Induction of interferon in L cells by defective-interfering (DI) particles of vesicular stomatitis virus: Lack of correlation with content of [±] snapback RNA

The ability of defective-interfering (DI) particles of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) to induce interferon was studied in relation to the amount of snapback [±] double-stranded sequences in their RNA. Five DI particles propagated in BHK-21 cells were analyzed: two DI particles generated by undiluted passages of cloned wild-type VSV (Indiana); two DI particles generated by serial undiluted passages of culture fluid from L cells persistently infected with VSV; and DI-011, a DI particle with [±] snapback RNA, which is known to be a potent inducer of interferon. Induction of interferon in L cells by these DI particles was not proportional to the amount of [±] sequences in their RNA. DI-011 (26 to 37% [±] RNA sequences) induced a significant amount of interferon at a multiplicity of infection of one DI particle per cell. In contrast, the two DI particles from wild-type VSV (43 to 54% [±] RNA sequences) were 20- to 30-fold less efficient inducers of interferon than DI-011. Furthermore, the two DI particles (1 to 4% [±] RNA sequences) generated from L cell carrier cultures were only slightly less efficient inducers of interferon than the wild-type DI particles. The data also indicate that a population of DI particles which contains [±] RNA is not selected in L cells persistently infected with VSV.     

Differences in the response of normal and transformed BHK21 cells to dual virus infection. Conditions affecting synergism between vesicular stomatitis virus and newcastle disease virus

Polyoma-transformed BHK21 cells were less sensitive than untransformed BHK21 cells to plaque production by vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) although neither the adsorption of the input virus to transformed cells nor the burst size were found to be reduced. Infection of either cell type with an avirulent strain (BI) of Newcastle disease virus (NDV) resulted in only a single cycle of noninfectious NDV hemagglutinin production. Neither BHK21 cells nor a polyoma-transformed clonal derivative (Cl-I) produced detectable interferon in response to NDV infection. On the contrary, dual infection with NDV and VSV resulted in a paradoxical enhancement of VSV plaque number and size in Cl-I but not in BHK21 cells. The degree of synergism was affected by the density of Cl-I cell cultures, by NDV multiplicity, and by the time interval between NDV and VSV infection. These findings suggest that alteration of cell functions affecting cellular sensitivity to single (VSV) and also dual (NDV-VSV) infection may be associated with the virus-transformed state.     

Fate of interferon-treated cells.

Interferon-treated cultures of Ly cells survived initial infection with high multiplicities of vesicular stomatitis (VSV) or herpes simplex virus (HSV). In the case of HSV, infectious virus and intracellular viral antigen were rapidly eliminated from the interferon-treated cultures, and the cells grew out to form apparently normal monolayers that could be cultured indefinitely. In the VSV-infected Ly cultures, virus titers remained at low levels in interferon-treated cells but after about 14 days rapidly rose and the culture was destroyed. If interferon was added to the medium on days 4 and 6 after infection, virus titers rapidly declined but again recovered and the cells were destroyed. If, however, interferon treatment was resumed 9 days after initial infection, detectable infectious VSV was eliminated from the medium. Several methods, including cocultivation and molecular hybridization, failed to demonstrate persistence of a significant portion of the VSV genome in these cultures.     

A persistent infection of baby hamster kidney-21 cells with mumps virus and the role of temperature-sensitive variants.

A persistent infection of baby hamster kidney-21 (BHK-21) cells with mumps virus (BHKpi) was maintained for over 60 cell passages in the absence of antiserum. Viral persistence was demonstrated in the cultures by hemadsorption, immunofluorescence, multinucleate syncytia, and released mumps virus at the level of 10(2)--10(3) fluorescent focus-forming units/ml. No detectable levels of interferon were found in cultures persistently infected with mumps virus. Approximately 85--95% of the cells contained viral antigens. Nuclear fluorescence was observed in the persistently infected cells. Mumps virus from persistently infected clutures (MuVpi) was more heat-labile than wild-type mumps (MuVo) when subjected to 40 degrees C. BHKpi cells had a more rapid doubling time and a higher cloning efficiency in soft agar in comparison to BHK-21 cells. MuVpi was also found to be temperature-sensitive. The temperature-sensitivity of MuVpi was determined by the efficiency of plating at 33 degrees and 39 degrees C. MuVpi readily established a persistent infection in BHK-21 cells with less cytopathology than MuVo, and released temperature-sensitive virus.     

The use of vesicular stomatitis virus pseudotype production in the study of a temperature-sensitive murine leukemia virus.

