The history of radical dissection of cervical lymph nodes--in centenary of George Crile publication

The history of surgical management of cervical lymph nodes metastases evolved from the XIX century period, when the lymph nodes metastases in head and neck cancer had been recognized as a stage of disease above the limits of rational surgical treatment. Among the Pioneers of surgery of that time was Franciszek Jawdyński. The second period dated from 1906 publication of George Crile, who postulated the necessity of surgical resection of primary tumor as well as regional head and neck lymph nodes and defined a procedure of radical block dissection of cervical lymph nodes ended, when Hughes Martin and his contemporaries established a comprehensive radical neck dissection as a universal standard procedure of head and neck surgery. At present, not forgetting the value of radical neck dissection in treatment of cervical lymph nodes metastases, we return back to less mutilating surgical procedures, with preservation of non lymphatic structures and selective resections of regional group of nodes, due to the progress in non surgical treatment modalities (radiotherapy and chemotherapy) and new techniques of imaging and pathology.     

Ultrasonography-guided fine-needle aspiration for the assessment of cervical metastases

OBJECTIVE: To assess the value of ultrasonography (US) combined with fine-needle aspiration (FNA) cytology for the investigation of lymph node metastases in patients with head and neck cancer. DESIGN: Comparison of clinical examination (palpation) and preoperative US-FNA examination results of cervical nodes in a sample of patients with head and neck cancer. The histological features of the neck dissection specimens are used to validate these 2 variables. SETTING: A head and neck oncology service in a tertiary referral hospital. PATIENTS: A consecutive sample of 56 patients with head and neck squamous cell carcinoma, first seen between April 1, 1996, and July 30, 1998, who had neck dissections performed after the US-FNA examination. INTERVENTION: Cervical US-FNA preoperatively, followed by elective or therapeutic radical modified or selective neck dissection. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The histological examination results of subsequent neck dissection specimens are used to determine the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of US-FNA for individual nodes. Second, the results of node staging by clinical examination and US-FNA examination are compared. RESULTS: The sensitivity was 89.2%; specificity, 98.1%; and accuracy, 94.5%. Correct node stages were obtained in 52 (93%) of the patients using US-FNA compared with 34 (61%) using palpation. CONCLUSIONS: Ultrasonography combined with FNA is a highly accurate technique for the investigation of cervical lymph node metastases. A more accurate diagnosis may result in more appropriate treatment, particularly in a setting with limited resources. Retropharyngeal nodes, micrometastases, and lymph nodes smaller than 4 mm are limitations of US-FNA. Ultrasonography combined with FNA is a useful technique for the staging of head and neck cancer.     

Lymph node metastasis of glottic laryngeal carcinoma

The incidence of lymph node metastases in glottic cancer is assumed to be lower than in other head and neck cancers. In a retrospective study this statement was investigated. MATERIAL AND METHODS: This analysis was based on 910 consecutive patients with glottic carcinoma treated between 1970 and 1990 by means of surgery with special interest on regional lymph node metastases. RESULTS: 8.6 % patients had clinically positive necks (N+) and 5.9 % pathohistologically positive necks (pN+). The incidence of lymph node metastases showed correlation with pT category and vocal cord mobility. Lymph node metastases were found in 5 % of pT2, in 18 % of pT3 and in 32 % of pT4 tumors. Only one patient with pT1 cancer had metastatic lymph node involvement. The incidence of occult lymph node metastases was 18 %. Lymph node involvement, extracapsular spread and lymphangiosis carcinomatosa proved to be relevant prognostic factors. The 5 year recurrent free survival rate was 86.7 % for the whole group, 81.6 % for patients with negative nodes (pN0), and 61.8 % for patients with pN+ nodes (p < 0.001 according to logrank test). CONCLUSIONS: Clinical lymph node staging plays an important prognostic role in the staging procedure also in glottic carcinoma. At least in T3 carcinomas, elective treatment of the cervical lymph nodes seems to be necessary. T2 carcinomas with impaired cord mobility have a significant higher risk for metastatic spread; therefore neck dissection should be discussed also in these cases.     

