A new diagnostic workflow for patients with mental retardation and/or multiple congenital abnormalities: test arrays first

High-density single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genotyping technology enables extensive genotyping as well as the detection of increasingly smaller chromosomal aberrations. In this study, we assess molecular karyotyping as first-round analysis of patients with mental retardation and/or multiple congenital abnormalities (MR/MCA). We used different commercially available SNP array platforms, the Affymetrix GeneChip 262K NspI, the Genechip 238K StyI, the Illumina HumanHap 300 and HumanCNV 370 BeadChip, to detect copy number variants (CNVs) in 318 patients with unexplained MR/MCA. We found abnormalities in 22.6% of the patients, including six CNVs that overlap known microdeletion/duplication syndromes, eight CNVs that overlap recently described syndromes, 63 potentially pathogenic CNVs (in 52 patients), four large segments of homozygosity and two mosaic trisomies for an entire chromosome. This study shows that high-density SNP array analysis reveals a much higher diagnostic yield as that of conventional karyotyping. SNP arrays have the potential to detect CNVs, mosaics, uniparental disomies and loss of heterozygosity in one experiment. We, therefore, propose a novel diagnostic approach to all MR/MCA patients by first analyzing every patient with an SNP array instead of conventional karyotyping.     

Detection of pathogenic gene copy number variations in patients with mental retardation by genomewide oligonucleotide array comparative genomic hybridization

Genomic imbalance is a major cause of developmental disorders. Microarray-based comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) has revealed frequent imbalances associated with clinical syndromes, but also a large number of copy number variations (CNVs), which have complicated the interpretation of results. We studied 100 consecutive patients with unexplained mental retardation and a normal karyotype using several platforms of CGH arrays. A genomewide array with 44,290 oligonucleotide probes (OaCGH44K) detected imbalances in 15% of cases studied with sizes ranged from 459 kb to 19 Mb while revealing a small number of CNVs (0.72/individual). Another platform with approximately 240,000 oligonucleotide probes (OaCGH244K) revealed a large number of CNVs (20/individual) in selected cases and their normal parents. We used a comprehensive approach for interpreting the results of aCGH, including consideration of the size, inheritance and gene content of CNVs, and consultation with an online Database of Genomic Variants (DGV) and Online Mendelian Inheritance in Men (OMIM) for information on the genes involved. Our study suggests that genomewide oligonucleotide arrays such as the OaCGH44K platform can be used as a powerful diagnostic tool for detection of genomic imbalances associated with unexplained mental retardation or syndromic autism spectrum disorders. It is interesting to note that a small number of common variants were revealed by OaCGH244K in some study subjects but not in their parents and that some inherited CNVs had altered breakpoints. Further investigations on these alterations may provide useful information for understanding the mechanism of CNVs.     

Array CGH identifies reciprocal 16p13.1 duplications and deletions that predispose to autism and/or mental retardation

Autism and mental retardation (MR) are often associated, suggesting that these conditions are etiologically related. Recently, array-based comparative genomic hybridization (array CGH) has identified submicroscopic deletions and duplications as a common cause of MR, prompting us to search for such genomic imbalances in autism. Here we describe a 1.5-Mb duplication on chromosome 16p13.1 that was found by high-resolution array CGH in four severe autistic male patients from three unrelated families. The same duplication was identified in several variably affected and unaffected relatives. A deletion of the same interval was detected in three unrelated patients with MR and other clinical abnormalities. In one patient we revealed a further rearrangement of the 16p13 imbalance that was not present in his unaffected mother. Duplications and deletions of this 1.5-Mb interval have not been described as copy number variants in the Database of Genomic Variants and have not been identified in >600 individuals from other cohorts examined by high-resolution array CGH in our laboratory. Thus we conclude that these aberrations represent recurrent genomic imbalances which predispose to autism and/or MR.     