A mutant of Moloney murine leukemia virus (MoLV), designated ts₃ was recently shown to have a temperature-sensitive defect associated with the release of mature virus particles budding from the cell membrane [Wong, P. K. Y., and McCarter, J. A., Virology58, 396–408 (1974)]. In an attempt to determine whether the defective function resides in an envelope component of the virion, the formation of pseudotypes between VSV and ts₃ was studied under nonpermissive and permissive conditions of ts₃ infection. Whereas similar levels of phenotypic mixing were observed between VSV and wild-type MoLV at both 39 and 34°, the level of pseudotypes formed between VSV and ts₃ was found to be considerably lower at 39° (nonpermissive temperature) than at 34° (permissive temperature). The results of temperature-shift experiments indicate that two separate blocks to VSV ts₃ pseudotype production may occur depending on the length of time ts₃-infected cells are incubated at the nonpermissive temperature. Preincubation of ts₃-infected cells for 24 hr at 39°, prior to superinfection with VSV at 39°, prevents pseudotype formation. In contrast, brief incubation at 39°C, coincident with VSV infection, introduces a reversible block on the release of VSV (ts₃) pseudotypes from the cell membrane. Complementation of ts₃ through ts₃ (VSV) pseudotype production was not detected at the nonpermissive temperature.     

Induction of interferon by temperature-sensitive mutants of Newcastle disease virus

Spontaneously-selected and mutagen-induced temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants of Newcastle disease virus (NDV) were used to study interferon induction in chick embryo (CE) cells at temperatures permissive (37°) and nonpermissive (42°) for virus replication. Both infectious and UV-irradiated virus were tested for interferon-inducing ability in cells pretreated or not pretreated with homologous interferon. At 37°, only UV-irradiated NDV was capable of inducing interferon in cells not treated with interferon before infection. In cells pretreated with interferon, on the other hand, both unirradiated and UV-irradiated virus stimulated the production of interferon. At 42°, the interferon-inducing phenotype for some UV-irradiated ts mutants was dependent on whether or not cells were pretreated with interferon. For example, out of 10 mutants examined, one UV-irradiated ts mutant induced interferon in both untreated and interferon pretreated cells; 7 mutants failed to induce in untreated cells but induced from 25–100% of the wild-type level of interferon in cells pretreated with interferon; and two mutants failed to induce interferon in both types of cells. In addition, one mutant (NDV₀ts-100) induced low or undetectable levels of interferon at both 37° and 42°, conditions under which wild-type virus (NDV₀) produced significant levels of interferon. Co-infection of cells with UV-irradiated ts-100 and a preparation of NDV₀ exposed to prolonged irradiation resulted in considerable production of interferon. These results suggest the possibility that more than one virus function may be involved in interferon induction by NDV in CE cells.     

Cytopathic effect induced by rabies virus in McCoy cells.

Both fixed and street rabies virus when cultivated in McCoy cells caused cytopathic changes 24 to 72 h after infection, depending on the multiplicity of infection. The cytopathic effect (CPE) was easily recognizable and resembles that induced by other members of the Rhabdovirus group, such as vesicular stomatitis virus, in several cell cultures. Higher titers of the Pasteur strain (PV) of fixed rabies virus were found in supernatants of McCoy cells when compared to those in VERO cells. The virus titer increased with the number of passages attaining a high titer after three passages. Rabies antigens were detected by direct immunofluorescence labeling in most McCoy cells of the infected culture, and specific antibodies neutralized the virus growth and CPE. There was also inhibition by treatment of the cells with human interferon (HuIFN) -alpha or -gamma, but not by murine interferon (MuIFN) -alpha, -beta or -gamma. Rabies-infected McCoy cell cultures may provide a useful assay system, based on the induction of CPE, the high virus production and the sensitivity to IFN.     

Appearance of defective simian virus 40 following infection of cultured human glioblastoma cells.

Infection of human glioblastoma cells (A172) with SV40 is followed by virus propagation and cell death. Abbreviated viral genomes, however, appear rapidly in the virus pool. These are shown to be defective (i.e., they require helper activity from standard virus) and to exhibit interference with the lytic growth of standard virus. Experiments with triply plaque-purified SV40 have demonstrated (1) that substantial levels of defectives appear within one very low multiplicity infection of A172 cells or within two to three moderately low multiplicity passages; (2) that defectives are in fact generated at a high rate in A172 cells; and (3) that the generation and amplification processes do not select strongly for particular genome sizes. Carrier cultures have been established in the A172 cells. The unusual features of the accumulation of defective SV40 in A172 cells are the high rate of accumulation and the lack of a requirement for high multiplicity passage to amplify and to maintain high levels of defectives.     