Sentinel node biopsy for early oral and oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma

The appearance of lymph node metastases represents the most important adverse prognostic factor in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. Therefore, accurate staging of the cervical nodes is crucial in these patients. The management of the clinically and radiologically negative neck in patients with early oral and oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma is still controversial, though most centers favor elective neck dissection for staging of the neck and removal of occult disease. As only approximately 30% of patients harbor occult disease in the neck, most of the patients have to undergo elective neck dissection with no benefit. The sentinel node biopsy concept has been adopted from the treatment of melanoma and breast cancer to early oral and oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma during the last decade with great success. Multiple validation studies in the context of elective neck dissections revealed sentinel node detection rates above 95% and negative predictive values for negative sentinel nodes of 95%. Sentinel node biopsy has proven its ability to select patients with occult lymphatic disease for elective neck dissection, and to spare the costs and morbidity to patients with negative necks. Many centers meanwhile have abandoned routine elective neck dissection and entered in observational trials. These trials so far were able to confirm the high accuracy of the validation trials with less than 5% of the patients with negative sentinel nodes developing lymph node metastases during observation. In conclusion, sentinel node biopsy for early oral and oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma can be considered as safe and accurate, with success rates in controlling the neck comparable to elective neck dissection. This concept has the potential to become the new standard of care in the near future.     

Radical neck dissection.

Radical neck dissection has evolved into a standard surgical technique over the past century. It has been the most effective method of attempting to control suspected or gross metastasis to the cervical region. The technique embraces the en masse removal of all tissue elements in the space between the subdermis and the fascia colli. The perimeters of the dissection extend from the midline anteriorly to the anterior border of the trapezius muscle posteriorly, and from the clavicle to the mandible. The essential portion of this large mass of tissue is the cervical lymph system with its lymph nodes and afferent and efferent connecting vessels. Controllability of the cancer process is in direct proportion to the number of nodes involved, their size and their position in the neck. Complications in the routine radical neck dissection are minimal. Cure rates are influenced by the type, size and site of the primary cancer, the possibilities for the adjunctive treatment such as radiotherapy and chemotherapy, and the, as yet, little understood immunological factors. The radical neck dissection has proven itself to be an essential tool in the management of cancer in the head and neck.     

Selective lateral neck dissection for laryngeal cancer in the clinically negative neck: is it justified?

Selective lateral neck dissection is a recently-introduced surgical procedure for the treatment of cervical lymph nodes believed to be at risk of metastasis from primary malignant neoplasms of the upper respiratory and digestive tracts. Its value in the management of the clinically negative neck in cancer of the larynx is discussed.     

Early history of neck dissection

With the exception of distant metastases, the presence of lymph node metastasis in the neck is accepted as the single most important adverse independent prognostic factor and an indicator of survival in squamous carcinoma of the head and neck. Neck dissection in its various forms is the standard surgical treatment for clinical, subclinical and subpathologic metastatic cancer to the neck. The pertinent literature from the beginning of the nineteenth century to the middle of the twentieth century was reviewed. The four giants of late nineteenth century surgery: von Langenbeck, Billroth, von Volkmann and Kocher developed and reported the early cases of different types of neck dissection. Butlin, in England, conceived and developed the concept of elective neck dissection. In 1888, the Polish surgeon Jawdyńsky reported and described in detail the first successful extended en bloc neck dissection. Crile, in 1905 and 1906, reported the first significant series of radical en bloc neck dissections, bringing this procedure to the attention of the medical world as an effective operation with reproducible technique and results. The greatest impetus to the status of this surgical procedure came from Martin and colleagues, who published a monumental report in 1951 of 1,450 cases that established the place and technique of radical neck dissection in the modern treatment of head and neck cancer. Neck dissection, for treatment of cervical lymph node metastases in head and neck cancer, was conceived and attempted in the nineteenth century, with some limited success reported by the end of that era. An effective operation was described and reported in the early twentieth century and evolved by the mid century into a fundamental tool in the management of patients with head and neck cancer.     

