of culture, with respect to pre-culture conditions, the viability of the pressurized constructs did not vary, whereas it underwent a 16% drop in the unpressurized controls. Synthesis of alfa-actin was 34% lower in all cultured constructs. Synthesis of collagen II/collagen I did not vary in pressurized constructs, was 76% lower in unpressurized controls, and was around 230% higher in pressurized constructs with respect to unpressurized controls. Chondrocytes showed a phenotypic spherical morphology at time zero and at 3 days of pressurized culture. CONCLUSIONS: Although the passage from 2D expansion to 3D geometry was effective to guide cell differentiation, only mechanical conditioning enabled the maintenance and further cell differentiation toward a mature chondrocytic phenotype.     

间歇静水压对ATDC5软骨细胞分化早期的影响

文题释义： 间歇静水压：软骨细胞的新陈代谢及发育,除了有必要的营养成分支持外,力学刺激也是必不可少的,而力学刺激又有许多方式,如剪切力、流水动力、持续压力、间歇压力等,这些力学刺激对软骨细胞的诱导分化结果不尽相同,而最接近生理状态下的力学刺激最有利于软骨细胞的发育与分化,间歇静水压就是模仿关节运动的方式,把细胞放在培养液里间断对细胞进行力学刺激,进而促进细胞分化和发育。 软骨组织工程：软骨组织损伤后很难再生,如何修复受损伤的软骨组织是目前国际关注的焦点,利用工程学原理,重新构建新的软骨组织,是修复软骨组织最有效的方法,但构建新的软骨组织非常复杂,需要能够分化成软骨细胞的干细胞,需要分化所必需的培养液、培养支架、力学环境等因素,还需要稳定的生长发育环境,因此从种子细胞到软骨细胞,最后形成软骨组织是一个复杂的生物工程。 背景：软骨组织修复是组织工程研究的重要领域,如何利用工程学技术有效将种子细胞定向分化成软骨细胞是组织工程的重点和难点。目前,单纯应用各种定向诱导培养试剂很难使其分化为成熟稳定的软骨细胞,正是在这一背景下,作者利用ATDC5软骨细胞的特点,除了应用有效的培养液处理外,还采用间歇净水压的压力刺激方法,对其定向诱导分化进行早期研究。 目的：了解间歇静水压对ATDC5软骨细胞早期软骨方向分化成熟的影响。 方法：将ATDC5软骨细胞株在单层条件下培养,3 d细胞贴壁良好,并形成复层,而后在密封条件下进行间歇静水压(施加强度10 MPa,加压频率1 Hz,4 h/d)培养,设立无间歇静水压且其他条件相同的培养细胞为对照组。在第4,7,11,14,17天,通过显微镜观察细胞形态变化,应用Real-time PCR检测Aggrecan,COL-2,SOX-9的mRNA表达水平。 结果与结论：经间歇静水压作用后,ATDC5细胞表现出较明显的斑块样改变和细胞浓聚现象;Aggrecan、COL-2 mRNA表达水平明显升高,SOX-9 mRNA虽然与对照组变化不大,但也出现了先抑后扬的特点。结果表明,间歇静水压影响ATDC5软骨细胞向软骨方向分化的基因表达,促进软骨特征基质的分泌,利于向软骨细胞分化成熟。 ORCID: 0000-0003-0911-8294(张强) 中国组织工程研究杂志出版内容重点：组织构建;骨细胞;软骨细胞;细胞培养;成纤维细胞;血管内皮细胞;骨质疏松;组织工程     

Nondestructive evaluation of tissue engineered articular cartilage using time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy and ultrasound backscatter microscopy

The goal of this study is to evaluate the ability of a bimodal technique integrating time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy (TRFS) and ultrasound backscatter microscopy (UBM) for nondestructive detection of changes in the biochemical, structural, and mechanical properties of self-assembled engineered articular cartilage constructs. The cartilage constructs were treated with three chemical agents (collagenase, chondroitinase-ABC, and ribose) to induce changes in biochemical content (collagen and glycosaminoglycan [GAG]) of matured constructs (4 weeks); and to subsequently alter the mechanical properties of the construct. The biochemical changes were evaluated using TRFS. The microstructure and the thickness of the engineered cartilage samples were characterized by UBM. The optical and ultrasound results were validated against those acquired via conventional techniques including collagen and GAG quantification and measurement of construct stiffness. Current results demonstrated that a set of optical parameters (e.g., average fluorescence lifetime and decay constants) showed significant correlation (p<0.05) with biochemical and mechanical data. The high-resolution ultrasound images provided complementary cross-section information of the cartilage samples morphology. Therefore, the technique was capable of nondestructively evaluating the composition of extracellular matrix and the microstructure of engineered tissue, demonstrating great potential as an alternative to traditional destructive assays.     

