High tibial osteotomy alone or combined with ligament reconstruction in anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knees

High tibial osteotomy (HTO) is widely accepted as a treatment option in patients with medial unicompartimental osteoarthritis (OA) and varus morphotype of the knee. We increasingly see younger patients with a chronic anterior instability, an additional varus morphotype and beginning medial OA. Treatment options for these patients are not clear up to now. In this clinical study we compare for the first time three different treatment rationales and introduce a concept of symptom-oriented surgery in young patients with medial OA and chronic anterior instability.Materials/methods: Between 1984 and 1994 30 patients were treated with a medial unicompartimental OA and chronic anterior instability of the knee. Patients were grouped into three different groups according to treatment. 1) only HTO was performed. 2) HTO and simultaneously an ACL-reconstruction and 3) HTO and 6–12 months later an ACL-reconstruction was performed. 27/30 patients were available for follow-up. All patients had an arthroscopy before surgery. Evaluation was done according to the IKDC-protocol and X-ray documentation.Results: Pain was a major problem in all patients. None of them was completely pain-free. 8/27 patients had pain even with light activities. This included 1/11 patients of group 1, 3/8 of group 2 and 4/8 of group 3. 9/27 patients had stable knee joints with a Lachman-test of 3–5 mm. No patient had a Lachman test<3 mm. 3/11 patients of group 1, 3/8 of group 2 and 2/8 of group 3 had a Lachman test of 5–10 mm. A positive pivot-shift could be found in 9/27 patients. 2/11 of group 1, 4/8 in group 2 and 3/8 in group 3. The overall IKDC-score improved in 23/27 patients, one patient remained unchanged, two deteriorated. Radiologically a slight progression of OA could be seen in all patients. Radiological signs of OA and pain did not show any correlation. There was, however, a significant rate of postoperative complications involving 4/11 patients of group 1 and 3/8 of group 3. There were 6 major complications in 5/8 patients in group 2. Nevertheless overall patient satisfaction was high. 25/27 patients would undergo the procedure again.Conclusion: HTO is a good treatment option for younger patients with medial OA and chronic anterior instability of the knee. These patients pose a high challenge to diagnostic and operative skills of the surgeon. Main symptoms of these patients have to be analysed clearly in terms of instability and pain. In patients aged 40 and older an HTO alone is an excellent treatment option with reproducably good results. In younger patients we advise an HTO first. If instability persists, an ACL-reconstruction can be done 6–12 months later. One has to be aware that a simultaneous combined procedure has a significant complication rate. Hence if a simultaneous combined treatment is planned the surroundings including surgical technique, rehabilitation and patient compliance have to be ideal. These young patients need an activity counselling in order to realise that their knee joint has suffered significantly from the injury and ongoing high physical demands on their knee joint.     

Combined ACL reconstruction and closing-wedge HTO for varus angulated ACL-deficient knees

Purpose

To report the medium-term clinical and radiographic outcomes of a group of patients who underwent anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) surgery combined with high tibial osteotomy (HTO) for varus-related early medial osteoarthritis (OA) and ACL deficiency knee.

Methods

Thirty-two patients underwent single-bundle over-the-top ACL reconstruction or revision surgery and a concomitant closing-wedge lateral HTO. The mean age at surgery was 40.1 ± 8.1 years. Evaluation at a mean of 6.5 ± 2.7 years of follow-up consisted of subjective and objective IKDC, Tegner Activity Level, EQ-5D, VAS for pain and AP laxity assessment with KT-1000 arthrometer. Limb alignment and OA changes were evaluated on radiographs.

Results

All scores significantly improved from pre-operative status to final follow-up. KT-1000 evaluation showed a mean side-to-side difference of 2.2 ± 1.0 mm. Two patients were considered as failures. The mean correction of the limb alignment was 5.6° ± 2.8°. Posterior tibial slope decreased at a mean of 1.2° ± 0.9°. At final follow-up, the mechanical axes crossed the medial–lateral length of tibial plateau at a mean of 56 ± 23 %, with only 1 patient (3 %) presenting severe varus alignment. OA progression was recorded only on the medial compartment (p = 0.0230), with severe medial OA in 22 % of the patients. No patients underwent osteotomy revision, ACL revision, UKA or TKA.

Conclusions

The described technique allowed patients with medial OA, varus alignment and chronic ACL deficiency to restore knee laxity, correct alignment and resume a recreational level of activity at 6.5 years of follow-up.

Level of evidence

Case series with no comparison group, Level IV.     

