Breast and cervical cancer screening for women with mental illness: patient and provider perspectives on improving linkages between primary care and mental health

Summary Objective: Previous research suggests that women with mental illness may be at increased risk for breast and cervical cancer. This qualitative study of patients and primary care and mental health providers explored challenges to accessing and providing breast and cervical cancer screening for women with mental illness. Method: Key informant patient and provider participants were recruited from a community health setting and teaching hospital. Narrative data from 1) interviews with women in a community primary care setting (n = 16); 2) telephone interviews with women with mental illness (n = 16); and 3) focus groups with primary care providers (n = 9) and mental health providers (n = 26) were collected. Results: Patient, provider, and system factors that may contribute to suboptimal cancer screening among women with mental illness were identified. Communication between primary care and mental health providers was noted as a key area for intervention to enhance screening. Barriers to and possibilities for a more proactive role for mental health providers were also considered. Conclusions: Both patient and provider study participants emphasized the need to address communication gaps between primary care and mental health providers and to promote the active collaboration of mental health providers in preventive cancer screening for women with mental illness.     

Nursing Homes as Primary Care Sites for Psychological Practice

Speer and Schneider (2003 ; this issue) reviewed the literature on the mental health needs of older adults in primary care sites. Their conclusions are especially salient for the nontraditional nursing home primary care setting. Health care providers in nursing homes must routinely address multiple psychiatric and medical comorbidities. Most nursing home medical directors have limited training in psychological issues resulting in few mental health referrals. Psychologists have sparse research findings to guide their practice due to lack of inclusion of nursing home residents in research studies. The need to implement a multidisciplinary approach is essential in nursing home primary care settings.     

Bringing Psychotherapy to Primary Care: Innovations and Challenges

[Clin Psychol Sci Prac 17: 191–214, 2010] The segregation of mental health treatment and primary medical care in our health care system is increasingly recognized as anachronistic, as a majority of patients with psychosocial problems are turning to primary care providers. Accordingly, the development and dissemination of evidence‐based psychotherapeutic interventions compatible with the constraints of primary care is becoming increasingly urgent. This article discusses the importance of finding feasible ways to bring psychotherapy to primary care, examines interventions either specifically adapted for primary care or consistent with its constraints, assesses the compatibility of these interventions with the primary care environment, considers barriers inhibiting the widespread integration of such interventions into primary care, and discusses future directions.     

The role of coping in depression treatment utilization for VA primary care patients

Objective

To examine the impact of Veterans’ coping strategies on mental health treatment engagement following a positive screen for depression.

Methods

A mixed-methods observational study using a mailed survey and semi-structured interviews. Sample included 271 Veterans who screened positive for depression during a primary care visit at one of three VA medical centers and had not received a diagnosis of depression or prescribed antidepressants 12 months prior to screening. A subsample of 23 Veterans was interviewed.

Results

Logistic regression models showed that Veterans who reported more instrumental support and active coping were more likely to receive depression or other mental health treatment within three months of their positive depression screen. Those who reported emotional support or self-distraction as coping strategies were less likely to receive any treatment in the same time frame. Qualitative analyses revealed that how Veterans use these and other coping strategies can impact treatment engagement in a variety of ways.

Conclusions

The relationship between Veterans’ use of coping strategies and treatment engagement for depression may not be readily apparent without in-depth exploration.

Practice implications

In VA primary care clinics, nurse care managers and behavioral health providers should explore how Veterans’ methods of coping may impact treatment engagement.     

Integration and coordination of pain management in primary care

Pain is one of the most common symptoms reported to primary care providers and has significant implications for health care costs. The primary aim of this article is to describe and illustrate how to integrate the treatment of chronic pain in the primary care setting. First, we address the integration and coordination of care between mental health and primary care. We then present a typical case and discuss the patient's treatment, outcome, and prognosis. The article concludes with a discussion of issues that frequently arise when integrating psychological treatment for pain in primary care settings.     

