Intentional limited resection for small peripheral lung cancer based on intraoperative pathologic exploration

Objective: The aim of this study was to assess the adequacy of our intentional limited resection for small peripheral lung cancer based on intraoperative pathologic exploration. Methods: Patients who had stage IA non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) with a maximum tumor diameter of 2 cm or less were candidates for limited resection. If bronchioloalveolar carcinoma (BAC) was suspected on computed tomography and intraoperative pathologic exploration revealed the lesion as BAC without foci of active fibroblastic proliferation (Noguchi type A and B), wedge resection was performed. If the tumor was not suspected of being Noguchi type A or B, extended segmentectomy with intraoperative lymph node exploration was performed. Results: Limited resection was performed in 34 patients, wedge resection in 14, and extended segmentectomy in 20. The median follow-up period after wedge resection was 36 months, and all patients are alive with no signs of recurrence. The median follow-up period after extended segmentectomy was 54 months. No local recurrences were found, but distant metastasis was diagnosed in one patient. The 5-year survival rate after extended segmentectomy was 93%. In the same period, lobectomy was performed in 57 patients with stage IA NSCLC with a maximum tumor diameter of 2 cm or less, and the 5-year survival rate was 84%. There were no significant differences in 5-year survival between extended segmentectomy and lobectomy. Conclusions: Careful selection of patients based on high-resolution computed tomography findings and intraoperative pathologic exploration makes intentional limited resection an acceptable option for the treatment of small peripheral NSCLC. Read at the Fifty-sixth Annual Meeting of the Japanese Association for Thoracic Surgery, Panel Discussion, Tokyo, November 19–21, 2003.     

Limited resection for small peripheral lung cancer using intraoperative pathologic examination

From 1996 to 2002, we performed intentional limited resection for small peripheral lung cancer using intraoperative pathologic examination. Wedge resection was performed in patients who had small peripheral adenocarcinoma (< or = 20 mm), suspected of being Noguchi type A or B, and confirmed by intraoperative pathologic examination. Extended segmentectomy was performed in the rest of patients (tumor diameter < or = 20 mm), and not suspected of being Noguchi type A or B. Hilar and mediastinal lymph nodes sampling was performed in this group. If lymph node metastasis was detected by the intraoperative pathologic examination, the surgical procedures was converted into a lobectomy with lymph node dissection. Limited resection was performed in 27 patients, wedge resection in 8, and extended segmentectomy in 19. All patients received wedge resection are alive without sign of recurrence. In extended segmentectomy, 17 patients are alive with no evidence of disease, 1 patient died of non-pulmonary disease, and 1 patient is alive with recurrent disease. The overall survival rate at 5 years was 100% in wedge resection, 91% in extended segmentectomy, and 79% in standard lobectomy. We conclude that limited resection for small peripheral lung cancer using intraoperative pathologic examination may be safe and effective procedure.     

Early results of a prospective study of limited resection for bronchioloalveolar adenocarcinoma of the lung

BACKGROUND: We reported that bronchioloalveolar adenocarcinoma (BAC) without active fibroblastic proliferation of the lung had no lymph node and pulmonary metastasis and had a favorable prognosis. However, there has been no prospective trial regarding limited pulmonary resection for this type of BAC. The purpose of this study is to confirm the effectiveness of limited resection for histologically confirmed BAC without active fibroblastic proliferation. METHODS: From 1996 through 1999, 42 patients who had small peripheral lung tumors (< or = 20 mm), suspected of being BAC, were enrolled in this trial. The patient population consisted of 24 men and 18 women with a mean age of 58.4 years. Limited resection was completed when BAC, without both active fibroblastic proliferation and lymph node metastasis, was confirmed histologically by intraoperative pathologic examination. RESULTS: Limited resection was completed in 36 patients, wedge resection in 34, and segmentectomy in 2 patients. In 6 patients, the procedure was converted into lobectomy because of pathologic invasive sign in 3, active fibroblastic proliferation in 1, and for other reasons in 2 patients. All patients have been followed for a median follow-up period of 30 months and are alive without sign of recurrence. CONCLUSIONS: Our early results indicate that limited resection may be an acceptable alternative to lobectomy for histologically confirmed BAC without active fibroblastic proliferation.     