Transient exposure to transforming growth factor beta 3 under serum-free conditions enhances the biomechanical and biochemical maturation of tissue-engineered cartilage

A goal of cartilage tissue engineering is the production of cell-laden constructs possessing sufficient mechanical and biochemical features to enable native tissue function. This study details a systematic characterization of a serum-free (SF) culture methodology employing transient growth factor supplementation to promote robust maturation of tissue-engineered cartilage. Bovine chondrocyte agarose hydrogel constructs were cultured under free-swelling conditions in serum-containing or SF medium supplemented continuously or transiently with varying doses of transforming growth factor beta 3 (TGF-beta3). Constructs were harvested weekly or bi-weekly and assessed for mechanical and biochemical properties. Transient exposure (2 weeks) to low concentrations (2.5-5 ng/mL) of TGF-beta3 in chemically defined medium facilitated robust and highly reproducible construct maturation. Constructs receiving transient TGF-beta3 exposure achieved native tissue levels of compressive modulus (0.8 MPa) and proteoglycan content (6-7% of wet weight) after less than 2 months of in vitro culture. This maturation response was far superior to that observed after continuous growth factor supplementation or transient TGF-beta3 treatment in the presence of serum. These findings represent a significant advance in developing an ex vivo culture methodology to promote production of clinically relevant and mechanically competent tissue-engineered cartilage constructs for implantation to repair damaged articular surfaces.     

Chondrocytes from different zones exhibit characteristic differences in high density culture

Superficial and middle/deep zone chondrocytes were isolated from goat femoral cartilage by a zonal abrasion method. The cells were expanded 100-fold through two passages, then seeded into agarose wells to form high-density constructs through a self-assembling process. After 4 weeks in culture, the superficial zone constructs contracted into a dense cell mass, while middle/deep zone chondrocytes formed constructs with four distinct regions. Middle/deep zone chondrocytes produced 250% more glycosaminoglycans per dry weight and more collagen per dry weight than superficial zone chondrocytes. The superficial and middle/deep zone chondrocytes were found to retain characteristic differences even after 100-fold expansion, as evidenced by construct morphology and extracellular matrix content. This study uniquely demonstrated the ability of expanded superficial and middle/deep zone chondrocytes to form constructs of distinct characteristics without a scaffold. The goal of tissue engineering different zones of cartilage is to eventually replicate the specific function of each zone.     

Chondrocytes from Different Zones Exhibit Characteristic Differences in High Density Culture

Superficial and middle/deep zone chondrocytes were isolated from goat femoral cartilage by a zonal abrasion method. The cells were expanded 100-fold through two passages, then seeded into agarose wells to form high-density constructs through a self-assembling process. After 4 weeks in culture, the superficial zone constructs contracted into a dense cell mass, while middle/deep zone chondrocytes formed constructs with four distinct regions. Middle/deep zone chondrocytes produced 250% more glycosaminoglycans per dry weight and more collagen per dry weight than superficial zone chondrocytes. The superficial and middle/deep zone chondrocytes were found to retain characteristic differences even after 100-fold expansion, as evidenced by construct morphology and extracellular matrix content. This study uniquely demonstrated the ability of expanded superficial and middle/deep zone chondrocytes to form constructs of distinct characteristics without a scaffold. The goal of tissue engineering different zones of cartilage is to eventually replicate the specific function of each zone.     

