足板小孔与大孔开窗镫骨切除术的远期效果比较

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the postoperative long-term hearing results of small fenestra stapedectomy versus large fenestra techniques. METHODS: A retrospective review of 102 ears of 94 patients who had stapedectomy (small fenestra technique) performed by the same surgeon between 1972-1990 was conducted. Patients undergoing stapedectomy and stapedotomy were followed for 6.4 +/- 2.2 and 6.6 +/- 3.0 month in initial postoperative and 14.5 +/- 3.0 and 7.4 +/- 2.2 years in late postoperative, respectively. RESULTS: There were no statistically significant differences in initial or late postoperative pure-tone (PTA), PTA air-bone gap, speech reception threshold (SRT) between the two groups. Ears treated by stapedotomy showed statistically better initial postoperative air-conduction threshold and initial 4-KHz air-bone gap closure, but the gap difference was not significant with late follow-up. The successful outcomes in both groups were stable over long-term follow-up. Results were the same when comparing the two procedures in the patients having undergone both. CONCLUSIONS: These results show that, in the operation of an experienced surgeon for otosclerosis, either large or small fenestra technique provides satisfactory and stable long-term results.     

不同术式治疗耳硬化症的疗效比较

目的：比较治疗耳硬化症不同术式的疗效。方法：回顾性分析1993～2005年行手术治疗且资料完整的耳硬化症患者70例（76耳）的临床资料，按术式分为3组：镫骨全切除术30例（33耳），足板小孔开窗术24例（27耳）和镫骨撼动或提高术16例（16耳），统计3组患者术后各频率段气骨导差闭合、骨导损失及眩晕发生率等指标，比较3种术式问的差异，同时比较镫骨撼动术5例（5耳）与镫骨提高术11例（11耳）2组手术亚型间的疗效差异。结果：3种术式术后言语频率气骨导差闭合无明显差异，但在高频气骨导差改善及减少术后高频感音神经性听力损失和眩晕方面，足板小孔开窗术和镫骨撼动或提高术明显优于镫骨全切除术，并有统计学意义。镫骨撼动术与镫骨提高术无论在听力改善或术后并发症发生率方面差异均无统计学意义。结论：3种术式在提高耳硬化症患者的听力方面均具有较好的疗效，其中以足板小孔开窗术疗效最佳，其次是镫骨撼动或提高术，并且在减少术后并发症方面均优于镫骨全切除术。足板小孔开窗术是治疗耳硬化症较理想的术式。     

Vein versus tragal perichondrium in stapedotomy.

OBJECTIVE: To assess, in otosclerosis surgery, whether the vein or the tragal perichondrium in stapedotomy with interposition yields the better long-term hearing outcome. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective chart review of prospectively collected audiometric data of 452 ears. SETTING: Academic tertiary otology-neurotology referral center. PATIENTS: Four hundred fifty-two stapedotomies with interposition were performed in 412 patients (bilateral in 40 patients) by the senior author (R.C.) between 1987 and 1998. A tragal perichondrium graft was used in 314 cases and a vein graft was used in 138 cases as sealing material of the oval window. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Audiometric data were recorded at 4 months, at 1 year, and at 3 years after surgery after American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery guidelines, except for thresholds at 3 kHz, which were not available and which were replaced with those at 4 kHz. RESULTS: There were no significant intergroup differences in initial or late postoperative hearing outcome with regard to change in the pure-tone average bone conduction and air-bone gaps, or sensorineural hearing loss. Ears treated with a vein graft showed statistically better postoperative 2-kHz air-bone gap closure (p =0.0157), but the pure-tone average air-bone gap difference was not significant. Postoperative air-bone gap closure to within 10 dB was achieved in 91% of cases in the vein group and in 76% of cases in the perichondrium group. Specific study of the bone conduction level at 4 kHz showed a sensorineural hearing loss greater than 10 dB in 8% of cases in the vein group and in 11% of cases in the perichondrium group. One case of complete sensorineural hearing loss was observed with a tragal perichondrium graft (0.22%). CONCLUSION: These results suggest that the vein should be preferred to the tragal perichondrium in stapedotomy with interposition.     

