Reconstruction of noncontained distal femoral defects with polymethylmethacrylate and crossed-screw augmentation: a biomechanical study

BACKGROUND: Curettage and cementation with polymethylmethacrylate are frequently used in the treatment of aggressive benign bone lesions such as giant-cell tumors, but strength and stiffness of the reconstructed bone have been concerns. This biomechanical study was undertaken to determine whether augmenting the cement with crossed screws would result in a stronger reconstruction. METHODS: Large noncontained defects were created in the medial femoral condyles of twenty matched pairs of human cadavera. Four groups were organized to compare three types of reconstruction: (1) polymethylmethacrylate alone, (2) polymethylmethacrylate and intramedullary Steinmann pins, and (3) polymethylmethacrylate with crossed screws engaging the opposite cortex. The specimens were subjected to 2000 compressive cycles and were subsequently monotonically loaded to failure under a controlled displacement rate. Failure load and stiffness were determined for each femur that survived the cycling process. RESULTS: Femora reconstructed with crossed screws and cement failed at higher loads and had greater stiffness than those reconstructed with cement alone (p = 0.025 and p = 0.0007) or cement augmented with intramedullary Steinmann pins (p = 0.019). Failure of femora reconstructed with cement and crossed screws occurred through an extra-articular transverse fracture, while failure in those with cement alone and cement with Steinmann pins occurred through an intra-articular (intercondylar) fracture. CONCLUSIONS: In this in vitro cadaver study, augmentation of polymethylmethacrylate cement with crossed screws resulted in a stronger reconstruction of distal femoral tumor defects than that obtained with cement alone or with cement and intramedullary Steinmann pins.     

Contained femoral defects: biomechanical analysis of pin augmentation in cement

Although in the proximal tibia the need for pin augmentation of cemented giant cell tumor defects depends on whether the defect is contained, there is controversy regarding the role for pins in the distal femur. The current study investigated whether Steinmann pin augmentation offers biomechanical advantages in cement reconstruction of contained defects of the lateral femoral condyle. Twelve pairs of human femurs were used. They were tested either with the bone intact, with a standardized contained defect in the lateral condyle, with a defect repaired with cement alone, and with a defect repaired with pins in the cement. Intact specimens had significantly higher load to failure than specimens with a defect. In the repaired specimens there were no significant differences in stiffness, peak load to failure, and energy to failure between the specimens repaired with just cement or augmented with pins. This study did not show any significant biomechanical advantage of this configuration of Steinmann pin reinforcement in cement for contained defects of the lateral femoral condyle.     

Biomechanical study of pins in cementing of contained proximal tibia defect

Defects from curettage for giant cell tumors of bone frequently have been reconstructed with bone cement with or without reinforcement pins. The biomechanical basis for the addition of reinforcement pins was examined using a model of a contained defect in the proximal tibia. Fifty-four cadaveric proximal tibia in matched pairs were divided into five test groups: intact tibia, medial metaphyseal contained defect, defect reconstructed with cement alone, defect reconstructed with cement and pins inserted within the medullary canal, and defect reconstructed with cement and pins inserted through the cortex. Specimens were tested to failure during one cycle of compressive loading. Defect specimens were significantly weaker and less stiff than intact specimens, establishing the validity of the model-contained defects. For the reconstructions, there was no statistically significant difference in load to failure, stiffness, energy to failure, or displacement for the polymethylmethacrylate treatment alone when compared with matched specimen receiving polymethylmethacrylate and pins treatment. Similarly, there was no statistical difference in biomechanical properties in comparing matched specimens treated with polymethylmethacrylate alone or polymethylmethacrylate/pins (cortex). For contained defects of the proximal tibia that are typical after curettage for giant cell tumor, there appears to be no biomechanical advantage to use of reinforcement pins in the cement.     