汶川地震受灾地区灾后社区、乡镇卫生院工作者精神卫生服务能力评估

目的:了解汶川受灾地区社区、乡镇卫生院工作者的精神卫生知识掌握情况及精神卫生服务能力,为精神卫生培训提供依据,为我国精神卫生服务体系建设提供科学参考。方法:选取灾后社区、乡镇卫生工作者心理卫生服务技能培训班学员353名为研究样本,回收有效问卷313份。使用自编精神卫生知识评估问卷和精神卫生服务调查表进行评估。自编精神卫生知识评估问卷包含抑郁症、酒精依赖、精神分裂症(阳性症状为主)、创伤后应激障碍和躯体形式障碍5种精神障碍。结果:受灾地区乡镇、社区卫生院工作者对于社区5种精神障碍准确诊断率最高的案例为抑郁症(77.0%),药物处理中位数得分最高的为酒依赖;非药物处理中位数得分最高的是酒依赖和创伤后应激障碍。培训前1月内报告未接诊过精神障碍患者的社区、乡镇卫生院工作者占53.4%。不知道任何1所精神卫生服务机构的卫生院工作者占35.1%;不知道精神科专科会诊的占37.7%;不能邀请精神科专科会诊的占39.6%。结论:汶川地震后,受灾地区的乡镇、社区卫生院工作者精神卫生知识和技能掌握较少,精神卫生服务能力相对弱。     

Meeting the Mental Health Needs of Older Adults in Primary Care: How Do We Get the Job Done?

Most elderly persons in the United States with mental health problems such as depression receive no attention or care. Those who receive treatment generally do so in primary care settings, where disorders like depression have a hard time competing with other common and chronic medical problems. Typically, mental illnesses are under-recognized and under-treated in elderly persons attending primary care clinics. The experience of the PROSPECT (Prevention of Suicide in Primary Care Elderly: Collaborative Trial) study is briefly described, indicating that depression, for example, can be treated successfully in primary care elderly using the type of multidisciplinary collaborative care model advocated by Speer and Schneider (2003 ; this issue). The challenge now facing all of us is to create a consumer- and family-driven demand for good mental health services in geriatric clinics and a political consensus to reimburse such services fairly. Recent improvement in Medicare reimbursement for mental health services to victims of Alzheimer's dementia provides a basis for hope.     

“One end has nothing to do with the other:” Patient attitudes regarding help seeking intention for depression in gynecologic and obstetric settings

Many women rely on their obstetrician/gynecologist (OB/GYN) as their primary contact with the health care delivery system. There have been few studies exploring patient views on getting help for depression from these providers. The purpose of this study is to assess help seeking intention for depression and identify beliefs which moderate this intention. Telephone interviews of women following a routine gynecologic visit or in the immediate postpartum period (regarding prenatal care) were used to assess intention to seek help from their providers in a case of depression. For women who lacked this intention, related beliefs were elicited with the open ended question “why not?” Among the 225 women in the study more than half receiving gynecologic care (59%) and nearly a third of women who received prenatal care (29%; p?相似文献   

A randomised controlled trial to test the feasibility of a collaborative care model for the management of depression in older people

BACKGROUND: Depression is the most common mental health disorder in people aged over 65 years. Late-life depression is associated with chronic illness and disability. AIM: To investigate the feasibility of a collaborative care model for depression in older people in a primary care setting. DESIGN OF STUDY: Randomised controlled trial with 16-weeks follow up. SETTING: A primary care trust in Manchester. METHOD: Participants were 105 people aged 60 years or older who scored 5 or more on the Geriatric Depression Scale; 53 were randomly allocated to an intervention group and 52 to a usual care group. The intervention group received care managed by a community psychiatric nurse who delivered an intervention comprising a facilitated self-help programme with close liaison with primary care professionals and old-age psychiatry according to a defined protocol. The usual care group received usual GP care. A nested qualitative study explored the views of the health professionals and patients regarding the acceptability and effectiveness of the intervention. RESULTS: The main outcome measure was recovery from depression. Patients in the intervention group were less likely to suffer from major depressive disorder at follow up compared with usual care (0.32, 95% confidence = interval = 0.11 to 0.93, P = 0.036). The qualitative component of the study demonstrated the acceptability of the intervention to patients. CONCLUSION: A model of collaborative care for older people with depression, used in a primary care setting with a facilitated self-help intervention is more effective than usual GP care. This study demonstrates that the implementation of a collaborative care model is feasible in UK primary care and that the intervention is effective and acceptable to patients.     

Psychologists Entering Primary Care: Manhattan Cannot Be Bought for $24 Worth of Beads

Speer and Schneider's review (2003 ; this issue) illustrates a number of problems in psychologists' understanding of elderly primary care (PC) patients and their providers, as well as the context of PC. Claims that elderly patients overutilize health services and do so primarily because of mental health problems are not well founded. Older PC patients also face practical and preference barriers to accepting conventional psychological treatment The evidence that psychological services provide cost offset is questionable, and cost offset is not the best way of evaluating the value of psychological services. Rather than as frontline providers, psychologists' best prospects for an expanded role in PC is in the design, supervision, and evaluation of augmented services in this setting.     

