Aquired inhibitors of coagulation in a patient with systemic lupus erythematosus and antiphospholipid antibodies: response to rituximab

Hematologic signs of systemic lupus erythematosus are diverse (SLE). Although a delayed coagulation time is anti-phospholipid antibody related, thrombotic events are the usual clinical manifestation. Spontaneous appearance of circulating anticoagulant in the absence of a previous coagulation disorder is secondary to the development of antibodies to factors II, V, VIII, IX, XI, XII,vonWillebrand, and other membrane glucoproteins, all of them uncommon causes (1 case per million persons per year) of life threatening coagulopathies. We report a case of SLE and antiphospholipid antibodies in a woman with a hemorrhagic syndrome, probably caused by multiple antibodies to coagulation factors, unresponsive to steroids and high-dose immunosupressive therapy and a favorable response to rituximab.     

Noncoagulation inhibitory factor VIII antibodies after induction of tolerance to factor VIII in hemophilia A patients

We recently described tolerance induction with factor VIII/IX, cyclophosphamide, and high-dose intravenous IgG in hemophilia A or B patients with coagulation inhibitory antibodies. Circulating noninhibitory antibodies complexed with factor IX have been demonstrated in tolerant hemophilia B patients. Similar findings are now described in six tolerant hemophilia A patients. Complexes between factor VIII and the 'tolerant' antibody were demonstrated by subjecting plasma to gel filtration chromatography, void fractions containing factor VIII/vWF complexes being collected and adsorbed to protein A. Using 125I-labeled F(ab')2 fragments against IgG subclass and factor VIII antigen, complexes between an IgG4 antibody and factor VIII were found to adsorb to protein A. After infusion of factor VIII to tolerant patients, all factor VIII circulated in complex with IgG4 antibody. In three of the patients, the 'tolerant' antibodies inhibited an ELISA specific for factor VIII light chain but, unlike the pretolerant antibodies, did not bind radiolabeled factor VIII heavy chain. Although after induction of tolerance the patients still have circulating IgG4 antibodies against factor VIII, the antibodies differ in specificity, lack coagulation inhibitory activity, and do not enhance the rate of elimination of factor VIII.     

Properties of anti-factor VIII inhibitor antibodies in hemophilia A patients

Blood coagulation factor VIII functions in the intrinsic pathway of blood coagulation as a cofactor by enhancing the assembly of its complex with factors IX and X on the surface of activated platelets. This requires factor VIII interaction with these two proteins, von Willebrand factor (vWF), and phospholipids on the platelet surface. Once factor VIII and factor IX are activated by proteolytic cleavage, the complex is able to activate factor X to factor Xa by proteolysis. In hemophilia A patients with severe factor VIII deficiency, about 30% respond to factor VIII infusion therapy immunologically to produce antibodies that inactivate the infused factor VIII and others that are noninhibitory. An assay that measures only the inhibitor antibodies demonstrated that the factor VIII A2, A3, and C2 domains are the most immunogenic, and domains A1 and B are poorly immunogenic or not immunogenic. The specific antibody responses to A2, A3, and C2 vary considerably among individuals, and epitopes for inhibitor antibodies have been determined for all three. The anti-C2 inhibitors prevent factor VIII binding to phospholipids and vWF, and anti-A3 inhibitors prevent binding to factor IX (IXa). An inhibitor binding site for factor X has been localized to the A1 domain acidic region, leading to inhibition of factor VIII/factor X binding by antibodies. This inhibitor mechanism is rare. Because a second binding site for factor IX was localized to the factor VIII A2 domain, it is likely but not proven that prevention of factor IX binding to factor VIII is the inhibitor mechanism for this epitope.     

Immune deviation by mucosal antigen administration suppresses gene-transfer-induced inhibitor formation to factor IX

Formation of inhibitory antibodies is a serious complication of protein or gene replacement therapy for hemophilias, congenital X-linked bleeding disorders. In hemophilia B (coagulation factor IX [F.IX] deficiency), lack of endogenous F.IX antigen expression and other genetic factors may increase the risk of antibody formation to functional F.IX. Here, we developed a protocol for reducing inhibitor formation in gene therapy by prior mucosal (intranasal) administration of a peptide representing a human F.IX-specific CD4(+) T-cell epitope in hemophilia B mice. C3H/HeJ mice with a F.IX gene deletion produced inhibitory IgG to human F.IX after hepatic gene transfer with an adeno-associated viral vector. These animals subsequently lost systemic F.IX expression. In contrast, repeated intranasal administration of the specific peptide resulted in reduced inhibitor formation, sustained circulating F.IX levels, and sustained partial correction of coagulation following hepatic gene transfer. This was achieved through immune deviation to a T-helper-cell response with increased IL-10 and TGF-beta production and activation of regulatory CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells.     