Intramedullary pin fixation in clavicular fractures: A study comparing the use of small and large pins

The S-shaped clavicle poses a problem for intramedullary pin fixation. Stability of fracture fixation is closely related to the length of intramedullary pin engagement. This study was carried out to determine the engagement length of intramedullary pins into clavicular fractures using a small and a large pin. Seven pairs of fresh cadaveric clavicles were prepared and arranged into Group 1 and Group 2 for paired study. A mid-third clavicular fracture was created at the junction of the two curves of the clavicle. In Group 1, a 3.2 mm diameter threaded Steinman pin was introduced into the medullary canal of the clavicle by retrograde technique and the medial fragment of the fracture was drilled until the pin perforated the bone cortex. In Group 2, a 4 mm diameter threaded Steinman pin was used in the same manner. The results showed that Group 1 had an average engagement of pin into the clavicle of 9.11 cm with a ratio to total length of the clavicle of 0.59. In Group 2, the average engagement length into the clavicle was 7.17 cm with a ratio of 0.47. The difference was significant, with the smaller pin providing better fixation. The pins in both groups perforated the lateral fragment at the posterosuperior aspect and the medial fragment at the anterior aspect of the clavicle. The angle that the pin made with the long axis of the clavicle in Group 1 was 22.43 degrees and in Group 2, 26.57 degrees. Although the 3.2 mm diameter pin was more aligned to the long axis of the clavicle than the 4 mm diameter pin, the difference was not significant.     

In vitro strength comparison of hydroxyapatite cement and polymethylmethacrylate in subchondral defects in caprine femora

Hydroxyapatite cement was investigated in situ for the reconstruction of juxta-articular defects. Polymethylmethacrylate is currently the most commonly used material for the reconstruction of bone defects following the exteriorization and curettage of aggressive benign tumors. In vitro, we compared the effects of hydroxyapatite cement and polymethylmethacrylate in restoring the stiffness of the subchondral plate in a caprine femoral defect model, fen matched pairs of caprine femora underwent nondestructive compression testing normal to the load-bearing surface. A standardized subchondral defect 12 mm in diameter was created in the medial femoral condyle. Compression testing was repeated to determine the reduction in stiffness caused by the defect. Each femur from each pair was randomly assigned to one of two groups (n = 9), and the defects were augmented with either polymethylmethacrylate or hydroxyapatite cement. After 12 hours, compression tcsting/vas repeated to determine the subchondral stiffness after augmentation. Compared with intact femora, the defect specimens that were later treated with either polymethylmethacrylate or hydroxy-npatite cement exhibited stiffness values of 70 (386 ± 107 N/mm) and 59% (343 ± 94 N/mm) respectively, which represented a significant reduction in stiffness (p = 0.05). Augmentation with polymethylmethacrylate or hydroxyapatite cement restored stiffness by 81 (450 111 N/mm) and 71% (413 ± 115 N/mm), respectively, of tile values of intact specimens. Hydroxyapatite cement restored stiffness significantly (p = 0.05) over the stiffness of the nonaugmented defect compared with the stiffness after augmentation with polymethylmethacrylate (p = 0.12). Neither polymethylmethacrylate nor hydroxyapatite cement restored stiffness to that of intact femora (p = 0.05). In the current defect model, hydroxyapatite cement was comparable with poly-moihylmethacrylate in restoring subchondral stiffness. Unlike polymethylmethacrylate, however, hydroxy-apalile cement has the following advantages: it is osteoconductive, is replaced by host bone, and avoids the potential for thermal necrosis. Hydroxyapatite cement may therefore provide a viable alternative to poly-methylmethacrylate lor augmentation of juxta-articular and other bone defects.     

A study of external skeletal fixation systems for unstable pelvic fractures

This study was undertaken to determine the feasibility of constructing an anterior pelvic external fixator capable of resisting displacement of vertical shear fractures. Newly designed tapered thread pins for cancellous bone had better bone pin fixation and their greater 6-mm diameter provided more than twice the stiffness of Hoffmann 4-mm pins when tested in clusters. Using these pins and a more rigid anterior frame as one model, various pelvic fixators were tested to determine their resistance to vertical shear forces. These tests determined that this new fixator was 16 times stiffer than a Bonnel single anterior frame and five times stiffer than a double anterior frame (both constructed of Hoffmann components). Extrapolation from the data shows that 13 mm of posterior fracture displacement would occur with loads of one half body weight using the new fixator. Additionally it was noted that Hoffmann frames constructed with two 5-mm pins performed as well as those using three 4-mm pins.     

Modulation of the soft tissue reactions to percutaneous orthopaedic implants.