Array-based MLPA to detect recurrent copy number variations in patients with idiopathic mental retardation

Microdeletions, either subtelomeric or interstitial, are responsible for the mental handicap in approximately 10-20% of all patients. Currently, Multiplex Ligation-dependent Probe Amplification (MLPA) is widely used to detect these small aberrations in a routine fashion. Although cost-effective, the throughput is low and the degree of multiplexing is limited to maximally 40-50 probes. Therefore, we developed an array-based MLPA method, with probes identified by unique tag sequences, allowing the simultaneous analysis of 180 probes in a single experiment thereby covering all known mental retardation loci with at least two probes. We screened 120 patients with idiopathic mental retardation. In this group we detected 6 aberrations giving a detection rate of 5%, consistent with similar studies. In addition we tested 293 patients with mental retardation who were negative for fragile X syndrome and commercially available subtelomeric MLPA. We found seven causative rearrangements in this group (detection rate of 2.4%) thereby illustrating the value of including probes for interstitial microdeletion syndromes and additional probes in the telomeric regions in targeted screening sets for mental retardation. Array-based MLPA may thus be a good candidate to develop probe sets that rapidly detect copy number changes of disease associated loci in the human genome. This method may become a valuable tool in a routine diagnostic setting as it is a fast, user-friendly and relatively low-cost technique providing straightforward results requiring only 125 ng of genomic DNA.     

Array-CGH study of partial trisomy 9p without mental retardation

Partial trisomy 9p is one of the most common detected autosomal structural anomalies, so the phenotype-genotype correlation of this rearrangement has been well described. Despite variation in size of the 9p duplications, trisomy 9p syndrome is characterized by typical dysmorphic features and a variable but constant psychomotor and mental retardation. Previously reported phenotype genotype correlation studies proposed that the critical region for phenotype is located in 9p22. We report here on a new patient with partial trisomy 9p13.3→9pter in an 8-year-old boy with typical trisomy 9p dysmorphic features but a normal mental development. Cytogenetics investigations showed that our patient karyotype was 47,XY,+ der(22)t(9;22)(p13.q11) inherited by a 3:1 disjunction of a maternal reciprocal translocation t(9;22)(p13.q11). FISH and array CGH analysis were used to better characterize duplicated chromosomal regions and showed a large duplication of chromosome 9p13.3→9pter associated to microduplication in 22q11.1. The size of the duplications in chromosomes 9p and 22q were estimated about 33.9 and 2.67 Mb, respectively. The comparison between this case and those reported in the literature allows us to support that all syndromes show variability and that not all partial trisomies 9p are associated with intellectual disability.     

Subtelomeric imbalances in phenotypically normal individuals

Subtelomeric imbalances are identified in approximately 5% of patients with idiopathic mental retardation (MR) and multiple congenital anomalies (MCA). Because of this high incidence, screening for subtelomeric anomalies became part of the routine genetic evaluation of MCA/MR patients. In contrast to the general view that subtelomeric imbalances cause MCA/MR, we report here 15 subtelomeric copy-number changes in 12 families in which the imbalance is inherited from a phenotypically normal parent. We detected inherited deletions at subtelomeres 2q, 3p, 4p, 4q, 6q, 10q, 17p, 17q, Xp, and Yq and duplications at 1q, 4q, 10q, and 11q. Interestingly, in addition to small deletions (<1 Mb) also unexpected large deletions and duplications up to 7.8 Mb were detected. Taken together with previous reports, a total of 16 subtelomeric duplications and 18 deletions inherited from a phenotypically normal parent have now been reported. Clearly, more extensive genotype-phenotype correlations are needed to better understand the phenotypic consequences of these subtelomeric copy number variations and to resolve the current uncertainty for genetic counseling in postnatal and prenatal diagnosis.     