Developing and Implementing Randomized Effectiveness Trials in General Medical Settings

This article discusses the development of two mental health services research programs: one targeting depression treatment in primary care and the other early intervention for posttraumatic stress disorders in acute care. Both programs have used the randomized effectiveness trial to assess the delivery of empirically supported psychotherapeutic and psychopharmacologic interventions in these general medical settings. This article explores the fellowship training, clinical experiences, and conceptual frameworks that have informed the progression of the two research programs. Specific modifications to the traditional randomized clinical trial design employed in the effectiveness trials are discussed. This article concludes with reflection on intervention development trajectories and interdisciplinary team compositions that may facilitate the development of mental health interventions that both derive from the best scientific evidence and can be feasibly delivered in real-world treatment settings.     

Preferences for relational style with mental health clinicians: a qualitative comparison of African American, Latino and Non-Latino White patients

The goal of this study is to analyze preferences for relational styles in encounters with mental health providers across racial and ethnic groups. Four primary themes describe what patients want from a mental health provider: listening, understanding, spending time, and managing differences. However, using contextual comparative analysis, the findings explicate how these themes are described differently across African Americans, Latinos, and non-Latino Whites, uncovering important qualitative differences in the meaning of these themes across the groups. The article suggests that closer attention to qualitative preferences for style of interaction with providers may help address disparities in mental health care for racial and ethnic minorities.     

A Little Effort Can Withstand the Hardship: Fielding an Internet-Based Intervention to Prevent Depression among Urban Racial/Ethnic Minority Adolescents in a Primary Care Setting

Background

This study explored the implementation of Chicago Urban Resiliency Building (CURB), a randomized clinical trial designed as an Internet-based primary care depression prevention intervention for urban African American and Latino adolescents.

Suicide prevention in late life: directions for science and practice

Suicide among the elderly is a critical public health problem, yet there remains limited information on risk factors to target due to the few number of controlled studies that could help isolate and focus on the most potent risk factors. We suggest that because there are no proven, effective interventions showing reduced suicidal behaviors in older adults, the best current approach is to improve detection and treatment of later-life depression. This effort may be especially effective in primary care settings, where the majority of our nation's elderly seek and receive their mental health care. We review approaches to assessment and treatment of later life depression that seem most relevant for later life suicide prevention. Testing and determining whether these treatment approaches are effective is an immediate goal on the path to advancing the science and practice of late-life suicide prevention.     

Striking a balance: Health care providers’ experiences with home-based,patient-centered care for older people—A meta-synthesis of qualitative studies

ObjectiveThe aim of this article was to synthesize research findings about health care providers’ experiences of patient-centered care in the home setting.MethodsThis is a meta-synthesis of qualitative findings using the analytical method of meta-ethnography developed by Noblit and Hare. We performed a systematic literature search in seven databases and assessed potential studies against eligibility criteria and quality. Subsequently, 10 primary studies were included for analysis.ResultsThe core theme “being a balance artist” emerged from the synthesis, incorporating the participants’ experiences when faced with conflicting and competing responsibilities and needs. Two subthemes—“balancing the older clients’ needs against organizational demands” and “balancing the older clients’ needs against professional standards”—further elaborated on this core theme.ConclusionHealth care providers’ experiences indicate that organizational factors play a crucial role in shaping the conditions for patient-centered care for older people in the home setting.Practice implicationsTo motivate and facilitate health care providers to move to a more patient-centered practice, it is important to expand the values of patient-centered care beyond the clinical encounter into the organization.     