Semi-continuous perfusion system for delivering intermittent physiological pressure to regenerating cartilage

A semi-continuous compression/perfusion system has been custom made to allow the application of intermittent hydrostatic pressure, at physiological levels, to regenerating tissues over the long term. To test the system, isolated foal chondrocytes were seeded in resorbable polyglycolic acid meshes and cultured in the system for 5 weeks. The cell/polymer constructs were subjected to an intermittent hydrostatic pressure of 500 psi and were fed semi-continuously. Assays of the resulting tissue constructs indicate that the reactor supports cartilage development and that physiological intermittent compression enhances the production of extracellular matrix by the chondrocytes. The concentrations of sulfated glycosaminoglycan were found to be at least twice as high as those in control (unpressurized) samples. A correlation between the sulfated glycosaminoglycan content and the compressive modulus in pressurized, but not control, samples suggests that physiological intermittent pressurization not only enhances the production of extracellular matrix but may also influence matrix organization resulting in a stronger construct.     

Chondrogenic differentiation of adipose-derived adult stem cells by a porous scaffold derived from native articular cartilage extracellular matrix

Adipose-derived adult stem cells (ASCs) have the ability to differentiate into a chondrogenic phenotype in response to specific environmental signals such as growth factors or artificial biomaterial scaffolds. In this study, we examined the hypothesis that a porous scaffold derived exclusively from articular cartilage can induce chondrogenesis of ASCs. Human ASCs were seeded on porous scaffolds derived from adult porcine articular cartilage and cultured in standard medium without exogenous growth factors. Chondrogenesis of ASCs seeded within the scaffold was evident by quantitative RT-PCR analysis for cartilage-specific extracellular matrix (ECM) genes. Histological and immunohistochemical examination showed abundant production of cartilage-specific ECM components-particularly, type II collagen-after 4 or 6 weeks of culture. After 6 weeks of culture, the cellular morphology in the ASC-seeded constructs resembled those in native articular cartilage tissue, with rounded cells residing in the glycosaminoglycan-rich regions of the scaffolds. Biphasic mechanical testing showed that the aggregate modulus of the ASC-seeded constructs increased over time, reaching 150 kPa by day 42, more than threefold higher than that of the unseeded controls. These results suggest that a porous scaffold derived from articular cartilage has the ability to induce chondrogenic differentiation of ASCs without exogenous growth factors, with significant synthesis and accumulation of ECM macromolecules, and the development of mechanical properties approaching those of native cartilage. These findings support the potential for a processed cartilage ECM as a biomaterial scaffold for cartilage tissue engineering. Additional in vivo evaluation is necessary to fully recognize the clinical implication of these observations.     

Effect of low oxygen tension on tissue-engineered cartilage construct development in the concentric cylinder bioreactor

Cartilage is exposed to low oxygen tension in vivo, suggesting culture in a low-oxygen environment as a strategy to enhance matrix deposition in tissue-engineered cartilage in vitro. To assess the effects of oxygen tension on cartilage matrix accumulation, porous polylactic acid constructs were dynamically seeded in a concentric cylinder bioreactor with bovine chondrocytes and cultured for 3 weeks at either 20 or 5% oxygen tension. Robust chondrocyte proliferation and matrix deposition were achieved. After 22 days in culture, constructs from bioreactors operated at either 20 or 5% oxygen saturation had similar chondrocyte densities and collagen content. During the first 12 days of culture, the matrix glycosaminoglycan (GAG) deposition rate was 19.5 x 10(-9) mg/cell per day at 5% oxygen tension and 65% greater than the matrix GAG deposition rate at 20% oxygen tension. After 22 days of bioreactor culture, constructs at 5% oxygen contained 4.5 +/- 0.3 mg of GAG per construct, nearly double the 2.5 +/- 0.2 mg of GAG per construct at 20% oxygen tension. These data demonstrate that culture in bioreactors at low oxygen tension favors the production and retention of GAG within cartilage matrix without adversely affecting chondrocyte proliferation or collagen deposition. Bioreactor studies such as these can identify conditions that enhance matrix accumulation and construct development for cartilage tissue engineering.     

