Spinal cord lesions in patients with multiple sclerosis: comparison of MR pulse sequences.

PURPOSETo compare T2-weighted conventional spin-echo (CSE), fast spin-echo (FSE), shorttau inversion recovery (STIR) FSE, and fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) FSE sequences in the assessment of cervical multiple sclerosis plaques.METHODSTwenty patients with clinically confirmed multiple sclerosis and signs of cervical cord involvement were examined on a 1.5-T MR system. Sagittal images of T2-weighted and proton density-weighted CSE sequences, T2-weighted FSE sequences with two different sets of sequence parameters, STIR-FSE sequences, and FLAIR-FSE sequences were compared by two independent observers. In addition, contrast-to-noise measurements were obtained.RESULTSSpinal multiple sclerosis plaques were seen best on STIR-FSE images, which yielded the highest lesion contrast. Among the T2-weighted sequences, the FSE technique provided better image quality than did the CSE technique, but lesion visibility was improved only with a repetition time/echo time of 2500/90; parameters of 3000/150 provided poor lesion contrast but the best myelographic effect and overall image quality. CSE images were degraded by prominent image noise; FLAIR-FSE images showed poor lesion contrast and strong cerebrospinal fluid pulsation artifacts.CONCLUSIONSThe STIR-FSE sequence is the best choice for assessment of spinal multiple sclerosis plaques. For T2-weighted FSE sequences, shorter echo times are advantageous for spinal cord imaging, long echo times are superior for extramedullary and extradural disease. FLAIR-FSE sequences do not contribute much to spinal imaging for multiple sclerosis detection.     

Sagittal MR of multiple sclerosis in the spinal cord: fast versus conventional spin-echo imaging.

PURPOSEWe compared conventional spin-echo (CSE) with fast spin-echo (FSE) dual-echo MR images to determine which of these sequences was better able to depict spinal cord abnormalities in patients with multiple sclerosis (MS).METHODSCSE and FSE dual-echo MR images were obtained in 37 patients with MS and in six healthy control subjects, all of whom were examined on a 1.0-T MR unit with a phased-array coil and cardiac triggering. Two blinded interpreters graded the MR studies, first separately and then by consensus. Images were scored for presence of artifacts, number of focal lesions, and presence of a diffuse increase in signal intensity.RESULTSNo abnormalities were seen in the volunteers. The CSE sequences were significantly less hindered by MR imaging artifacts than were the FSE sequences. Interobserver agreement was slightly higher for the CSE than the FSE sequences. After reaching a consensus, the observers found that both CSE and FSE techniques enabled detection of approximately the same number of focal lesions; however, in three patients, small single lesions seen on the CSE images were missed on the FSE images. Also, depiction of a diffuse increase in signal intensity was better on the CSE images. As a result, more patients had abnormal findings on the CSE sequences than on the FSE sequences (35 versus 31).CONCLUSIONCardiac-triggered dual-echo FSE sequences are almost as good as CSE sequences for depicting spinal MS lesions. Therefore, in cases of established spinal MS, FSE techniques may be as effective as CSE techniques. Because sensitivity for subtle abnormalities is lower with FSE imaging, CSE remains the preferred technique for patients with suspected MS of the spinal cord.     

MRI in multiple sclerosis of the spinal cord: evaluation of fast short-tan inversion-recovery and spin-echo sequences

We compared the sensitivity of T2-weighted spin-echo (FSE) and fast short-tau inversion-recovery (fSTIR) sequences in detection of multiple sclerosis of the spinal cord in 100 consecutive patients with clinically confirmed multiple sclerosis (MS); 86 patients underwent also brain MRI. In all, 310 focal lesions were detected on fSTIR and 212 on T2-weighted FSE, spinal cord lesions were seen better on fSTIR images, with a higher contrast between the lesion and the normal spinal cord. In 24 patients in whom cord plaques were shown with both sequences, the cranial study was normal or inconclusive. Assessment of spinal plaques can be particularly important when MRI of the brain is inconclusive, and in there situations fSTIR can be helpful. Received: 20 October 1999 Accepted: 23 February 2000     

