Testosterone and erectile dysfunction

Aging is associated with a decline in several important health factors in men, including libido. Serum testosterone concentrations also decrease with age, and many age-related clinical features are closely associated with androgen deficiency, including erectile function (ED). Approximately 70% of ED is of organic origin, with the major risk factors being diabetes mellitus, hypercholesterolemia, smoking and chronic medical illnesses. These are also established risk factors for atherosclerosis, which is the predominant predisposing factor of vasculogenic ED. The introduction of phosphodiasterase-5 (PDE-5) inhibitors for the treatment of ED made a significant impact both in terms of clinical efficacy, and increasing the awareness of the condition. In spite of this, some patients fail to respond to PDE-5 inhibitors alone. Both animal and clinical studies indicate that testosterone therapy improves both erectile function and the response to PDE-5 inhibitors in patients with ED and hypogonadism. Indeed, interventional studies demonstrate that testosterone replacement therapy improves erectile function in hypogonadal men who have previously failed to respond to PDE-5 inhibitors alone. Furthermore, it has been demonstrated that the full therapeutic potential of PDE5 inhibitors will only become manifest in a eugonadal state. Recent studies have demonstrated a close relationship between testosterone and ED and suggest that testosterone therapy may be a valuable option for an increasing number of affected men. European guidelines recommend that all men presenting with ED should have their testosterone concentrations measured.     

Synergetic effect of testosterone and phophodiesterase-5 inhibitors in hypogonadal men with erectile dysfunction: A systematic review

Testosterone deficiency seems to impair the clinical response to phophodiesterase-5 (PDE-5) inhibitors in patients with erectile dysfunction (ED). In hypogonadal men, testosterone repletion was associated with enhanced sexual function in patients who failed initial treatment with sildenafil or tadalafil. We conducted a systematic review of studies that evaluated combination therapy of testosterone and PDE-5 inhibitors in patients with ED and low, low-normal testosterone levels who failed monotherapy. The studies we examine are heterogeneous with several methodological drawbacks and that, overall, the addition of testosterone to PDE-5 inhibitors might benefit patients with ED associated with testosterone <300 ng/dL (10.4 nmol/L) who failed monotherapy. Further studies, with a randomized placebo-controlled and double blind design, are needed to describe the appropriate target patient group, testosterone cut-off and to define the optimal dose and duration of combination therapy.     

Hypogonadism and erectile dysfunction: the role for testosterone therapy

The role of low testosterone levels in erectile dysfunction (ED) remains unclear. Both organic and psychogenic factors contribute to ED, with vasculogenic causes being the most common etiology. Approximately 10-20% of patients with ED are diagnosed with hormonal abnormalities. At the physiologic level, two second messenger systems are involved in mediating erections, one involving cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) and the other involving cyclic guanosine monophosphate (cGMP). PDE5 inhibitors such as sildenafil promote the cGMP pathway, while alprostadil affects the cAMP pathway. Evidence is strong that, in animal systems, testosterone has direct effects on erectile tissue. However, although testosterone clearly has an impact on libido in humans, its effect on penile function is less clear. Evaluation of ED includes medical, sexual, and psychosocial history assessments, as well as laboratory tests to check for diabetes and hormonal abnormalities. Initial interventions should involve correction of potentially reversible causes of ED, such as hypogonadism. First-line therapy for other patients is typically oral PDE5 inhibitors, such as sildenafil, tadalafil, or vardenafil. For patients who fail treatment with PDE5 inhibitors, local therapies such as intracavernous alprostadil are highly successful. Recent data also support the success of combination therapy with sildenafil and testosterone. This opens the possibility of other combinations of testosterone and other treatments of ED. The ability to exploit multiple pathways in the physiologic processes leading to erection may help improve therapy for ED.     

