Clinical significance of fetal heart rate patterns during labor. I. Baseline patterns.

From a population of 2,774 high-risk patients monitored during labor, 1,304 single pregnancies in cephalic presentation and with direct monitoring for at least 1 hour before completion or cesarean-section were studied. The maternal and fetal clinical data and the tracings were hand reviewed, coded, and programmed for computer analysis. In the record were studied baseline, its changes (tachycardia, fixed, saltatory), the accelerations, and the decelerations (early, variable, late). Fifty-four per cent had some type of FHR deceleration. Accelerations were recorded in over 12 per cent of all cases and were associated with cord problems in 41 per cent. Subgrouping the patients by age of gestation (less than or equal to 36 weeks, 37 to 41 weeks, and greater than or equal to 42 weeks) revealed a 10 per cent prolonged gestation rate and only 6.8 per cent premature; these had a lower 5 minute Apgar score. Fetal weight and age were positively correlated with Apgar score. Baseline changes were much frequent among pre- and postmature infants, particularly tachycardia in the latter (40 per cent). The premature infants had a 25 per cent incidence of fetal distress and the postmature infants had 20 per cent. Neonatal morbidity and mortality rates were very high among premature infants and a mortality rate of 2.3 per cent was found among postmature infants. Saltatory pattern and particularly fixed baseline seem characteristic of prolonged gestation and placental insufficiency. With tachycardia, they constitute subtle symptoms of fetal distress.     

Intrapartum fetal heart rate monitoring. VIII. Atypical variable decelerations

A total of 1,996 fetal heart rate (FHR) tracings were analyzed to assess the prognostic significance of variable decelerations. Nineteen percent (186 cases) of 988 tracings with variable decelerations in the last 30 minutes of monitored labor exhibited signs of atypia listed in order of frequency: (1) loss of initial acceleration, (2) slow return to the baseline FHR, (3) loss of secondary acceleration, (4) prolonged secondary acceleration, (5) biphasic deceleration, (6) loss of variability during deceleration, and (7) continuation of the baseline at a lower level. Variable decelerations with one or more of these features were called atypical variable decelerations and predicted a high incidence of fetal acidosis and low Apgar scores. By contrast, adverse fetal outcome was uncommon with pure variable decelerations (p much less than 0.001) irrespective of the duration and amplitude of the deceleration. Both pure and atypical variable decelerations were associated with other FHR abnormalities in over 60% of the cases. However, the particularly unfavorable combination with decreased FHR variability and tachycardia or bradycardia was seen more frequently with atypical than with pure variable decelerations (p much less than 0.001) and predicted the highest incidence of low Apgar scores. It is concluded that atypical features aid greatly in the identification of distress in fetuses with variable decelerations.     

Clinical significance of fetal heart rate patterns during labor: IV. Agonal patterns

The characteristics of fetal heart rate (FHR) patterns were reviewed in 11 cases where the infants died either intrapartum or within eight hours of birth as a consequence of distress during labor without prior recovery. The neonatal charts and the autopsy reports were also reviewed. The infants were grouped according to gestational age as premature (four), term (four), and postmature (three). Similarities and differences were studied in an attempt to delineate some common underlying factors. The premature fetuses have an extraordinary capacity to withstand clinical signs of severe distress (late deceleration and fixed and tachycardic base line) for many hours until the very moment of death and rarely pass meconium. The term fetuses can withstand less prolonged periods of severe distress, the fixed FHR base line and impressive decelerations preceding immediate death; they consistently passed meconium, three of four had aspirated meconium. All of the postterm fetuses had massive meconium aspiration, but the FHR patterns had a bizarre appearance; several hours before death some late decelerations were followed by tachycardia and fixed base lines but no decelerations. Subsequent occurrence of erratic severe decelerations immediately preceded sudden death. Possible reasons for these different pathophysiologic responses are discussed. In the study of FHR tracings, a variable of utmost importance is chronologic age of gestation. Its value cannot be overemphasized for an accurate interpretation of the fetal condition and good decisions for management.     

A study of variable decelerations in association with other heart rate patterns during monitored labor.

