A scoring system for primary biliary cirrhosis and its application for variant forms of autoimmune liver disease

Background: Although primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) and autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) are two independent autoimmune liver diseases, it is sometimes difficult to characterize the variant forms of autoimmune liver disease. A PBC scoring system, in combination with the AIH scoring system may be helpful to characterize such patients. Methods: A PBC scoring system was introduced that selected 14 categories characteristic of PBC. One hundred and thirty-four patients with PBC, 31 patients with autoimmune cholangitis (AIC), 22 patients with overlap syndrome, and 48 patients with AIH were included in the study. The AIC patients fulfilled the PBC criteria but were negative for anti-mitochondrial antibody and positive for anti-nuclear antibody. Overlap syndrome patients fulfilled both the PBC and AIH criteria. Results: The total scores (means ± SD) for the PBC, AIC, overlap syndrome, and AIH patients were 23.3 ± 4.7, 9.3 ± 4.4, 18.0 ± 5.9, and 3.6 ± 3.3, respectively. When definite and probable PBC patients were defined as those with a total score of over 17 and 9–17, respectively, all except for 1 patient could be classified as definite or probable PBC. Four of the 48 AIH patients were classified as probable PBC. PBC scores for the variant autoimmune liver diseases showed a wide deviation. Plotting both PBC and AIH scores in a rectangular coordinate enabled us to locate each patient with variant forms according to the deviation from classical PBC or AIH. Conclusions: The PBC scoring system might be useful in characterizing the features of variant forms of autoimmune liver disease. Received: March 6, 2002 / Accepted: June 14, 2002 Reprint requests to: K. Yamamoto Editorial on page 106     

Diagnostic value and utility of the simplified International Autoimmune Hepatitis Group criteria in acute‐onset autoimmune hepatitis

Background: The diagnosis of autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) is already difficult, and that of acute‐onset AIH with atypical features is even more challenging, even though the revised original diagnostic criteria created by an international AIH group were widely accepted and incorporated into clinical practice. Aims: Recently, simplified diagnostic criteria were proposed. We compared the performance parameters of the simplified scoring system in patients with acute‐onset AIH and examined its usefulness and limitations. Methods: Fifty‐five patients with acute‐onset AIH (29 non‐severe, 14 severe and 12 fulminant) were assessed according to the simplified scoring system and compared with the revised original one. Results: Of the 55 patients, 22 (40%) were diagnosed as ‘definite’ AIH, 28 (51%) as ‘probable’ and five (9%) as ‘non‐diagnostic’ based on the revised original scoring system. By the simplified scoring system, six (11%) were diagnosed as ‘definite’ AIH, 16 (29%) as ‘probable’ and 33 (60%) as ‘non‐diagnostic’. Anti‐nuclear antibody titres did not differ among the three groups. The immunoglobulin G level was higher in fulminant than in non‐severe patients (P=0.01). Sixty‐five per cent showed acute hepatitis (massive necrosis, submassive necrosis and severe acute hepatitis) and 35% showed chronic hepatitis. Conclusions: The revised original scoring system performed better in patients with acute‐onset AIH than the simplified scoring system.     

原发性胆汁性肝硬化和自身免疫性肝炎重叠综合征的临床与病理分析

目的 分析原发性胆汁性肝硬化(PBC)和自身免疫性肝炎(AIH)重叠综合征(PBC/AIH重叠综合征)患者的临床表现、肝组织病理学特征。 方法 采用国际自身免疫性肝炎小组新修订的描述性诊断标准和计分系统,从68例PBC患者中筛选出9例PBC/AIH重叠综合征患者,分析比较PBC/AIH重叠综合征和单纯PHC患者的临床表现、肝组织病理学特征。 结果 68例PBC患者中,PBC/AIH重叠综合征9例,单纯PBC 59例,分别占13.2％和86.8％,PBC/AIH重叠综合征血清丙氨酸氨基转移酶、天冬氨酸氨基转移酶、γ-球蛋白、免疫球蛋白G,以及抗平滑肌抗体和(或)抗核抗体阳性率明显高于单纯PBC;PBC/AIH重叠综合征合并其他自身免疫性疾病发生率亦明显高于单纯PBC;PBC/AIH重叠综合征兼有PBC和AIH的双重组织学特点,显示界面炎和碎屑样坏死,肝组织免疫荧光检测显示肝细胞膜、汇管区有免疫球蛋白G沉着。 结论 PBC/AIH重叠综合征表现出A·IH和PBC双重特征,不同于单纯的PBC,两者的临床表现、免疫学及肝组织病理学特征上有差异。     