To evaluate soft tissue reactions and biofilm formation on percutaneous external fixator screws coated with diamond-like carbon (DLC) and hydroxyapatite (HA) coatings on stainless-steel (SS) pins in an ovine loaded osteotomy model, an Orthofix external fixator was used to stabilize a 3-mm tibial midshaft osteotomy with six tapered pins inserted into the right tibia of 32 skeletally mature Friesland ewes. Animals were divided into four groups; SS, fully coated HA, DLC, and HA-coated threads. At 10 weeks, specimens were harvested and the pins were removed en bloc to examine the interfaces between the surface coatings and the tissues. Fully coated HA pins had a significantly higher percentage of dermal contact with the pin surface than HA-coated threads (p=0.028). The presence of a biofilm was evident on all pin surfaces except DLC-coated pins. Significantly greater numbers of bacteria were present on fully coated HA and plain stainless-steel pins compared with DLC. The surface of DLC-coated pins had a significantly lower number of bacterial colonies compared to SS (p=0.028) and fully coated HA pins (p=0.005). Fully coated HA pins have greater dermal attachment to the pin surface than the other pin coatings investigated. DLC-coated pins have the potential to prevent biofilm formation and bacterial colonization that may reduce infection and consequent pin loosening. An external fixator pin that is partially coated with HA to encourage bone and soft tissue integration and with DLC to reduce biofilm formation is advocated.     

Biomechanical evaluation of Hackethal's intramedullary bundle pin fixation of humeral neck fractures

Humeral neck fractures can be stabilized using a bundle of intramedullary pins as described by Hackethal. In order to decrease the risk of pin migration, packing of the medullary cavity with as many pins as possible is sometimes recommended, but others believe that stability can be decreased by destruction of cancellous bone in the humeral head by a large bundle of pins. A surgical neck fracture was created with a saw in 30 frozen cadaveric humeri. Bone quality was evaluated by radiography and densitometry. Fractures were stabilized using Hackethal's technique of retrograde intramedullary pinning with varying numbers of 2.5-mm diameter pins; increasing torsion or bending moments of force were then applied to the bones studied. Stability was found to improve with an increasing number of pins and with higher humeral head density. Based upon these findings, the use of a large number of pins is recommended to reduce the risk of pin migration. Up to eight pins, the risk of destruction of cancellous bone in the humeral head appears very low.     

Bone accretion around polymethylmethacrylate and polyethylene implanted in the rabbit tibia

This study examines the accretion rate of bone surrounding orthopaedic polymeric implants in different physical forms. Forty mature, female, New Zealand white rabbits were used in the study. Bilateral 6mm drill holes were made in the anteromedial tibias, 1cm from the joint line. The right tibia received a polymeric implant and the left tibia functioned as a prepared but nonimplanted control. The animals were allocated as follows: Group 1--bulk, preformed cooled polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) plug; Group 2--bulk, doughy PMMA implant; Group 3--cement polymer powder; Group 4--bulk ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene (UHMWP) plug; Group 5--UHMWP particles averaging 67.29 mum; Group 6--UHMWP particles averaging 15.68 mum. All animals received the same volume of PMMA or UHMWP. The animals were killed after four months by barbiturate overdose. Beginning four weeks prior to sacrifice, the animals were given tetracycline injections at two-weekly intervals for two consecutive days. The upper tibias were harvested bilaterally and the specimens were processed undecalcified. Using a fluorescent microscope, the distance between successive tetracycline bands was assessed. Doughy PMMA tended to suppress bone formation compared to the control side, whereas preformed PMMA plugs and particulate PMMA polymer did not. This may be due to the heat of polymerization or to the presence of residual monomer in the doughy group. Polyethylene tended to facilitate bone accretion whether in bulk or particulate form when compared to the control side or to doughy cement. This effect was less marked when the cement was in particulate form.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Anodic plasma chemical treatment of titanium Schanz screws reduces pin loosening