Comparison of augmented and non-augmented anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction combined with high tibial osteotomy

In a follow-up study 27 patients were evaluated after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL-)reconstruction combined with high tibial osteotomy because of chronic rupture of the ACL, cartilaginous lesions of the medial compartment and varus malalignment. They were divided into two groups. In 14 patients (non-LAD group) ACL reconstruction was performed using the central third of the autologous patellar tendon modified according to Eriksson-Trillat. Thirteen patients (LAD group) underwent repair with the same technique, but a Kennedy ligament augmentation device (LAD) in hot dog technique and fixed over the top was added. The postoperative treatment was the same in both groups. All patients were examined according to IKDC criteria. KT-1000 arthrometer testing at maximum manual traction was performed. Although the mean follow-up interval was more than double in the non-LAD group (non-LAD: 127 months vs LAD: 58 months), the subjective and clinical results, IKDC evaluation and KT-1000 arthrometer testing results were similar, showing no statistically significant difference. Further, no complications due to the use of LAD occurred. In this study no evident functional or clinical advantage from the augmentation performed could be shown.Investigation performed at the Department of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery, University Hospital Basle, Switzerland. No benefits in any form have been received or will be received from a commercial party related directly or indirectly to the subject of this article. Funds were received in total or partial support of the research or clinical study presented in this article. The funding sources were SUVA Assurance, Lucerne, and the science fund of the University Hospital Basle     

Anatomical double-bundle anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction after valgus high tibial osteotomy: a biomechanical study

BACKGROUND: Although anatomical double-bundle anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction can successfully restore normal knee biomechanics for knees with typical varus-valgus alignment, the efficacy of the same reconstruction method for knees after a valgus high tibial osteotomy is unclear. HYPOTHESIS: Anatomical double-bundle anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction for valgus knees after a high tibial osteotomy cannot restore normal knee kinematics and can result in abnormally high in situ forces in the ligament graft. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Ten cadaveric knees were subjected to valgus high tibial osteotomy followed by an anatomical double-bundle anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. The valgus knees were tested using a robotic/universal force-moment sensor system before and after the ligament reconstruction. The knee kinematics in response to anterior tibial load and combined rotatory loads, as well as the corresponding in situ forces of the anterior cruciate ligament bundles and grafts, were compared between the ligament-intact and ligament-reconstructed valgus knees. RESULTS: After reconstruction, the anterior tibial translation and internal tibial rotation for the valgus knee decreased approximately 2 mm and 2 degrees , respectively, at low flexion angles compared with those of the anterior cruciate ligament-intact knee (P < .05). The in situ forces in the posterolateral graft became 56% to 200% higher than those in the posterolateral bundle of the intact anterior cruciate ligament (P < .05). CONCLUSION: Performing an anatomical double-bundle anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction on knees after valgus high tibial osteotomy may overconstrain the knee and result in high forces in the posterolateral graft, which could predispose it to failure. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Modifications of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction procedures to reduce posterolateral graft force may be needed for valgus knees after a high tibial osteotomy.     

Fixed tibial subluxation after successful anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction results in improved function and stability in many patients. However, it is not known whether the improved stability is associated with an improved tibiofemoral relationship. We used stress radiographs to determine not only stability but also the tibiofemoral relationship in 15 patients who had a clinically successful anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Their results were compared with those of 14 volunteers with normal knees. The average Lysholm score for the patients was 94. None of the patients had more than 3 mm of side-to-side difference on KT-1000 arthrometer testing. Maximal anteroposterior tibial translation as measured by stress radiography was slightly increased in the reconstructed knees but was not statistically significantly different (6.6 +/- 3.2 mm versus 5.0 +/- 3.3 mm). However, with a posteriorly directed stress the tibia in the reconstructed knees did not translate posteriorly to the same extent as did the control knees, resulting in a significant difference in tibial position (-1.2 +/- 3.0 mm versus -4.0 +/- 3.3 mm). Surgical anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction may result in reduced anteroposterior tibial translation, accomplished, in part, through restraining posterior translation, leaving the tibia with persistent subluxation. Fibrosis and contracture of the posterior structures may explain this phenomenon.     