History of limited resection for non-small cell lung cancer.

A retrospective study of limited resection for lung cancer in a large number of patients was first reported in the 1970s. The reported outcome of segmentectomy was comparable to that of standard lobectomy. The North American Lung Cancer Study Group (LCSG) performed a randomized controlled clinical trial to compare limited resection (segment or wedge) with lobectomy for T1N0 (stage IA) non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) in the 1980s. The study revealed a significant excess of intrathoracic recurrence rate and a tendency to poorer survival in the limited resection group. Since then, limited resection has not been considered the standard operation for lung cancer. However, this situation is gradually changing, because the recent introduction of chest computed tomography (CT) to mass surveys has made peripherally located lung cancer detectable at the earliest stage. Several recent non-randomized studies of intentional limited resection from Japan demonstrated good outcomes comparable to those of lobectomy. Organ-sparing wedge resection without systematic dissection of lymph nodes may be suitable for some types of small lung cancers detected only by CT. Our meta-analysis of published data comparing survival rates after limited resection and lobectomy for stage I lung cancer revealed that limited resection was comparable to lobectomy. Further studies are necessary to define precise targets of intentional limited resection for lung cancer.     

Review and evaluation of limited resection for early lung cancer

Limited resection for early lung cancer has been associated with significantly higher local recurrence rates based on previous reports such as those from lung cancer study groups. On the other hand, a few groups demonstrated that patients with small peripheral cancer who undergo limited resection have comparable survival rates with those who undergo lobectomy. Recent advances in radiologic investigation and pathologic analysis have broadened the indications for limited resection. Since the introduction of the adenocarcinoma classification by Noguchi surgery for localized bronchioloalveolar carcinoma has focused on limited resection. Caution is necessary when performing wedge resection even if 10 mm or less in diameter and in compromised segmentectomy for early lung cancer. Although limited resection is still controversial intentional segmentectomy for localized bronchioloalveolar carcinoma or less than 20 mm or less in diameter may be recommended without evidence-based medicine. It is important to accumulate further evidence clarifying the survival and function benefits of limited resection. New therapeutic modalities for limited surgery for small-sized lung cancer may increase patient life expectancy.     

Results of surgical treatment for small (2 cm or Under) adenocarcinomas of the lung

Purpose The objectives of this study were to identify the clinicopathologic characteristics and prognostic factors of small (2 cm or less in diameter) adenocarcinomas, and furthermore to assess the acceptability of performing a limited pulmonary resection in such patients. Methods We retrospectively reviewed 523 cases of cT1N0M0 peripheral adenocarcinoma measuring 2 cm or less on diagnostic images treated by a complete resection between 1991 and 2004. Results The overall 5-year survival rate of the patients with small adenocarcinomas was 83.6%. Univariate and multivariate analyses identified an older age, male sex, wedge resection, advanced stage, and Noguchi classification of C, D, E, or F as independent prognostic factors that adversely affected overall survival. However, there were no significant differences in the survival according to surgical procedure in the patients whose tumors had a maximum diameter of 1.0 cm or less or in Noguchi type A and B cases. Conclusions Age, sex, surgical procedure, p-stage, and Noguchi classification were independent prognostic factors for survival in patients with small adenocarcinomas. A segmentectomy is therefore considered to be an acceptable alternative to a lobectomy for adenocarcinomas of 2 cm or less in diameter. A wedge resection may be acceptable for tumors measuring 1 cm or less in diameter or Noguchi type A and B tumors.     