Engineering lubrication in articular cartilage

Despite continuous progress toward tissue engineering of functional articular cartilage, significant challenges still remain. Advances in morphogens, stem cells, and scaffolds have resulted in enhancement of the bulk mechanical properties of engineered constructs, but little attention has been paid to the surface mechanical properties. In the near future, engineered tissues will be able to withstand and support the physiological compressive and tensile forces in weight-bearing synovial joints such as the knee. However, there is an increasing realization that these tissue-engineered cartilage constructs will fail without the optimal frictional and wear properties present in native articular cartilage. These characteristics are critical to smooth, pain-free joint articulation and a long-lasting, durable cartilage surface. To achieve optimal tribological properties, engineered cartilage therapies will need to incorporate approaches and methods for functional lubrication. Steady progress in cartilage lubrication in native tissues has pushed the pendulum and warranted a shift in the articular cartilage tissue-engineering paradigm. Engineered tissues should be designed and developed to possess both tribological and mechanical properties mirroring natural cartilage. In this article, an overview of the biology and engineering of articular cartilage structure and cartilage lubrication will be presented. Salient progress in lubrication treatments such as tribosupplementation, pharmacological, and cell-based therapies will be covered. Finally, frictional assays such as the pin-on-disk tribometer will be addressed. Knowledge related to the elements of cartilage lubrication has progressed and, thus, an opportune moment is provided to leverage these advances at a critical step in the development of mechanically and tribologically robust, biomimetic tissue-engineered cartilage. This article is intended to serve as the first stepping stone toward future studies in functional tissue engineering of articular cartilage that begins to explore and incorporate methods of lubrication.     

Hydrodynamic stimulation and long term cultivation of nucleus pulposus cells: a new bioreactor system to induce extracellular matrix synthesis by nucleus pulposus cells dependent on intermittent hydrostatic pressure

A novel bioreactor system was constructed to induce extracellular matrix (ECM) synthesis by intervertebral disc (ID) cells due to intermittent hydrostatic pressure. The developed system is completely sterilizable and reusable. It is viable for cultivation, immobilization, and stimulation of various other cell types and tissues especially for cartilage. The custom made lid allows long-run cultivation through semi-continuous operation. Manual interferences and therefore the risk of contamination are reduced. Sampling, medium changing and addition of supplements are easily performed from the connected conditioning vessel, which could be placed in an incubator. For the present investigations nucleus pulposus cells from pigs were taken and immobilized in agarose to obtain three-dimensional cell matrix constructs which were subjected to intermittent hydrostatic pressure. Afterwards the construct was biochemically examined. The proven constituents of ECM were found to be released in dependence of the magnitude and profile of the applied pressure.     

Cellular utilization determines viability and matrix distribution profiles in chondrocyte-seeded alginate constructs

The long-term success of any cellular construct used for cartilage tissue engineering is dependent on the maintenance of cell viability throughout the construct thickness. Furthermore, the cells must continue to be metabolically active in order to synthesize a mechanically functional extracellular matrix (ECM). In the present study, a live-dead staining technique and systematic profiling procedure enabled the spatial and temporal distribution of chondrocyte viability to be characterized within 4-mm-thick alginate scaffolds. ECM distribution after 14 days of culture is described both biochemically and histologically and the mechanical functionality of the constructs was assessed by an unconfined compression test. Parameters investigated included alginate permeability, cell-seeding density, and volume of culture medium. Nonhomogeneity of cell and matrix distribution was evident, with greater densities of both parameters in the periphery of the constructs. The culture time preceding central viability loss was inversely related to cell density but relatively independent of scaffold density. However, homogeneity could be attained with increasing medium volume, as evidenced with cell and matrix distribution for cultures in 6.4 mL of medium per 10(6) cells. Moreover, the mechanical properties of the construct were enhanced by culture in increasing volumes of medium. This work indicates that cellular utilization determines the nonhomogeneous nature of cartilage formation in three-dimensional constructs and presents a guide to nonlimiting medium volumes for static culture conditions.     