Evaluation of Validity and Efficiency of Diagnostic Criteria in Autoimmune Hepatitis in Children

Background: Autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) is a progressive inflammatory liver disease with various clinical symptoms, but treatment and prevention of hepatic failure and cirrhosis is possible with early diagnosis. However, no specific test has been approved for the diagnosis of AIH. In 2008, the International Autoimmune Hepatitis Group (IAIHG) developed a simplified diagnostic scoring system that has been widely used in practice. Nevertheless, it cannot distinguish AIH from Primary Sclerosing Cholangitis (PSC) and consensus is lacking with respect to its validity, sensitivity, and applicability for children patients. The newer 2018 version also requires validation. The present study intends to evaluate the validity and efficiency of the IAIHG simplified scoring system and new scoring system in children with AIH.Methods: The present study is a non-interventional case–control study covering 152 patients with hepatic diseases (83 patients with AIH and 69 patients with Wilson disease (WD)). Titers of autoantibodies, IgG levels, hepatic histology, and absence of viral hepatitis were scored and calculated according to IAIHG diagnostic criteria. Statistics software package (SPSS) and draft receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves was used to analyze data and determine value of diagnostic criteria.Result: In our study, both scoring systems’ accuracy was good in AIH diagnosis, although new score displays higher sensitivity and specificity, suggestive of greater accuracy and predictive strength.Conclusion: Our study is the first validation study of the new scoring system in diagnosing AIH, and further studies require verifying this scoring system.     

Overlap of autoimmune hepatitis and primary biliary cirrhosis: an evaluation of a modified scoring system

OBJECTIVE: The coexistence of autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) with primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) as an overlap syndrome has been previously described. The ability to detect AIH overlap with a revised version of the International Autoimmune Hepatitis Group (IAHG) scoring system, however, remains unknown. Our specific aim was to evaluate the revised IAHG scoring system and its ability to identify AIH overlap in PBC. MErHODS: One hundred forty-one PBC patients with first-time visits to the Mayo Clinic from January 1, 1990 to December 31, 1992 were evaluated. The calculation of individual revised IAHG scores was performed and compared to original IAHG scores. RESULTS: Among 137 PBC patients with available liver histologies, use of the original IAHG scoring system detected "definite" and "probable" AIH overlap among 2.2% and 62% of cases, respectively. Application of the revised IAHG scoring system, however, revealed no individuals (0%) with definite AIH overlap (>15 points). Twenty-six subjects (19%) fulfilled IAHG criteria for probable AIH overlap (10-15 points). The presence of antinuclear antibody and/or smooth muscle antibody positivity (p = 0.05), other autoimmune disorders (p < 0.01), and total histological score (p < 0.001) were significantly greater in the PBC plus probable AIH group than in subjects with PBC alone. CONCLUSION: A reduction in the prevalence of definite 2.2% vs 0%) and probable (62% vs. 19%) AIH overlap among PBC subjects was observed with use of the revised IAHG coring system relative to the original criteria. Applicability of the revised IAHG scoring system, however, remains questionable, as nearly 20% of PBC patients will be classified with probable AIH overlap.     

Transitions between variant forms of primary biliary cirrhosis during long-term follow-up