Arthroscopic cartilage indentation and cartilage lesions of anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knees

BACKGROUND: The anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knee is prone to osteoarthritis and meniscus lesions. Very little, however, is known about the biomechanical properties of articular cartilage in anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knees. PURPOSE: To evaluate biomechanical and macroscopical cartilage changes in the knee joint with respect to the time after anterior cruciate ligament rupture. HYPOTHESIS: Chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficiency induces cartilage softening. STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: Cartilage stiffness of 50 patients undergoing anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery because of symptomatic knee instability after chronic anterior cruciate ligament rupture was measured with an arthroscopic indenter device, and the number and size of cartilage lesions were evaluated. RESULTS: The cartilage stiffness did not correlate with time from trauma to surgery (r = 0.002, P = .99), but the number of cartilage lesions in the knee increased when the time from the initial trauma to reconstructive surgery increased (r = 0.356, P = .011). Indentation values measured on healthy-looking cartilage on damaged joint surfaces were lower than the values measured on healthy joint surfaces (P < .01 on lateral femoral condyle and on tibial plateaus). CONCLUSIONS: The number of cartilage lesions increases with increased time after initial trauma. The arthroscopic indenter device is able to detect cartilage softening as the early mechanical sign of degradation not yet visible to the eye.     

Arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Our understanding of the structure and function of the anterior cruciate ligament has progressed rapidly over the past decade. Arthroscope-assisted anterior cruciate ligament replacement is a new procedure that allows isometric placement of the anterior cruciate ligament graft. Postoperative rehabilitation is enhanced by preservation of the extensor mechanism.     

Gore-Tex prosthetic ligament in anterior cruciate deficient knees

Reconstruction for symptomatic anterior cruciate deficient knees has yielded varying success rates. Prosthetic cruciate replacement has recently become a potentially attractive alternative. The results of the Gore-Tex polytetrafluoroethylene ligament, which is intended as a permanent replacement, are reported. Eighty-two patients were followed prospectively, mean age was 28 years (range, 16 to 51 years) and mean followup was 18 months (range, 12 to 30 months). Subjective scores improved in all categories, including pain, swelling, giving way, locking, and stair climbing. All patients without complications had no episodes of actual giving way, considered themselves improved, and returned to activities of daily living at 3 weeks and athletics at 8 months. Range of motion lacking at 3 months was 2 degrees of extension and 10 degrees of flexion, and at 12 months was 0 degrees of extension and 4 degrees of flexion. All mean objective data, including the anterior drawer, Lachman, and pivot shift, demonstrated improvement at final followup. Cybex testing revealed improvement in relative quadriceps strength from 88% to 99%. The KT-1000 Arthrometer showed improvement in the injured-normal knee difference score throughout the follow-up period. Of importance is that while final objective data was improved over initial data, an early nonprogressive shift toward loosening was indicated by worsening of the drawer, Lachman, pivot shift, and KT-1000 scores. This shift may be attributed to resorption of interposed soft tissue, creep, or loosening of the graft. Subjective scores remained stable after improving. Complications included four ruptures, four chronic sterile effusions with partial attenuation, one infection, and one symptomatic loose body.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction combined with valgus tibial osteotomy (combined procedure)

We assessed the patients who were operated on in a combined procedure from 1980 to 1992 with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) insufficiency, cartilaginous lesions of the medial compartment, lesion of medial meniscus and varus malalignment. The combined operative procedure was autologous intra-articular ACL reconstruction with the middle third of the patellar ligament-partially augmented with Kennedy-ligament augmentation device (LAD) in hot dog technique-and high tibial osteotomy. The patients were examined according to the criteria of IKDC including testing of anterior stability with the KT-1000 arthrometer. Radiographically we checked axis and arthritis according to a modified score of Kannus. Twentyseven of 34 patients who fulfilled the inclusion criteria could be followed up in three categories (2–5 years postoperatively, 5–10 years postoperatively, over 10 years postoperatively). Total qualification was good in 37%; there were no perioperative complications. Rehabilitation was not prolonged. Eighty-nine percent practised their prcoperative job, over 50% had a higher level of sports activities than preoperatively, and more than 25% regained their pretraumatic sports capacity. Two-thirds had no giving way and less than 3 mm translation difference in comparison to the contralateral knee. Seventy-five percent of patients would accept the operation again. Radiological findings had no correlation to overall qualification. The encouraging results with respect to many of the criteria suggest using the combined procedure in a young patient with ACL insufficiency, varus malalignment and medial compartment damage including medial meniscus lesion.     