Surgical results for second primary lung cancer

Of 897 patients who underwent operation for lung cancer between April 1996 and March 2010, 57 patients underwent pulmonary resection for 2nd primary lung cancer. There were 44 men and 13 women. The average age at the 2nd operation was 71. The initial pulmonary resection was lobectomy in 49 patients, segmentectomy in 4 and wedge resection in 4. The 2nd pulmonary resection was lobectomy in 10 patients, segmentectomy in 12 and wedge resection in 35. Preoperative stage of the 2nd primary lung cancer was IA in 43, IB in 13 and IIB in 1. Postoperative stage was IA in 38, IB in 10, IIA in 1, IIB in 3, IIIA in 2 and IIIB in 3. Surgical complications occurred in 4, but there were no perioperative deaths. The 5-year survival rate for 2nd primary lung cancers was 59.9%. The 5-year survival rate for patients treated with wedge resection was 71.1%. The 5-year survival rate of the patients with p-stage IA was 72.7%, and that for patients with p-stage IB or more advanced diseases was 32.9%. We conclude that an aggressive surgical approach for a 2nd primary lung cancer is effective and is linked with good outcome if the tumor is detected at stage IA, when the possible cure by performing wedge resection is promissing.     

Intentional limited pulmonary resection for peripheral T1 N0 M0 small-sized lung cancer

OBJECTIVE: The present study was undertaken to demonstrate that limited pulmonary resection for peripheral small-sized lung cancer yields outcomes not inferior to those of lobectomy. METHODS: During the 9-year period from 1992 to 2000, patients with cT1 N0 M0 peripheral non-small cell lung cancer whose maximum tumor diameter was 2 cm or less on diagnostic imaging and in whom lobectomy was determined to be feasible were treated with limited resection if the patient consented to the procedure and with lobectomy if consent to limited resection was not obtained. The survival and clinical outcome of the patients whose tumors were postoperatively staged as pT1 N0 M0 were compared between the limited resection group (n = 74) and the lobectomy group (n = 159). RESULTS: The limited resection group consisted of 60 patients treated with segmentectomy and 14 patients treated with wedge resection. Among patients followed up for a mean period of 52 months after the operation, neither the 3-year nor 5-year survivals differed significantly between the limited resection group (3-year survival, 94.0%; 5-year survival, 89.1%) and the lobectomy group (3-year survival, 97.0%; 5-year survival, 90.1%). Postoperative tumor recurrence was noted in 5 patients after limited resection and in 9 patients after lobectomy, and the difference in the incidence of postoperative recurrence between the 2 groups was not significant. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study indicate that in patients with peripheral T1 N0 M0 non-small cell lung cancer whose maximum tumor diameter was 2 cm or less, the outcome of limited pulmonary resection is comparable with that of pulmonary lobectomy.     

Is segmentectomy with lymph node assessment an alternative to lobectomy for non-small cell lung cancer of 2 cm or smaller?

BACKGROUND: Lesser resection than the standard lobectomy for small-sized cT1N0M0 non-small cell lung cancers continues to be debated. METHODS: We reviewed specimens of 139 patients after lobectomy for cT1N0M0 cancer of 2 cm or less. In addition, we prospectively enrolled 70 patients able to tolerate a lobectomy, in a trial of lesser resection for these lesions. The limited procedure consisted of segmentectomy in which the resection line was delivered beyond the burdened segment, plus exploration of lymph nodes by frozen sectioning. This procedure was modified if the result was positive; this modified procedure was called extended segmentectomy. RESULTS: The nodal status after lobectomy was pN0, 107 patients; pN1, 12 patients; and pN2, 20 patients. Of the pN1 patients, 2 had only intralobar nodal involvement within the same segment of the main tumor. In the remaining 30 patients with nodal involvement, we ascertained the nodal involvement during the operation. Regarding intrapulmonary metastasis, 1 of 8 patients having this metastasis had the lesion at the segment where the main tumor was not located and had N2 disease, which was detected intraoperatively. If extended segmentectomy had been performed instead of lobectomy, the lesion could have been removed completely. The 5-year survival of patients with cT1N0M0 cancer of 2 cm or less was 87.3% after extended segmentectomy. There were no local recurrences and three noncancer-related deaths. Among patients with pT1N0M0 cancer of 2 cm or less, the 5-year survival was 87.1% in the extended segmentectomy group and 87.7% in the lobectomy group (p = 0.8008). CONCLUSIONS: Extended segmentectomy should be considered as an alternative for patients with cT1N0M0 non-small cell lung cancer of 2 cm or smaller.     