BackgroundConditions exhibiting features of two different autoimmune liver diseases are designated overlap syndromes. Variant forms display some, but not all, characteristics of a distinct autoimmune liver disease. We describe transitions over time between variant forms of PBC, i.e. AMA-negative PBC, autoimmune hepatitis (AIH)–PBC overlap and autoimmune cholangitis (AIC) in a large cohort of PBC patients in Sweden.MethodsWe retrieved all patients with variant forms of PBC in six university hospitals in Sweden, covering 60% of the Swedish population. The diagnosis of PBC and its variants was based on laboratory findings and compatible histological features. The revised autoimmune hepatitis scoring system proposed by the International Autoimmune Hepatitis Group was used to establish the diagnosis of AIH.ResultsIn a population of 800 patients with PBC, we identified 35 (5%) variant forms; 25 patients with AIH–PBC overlap, 8 with AIC and 2 with AMA-negative PBC at the time of our study. The initial diagnoses were PBC (3 patients), AIH (3), AIH–PBC overlap (16), AIC (8) and AMA-negative PBC with (1) or without (4) concomitant AIH. The median follow-up was 125 (41–360) months. Immunosuppression and ursodeoxycholic acid induced a complete or good regression of increased aminotransferases in about half of the patients who were given one or both of these treatments.ConclusionsVariant forms of PBC are seen in approximately 5% of PBC patients in Sweden. Transition between different forms may occur, emphasizing the value of repeat biopsies, but established overlapping AIH–PBC seems to be stable over time.     

Overlap of primary biliary cirrhosis and autoimmune hepatitis: Characteristics,therapy, and long term outcomes

Background: Coexistence of primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) and autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) is referred to as PBC‐AIH overlap. Pathogenesis of PBC‐AIH is not well understood and its diagnosis is challenging. We previously reported the clinical characteristics of 10 patients diagnosed with PBC‐AIH overlap. Aims: The aim of the study was extend the earlier series and evaluate the diagnostic criteria, biological characteristics, potential therapy, and long‐term outcomes of patients with PBC‐AIH overlap. Methods and Results: We retrospectively analyzed clinical, biochemical, and histological characteristics of 144 patients diagnosed with PBC and 73 diagnosed with AIH. We identified 16 cases of PBC‐AIH overlap, according to criteria established by Chazouillères et al. and other studies. PBC preceded AIH in 6 patients and both diseases occurred simultaneously in the remaining 10 patients. PBC‐AIH overlap has clinical, biochemical, and histological characteristics of both PBC and AIH. Thirteen patients treated with both ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA) and immunosuppressive therapy responded well, with normal alanine aminotransferase (ALT) and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) levels. The remaining three patients treated with either prednisolone (PSL) or UDCA alone developed cirrhosis, varices, ascites, encephalopathy, or died of liver‐related causes at the 5, 12, and 14‐year follow up. Conclusions: PBC‐AIH overlap is not a rare entity; it was observed in 11% of PBC patients in this study. Further studies will be required to investigate whether PBC‐AIH overlap is distinct from the two individual diseases in terms of long‐term outcomes and therapeutic implications.     

Overlap syndromes

In hepatology, the term overlap syndrome describes variant forms of the major hepatobiliary autoimmune diseases, autoimmune hepatitis (AIH), primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC), and primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC). Patients with overlap syndromes present with both hepatitic and cholestatic biochemical and histological features of AIH, PBC, and/or PSC, and usually show a progressive course toward liver cirrhosis and liver failure without adequate treatment. AIH-PBC overlap syndromes have been reported in almost 10% of adults with AIH or PBC, whereas AIH-PSC overlap syndromes were found in 6 to 8% of children, adolescents, and young adults with AIH or PSC. A minority of patients may also show transition from stable PBC to AIH, AIH to PBC, or AIH to PSC, as documented by single case reports and small case series. Single cases of AIH and autoimmune cholangitis (antimitochondrial antibody-negative PBC) overlap have also been reported. Empiric medical treatment of AIH-PBC and AIH-PSC overlap syndromes includes anticholestatic therapy with ursodeoxycholic acid and immunosuppressive therapy with corticosteroids and azathioprine. In end-stage disease, liver transplantation is the treatment of choice.     

Overlap syndromes among autoimmune liver diseases

The three major immune disorders of the liver are autoimmune hepatitis（AIH）,primary biliary cirrhosis（PBC） and primary sclerosing cholangitis（PSC）.Variant forms of these diseases are generally called overlap syndromes,although there has been no standardised definition.Patients with overlap syndromes present with both hepatitic and cholestatic serum liver tests and have histological features of AIH and PBC or PSC.The AIH-PBC overlap syndrome is the most common form,affecting almost 10% of adults with AIH or PBC.Single cases of AIH and autoimmune cholangitis（AMA-negative PBC） overlap syndrome have also been reported.The AIH-PSC overlap syndrome is predominantly found in children,adolescents and young adults with AIH or PSC.Interestingly,transitions from one autoimmune to another have also been reported in a minority of patients,especially transitions from PBC to AIH-PBC overlap syndrome.Overlap syndromes show a progressive course towards liver cirrhosis and liver failure without treatment.Therapy for overlap syndromes is empiric,since controlled trials are not available in these rare disorders.Anticholestatic therapy with ursodeoxycholic acid is usually combined with immunosuppressive therapy with corticosteroids and/or azathioprine in both AIH-PBC and AIH-PSC overlap syndromes.In end-stage disease,liver transplantation is the treatment of choice.     