Hepatic T2-weighted MRI: A prospective comparison of sequences,including breath-hold,half-Fourier turbo spin echo (HASTE)

The purpose of this study was to quantitatively compare the hepatic contrast characteristics of conventional spin-echo (CSE) and fast spin-echo (FSE) sequences with breath-hold T2-weighted images acquired with half-Fourier turbo spin echo (HASTE). Forty-five patients were examined with a phased-array surface coil. Nineteen patients had focal hepatic lesions, including eight malignant tumors, 10 cavernous hemangiomas, and one hepatic adenoma. Twenty-six patients had no focal hepatic lesions. T2-weighted images with comparable TE were acquired with CSE, FSE, and HASTE pulse sequences. Signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) for liver, spleen, and lesions were measured. FSE demonstrated significantly better quantitative performance than CSE for liver-spleen CNR (P = .0084). No statistically significant difference was demonstrated between FSE and CSE for liver or spleen SNR. FSE demonstrated clear scan time and resolution advantages over CSE. HASTE performed significantly poorer than CSE and FSE for liver-spleen CNR (P < .0001), liver SNR (P = .0002 for CSE and P < .0001 for FSE), and spleen SNR (P < .0001). Optimized FSE images with a short echo train length performed comparably to CSE images of equivalent TE. Liver-lesion CNR was suppressed on HASTE images, suggesting that long echo train length FSE sequences could diminish solid lesion detection compared to CSE and short echo train length FSE.     

A comparison of conventional spin-echo and fast spin-echo in the detection of multiple sclerosis

Fast spin-echo (FSE) pulse sequences enable T2-weighted imaging in a fraction of the time required for T2-weighted conventional spin-echo (CSE) imaging. Due to concerns that the altered contrast characteristics of FSE may interfere with the visualization of multiple sclerosis (MS) lesions, the sensitivity of T2-weighted FSE sequences was compared to comparably weighted CSE sequences in the imaging of the brain in 100 patients with clinically suspected MS. The proton-density FSE sequence revealed more MS lesions than its CSE counterpart, while the T2-weighted CSE sequences were found to be more sensitive than the T2-weighted FSE sequence. Contrast-to-noise ratios and signal-to-noise ratios compared favorably between sequences. Overall, there was little difference in the specificity between FSE and CSE in the diagnosis of MS. The higher sensitivity and the reduction in time attainable through the use of FSE warrants its replacement of CSE when imaging the brain in patients with clinically suspected MS. J. Magn. Reson. Imaging 2001;13:657-667.     

MRI in the investigation of patients with myelopathy thought to be due to multiple sclerosis

The role of cerebral and spinal cord MRI was investigated in 65 patients with myelopathy suspected of having demyelinating disease. Cerebral MRI demonstrated lesions compatible with demyelination in 80% and spinal cord MRI in 68.6%. In 28.5% of our patients brain lesions were present with normal spinal cord images, but in 17% spinal cord lesions were depicted with a normal brain MRI. The combination of the two examinations demonstrated lesions in 97% of the patients. The frequency of coexistent cerebral lesions in patients with spinal cord lesions was over 85% in patients with chronic disease but only 28.5% in patients with acute myelitis.     