A review of 1,011 consecutive intrapartum heart rate tracings yielded 37.3% with some degree of variable deceleration pattern. No differences in Apgar score distribution were observed in the presence of uncomplicated variable deceleration pattern when compared to those tracings marked normal. However, the presence of variable decelerations in association with other heart rate patterns resulted in lower mean Apgar scores at 1 and 5 minutes, which were significantly different from those of the fetal heart rate (FHR) normal group. Mean Apgar scores at 1 and 5 minutes were significantly different from normal when variable decelerations were noted in the presence of tachycardia and loss of variability. Mean Apgar scores were lower when bradycardia (prolonged episodes of heart rate less than 120 bpm) was present in the record when compared to normal, but the presence of variable decelerations with bradycardia did not result in different mean scores. The presence of baseline changes with loss of variability and variable decelerations appeared to result in the lowest mean scores. When bradycardia or tachycardia occurred in exclusive association with variable decelerations, the percentage of depressed newborn infants was relatively high.     

脐血乳酸水平及胎心监护图形预测胎儿窘迫的价值

目的　探讨新生儿脐动脉血乳酸水平及胎心监护图形预测胎儿窘迫的价值。方法　测定 73例胎心监护图形为不良图形 (胎心基线异常、重度变异减速、轻度变异减速、心动过速 )的新生儿(病例组 )和 118例产前无胎儿窘迫征象 ,出生后 1分钟Apgar评分≥ 9分的新生儿 (对照组 )出生后脐动脉血乳酸水平。结果　病例组中产钳助产率明显高于对照组 (P <0 0 1) ,顺产率低于对照组 (P<0 0 1)。病例组中 ,胎心重度变异减速多发于第二产程 ;胎心基线异常的新生儿Apgar评分≤ 7分的发生率高于重度变异减速、轻度变异减速、心动过速的新生儿 (P <0 0 5 )。病例组中 ,胎心基线异常者脐动脉血乳酸水平为 (4 5 5± 0 2 3 )mmol/L ;重度变异减速者为 (3 84± 0 40 )mmol/L ,出现以上两种图形的新生儿脐动脉血乳酸水平均明显高于对照组 (P <0 0 1)。轻度变异减速者脐动脉血乳酸水平为 (2 63± 0 3 2 )mmol/L ;心动过速者脐动脉血乳酸水平为 (2 5 5± 0 46)mmol/L。并且轻度变异减速与心动过速者脐动脉血乳酸水平与对照组比较 ,差异无显著性 (P >0 0 5 )。结论　测定新生儿脐动脉血乳酸水平是一种有效、准确的诊断胎儿窘迫的方法。胎心基线异常、重度变异减速与胎儿窘迫的发生密切相关 ;轻度变异减速、心动过速与胎     

Intrapartum fetal distress and magnesium sulfate.

OBJECTIVE: Intrapartum fetal distress is an obstetric emergency traditionally managed by immediate delivery by either the vaginal route or cesarean section. However, there is usually time to attempt intrauterine resuscitation. The purpose of this study was to report the utilization of magnesium sulfate for intrauterine resuscitation. METHOD: Twenty-one fetuses received magnesium sulfate 4-g intravenous bolus in mothers awaiting cesarean section for fetal distress in the labor room of the Complejo Hospitalario Metropolitano de la Caja de Seguro Social de Panamá, from March through August 1997. Fetal distress in labor was defined as the presence of repetitive late decelerations, persistent loss of baseline variability, severe variable decelerations, or bradycardia. RESULTS: Twenty-one fetuses received magnesium sulfate 4-g intravenous bolus in mothers awaiting cesarean section for fetal distress. Uterine activity ceased in seven patients, diminished in 13 patients and did not change in one. In all cases, but one, there was recovery of the FHR within 4 min; furthermore there was rose reactive of FHR in nine patients. The 1-min Apgar scores were 7 or above in 18 cases and the 5-min Apgar scores were 7 or above in 20 patients. CONCLUSIONS: In summary, magnesium sulfate may be useful in the management of acute intrapartum fetal distress when there is evidence of increased uterine activity.     