熊去氧胆酸治疗无重叠和有重叠特征原发性胆汁性肝硬化的疗效及生存分析

目的观察熊去氧胆酸（ursodeoxyeholicacid,UDCA）对具有自身免疫性肝炎（autoimmunehepatitis,AIH）重叠特征的原发性胆汁性肝硬化（Drimarybiliarycirrhosis．PBC）和单纯PBC患者的疗效以及对生存期的影响。方法回顾性分析20例因PBC死亡的患者,以患者死亡为研究终点,采用简化评分标准进行分组。其中12例诊断可能为AIH,将此12例具重叠特征和8例无重叠特征的PBC患者分别进行研究,分析2组在UDCA初治及研究终点时的临床特征、UDCA治疗的生化学应答及生存期情况。结果2组在UDCA治疗基线的PLT、ALP、GGT、ALT、AST、ALB、TBIL、TBA、CRE、PT、INR水平及梅奥风险评分差异均无统计学意义,而抗核抗体或抗平滑肌抗体≥1：80的阳性率、血清球蛋白或IgG／〉1．1倍正常值上限的百分比及AIH治疗前的简化评分差异均有统计学意义。UDCA治疗后有重叠特征组的生存时间为（24．4＋16．5）个月,中位生存时间为22．0个月;无重叠特征组生存时间为（60．6＋43-3）个月,中位生存时间为50．5个月。采用Kaplan-Meier生存分析显示,重叠特征组经过UDCA治疗后预后较差,Log-rank检验结果显示2组生存时间差异有统计学意义。在导致死亡的原因中,2组发病率差异均无统计学意义,但数据显示上消化道出血仍为主要死亡原因。结论对于巴黎标准不能确诊而简化评分标准可确诊的AIH—PBC患者,单纯UDCA治疗预后差,生存时间较无重叠特征的PBC患者短。     

自身免疫性肝病活检组织病理学特征分析109例

目的:分析比较自身免疫性肝炎(AIH)、原发性胆汁性肝硬化(PBC)、原发性硬化性胆管炎(PSC)及其重叠综合征的组织病理学变化,提高对自身免疫性肝病(AILD)的认识.方法:对27例AIH、67例PBC、4例PSC、1例AIH-PSC重叠综合征和10例AIH-PBC重叠综合征患者的肝穿组织病理资料进行回顾性分析.结果:AILD患者多发于中年女性(73.3%),肝组织病理变化以界面性肝炎为主(77.7%),在重度患者则出现重度界面性肝炎、桥样坏死等.PBC患者早期(Ⅰ、Ⅱ)占28.3%,而晚期(Ⅲ、Ⅳ)占71.7%,肝组织病理变化以小胆管减少甚至消失为主(62.6%).AIH-PBC重叠综合征患者并非罕见,他的肝组织病理学具有AIH和PBC的双重特征.结论:AILD是非病毒性肝病的重要组成部分,其诊断需综合临床表现、生化、免疫指标和组织学变化.     

Clinical and pathological characteristics of the autoimmune hepatitis and primary biliary cirrhosis overlap syndrome