Comparison of three MR sequences for the detection of cervical cord lesions in patients with multiple sclerosis.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Improving the sensitivity of MR imaging for the detection of multiple sclerosis (MS) lesions in the cord might be useful in the diagnostic workup and could lead to a better understanding of the evolution of the disease. The purpose of this study was to compare fast spin-echo (FSE) with magnetization transfer-prepared gradient-echo (MT-GE) and fast short-inversion-time inversion recovery (fast-STIR) MR sequences to determine which is best for imaging cervical cord lesions in MS patients. METHODS: FSE, MT-GE, and fast-STIR MR images were obtained in 56 MS patients and 10 healthy control subjects with a 1.5-T MR system and a phased-array coil. Cord lesions seen on images obtained with each sequence were counted by two observers in two stages (stage 1: random review of the complete sets of images from each technique; stage 2: side-by-side review with a retrospective count of lesions). RESULTS: At the end of stage 1, a mean of 1.16 cord lesions per patient were seen on FSE images, 1.57 on MT-GE images (35% more than on FSE), and 1.92 on fast-STIR images (66% more than on FSE). Two or more cervical cord lesions were found on 16 FSE images (29%), 23 on MT-GE images (46%), and 30 on fast-STIR images (54%). Differences were reduced after stage 2: MT-GE detected 22% more lesions and fast-STIR 36% more lesions than FSE. Considering the three sequences together, 113 cervical cord lesions were seen in 50 patients (89%). CONCLUSION: Both MT-GE and fast-STIR sequences depict more cervical cord MS lesions than the FSE sequence, with fast-STIR having the best sensitivity. Fast-STIR MR images may be useful for the diagnostic workup of patients with suspected MS and for improving our understanding of the evolution of MS.     

Optimisation of unenhanced MRI for detection of lesions in multiple sclerosis: a comparison of five pulse sequences with variable slice thickness

We used five MRI sequences in six patients with multiple sclerosis (MS): conventional spin-echo (CSE) with 5-mm slices; 2D fast spin-echo (FSE) with 2-mm slices; multishot T2^*-weighted echo-planar imaging (EPI) with 5-mm slices; fast fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (fFLAIR) with 2-mm slices; and 3D fast spin-echo with 1.5-mm-thick slices. A total of 225 lesions were detected on CSE, 274 on 2D FSE, 137 on EPI, 385 on fFLAIR and 320 on 3D FSE. The EPI sequence was clearly the least sensitive and susceptibility artefact was a problem, particularly in the brain stem and temporal lobes. Fast FLAIR displayed a much higher number of supratentorial lesions (380) than 3D FSE (297), 2D FSE (264) or CSE (211). However, in the posterior cranial fossa 3D FSE was the most sensitive sequence (23 lesions), followed by CSE (14) and 2D FSE (10), while fFLAIR (5) was extremely insensitive.     

Pathology-guided MR analysis of acute and chronic experimental allergic encephalomyelitis spinal cord lesions at 1.5T

PURPOSE: To directly correlate spinal cord pathology of guinea pigs with experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) to the MRI data obtained at 1.5T. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Spinal cords from EAE animals were imaged in vivo with the following MRI sequences: T2-FSE, PD-FSE, fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR)-FSE, T2-CSE, T1-CSE, T1-CSE + gadolinium-DTPA (Gd-DTPA), PD-CSE, and short-tau inversion recovery (STIR)-FSE. The spinal cords were removed and the lesions with specific pathological compositions were identified by histological analysis. Regions of interest (ROIs) were drawn on the corresponding MR images, and signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) were measured for each MR sequence and compared with controls. RESULTS: The receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis of STIR-FSE and PD-CSE was able to differentiate tissue that contained cellular infiltrates with a high degree of accuracy. The SNRs of T2-FSE, STIR-FSE, T2-CSE, PD-CSE, and T1-CSE + Gd-DTPA were elevated in lesions that contained cellular infiltrates alone, whereas the SNRs of PD-CSE and T1-CSE + Gd-DTPA were reduced in demyelinated lesions that also contained inflammation. CONCLUSION: The SNR difference between the two lesion groups suggests that the combination of STIR-FSE, PD-CSE, and T1-CSE + Gd-DTPA sequences may be useful for differentiating inflammatory lesions containing demyelination from lesions with inflammation alone.     