Late second-trimester nonstress test characteristics in preterm delivery before 32 weeks of gestation

OBJECTIVE: To clarify electronic fetal heart rate (FHR) monitoring characteristics in pregnancies with preterm delivery before 32 weeks of gestation, using the late second-trimester nonstress test. METHODS: Among 953 children born from 1993 to 1996, we identified 100 singleton infants born before 32 weeks of gestation in whom second-trimester (24-27 weeks of gestation) electronic fetal monitoring (EFM) records were obtained. Individual components of the FHR patterns [baseline rate, baseline FHR variability, presence of acceleration (at least 10 beats/min for at least 10 s) and periodic or episodic deceleration (at least 25 beats/min for at least 15 s)] and birth characteristics were compared between pregnancy with or without second-trimester decelerations. RESULTS: Among 100 infants, 65 had and 35 did not have second-trimester decelerations. There were no significant differences in gestational age at birth, birth weight, cord arterial blood pH, Apgar score and meconium staining between pregnancies with second-trimester decelerations and those without second-trimester decelerations. There were no significant differences in baseline rate and baseline variability between pregnancies with or without second-trimester decelerations. The number of accelerations in pregnancies with second-trimester decelerations was significantly more frequent than that in pregnancies without second-trimester decelerations (p < 0.001). There was a significant increase in the occurrence of premature rupture of the membranes (PROM; 60.0%) in pregnancies with second-trimester decelerations, when compared with events (37.1%) related to pregnancies without second-trimester decelerations (p < 0.05). There were no significant differences in the onset of breech presentation, cervical incompetency, preeclampsia and abnormal FHR pattern at birth between pregnancies with second-trimester decelerations and those without second-trimester decelerations. Pregnancies with PROM after second-trimester EFM were significantly more likely to have second-trimester decelerations than those without PROM (75.0 vs. 54.2%, p < 0.05). CONCLUSION: Periodic or episodic decelerations during late second-trimester EFM were associated with an increased risk of the occurrence of PROM in pregnancies with preterm delivery before 32 weeks of gestation.     

Comparison of late-second-trimester nonstress test characteristics between small for gestational age and appropriate for gestational age infants

OBJECTIVE: To compare electronic fetal heart rate (FHR) monitoring characteristics between appropriate for gestational age (AGA) fetuses and small for gestational age (SGA) fetuses and to determine whether SGA fetuses have specific abnormalities at second-trimester electronic fetal monitoring (EFM), using nonstress test. METHODS: Among 953 children born from 1993-1996, we identified 500 singleton infants born after 36 weeks' gestation of uncomplicated pregnancies in whom second-trimester (24-27 weeks' gestation) EFM records were obtained. Individual components of FHR patterns (baseline rate, baseline FHR variability, presence of acceleration [at least 10 beats per minute for at least 10 seconds], and periodic or episodic deceleration [at least 25 beats per minute for at least 15 seconds]) and birth characteristics were compared between AGA and SGA infants, or between pregnancies with or without second-trimester decelerations. RESULTS: Among 500 infants, 443 were AGA and 57 SGA; 105 had and 395 did not have second-trimester decelerations. Baseline FHR variability (12.9+/-3.2 beats per minute) in SGA fetuses was significantly higher than variability (10.3+/-3.4 beats per minute) in AGA fetuses (P<.001). Small for gestational age fetuses were significantly more likely to have second-trimester decelerations than AGA fetuses (33.3% vs. 19.4%, P<.05). There were no significant differences in baseline rate and accelerations between AGA and SGA infants. Small for gestational age infants were more frequent in pregnancies with second-trimester decelerations, compared with those without second-trimester decelerations (18.1% vs. 9.6%, P<.05). Baseline FHR variability in pregnancies with second-trimester decelerations was significantly higher than in pregnancies without second-trimester decelerations (12.2+/-3.7 vs. 10.0+/-3.1 beats per minute, P<.001). CONCLUSION: Periodic or episodic decelerations and increased FHR variability during late second-trimester EFM were associated with an increased risk of SGA birth weight.     

II. Multifactorial analysis of intrapartum fetal heart rate tracings.

The first 30 minutes and the last 30 minutes of 1,996 intrapartum FHR tracings were analyzed for baseline FHR, variability (amplitude and frequency of oscillations), accelerations, and decelerations. A modified FHR scoring system incorporating these FHR features was employed. According to the association between various FHR scores and the incidence of low Apgar scores, FHR patterns were grouped into three basic categories with distinct prognostic significance: (1) normal FHR patterns, (2) compensated distress patterns, and (3) decompensated distress patterns. It is concluded that the prognostic significance of FHR tracings is increased by incorporating several FHR monitoring criteria in the analysis.     