Cytogenetics and holoprosencephaly: A chromosomal microarray study of 222 individuals with holoprosencephaly

Holoprosencephaly (HPE), a common developmental forebrain malformation, is characterized by failure of the cerebrum to completely divide into left and right hemispheres. The etiology of HPE is heterogeneous and a number of environmental and genetic factors have been identified. Cytogenetically visible alterations occur in 25% to 45% of HPE patients and cytogenetic techniques have long been used to study copy number variants (CNVs) in this disorder. The karyotype approach initially demonstrated several recurrent chromosomal anomalies, which led to the identification of HPE-specific loci and, eventually, several major HPE genes. More recently, higher-resolution cytogenetic techniques such as subtelomeric multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification and chromosomal microarray have been used to analyze chromosomal anomalies. By using chromosomal microarray, we sought to identify submicroscopic chromosomal deletions and duplications in patients with HPE. In an analysis of 222 individuals with HPE, a deletion or duplication was detected in 107 individuals. Of these 107 individuals, 23 (21%) had variants that were classified as pathogenic or likely pathogenic by board-certified medical geneticists. We identified multiple patients with deletions in established HPE loci as well as three patients with deletions encompassed by 6q12-q14.3, a CNV previously reported by Bendavid et al. In addition, we identified a new locus, 16p13.2 that warrants further investigation for HPE association. Incidentally, we also found a case of Potocki-Lupski syndrome, a case of Phelan-McDermid syndrome, and multiple cases of 22q11.2 deletion syndrome within our cohort. These data confirm the genetically heterogeneous nature of HPE, and also demonstrate clinical utility of chromosomal microarray in diagnosing patients affected by HPE.     

Molecular karyotyping in patients with mental retardation using 100K single-nucleotide polymorphism arrays

Background

Using array techniques, it was recently shown that about 10% of patients with mental retardation of unknown origin harbour cryptic chromosomal aneusomies. However, data analysis is currently not standardised and little is known about its sensitivity and specificity.

Methods

We have developed an electronic data analysis tool for gene‐mapping SNP arrays, a software tool that we call Copy Number Variation Finder (CNVF). Using CNVF, we analysed 104 unselected patients with mental retardation of unknown origin with a genechip mapping 100K SNP array and established an optimised set of analysis parameters.

Results

We detected deletions as small as 20 kb when covered by at least three single‐nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and duplications as small as 150 kb when covered by at least six SNPs, with only one false‐positive signal in six patients. In 9.1% of patients, we detected apparently disease‐causing or de novo aberrations ranging in size from 0.4 to 14 Mb. Morphological anomalies in patients with de novo aberrations were equal to that of unselected patients when measured with de Vries score.

Conclusion

Our standardised CNVF data analysis tool is easy to use and has high sensitivity and specificity. As some genomic regions are covered more densely than others, the genome‐wide resolution of the 100K array is about 400–500 kb for deletions and 900–1000 kb for duplications. The detection rate of about 10% of de novo aberrations is independent of selection of patients for particular features. The incidental finding in two patients of heterozygosity for the 250 kb recurrent deletion at the NPH1 locus, associated with autosomal recessive juvenile nephronophthisis, which was inherited from a healthy parent, highlights the fact that inherited aberrations might be disease‐related even though not causal for mental retardation.     

Array-Based Comparative Genomic Hybridization in 190 Korean Patients with Developmental Delay and/or Intellectual Disability: A Single Tertiary Care University Center Study

Purpose

This study analyzed and evaluated the demographic, clinical, and cytogenetic data [G-banded karyotyping and array-based comparative genomic hybridization (array CGH)] of patients with unexplained developmental delay or intellectual disability at a single Korean institution.

Materials and Methods

We collected clinical and cytogenetic data based on retrospective charts at Ajou University Medical Center, Suwon, Korea from April 2008 to March 2012.

