Multiparameter Immune Profiling of Operational Tolerance in Liver Transplantation

Immunosuppressive drugs can be completely withdrawn in up to 20% of liver transplant recipients, commonly referred to as 'operationally' tolerant. Immune characterization of these patients, however, has not been performed in detail, and we lack tests capable of identifying tolerant patients among recipients receiving maintenance immunosuppression. In the current study we have analyzed a variety of biological traits in peripheral blood of operationally tolerant liver recipients in an attempt to define a multiparameter 'fingerprint' of tolerance. Thus, we have performed peripheral blood gene expression profiling and extensive blood cell immunophenotyping on 16 operationally tolerant liver recipients, 16 recipients requiring on-going immunosuppressive therapy, and 10 healthy individuals. Microarray profiling identified a gene expression signature that could discriminate tolerant recipients from immunosuppression-dependent patients with high accuracy. This signature included genes encoding for gammadelta T-cell and NK receptors, and for proteins involved in cell proliferation arrest. In addition, tolerant recipients exhibited significantly greater numbers of circulating potentially regulatory T-cell subsets (CD4+ CD25+ T-cells and Vdelta1+ T cells) than either non-tolerant patients or healthy individuals. Our data provide novel mechanistic insight on liver allograft operational tolerance, and constitute a first step in the search for a non-invasive diagnostic signature capable of predicting tolerance before undergoing drug weaning.     

Analyses of Peripheral Blood Mononuclear Cells in Operational Tolerance After Pediatric Living Donor Liver Transplantation

Operational tolerance (graft acceptance in an immunosuppression (IS)-free environment) after living-donor liver transplantation (LDLT) could occur by our elective protocol in some patients. There is, nevertheless, no reliable parameter to monitor patients who may discontinue IS without a risk of rejection. To identify such parameters, we systemically phenotyped peripheral blood mononuclear cells from operationally tolerant patients. An increase was observed in the frequency of CD4+CD25high+ cells, B cells and Vdelta1/Vdelta2 gammadeltaT-cells ratio in operationally tolerant patients (Gr-tol; n = 12), compared with those from age-matched volunteers (Gr-vol; n = 24) or patients on IS (Gr-IS; n = 19). The frequency of NK cells was decreased in Gr-tol, compared with those in Gr-IS or Gr-vol. The frequency of NKT cells was decreased after LDLT, compared with that in Gr-vol. Although the contribution of those subsets to the tolerant state remains elusive, the results may provide important clues for reliable indicators of tolerance after LDLT.     

Clinical Operational Tolerance after Kidney Transplantation

Induction of allograft-specific tolerance and the detection of a "tolerance" state in recipients under immunosuppression with long-term stable graft function are major challenges in transplantation. Clinical "operational tolerance," defined as stable and acceptable graft function without immunosuppression for years, is a rare event. There is no report on the clinical history of such patients. In this article, we report on the medical history of 10 kidney recipients who display an immunosuppressive drug-free "operational tolerance" for 9.4 +/- 5.2 years. Clinical factors that may favor such a tolerant state are underlined. Firstly, most of the patients interrupted immunosuppression over a long time period (until 4 years), which mimics the procedure of intentional immunosuppression weaning following liver transplantation. Secondly, donor age was younger (median 25 years) than the one of the general transplanted population, suggesting that graft quality is one of the conditions favoring "operational tolerance." Moreover, the "operationally tolerant" recipients may be 'low responders' to blood transfusions (PRA 6 +/- 5.4%, six blood transfusions). We also show that "operational tolerance" occurs in the presence of anti-donor class II antibodies, as assessed in two patients. Finally, two patients degraded their renal function 9 to 13 years after treatment withdrawal, however only one presented histological lesions of chronic rejection.     

