The role of faith-based organizations in maternal and newborn health care in Africa

Background

Global disparities in maternal and newborn health represent one of the starkest health inequities of our times. Faith-based organizations (FBOs) have historically played an important role in providing maternal/newborn health services in African countries. However, the contribution of FBOs in service delivery is insufficiently recognized and mapped.

Objectives

A systematic review of the literature to assess available evidence on the role of FBOs in the area of maternal/newborn health care in Africa.

Search strategy

MEDLINE and EMBASE were searched for articles published between 1989 and 2009 on maternal/newborn health and FBOs in Africa.

Results

Six articles met the criteria for inclusion. These articles provided information on 6 different African countries. Maternal/newborn health services provided by FBOs were similar to those offered by governments, but the quality of care received and the satisfaction were reported to be better.

Conclusion

Efforts to document and analyze the contribution of FBOs in maternal/newborn health are necessary to increase the recognition of FBOs and to establish stronger partnerships with them in Africa as an untapped route to achieving Millennium Development Goals 4 and 5.     

What is quality in maternal and neonatal health care?

Objective

to review published papers and reports examining quality of care in maternal and newborn health to identify definitions and models of quality of care.

Design

literature review.

Search strategy

electronic search of MEDLINE and organisational databases for literature describing definitions and models of quality used in health care and maternal and newborn health care. Relevant papers and reports were reviewed and summarised.

Findings

there is no universally accepted definition of quality of care. The multi-faceted nature of quality is widely acknowledged. In the literature quality of care is described: from the perspective of health care providers, managers and patients; dimensions within the health care system; using elements such as safety, effectiveness, patient-centeredness, timeliness, equity and efficiency; and through the provision of care and experience of care.

Key conclusions

the importance of ensuring good quality of care for women and newborn babies is well recognised in the literature, however, there is currently no agreed single and comprehensive definition described. Several models were identified, which can be combined to form a comprehensive framework to help define and assess quality of care or lack of quality. Approaches to quality of care that are specifically important for maternal and newborn health were identified and include a rights based approach, adopting care that is evidence-based, consideration of the mother and baby as interdependent and the fact that pregnancy is on the whole a healthy state.

Implications for practice

a model of quality of maternal and newborn health care using perspectives, characteristics, dimensions of the system and elements of quality of care specific to maternal and newborn health is proposed, which can be used as a basis for developing quality improvement strategies and activities, and incorporating quality into existing programmes.     

Availability and quality of emergency obstetric care in Shanxi Province, China

Objective

To investigate the availability and quality of emergency obstetric care (EmOC) received by women in a rural Chinese province.

Methods

The study was conducted in 7 rural counties and townships in Shanxi Province, China. Data sources included interviews with 7 hospital leaders, 5 maternal and child health workers, and 7 obstetricians; 118 records of complicated delivery were audited, 21 Maternal and Child Health Annual Reports analyzed, and observations conducted of facilities and advanced labor care.

Results

The number of comprehensive EmOC facilities was adequate in all counties. Three counties had fewer basic EmOC facilities than recommended and only 4 counties reached the recommended level. Most of the existing township hospitals did not provide birthing services. All the county hospitals could perform cesarean deliveries with rates from 6.8%-40.8%. The management of complications was not evidence-based. For example, women with pre-eclampsia and eclampsia were given too little magnesium sulfate; women were not closely monitored for hemorrhage after birth and the partograph was used incorrectly with consequences for obstructed labor.

Conclusion

Basic EmOC facilities are not adequate and township hospitals should be upgraded to provide birthing services. The quality of EmOC is poor and needs improvement.     

The status of maternal and newborn care services in Sierra Leone 8 years after ceasefire

Objective

To conduct a needs assessment for emergency obstetric care (EmOC) to address the unacceptably high maternal and newborn mortality indices in Sierra Leone 8 years after the end of the civil war.

Methods

From June to August 2008, a cross-sectional survey was conducted of health facilities in Sierra Leone offering delivery services. Assessment tools were local adaptations of tools developed by the Averting Maternal Death and Disability program at Columbia University, New York, USA.