Fast spin-echo imaging of the temporomandibular joint

The applicability of a fast spin-echo (PSE) technique for magnetic resonance imaging of the tem-poromandibular joint (TMJ) was studied, and the technique compared with a conventional spin-echo (CSE) technique. Sagittal Tl-weighted CSE and dual-echo FSE images of 50 TMJs in 25 patients with symptoms of internal TMJ derangement were compared. CSE and FSE images were diagnostically comparable in 22 TMJs (44%). The FSE technique was rated better than CSE imaging for delineation of the disk in 26 joints (52%), whereas the CSE technique was rated better in only two joints (4%). The FSE technique was preferred overall in 54% of the joints. Mild to moderate joint effusion was detected in 17 joints because additional T2-weighted data were provided with the dual-echo FSE technique. The study showed that FSE imaging is an effective technique for evaluation of the TMJ. It is faster and diagnostically comparable to or better than CSE imaging, with the added advantage of providing T2-weighted data.     

Fast spin echo vs conventional spin echo in cervical spine imaging

The major attraction of fast-spin-echo (FSE) imaging is reduced acquisition time; however, careful review of the literature reveals many weaknesses: phase-encoded blurring, truncation artefact, bright fat signal, reduced magnetic susceptibility and increased motion artefact. Our aim was a prospective, blinded comparison of FSE and conventional spin echo (CSE) in the cervical spine. Both sequences were performed in 43 patients (19 males and 24 females; mean age 45 years, range 15–66 years). Twenty-eight patients were studied at 1.5 T and 15 at 0.5 T. Typical sequence parameters were: at 1.5 T, TR/TE 2000/90 CSE and 3000/120 FSE, and at 0.5 T, 2200/80 CSE and 2800/120 FSE. Time saved on the FSE was used to increase the matrix and the number of acquisitions. Two neuroradiologists evaluated the images for pathology, artefacts, disc signal intensity, thecal sac compression and image quality. Ten patients had cord lesions; 2 (20 %) were missed on CSE. In 4 of 10 patients with moderate/severe thecal sac compression, the degree of stenosis was apparently exaggerated on CSE. The mean degree of confidence for the CSE sequences was 1.8 and for the FSE 1.1, where 1 is optimal. For cervical spine imaging, FSE should be preferred to CSE. Received 6 May 1996; Revision received 19 July 1996; Accepted 26 February 1997     

A comparison of conventional and fast spin-echo sequences for the measurement of lesion load in multiple sclerosis using a semi-automated contour technique

Changes on serial assessments of brain MRI lesion load are used for monitoring therapeutic efficacy in patients with multiple sclerosis (MS). We assessed the accuracy and reliability of conventional spin-echo (CSE) and fast spin-echo (FSE) sequences for measurement of lesion volume using a semiautomated contour technique. Cranial CSE and FSE examinations of 18 patients with secondary progressive MS were studied. The mean lesion load was slightly higher with the CSE sequence (p = 0.002). Intraobserver variability was significantly higher for FSE than for CSE, according to both the coefficient of variation between two measurements (mean 2.48 % and 1.35 % respectively, p < 0.05) and back-transformed 95 % limits of agreement (1.005–1.060 for FSE; 0.988–1.019 for CSE). Although FSE sequences are quicker and the total lesion volume measurements are similar to those obtained with CSE, the poorer reproducibility raises doubts about the use of FSE to replace CSE in clinical trials. Received: 26 March 1996 Accepted: 4 April 1996     

Comparison of T2-weighted spin-echo and fast spin-echo techniques in the evaluation of myelination

To evaluate T2-weighted fast spin-echo (FSE) and conventional spin-echo (CSE) magnetic resonance (MR) techniques in the assessment of brain myelination, 100 consecutive pediatric patients were imaged prospectively with both CSE and FSE sequences. All patients underwent a routine MR examination that included T2-weighted CSE imaging (imaging time, 10 minutes 21 seconds) and T2-weighted FSE imaging (imaging time, 2 minutes 5 seconds). The two techniques were compared for estimating the degree of myelination (using normal anatomic landmarks) by blind review. With T2-weighted CSE images as the “gold standard” for estimation of normal myelination, FSE images were evaluated to determine if they showed the degree of myelination similarly to CSE images. There was a strong correlation (P <.01) between CSE and FSE images in the estimation of myelination over a wide range of patient ages.     