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: The defining of the autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) and primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) overlap syndrome as a separate clinicopathological entity has been controversial and temporally and geographically subjective. METHODS: From 1979 until 2000, 227 patients diagnosed with AIH, PBC or the overlap thereof were treated. Cases with genuine AIH/PBC overlap syndrome were sorted out using close clinical follow up and serial liver biopsies. RESULTS: Of the 227 patients, 19 (8.4%) were diagnosed with the AIH/PBC overlap syndrome. They all cleared a score >10 for the diagnosis of AIH, and tested positive for antimitochondrial antibodies during their courses. Long-term follow up with frequent histological examinations, however, established the diagnosis of AIH/PBC overlap syndrome in only two (0.8%) patients. The most powerful factor distinguishing AIH from PBC was acidophilic bodies in lobules that were detected significantly more frequently in patients with AIH than PBC or spurious overlap syndrome (39/46 [85%]vs 3/85 [4%], P < 0.001). It was more reliable than bile-duct lesions for the distinction of PBC from AIH. CONCLUSIONS: Although AIH/PBC overlap syndrome does exist, it is infrequent and needs to be diagnosed carefully using close clinical and histological follow up to enable timely and effective treatment.     

Detection of D‐3‐phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase autoantibodies in patients with autoimmune hepatitis: Clinical significance evaluation

Aim: D‐3‐phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase (3‐PHGDH) was identified as a putative target of autoantibodies in autoimmune hepatitis (AIH). The aims of the present study were to detect anti‐3‐PHGDH in patients with AIH and other chronic liver diseases and to analyze their clinical relevance. Methods: Human 3‐PHGDH gene was cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli and used in enzyme‐linked immunosorbent assays and Western blots. Serum from patients with AIH (n = 101), primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC, n = 122), chronic hepatitis C (CHC, n = 117), chronic hepatitis B (CHB, n = 112), and from patients with other autoimmune disease (n = 125) were investigated. Results: The highest incidence and activity of anti‐PHGDH was observed in AIH patients. Thirty‐two of 40 untreated (80%) and 37 of 61 AIH patients treated with corticosteroid (60.7%) were positive. Antibody titers decreased significantly during corticosteroid treatment. 15.8% of PBC patients, 9.8% of CHB and 12.8% of CHC patients, were anti‐PHGDH‐positive, with less than 12% of patients positive with other autoimmune diseases via reactions with recombinant 3‐PHGDH protein. Conclusion: Anti‐PHGDH were detected in chronic liver diseases. They occur predominantly in AIH, and corticosteroid treatment seems to decrease antibody titers. Whether the antibodies are primary or secondary phenomena and whether they are related to the etiology or pathogenesis, at least in a subgroup of patients with chronic liver diseases, has still to be evaluated.     

Frequency and predictive factors for overlap syndrome between autoimmune hepatitis and primary cholestatic liver disease

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the frequency of cholestatic pattern in patients with autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) and to identify predictive factors associated with the development of the overlap syndrome. METHODS: Eighty-two consecutive patients diagnosed with AIH at the referral centre between January 1998 and June 2002 were included in the study. The new scoring system modified by the International Autoimmune Hepatitis Group was used to classify patients as definite/probable. Overlap syndrome was considered when the patient had clinical, serological and histological characteristics of two conditions: AIH and primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) or AIH and primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC). RESULTS: From the 82 AIH patients (76 female and six male), 84.1% presented definite AIH (> 15 points) and 15.9% probable AIH (10 - 15 points). The frequency of the overlap syndrome was 20%: 13% with PBC and 7% with PSC. In the univariate analysis the overlap syndrome was associated with male gender (P = 0.01), age < 35 years (P < 0.0001), histopathological aspect of cholestasis (P < 0.0001), suboptimal response to treatment (P < 0.0001) and probable AIH (P < 0.0001). Age < 35 years, probable AIH and the absence of anti-nuclear antibody (ANA) have been identified as independent indicators of the overlap diagnosis by the logistic regression analysis. CONCLUSION: Patients with overlap syndrome between AIH and primary cholestatic liver disease are frequently diagnosed in clinical practice, representing 20% of AIH cases in our study. The independent predictive factors associated with the diagnosis of overlap syndrome are young age, ANA(-) profile, and probable diagnosis according with the scoring system for AIH.     

Development of autoimmune hepatitis in primary biliary cirrhosis.