The management of neck metastases in nasopharyngeal cancer

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The management of cervical lymph node metastases in nasopharyngeal carcinoma is important for a favourable outcome. The strategy of diagnosis and treatment for the lymph nodes on presentation and those that have recurred after initial therapy are different. This review presents the current concept. RECENT FINDINGS: The detection of the cervical lymph node metastases on presentation has improved with magnetic resonance imaging and positron emission tomography. The confirmation of the presence of malignancy is through fine needle aspiration cytology. For those lymph nodes that have recurred after concurrent radiotherapy and chemotherapy, the progression of the nodes detected through clinical examination and imaging studies indicates that salvage therapy is necessary. The surgical procedure of salvage is radical neck dissection, as pathological studies have shown that these lymph nodes exhibit extensive involvement of the neck tissue. Postoperative brachytherapy should be applied when the deep resection margins are close. SUMMARY: Identification of lymph node metastasis provides accurate staging of the disease and radical surgery should be performed for salvage.     

Clinical application of real-time tissue elastography to head and neck cancer--evaluation of cervical lymph node metastasis with real-time tissue elastography

Real-time tissue elastography (elastography) is a new ultrasonography procedure that display tissue elasticity. We evaluated the usefulness of elastography in the diagnosis of cervical lymph node metastasis and its treatment results in patients with head and neck cancer. Metastatic lymph nodes tended to produce little distortion when displayed as hard tumors, and produced distortion, displayed as soft tumors, after radiation therapy and/or chemotherapy. Elastography thus is useful as a potential new diagnostic procedure in the diagnosis of neck lymph node metastasis in head and neck cancer.     

Modern imaging techniques and ultrasound-guided aspiration cytology for the assessment of neck node metastases: a prospective comparative study

Summary Although palpation has proved to be an unreliable staging procedure, the indications for and the implications of more reliable radiologic staging methods for the neck in patients with a primary squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck remain controversial. Only a very accurate imaging technique can replace neck dissection in clinical NO disease. This study compares the value of palpation with computed tomography (CT), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and ultrasound (US) with or without guided aspiration cytology for neck node staging. One hundred and thirty-two patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck were examined radiologically before undergoing a total of 180 neck dissections as part of their treatment. CT, US and MRI proved to be significantly more accurate than palpation for cervical lymph node staging. The accuracy of US-guided aspiration cytology was significantly better than of any other technique used in this study. Modern imaging techniques are essential for appropriate assessment of neck node metastases. In view of advances in the accuracy of contemporary imaging, the need for elective treatment of the neck requires reappraisal.     

Mediastinal dissection in head and neck cancer

The superior mediastinum contains a considerable number of lymph nodes. Although occasionally involved in head and neck cancer, there are not many reports of mediastinal dissection in the practice of head and neck surgery. We present a group of seven patients with head and neck tumours that underwent mediastinal dissection in our department. Three patients are alive and free of disease six months to three years after the operation, two are alive with disease four and five years after the procedure, and two patients died peri-operatively. According to reviewed current literature, direct invasion of cancer of the head and neck to the mediastinum or mediastinal lymph node involvement is uncommon. Yet, mediastinal dissection provides the only chance for cure in selected cases.     

Positron emission tomography using [<Superscript>18</Superscript>F]fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG-PET) in the clinically negative neck: is it likely to be superior?

The capability of modern imaging techniques such as CT, MRI, US and US-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology (USgFNAC) to detect small tumour deposits is limited. Therefore, the detection of occult metastases in the clinically negative neck remains a diagnostic problem. One of the novel options to refine staging of head and neck cancer is [¹⁸F]fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (FDG-PET). To evaluate the diagnostic value of FDG-PET in the detection of occult malignant lymph nodes, we compared the results of FDG-PET with other diagnostic techniques and the histopathological outcome of 15 neck dissection specimens from 15 head and neck cancer patients with a clinically negative neck. Three sides contained metastases of squamous cell carcinoma. FDG-PET enabled detection of metastases in two sides, which were also detected by MRI or USgFNAC. FDG-PET and CT missed metastases in one patient, which were detected by both MRI and USgFNAC. In studies with a detailed examination of lymph nodes of a neck dissection, a low sensitivity of FDG-PET for the detection of occult lymph node metastases is found. It is unlikely that FDG-PET is superior in the detection of occult lymph node metastases in head and neck cancer patients with a palpably negative neck. The histopathological method used seems to be the most important factor for the differences in sensitivity in reported FDG-PET studies. New approaches such as the use of monoclonal antibodies labelled with a positron emitter may improve the results of PET in these patients.     