Inhibition of platelet prothrombinase activity by a lupus anticoagulant

Lupus anticoagulants are spontaneously occurring antibodies with specificity for negatively charged phospholipids. The plasma of a patient with such a polyclonal antibody of IgM type demonstrated low levels of factor VIII coagulant activity (VIII:C) and factors IX, XI and XII when analyzed by biologic clotting assays, whereas in immunochemical assays, normal levels of VIII coagulant antigen and factor IX were obtained. After immunoadsorption of patient plasma with anti-IgM Sepharose, normal biologic activities were demonstrated in clotting assays for VIII:C, factors IX, XI, and XII. The addition of the patient's isolated IgM to normal plasma resulted in grossly abnormal results in these coagulation assays, and a pattern similar to that of the patient's plasma was obtained. The inhibitory effect of the patient's lupus anticoagulant on blood coagulation was demonstrated also in platelet-rich plasma. The results of the clotting assays indicated that the anticoagulant inhibited several of the reactions in the blood coagulation cascade. The availability of purified components made it possible to demonstrate an inhibiting effect on the activation of prothrombin by factor Xa in the presence of isolated platelets, as well as in a system where purified factor V and well defined phospholipid vesicles were substituted for the platelets.     

Gene therapy of the hemophilias

Development of hemophilia gene therapy depends on testing gene transfer vectors in hemophilic and nonhemophilic animals. Available animal models include factor VIII or factor IX knockout mice as well as dogs with spontaneous hemophilia A or B. Large animals (particularly dogs) more closely replicate the requirements for correction of human hemophilia than do mice. Small animals are more convenient to maintain and require significantly less vector for testing than do large animals. Nonhemophilic animals (mice or nonhuman primates), whose endogenous factor VIII and factor IX complicate analysis of the human proteins, have utility for safety testing of vectors; some assays can discriminate between human coagulation factors and the endogenous coagulation factors. Most animal models suffer the limitations imposed by the immune response to human factor VIII or IX protein. Clinical trials have failed to achieve significant factor VIII expression in hemophilia A patients, while one clinical trial in hemophilia B patients showed only transient therapeutic increments of factor IX expression. Gene therapy remains an investigational method with many obstacles to overcome before it can be widely used as treatment for hemophilia.     

New characteristics of anti-factor VIII inhibitor antibody epitopes and unusual immune responses to Factor VIII

Treatment of individuals with severe hemophilia A by plasma-derived or recombinant factor VIII leads to the production of anti-factor VIII antibodies in approximately 30% of such patients. Because some of these antibodies inactivate factor VIII, they are considered a major factor in preventing optimal therapeutic treatment. Factor VIII is a cofactor that must bind to factors IX and X and phospholipids in order for normal blood coagulation to occur. The inhibition of factor VIII activity is due to binding by anti- factor VIII antibodies in the patient plasma to the same sites required for factors IX and X and phospholipid binding. Previously, inhibitor epitopes were localized to the A2, A3, and C2 domains and to a region of acidic amino acids between the A1 and A2 domains. Inhibitor binding to these domains prevented factor VIII binding to factor IXa (A2, A3), factor Xa (C2), and phospholipids (C2), and binding to the acidic region interfered with factor X binding. Antibody binding to a minor C2 domain epitope slowed activated factor VIII release from von Willebrand factor (vWF) and interfered with factor Xa binding to factor VIII.     

Immunochemical characterization of a polyclonal human antibody to factor IX.

Inhibitors of clotting factors occuring in humans are often antibody molecules synthesized in response to exogeneous proteins used in replacement therapy. Extensive studies of inhibitors to factor VIII indicate such antibodies may be monoclonal or polyclonal in nature. To date, only one factor IX inhibitor has been subjected to detailed immunochemical analysis and it appears to be a monoclonal IgGA lambda antibody. We have discovered a second inhibitor of factor IX in a patient with severe hemophilia B and have subjected it to immunochemical analysis. Studies on this second inhibitor have been carried out before and after an anamnestic response. Column chromatography, preparative zone electrophoresis, and specific inhibitor neutralization assays using monospecific heterologous antisera to human immunoglobulin classes, subclasses, and light-chain types indicate that the antibody is of the IgG class and contains both kappa and lambda light chains and probably all four IgG subclasses. Thus, the inhibitor appears to be polyclonal by immunochemical and structural criteria. In addition, preparative isoelectric focusing of pre- and postanamnestic inhibitor samples indicates that recruitment of new clones of IgG antibody occurs as a result of anamnesis. It is conceivable that an antibody initially restricted in immunoglobulin subclass became polyclonal following an anamnestic response.     