Clinical, immunological, and pathological aspects of operational tolerance after pediatric living-donor liver transplantation

In the setting of our pediatric living-donor liver transplantation (LDLT), 87 patients (15.0% of all the patients: significantly higher proportion, compared with those of other transplant centers) achieved complete withdrawal of immunosuppression, which is referred to as "operational tolerance". Immunosuppressants were completely discontinued for 54 patients as scheduled, and for 33 because of EBV infection or other complications. Immunological analyses of the peripheral blood derived from operationally tolerant patients demonstrated that non-deletional tolerance takes place in which potentially reactive T cells to donor-antigens remain physically in the immune repertoire, but specifically suppressed by certain mechanisms. Not only CD4(+)CD25(high+) T cells were increased in the proportion in the tolerant patients' peripheral lymphocytes and suppressed MLR specifically to the donor antigen, but also FOXP3 expressing cells were present within the tolerant liver. Thus, among several mechanisms accounting for non-deletional tolerance, Tregs are likely to involve at least in part in our tolerant patients. Vdelta1gammadeltaT cells, a subset of gammadeltaT cells, which otherwise reside mainly in the intestine, emerge into the peripheral blood during successful pregnancy but not abortive pregnancy. Since Vdelta1gammadeltaT cells produce massive IL-10, it is proposed that Vdelta1gammadeltaT cells induce fetomaternal tolerance by promoting Th2 immune deviation. Consistent with pregnancy, IL-10 producing Vdelta1gammadeltaT cells emerge into the blood of our tolerant patients. This may reflect a common feature between fetomaternal tolerance and transplant tolerance. We began protocol biopsy in post-LDLT patients who exhibit normal liver function from January 2003. Operationally tolerant patients, albeit showing normal liver function, exhibited decrease in size and increase in number of the bile duct and the fibrosis to a greater extent, compared with patients on maintenance immunosuppression. This warrants serial protocol biopsy before and after complete cessation of immunosuppression even in the presence of normal liver function.     

Central Role of CD45RA? Foxp3hi Memory Regulatory T Cells in Clinical Kidney Transplantation Tolerance

The role of Foxp3⁺ regulatory T cells (Tregs) in operational tolerance remains elusive, as initial results revealed an increased frequency of this subset in tolerant patients but no functional differences compared with immunosuppressed recipients. In addition, recent studies of regulatory B cells strongly suggest that Tregs may not have a central role in kidney transplantation tolerance. However, recent investigations of the crucial role of Foxp3 demethylation in Treg function and the possibility of identifying distinct Foxp3 T cell subsets prompted us to more thoroughly characterize Tregs in operationally tolerant patients. Thus, we studied the level of demethylation of the Foxp3 Treg-specific demethylated region (TSDR) in circulating CD4⁺ T cells and analyzed Treg subset frequency in tolerant patients, healthy volunteers, patients with stable graft function under immunosuppression, and chronically rejecting recipients. We observed a higher proportion of CD4⁺ T cells with demethylated Foxp3 and a specific expansion of CD4⁺ CD45RA⁻ Foxp3^hi memory Tregs exclusively in tolerant patients. The memory Tregs of tolerant recipients exhibited increased Foxp3 TSDR demethylation, expressed higher levels of CD39 and glucocorticoid-induced TNF-related receptor, and harbored greater suppressive properties than memory Tregs from patients with stable graft function. Taken together, our data demonstrate that operationally tolerant patients mobilize an array of potentially suppressive cells, including not only regulatory B cells but also Tregs. Our results also indicate that tolerant patients have potent CD4⁺CD45RA⁻ Foxp3^hi memory Tregs with a specific Foxp3 TSDR demethylation pattern, which may contribute to the maintenance of graft tolerance.     