The node-negative neck: accuracy of clinical intraoperative lymph node assessment for metastatic disease in head and neck cancer

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Often, the type of neck dissection performed in patients with head and neck malignancy is finally determined by intraoperative assessment of clinically suspect lymph nodes by frozen section. This prospective study aimed to assess the accuracy of clinical intraoperative lymph node assessment and therefore to examine validity of the underlying assumption that the surgeon can consistently identify nodes that contain metastatic tumor. We also aimed to assess whether gross morphological characteristics of the lymph nodes examined could be correlated with nodal status and therefore used to predict those nodes containing metastatic disease. STUDY DESIGN: A prospective study assessing the accuracy of clinical intraoperative lymph node assessment in the node-negative neck. METHODS: Forty-six neck dissections from 34 patients with head and neck cancer were prospectively examined intraoperatively by a single surgeon. All obvious nodes were clinically assessed, morphologically described, and subsequently correlated with pathological findings. RESULTS: Sixty palpable nodes were identified in 32 neck dissections. They were clinically categorized as malignant or suspect (22) or benign (38). Pathological examination revealed a false-positive rate of 30% and a false-negative rate of 44%. The sensitivity of intraoperative lymph node assessment was 56%, and the specificity was 70%. Apart from "infiltration," morphological characteristics could not be correlated with nodal status. In the 14 neck dissections with no obviously palpable lymph nodes, 4 (29%) were positive for metastatic disease. CONCLUSIONS: In the node-negative neck, intraoperative assessment does not seem to improve the accuracy of staging. The only parameter of benefit and correlating with metastatic disease is clinical evidence of infiltration. The assumption that frozen section is a good determinate for selection of type of neck dissection is questionable. If selective neck dissection is not found to be therapeutic, its use leads to over-reliance on other therapeutic treatment such as postoperative radiotherapy, depriving the patient of a potential useful treatment modality in cases of locoregional recurrence.     

Upper jugular lymph nodes (submuscular recess) in non-squamous-cell cancer of the head and neck: surgical considerations

Cervical lymphadenectomy of level II encompasses lymph nodes associated with the upper internal jugular vein and the spinal accessory nerve (SAN). Removal of tissue superior to the SAN (submuscular recess-(SMR)) was recently shown to be unwarranted in selected cases of squamous-cell cancer. Thirty-five patients with non-squamous-cell cancer (SCC) of the head and neck treated with cervical lymphadenectomy were prospectively evaluated. Thirty-seven neck dissection specimens were histologically analysed for the number of lymph nodes involved with cancer. At the time of surgery, level II was separated into the supraspinal accessory nerve component (IIa) and the component anterior to the SAN (IIb). Neck dissections were most commonly performed for cancer of the thyroid gland (19) followed in frequency by the parotid gland (seven), skin: melanoma (five), basal-cell cancer (two), and other sites (four). Twenty-five neck dissections were modified-selective procedures and 12 were either radical or modified radical neck dissection. Twenty-nine necks were clinically N+ and eight N0. Histological staging was pathologically N+ in 32 neck dissection specimens. Level IIb contained an average of 12 nodes and the IIa component contained a mean of 5.0 nodes. Level II contained metastatic disease in 28 of 32 histologically node-positive specimens (87 per cent). Level IIa was involved with cancer in six cases (16 per cent), five of which were pre-operatively staged as clinically N+. All cases (100 per cent) with level IIa involvement had level IIb positive nodes. Three of the level IIa positive cases were cancer of the parotid gland comprising 43 per cent of this sub-group of patients. Incidence of involvement of SMR in non-SCC cases is not uncommon. The additional time required and morbidity associated with dissection of the supraspinal accessory nerve component of level II are probably justified when performing neck dissection in cancer of the thyroid gland. The SMR should be excised in cancer of the parotid gland. Large-scale prospective controlled studies with long-term follow-up periods are necessary to support resection of level IIb only.     

