Relation of angina to coronary artery disease in mitral and in aortic valve disease

Of 129 patients with either mitral or aortic valve disease angina was present in 55 (42%). It was more frequent in aortic (60%) than in mitral valve disease (33%). The standard 12-lead electrocardiogram was not helpful in distinguishing underlying occlusive coronary artery disease. Coronary arteriography demonstrated coronary artery disease in 26 patients (20%), only 2 of whom had no angina. The incidence of coronary artery disease was almost identical in both the mitral and aortic groups (22% and 17%, respectively), but the percentage of those with demonstrable coronary artery disease accompanying angina was much higher in the mitral group (67% as against 29%). Angina in mitral valve disorders is thus much more likely to be the result of disease of the coronary arteries. Coronary arteriography is mandatory in all patients in both groups who have angina. Otherwise it seems unnecessary as coronary artery disease was found in only 2 patients who did not have angina.     

Relation of angina to coronary artery disease in mitral and in aortic valve disease.

Of 129 patients with either mitral or aortic valve disease angina was present in 55 (42%). It was more frequent in aortic (60%) than in mitral valve disease (33%). The standard 12-lead electrocardiogram was not helpful in distinguishing underlying occlusive coronary artery disease. Coronary arteriography demonstrated coronary artery disease in 26 patients (20%), only 2 of whom had no angina. The incidence of coronary artery disease was almost identical in both the mitral and aortic groups (22% and 17%, respectively), but the percentage of those with demonstrable coronary artery disease accompanying angina was much higher in the mitral group (67% as against 29%). Angina in mitral valve disorders is thus much more likely to be the result of disease of the coronary arteries. Coronary arteriography is mandatory in all patients in both groups who have angina. Otherwise it seems unnecessary as coronary artery disease was found in only 2 patients who did not have angina.     

Coronary angiography in the preoperative exploration of non-ischemic acquired valve diseases]

One hundred and fifty-nine patients with aortic valve disease (86 cases), mitral valve disease (58 cases) or mitral and aortic disease (15 cases) underwent a pre-operative haemodynamic study, including coronary arteriography either as a routine (age greater than 50 years) or because of chest pains. Coronary arteriography is easy to do during left heart catheterisation and nowadays carries minimal risk. In the cases of chest pains, it showed stenotic lesions of the coronary vessels in 22% of patients with aortic valve disease and in 35% of those with mitral disease. In the absence of angina, coronary arteriography showed no evidence of coronary artery disease in the cases of mitral regurgitation and of aortic valve disease. In contrast, it showed stenotic lesions in three cases of mitral stenosis. In the whole of the series, coronary artery disease proved a contra-indication to surgery in three cases, and was an indication for aorta-coronary by-pass grafting, in addition to valve surgery, in seven other cases. In the absence of angina, coronary arteriography has only a slight influence on the decision to operate. It does however give additional security, which justifies its routine use in patients over 50 years of age, particularly those with mitral valve disease.     

Angina pectoris and coronary artery disease in patients with severe aortic valvular disease

We studied the clinical, hemodynamic, and angiographic findings of 90 consecutive patients with significant symptomatic aortic valve disease, 40 years of age or older, to evaluate the prevalence of angina pectoris in relation to coronary artery disease and the effect upon cardiac function.The prevalence of chest pain was 66% (typical angina, 39%; atypical chest pain, 27%), and the prevalence of coronary artery disease was 39%. The prevalence of coronary artery disease in patients with typical angina was 77%, in contrast to 25% in patients with atypical chest pain $\text{(}\text{P}\text{= 0.001)}$. Only two of the 35 patients (6%) with coronary artery disease were free of chest pain. Although the incidence of coronary artery disease in patients with aortic stenosis was slightly higher than in patients with aortic regurgitation or aortic stenosis-aortic regurgitation, it was not statistically significant.Patients with aortic regurgitation and coronary artery disease had significantly lower ejection fraction than patients with aortic stenosis and coronary artery disease. There were no significant differences between ejection fraction in patients without coronary artery disease in the different groups. Patients with aortic stenosis and coronary artery disease tend to have lower mean pressure gradients than those without coronary artery disease. Patients with coronary artery disease in aortic regurgitation and aortic stenosis-aortic regurgitation tend to have higher left ventricular end-diastolic pressure.This study indicates that although patients with aortic valve disease and typical angina are most likely to have associated coronary artery disease, it is not possible to predict this disorder with accuracy by means of clinical or hemodynamic findings.Since the presence or absence of coronary artery disease in patients undergoing aortic valve replacement has prognostic and therapeutic significance, we recommend that coronary arteriography be performed in all patients with significant aortic valve disease undergoing cardiac catheterization when they present with any form of chest pain, or in patients over the age of 40 years even if no chest pain is present. Coronary arteriography would also rule out anomalous aortic origin of the coronary arteries.     