Short- and long-term results of stapedotomy and stapedectomy with a teflon-wire piston prosthesis

We analyzed the results of 604 cases of primary stapes surgery performed between 1974 and 1997 with replacement of the stapes by a 0.6- or 0.8-mm Schuknecht Teflon-wire piston. At long-term follow-up (1 to 21 years; mean, 7 years), the residual air-bone gap was 10 dB or less in 79% of the cases. The hearing results and postoperative complications were comparable to those reported by authors who used the same evaluation criteria. Although the aim of the surgery was to perform a small stapedotomy with a narrow footplate perforation (0.8 mm), a large stapedotomy or a stapedectomy was performed in 134 cases (22.2%) because of surgical or anatomic conditions. Our results show that the larger footplate perforations allowed a better correction of the air-bone gap at the lower frequencies. The ears with larger perforations did not show a higher incidence of sensorineural hearing loss.     

Eliminating the Limitations of Manual Crimping in Stapes Surgery? A Preliminary Trial with the Shape Memory Nitinol Stapes Piston

OBJECTIVE: Manual piston malcrimping in stapedotomy may be the major cause of the occurrence of the significant, interindividual variations of postoperative air-bone gap (ABG), air-bone gap closures (ABGC), and postoperative recurrences of conductive hearing loss. To eliminate the effects of manual crimping on stapedotomy outcomes, the self-crimping, shape memory alloy Nitinol stapes piston was investigated and hearing evaluated. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective, preliminary case-control study in a tertiary care referral center. METHODS: Sixteen patients with otosclerosis undergoing reversed stapedotomy using the Nitinol stapes piston were matched to reference patients out of our conventional titanium piston database. The effects of the self-crimping Nitinol piston on the postoperative ABGC, the postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) variations, and the postoperative short-term hearing results were investigated 3, 6 and 9 months postoperatively. These data were statistically compared with the results of the control patients in our titanium stapes piston database. RESULTS: The mean postoperative ABG and the interindividual variations of the postoperative ABG were significantly smaller in the Nitinol group, the extent of ABGC greater in the Nitinol piston group, but not significant. The postoperative short-term stability of ABGC was similar in both groups. No infections or adverse reactions occurred during follow-up. CONCLUSION: Our preliminary results suggest that the self-crimping shape memory alloy Nitinol stapes piston eliminates the limitations of manual malcrimping in stapedotomy, thus optimising the surgical procedure. This allows reliable, safe, and consistent air-bone-gap closure in patients with otosclerosis up to 1 year after surgery.     

Clinical results after stapedotomy: a comparison between the erbium: yttrium-aluminum-garnet laser and the conventional technique.

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to assess whether the use of the erbium: yttrium-aluminum-garnet (Er:YAG) laser has negative effects on inner ear function and to compare the short- and long-term hearing outcome of patients undergoing conventional stapedotomy versus laser stapedotomy. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective review of prospectively collected audiometric data of patients with otosclerosis operated on by one experienced surgeon. SETTING: Academic tertiary referral center. PATIENTS: A total of 266 stapes surgeries were evaluated for intraoperative findings, of which 209 patients were evaluated for preoperative and postoperative hearing thresholds after a 6- to 452-week (mean, 22 wk) audiological follow-up. INTERVENTION: One hundred fifteen (43%) of the operations were performed conventionally, using manual perforators for stapedotomy (Group A); in 115 (43%) surgeries, the perforators were used in combination with the Er:YAG laser (Group B), and in 36 (14%) operations, the Er:YAG was used exclusively for footplate perforation (Group C). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Pure-tone audiometry was performed before surgery, 2 days postoperatively (bone conduction only) and at 5, 26, and 57 weeks postoperatively. RESULTS: A postoperative temporary threshold shift of the bone conduction could be found in all groups. In Group C, where the laser was used exclusively for footplate perforation, this threshold shift was not only the most significant, but also-in contrast to the other groups-not totally reversible. In all techniques, a satisfactory air-bone gap closure could be achieved. The best long-term results (96% of the patients had 相似文献   

Congenital stapes ankylosis: study of 28 cases and surgical results

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to analyze functional results after stapes surgery in patients with congenital nonprogressive conductive deafness resulting from an isolated fixation of the stapes according to age and surgical procedure. STUDY DESIGN: The authors conducted a retrospective case series from March 1993 to December 2003 in patients from two tertiary referral centers. METHODS: Twenty-eight patients were operated on by stapedotomy or partial stapedectomy using Teflon stapes prostheses. The median age at surgery was 14.2 years (range, 8.3-29.1 years). Main outcome measures were clinical and audiometric evaluation before and after surgery. Mean air conduction (MAC) and bone conduction (MBC) thresholds were recorded at 0.5, 1, 2, and 4 kHz. The evaluation of functional outcome was based on the MAC gain, the MBC comparison, and the mean postoperative and residual air-bone gaps. RESULTS: The median preoperative MAC was 50 dB (range, 19.0-65.0 dB) with a 35.0 dB median dB air-bone gap. With a mean follow up of 19 months, postoperative hearing improvement was statistically significant: median gain of 32.5 dB (P<.001) and median residual air-bone gap of 3.5 dB. The MBC was also statistically improved with median pre- and postoperative MBC of 11.5 and 6.5 dB, respectively (P<.001). Results were not dependent on the age group or type of surgery (stapedotomy or partial stapedectomy). No perceptive hearing loss was observed despite one gusher case. CONCLUSION: Surgical treatment of isolated congenital stapes ankylosis allows good functional results regardless of age or type of surgery.     