The Natural History of Clinical Operational Tolerance After Kidney Transplantation Through Twenty‐Seven Cases

We report here on a European cohort of 27 kidney transplant recipients displaying operational tolerance, compared to two cohorts of matched kidney transplant recipients under immunosuppression and patients who stopped immunosuppressive drugs and presented with rejection. We report that a lower proportion of operationally tolerant patients received induction therapy (52% without induction therapy vs. 78.3%[p = 0.0455] and 96.7%[p = 0.0001], respectively), a difference likely due to the higher proportion (18.5%) of HLA matched recipients in the tolerant cohort. These patients were also significantly older at the time of transplantation (p = 0.0211) and immunosuppression withdrawal (p = 0.0002) than recipients who rejected their graft after weaning. Finally, these patients were at lower risk of infectious disease. Among the 27 patients defined as operationally tolerant at the time of inclusion, 19 still display stable graft function (mean 9 ± 4 years after transplantation) whereas 30% presented slow deterioration of graft function. Six of these patients tested positive for pre‐graft anti‐HLA antibodies. Biopsy histology studies revealed an active immunologically driven mechanism for half of them, associated with DSA in the absence of C4d. This study suggests that operational tolerance can persist as a robust phenomenon, although eventual graft loss does occur in some patients, particularly in the setting of donor‐specific alloantibody.     

Nonchimeric HLA‐Identical Renal Transplant Tolerance: Regulatory Immunophenotypic/Genomic Biomarkers

We previously described early results of a nonchimeric operational tolerance protocol in human leukocyte antigen (HLA)‐identical living donor renal transplants and now update these results. Recipients given alemtuzumab, tacrolimus/MPA with early sirolimus conversion were multiply infused with donor hematopoietic CD34⁺ stem cells. Immunosuppression was withdrawn by 24 months. Twelve months later, operational tolerance was confirmed by rejection‐free transplant biopsies. Five of the first eight enrollees were initially tolerant 1 year off immunosuppression. Biopsies of three others after total withdrawal showed Banff 1A acute cellular rejection without renal dysfunction. With longer follow‐up including 5‐year posttransplant biopsies, four of the five tolerant recipients remain without rejection while one developed Banff 1A without renal dysfunction. We now add seven new subjects (two operationally tolerant), and demonstrate time‐dependent increases of circulating CD4⁺CD25⁺⁺⁺CD127^?FOXP3⁺ Tregs versus losses of Tregs in nontolerant subjects (p < 0.001). Gene expression signatures, developed using global RNA expression profiling of sequential whole blood and protocol biopsy samples, were highly associative with operational tolerance as early as 1 year posttransplant. The blood signature was validated by an external Immune Tolerance Network data set. Our approach to nonchimeric operational HLA‐identical tolerance reveals association with Treg immunophenotypes and serial gene expression profiles.

     

Renal Operational Tolerance Is Associated With a Defect of Blood Tfh Cells That Exhibit Impaired B Cell Help

Renal operationally tolerant patients (TOL) display a defect in B cell differentiation, with a deficiency in plasma cells. Recently described, T follicular helper (Tfh) cells play a critical role in B cell differentiation. We analyzed blood Tfh subsets in TOL and transplanted patients with stable graft function under immunosuppression (STA). We observed a reduced proportion of blood activated and highly functional Tfh subsets in TOL, without affecting Tfh absolute numbers. Functionally, Tfh cells from TOL displayed a modified gene expression profile, failed to produce interleukin‐21, and were unable to induce IgG production by naive B cells. This Tfh defect is linked to a low incidence of postgraft de novo donor‐specific antibody (dnDSA) immunization, suggesting that the lack of Tfh cells in TOL may induce a protolerogenic environment with reduced risk of developing dnDSA. Finally, we showed that elevated Tfh in STA precedes the occurrence of dnDSA during an alloresponse. These data provide new insights into the mechanisms of antibody response in operational tolerance. Disrupted homeostasis and impaired Tfh function in TOL could lead to a reduced risk of developing dnDSA and suggest a predictive role of blood Tfh cells on the occurrence of dnDSA in transplant recipients.     