Approximate entropy: a regularity measure for fetal heart rate analysis.

Approximate entropy (ApEn), a recently developed mathematical formula quantifying regularity, was applied to fetal heart rate (FHR) data. Three groups were analyzed: 1) 19 women had normal labors (uncomplicated course of labor, vaginal delivery, no unusual FHR tracings, and 1- and 5-minute Apgar scores of at least 7 and 9, respectively; 2) 15 women had presumed fetal distress (severe cord or late decelerations, bradycardia, or tachycardia; delivery by cesarean with both arterial and venous cord pH above 7.20); and 3) 20 women had acidotic fetuses (both venous and arterial cord pH less than 7.20). Hourly mean (+/- SD) ApEn values for the three groups were: acidotic fetuses, 0.924 +/- 0.235, 102 hours; normal fetuses, 1.051 +/- 0.145, 97 hours; and nonacidotic "distressed" fetuses, 1.043 +/- 0.147, 74 hours. The ApEn values for nonacidotic, presumed distressed fetuses were not significantly different from those of normal fetuses (P greater than .75). Acidotic fetuses had many more instances of ApEn hourly values less than 0.8 (28%, 29 of 102) than did the normal and the nonacidotic, presumed distressed fetuses combined (5%, nine of 171). The probability that ApEn was less than 0.8 was larger for acidotic fetuses than for the other groups (P less than .00003), supporting the hypothesis that extremely regular FHR patterns imply a greater likelihood of acidosis. Significant hourly deviations in ApEn generally corresponded to drug administration or to physiologic changes such as cord compression and its relief. Thus ApEn, a major departure from variability statistics, appears to be able to detect subtle and possibly important differences in heart rate that are not visually apparent.     

Deceleration/contraction ratios as an index of fetal health during labor.

Internal FHR tracings of 259 patients with variable decelerations and 49 with late decelerations were analyzed for frequency and severity of the pattern in an attempt to correlate with fetal pH or Apgar score at 1 minute. A significant increase in the risk of fetal acidosis was associated with a frequency of greater than 30% variable decelerations and 20% late decelerations. It also increased with the increase of severity of the pattern. Variable decelerations are not good predictors of Apgar scores less than or equal to 6 at 1 minute, but late decelerations are predictive when they occur more than 20% of the time. The fetus with variable decelerations a normal pH can be observed through the first stage of labor with a high degree of confidence. However, when a 20% or more moderate-to-severe late deceleration/contraction ratio is present, intervention is necessary even if scalp blood pH is normal. The FHR deceleration/uterine contraction (UC) ratio is a simple bedside technique for assessing fetal outcome.     

Mechanisms of late decelerations in the fetal heart rate. A study with autonomic blocking agents in fetal lambs.

Fetal heart rate decelerations resembling the late deceleration FHR pattern were produced in fetal sheep by periodic occlusion of the maternal common hypogastric artery for 30-60 sec. Transient fetal hypertension also occurred during the occlusions. Alpha-adrenergic blockade with phentolamine eliminated or markedly reduced the hypertensive response. FHR decelerations still occurred intermittently with some occlusions; however, their character was greatly altered. After parasympathetic blockade with atropine, the decelerations were replaced by periodic FHR accelerations during the occlusions. These accelerations were, in turn, eliminated by the beta-adrenergic blocking agent, propranolol. In the presence of combined parasympathetic, alpha- and beta-adrenergic blockade, the FHR remained essentially constant during the hypogastric artery occlusions in non-acidemic fetuses. FHR decelerations persisted after parasympathetic or total autonomic blockade when the fetuses were significantly hypoxic, as judged by depressed arterial blood pH and base excess values. Beat-to-beat variability of the baseline FHR persisted in the face of severe hypoxia and acidosis. These observations demonstrate that reflex mechanisms are involved importantly in the genesis of late deceleration FHR patterns in the acutely hypoxemic fetus, but that direct depression of myocardial rhythmicity becomes a factor as hypoxic acidosis develops.     