OBJECTIVE: This study was designed to assess the benefits of a new Anodic Plasma Chemical calcium-phosphate (APC-CaP) surface treatment on reducing pin track infection and pin loosening in comparison to anodized titanium (Ti) during external fracture fixation. METHODS: A tibial midshaft, transverse, 6-mm gap osteotomy was created in 17 adult female Swiss alpine sheep. The tibia was stabilized with an external fixator and 4 Schanz screws of Ti or APC-CaP-treated Ti. The sheep were examined during a 12-week observation period. Infection was assessed with weekly clinical pin track grading and microbiologic assessment at sacrifice. Pin loosening was assessed by grading for radiolucency on biweekly radiographs and by measuring extraction torque on pin removal. In vivo bending stiffness measurements were performed to determine gap healing. A qualitative histologic assessment of the tissue adjacent to pin sites was also performed. RESULTS: A trend (P = 0.056) for less infection around APC-CaP pins was found at 6 weeks, but the strength of this difference diminished with time. Significantly more radiolucency was found around Ti pins after 8 (P = 0.011) and 12 (P < 0.001) weeks. At all pin sites, the extraction torque for APC-CaP pins was higher than for Ti pins (P = 0.007). No difference in the progression of gap healing was found. Histology showed bone growth at the implant surface in the form of distance osteogenesis for Ti and contact osteogenesis for APC-CaP. CONCLUSIONS: This study has shown that the APC-CaP surface improves the clinical performance of Ti pins with respect to pin loosening and pin track infection.     

Tibial plateau stress fracture: a complication of unicompartmental knee arthroplasty using 4 guide pinholes

Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty has gained popularity recently as a treatment for unicompartmental tibiofemoral non inflammatory arthritis. Tibial plateau stress fracture after unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) through guide pin holes placed in the proximal tibia has not been previously reported. In each case in this report, the compressive strength of the proximal tibia was reduced by the drilling of multiple holes for the placement of guide pins and holes for the lugs of the tibia component resulting in fracture through these holes between 3 and 18 weeks (median 8 weeks) post-operatively. In at least one case, the medial tibial cortex was violated by one pin. All cases required revision total knee arthroplasty (TKA). It is intuitive to caution against the use of multiple guide holes in the proximal tibia in UKA. If 3 or more hole pins are deemed necessary, surgeons must be aware of the potential for stress fracture and monitor patients accordingly. Peripheral pins that infract the medial tibial cortex should also be avoided.     

Steinmann pin augmentation versus locking plate constructs

BackgroundAggressive bone neoplasms, such as giant cell tumors, often affect the proximal tibia warranting bony resection via curettage leaving behind massive defects that require extensive reconstruction. Reconstruction is usually accomplished with poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) packing supplemented with an internal fixation construct. The purpose of this study is to compare Steinmann pin augmentation to locking plate constructs to determine which offers the stiffer reconstruction option.ResultsLocking plate constructs (801.8 ± 78 N/mm) had greater (p = 0.041) stiffness than tibial constructs fixed with Steinmann pins (646.5 ± 206.3 N/mm).ConclusionsPermanent deformation was similar between the Pin and Plate group; however, two tibia from the Pin group exhibited displacements >5 mm which we considered failure.

Level of evidence

n/a.     

External fixator pin tract infection model in the caprine (goat) tibia: a randomized, prospective, blinded study

Six goats had 2 Schanz pins inserted in each tibia. Twenty-four pins were inoculated with saline or Staphylococcus aureus. Three investigators, blinded to the inoculum, evaluated 23 pins at 14 days. Clinical pin tract infections developed in all inoculated pins and in 5/12 uninoculated pins, Quantitative cultures demonstrated that infections were produced in 10/11 inoculated and in 0/12 uninoculated pins. Prediction of culture status by clinical criterion (P<.01, Fisher Exact Test) had 100% sensitivity and a 58% specificity. The prediction of infection in inoculated sites by culture criterion (P<.001, Fisher Exact Test) had a 91% sensitivity and 100% specificity. A reproducible long bone pin tract infection model was developed that produced clinically and microbiologically evident pin tract infections.     