Decreased expression of miR-204-3p in peripheral blood and wound margin tissue associated with the onset and poor wound healing of diabetic foot ulcers

To investigate the relationship between small non-coding RNA-204-3p (miR-204-3p) and the onset and wound healing of diabetic foot ulcers (DFU) and the underlying molecular mechanism, sixty four newly diagnosed patients with T2DM without DFU (T2DM group), 82 T2DM patients with DFU (DFU group), and 60 controls with normal glucose tolerance (NC group) were included. Quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR) method was used to determine miR-204-3p expression levels in peripheral blood and wound margin tissue of subjects, and to analyse the relationship between the expression of miR-204-3p and wound healing. In vitro experiments were also performed to understand the effect of miR-204-3p on high glucose induced injury of HaCaT cells (human keratinocytes). The results showed that miR-204-3p expression level of peripheral blood in the T2DM group was marked lower than that in the NC group [2.38 (1.31-5.04) vs 3.27 (1.51-6.98)] (P < .05). Similarly, the miR-204-3p expression level of peripheral blood in the DFU group was significantly lower than the T2DM group [1.15 (0.78-2.89) vs 2.38 (1.31-5.04)] (P < .01). The expression level of miR-204-3p in peripheral blood and wound margin tissues of DFU patients was positively correlated with the healing rate of foot ulcers after 8 weeks (P < .05). Multifactorial logistic regression analysis showed that decreased expression of miR-204-3p in peripheral blood was an independent risk factor for DFU (OR = 2.95, P < .05). The results of in vitro experiments showed that miR-204-3p could improve the proliferation and migration of HKC cells and reduce the proportion of apoptosis of HKC cells by targeted regulation of zinc finger protein Kruppel like factor 6 (KLF6) in high glucose environment. Therefore, the decreased expression of miR-204-3p in peripheral blood and wound tissue of T2DM patients is closely related to the occurrence and poor wound healing of DFU. The down-regulated expression of miR-204-3p can reduce its ability to antagonise the functional damage of keratinocytes induced by high-glucose conditions. These results will provide potential targets for the treatment of DFU.     

Longitudinal Studies of a B Cell–Derived Signature of Tolerance in Renal Transplant Recipients

Biomarkers of transplant tolerance would enhance the safety and feasibility of clinical tolerance trials and potentially facilitate management of patients receiving immunosuppression. To this end, we examined blood from spontaneously tolerant renal transplant recipients and patients enrolled in two interventional tolerance trials using flow cytometry and gene expression profiling. Using a previously reported tolerant cohort as well as newly identified tolerant patients, we confirmed our previous finding that tolerance was associated with increased expression of B cell–associated genes relative to immunosuppressed patients. This was not accounted for merely by an increase in total B cell numbers, but was associated with the increased frequencies of transitional and naïve B cells. Moreover, serial measurements of gene expression demonstrated that this pattern persisted over several years, although patients receiving immunosuppression also displayed an increase in the two most dominant tolerance‐related B cell genes, IGKV1D‐13 and IGLL‐1, over time. Importantly, patients rendered tolerant via induction of transient mixed chimerism, and those weaned to minimal immunosuppression, showed similar increases in IGKV1D‐13 as did spontaneously tolerant individuals. Collectively, these findings support the notion that alterations in B cells may be a common theme for tolerant kidney transplant recipients, and that it is a useful monitoring tool in prospective trials.     

Identification of a gene expression profile associated with operational tolerance among a selected group of stable kidney transplant patients

Despite their utility, immunosuppressive treatments have numerous side effects, including infectious complications, malignancies and metabolic disorders, all of which contribute to long‐term graft loss. In addition to the development of new pharmaceutical products with reduced toxicity and more comfortable modes of administration, tailoring immunosuppression according to the immune status of each patient would represent a significant breakthrough. Gene expression profiling has been shown to be a clinically relevant monitoring tool. In this paper, we have assessed the overall long‐term kidney transplant outcome and attempted to identify operationally tolerant‐like patients among recipients with stable clinical status at least 5 years post‐transplantation. We thus measured a combination of noninvasive blood biomarkers of operational tolerance in a cohort of 144 stable patients and showed that only 3.5% exhibited a gene expression profile of operational tolerance, suggesting that such a profile can be detected under immunosuppressive therapy but that its frequency is low in kidney transplant recipients when compared with liver transplant recipients. We suggest that a rational approach to patient selection, based on a combination of clinical and biological characteristics, may help to provide a safer method for identification of patients potentially suitable for immunosuppressive drug weaning procedures.