Clinical significance of altered gastrocnemius muscle coordination in anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knees

In a study of conservatively treated patients with isolated anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) ruptures, 7 patients with good or excellent results (Lysholm score > 84) and 7 patients with poor results (Lysholm score < 64) were compared considering muscle coordination, which was assessed by means of electromyographic (EMG) recordings from the thigh muscles and the medial head of gastrocnemius and heel contact recordings while the patient walked on a treadmill at different gradients. The results of this study revealed that significant differences were seen only in the medial gastrocnemius. An earlier onset, an earlier peak, a longer activation of EMG and a greater normalized root mean square amplitude, correlating with muscular tension, were seen in the medial gastrocnemius of the patients with good or excellent Lysholm score. This study is the first to investigate and demonstrate EMG differences between ACL-deficient patients with good and poor functional results. Furthermore, it reveals that the strength and coordination of the gastrocnemius might be of importance and should be considered in the search for optimal training programmes.     

Computer-assisted surgery for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is one of the most common orthopedic procedures. Revision rates are as high as 40% with malpositioned tunnels as a chief contributor. Computer-assisted orthopedic surgery or navigation for ACL reconstruction has been introduced to help decrease the revision rate. We review the role of computer navigation in improving the accuracy of tunnel placement, assessing kinematics of the knee, and in training surgeons to correctly perform ACL reconstructions. We report on our experience with navigated ACL reconstruction and describe the kinematic evaluation of a series of patients who underwent the procedure.     

Freeze-dried allografts for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Freeze-dried allografts represent a viable and functional alternative to fresh-frozen allograft and autograft constructs. Compared with fresh-frozen allograft constructs, freeze-dried soft tissue allograft constructs have many advantages including limited immunogenicity, ease of graft storage, comparable mechanical properties of soft tissue constructs, and the potential for improved biologic incorporation. This article reviews the fundamental processing of freeze-dried allografts and summarizes the clinical and basic science studies supporting the safe and effective use of freeze-dried allograft constructs for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. It also discusses potential directions of future research on tissue-engineered anterior cruciate ligament constructs using freeze-dried tendon constructs.     

Healing potential of meniscal tears without repair in knees with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

BACKGROUND: Few previous studies have documented the healing potential of meniscal tears that are left to heal without repair. PURPOSE: To determine the healing rates of meniscal tears left without repair in knees with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective cohort study. METHODS: One hundred and ninety-two knees were evaluated at the time of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and repeat arthroscopy. The healing rates of 41 medial and 42 lateral torn menisci without repair were evaluated by the same 2 surgeons in an identical fashion. RESULTS: Of 41 medial torn menisci left without repair, 22 (56%) were considered completely healed, 3 (7%) were incompletely healed, 11 (24%) were unhealed, and 5 (10%) had expanded unhealed lesions. Of 42 lateral torn menisci, 31 (74%) were considered completely healed, 2 (5%) were incompletely healed, 6 (14%) were unhealed, and 3 (7%) had expanded unhealed lesions. The healing rate of a medial meniscal tear was length dependent and not related to reconstructed ligament stability. CONCLUSIONS: Stable meniscal tears at the time of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction possibly could be left in situ. However, longer medial meniscal tears are thought to require additional stabilizing procedures.     

Sagittal tibial translation during exercises in the anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knee

The aim of this study was to describe and compare the sagittal tibial translation and electromyographic activity of muscles v. medialis and lateralis, gastrocnemius and hamstrings, during common rehabilitation exercises, in patients with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency and non-injured controls. Sagittal tibial translation was registered with the CA-4000 electrogoniometer, in 12 patients and 17 controls, during Lachman test (static translation) and five exercises (dynamic translation). The exercises were grouped according to muscle work and joint compression (active extension, heel raises, cycling, one-legged squat and chair squat). The non-weight-bearing exercise with isolated muscle work (active extension) produced a large amount of tibial translation. During weight bearing, the total anterior-posterior tibial motion was halved compared to the non-weight-bearing exercises, but tibia was anterior positioned. Heel raising resulted in equal translation as the one-legged squat and chair squat, whereas cycling produced the smallest amount of tibial translation. The subjects utilized different amounts of their individual joint play (static translation) during the exercises, which may explain why there are no correlation between static translation and the patients functional outcome. These results enhance understanding on tibial translation during activity and gives indications on which exercises can be used early after ACL injury and reconstruction.     