Sublobar resections in stage IA non-small cell lung cancer: segmentectomies result in significantly better cancer-related survival than wedge resections

OBJECTIVE: Sublobar resections spare pulmonary function and offer a method of increasing resection rates in patients with lung cancer and limited functional operability. Previous studies demonstrated an increased local recurrence rate following wedge resections compared to segmentectomies in stage IA non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). However, a prognostic impact of this observation has never been shown and is still under debate. Therefore, this study has been performed to analyse the cancer-related survival of sublobar resections in stage IA patients. METHODS: Over a 17-year period 87 patients underwent sublobar complete resection (R0) of stage IA NSCLC via thoracotomy. Sublobar resection was reserved for patients with cardiopulmonary impairment. Wedge resections with selective lymphadenectomy were performed in 31 patients (36%) and segmentectomies with systematic lymphadenectomy in 56 patients (64%). Patient characteristics, functional parameters, tumour specifics and follow-up duration were analysed concerning their distribution between the two groups. Kaplan-Meier curves were compared and possible joint effects between prognostic parameters were analysed by multivariate Cox regression analysis. RESULTS: The median follow-up duration was 45 months. There was no significant difference between the two groups in gender (p=0.11), age (p=0.08), American Society of Anesthesiology physical performance status (ASA)-score (p=0.32), forced expiratory volume in 1s FEV(1) (p=0.08), tumour size (p=0.30), histology (p=0.17), grading (p=0.12), complication rate (p=0.15) and follow-up duration (p=0.29). The mean number of dissected lymph nodes in segmentectomies (12+/-6) was higher than in wedge resections (6+/-3) (p=0.0001). The 5-year survival rate was 63%. There were significantly less locoregional recurrences (p=0.001), an equal distribution of distant metastases (p=0.53) and a better cancer-related survival (p=0.016) following segmentectomies compared to wedge resections. Cox regression analysis showed that the prognostic effect of the resection type was independent from gender, age, ASA-score, respiratory function, tumour size, tumour histology, grading and number of dissected lymph nodes (p=0.04, relative risk 1.16). CONCLUSIONS: Studies investigating survival after sublobar resection of stage IA NSCLC should always distinguish between anatomical segmentectomies and wedge resections. If limited functional operability requires a sublobar resection of stage IA NSCLC, segmentectomy with systematic lymphadenectomy should be preferred.     

Surgical treatment for metachronous lung cancer

We performed a retrospective review of 45 consecutive patients with metachronous multiple primary lung cancer who underwent resection between 1990 and 2009. Surgical treatment of the 1st tumor consisted of 39 lobectomies and 3 segmentectomies, and 3 wedge resections. The 2nd tumor was removed by means of a lobectomy in 9 patients, a segmentectomy in 17 patients, a wedge resection in 19 patients. No postoperative mortality was observed. Histologic classification was similar in 86.4% of patients and different in 13.6%. Postoperative stage of the 2nd tumor was IA in 31 patients, IB in 7, IIA in 1, IIIA in 3, IIIB in 3. Median follow-up was 48.4 months after 2nd operation. The 5-year survival rate was 90.8% after 1st operation and 85.6% after 2nd operation. The 5-year survival rate in patients with p-stage IA was 96.4%. Patients with metachronous lung cancer could have a favorable outcome. Thus we need careful follow-up of the patients after treatment on the 1st lung cancer, and moreover an aggressive surgical treatment is recommended as long as their performance state or residual pulmonary function allows.     