Rescue of vesicular stomatitis virus from interferon-induced resistance by superinfection with vaccinia virus: I. Rescue in cell cultures from different species

The replication of two DNA viruses, vaccinia and pseudorabies (PsRV), was not inhibited in three cell lines of rabbit origin (RK-13 and RK-1337, rabbit kidney; and RC-60, rabbit cornea) which had been pretreated with rabbit interferon. In contrast, the replication of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), an RNA virus, was susceptible to interferon-induced resistance in rabbit cell lines. These results reinforced the possibility that there are separate interferon-induced resistance factors for RNA and DNA viruses and that cultured rabbit cells are deficient in the synthesis of the resistance factors needed to inhibit DNA viruses.When cell cultures of rabbit origin were pretreated with homologous interferon and doubly infected with vaccinia and VSV, a variety of responses was observed. Vaccinia was able to rescue VSV from the inhibitory effects of interferon-induced resistance in two rabbit cell lines (RK-13 and RC-60), but not in RK-1337 cells. Similar experiments were carried out in mouse L cells and in primary chick embryo (CE) cell cultures; both RNA and DNA viruses were susceptible to inhibition by interferon-induced resistance in these cells. In L cells, double infection with vaccinia was able to rescue VSV; however, in CE cell cultures superinfection with vaccinia did not rescue VSV from the inhibitory effect of interferon. In these cells the synthetic pathways or virion factors furnished by vaccinia which are required for the rescue of VSV are sensitive to the action of interferon.     

Properties of the viruses selected during persistent infection of L cells with VSV.

Two virus clones, VSV-mp and VSV-sp, were isolated from L cells persistently infected with VSV (New Jersey serotype). Both clones were more temperature sensitive than the parent virus, VSV-o, and grew more slowly, gave smaller plaques, less c.p.e. and lower virus yields in L cells. Unlike the parent virus, both persistent viruses induced interferon production in L cells. Stable carrier cultures could be obtained from L cells infected with VSV-sp at low multiplicities without pretreatment with interferon. This may be related to the fact that VSV-sp is more sensitive to interferon than either VSV-mp or VSV-o.     

Rescue of vesicular stomatitis virus from interferon-induced resistance by superinfection with vaccinia virus. II. Effect of UV-inactivated vaccinia and metabolic inhibitors

The rescue of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) from interferon-induced resistance in rabbit (RK-13) and mouse (L) cell cultures superinfected with vaccinia requires early (up to 2 hr) vaccinia DNA-dependent RNA synthesis. The inability of hydroxyurea to inhibit rescue of VSV in interferon-treated RK-13 and L cells, whether the drug is added at the time of or after infection, suggests that vaccinia DNA synthesis is not required for the rescue of VSV in cells superinfected with vaccinia.In both RK-13 and L cells pretreated with homologous interferon and then doubly infected with vaccinia and VSV, there was a significant increase (up to 8 hr) in the lag period before infective VSV progeny appeared. It appears that a product of vaccinia synthesis must accumulate before VSV replication can begin in cells pretreated with interferon. This product could be vaccinia-directed early RNA or a translation product of this RNA.In RK-13 cells pretreated with interferon, the ability of vaccinia to rescue VSV is much more resistant to UV-irradiation than the infectivity of the virus; in L cells there is a close correspondence in the inactivation rates of infectivity and the ability of vaccinia to rescue VSV. These results suggest a difference in the efficiency of uncoating of UV-irradiated vaccinia in RK-13 and L cells. In L cells it is possible that UV-irradiated vaccinia is not uncoated efficiently and the early vaccinia RNA product required for rescue of VSV is not synthesized.     

A carrier state in hamster-embryo cells with the Naples strain of phlebotomus fever virus

Summary Hamster embryonic cells, in which the Naples strain of phlebotomus fever virus multiplied without cytopathic effect, continued to yield virus for at least 15 serial passages over a period of ten weeks. This carrier state was not associated with production of interferon, but the cells continued to show resistance to infection with vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV). When 3×10⁵ carrier cells were planted on top of a monolayer of normal hamster embryonic cells and allowed to grow for three days, no plaques appeared on inoculation of VSV. When smaller numbers of carrier cells were planted in a similar manner, the number of plaques was reduced in proportion to the number of cells that were planted.This paper was part of a thesis approved for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the University of London.Visiting worker on a fellowship from the University of Khartoum, Sudan.     

A temperature-sensitive mutant of Sendai virus which establishes persistent infection in Vero cells without cell crisis

Eleven temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants of Sendai virus were examined for the ability to establish persistent infection in Vero cells at 37°. Only one mutant, ts-23, readily established persistent infection, while some of the mutants tested, like the parental wild virus, required long-term subcultivation for the establishment of persistent infection because of repeated cell crisis, and the remaining mutants failed to establish persistent infection. The ts-23 mutant replicated well in Vero cells, but infected cells showed no cytopathic effect and were readily subcultured. The fluid of these cultures contained neither defective interfering particles nor interferon, indicating that these factors are not involved in the establishment of persistent infection. In mixed infections, ts-23 virus markedly inhibited the development of cytopathic effect by the wild-type virus or the other ts mutants, and all or a part of the cells in the cultures beame persistently infected without showing cell crisis.     