Angina, coronary risk factors and coronary artery disease in patients with valvular disease. A prospective study

The relationship between coronary risk factors and coronaryartery disease in patients with valvular heart disease was studiedprospectively in 387 consecutive patients undergoing routinecoronary arteriography prior to valve replacement. Coronary artery disease was as common in patients with mitralvalve disease (31.9%) as in those with aortic valve disease(26.8%) Although it occurs more frequently in patients withangina (45.7%) significant coronary artery disease is foundin 19.2% (47 of 245) of those without angina (P<0.001), suggestingthat the presence of angina alone is an unreliable indicatorof significant coronary disease. The prevalence and severityof significant coronary artery disease increases progressivelyas the number of coronary risk factors also increase (P<0.001)but the prevalence is low (3%) in patients in whom both anginaand coronary risk factors are absent. These findings suggestthat preoperative coronary arteriography might be omitted inthis latter group of patients.     

Chest pain as a predictor of coronary artery disease in patients with obstructive aortic valve disease

To clarify the association between chest pain and significant coronary artery disease in patients who have aortic valve disease, 76 consecutive candidates for aortic valve replacement were evaluated prospectively with use of a historical questionnaire and coronary arteriography. Of the 76 patients, 19 (25 percent) had no chest pain, 21 (28 percent) had chest pain that was not-typical of angina pectoris and 36 (47 percent) had chest pain typical of angina pectoris. In 18 of 19 patients the absence of chest pain correlated with the absence of coronary artery disease. The single patient without chest pain who had coronary artery disease had evidence of an inferior myocardial infarction in the electrocardiogram. Thus, absence of chest pain and the absence of electrocardiographic evidence of infarction predicted the absence of coronary disease in all cases.

The presence of chest pain did not predict the presence of coronary artery disease, but the more typical the pain of angina pectoris the more likely were patients to have significant coronary artery disease. Of the 21 patients with atypical chest pain, 6 (29 percent) had coronary artery disease, but of the 36 patients with typical angina pectoris 23 (64 percent) had significant coronary artery disease. In addition, when patients with chest pain not typical of angina pectoris also had coronary artery disease, the diseased vessels usually supplied smaller areas of the left ventricle than when the pain was typical of angina pectoris. In 21 of 23 patients (91 percent) with typical angina pectoris and significant coronary artery disease, lesions were present in the left coronary artery. There was no systolic pressure gradient across the aortic valve that excluded the presence of coronary artery disease, although all patients with a calculated aortic valve area of less than 0.4 cm² were free of coronary artery disease. Patients with severe left ventricular dysfunction were more likely to have normal coronary arteries.     

Frequency of angina pectoris and coronary artery disease in severe isolated valvular aortic stenosis

A consecutive series of 192 patients (121 men and 71 women, mean age 59 years, range 28 to 82) with isolated, severe valvular aortic stenosis was with isolated, severe valvular aortic stenosis was analyzed retrospectively to determine the relation of angina pectoris and coronary risk factors to angiographically significant coronary artery disease (CAD). Significant CAD (diameter reduction greater than or equal to 50%) was found in 47 patients (24%). Angina was present in 83% of them, but it was also found in 61% of the non-CAD patients. This symptom had as a result a low positive predictive value (31%). Of the patients without angina (n = 65) 12% had significant CAD. The negative predictive value of angina alone was thus 88%. By using multivariate logistic regression, a risk score could be calculated based on angina, age and sex, which increased the negative predictive value to 95%. It was concluded that coronary arteriography can only be omitted in severe aortic valvular stenosis, when patients have no angina and when they are less than 40 years of age for men and less than 50 years for women. For all other cases, coronary arteriography should be recommended.     

Detection of coronary disease before valve surgery. Contribution of myocardial scintigraphy with dipyridamole

The detection of coronary disease before valve surgery remains difficult in the absence of coronary arteriography. The contribution of myocardial scintigraphy with dipyridamole (MS-DP) was studied in 34 consecutive patients with valve disease (11 mitral and 23 aortic) with a mean age of 63 +/- 11 years having undergone coronary arteriography before valve surgery. Coronary arteriography was performed because of angina (21 cases) or age (women greater than 50, men greater than 40). Positive criteria of coronary disease were the presence of at least one frank and clearly visible fault of myocardial perfusion (MS-DP positive) and at least one stenosis of greater than 70 per cent by coronary arteriography. Coronary disease existed in 13 patients (38 per cent). Ten patients (29 per cent) had a positive MS-DP. The sensitivity and specificity of MS-DP in detecting coronary disease were 69 per cent and 95 per cent respectively. Its positive predictive value was 90 per cent. MS-DP was negative in all asymptomatic patients (19 per cent of them having coronary disease) and in 11 symptomatic patients (18 per cent of them having coronary disease). The low positive predictive value of angina (52 per cent) increased to 90 per cent when combined with a positive MS-DP. Because of relatively low sensitivity, basing indications for coronary arteriography before valve surgery on the results of MS-DP cannot be advised.     