Comparative studies of diagnosis with US or CT of the cervical lymph node metastases in head and neck cancer

Correct assessment of lymph node metastasis in the head-neck region is very important for management of head and neck cancer. 233 lymph nodes were removed by radical neck dissection from 12 cases with cancer in the head and neck region, who did not undergo any preoperative treatment, and the materials were histopathologically examined. The histopathological findings were compared with preoperative US and CT findings. Histopathologically, 26 lymph nodes were found positive for metastasis and the remaining 207 lymph nodes, negative. US detected 45 (19%) of 233 lymph nodes before operation, and 40 of the 45 lymph nodes (89% : 40/45) were qualitatively correctly diagnosed. CT detected 21 lymph nodes (19%), 16 of which were qualitatively correctly diagnosed (76% : 16/21). Of 26 lymph nodes which were histopathologically involved, 19 lymph nodes were correctly diagnosed by US and 11 by CT. Possible reasons explaining the superiority of US to CT in terms of diagnostic reliability are the following: 1) US demonstrates more clearly the existence of lymph nodes than CT. 2) US is more reliable for measuring sizes of lymph nodes than CT. In literature, CT has been often reported to be useful to diagnose cervical lymph node involvement in individual cases. However, we insist that it is necessary to diagnose individual lymph nodes strictly for correct assessment of the reliability of image diagnosis.     

Neck dissection: past, present and future?

With the exception of distant metastasis, the presence of cervical lymph node metastasis is the single most adverse independent prognostic factor in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. Surgical removal of metastatic cervical lymph nodes had been attempted during the late nineteenth century, with varying techniques and poor results. A systematic approach to en bloc removal of cervical lymph node disease, described in detail by Jawdyński at the end of the nineteenth century and popularized and illustrated by Crile in the early twentieth century, provided consistent and more effective treatment and forms the basis of our current techniques. The concepts of radical neck dissection, employed extensively by Martin, were followed with almost religious consistency by most head and neck surgeons until the late twentieth century, when the principles of 'functional' neck dissection, developed by Suárez and popularized by Bocca, Gavilán, Ballantyne, Byers and others, led to the acceptance of modified radical neck dissection as treatment for lymph node disease in various stages. More recently, selective neck dissection, involving removal of nodes confined to the levels at greatest risk of metastasis from primary tumours at various sites, has become accepted practice for elective and, in some instances, therapeutic treatment of the neck. In the future, sentinel lymph node biopsy and the use of molecular pathological analyses may be employed to predict the presence of occult cervical disease, thus directing therapy to patients at greatest risk and sparing those without regional metastasis.     

Assessment of cobalt 57 tagged bleomycin as a clinical aid in staging of head and neck carcinoma

Critical assessment of head and neck cancer with respect to staging has, on occasion, been disappointingly ineffective. We have attempted to correlate the incidence of measureable uptake of cobalt 57 tagged bleomycin by primary squamous cell carcinoma and metastatic cervical lymph nodes. Forty-six cases have been evaluated with respect to histopathological confirmation of the suspected metastatic disease. We have found that this diagnostic measure increases our acumen in staging of head and neck cancer. The relevance of the Co-Bleo scans as a diagnostic aid is reported in 46 cases. Malignant tumors greater than 2 cm in size appear to demonstrate active uptake of the imaging agent. Small tumor size and excess background radioactivity contribute to the false-negatives (17%). Inflammatory conditions or benign tumors of the salivary apparatus may result in minimal uptake, thus, a false-positive result (10%). An increase in the radioactivity of the Co-Bleo may enhance the benefits of this procedure in the search for an undiagnosed primary, as well as undiagnosed local or distant metastases.     