How to optimise treatment of erectile dysfunction above and beyond the beneficial effects of a phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitor

The introduction in 1998 of the phosphodiesterase type 5 (PDE-5) inhibitors has changed the landscape of diagnosis and, in particular, the treatment of erectile dysfunction (ED). It has paved the road for a more profound insight into ED. ED and other ailments of elderly men, such as atherosclerosis, hypertension, diabetes mellitus and lower urinary tract symptoms were usually regarded as distinct diagnostic/therapeutic entities, but there is growing evidence that they are interrelated and are factors in ED. To optimise the treatment of ED, an integral approach to the health of the ageing male is required. There is an interdependence between the metabolic syndrome, ED and patterns of testosterone in ageing men. The main features of the metabolic syndrome are abdominal obesity, insulin resistance, hypertension and dyslipidaemia, significant factors in the aetiology of erectile function. The metabolic syndrome is associated with lower-than-normal testosterone levels. Testosterone is a determinant of glucose homeostasis and lipid metabolism. Testosterone is not only a factor in libido but also exerts essential effects on the anatomical and physiological substrate of penile erection. With these recent insights, the health problems of elderly men must be placed in a context that allows an integral approach. While PDE-5 inhibitors are the mainstay of treatment of men with ED, treatment of testosterone deficiency is becoming part and parcel of a new approach to both ED and the metabolic syndrome. The diagnostic work-up of ED should comprise measurement of plasma testosterone. If proven deficient, treatment with testosterone is indicated.     

Sexual functions of men with obstructive sleep apnoea syndrome and hypogonadism may improve upon testosterone administration: a pilot study

This study examined 72 patients with obstructive sleep apnoea syndrome (OSAS), confirmed by polysomnography. Thirty-two patients were suffering from erectile dysfunction (ED) assessed by IIEF-5 questionnaires and confirmed by nocturnal penile tumescence examination. Their testosterone levels were measured. Eight patients had normal testosterone levels and were treated with a PDE-5 inhibitor (vardenafil) only; after 6 months of treatment, 6 of these patients (75%) showed significant improvement in erectile function. The remaining 24 patients with OSAS, ED and hypogonadism (total testosterone <12 nmol l⁻¹), were divided into two groups based on the indication for continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) therapy: five patients received CPAP therapy (group 1) and 19 patients did not (group 2). The patients of group 2 received only a PDE-5 inhibitor (vardenafil 20 mg) for ED; and eight patients (42%) showed an improvement after 3 months of treatment. The five patients receiving CPAP therapy were treated with a combination of parenteral testosterone undecanoate and a PDE-5 inhibitor (vardenafil) and all had normal erectile function after 3 months of therapy. The results suggest positive effects of addition of testosterone to treatment with PDE-5 inhibitors in hypogonadal men with OSAS, which should be confirmed in larger controlled studies.     

Testosteron und erektile Dysfunktion

Primary hypogonadism represents a classic but rare cause of erectile dysfunction (ED) in men. Therapy with testosterone as monotherapy is therefore unlikely to cure ED in the typical ED patient. However, recent developments indicate a much greater role of testosterone in erectile function than has been supposed in the past. Serum testosterone levels decline in men with increasing age. Aging men might develop late-onset hypogonadism (LOH) associated with characteristic symptoms. Typical symptoms of LOH are represented by decreased libido and sexual function, osteoporosis, altered distribution of body fat, overall reduction in physical strength, and alterations in the general mood. Experimental and clinical studies over the last few years have also pointed out that hypogonadism results in characteristic alterations of the erectile tissue of the penis. These alterations might be reversible in response to hormone therapy with testosterone. Particularly testosterone might be a helpful supportive therapy in cases where PDE-5 antagonists have tended to lose their effectiveness on the erectile tissue in the treatment of ED.     

The relationship between hypogonadism and erectile dysfunction

It is well known that testosterone enhances sexual interest leading to an increased frequency of sexual acts and an increase in the frequency of sleep-related erections. However, it has little effect on fantasy- or visually induced erections. Exact contribution to erection from testosterone in men remains unclear. Animal studies have well demonstrated that testosterone plays critical physiological (activity of nitric oxide synthases and phosphodiesterases), biochemical (through an endothelial-independent pathway and adrenergic tonicity) and structural (change of fibroelasticity and hollow cell accumulation) roles in erectile function. The supplementation of testosterone to castrated animals can restore erectile function. Clinically, reports of patients with erectile dysfunction (ED) combined with hypogonadism who receive testosterone therapy have inconsistent results. However, testosterone may ameliorate the expression of the phosphodiesterase-5 (PDE5) inhibitor, and the use of testosterone in conjunction with the PDE5 inhibitor revealed convincing results. Because of potential risks in clinical use, testosterone therapy should be individualized, carefully considered and closely monitored, especially, in patients with possible occult prostate cancer, and large benign prostatic hyperplasia. Lower urinary tract symptoms might be worsened by this treatment, since the prostate is an androgen-dependent tissue.     