Results

There were enough comprehensive EmOC (CEmOC) facilities in the country but they were poorly distributed. There were no basic EmOC (BEmOC) facilities. Few facilities (37% of hospitals and 2% of health centers) were able to perform assisted vaginal delivery (AVD), and 3 potentially BEmOC facilities did not meet the standard only because they did not perform AVD. Severe shortages in staff, equipment, and supplies, and unsatisfactory supply of utilities severely hampered the delivery of quality EmOC services. Demand for maternity and newborn services was low, which may have been related to the poor quality and the high/unpredictable out-of-pocket cost of such services.

Conclusion

Significant increases in the uptake of institutional delivery services, the linkage of remote health workers to the health system, and the recruitment of midwives, in addition to rapid expansion in the training of health workers (including training in midwifery and obstetric surgery skills), are urgently needed to improve the survival of mothers and newborns.     

Implementation of the Zambia Electronic Perinatal Record System for comprehensive prenatal and delivery care

Objective

To characterize prenatal and delivery care in an urban African setting.

Methods

The Zambia Electronic Perinatal Record System (ZEPRS) was implemented to record demographic characteristics, past medical and obstetric history, prenatal care, and delivery and newborn care for pregnant women across 25 facilities in the Lusaka public health sector.

Results

From June 1, 2007, to January 31, 2010, 115 552 pregnant women had prenatal and delivery information recorded in ZEPRS. Median gestation age at first prenatal visit was 23 weeks (interquartile range [IQR] 19-26). Syphilis screening was documented in 95 663 (83%) pregnancies: 2449 (2.6%) women tested positive, of whom 1589 (64.9%) were treated appropriately. 111 108 (96%) women agreed to HIV testing, of whom 22% were diagnosed with HIV. Overall, 112 813 (98%) of recorded pregnancies resulted in a live birth, and 2739 (2%) in a stillbirth. The median gestational age was 38 weeks (IQR 35-40) at delivery; the median birth weight of newborns was 3000 g (IQR 2700-3300 g).

Conclusion

The results demonstrate the feasibility of using a comprehensive electronic medical record in an urban African setting, and highlight its important role in ongoing efforts to improve clinical care.     

The need for integrating family planning and postabortion care in China

Objective

To assess the need for integrating postabortion care with family planning services in China.

Method

We collected data from a clinic-based study of 24 abortion clinics in 3 large cities in China.

Results

There was a total of 287 (10.3%) high-risk abortions among the 2780 respondents, 974 (35%) of whom had had repeated abortions and 48.4% had had 2 abortions within 1 year; 63.7% of the current pregnancies resulted from not using contraceptives; 28.8% and 19.8% of these new pregnancies, respectively, were due to the failure of the rhythm or the withdrawal method; only 9.7% of the respondents consistently used condoms; and only 9.1% could identify the correct time of their first ovulation following an abortion.

Conclusion

Contraceptive neglect and the high rates of repeated and high-risk abortions call for the integration of postabortion care with family planning services in China.     

Ethiopia's assessment of emergency obstetric and newborn care: Setting the gold standard for national facility-based assessments

Objective

To describe the methods used to implement Ethiopia's 2008 emergency obstetric and newborn care services (EmONC) assessment; highlight how the collaborative process contributed to immediate integration of results into national and subnational planning; and explain how the experience informed the development of a set of tools providing best practices and guidelines for other countries conducting similar assessments.

Methods

A team of maternal and newborn health experts from the Federal Ministry of Health (FMOH), the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF), the World Health Organization (WHO), and the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA), together with representatives from the Ethiopian Society of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, provided technical guidance for the 18-month process and facilitated demand for and use of the assessment results. Eighty-four trained data collectors administered 9 data collection modules in 806 public and private facilities. Field work and data were managed by a private firm who, together with the core team, implemented a multi-layered plan for data quality. Columbia University's Averting Maternal Death and Disability Program provided technical assistance.

Results

Results were published in national and regional reports and in 1-page facility factsheets informing subnational planning activities. Assessment results—which have been published in journal articles—informed water infrastructure improvements, efforts to expand access to magnesium sulfate, and FMOH and UN planning documents. The assessment also established a permanent database for future monitoring of the health system, including geographic locations of surveyed facilities.