Is intrapartum vibroacoustic stimulation an effective predictor of fetal acidosis?

OBJECTIVE: The hypothesis of this prospective study is that intrapartum vibroacoustic stimulation (VAS) is an effective predictor of fetal acidosis during labor. Various clinical conditions, such as term versus preterm gestation, first stage versus second stage of labor, and fetal heart rate (FHR) variable decelerations versus late decelerations will be tested. METHODS: During the study period, 113 patients were studied prospectively in either active phase of first stage (n = 53) or during the second stage of labor (n = 60). They were selected from cases exhibiting moderate to severe FHR variable decelerations or late decelerations. The fetuses of study subjects received a VAS for three seconds and FHR changes were recorded. Fetal scalp blood pH or umbilical arterial blood pH was obtained within 15 minutes of VAS. The relationship between FHR responses to VAS and fetal blood pH in term and preterm gestations, the relationship of two tests (VAS and fetal blood pH) to type of FHR decelerations, and the predictability of neonatal morbidity by two tests were analyzed. Where appropriate, Fisher's exact test (p < 0.05 was considered statistically different) and the odd ratio with 95% confidence intervals were used for statistical analyses. RESULTS: Excellent association between acceleration response to VAS and pH > or = 7.20, and between a negative response to VAS (no acceleration or decelerations) and pH < 7.20 were found in the first stage of labor, the second stage of labor, and the combination of both stages together (p = 0.0001, OR = 10.6 [3.3-34.0]). It was observed that negative VAS responses for predicting fetal acidosis (pH < 7.20) were comparable between term (> or = 37 weeks) and preterm (< 37 weeks, > or = 34 weeks) fetuses. Since the preterm fetuses enrolled in the study were limited in number, it is difficult to draw adequate conclusions. The positive predictive value (PPV) of fetal acidosis was 67% in both groups of FHR variable decelerations and late decelerations, but the false negative rate of acceleration VAS response for predicting no acidosis was significantly higher in the group of late decelerations (29% vs 8%, p = 0.034). Finally, both a negative VAS response and fetal acidosis (pH < 7.20) have equal predictability for neonatal morbidity. The PPV of NICU admission by a negative VAS response was two times higher than that of fetal acidosis (PPV = 61% vs 29%, p = 0.038). CONCLUSION: We found that intrapartum VAS was an effective predictor of fetal acidosis in cases of FHR variable decelerations, but its predictability for fetal acidosis in cases of FHR late decelerations was limited. Both VAS and fetal blood pH are good predictors of neonatal morbidity.     

Heart rate patterns in trisomic fetuses

A survey of the clinical records of fifteen fetuses with trisomy 21, six fetuses with trisomy 18, and two fetuses with trisomy 13 was made in order to find out typical patterns of fetal heart rate (FHR) possibly associated with these conditions. Antepartal FHR patterns of 55 normal pregnancies and intrapartal FHR patterns of 14 normal labors were used as a control material. Trisomic fetuses showed significantly fewer FHR accelerations than did the controls. Fetuses with trisomy 18 and 13 had more antepartal decelerations than fetuses with trisomy 21. Trisomic fetuses also showed more intrapartal late decelerations and epochs of silent FHR pattern than did the controls. The abnormal FHR patterns of the trisomic fetuses thus were similar to those in placental insufficiency. Cesarean section was performed for both fetuses with trisomy 13, for five of the six fetuses with trisomy 18 and for nine of fifteen fetuses with trisomy 21. In eleven of sixteen cesarean sections the main indication was abnormal cardiotocogram. Fetal karyotyping from an amniotic fluid sample should perhaps be considered when decelerations and silent patterns of FHR in a growth-retarded, late second or early third trimester fetus are seen. In most cases, however, the decision for optimal management o labor must be based on FHR patterns solely.     