Role of stapes surgery in improving hearing loss caused by otosclerosis

The aim of our study was to evaluate the functional results of stapes surgery and to compare the effectiveness of small fenestra stapedotomy with that of total stapedectomy in improving hearing in patients affected by otosclerosis. Three hundred and fifty-seven consecutive ears, in 265 patients affected by otosclerosis, underwent surgery. All cases underwent either primary small fenestra stapedotomy (group A, 196/357, 54.91 per cent) or stapedectomy (group B, 161/357, 45.09 per cent). After surgery, 256/357 (71.71 per cent) cases showed a 0-20 dB gap. There were no significant differences in hearing results between the two groups at either early or late post-operative assessment. The mean post-operative pure tone average and air-bone gap results were slightly greater for group B than for group A, at both early and late post-operative assessments, but these differences were not statistically significant. Therefore, in group A, the mean pure tone average at 4 kHz significantly improved, from 56.60 to 47.66 dB at early post-operative assessment and to 52.98 dB at late post-operative assessment. Our study suggests that the technique of microtomy of the oval window is able to improve hearing results especially at high frequencies.     

Hearing outcome following laser-assisted stapes surgery

This article reports the postoperative results of 76 operations addressing otosclerosis. All procedures were performed by the same surgeon and took place within a 4-year period. We compared the postoperative audiometric results of 54 laser-assisted procedures with those of 22 nonlaser operations. Our findings revealed a statistically significant improvement in the air-bone gap closure of the laser-operated patients: the air-bone gap was narrowed to within 10 dB in 72% of laser-operated cases versus 54% in nonlaser cases. Furthermore, laser use does not induce high-frequency sensorineural hearing loss. We believe that a laser entails less risk of inner ear microtrauma and improves the accuracy and reliability of stapedotomy.     

Stapedotomy technique and results: Ten years' experience and comparative study with stapedectomy

Fifty of the 810 patients who underwent stapedotomy for otosclerosis from 1969 through 1988 were randomly chosen for follow-up of at least 5 years. Most of the patients (65%) had follow-ups of 10 years after stapedotomy, but another 50 patients who underwent stapedectomy had follow-ups of longer than 10 years. In 50 patients, stapedectomy under local anesthesia was performed by removal of the footplate of the stapes, using an endaural incision, and covering the oval window with Gel-foam®. In the other 50 patients, stapedotomy was performed under general anesthesia, using an endopreauricular incision, making a small hole in the footplate, and covering the hole only with blood from the surgical area. Although both groups showed improvement in hearing after the operation, the air-bone gap in the stapedotomy group was significantly better than that in the stapedectomy group. The use of the endopreauricular incision under general anesthesia was preferable to endaural incision under local anesthesia because the operative field was wider, more convenient for the surgeon, and conducive to patient safety. There were no significant complications in either group. Our experience suggests that stapedotomy is the procedure of choice for otosclerosis.     

Experience with stapedectomy in a developing country: a review of 200 cases

Since stapedectomy was first performed in 1956, many innovations have been described. We retrospectively analyzed 200 cases of stapedectomy that had been performed with standard otologic instruments. Of the 200 patients, 54 (27.0%) had significant sensory deafness associated with footplate fixation. In most cases, the footplate was partially removed (stapedotomy group); in the remainder, the footplate was removed in its entirety or subtotally (stapedectomy group). Of the 200 patients, 163 were available for short-term follow-up. The air-bone gap was closed to within 10 dB in roughly 83% of both groups. Although long-term follow-up was possible in only a limited number of cases, we believe that an experienced otologist working with standard equipment and a basic operating microscope can obtain satisfactory stapedectomy results with minimal complications.     

Stapedectomy following tympanoplasty.