Current approaches to erectile dysfunction and testosterone deficiency

Androgens are essential for the development of the penis and it is well known that testosterone play a critical role in the physiology of erectile function. From animal studies, testosterone insufficiency disrupts cellular-signaling pathways and induces pathologic alterations in penile tissues leading to erectile dysfunction. In human, the testosterone threshold for maintaining erection is low which explains the reason why some contracted men still have an erection due to the androgens produced by the adrenal gland. Testosterone alone can improve erectile function in hypogonadic patients. Associated with PDE5-I, testosterone supplementation is a treatment for the hypogonadic patients non responders to therapy. The article reviews the different aspects of the testosterone role in the pathophysiology of erection.     

Testosterone and Erection: Practical Management for the Patient with Erectile Dysfunction

Although erectile dysfunction (ED) and testosterone deficiency syndrome are two independently distributed disorders, there is a degree of overlap between them. Testosterone replacement therapy, either alone or combined with other treatments such as a phosphodiesterase type 5 (PDE5) inhibitor, may therefore be useful in some men with ED. Corrective treatment of ED includes sex therapy, risk factor modification, chronic usage of PDE5 inhibitors, and testosterone replacement. Studies have shown that testosterone replacement in men with hypogonadism improves libido and erectile function in a significant proportion of cases. If corrective treatment fails or is not indicated, symptomatic treatments such as oral PDE5 inhibitors or intraurethral/intracavernous therapy are available. PDE5 inhibitors are an excellent first-line choice, although a significant proportion of men still fail to respond to monotherapy. Testosterone deficiency may be overlooked in some men with ED and, because this may be associated with lower expression of PDE5 in the penis, it could result in failure of PDE5 inhibitor therapy. Recent recommendations, therefore, suggest the need for combination therapy in some patients. In conclusion, all men presenting with ED should have their testosterone levels checked, and testosterone replacement should be considered in those with low levels. Testosterone replacement should also be considered in hypogonadal men with ED not responding to PDE5 inhibitors. If erections remain insufficient after 3 mo, a combination of testosterone and a PDE5 inhibitor may be beneficial.     

Testosterone and erectile dysfunction

The role of testosterone on sexual desire, interest and motivation is well established, but its effects on erectile function remain controversial. Animal data show that experimental or medical castration results in loss of the intracavernosal pressure, smooth muscle/connective tissue balance, and penile tissue concentration of nitric oxide synthase-containing nerves, which alter the fibroelastic properties of penile tissue compliance, leading to veno-occlusive dysfunction and therefore erectile dysfunction. Castration also induces apoptosis of penile erectile tissue, and new DNA synthesis is induced by treatment with testosterone. In an animal model of venogenic erectile dysfunction, intracavernous vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), in addition to testosterone, restores the smooth muscle/connective tissue balance, endothelial cell hypertrophy and hyperplasia and normalizes the diameter of the dorsal nerve fibres, thereby preventing veno-occlusive dysfunction. There is some evidence that treatment with testosterone may be beneficial to men with erectile dysfunction who have low baseline testosterone levels. Androgens may also control the expression and activity of phosphodiesterase type-5 (PDE-5) in the penile corpus cavernosum. Oral drug therapy with PDE-5 inhibitors fails in some patients with erectile dysfunction. However, when testosterone is used together with a PDE-5 inhibitor, sexual function is restored in these patients, creating the potential for pharmacological combination therapy with testosterone for the treatment of erectile dysfunction.     

The role of testosterone in erectile function and dysfunction

Erectile response is centrally and peripherally regulated by androgens. Severe hypogonadism in men usually results in loss of libido and potency which can be restored by androgen administration.It was originally thought that androgens exert their effects on libido and that effects on erections were secondary to effects on libido. It is now clear that androgens are necessary for the maintenance of the anatomical and physiological substrate of erections. Restoring testosterone levels to normal is required in cases of erectile dysfunction.It was long assumed that sexual functions required androgen levels below or at the low end of reference values of testosterone. It is now clear that there are individual differences while the threshold increases with aging.The administration of PDE-5-inhibitors is not always sufficient to restore erectile potency in men, and administration of testosterone improves the therapeutic response to PDE-5-inhibitors considerably.Erectile dysfunction is strongly age-related, and it is evident that its etiology is multi-factorial. It is intriguing that testosterone is interrelated with a number of etiological factors such as obesity, diabetes mellitus and atherosclerosis.     