Neck management in patients undergoing postradiotherapy salvage laryngeal surgery for recurrent/persistent laryngeal cancer

OBJECTIVE: To determine a plan for the management of cervical lymph nodes in patients undergoing salvage laryngeal surgery (SLS) for recurrent/persistent laryngeal cancer after primary radiotherapy (RT). STUDY DESIGN:: Retrospective chart review. METHODS: Charts of 51 consecutive patients who had salvage total or supracricoid laryngectomy with or without neck dissection for recurrent/persistent laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma after primary RT from 1988 to 2005 in our institution were reviewed. No patients received concomitant or neo-adjuvant chemotherapy. Thirty-four patients underwent SLS along with unilateral or bilateral neck dissection, whereas 17 patients underwent the SLS without neck dissection. Reports of preRT and preSLS staging of the primary tumor and the neck, recorded using the TNM system, were reviewed. Reports of the final histopathologic examination for the excised laryngeal cancer and cervical lymph nodes were reviewed. RESULTS: Thirty-four patients underwent SLS with unilateral or bilateral neck dissection. The preRT staging of the primary tumor for those 34 patients showed that 32 (94%) were staged T-1 (14) and T-2 (18), whereas the preSLS staging of the primary tumor for those 34 patients showed that 29 (85%) were staged T-3 and T-4. The postSLS final histopathologic examination of the excised lymph nodes in those 34 patients demonstrated that 30 (88%) did not have any evidence of nodal metastasis. On comparing patients with and without nodal metastasis (on their postSLS final histopathology), we found that the preSLS neck staging, based on computed tomographic (CT) scanning of the neck, was significantly associated with the negative/positive postSLS status of nodal metastasis (P = .006). Of 29 patients staged preSLS as N-0, 28 (97%) patients did not have nodal metastasis on their postSLS final pathology (negative predictive value = 97%, confidence interval, 82.2-99.9). PreRT neck staging, preRT and preSLS staging of the primary tumor, along with laryngeal subsite involvement (supraglottis, glottis, subglottis) did not significantly correlate with the status of neck metastasis on final postSLS histopathology (P = .68, 0.78, 0.49, and 0.42, respectively). None of the 34 patients had any neck tumor recurrence in the postSLS follow-up period (median, 3 yr). In addition, all 17 patients who underwent SLS without neck dissection were staged N-0 both before RT as well as preSLS, and none developed neck disease in the postSLS follow-up period (median, 2.5 yr). CONCLUSION: Management of the neck in patients undergoing salvage total or supracricoid laryngectomy for laryngeal cancer recurrence/persistence after primary RT should be based on the preSLS CT staging of the neck. Patients staged N-0 preSLS are not likely to harbor occult nodal metastasis and therefore may not require elective neck dissection.     

Preliminary multi-institutional prospective pathologic and molecular studies support preservation of sublevel IIB and level IV for laryngeal squamous carcinoma with clinically negative neck

Level II–IV selective neck dissection, often performed bilaterally, has become the procedure of choice for elective dissection of the clinically negative (N0) neck in the treatment of laryngeal cancer. The most significant morbidity of this procedure is dysfunction of the accessory nerve, incurred by the necessity of mobilization and retraction of the nerve in order to remove the contents of sublevel IIB. Other morbidity includes possible injury to the phrenic nerve and chylous fistula. These complications are associated with the dissection of level IV. A number of prospective multi-institutional studies of the distribution of cervical lymph node metastases in the neck indicate that lymph nodes in sublevel IIB and level IV are rarely involved in cases of laryngeal cancer with N0 neck. Information was obtained by the study of neck dissection specimens by conventional light microscopy, and by molecular analysis of the specimens. Molecular analysis reveals a significant number of metastases that are not discovered by light microscopy, and is thus essential for this type of evaluation. The authors conclude that these preliminary studies indicate that it is safe and appropriate to eliminate dissection of sublevel IIB and level IV from the elective neck dissection performed for laryngeal cancer with N0 neck. This practice will reduce both operating time and morbidity, particularly accessory nerve dysfunction, without compromising the oncologic result. Further prospective studies are needed to confirm these conclusions.