The aim of this study was to evaluate the success of stapedectomy in patients who have previously had a tympanoplasty because of chronic otitis media (COM). Fourteen patients from a private otology practice had undergone tympanoplasty for COM and subsequently underwent stapedectomy. Measurements were taken of the air-bone gap (ABG) closure and pure tone average (PTA) which showed hearing improvement. Patients had a mean 36.9 dB PTA hearing gain with 79 per cent closing the ABG to within 20 dB. The need for stapedectomy alone is a rare occurrence for patients with a history of COM requiring a tympanoplasty. Hearing improvement following stapedectomy in these cases was significant, although somewhat less than following traditional stapedectomy in otosclerosis alone.     

Argon laser stapedotomy

Lasers have been used in otology for 10 years. There have been reports of excellent hearing results using laser energy in surgery for otosclerosis. We used the argon laser in 75 consecutive primary stapedotomy procedures. The postoperative air-bone gap was 10 dB or less in 87% of patients and 20 dB or less in 95%. One ear (1.5%) had no postoperative hearing secondary to a granulomatous reaction. Complications were otherwise uncommon and mild. Most patients were treated on an outpatient basis. Our results compare favorably with other reports of laser surgery for otosclerosis. We conclude that excellent hearing results can be obtained using the argon laser for stapedotomy procedures.     

A review of 308 cases of revision stapedectomy

Objective/Hypothesis: Identify causes of primary and revision stapedectomy failure in 308 patients, assess whether these are different based on source of initial surgery, and evaluate hearing results in revision stapedectomy to improve outcome. Study Design: Retrospective, nonrandomized chart review of patients undergoing revision stapedectomy in a referral otology practice in a large metropolitan region. Materials and Methods: Intraoperative findings, preoperative and postoperative revision stapedectomy air and bone conduction pure-tone averages, speech discrimination scores, postoperative air-bone gaps, complications, and repeated revisions were noted in 308 patients. Results: Leading causes of primary stapedectomy failure included dislocated prosthesis (24.4%), inadequate prosthesis length (14%), long process resorption (14%), and fibrous adhesions (13.6%). Revision stapedectomy air-bone gaps were less than 10 dB in 80% and greater than 30 dB in 6.8% of cases. Increased sensorineural hearing loss occurred in 0.8% of revision stapedectomy cases. Five of seven cases of vertigo associated with primary stapedectomy resolved after revision surgery. Conclusion: Revision stapedectomy by experienced surgeons is highly effective in attaining successful air-bone gap closure in 80% and improved closure in 84.8% of operative cases. Risk of vertigo and/or sensorineural hearing loss was not any higher in this patient population when compared with reports of primary stapedectomy.     

An analysis of the air-bone gap closure obtained by a crimping and a non-crimping titanium stapes prosthesis in otosclerosis

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the hearing results of stapes surgery with two different titanium stapes prostheses. A crimping and a non-crimping prosthesis. METHODS: Retrospective analyses were carried out on the pre- and postoperative hearing results obtained after 126 primary stapedotomies with two different prostheses in patients with otosclerosis. Sixty-three patients had a stapedotomy with a K-piston Titanium (No. 1006107) type and 63 patients received a CliP-piston àWengen Titanium (No. 1006807) type after stapedotomy. The results were compared according to mean audiometrical parameters. A Chi-square Test analysis (a contingency table) was performed with odds ratio to analyze this retrospective case-control study. RESULTS: The hearing results of both titanium stapes prostheses were comparable. There was no difference in the final hearing results between the two pistons studied. No statistically significant difference between the postoperative air-bone gap closures by the two titanium stapes prostheses studied could be demonstrated. CONCLUSIONS: Because of the different properties of the two titanium piston studied (CliP-piston àWengen Titanium type, no crimping and K-piston Titanium crimping necessary) a difference in the closure of the air-bone gap could be suspected. This comparative study could not demonstrate a statistical better air-bone gap closure for one of the titanium pistons. Both stapes prostheses showed good results in reconstruction of the hearing loss due to otosclerosis.     

Long term outcome of otosclerosis surgery

The treatment of otosclerosis is eminently surgical. Good immediate results have been well documented when stapedotomy or stapedectomy are chosen.Objectives: This study aims to assess long term audiometric performance after otosclerosis surgery.Materials and Methods: this retrospective study enrolled stapedotomy and partial stapedectomy patients seen at our service with proven hearing improvement after surgery. Forty-one patients (47 ears) accepted the invitation to be reassessed. Audiometry results before and immediately after surgery were compared.Results: the median late follow-up was 11 years. To this date, 49% of the patients had normal hearing or mild dysacusis. Preoperative, postoperative, and late postoperative bone and air pure tone averages were 64.4 and 27.0 dB, 35.6 and 22.3 dB, and 44.1 and 29.5 dB respectively.Conclusion: Otosclerosis surgery offers good long term results. Despite the worsening of thresholds, the level of hypacusis ten years after surgery is lower than the levels observed before surgery.     