Video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) segmentectomy for small peripheral lung cancer tumors: intermediate results

Background We investigated the feasibility and suitability of video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) segmentectomy for curing selected non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) with this less invasive technique Methods We performed VATS segmentectomy for small (<20 nm) peripherally located tumors and pathologically confirmed lobar lymph node-negative disease by frozen-section examination during surgery. Of the 34 patients who underwent this limited resection, 22 were treated with complete hilar and mediastinal lymph node dissection (intentional group), whereas 12 patients who were deemed to be high risk in their toleration for lobectomy underwent VATS segmentectomy with incomplete hilar and mediastinal lymph node dissection (compromised group). The surgical and clinical parameters were evaluated and compared with those of segmentectomy under standard thoracotomy to evaluate the technical feasibility of VATS segmentectomy. Results We found that VATS segmentectomy could be performed safely with a nil mortality rate and acceptably low morbidity. The mean period of observation was relatively short at 656.7±572.1 and 783.4±535.8 days in the intentional and compromised groups, respectively. At the time of writing, all intentional patients remain alive and free of recurrence. There were two cases of non-cancer-related death in the compromised group. Clinical data indicated that VATS segmentectomy caused the same number or fewer surgical insults compared with segmen-tectomy under standard thoractomy Conclusions The present results are intermediate only; the rate of long-term survival and the advantages of the less invasive procedure still need further investigation. Nevertheless, we believe that VATS segmentectomy with complete lymph node dissection is a reasonable treatment option for selected patients with small peripheral NSCLC.     

T1期非小细胞肺癌肺叶切除和亚肺叶切除的临床疗效比较

目的探讨肺叶切除和亚肺叶切除在T1期非小细胞肺癌(NSCLC)(肿瘤直径≤3 cm)外科治疗中的应用价值。 方法收集2007年1月至2014年12月在北京中日友好医院胸外科接受手术治疗的278例T1期NSCLC患者的临床资料。患者平均年龄(60.7 ± 10.4)岁。其中亚肺叶切除61例(楔形切除35例,肺段切除26例),肺叶切除217例。腺癌占81.7%,鳞癌占12.9%,其他占5.4%;高分化癌占8.6%,中分化癌占27.0%,低分化癌占20.5%,不能确定占43.9%。在腺癌中,浸润前病变占4.0%,微浸润腺癌占7.5%,浸润性腺癌占88.5%。T1N0M0占86.7%,T1N1M0占1.1%,T1N2M0占12.2%。 结果与肺叶切除组比较,亚肺叶切除组患者年龄较大、手术时间较短、病变≤2 cm的比例较高,两组间比较差异均有统计学意义(t＝0.496,P＝0.009;t＝8.082,P＝0.029;χ²＝2.105,P＝0.002)。但两组间在1秒钟用力呼气容积(FEV₁)、FEV₁%,以及手术方式和术后并发症发生率方面,差异均无统计学意义(t＝0.065,P＝0.713;t＝2.12,P＝0.085;χ²＝0.399,P＝0.274;χ²＝0.438,P＝0.490)。对于T1N0M0的NSCLC患者,亚肺叶和肺叶切除组患者的5年生存率分别为73.9%和83.5%,差异无统计学意义(P＝0.883)。亚肺叶切除组内分析显示：楔形切除组和肺段切除组患者的5年生存率分别为79.4%和70.6%,差异无统计学意义(P＝0.979)。多因素分析显示：仅有年龄和纵隔淋巴结转移N2为预后不良的危险因素(HR＝1.07,P＝0.048;HR＝5.56,P＝0.011)。亚肺叶切除组患者的5年生存率与肺叶切除组比较差异无统计学意义(HR＝1.38,P＝0.552)。 结论对于T1N0M0的NSCLC患者,亚肺叶切除虽然不可能完全替代肺叶切除手术,但是对于肺功能储备较差的老年患者可能逐渐成为主流术式。     

A case-matched study of anatomical segmentectomy versus lobectomy for stage I lung cancer in high-risk patients.