The small pin circular fixator for distal tibial pilon fractures with soft tissue compromise

A Monticelli-Spinelli small pin circular external fixator was used in combination with closed reduction or a limited open reduction internal fixation in five cases in an attempt to salvage a satisfactory result in distal tibia pilon fractures when associated soft tissue compromise prevented standard fixation with plates and screws. The small pin fixator enhances the ability to perform a closed reduction through a technique that uses distraction with pins in the tibia and calcaneus, combined with correction of angulation by tensioning wires with a stop nut. Small pin stabilization of these comminuted fractures allows early patient mobilization. The small diameter pins support the soft cancellous bone fragments. This technique attempts to combine the benefits of traction, external fixation, and limited internal fixation. We recommend this technique as a salvage procedure when plates and screws are contraindicated because of poor bone and soft tissue conditions.     

Mechanical evaluation of a ligament fixation system for ACL reconstruction at the tibia in a canine cadaver model

OBJECT: Excellent fixation of an artificial ligament in bone is mandatory for initial stability. ACL reconstruction with the LARS artificial ligament may fail if anchorage to bone is inadequate. The weak metaphyseal bone of the proximal tibia is prone to inadequate fixation. This study evaluates the initial mechanical stability of two techniques with an interference screw on the tibial side of an ACL reconstruction with the LARS ligament. METHODS: Six left tibias were obtained from 1 to 3 year old mongrel dog weighing 20 to 26 kg. ACL straight line reconstruction according to the technique described by J.P. Laboureau was performed with a 4.5 mm drill. Two tunnels were created in the tibia, one oblique and one transverse, the latter 2 cm below the former. Reconstruction was done with a 30-fiber LARS ligament and a 5.2 mm x 15 mm conical titanium cannulated interference screw. Group I had an interference screw in the oblique tunnel and group II had an interference screw in the transverse tunnel. Pull-out tests were performed parallel to the oblique tunnel on an Instron 8521 machine at a speed of 5 mm per minute until failure. The oblique tunnel was tested first then the transverse tunnel. RESULTS: Group I (n = 6): sliding value = 238 +/- 115 N. Group II (n = 6): sliding value = 998 +/- 148 N. This is statistically significant (p < 0.001, student t-test). CONCLUSION: One interference screw in a transverse tibial tunnel for ACL reconstruction with the LARS ligament is 4 times more resistant on loading and impact than an oblique screw.     

Comparative fixation of tibial plateau fractures using alpha-BSM, a calcium phosphate cement, versus cancellous bone graft

OBJECTIVES: To compare the compressive strength of a bone substitute material (alpha-BSM) to cancellous bone when used to fill a defect void in a cadaver model of a Schatzker II split depression fracture of the lateral tibial plateau. DESIGN: Randomized, paired design. SETTING: Biomedical engineering laboratory. PATIENTS: Twenty-six human tibias were harvested from 13 cadavers. Three pairs of tibia fractured during preparation and were excluded. The remaining 10 matched pairs were randomized to fixation by using the bone substitute material or cancellous bone. INTERVENTION: A split depression fracture of the lateral tibial plateau was created in each tibia by using reproducible methods. This fracture was stabilized with a stainless steel L-plate and screws and either alpha-BSM or cancellous bone to fill the defect void. MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS: Stiffness of the elevated fragment in compression, total depression of the joint at 1000 N. RESULTS: The alpha-BSM bone substitute displayed significantly greater stiffness than cancellous bone constructs in Schatzker II split depression fractures of the lateral tibial plateau (P < 0.0001). Plateau defects displaced significantly less at 1000 N when using alpha-BSM in comparison to cancellous bone (P < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: In this cadaveric study, alpha-BSM is an effective bone substitute compared with cancellous bone graft for stabilizing split depression fractures of the lateral tibial plateau.     

Increased insertion torque delays pin-bone interface loosening in external fixation with tapered bone screws