Studies of L cells persistently infected with VSV: factors involved in the regulation of persistent infection.

Infection of interferon-treated L cells with VSV led frequently to the establishment of L cells persistently infected with VSV (LVSV cells). These cells were characterized by the following properties; (I) no supplement of antiviral factors such as anti-VSV antiserum, interferon, was required for their maintenance; (2) virus antigens were detected in about 5 to 30% of the cells by immunofluorescence staining; (3) the cells were not only resistant to superinfection by homologous virus, but also resistant to challenge by heterologous viruses such as Mengo virus; (4) the cells were destroyed by co-cultivation with heterologous cells susceptible to VSV infection; (5) the cells could be cured by serial cultivation in medium containing antiviral antibody, and the cured cells were as susceptible to VSV as normal L cells. It was shown that at least three factors (interferon, defective interfering [DI] particles and a selection of small-plaque temperature-sensitive [ts] mutants) took part in the maintenance of LVSV cells although it was difficult to evaluate exactly the relative importance of these factors. The effect of antiviral antibody, interferon and incubation temperature upon the maintenance of LVSV cells are discussed further.     

Latent pseudorabies virus infection established at supraoptimal temperature.

Little or no infectious virus was recovered from BHK-21 cells adapted to 40 degrees C, when they were infected with an attenuated strain of pseudorabies virus (PRV) at low multiplicity of infection (MOI) and subsequently kept at 40 degrees C. By passaging the infected cells at 40 degrees C, infectious virus disappeared within 2-3 passages. When the cells were shifted down to 37 degrees C, activation of virus growth occurred after a latent period of 48-72 hr. Infected cells kept at 40 degrees C were as sensitive to superinfection with the virulent PRV strain TOP as the control cells. The ability of PRV strains to enter into the described latent state was related with the degree of their virulence. When cells were treated with 5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine (BUdR) at 40 degrees C for 24 hr and then shifted to 37 degrees C, a slight increase in the number of infectious centres was observed and the latent period was also prolonged.     

Multiplicity-dependent replication of varicella-zoster virus in interferon-treated cells.

The inhibitory effects of interferon (IF) on the replication of varicella-zoster (VZ) virus in human foreskin fibroblast (HFF) cultures inoculated with infected cells or with cell-free virus were assayed by measuring (1) yields of infected cells, (2) plaques, (3) microfoci and (4) cytopathic effects. More IF was needed to reduce yields of infected cells at high input multiplicities of challenge than at low input multiplicites, and still more IF was needed to prevent cytopathology due to VZ virus. A cell-free virus inoculum was more sensitive to the inhibitory effects of IF than an inoculum of infected cells. With the latter, but not with cell-free virus, the continuous presence of IF in the medium was necessary for it to express its maximum antiviral activity. To explain these results, it is suggested that some herpesviruses may establish "reservoirs' of infectivity and thus provide a prolonged challenge to IF-treated cells which are not uniformly resistant to infection.     

A persistent infection of Vero cells by egg-adapted mumps virus

Serial subculture of Vero cells infected with the chick embryo adapted Enders strain of mumps virus gives rise to a low level productive though persistent infection. Persistently infected cultures exhibit minimal cytopathology; however, widely dispersed foci of multinucleate cells are almost always present. Neither infected cell nor virus growth is temperature sensitive. Biological and biochemical evidence indicate that defective interfering particles are replicated along with infectious (nondefective) virus during the course of the persistent infection, although the plaque-purified inoculum virus stock contained only genome size RNA. With continued cell passage a heterogeneous, changing population of subgenomic sized viral RNA accumulates, suggesting that defective interfering (DI) RNA species are evolving from virion RNA, with no single DI RNA predominating. Since such factors as interferon, antibody, and temperature-sensitive mutants are absent from this system, DI particles are the likely factor modulating this persistent infection.     

Persistence of vesicular stomatitis virus in interferon-treated cell cultures.

A significant difference was observed in the functional stability of the vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) genome in mouse L cells and the RK-13 line of rabbit kidney cells pretreated with homologous interferon. By utilizing the ability of vaccinia to rescue VSV from the inhibitory effects of interferon in these cell lines, it was demonstrated that there was a loss of a rescuable form of VSV genome in RK-13 cells pretreated with interferon; superinfection with vaccinia 24 hr after VSV infection did not result in a significant increase in VSV yield. In contrast, significant rescue of VSV occurred in interferon-treated L cells superinfected with vaccinia as late as 72 hr after VSV infection.The present study also provides evidence that in interferon-treated RK-13 cells doubly infected with VSV and vaccinia there was a correlation of the rescuability of the VSV genome and its ability to direct RNA synthesis.