Conclusion

Ethiopia's assessment was successful largely because of active local leadership, a collaborative process, ample financial and technical support, and rapid integration of results into health system planning.     

Indicators for availability, utilization, and quality of emergency obstetric care in Ethiopia, 2008

Objective

To report on the availability and quality of emergency obstetric and newborn care (EmONC) in Ethiopia.

Methods

All licensed hospitals and health centers were visited and standard questionnaires were administered. In addition, a nonrandom systematic sample was taken of recent cesarean deliveries, partographs, and maternal deaths—and these cases were systematically reviewed. Health facilities were geocoded using geographic positioning system devices.

Results

Too few facilities provided EmONC to meet the UN standards of 5 per 500 000 population, both nationally and in all but 2 regions. Only 7% of deliveries took place in institutions of any type, and only 3% in facilities that routinely provided all the signal functions. Only 6% of women with obstetric complications were treated in any health facility, half of whom were treated in fully functional EmONC facilities. Nationwide, 0.6% of expected deliveries were by cesarean. The mortality rate for women with serious obstetric complications (case fatality rate) was 2%. The cause of death was unknown in 10% of cases, and 21% were due to indirect causes (primarily malaria, anemia, and HIV-related).

Conclusion

None of the indicators met UN standards. Ethiopia faces many challenges—not least geography—with regard to improving EmONC. Nevertheless, the government places high priority on improvement and has taken (and will continue to take) action to achieve Millennium Development Goals 4 and 5. This comprehensive survey serves both as a road map for planning strategies for improvement and as a baseline for measuring the impact of interventions.     

Availability and distribution of, and geographic access to emergency obstetric care in Zambia

Objective

To assess the availability and coverage of emergency obstetric care (EmOC) services in Zambia.

Methods

Reported provision of EmOC signal functions in the Zambian Health Facility Census and additional criteria on staffing, opening hours, and referral capacity were used to classify all Zambian health facilities as providing comprehensive EmOC, basic EmOC, or more limited care. Geographic accessibility of EmOC services was estimated by linking health facility data with data from the Zambian population census.

Results

Few Zambian health facilities provided all basic EmOC signal functions and had qualified health professionals available on a 24-hour basis. Of the 1131 Zambian delivery facilities, 135 (12%) were classified as providing EmOC. Zambia nearly met the UN EmOC density benchmarks nationally, but EmOC facilities and health professionals were unevenly distributed between provinces. Geographic access to EmOC services in rural areas was low; in most provinces, less than 25% of the population lived within 15 km of an EmOC facility.

Conclusion

A national Health Facility Census with geographic information is a valuable tool for assessing service availability and coverage at national and subnational levels. Simultaneously assessing health worker density and geographic access adds crucial information.     

Evaluation of a traditional birth attendant training programme in Bangladesh

Background and context

the 1997 Safe Motherhood Initiative effectively eliminated support for training traditional birth attendants (TBAs) in safe childbirth. Despite this, TBAs are still active in many countries such as Bangladesh, where 88% of deliveries occur at home. Renewed interest in community-based approaches and the urgent need to improve birth care has necessitated a re-examination of how provider training should be conducted and evaluated.

Objective

to demonstrate how a simple evaluation tool can provide a quantitative measure of knowledge acquisition and intended behaviour following a TBA training program.

Design

background data were collected from 45 TBAs attending two separate training sessions conducted by Bangladeshi non-governmental organization (NGO) Gonoshasthaya Kendra (GK). A semi-structured survey was conducted before and after each training session to assess the TBAs’ knowledge and reported practices related to home-based management of childbirth.

Setting

two training sessions conducted in Vatshala and Sreepur in rural Bangladesh.

Participants

45 active TBAs were recruited for this training evaluation.

Findings

there were significant improvements following the training sessions regarding how TBAs reported they would: (a) measure blood loss, (b) handle an apneic newborn, (c) refer women with convulsions and (d) refer women who are bleeding heavily. A greater degree of improvement, and higher scores overall, were observed among TBAs with no prior training and with less birth experience.