OBJECTIVE: Sublobar resections may offer a method of increasing resection rates in patients with lung cancer and poor lung function, but are thought to increase recurrence and therefore compromise survival for stage I non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). To test this hypothesis we have compared the long-term outcome from lobectomy and anatomical segmentectomy in high-risk cases as defined by predicted postoperative FEV1 (ppoFEV1) less than 40%. METHODS: Over a 7-year period 55 patients (27% of all resections for stage I NSCLC) with ppoFEV1<40% underwent resection of stage I NSCLC. The 17 patients who underwent anatomical segmentectomy were individually matched to 17 patients operated by lobectomy on the bases of gender, age, use of VATS, tumour location and respiratory function. We compared their perioperative course, tumour recurrence and survival. RESULTS: There were no significant differences in hospital mortality (one case in each group), complications or hospital stay. Overall 5-year survival was 69%. There were no differences in recurrence rates (18% in both groups) or survival (64% after lobectomy and 70% after segmentectomy). There was preservation of pulmonary function after segmentectomy (median gain of 12%) compared to lobectomy (median loss of 12%) (P=0.02). CONCLUSIONS: Anatomical segmentectomy allowed for surgical resection in patients with stage I NSCLC and impaired respiratory reserve without compromising oncological results but with preservation in respiratory function.     

Indication for limited surgery on small lung cancer tumors measuring 1cm or less in diameter on preoperative computed tomography and long-term results

OBJECTIVE: Non-invasive lung cancers showed a good prognosis after limited surgery. But it is still uncertain about invasive lung cancers. We investigated the indications for limited surgery for small lung cancer tumors measuring 1 cm or less in diameter on preoperative computed tomography (CT). METHODS: This study retrospectively analyzed of 1,245 patients who underwent complete resection of lung cancer between 1989 and 2004 in our hospital. Sixty-two patients (5%) had tumors measuring 1 cm or less in diameter. The probability of survival was calculated using the Kaplan-Meier method. RESULTS: All diseases were detected by medical checkup, 52 % of the patients were not definitively diagnosed with lung cancer before surgery. Adenocarcinoma was histologically diagnosed in 49 patients (79%). Other histologic types included squamous cell carcinoma (8), large cell carcinoma (1), small cell carcinoma (1), carcinoid (2), and adenosquamous cell carcinoma (1). Fifty-seven patients (92%) showed pathologic stage IA. The other stages were IB (2), IIA (1), and IIIB (2). There were 14 bronchioloalveolar carcinomas (25% of IA diseases). The 5-year survival rates of IA patients were 90%. The 5-year survival rate of patients with tumors measuring 1cm or less diameter was 91% after lobectomy or pneumonectomy, and 90% after wedge resection or segmentectomy. There were 3 deaths from cancer recurrence, while there were no deaths in 14 patients with bronchioloalveolar carcinoma CONCLUSION: After limited surgery, non-invasive cancer showed good long-term results, while invasive cancer showed a recurrence rate of 2.3% to 79% even though the tumor measured 1 cm or less in diameter on preoperative CT.     

Formal hepatic resection of colorectal liver metastases. Ploidy and prognosis.