AIM/BACKGROUND: Primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) is a chronic cholestatic liver disease of unknown aetiology. Up to 10% of patients with typical features of PBC will have additional features of autoimmune hepatitis (AIH). A subset, however, have no such features but go on to develop a 'sequential' AIH overlap syndrome. Objectives: Describe our experience with eight patients who developed AIH after the diagnosis of PBC was made. METHODS: We reviewed the charts of all PBC patients over a 9-year period (from 1996 to 2005). Only PBC patients with no features of AIH were included. RESULTS: There were 1476 patients with PBC. Of these, eight patients developed features of AIH overlap syndrome based on biochemical and histological parameters. Treatment included prednisone and azathioprine for 24 or more months. The majority of patients remained on ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA) throughout treatment. Response to therapy was defined by improvement in enzymes, and was rapid for all patients. One patient was able to discontinue treatment with prednisone and azathioprine, while seven have continued on therapy to date. CONCLUSIONS: A 'sequential' overlap syndrome of AIH with PBC can occur. Treatment with prednisone and azathioprine may lead to a rapid improvement in aminotransferase levels.     

A case of primary biliary cirrhosis and autoimmune hepatitis overlap showing acute presentation and transient seropositivity for immunoglobulin G and anti-nuclear antibody

Autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) is generally regarded as a clinically and histologically “chronic” hepatitis. It often shows acute presentation like acute hepatitis without typical clinicopathological features of AIH, especially in a case of overlap with primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC). A 52-year-old man showed mild liver dysfunction for the first time at an annual medical check. Two months later, he showed jaundice, and laboratory tests revealed elevation of liver enzymes, hyperbilirubinemia and prolonged prothrombin time activity like acute liver failure. Anti-mitochondrial antibody was positive and other viral and autoimmune markers were negative. His liver function tests improved upon treatment with ursodeoxycholic acid and maximum intravenous glycyrrhizin (IVGL), but liver dysfunction was again exacerbated after the gradual reduction of IVGL. He showed transient elevation of immunoglobulin G (IgG) and anti-nuclear antibody (ANA) at only one point, and liver histology was compatible with PBC and AIH overlap syndrome. Corticosteroid was administered and his liver function tests returned to normal. It is important for the diagnosis of acute onset AIH to monitor IgG level and ANA titer, especially in patients without IgG and ANA elevations at first appearance.     

164例自身免疫性肝病临床分析

目的 分析比较自身免疫性肝炎（autoimmune hepatitis，AIH）、原发性胆汁性肝硬化（primary biliary cirrhosis，PBC）、原发性硬化性胆管炎（primary sclerosing cholangltis）及其重叠综合征的临床特点、生化特征和治疗反应，提高对自身免疫性肝病的认识。方法对77例AIH患者、46例PBC患者、11例PSC患者和30例PBC-AIH重叠综合征患者的临床及实验室检查资料进行回顾性分析。结果除PSC外，大多数自身免疫性肝病多发于中年女性，从出现症状到明确诊断平均需要2．5年。AIH、PBC-AIH重叠患者具有较高的转氨酶，PBC、PSC具有较明显的GGT、ALP升高。临床表现上AIH、PBC、PSC、AIH-PBC黄疸发生率分别为84％、78％、90％和67％，皮肤瘙痒的发生率分别为43％、56％、81％和60％。PSC和AIH-PBC具有较高的AIH评分，27％的PSC患者和33％AIH-PBC的评分达到可能的AIH。合理应用UDCA和免疫抑制剂可使90％的PBC和AIH患者症状在六个月内得到缓解、肝功能恢复明显改善。结论 AIH、PBC-AIH的肝功能异常以转氨酶升高为主，PBC、PSC以胆汁淤积为主。应用AIH评分系统诊断可能的AIH时应注意鉴别PSC及其它自身免疫性肝病。UDCA和免疫抑制剂可改善绝大多数患者的症状和肝功能异常。     

Clinical features of 89 patients with autoimmune hepatitis in Nagasaki Prefecture, Japan

We examined the clinical characteristics of 89 patients with autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) in Nagasaki Prefecture, Japan, and assessed the usefulness of a provisional scoring system for the diagnosis of AIH proposed by the International Autoimmune Hepatitis Group in 1993. The majority of patients were middle-aged women in their fifties. All patients showed a hepatitic picture. Forty-three patients (48%) had an insidious or chronic onset, while 34 (38%) had an acute onset, and 12 (14%) had liver cirrhosis at presentation. Seventy-nine patients (89%) were positive for antinuclear antibody (ANA), and 5 (6%) were positive for antibody to the hepatitis C virus (anti-HCV). The prognosis was good, with 90% 3-year survival, and most patients responded well to treatment with corticosteroids. The international scoring system was useful for the diagnosis of AIH in most of our patients; the percentages of patients with definite and probable AIH were 48% and 47%, respectively. However, certain factors, such as negative ANA, positive antimitochondrial antibody, concurrent infection with hepatitis B or C virus, and insufficient response to treatment precluded the diagnosis of AIH in some patients. Whether these patients were indeed "true" AIH patients is not clear at present, and further investigation of such patients may be useful for a better understanding of AIH. (Received: June 26, 1998; accepted: Oct. 23, 1998)     