Key conclusions and recommendations for practice

as the Safe Motherhood community strives to improve safe childbirth care, the quality of care in pregnancy and childbirth for women who rely on less-skilled providers should not be ignored. These communities need assistance from governments and NGOs to help improve the knowledge and skill levels of the providers upon which they depend. Gonoshasthaya Kendra's extensive efforts to train and involve TBAs, with the aim of improving the quality of care provided to Bangladeshi women, is a good example of how to effectively integrate TBAs into safe motherhood efforts in resource-poor settings. The evaluation methodology described in this paper demonstrates how trainees’ prior experiences and beliefs may affect knowledge acquisition, and highlights the need for more attention to course content and pedagogic style.     

Women’s feelings about early contact with their infants on the labour ward

Objectives

to identify women’s feelings after early contact with their newborn infants in the delivery room, and to identify how health professionals involved in mother and infant care behave in the intrapartum setting.

Design

a qualitative approach using semi-structured interviews and observation. Content analysis was used to derive the three themes that emerged from the interviews.

Setting and participants

23 postpartum women and their caregivers in a public maternity hospital in Ribeirão Preto, Brazil.

Findings

three thematic categories emerged from the interviews: heightened fear, severe pain and intense conflict. The professionals’ actions revealed that they have theoretical and practical abilities for humanisation of care, but their actions are fragmented.

Final considerations

women can feel lonely, fearful and conflicted in the delivery room, and they also experience pain. Giving birth is a major event in a woman’s life, so it is important to facilitate a positive experience. Health professionals were found to display interventionist and impersonal attitudes; these influenced the potential choices of women at their first contact with their infant.

Implications for practice

the focus of health care needs to extend beyond the institution. This means fewer normative actions performed by health professionals, enabling women to enjoy their early contact with their newborn infants.     

Obstetric quality assurance to reduce maternal and fetal mortality in Kano and Kaduna State hospitals in Nigeria

Objective

To achieve Millennium Development Goals 4 and 5 in Nigeria, a quality assurance project in obstetrics in 10 hospitals in northern Nigeria was established to improve maternal and fetal outcome.

Methods

The project commenced in January 2008 with assessment and improvement of the structure of the 10 hospitals. Continuous maternal and fetal data collection and analysis were conducted from 2008 to 2009 by means of a maternity record book and structured monthly summary form. The quality of hospital infrastructure and equipment was also assessed.

Results

The mean maternal mortality ratio (MMR) was reduced from 1790 per 100 000 births in the first half of 2008 to 940 per 100 000 births in the second half of 2009. The average fetal mortality ratio (FMR) decreased slightly from 84.9 to 83.5 per 1000 births. There was an inversely proportional relationship between the total number of deliveries in a hospital and MMR and FMR. There was a close correlation between the MMR and the equipment status and hygiene conditions of the hospitals.

Conclusion

Continuous monitoring of quality assurance in maternity units raised the awareness of the quality of obstetric performance and improved the quality of care provided, thereby improving MMR.     

Effects of unplanned pregnancy on maternal health in Turkey

Objective

to investigate the effects of unplanned pregnancy on maternal health in Turkey.

Design

a case-control study.

Setting

a government hospital in Ayd?n, Turkey.

Participants

314 women in the early postpartum period, selected with a non-probability method.

Findings

significantly more women with unplanned pregnancy had physical problems (76.4% vs. 63.7%; p<0.01) and lower haemoglobin levels (11.26±1.27g/dl vs. 11.62±1.27g/dl; p<0.01) compared with women with planned pregnancy. Also, significantly more women with unplanned pregnancy had lower scores for adaptive behaviour in pregnancy (14.78±3.08 vs. 19.19±3.11; p<0.001), felt negative feelings during labour (mean scores on Labour Agentry Scale: 81.03±19.07 vs. 98.64±16.94; p<0.001), felt more severe pain during labour (mean rank: 173.21 vs. 141.79, p<0.001), and were at high risk of depression in the early postpartum period (mean scores on Edinburgh Postpartum Depression Scale: 14.86±6.08 vs. 7.28±4.85; p<0.001) compared with women with planned pregnancy.