Variables associated with meconium aspiration syndrome in labors with thick meconium

OBJECTIVE: To examine the possible maternal and fetal variables associated with meconium aspiration syndrome in labors with thick meconium. STUDY DESIGN: The fetal heart rate tracings, cord pH, Apgar scores and maternal risk factors were evaluated in singleton pregnancies with vertex presentation and thick meconium in labor. The study included 33 consecutive fetuses which developed a moderate or severe meconium aspiration syndrome and 104 consecutive fetuses which had a favorable outcome. RESULTS: Significant differences between fetuses with meconium aspiration syndrome and healthy fetuses were found in the following parameters: baseline FHR (154+/-17 vs. 136+/-10, P<0.0001), small accelerations/30 min (1.47+/-1.52 vs. 3.04+/-1.2, P<0.0001), large accelerations/30 min (1.46+/-1.96 vs. 3.5+/-2.31, P<0.0003), decelerations/30 min (4.9+/-3.9 vs. 2.4+/-2.1, P<0.0034), number of fetuses with reduced beat-to-beat variability (9/33 vs. 0/104, P<0.0001), cord pH (7.21+/-0.09 vs. 7.33+/-0.08, P<0.0013) and Apgar scores at 1 min (5+/-2 vs. 8+/-1, P<0.0001) and Apgar scores at 5 min (8+/-2 vs. 9.7+/-0.6, P<0.0001). Maternal risk factors were found in two of 33 sick infants and in 13 of 104 healthy infants. CONCLUSION: Thick meconium by itself is not associated with adverse fetal outcome. However, the incidence of meconium aspiration syndrome increases in cases of a non-reassuring FHR.     

Reliability of intrapartum fetal heart rate monitoring in the postterm fetus with meconium passage

Fifty-six postterm fetuses with intrapartum meconium passage underwent routine scalp stimulation and scalp blood sampling. Fetal heart rate (FHR) patterns were compared with blood pH. Nine fetuses (16%) had a scalp pH less than 7.20. Twenty-nine fetuses (54%) demonstrated spontaneous or induced FHR accelerations; none were acidemic. Acidemia with normal variability was found only in conjunction with severe variable decelerations, and may represent respiratory acidosis. In this group, two of nine acidemic fetuses demonstrated no decelerations (pH 7.04) or mild variable decelerations only (pH 7.19). The absence of late decelerations was not as reliable as the presence of accelerations in the prediction of fetal well-being. Thirty-three percent of the fetuses who failed to exhibit spontaneous or provoked FHR accelerations were acidemic. These findings suggest that in this high-risk group of fetuses, the absence of spontaneous FHR accelerations should be followed by an attempt to induce accelerations, scalp pH assessment, or cesarean section.     

Significance of meconium during labor.

Continuous fetal heart rate (FHR) monitoring and routine fetal scalp blood sampling was utilized in the evaluations of 366 fetuses during labor. One hundred and six patients had meconium in the amniotic fluid at some time during labor. A total of 26,110 uterine contractions were monitored during these 366 labors. The incidence of FHR patterns as a percentage of uterine contractions was calculated for the meconium and nonmeconium groups. Although there was a 3 1/2-fold increase in the incidence of low five-minute Apgar scores (less than 7) in the meconium group, signs of fetal distress were, with rare esception, not significantly different from those in the nonmeconium group. The presence of meconium in the amniotic fluid without signs of fetal asphyxia (late decelerations and acidosis) is not a sign of fetal distress and need not be an indication for active intervention. The combination of fetal asphyxia and meconium staining of the amniotic fluid, however, does enhance the potential for meconium aspiration and a poor neonatal outcome. Universal fetal heart rate monitoring and appropriate fetal acid-base evaluation is recommended for following patients with meconium in the amniotic fluid during labor.     

Fetal acidemia and electronic fetal heart rate patterns: is there evidence of an association?