Androgen deficiency in the etiology and treatment of erectile dysfunction

The evaluation and management of erectile dysfunction (ED) has evolved dramatically following the introduction of oral phosphodiesterase-5 inhibitors. Despite the limited role of directed diagnostic testing in the evaluation of the impotent patient, routine de-termination of a serum testosterone likely is indicated based on evidence that testosterone modulates erectile function, that hypogonadism is prevalent among elderly men and men with ED, and that symptomatology alone rarely detects hypogonadism. Forms of testosterone commonly used include oral, parenteral, transdermal, and implantable preparations, each with significant advantages and disadvantages. The risks and benefits of testosterone supplementation have been characterized incompletely and will require further validation before widespread use of testosterone as hormone replacement therapy in aging men.     

Erectile dysfunction, testosterone deficiency, metabolic syndrome and prostatic disease in Taiwan

The purpose of this article is to review the current status and associations between erectile dysfunction (ED), testosterone deficiency (hypogonadism), the metabolic syndrome (MS) and prostatic disease in Taiwan. The prevalence of ED among Taiwanese men older than 40 years was 17.7%, and self-reported ED was lower than International Index of Erectile Function (IIEF)-5 defined ED. Phosphodiesterase type 5 (PDE-5) inhibitors are the first line treatment, but intracavernosal injection and penile prosthesis still have their place. The serum total testosterone (TT) level showed a decline with age, and is one of the major factors that reduces quality of life (QoL). Testosterone deficiency and hypogonadism are associated with ED, which can be improved by testosterone replacement. The MS was reported to have a prevalence of 14–16% in Taiwanese men, and was associated with an increase in all-cause and cardiovascular disease (CVD) mortality. It was also reported to be associated with hypogonadism and ED. The incidence of prostate cancer (PCa) has been rapidly increasing, and its management has also been changing in Taiwan. In conclusion, we need to pay more attention to men's health in Taiwan.     

Erectile dysfunction and treatment of carcinoma of the prostate

Prostate cancer is the leading malignancy in men in the United States and causes more than 60,000 deaths annually. Treatment of prostate cancer, whether it be with surgery, radiation therapy, cryotherapy, or medical treatment, is associated with significant life-altering morbidity. Incontinence and erectile dysfunction (ED) too often are sequelae of these treatment alternatives. ED can be a significant complication and can alter the life of the patient with prostate cancer and his partner. Newer modifications of the radical prostatectomy with nerve-sparing techniques are the cornerstone of erection preservation. Time following radical prostatectomy has been shown to increase erectile function such that more patients have functional erections at 3 years than 1 year after surgery. With the advent of phosphodiesterase-5 (PDE-5) inhibitors, many men can have improved functional erections and return to active coitus. Prevention of ED also is an important management technique. Evidence is gathering that prophylaxis with regular vasoactive injection or daily PDE-5 agents may be an integral part of preservation of corpus cavernosum smooth muscle function. Combination medical therapy and surgical penile prosthesis implantation also are options for patients who do not respond to oral PDE-5 inhibitors.     

Combined use of androgen and sildenafil for hypogonadal patients unresponsive to sildenafil alone

To investigate the therapeutic effect of androgen on hypogonadal patients unresponsive to sildenafil alone. In total, 32 hypogonadal patients with erectile dysfunction (ED), initially had an inadequate response to sildenafil (100 mg). Oral testosterone undecanoate (Restandol, 80 mg, bid or tid) alone was supplied for 2 months, and if patients could not achieve a satisfactory erection, combined use of testosterone and sildenafil was continued thereafter. Total testosterone (TT), free testosterone (FT), and the parameters of the International Index of Erectile Function (IIEF), International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS), and uroflow rate (UFR) were assessed. Eleven patients (34.3%) achieved satisfactory erectile function after testosterone replacement only. Another 12 (37.5%) patients experienced satisfactory intercourse after combined therapy. Serum TT and FT levels significantly increased after the use of testosterone alone (415+/-163 vs 220+/-101 ng/dl, P<0.01; 10.4+/-4.6 vs 5.1+/-1.9 ng/dl; P<0.01, respectively) and the combined use of testosterone and sildenafil (498+/-178 vs 220+/-101 ng/dl, P<0.01; 11.7+/-4.6 vs 5.1+/-1.9 ng/dl, P<0.001, respectively); as did the IIEF score (14.8+/-6.8 vs 12.6+/-7.5, P<0.01, 17.5+/-5.2 vs 12.6+/-7.5, P<0.001, respectively). However, no statistical differences were demonstrated for IPSS or UFR. In conclusions, one-third of hypogonadal patients with ED who failed to respond to sildenafil, responded to testosterone alone, another third responded to sildenafil again after normalization of testosterone. So, in hypogonadal patients with ED, androgen supplementation is first-line therapy. If patients are unresponsive to androgen alone or sildenafil alone, combined use may improve erectile function and enhance the therapeutic effect of PDE-5 inhibitors.     