Designing zonal organization into tissue-engineered cartilage

Cartilage tissue engineering strategies generally result in homogeneous tissue structures with little resemblance to the native zonal organization of articular cartilage. The objective of this study was to use bilayered photopolymerized hydrogels to organize zone-specific chondrocytes in a stratified framework and study the effects of this three-dimensional coculture system on the properties of the engineered tissue. Superficial and deep zone chondrocytes from bovine articular cartilage were photoencapsulated in separate hydrogels as well as in adjacent layers of a bilayered hydrogel. Histology, mechanical testing, and biochemical analysis was performed after culturing in vitro. To evaluate the influence of coculture on tissue properties, the layers were separated and compared to constructs containing only superficial or deep cells. In the bilayered constructs, deep cells produced more collagen and proteoglycan than superficial cells, resulting in cartilage tissue with stratified, heterogeneous properties. Deep cells cocultured with superficial cells in the bilayered system demonstrated reduced proliferation and increased matrix synthesis compared to deep cells cultured alone. The bilayered constructs demonstrated greater shear and compressive strength than homogenous cell constructs. This study demonstrated that interactions between zone-specific chondrocytes affect the biological and mechanical properties of engineered cartilage. Strategies aimed to structurally organize zone-specific cells and encourage heterotypic cell interactions may contribute to improved functional properties of engineered cartilage.     

Hydrostatic Pressure Enhances Chondrogenic Differentiation of Human Bone Marrow Stromal Cells in Osteochondrogenic Medium

This study demonstrated the chondrogenic effect of hydrostatic pressure on human bone marrow stromal cells (MSCs) cultured in a mixed medium containing osteogenic and chondrogenic factors. MSCs seeded in type I collagen sponges were exposed to 1 MPa of intermittent hydrostatic pressure at a frequency of 1 Hz for 4 h per day for 10 days, or remained in identical culture conditions but without exposure to pressure. Afterwards, we compared the proteoglycan content of loaded and control cell/scaffold constructs with Alcian blue staining. We also used real-time PCR to evaluate the change in mRNA expression of selected genes associated with chondrogenic and osteogenic differentiation (aggrecan, type I collagen, type II collagen, Runx2 (Cbfa-1), Sox9, and TGF-β1). With the hydrostatic pressure loading regime, proteoglycan staining increased markedly. Correspondingly, the mRNA expression of chondrogenic genes such as aggrecan, type II collagen, and Sox9 increased significantly. We also saw a significant increase in the mRNA expression of type I collagen, but no change in the expression of Runx2 or TGF-β1 mRNA. This study demonstrated that hydrostatic pressure enhanced differentiation of MSCs in the presence of multipotent differentiation factors in vitro, and suggests the critical role that this loading regime may play during cartilage development and regeneration in vivo.     

Optimization of allograft implantation using scaffold-free chondrocyte plates

If a tissue-engineered cartilage transplant is to succeed, it needs to integrate with the host tissue, to endure physiological loading, and to acquire the phenotype of the articular cartilage. Although there are many reported treatments for osteochondral defects of articular cartilage, problems remain with the use of artificial matrices (scaffolds) and the stage of implantation. We constructed scaffold-free three-dimensional tissue-engineered cartilage allografts using a rotational culture system and investigated the optimal stage of implantation and repair of the remodeling site. We evaluated the amounts of extracellular matrix and gene expression levels in scaffold-free constructs and transplanted the constructs for osteochondral defects using a rabbit model. Allografted 2-week constructs expressed high levels of proteoglycan and collagen per DNA content, integrated with the host cartilage successfully, and were able to counter physiological loads, and the chondrocyte plate contributed reparative mesenchymal stem cells to the final phenotype of the articular cartilage.     

Scaffolds for tissue engineering of cartilage

Articular cartilage lesions resulting from trauma or degenerative diseases are commonly encountered clinical problems. It is well-established that adult articular cartilage has limited regenerative capacity, and, although numerous treatment protocols are currently employed clinically, few approaches exist that are capable of consistently restoring long-term function to damaged articular cartilage. Tissue engineering strategies that focus on the use of three-dimensional scaffolds for repairing articular cartilage lesions offer many advantages over current treatment strategies. Appropriate design of biodegradable scaffold conduits (either preformed or injectable) allow for the delivery of reparative cells bioactive factors, or gene factors to the defect site in an organized manner. This review seeks to highlight pertinent design considerations and limitations related to the development, material selection, and processing of scaffolds for articular cartilage tissue engineering, evidenced over the last decade. In particular, considerations for novel repair strategies that use scaffolds in combination with controlled release of bioactive factors or gene therapy are discussed, as are scaffold criteria related to mechanical stimulation of cell-seeded constructs. Furthermore, the subsequent impact of current and future aspects of these multidisciplinary scaffold-based approaches related to in vitro and in vivo cartilage tissue engineering are reported herein.