Key conclusions

unplanned pregnancy has a negative impact on the development of positive behaviour concerning self-care, physical well-being, labour experience, pain in labour and psychological status in the early postpartum period.

Implications for practice

midwives and nurses should identify women with unplanned pregnancy at an early stage, and try to decrease the negative effects of unplanned pregnancy on maternal health and to improve prenatal, perinatal and postnatal care.     

Perinatal audit using the 3-delays model in western Tanzania

Objective

To audit intrapartum fetal and early neonatal deaths of infants weighing ≥ 2000 g in a regional hospital in western Tanzania.

Methods

The 3-delays methodology was applied to a cohort of perinatal deaths from July 2002 to July 2004.

Results

The overall perinatal mortality rate in the hospital was 38 per 1000 live births, and in just over half of these cases the birth weight was ≥ 2000 g. The leading clinicopathologic causes of death were birth asphyxia (19.0%), prolonged or obstructed labor (18.5%), antepartum hemorrhage (11.5%), and uterine rupture (9.0%). First delays occurred in 19.0% of the cases, second delays occurred in 21.5%, and third delays occurred in 72.5%.

Conclusion

For women who delivered in this hospital, most of the substandard care occurred after admission to the health facility. The improvement of institutional health care may have a significant impact on the decision to attend health institutions and, thereby, reduce first delays.     

Maternal decision on obtaining prenatal care: a study in Brazil

Objective

to address the social aspects of pregnancy and the views of pregnant women regarding prenatal assistance in Brazil.

Design

this qualitative study was focused on describing the Social Representations of prenatal care held by pregnant women. The discourse of the collective subject (DCS) framework was used to analyse the data collected, within the theoretical background of social representations, as proposed and developed by Serge Moscovici.

Participants and setting

21 pregnant women who were users of the publicly funded Brazilian unified health-care system and resided in the area served by its family health programme in a low- to middle-income neighbourhood on the outskirts of Campo Grande, the capital of the state of Mato Grosso do Sul, in southwestern Brazil. Data were collected by conducting in-depth, face-to-face interviews from January to October 2006.

Findings

all participants were married. Formal education of the participants was less than five years in four cases, between five and eight years in six cases, and greater than 11 years in 10 cases. Nine participants had informal jobs and earned up to US$ 200 per month, four paricipants had administrative jobs and earned over US$ 500 per month, and eight participants did not work. No specific racial/ethnic background predominated. Lack of adherence to prenatal care allowed for the identification of two DCS themes: ‘organisation of prenatal care services’ and ‘lifestyle features’.

Key conclusions

the respondents were found to have negative feelings about pregnancy which manifest as many fears, including the fear of harming their children's health, of being punished during labour, and of being reprimanded by health-care professionals for overlooking their prenatal care, in addition to the insecurity felt towards the infant and self.

Implications for practice

the findings reveal that communication between pregnant women and health-care professionals has been ineffective and that prenatal care has not been effective for the group interviewed—features that are likely to be found among other low- to middle-income groups living elsewhere in Brazil.     

Maternal mortality in low-income countries: What interventions have been evaluated and how should the evidence base be developed further?

Objective

This article reviews the evidence for the effectiveness of non-clinical interventions to reduce maternal mortality in low-income settings and identifies the gaps in the evidence base.

Methods

A systematic search was conducted to identify reviews and evaluations of non-clinical interventions to reduce maternal mortality in lower-income countries with high maternal mortality published between 1997 and 2008. Studies were reviewed to identify the topic focus, study design, and outcomes measured.

Results

There were 109 intervention evaluations and 30 reviews identified. Studies had been conducted in less than half of the countries and were generally poor quality. More studies focused on tertiary prevention (i.e., preventing death) rather than secondary prevention (i.e., preventing complications). More interventions sought to address quality of care than delays in seeking or accessing care.

Conclusions

While evidence partly reflects difficulties in evaluating complex public health interventions, more robust study designs are possible to evaluate interventions to reduce maternal mortality. In addition, better standardized outcome measures are needed. This overview identifies topic areas neglected by intervention research.