Fifty consecutive patients who underwent 52 formal hepatic resections (excluding isolated wedge resections) for metastatic colorectal cancer were analyzed to determine whether DNA content was of prognostic significance. The Dukes' stages of the colorectal primaries were: A (10%), B (20%), C (40%), D (28%), and unknown in 2%. Four patients whose liver metastases were discovered at the time of resection of the primary bowel cancer underwent concomitant liver resection, and the remaining patients underwent delayed resections. The hepatic resections performed were right lobectomy (50%), extended right lobectomy (19%), left lobectomy (13%), left lateral segmentectomy (6%), left lobectomy and right wedge (6%), extended left lobectomy (4%), and right lobectomy and left wedge (2%). The overall morbidity rate was 29%. The in-hospital mortality rate was 9%. As of November 1991, 36 patients have recurred. The 5-year actuarial survival was 28%. Flow cytometry could be performed on 37 archival specimens, 15 of which were found to be diploid whereas 22 were aneuploid. All metastases from Dukes A colorectal primaries demonstrated a diploid DNA content. In addition, there was no difference in actuarial survival between diploid and aneuploid tumors. These data suggest that in selected patients, formal hepatic resection of colorectal liver metastases can be performed with an acceptable morbidity rate, mortality rate, and survival, but ploidy of the resected tumor is not of prognostic significance.     

Multiple primary lung cancers. Results of surgical treatment

During a 13-year period, multiple primary lung cancers were diagnosed in 80 consecutive patients. Forty-four patients had metachronous cancers. The initial pulmonary resection was lobectomy in 36 patients, bilobectomy in 3, pneumonectomy in 1, and wedge excision or segmentectomy in 4. The second pulmonary resection was lobectomy in 16 patients, bilobectomy in 2, completion pneumonectomy in 7, and wedge excision or segmentectomy in 19. There were two 30-day operative deaths (mortality rate, 4.5%). Actuarial 5- and 10-year survival rates after the first pulmonary resection for stage I disease were 55.2% and 27.0%, respectively. Five-year and 10-year survival rates for stage I disease after the second pulmonary resection were 41.0% and 31.5%, respectively. The remaining 36 patients had synchronous cancers. The pulmonary resection was lobectomy in 18 patients, bilobectomy in 3, pneumonectomy in 10, and wedge excision or segmentectomy in 8. There were two 30-day operative deaths (mortality rate, 5.6%). Actuarial overall 5- and 10-year survival rates after pulmonary resection were 15.7% and 13.8%, respectively. We conclude that an aggressive surgical approach is safe and warranted in most patients with multiple primary lung cancers and that the presence of synchronous primary cancers is ominous.     

Limited resection trial for pulmonary ground-glass opacity nodules: fifty-case experience

OBJECTIVE: This study was undertaken to determine the recurrence rate after limited resection of small lung carcinoma and to evaluate intraoperative frozen-section examination accuracy for Noguchi classification. METHODS: Enrollment requirements were as follows: pulmonary nodule 2 cm or smaller, diagnosed or suspected clinical T1 N0 M0 carcinoma in the lung periphery, and ground-glass opacity findings and lack of evident pleural indentations or vascular convergence on high-resolution computed tomographic scan. A wedge or segmental resection specimen, removed with custom stapler cartridges, was immediately reinflated and examined by frozen-section with hematoxylin-eosin and Victoria blue-van Gieson stains. If the tumor was confirmed as Noguchi type A or B with resection margins greater than 1 cm, the patient was closed and followed up on an outpatient basis. End points were 5-year disease-free survival and intraoperative classification accuracy. RESULTS: From August 1998 through October 2002, a total of 50 patients were enrolled (20 men and 30 women, ages 30-77 years). Tumor sizes ranged from 2 to 21 mm (11 mm average). There were 2 Noguchi type A tumors, 23 Noguchi type B tumors, 15 Noguchi type C tumors, 5 atypical adenomatous hyperplasias, 4 fibroses, and 1 granuloma. Frozen-section accuracy was approximately 98% (39/40). One intraoperative type B diagnosis was revised to type C after postoperative pathologic study. No morbidity, mortality, or recurrence has been seen with a median follow-up of 50 months. CONCLUSION: Noguchi type A and B tumors may well be in situ carcinomas, and frozen-section examination was highly accurate. Neither local recurrence nor distant metastases have been found to date. Limited resection initial results appear promising.     