Evaluation of Adsorption Selectivity Dextran Sulfate Bound Cellulose Beads for the Removal of Anti-DNA Antibodies

The purpose of this study was to clarify the basic adsorption selectivity characteristics of dextran sulfate (DS) columns (Selesorb, Kaneka Corporation, Osaka, Japan). Recovery rates of blood chemical components, hormones, coagulation factors, and antinuclear antibodies (anti-SS-A, SS-B, Sm, Scl-70, and RNP antibody) in vitro were assessed by mixing normal volunteers' or patients' sera with DS bound cellulose beads. For tested blood chemical components other than triglyceride and total cholesterol, the recovery rate was not changed significantly by incubation. No significant changes in hormone levels resulted from incubation. Among coagulation factors, the activities of antithrombin III, plasminogen, and factors V, VIII, IX, XI, and XII were significantly reduced by incubation. Among antinuclear antibodies tested, anti-SS-A and anti-RNP were absorbed to some extent, but not anti-SS-B, Sm, or Scl-70 antibodies. Taking into account these characteristics, apheresis therapy using a DS column should be performed.     

Inhibitors to clotting factors

  Clot formation is the final result of interaction among multiple plasma proteins; after activation, it results in the conversion of fibrinogen to fibrin and cross-linking of fibrin by activated factor XIII, which stabilizes the formed clot. Deficiency or functional abnormality of the factors involved in these reactions causes bleeding disorders. Natural inhibitors of clotting factors include antithrombin III, protein S, and protein C. When activated, these proteins inactivate specific clotting factors, providing a regulatory mechanism that serves to control the coagulation response and limit the extension of the clot. Physiologic or natural inhibitors should not be confused with acquired inhibitors of coagulation factors, which are discussed in this review. Inhibitors to coagulation factors, also known as circulating anticoagulants, are antibodies that neutralize specific clotting proteins, thereby interfering with their normal function. Antibodies may be directed against isolated clotting factors, as is the case with factor VIII or IX inhibitors. On the other hand, the antiphospholipid antibodies are known to develop against multiple coagulation proteins. In contrast to patients with antibodies against isolated clotting factors, who commonly present with spontaneous bleeding, individuals with antiphospholipid antibodies may be asymptomatic or present with venous or arterial thrombosis. In this article I refer to inhibitors developing in patients with hemophilia A or other congenital factor deficiency as alloantibodies, and to spontaneous formation of antibodies in patients without prior history of hemorrhagic diathesis as autoantibodies. The antiphospholipid antibodies are discussed separately. Received: 11 March 1997 / Accepted: 23 May 1997     

Acquired haemophilia: management of bleeds and immune therapy to eradicate autoantibodies

Acquired haemophilia is a rare, but often severe bleeding disorder caused by autoantibodies against a coagulation factor, usually factor VIII (FVIII). Between 1997 and 2004 we observed 14 patients (mean age of 78 years) with acquired haemophilia. The aim of the present study was to investigate the effect of activated prothrombin complex concentrate (aPCC) for bleeds and the response to corticosteroids and cyclophosphamide to eradicate the offending autoantibodies. The most common clinical presentations were severe profuse bruising (12) and haematuria (5). Ten patients were classified as idiopathic. At the time of diagnosis all patients had a very low FVIII level, and one patient also showed factor IX < 1%. High levels of antibodies to FVIII varying from 10 to 1340 Bethesda units (BU) and prolonged activated partial thromboplastin time were disclosed in all patients. Eight severe bleeds were treated with aPCC (FEIBA) at a dosage of 70 IU kg(-1) every 8 h until haemostasis. Ten patients received corticosteroids and cyclophosphamide as immunomodulatory therapy. Effective haemostasis was achieved in all bleeds after aPCC. Ten of 11 patients responded either completely or partially to the immunomodulatory regime within 6 months. Five patients achieved complete response (CR) whereas partial responses were seen in five patients. The anti-CD20 monoclonal antibody rituximab was given to two patients in conventional doses and a CR was seen in one patient. aPCC is effective in treating acute bleeds in patients with acquired haemophilia with high inhibitor levels. The combination of oral corticosteroids and cyclophosphamide seems to be effective to eradicate the inhibitor.     