Vardenafil: A new approach to the treatment of erectile dysfunction

Vardenafil is a phosphodiesterase type-5 (PDE-5) inhibitor developed as an oral therapy for erectile dysfunction (ED). Multiple phase 3 clinical trials have been completed and vardenafil is expected to launch worldwide in 2003. Two pivotal, randomized, double-blind, multicenter studies have evaluated the use of vardenafil in men with ED. Vardenafil improved the rate of achieving and maintaining an erection during sexual intercourse. Improvement also was noted in other aspects of sexual function, including confidence, orgasmic function, and overall satisfaction. Vardenafil produces clinically and statistically significant improvements in erectile function regardless of age, baseline severity, and etiology and is efficacious for the treatment of ED in diabetic and postprostatectomy patients. Vardenafil has a rapid onset of action and completion of successful sexual intercourse is possible for some patients 16 minutes after its administration. Twenty milligrams of vardenafil has sustained long-term efficacy by providing up to 92% of patients with improved erections during more than 2 years of treatment. Vardenafil is well tolerated, with an adverse event profile typical of the class of PDE-5 inhibitors. The most common adverse events were headache, flushing, rhinitis, and dyspepsia, which were mild or moderate and generally decreased with continued treatment. Vardenafil may be associated with transient reductions in blood pressure and commensurate increases in heart rate, with the overall incidence of cardiovascular-related adverse events similar to that of placebo.     

Recent insights into androgen action on the anatomical and physiological substrate of penile erection

Erectile response is centrally and peripherally regulated by androgens.The original insights into the mechanismsof action of androgens were that androgens particularly exert effects on libido and that erections in response to eroticstimuli were relatively androgen-independent.It was shown that sexual functions in men required androgen levels atthe low end of reference values of testosterone.So it seemed that testosterone was not useful treatment for men witherectile difficulties,particularly following the advent of the phosphodiesterase type 5(PDE5)inhibitors.However,approximately 50% of those treated with PDE5 inhibitors discontinue their treatment.A number of recent develop-ments shed new light on testosterone treatment of erectile dysfunction(ED)in aging men.(1)A recent insight is that,in contrast to younger men,elderly men might require higher levels of testosterone for normal sexual functioning.(2)Several studies have indicated that PDE5 inhibitors are not always sufficient to restore erectile potency in men,andthat testosterone improves the therapeutical response to PDE5 inhibitors considerably.(3)There is growing insightthat testosterone has profound effects on tissues of the penis involved in the mechanism of erection and that testoster-one deficiency impairs the anatomical and physiological substrate of erectile capacity,reversible upon androgenreplacement.The synthesis of PDE5 is upregulated by androgens,and the arterial inflow into the penis is improved bygiving androgen.The above invites a re-examination of the merits of giving testosterone to aging men with ED.Thebeneficial effects of PDE5 inhibitors may only be optimally expressed in a eugonadal environment.(Asian J Androl2006 Jan;8:3-9)     

The costs of caring for erectile dysfunction in a managed care setting: evidence from a large national claims database