Results

A total of 190 patients were identified. Mean age was 5.1±1.87 years. Array CGH yielded abnormal results in 26 of 190 patients (13.7%). Copy number losses were about two-fold more frequent than gains. A total of 61.5% of all patients had copy number losses. The most common deletion disorders included 22q11.2 deletion syndrome, 15q11.2q12 deletion and 18q deletion syndrome. Copy number gains were identified in 34.6% of patients, and common diseases among these included Potocki-Lupski syndrome, 15q11-13 duplication syndrome and duplication 22q. Abnormal karyotype with normal array CGH results was exhibited in 2.6% of patients; theses included balanced translocation (n=2), inversion (n=2) and low-level mosaicism (n=1). Facial abnormalities (p<0.001) and failure to thrive were (p<0.001) also more frequent in the group of patients with abnormal CGH findings.

Conclusion

Array CGH is a useful diagnostic tool in clinical settings in patients with developmental delay or intellectual disability combined with facial abnormalities or failure to thrive.     

Emerging patterns of cryptic chromosomal imbalance in patients with idiopathic mental retardation and multiple congenital anomalies: a new series of 140 patients and review of published reports

Background

Chromosomal abnormalities are a major cause of mental retardation and multiple congenital anomalies (MCA/MR). Screening for these chromosomal imbalances has mainly been done by standard karyotyping. Previous array CGH studies on selected patients with chromosomal phenotypes and normal karyotypes suggested an incidence of 10–15% of previously unnoticed de novo chromosomal imbalances.

Objective

To report array CGH screening of a series of 140 patients (the largest published so far) with idiopathic MCA/MR but normal karyotype.

Results

Submicroscopic chromosomal imbalances were detected in 28 of the 140 patients (20%) and included 18 deletions, seven duplications, and three unbalanced translocations. Seventeen of 24 imbalances were confirmed de novo and 19 were assumed to be causal. Excluding subtelomeric imbalances, our study identified 11 clinically relevant interstitial submicroscopic imbalances (8%). Taking this and previously reported studies into consideration, array CGH screening with a resolution of at least 1 Mb has been undertaken on 432 patients with MCA/MR. Most imbalances are non‐recurrent and spread across the genome. In at least 8.8% of these patients (38 of 432) de novo intrachromosomal alterations have been identified.

Conclusions

Array CGH should be considered an essential aspect of the genetic analysis of patients with MCA/MR. In addition, in the present study three patients were mosaic for a structural chromosome rearrangement. One of these patients had monosomy 7 in as few as 8% of the cells, showing that array CGH allows detection of low grade mosaicisims.     

Pure subtelomeric microduplications as a cause of mental retardation

Submicroscopic subtelomeric aberrations are a common cause of mental retardation (MR). New molecular techniques allow the identification of subtelomeric microduplications, but their frequency and significance are largely unknown. We determined the frequency of subtelomeric, pure microduplications in a cohort of 624 patients with MR and/or multiple congenital anomalies using multiplex ligation dependent probe amplification (MLPA) and delineated the identified microduplications using array based comparative genomic hybridization (array CGH). In 11 patients, MLPA revealed a subtelomeric duplication without a concurrent deletion. Additional fluorescence in situ hybridization studies and parental analyses showed that three had occurred de novo: one duplication 5q34qter (12.7 Mb), one duplication 9q34.13qter (7.2 Mb) and one duplication 9p24.2pter (4.1 Mb). Five microduplications (9p, 11q, 12q, 15q and 16p) appeared to be inherited from an unaffected parent, while in three cases (9p, 12p and 17p) the parents were not available for testing. Based on our findings and data from the literature, the three de novo duplications were the only ones likely to be disease-causing, leading to a frequency of pathogenic subtelomeric, pure microduplications of 0.5%. Our study shows that subtelomeric microduplications are an infrequent cause of MR and that additional clinical and family studies are required to assess their clinical significance.     