Importance of factor-IX-dependent prothrombinase formation--the Josso pathway--in clotting plasma

We report a study on the importance of factor IX activation in thromboplastin-dependent coagulation in plasma. Diluted, CaCl2-containing thromboplastin solutions at constant phospholipid concentration were used to trigger the coagulation in plasma from patients with congenital factor IX and factor VIII deficiency in the presence and absence of added factors IX and VIII, and the generation of thrombin activity was monitored. When coagulation is triggered with the high thromboplastin concentrations normally used in clinical routine tests, the generation of thrombin activity in plasma of patients with congenital factor IX deficiency before and after reconstitution with purified factor IX appears identical. When, however, coagulation is triggered with low thromboplastin concentrations, a clear dependency of the generation of thrombin activity on the concentration of factor IX becomes evident at factor IX concentrations lower than 30 nM (about 40% clotting factor activity). Factor VIII is a compulsory cofactor for this factor IX activity because the prothrombinase activity at optimal factor IX concentration is still critically dependent upon the amount of factor VIII present. The lower the amount of thromboplastin, the higher the importance of factor IX and factor VIII activation in thromboplastin-dependent coagulation. This suggests a role of this pathway in pathophysiological thrombin formation.     

Resistance to Activated F IX Concentrate (FEIBA)

A 10-year-old haemophiliac with an inhibitor to Factor VIII was treated by repeated infusions of an activated Factor IX concentrate (FEIBA). During therapy the patient was monitored with extensive coagulation studies, and the initial effect of FEIBA on the whole blood coagulation time was seen to disappear in spite of increased doses of concentrate. A fall in Factor IX activity and a rise of antithrombin III and anti-Factor Xa was recorded, while the titer of anti-F VIII remained unchanged. The exact nature of this FEIBA-resistant state was not revealed, however, it was speculated that a rise of natural inhibitors of the coagulation system could explain the findings.     

Spectrum of changes in endogenous thrombin potential due to heritable disorders of coagulation

The modern thrombin generation tests describe different phases of generation of thrombin that is initiation, amplification and inhibition of thrombin generation as well as the integral amount of generated thrombin. We investigated 55 patients with congenital deficiencies of different coagulation factors and analysed the relationship between the nature and the concentration of clotting factors, with different parameters of thrombin generation curve that is lag time, peak, time to peak and the area under curve or endogenous thrombin potential. The endogenous thrombin potential was unaffected by severe deficiency of factors XI and XII, and reduced in factor IX, VII and factor V and VIII deficiencies. The lag time was significantly prolonged in cases of severe factor VII, X and V deficiencies, and was almost normal in cases of factors VIII, IX, combined factors V and VIII, factor XI, XII and XIII deficiencies. The peak height was severely affected in cases of severe factor X, V, VIII and IX deficiency and combined deficiency of multiple vitamin K dependant coagulation factors, and significantly reduced in factor VIII, V, X, XIII and combined vitamin K deficiency.In all the patients with less than 40% thrombin generation, the clinical symptoms were severe. Bleeding symptoms were restricted to epistaxis and ecchymosis when thrombin generation was more than 90% of the normal. In the cases of combined deficiency of factors V and VIII all the values were intermediate as they exhibit mild deficiencies of both factors V and VIII and correlated well with the clinical symptoms. Endogenous thrombin potential of inherited isolated deficiencies of coagulation factors may thus provide an interesting insight about involvement of the deficient factor(s) at different phases of thrombin generation.     

Prevention and treatment of factor VIII inhibitors in murine hemophilia A

Inhibitory antibody formation is a major complication of factor VIII replacement therapy in patients with hemophilia A. To better understand the pathogenesis of this immunologic reaction, we evaluated the role of T-cell costimulatory signals for antifactor VIII antibody formation in a murine model of hemophilia A. Repeated intravenous injections of factor VIII in these factor VIII-deficient mice induced an antifactor VIII inhibitor antibody response. This response was shown to be T-cell dependent by its absence in hemophilic mice also deficient for the T-cell costimulatory ligand B7-2. In separate experiments, injection of murine CTLA4-Ig completely blocked the primary response to factor VIII in hemophilic mice with intact B7 function. This reagent also prevented or diminished further increases in antifactor VIII when given to hemophilic mice with low antifactor VIII antibody titers. These studies suggest that strategies targeting the B7-CD28 pathway are potential therapies to prevent and treat inhibitory antifactor VIII antibodies. Moreover, because the development of antibodies to replaced proteins may limit the success of many human gene therapy approaches, our results may be broadly applicable. (Blood. 2000;95:1324-1329)     