PURPOSE: We examined the direct costs of erectile dysfunction (ED) empirically. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A naturalistic cohort study was done in 285,436 patients with ED and 51 health plans that covered 28 million lives nationwide from 1999 through 2001. Based on claims that had an ED related diagnosis code, procedure code or medication code we categorized the cost structure of ED care and calculated the annual costs of ED care per patient with ED, per user and per member monthly for individual and for all categories of ED care. RESULTS: A patient with ED in a health plan spent about an average of 83.91 dollars in 1999, 95.41 dollars in 2000 and 119.26 dollars in 2001 for ED care. In 2001, 37.08% of ED care costs per patient with ED were spent on phosphodiesterase type 5 (PDE-5) inhibitor therapy, 14.36% were spent on physician office visits, 10.19% were spent on diagnosis procedures, 8.45% were spent on testosterone hormone therapy, 3.85% were spent on penile prosthesis implantation, 4.41% were spent on intracavernous injection, 2.68% were spent on alprostadil pellet insertion and 0.81% was spent on vacuum erection devices. Of the 7 commonly used ED treatments PDE-5 inhibitor therapy has the lowest annual cost per user. CONCLUSIONS: In 2001 ED imposed a 122,669 dollars annual burden to a health plan with 100,000 members, that is or 0.108 dollars per member monthly. Each patient with ED spent 119.26 dollars annually for all ED related services or treatments. Of the 7 commonly used treatments PDE-5 inhibitor therapy had the lowest annual cost per user.     

Diagnosis of hypogonadism in patients treated with low energy shock wave therapy for erectile dysfunction: a narrative review

Several methods of treatment of erectile dysfunction (ED) are offered with low energy shock-wave therapy (LESWT) gaining increasing attention. Reports have documented that LESWT stimulates tissue neovascularization, proliferation and differentiation of endothelial cells, and production of nitric oxide - all can improve the condition of erectile tissue. However, the overall and sexual condition of men deteriorates with age which is linked with a constant decrease in testosterone concentration. A higher risk of sexual health disorders and reduced physical fitness correlates with a testosterone concentration of <12 nmol/L. Such patients may require testosterone replacement therapy. We conducted a target literature review to investigate whether testosterone concentration is taken into account in studies on the use of LESWT in the treatment of ED. We found that most studies did not provide any information on testosterone status. Only 8 of 25 studies examined showed values of testosterone concentrations. Only one of these analyses checked the relationship between the efficacy of LESWT and testosterone concentration. As a result, meta-analyses published to date may not show the full value of LESWT in the treatment of ED. We conclude that in the light of the significant role testosterone plays in the process of an erection and the mechanism of LESWT action, it can be recommended to examine testosterone concentration and to diagnose hypogonadism during the qualification of patients to studies on LESWT efficacy. Moreover, the effectiveness of LESWT in relation to the current testosterone concentration should also be further investigated.     

A Critical Analysis of the Role of Testosterone in Erectile Function: From Pathophysiology to Treatment—A Systematic Review

Context

Androgen modulation of erectile function (EF) is widely accepted. However, the use of testosterone replacement therapy (TRT) in men with erectile dysfunction (ED) has generated an unprecedented debate.

Objective

To summarize the relevant data on the incidence, diagnosis, and management of ED coexisting with hypogonadism and to develop a pathophysiology-based treatment algorithm.

Evidence acquisition

We reviewed the relevant medical literature, with a particular emphasis on original molecular studies, prospective observational data, and randomized controlled trials performed in the past 20 yr.

Evidence synthesis

Testosterone modulates nearly every component involved in EF, from pelvic ganglions to smooth muscle and the endothelial cells of the corpora cavernosa. It also regulates the timing of the erectile process as a function of sexual desire, coordinating penile erection with sex. Epidemiologic studies confirm the significant overlap of hypogonadism and ED; however, most guidelines do not consider the differential diagnosis of hypogonadism or the relevance of subclinical disease. Various clinical tools can help the physician to assess and restore androgen levels in men with ED. Special attention is given to fertility-sparing treatments, due to the increasing number of older men desiring fatherhood. The simultaneous use of phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitors (PDE5-Is) and TRT has recently been questioned. Originally proposed as a salvage therapy for nonresponders to PDE5-Is, this approach has been inappropriately transformed into a combination therapy. Clinical data are consistent when reinterpreted in the proper framework, whereas molecular evidence remains controversial.

Conclusions

A body of molecular and clinical evidence supports the use of TRT in hypogonadal patients with ED, although the benefit–risk ratio is uncertain in advanced age. Critical appraisal of this evidence enabled the development of a pathophysiology-oriented algorithm designed to avoid inappropriate treatments and support whether to start with TRT, PDE5-I only, or both. Apparently divergent findings are reconciled when TRT is correctly indicated. An improved diagnosis and individualized management is desirable in light of the many available options.