Effect of tumor size on prognosis in patients with non-small cell lung cancer: the role of segmentectomy as a type of lesser resection

OBJECTIVE: As a result of increasing discovery of small-sized lung cancer in clinical practice, tumor size has come to be considered an important variable affecting planning of treatment. Nevertheless, there have been no reports including large numbers of patients and focusing on tumor size, and controversy remains concerning the surgical management of small-sized tumors. Therefore, we investigated the relationships between tumor dimension and clinical and follow-up data, as well as surgical procedure in particular. METHODS: We reviewed the records of 1272 consecutive patients who underwent complete resection for non-small cell carcinoma of the lung. RESULTS: Fifty patients had tumors of 10 mm or less, 273 had tumors of 11 to 20 mm, 368 had tumors of 21 to 30 mm, and 581 had tumors of greater than 30 mm in diameter. The cancer-specific 5-year survivals of patients in these 4 groups were 100%, 83.5%, 76.5%, and 57.9%, respectively. For patients with pathologic stage I disease, they were 100%, 92.6%, 84.1%, and 76.4%, respectively. Multivariate analysis demonstrated that male sex, older age, larger tumor, and advanced pathologic stage adversely affected survival. Lesser resection was performed in 167 (52%) of 323 patients with a tumor of 20 mm or less in diameter but in 156 (16%) of 949 patients with a tumor of greater than 20 mm in diameter. The percentages of lesser resection among all procedures performed were 79%, 56%, 30%, and 15% in patients with pathologic stage I disease with a tumor of 10 mm or less, 11 to 20 mm, 21 to 30 mm, and greater than 30 mm in diameter, respectively. The 5-year cancer-specific survivals of patients with pathologic stage I disease with tumors of 20 mm or less and 21 to 30 mm in diameter were 92.4% and 87.4% after lobectomy, 96.7% and 84.6% after segmentectomy, and 85.7% and 39.4% after wedge resection, respectively. On the other hand, with a tumor of greater than 30 mm in diameter, survivals were 81.3% after lobectomy, 62.9% after segmentectomy, and 0% after wedge resection, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Tumor size is an independent and significant prognostic factor and important for planning of surgical treatment. Although lobectomy should be chosen for patients with a tumor of greater than 30 mm in diameter, further investigation is required for tumors of 21 to 30 mm in diameter. Segmentectomy should, as a lesser anatomic resection, be distinguished from wedge resection and might be acceptable for patients with a tumor of 20 mm or less in diameter without nodal involvement.     

Diagnosis and treatment of lung cancer – Non-small cell lung cancer, small cell lung cancer and carcinoids

Summary BACKGROUND: The prognosis of lung tumors is determined by histology and staging (nodal status). The most common tumor is non-small cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC) with a 5-year survival rate of 67 % (stage IA) to <5 % (stage IV). METHODS: By reviewing the literature guidelines for diagnosis and treatment of non-small cell lung cancer and neurendocrine tumors are presented. RESULTS: Functional operability provided, (bi)lobectomy or pneumonectomy with mediastinal lymph node dissection are the standard procedures. In case of positive mediastinal lymph nodes (stage IIIA/IIIB) induction chemo(radio)therapy is indicated. Cervical mediastinoscopy is performed in patients with enlarged mediastinal nodes (CT >1 cm), especially in PET-positive cases. Adjuvant chemotherapy is used in clinical trials. Small-cell lung cancer (SCLC, neuroendocrine tumor grade III) has a poor prognosis, and is treated with chemotherapy; resection may be performed in early stages. Neuroendocrine tumors grade I (typical carcinoid) are resected by segmentectomy, lobectomy, or bronchoplastic resection. Neuroendocrine tumors grade II (atypical carcinoids) are treated like NSCLC. CONCLUSIONS: The incidence of lung cancer is decreased by tobacco control, and the chances of survival are improved by early detection and multimodality regimens.