Overlap syndromes: the International Autoimmune Hepatitis Group (IAIHG) position statement on a controversial issue

Some patients present with overlapping features between disorders within the spectrum of autoimmune liver diseases (i.e. autoimmune hepatitis (AIH), primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC), and primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC)) and are commonly classified as having an "overlap syndrome". Standardized definitions of "overlap syndromes" are lacking. The aim of this report by the International Autoimmune Hepatitis Group (IAIHG) is to evaluate if there are important reasons to classify conditions with overlapping features between autoimmune liver diseases as separate diagnostic entities. Definition of diagnostic criteria for overlap conditions can only be arbitrary. The IAIHG scoring system for diagnosis of AIH has been widely used to diagnose "overlap syndromes", but was not intended for such use and has not proven to be an efficient tool for this purpose. Some patients with overlapping features between a cholestatic and hepatitic disorder appear to benefit from treatment with a combination of ursodeoxycholic acid and immunosuppressants, but this strategy is not evidence-based, and it seems unjustified to define new diagnostic groups in this regard. The IAIHG suggests that patients with autoimmune liver disease should be categorized according to the predominating feature(s) as AIH, PBC, and PSC/small duct PSC, respectively, and that those with overlapping features are not considered as being distinct diagnostic entities. The IAIHG scoring system should not be used to establish subgroups of patients. Patients with PBC and PSC with features of AIH should be considered for immunosuppressive treatment. Due to the low prevalence of such "overlap syndromes", prospective interventional therapeutic trials cannot be expected in the foreseeable future.     

Diagnosing autoimmune hepatitis in nonalcoholic fatty liver disease: is the International Autoimmune Hepatitis Group scoring system useful?

Background There are no surrogate serum markers for autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD). An AIH scoring system was reported by the International Autoimmune Hepatitis Group; however, the criteria did not focus on making the distinction between AIH and NAFLD. We examined the effectiveness of using the AIH score for diagnosing AIH in NAFLD patients. We also identified the prevalence of autoimmune phenomena, in terms of various auto-antibodies, including antinuclear antibodies (ANA), to determine whether these markers had any clinicopathological significance, and whether they were related to the patients' clinical courses. Methods We studied 212 patients (103 males and 109 females) with biopsy-proven NAFLD. The AIH score of each patient was calculated without including the liver biopsy results. The patients were divided into three groups based on their clinicopathological features: the overlap group (those with clinical and histological features of both NAFLD and AIH), the systemic group (those with systemic antoimmune disease other than AIH), and the “other” group (patients with no antoimmune disease). To evaluate the clinicopathological significance of ANA in NAFLD patients, those without autoimmune diseases (the “others” group) were classified according to their ANA positivity and ANA titer. Results Seventy patients (33.0%) were positive for ANA. Among the female patients, 106 patients (97.2%) had an AIH score of 10 or more. Of the 103 male patients, 21 (20.4%) had an AIH score of 10 or more. However, after liver biopsy, only 1 patient (0.5%) could be classified as “definite AIH.” In the NAFLD patients without autoimmune diseases (“other” group), multivariate logistic regression analysis found that female sex was an independent predictor of the presence of ANA (P = 0.029). In contrast, multivariate logistic regression analysis found that severe obesity (body mass index [BMI], ≥30 kg/m²) was the only independent predictor of the presence of an ANA titer of 1 : 80 or more (P = 0.026). Conclusions The AIH score without liver biopsy findings was not useful for diagnosing AIH in NAFLD patients. In patients with elevated ANA titers and risk factors for NAFLD, it is very important to perform a liver biopsy to make a definitive diagnosis before treatment.