Molecular karyotyping of patients with unexplained mental retardation by SNP arrays: A multicenter study

Genomic microarrays have been implemented in the diagnosis of patients with unexplained mental retardation. This method, although revolutionizing cytogenetics, is still limited to the detection of rare de novo copy number variants (CNVs). Genome‐wide single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) microarrays provide high‐resolution genotype as well as CNV information in a single experiment. We hypothesize that the widespread use of these microarray platforms can be exploited to greatly improve our understanding of the genetic causes of mental retardation and many other common disorders, while already providing a robust platform for routine diagnostics. Here we report a detailed validation of Affymetrix 500k SNP microarrays for the detection of CNVs associated to mental retardation. After this validation we applied the same platform in a multicenter study to test a total of 120 patients with unexplained mental retardation and their parents. Rare de novo CNVs were identified in 15% of cases, showing the importance of this approach in daily clinical practice. In addition, much more genomic variation was observed in these patients as well as their parents. We provide all of these data for the scientific community to jointly enhance our understanding of these genomic variants and their potential role in this common disorder. Hum Mutat 30:1–11, 2009. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Homozygosity mapping in outbred families with mental retardation

Autosomal recessive mental retardation (AR-MR) may account for up to 25% of genetic mental retardation (MR). So far, mapping of AR-MR genes in consanguineous families has resulted in six nonsyndromic genes, whereas more than 2000 genes might contribute to AR-MR. We propose to use outbred families with multiple affected siblings for AR-MR gene identification. Homozygosity mapping in ten outbred families with affected brother-sister pairs using a 250 K single nucleotide polymorphism array revealed on average 57 homozygous regions over 1 Mb in size per affected individual (range 20-74). Of these, 21 homozygous regions were shared between siblings on average (range 8-36). None of the shared regions of homozygosity (SROHs) overlapped with the nonsyndromic genes. A total of 13 SROHs had an overlap with previously reported loci for AR-MR, namely with MRT8, MRT9, MRT10 and MRT11. Among these was the longest observed SROH of 11.0 Mb in family ARMR1 on chromosome 19q13, which had 2.9 Mb (98 genes) in common with the 5.4 Mb MRT11 locus (195 genes). These data support that homozygosity mapping in outbred families may contribute to identification of novel AR-MR genes.     

Epilepsy with cognitive deficit and autism spectrum disorders: Prospective diagnosis by array CGH

The clinical significance of chromosomal microdeletions and microduplications was predicted based on their gene content, de novo or familial inheritance and accumulated knowledge recorded on public databases. A patient group comprised of 247 cases with epilepsy and its common co‐morbidities of developmental delay, intellectual disability, autism spectrum disorders, and congenital abnormalities was reviewed prospectively in a diagnostic setting using a standardized oligo‐array CGH platform. Seventy‐three (29.6%) had copy number variations (CNVs) and of these 73 cases, 27 (37.0%) had CNVs that were likely causative. These 27 cases comprised 10.9% of the 247 cases reviewed. The range of pathogenic CNVs associated with seizures was consistent with the existence of many genetic determinants for epilepsy. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

De novo duplication of MECP2 in a girl with mental retardation and no obvious dysmorphic features

Makrythanasis P, Moix I, Gimelli S, Fluss J, Aliferis K, Antonarakis SE, Morris MA, Béna F, Bottani A. De novo duplication of MECP2 in a girl with mental retardation and no obvious dysmorphic features. Loss‐of‐function mutations of MECP2 are responsible for Rett syndrome (RTT), an X‐linked neurodevelopmental disorder affecting mainly girls. The availability of MECP2 testing has led to the identification of such mutations in girls with atypical RTT features and the recognition of milder forms. Furthermore, duplication of the entire gene has recently been described in boys with mental retardation and recurrent infections. We describe a girl with a heterozygous de novo MECP2 duplication. The patient, at the age of 19, has mental retardation with no autistic features. She is friendly but gets frequently anxious. She has neither dysmorphic features nor malformations. Her motor development was delayed with walking at 20 months. Speech is fluid with good pronunciation but is simple and repetitive. Diagnosis was made after single‐strand conformation analysis (SSCA) and multiplex ligation‐dependent probe amplification (MLPA) analysis of MECP2. Array comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) analysis showed a duplication of 29 kb including MECP2 and part of IRAK1. Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) has revealed that the duplicated region is inserted near the telomere of the short arm of chromosome 10. X‐chromosome inactivation in leukocyte DNA was not skewed. We conclude that it is likely that this MECP2 duplication is responsible for the mental retardation in this patient. This case broadens the phenotypic spectrum of MECP2 abnormalities with consequent implication in diagnosis and genetic counselling of girls with non‐syndromic mental retardation.     