Fast spin-echo MR imaging of the female pelvis. Part I. Use of a whole-volume coil.

In this prospective study, axial and sagittal magnetic resonance (MR) images were obtained with T2-weighted conventional spin-echo (CSE) and fast spin-echo (FSE) sequences in 34 consecutive female patients who underwent clinical pelvic MR examination at 1.5 T. The MR images from each patient were compared side by side, blindly and independently, by two radiologists experienced in MR imaging who used a standardized score sheet for anatomic and pathologic findings. The FSE sequences were rated superior significantly more often than the CSE sequences in most categories of findings (P less than .05), including overall image quality and reduction of motion artifact. The examination time for the FSE sequences was 1 minute 46 seconds versus an examination time of 9 minutes 14 seconds for the CSE sequences. (Both CSE and FSE sequences provided 18 sections.) It is concluded that the FSE sequence provides T2-weighted anatomic and pathologic information superior to that provided by the CSE sequence and requires substantially less imaging time.     

High-resolution constructive interference in a steady state imaging of cervicothoracic adhesive arachnoiditis

PURPOSE: To assess the usefulness of constructive interference in a steady state (CISS) sequence for an evaluation of cervicothoracic adhesive arachnoiditis. METHODS: Seven patients with arachnoiditis underwent magnetic resonance imaging with T1- and T2-weighted fast spin-echo (FSE) and 3-dimensional CISS sequences. Three observers compared T2-weighted FSE and 3-dimensional CISS images with regard to image quality for spinal adhesive arachnoiditis. Magnetic resonance appearances accompanied with cervicothoracic adhesive arachnoiditis on CISS coupled with T2-weighted FSE sequences were also evaluated. RESULTS: The CISS images were superior to T2-weighted FSE images in the demarcation of spinal cord, dura matter, nerve root, and adhesive point. In our 7 cases with cervicothoracic adhesive arachnoiditis, dural thickening in 2 cases, syringomyelia in 6, arachnoidal cysts in 3, findings of presyrinx in 2, intramedullary microcyst in 2, and deformity of the spinal cord were present. CONCLUSIONS: A CISS sequence was more desirable for an evaluation of the cervicothoracic adhesive arachnoiditis than T2-weighted FSE images and could provide useful additional information.     

脊髓亚急性联合变性的MRI诊断价值及临床特点

目的:探讨MRI对脊髓亚急性联合变性(SCD)的诊断价值及其临床表现。方法:维生素B_(12)缺乏及临床诊断为SDC患者9例,行MRI检查,扫描序列包括矢状面SE T_1WI、FSE T_2WI、T_2-FLAIR及横轴面T_2WI,其中6例行Gd- DTPA增强扫描。结果:MR图像上所有病例均显示颈髓或胸髓侧索或后索对称性病变,T_1WI上显示为等或稍低信号,T_2WI上为高信号,T_2-FLAIR上为高信号,病灶范围显示清晰,Gd-DTPA增强扫描病灶无明显强化。结论:MRI有助于SCD的诊断和随访观察,尤其是T_2-FLAIR序列,能准确显示病变范围。     

Comparison of a conventional cardiac-triggered dual spin-echo and a fast STIR sequence in detection of spinal cord lesions in multiple sclerosis