Back to the future: a recent history of haemophilia treatment

Summary.  In the last few decades, the management of patients with haemophilia has witnessed dramatic improvements, through the larger availability of safe plasma-derived and recombinant products for replacement therapy. Another important step forward is the progressively larger-scale implementation of primary prophylaxis in children. Currently, the main problem in patients with haemophilia is the onset of antibodies inactivating the infused clotting factor (inhibitors), even though immune tolerance regimens that are able to eradicate inhibitors and the availability of products that bypass the intrinsic coagulation defects have dramatically improved the management of these patients. Cure of haemophilia through gene transfer is being attempted, but relatively, it is far from being implemented on a large scale. It is likely that further improvements in replacement therapy will occur in the near future, through the availability of new-therapeutic tools such as factors VIII and IX with longer half-lives, more potent bypassing agents and factors extracted from the milk of transgenic animals.     

Recent advances in developing specific therapies for haemophilia

Haemophilia therapy has undergone very rapid evolution in the last 10 years. The major limitation of current replacement therapy is the short half‐life of factors VIII and IX. These half‐lives have been extended by the addition of various moieties, allowing less frequent infusion regimens. Entirely novel approaches have also entered the clinic, including a bispecific antibody that mimics factor VIII and strategies that rebalance the haemostatic mechanism by reducing antithrombin through inhibition of synthesis. These two treatments are available by subcutaneous injection at infrequent intervals and both can be used in patients with neutralising antibodies (inhibitors). Finally, a cure may be on the horizon with preliminary evidence of success for gene therapy in haemophilia B and A.     

Immune implications of gene therapy for hemophilia

Similar to any novel treatment strategy for hemophilia, gene therapy faces the question of the risk of formation of inhibitory antibodies to the therapeutic factor VIII or factor IX protein. Activation of CD4 (+) or CD8 (+) T cells could lead to antibody formation or cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses to transgene-expressing cells. Preclinical studies in animal models of hemophilia A and B with different mutations in the dysfunctional gene shed light on the risk for such immune responses and point toward strategies to avoid immune activation or even promote tolerance induction. The impacts of variables such as choice and design of gene transfer vector, underlying gene mutation, route of vector administration, and transient immune suppression are discussed. Maintenance of immunological hyporesponsiveness to the therapeutic gene product is critical for successful gene therapy. Recent studies provide evidence for tolerance induction to coagulation factor antigens by viral hepatic or neonatal in vivo gene transfer, by in utero gene delivery, and by oral or nasal administration of protein or peptides.     

Acquired inhibitors of coagulation factors: part II

Acquired coagulation inhibitors are antibodies that bind to coagulation factors and neutralize their activity or accelerate their clearance. Inhibitors occurring in patients with inherited deficiencies of coagulation factors are referred to as "alloantibodies," while those developing spontaneously in individuals with previously normal coagulation factor function are designated as "autoantibodies." The latter category includes inhibitors against coagulation factors I, II, V, VII, VIII (acquired hemophilia A), IX (acquired hemophilia B), X, XI, and XIII. This review will discuss the most important pathogenic, clinical, laboratory, and therapeutic aspects of the inhibitors of coagulation factors other than acquired hemophilia A, as this is reviewed separately within this issue of the journal.     

Haemophilias A and B

The haemophilias are inherited disorders in which one of the coagulation factors is deficient. Although deficiencies of factor VIII (haemophilia A) and factor IX (haemophilia B) are well recognised, von Willebrand's disease is much more common. Rare defects can occur in any of the coagulation factors. In the past, men with haemophilia were likely to die in their youth. With advances in diagnosis, and especially with development of safe and effective treatment, affected individuals can now look forward to a normal life expectancy. Complications of the disorder, particularly the development of antibodies that make treatment ineffective, and of treatment, such as transfusion-transmitted infections, have taken a severe toll on these patients. The future holds the realistic possibility of gene therapy. However, we must not forget that haemophilia is a worldwide disorder that requires significant economic resources not available for the majority.