Genomic copy number variations in three Southeast Asian populations

Research on the role of copy number variations (CNVs) in the genetic risk of diseases in Asian populations has been hampered by a relative lack of reference CNV maps for Asian populations outside the East Asians. In this article, we report the population characteristics of CNVs in Chinese, Malay, and Asian Indian populations in Singapore. Using the Illumina Human 1M Beadchip array, we identify 1,174 CNV loci in these populations that corroborated with findings when the same samples were typed on the Affymetrix 6.0 platform. We identify 441 novel loci not previously reported in the Database of Genomic Variations (DGV). We observe a considerable number of loci that span all three populations and were previously unreported, as well as population‐specific loci that are quite common in the respective populations. From this we observe the distribution of CNVs in the Asian Indian population to be considerably different from the Chinese and Malay populations. About half of the deletion loci and three‐quarters of duplication loci overlap UCSC genes. Tens of loci show population differentiation and overlap with genes previously known to be associated with genetic risk of diseases. One of these loci is the CYP2A6 deletion, previously linked to reduced susceptibility to lung cancer. Hum Mutat 31:1–7, 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Characterization of copy number-stable regions in the human genome

In the past few years the number of copy number variants (CNVs) identified in the human genome has increased significantly, but our understanding of the functional impact of CNVs is still limited. Clinically significant variations cannot easily be distinguished from benign, complicating interpretation of patient data. Multiple studies have focused on analysis of regions that vary in copy number in specific disorders. Here we use the opposite strategy and focus our analysis on regions that never seem to vary in the general population, hypothesizing that these are copy number stable because variations within them are deleterious. Our results show that copy number stable regions are characterized by correlation with a number of genomic features, allowing us to define a list of genomic regions that are dosage sensitive in humans. We find that these dosage-sensitive regions show significant overlap with de novo CNVs identified in patients with intellectual disability or autism. There is also a significant association between copy number stable regions and rare inherited variants in autism patients, but not in controls. Based on this predictive power, we propose that copy number stable regions can be used to complement maps of known CNVs to facilitate interpretation of patient data.     

Complete ascertainment of intragenic copy number mutations (CNMs) in the CFTR gene and its implications for CNM formation at other autosomal loci

Over the last 20 years since the discovery of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene, more than 1,600 different putatively pathological CFTR mutations have been identified. Until now, however, copy number mutations (CNMs) involving the CFTR gene have not been methodically analyzed, resulting almost certainly in the underascertainment of CFTR gene duplications compared with deletions. Here, high‐resolution array comparative genomic hybridization (averaging one interrogating probe every 95 bp) was used to analyze the entire length of the CFTR gene (189 kb) in 233 cystic fibrosis chromosomes lacking conventional mutations. We succeeded in identifying five duplication CNMs that would otherwise have been refractory to analysis. Based upon findings from this and other studies, we propose that deletion and duplication CNMs in the human autosomal genome are likely to be generated in the proportion of approximately 2–3:1. We further postulate that intragenic gene duplication CNMs in other disease loci may have been routinely underascertained. Finally, our analysis of ±20 bp flanking each of the 40 CFTR breakpoints characterized at the DNA sequence level provide support for the emerging concept that non‐B DNA conformations in combination with specific sequence motifs predispose to both recurring and nonrecurring genomic rearrangements. Hum Mutat 31:1–8, 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.