The current optimal imaging protocol in spinal cord MR imaging in patients with multiple sclerosis includes a long TR conventional spin-echo (CSE) sequence, requiring long acquisition times. Using short tau inversion recovery fast spin-echo (fast STIR) sequences both acquisition time can be shortened and sensitivity in the detection of multiple sclerosis (MS) abnormalities can be increased. This study compares both sequences for the potential to detect both focal and diffuse spinal abnormalities. Spinal cords of 5 volunteers and 20 MS patients were studied at 1.0 T. Magnetic resonance imaging included cardiac-gated sagittal dual-echo CSE and a cardiac-gated fast STIR sequence. Images were scored regarding number, size, and location of focal lesions, diffuse abnormalities and presence/hindrance of artifacts by two experienced radiologists. Examinations were scored as being definitely normal, indeterminate, or definitely abnormal. Interobserver agreement regarding focal lesions was higher for CSE (ϰ = 0.67) than for fast STIR (ϰ = 0.57) but did not differ significantly. Of all focal lesions scored in consensus, 47 % were scored on both sequences, 31 % were only detected by fast STIR, and 22 % only by dual-echo CSE (n. s.). Interobserver agreement for diffuse abnormalities was lower with fast STIR (ϰ = 0.48) than dual-echo CSE (ϰ = 0.65; n. s.). After consensus, fast STIR showed in 10 patients diffuse abnormalities and dual-echo CSE in 3. After consensus, in 19 of 20 patients dual-echo CSE scans were considered as definitely abnormal compared with 17 for fast STIR. The fast STIR sequence is a useful adjunct to dual-echo CSE in detecting focal abnormalities and is helpful in detecting diffuse MS abnormalities in the spinal cord. Due to the frequent occurrence of artifacts and the lower observer concordance, fast STIR cannot be used alone. Received: 9 September 1999; Revised: 14 December 1999; Accepted: 16 December 1999     

Practical choices of fast spin echo pulse sequence parameters: clinically useful proton density and T2-weighted contrasts

Summary With the development of fast spin echo (FSE) MRI techniques, T2-weighted images of the brain may be obtained much more quickly than when using conventional spin echo techniques (CSE), because made the individual echoes on the FSE pulse sequence are phase encoded, allowing acquisition of the same spatial information as in CSE with less excitations. The pulse sequence parameters (echo train length, bandwidth echo spacing) are discussed. Images were obtained on four volunteers using both CSE and FSE while varying repetition time, echo time and matrix. Comparison for signal intensity gray-white differentiation, fat and CSE signal, arifacts and vascular resolution showed that FSE images comparable in quality to those of CSE can be obtained in less than half the time. A practical choice of FSE parameters is recommended for clinical use. However, artifacts, possibly related to CSF and vascular pulsation, of which the radiologist should be aware, were identified on the FSE images.     

MRI of the knee: value of short echo time fast spin-echo using high performance gradients versus conventional spin-echo imaging for the detection of meniscal tears

Objective. Fast spin-echo (FSE) sequences reduce imaging time compared with conventional spin-echo (CSE) sequences, but may result in blurring. High-performance gradients permit shorter interecho spacing and use of the second echo as the effective TE (20 ms); both improvements reduce blurring. This randomized observer study compared a short TE, second-echo FSE sequence obtained using high-performance gradients and a CSE sequence with similar TR/TE for the detection of meniscal tears in the knee. Design and patients. One hundred consecutive MR examinations of the knee using FSE and CSE sequences at 1.5 T were evaluated. The FSE sequence used an effective TE of 20 ms (centered on the second echo at 2 times minimal interecho spacing) and an echo train length of 4. FSE and CSE parameters were otherwise similar. Four independent, masked readers reviewed randomized sagittal FSE and CSE sequences. Results. Cases were assessed for the presence or absence of meniscal tears and, if present, whether tears were medial or lateral and anterior or posterior. Sequence concordance was 93.5% (1496 of 1600 meniscal segments); the intermethod kappa value was 0.78. Sequence quality was graded from 1 to 5. Average quality of CSE images was slightly but statistically significantly preferred by three of the four readers. Conclusion. There was no statistically significant difference between CSE imaging and FSE imaging centered on the second echo (20 ms) using high-performance gradients for the detection of meniscal tears in the knee. There was a small preference for the quality of CSE images. Received: 22 July 1999 Revision requested: 27 October 1999 Revision received: 7 February 2000 Accepted: 21 March 2000