Anatomical double-bundle anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

A careful review of the literature suggests that a significant number of patients undergoing anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction have less than optimal results. Although overall outcomes of ACL reconstruction are favourable, there remains considerable room for improvement. Anatomically, the ACL consists of two major functional bundles, the anteromedial and the posterolateral bundle. Biomechanically, both bundles contribute significantly to the anterior and the rotational stability of the knee. Therefore, anatomical double-bundle ACL reconstruction techniques may further improve the outcomes in ACL surgery. Our preferred technique for arthroscopic double-bundle ACL reconstruction includes the use of two femoral and two tibial tunnels to restore both the anteromedial and the posterolateral bundle of the ACL and their anatomical footprints at their tibial and femoral insertion site. We use two tibialis anterior tendon allografts for the restoration of the two ACL bundles. Clinical long-term outcome studies may focus on the evaluation of functional outcomes, restoration of anterior and rotational knee stability, and the risk of degenerative osteoarthritis of the knee joint following anatomical double-bundle ACL reconstruction versus single-bundle ACL reconstruction.     

Fresh-frozen allograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament provides consistently good to excellent results allowing return to work and sport. Allograft tissue is an alternative to autografts when appropriate donor tissue is not available or its use is not advisable for other reasons. The technique and results for allograft use are similar to those for autograft, making its use appropriate in a variety of clinical scenarios. This article reviews the indications for allograft ACL reconstruction, graft options, and technique for allograft use.     

Simultaneous bilateral anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

BACKGROUND: There are no reports on the outcome of bilateral simultaneous anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. HYPOTHESIS: There is no difference in outcome between unilateral and simultaneous bilateral operations. STUDY DESIGN: Case control study. METHODS: We compared the short-term outcome (mean, 37.2 months) of 28 patients who had bilateral simultaneous reconstructions with that of a matched group of patients who had unilateral reconstruction. RESULTS: Postoperative narcotic requirements for pain did not differ between groups. The mean quadriceps muscle strength for the simultaneous group was 99% in the right leg and 102% in the left leg compared with the strongest leg preoperatively; the mean for the unilateral group was 99%. The mean modified Noyes score for the simultaneous group was 91.2 points in the left knee and 93.5 points for the right knee; the mean for the unilateral group was 88.7 points. The mean time to return to full-time work and to full sports was 4.1 weeks and 6.1 months for the simultaneous group and 3.0 weeks and 6.3 months for the unilateral group. The mean hospital costs were US dollars 6687 and US dollars 4307, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: When clinical indications exist, we recommend simultaneous bilateral anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction as opposed to staged procedures because it is a safe, effective, and cost-effective option.     

One-stage bilateral anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Purpose

The ideal treatment for patients presenting with bilateral anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency remains controversial. The purpose was to evaluate cost and functional results after one-stage bilateral ACL reconstruction using either hamstring or patella tendon autograft.

Methods

This prospective comparative study was compared the mid-term outcome of 7 patients (14 knees) who had one-stage bilateral ACL reconstruction with that of a matched group of patients who had unilateral reconstruction (21 patients).

Results

The median length of hospital stay was 4 (3–5) nights for the bilateral group and 2 (1–4) nights for the control group. The duration of rehabilitation process in patients from control group with unilateral ACL reconstruction was one week shorter (9 vs 8 weeks). In the bilateral group, the median Lysholm score was 96 (85–100), and in the control group, the median score was 93 (81–100). The median time to return to full-time work and to full sports was 9 weeks and 7 months for the one-stage group and 8 weeks and 6 months for the unilateral group. Six patients (86 %) in the bilateral group and 17 patients (81 %) in the control group were still performing at their pre-injury level of activity. National Health Institution saved 2925 EUR when we performed one-stage bilateral reconstruction instead of two-stage ACL reconstruction.

Conclusions

Mid-term clinical results suggested that one-stage bilateral ACL reconstruction using either hamstring or patella tendon autograft is clinically effective. For patients presenting bilateral ACL-deficient knees, one-stage bilateral ACL reconstruction is reproducible, cost effective and does not compromise functional results.

Level of evidence

II.     

自体胭绳肌腱与同种异体胫前肌腱重建前交叉韧带的对照研究

目的观察自体胭绳肌腱与同种异体移植物关节镜下重建膝关节前交叉韧带（ACL）的疗效与差异。方法将54例ACL损伤患者分为2组,自体胭绳肌腱移植组33例,同种异体肌腱移植组21例,均采用美国强生公司生产的Rigidfix及Intrafix系统固定,评价项目包括手术时间、发热天数、大腿周径患健侧比值、Lachman试验、中立位前抽屉试验（ADT）和国际膝关节评分委员会（IKDC）、Lysholm及Tegner评分。结果两组患者术后膝关节稳定性均较术前得到明显好转,除手术时间外,物理检查及功能评分差异均无统计学意义（P〉0．05）。结论关节镜下自体及同种异体肌腱重建ACL都有较好的疗效,可根据患者的病情及主观要求灵活选择。