OBJECTIVE: To test the null hypothesis that osseomechanical integration is not related to the maximum insertion torque of tapered external fixation pins. DESIGN: Prospective in vivo study in a functionally loading ovine model. In 12 animals, tapered commercial external fixation pins were inserted at predefined locations with measured insertion torques and extraction torque measured at 10 weeks postoperatively. SETTING: Unrestricted stall activity under veterinary supervision. INTERVENTIONS: Under general anesthesia and aseptic conditions, mid-diaphyseal tibial osteotomies were created and a 3-mm gap width stabilized with a custom-made, high-precision, single-sided external fixator, in compliance with United Kingdom government regulations [Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986]. MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS: Primary pin site stability and interface load were assessed by measuring maximum insertion torque (Nm). At a 10-week postoperative end point, osseomechanical stability was assessed by measuring the extraction torque and a pin performance index determined from the insertion/extraction torque ratio. RESULTS: A positive correlation was found between extraction torque and insertion torque (R2 = 0.322, P < 10(-6)). All pins with an insertion torque equal to or greater than 7 Nm had a measurable extraction torque, as did 98% of the pins with an insertion torque above 5 Nm. Extraction torque decreased both as a function of pin site position by the postoperative end point. High insertion torques were found to enhance end point stability in both diaphyseal and metaphyseal bone. CONCLUSION: The data from this study indicate that tapered external fixation pins should be inserted with a high torque to enhance the long-term integrity of the pin-bone interface.     

Experimental stabilization of segmental defects in the human femur. A torsional study.

One of each of thirty-five pairs of fresh intact femora were tested to failure in torsion, recording the dynamic torque, the absorbed energy, and the angle of rotation. These results were compared with the results obtained with the contralateral femur, reconstituted after removal of a segment. Intramedullary nails with polymethylmethacrylate cement, strips of titanium mesh with cement, bone plates with and without cement, and multiple Steinmann pins with cement were the reconstituting configurations. Bone plates were the strongest configuration; the failure torques in all cases were limited by the stress concentration effects of the holes in the bone used for screw fixation. The use of cement as an adjunct to single-plate fixation provided some additional strength. The torsional strength of femora fixed with Küntscher and Schneider nails was limited by failure of the cement and bone. The use of titanium mesh with polymethylmethacrylate was less effective, because this composite has a low torsional rigidity. The use of multiple Steinmann pins packed with polymethylmethacrylate in the medullary cavity should be discouraged because severe twisting and fragmentation of the surrounding acrylic will occur at low levels of torque.     

The small pin circular fixator for proximal tibial fractures with soft tissue compromise

We used a Monticelli-Spinelli small pin circular external fixator in five cases, in combination with closed reduction or limited open reduction internal fixation, to salvage a satisfactory result in juxtaarticular, intraarticular fractures of the proximal tibia, when associated soft tissue compromise prevented standard fixation with plates and screws. The small pin circular fixator allows juxtaarticular placement of the small pins, enhancing stabilization of the comminuted fractures, allowing early range of motion of the joint and early patient mobilization. The small diameter pins support the soft cancellous bone fragments. This technique attempts to combine the benefits of traction, external fixation, and limited internal fixation. We recommend this method as a salvage procedure when plates and screws are contraindicated because of poor bone and soft tissue conditions.     

Primary stability of bone-patellar tendon-bone graft fixation with biodegradable pins

Purpose: We evaluated the initial bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) graft fixation strength of biodegradable pins compared with interference screws in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using bovine knees. Type of Study: Biomechanical in vitro study. Methods: Ten BPTB grafts from human donors fixed with 2 biodegradable 2.7-mm pins (Rigid Fix; Ethicon, Mitek Division, Norderstedt, Germany) crossing the bone block perpendicular and 10 BPTB grafts fixed with conventional biodegradable interference screws (Absolute Absorbable Interference Screw; Innovasive Devices, Marlborough, MA) underwent ultimate single-cycle failure loading at a rate of 200 mm/min. The grafts were fixed to bovine tibia to simulate young human femoral bone density. Failure mode, displacement before failure, and ultimate failure load were tested with a testing machine. The pullout force was in line with the bone tunnel to simulate a worst case scenario. Results: The failure mode for cross pins was either fracture of the bone block (5 specimens) or fracture of the articular pin (5 specimens). The failure mode for interference screws was slippage past the screw in all specimens. In the single cycle loading test, the mean yield load for the biodegradable pins was 400.2 (± 122.4) N, maximum load, 524.6 (± 136.6) N, with a mean stiffness of 155.2 (± 32.4) N/mm. The yield load at failure for the interference screw was 402.7 (± 143.9) N, maximum load 515.7 (± 168.5) N with a mean stiffness of 168 (± 42) N/mm. Conclusions: Fixation of a BPTB graft with 2 biodegradable 2.7-mm pins (Rigid Fix) leads to primary stability that is comparable to fixation with biodegradable interference screws.