OBJECTIVE: Despite the ubiquity of electronic fetal monitoring, the validity of the relationship between various fetal heart rate (FHR) patterns and fetal acidemia has not yet been established in a large unselected series of consecutive pregnancies. The aim of this study was to examine the published literature for evidence of such a relationship. METHODS: Four hypotheses based on assumptions in common clinical use were examined. The literature was searched for relationships between certain aspects of FHR patterns (e.g., degree of FHR variability, depth of decelerations), and fetal acidemia, or fetal vigor (5-minute Apgar score >or=7). We also attempted to relate duration of these patterns to the degree of acidemia. Using standardized FHR nomenclature we defined patterns based on baseline FHR variability, baseline rate, decelerations, and accelerations. RESULTS: The following relationships were observed: (1) Moderate FHR variability was strongly associated (98%) with an umbilical pH >7.15 or newborn vigor (5-minute Apgar score >or=7). (2) Undetectable or minimal FHR variability in the presence of late or variable decelerations was the most consistent predictor of newborn acidemia, though the association was only 23%. (3) There was a positive relationship between the degree of acidemia and the depth of decelerations or bradycardia. (4) Except for sudden profound bradycardia, newborn acidemia with decreasing FHR variability in combination with decelerations develops over a period of time approximating one hour. Most studies identified were observational and uncontrolled (grade III evidence of US Preventive Services Task Force); however, there was general agreement amongst the various studies, strengthening the validity of the observations. CONCLUSIONS: The validity of the relationship between certain FHR patterns and fetal acidemia and/or vigor, is supported by observations from the literature. In addition four assumptions commonly used in clinical management are supported. These conclusions need to be confirmed by a prospective examination of a large number of consecutive, unselected FHR patterns, and their relationship to newborn acidemia. Pending the completion of such studies, these observations can be used to justify certain aspects of current clinical management, and may assist in standardizing the diversity of opinions regarding FHR pattern management.     

Recurrence of preterm birth in twin pregnancies in the presence of a prior singleton preterm birth

Objective.?Despite the ubiquity of electronic fetal monitoring, the validity of the relationship between various fetal heart rate (FHR) patterns and fetal acidemia has not yet been established in a large unselected series of consecutive pregnancies. The aim of this study was to examine the published literature for evidence of such a relationship.

Methods.?Four hypotheses based on assumptions in common clinical use were examined. The literature was searched for relationships between certain aspects of FHR patterns (e.g., degree of FHR variability, depth of decelerations), and fetal acidemia, or fetal vigor (5-minute Apgar score ≥7). We also attempted to relate duration of these patterns to the degree of acidemia. Using standardized FHR nomenclature we defined patterns based on baseline FHR variability, baseline rate, decelerations, and accelerations.

Results.?The following relationships were observed: (1) Moderate FHR variability was strongly associated (98%) with an umbilical pH >7.15 or newborn vigor (5-minute Apgar score ≥7). (2) Undetectable or minimal FHR variability in the presence of late or variable decelerations was the most consistent predictor of newborn acidemia, though the association was only 23%. (3) There was a positive relationship between the degree of acidemia and the depth of decelerations or bradycardia. (4) Except for sudden profound bradycardia, newborn acidemia with decreasing FHR variability in combination with decelerations develops over a period of time approximating one hour. Most studies identified were observational and uncontrolled (grade III evidence of US Preventive Services Task Force); however, there was general agreement amongst the various studies, strengthening the validity of the observations.

Conclusions.?The validity of the relationship between certain FHR patterns and fetal acidemia and/or vigor, is supported by observations from the literature. In addition four assumptions commonly used in clinical management are supported. These conclusions need to be confirmed by a prospective examination of a large number of consecutive, unselected FHR patterns, and their relationship to newborn acidemia. Pending the completion of such studies, these observations can be used to justify certain aspects of current clinical management, and may assist in standardizing the diversity of opinions regarding FHR pattern management.     

Acute fetal distress

Three different clinical patterns of acute fetal distress may be observed during labor: an ante-partum hypoxia with a persistent nonreactive and "fixed" fetal heart rate (FHR) on admission to the hospital, a progressive intra-partum asphyxia manifested, as the labor continues, by a substantial rise in baseline heart rate, a loss of variability and repetitive severe variable or late decelerations, and finally, as a result of a catastrophic event, a sudden prolonged FHR deceleration to approximately 60 beats per minute lasting until delivery. However the majority of fetuses with nonreassuring tracings of FHR are neurologically intact, as evidenced by the high false-positive rate of electronic fetal monitoring (EFM). Therefore the diagnosis of fetal distress must be corroborated by complementary methods, such as continuous recording of the fetal electrocardiogram or computed-assisted EFM, fetal pulse oximetry or fetal scalp sampling with immediate determination of blood gases or lactates. Defavorable outcome of an acute fetal distress leading to neonatal encephalopathy or death is best predicted by a persisting low Apgar score (<3) for more than 5 minutes and by a severe metabolic acidosis (umbilical artery pH<7,00 and base-excess>-12mmol/l).