Stapedectomy in the Pediatric Patient

The purpose of this study was to evaluate and compare the results of stapedectomy in pediatric patients with otosclerosis and tympanosclerosis. A retrospective review of 14 patients (15 ears) who underwent stapedectomy from 1993 to 1995 was conducted. In 5 ears stapedectomy for tympanosclerosis was performed; 9 patients had otosclerosis and 1 had Treacher Collins syndrome. Patients were evaluated for preoperative and postoperative air-bone gaps, preoperative and postoperative speech reception thresholds, postoperative air conduction hearing improvement, and preoperative and postoperative speech discrimination. Children with otosclerosis who underwent stapedectomies had an average postoperative airbone gap of 16 dB with an average air conduction hearing improvement of 17.6 dB. Children with tympanosclerosis who underwent stapedectomies had an average air-bone gap of 14 dB with an average air conduction hearing improvement of 28 dB. Stapedectomy is a safe and effective treatment for otosclerosis and tympanosclerosis in pediatric patients.     

Stapedectomy in Patients With Small Air-Bone Gaps

Controversy exists concerning stapedectomy for patients with small air-bone gaps. The purpose of this study was to examine the results for patients who had a stapedectomy to correct a small (10 dB or less) air-bone gap. One hundred fifty-four patients with suspected otosclerosis were explored and a stapedectomy was performed in 136 (88.3%) of these cases. The mean pure-tone average (PTA) improved 16.7 dB and overclosed the preoperative bone conduction PTA by 8.1 dB. The majority of the stapedectomy patients (89.7%) had a PTA closure greater than or equal to 0 dB. These results showed that stapedectomy can be an effective procedure for eliminating and overclosing even small air-bone gaps due to otosclerosis.     

Otosclerosis surgery: hearing results and complications

A retrospective study was made of 183 stapedectomies performed at the Santiago de Compostela Hospital from 1989 to 1996. Sixty-seven percent (67.3%) of patients were women and 32.7% were men. Good results were obtained in 87% of cases (79% had an air-bone gap closure difference under 10 dB, and 8% 10-20 dB). Ten pefect had not change in air threshold and the rest deteriorated. There were no significant differences between stapedectomy and stapedotomy. The 4. 000-Hz improvement obtained was inferior to those in 500, 1,000 and 2,000 Hz. In 8.7% of patients with obliterated footplate, heaving outcome was significantly worse. In patients with exposed or overhanging facial nerve, floating footplate, middle ear fibrosis, and necrosis of the long incus process had better results. Total sensorineural hearing loss occurred in 1.1% of cases.     

Surgical treatment of tympanosclerosis

OBJECTIVE: To report the hearing results of the surgical treatment of tympanosclerosis. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective review of surgically treated cases of tympanosclerosis. SETTING: A tertiary referral center. PATIENTS: One hundred fifteen patients with middle ear tympanosclerosis operated on between 1987 and 1996, with an average age of 36 years (range 18-59 years). Cases were classified into four groups according to Wielinga and Kerr. Those with an associated cholesteatoma were excluded. INTERVENTION: Depending on the ossicular status, either mobilization of the major ossicles or epitympanic bypass procedure, mobilization of the stapes or stapedectomy. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The postoperative pure-tone average was compared with the preoperative levels by use of conventional audiometry. The air-bone gap was measured. RESULTS: The average postoperative air-bone gap was 18.0+/-10.21 dB in the type II group (attic fixation of the malleus-incus complex with a mobile stapes). 21.8+/-9.5 dB in the type III group (mobile malleus-incus complex, if present, with stapes footplate fixation), and 22.92+/-10.03 dB in the type IV group (fixation of both the stapes footplate and the malleus-incus complex). Patients with a fixed malleus and mobile stapes had significantly better hearing results than those with stapes fixation (p = 0.042, Mann-Whitney U test). CONCLUSION: In ossicular attic fixation, atticotomy and mobilization of ossicles yielded better results than did the epitympanic bypass procedure. The difference, however, did not reach statistical significance. Patients with fixed stapes treated with stapedectomy displayed good hearing results immediately after surgery, but the air-bone gap deteriorated after some time.