Major depressive disorder in the African American population

Depression is a common mental disorder that presents with depressed mood. It can become chronic or recurrent and lead to substantial impairment in an individual's ability to function. At this level, it is identified as major depressive disorder (MDD). Depression and MDD occur across all racial and ethnic groups. Although many depressed patients are treated in primary care, depression in these settings has been underdetected and undertreated. African Americans, especially, who suffer from depression are frequently underdiagnosed and inadequately managed in primary care due to patient, physician, and treatment setting factors. Patient factors include being poor, uninsured, restrictive insurance policies, biological-genetic vulnerability, nonresponsiveness to traditional pharmacological interventions, and stigma (i.e., attitudes and perceptions of mental illness). Physician factors include diagnosis and assessment, physician characteristics, physician bias, and culture; and treatment setting factors include systemic variables such as lack of or poor access to health care, racism, environment, and patient management. African Americans are less likely to receive proper diagnosis and treatment, more likely to have depression for long periods of time, and more likely to suffer greater disability from depression. Understanding patient, physician, and treatment setting factors as contributing barriers that impede effective diagnosis and treatment of depression and MDD in African Americans is critical to effective patient management and discovery. Greater African American participation in clinical research trials also is needed to effectively improve, diagnose, and treat depression in African Americans. This article examines depression among African Americans in the context of gender, culture, and psychosocial determinants, and their engagement in clinical trials.     

Psychological Interventions in the Age of Managed Care: A Commentary on Medical Cost Offsets

This article provides a commentary on the Chiles, Lambert, and Hatch (this issue) meta-analytic review of the medical cost-offset literature. Emphasis is placed on the impact of managed care on their findings and on the field. Under conditions of closely monitored and/ or restricted care, cost offsets may be more difficult to achieve. Moreover, recent research indicates that specialty care for mental health may be more costly than management by primary care physicians. However, specialty care is associated with more optimal outcomes and greater cost-effectiveness. Attention to the value of care (cost-effectiveness) will help ensure that psychological interventions compete well in current fiscal environments.     

Depressed mothers coming to primary care: maternal reports of problems with their children

BACKGROUND: Studies of depressed mothers have generally been conducted in psychiatric settings with non-minority, middle-class women. Primary care has an increasing role in early detection and treatment, especially for the poor who have less access to specialized mental health services. Data on the relationship between maternal depression and problems in the offspring in a primary care context could help physicians to more effectively identify children in need of psychiatric help. METHODS: All mothers aged 25 to 55 from a systematic sample of consecutive adults (response rate, 80%) in an urban general medicine practice were screened using the PRIME-MD Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ). Mothers who screened positive for major depression (n=85); other psychiatric disorders, but not major depression (n=67); or no psychiatric disorders (n=191) were compared on their children's history of emotional problems, unmet need for mental health treatment, parent-child discord, maternal functional status and mental health treatment. RESULTS: Compared to non-psychiatric controls, depressed mothers reported a three-times greater risk of serious emotional problems in their children (95% confidence interval [CI], 1.7-6.1); a four-times greater risk of having their children's problems left untreated (95% CI, 2.3-8.2), and a 10-times greater risk of having poor mother-child relations within the past month (95% CI, 3.9-29.4). Depressed mothers reported more functional disability, more psychiatric treatment and more problems in their offspring than mothers with non-depressive psychiatric disorders. Although a majority of mothers (regardless of psychiatric status) believed that counseling (96%) or medication (84%) should be offered to those with serious emotional problems, only about half (49%) of the depressed mothers had received mental health treatment in the past month. LIMITATIONS: Children were not assessed directly. CONCLUSIONS: The children of low-income depressed women at a general medicine practice were reported to have a greatly increased risk for emotional problems. Many mothers had not received treatment for their own emotional problems. By enquiring about the emotional health of children of adult primary care patients, primary care providers have an opportunity to promote early detection and to facilitate appropriate treatment for both the mothers and their children.     

Implementing the role of the primary care mental health worker: a qualitative study

BACKGROUND: Primary care mental health workers are a new role recently introduced into primary care in England to help manage patients with common mental health problems. AIM: To explore the views of GPs, primary care teams and patients on the value and development of the new role of primary care mental health workers in practice. DESIGN OF STUDY: Qualitative study. SETTING: The Heart of Birmingham Primary Care Teaching Trust in the West Midlands, UK. METHOD: Thirty-seven semi-structured interviews involving seven primary care mental health workers, 21 patients and 11 focus groups involving 38 members of primary care teams were held with six teams with a worker. Two teams asked for the worker to be removed. Six practice managers also took part in the study. RESULTS: A number of different approaches were used to implement this new role. Strategies that incorporated the views of primary care trust senior management, primary care teams and workers' views appeared most successful. Rapid access to a healthcare professional at times of stress and the befriending role of the worker were also highly valued. Workers felt that their role left them professionally isolated at times. A number of workers described tension around ownership of the role. CONCLUSION: Primary care mental health workers appear to provide a range of skills valued by patients and the primary care teams and can increase patient access and choice in this area of health care. Successful implementation strategies highlighted in this study may be generalisable to other new roles in primary care.