Surgical implications and results of combined aortic valve replacement and myocardial revascularization.

To better define the indications for and results of simultaneous aortic valve replacement and myocardial revascularization, a cohort of 271 patients with angiographically defined coronary anatomy who underwent xenograft bioprosthetic aortic valve replacement were analyzed. Two hundred and twelve patients had predominant aortic stenosis, and 55 had pure aortic regurgitation. Discordance between the clinical assessment of angina and the angiographic assessment of coronary artery disease was apparent in 39 percent of the patients with aortic stenosis and 45 percent of the patients with aortic regurgitation. Thirty-seven percent of patients in the aortic stenosis subgroup without angina and 41 percent of patients in the aortic regurgitation subgroup without angina had hemodynamically significant coronary artery disease. Concomitant coronary artery bypass grafting and aortic valve replacement were performed in 101 patients. The incidence of perioperative myocardial infarction and operative death was significantly greater (P < 0.05) in the subsets of patients with coronary disease than in those without coronary disease (9.9 percent versus 0.7 percent and 8.3 percent versus 2.2 percent, respectively). Late postoperative angina and myocardial infarction also correlated with the preoperative presence of coronary artery disease. Excluding operative mortality, the late actuarial survival rate (mean follow-up, 1.6 years; maximal follow-up, 4.9 years) was not statistically lower for the patients with coronary disease.It is concluded that angina pectoris in patients with aortic valve disease is not a reliable indicator of coronary artery disease and that patients with coronary disease who undergo aortic valve replacement have an increased risk. It is inferred from this study that preoperative coronary arteriography is advisable in most adults undergoing the evaluation of aortic valve disease and that simultaneous aortic valve replacement and myocardial revascularization may provide some protection against late attrition due to the combined effects of coexistent aortic valve and coronary artery disease.     

Prevalence of coronary artery disease in patients with isolated aortic valve stenosis.

The prevalence of significant coronary artery disease (reduction in luminal diameter by more than 50%) among 88 consecutive patients with aortic stenosis requiring aortic valve replacement at Hammersmith Hospital was examined. Twenty two (34%) patients had significant coronary disease. Nineteen of 42 (45%) patients with typical angina had coronary disease; three of 20 (15%) patients with atypical chest pain had coronary disease, while none of 26 patients free of chest pain had significant coronary disease. Risk factors for coronary disease were equally distributed among patients with and without significant luminal obstruction. Because of the small, but definite, hazard of coronary arteriography and in the interest of cost containment it is suggested that patients with aortic stenosis who are free of chest pain do not require routine coronary arteriography. This applies particularly to patients requiring urgent aortic valve replacement.     

Aortic stenosis, angina pectoris, and coronary artery disease.

The relationships between aortic stenosis, coronary artery disease, angina pectoris, and myocardial infarction were examined in 173 patients with isolated calcific aortic stenosis who had coronary arteriography as well as cardiac catheterization. All were over age 40 and had definite cardiac symptoms; 156 later had aortic valve replacement. Coronary lesions narrowing the lumen by 50% or more were present in 37% of patients aged 40 to 59 and 68% of those aged 60 to 82. Coronary disease was present in 64% of patients with angina pectoris and 33% of those without angina. Angina which occurred only in association with dyspnea on exertion was associated with coronary disease in 45% of instances, whereas angina which also occurred on exertion without any dyspnea or which occurred with emotional stress, after meals, during sleep, or at rest unprovoked was associated with coronary disease in 80% of instances. Patients with coronary disease without any chest pain or with atypical pain considered nonanginal were men, usually over age 60, with congestive heart failure as the predominant symptom. Electrocardiograms showing transmural inferior or anterolateral infarction nearly always indicated coronary disease, while QS patterns in Leads V1-2 occurred frequently with normal coronary arteries. Serum cholesterol was elevated in 23% of those with coronary disease and 8% of those without. A group of patients with moderate aortic stenosis could be identified, with aortic valve areas of 0.55 to 0.80 cm. per square meter, in whom coronary disease was the sole or chief cause of symptoms. The operative mortality rate with aortic valve replacement was 9.6% in those with coronary disease and 1.4% in those without significant coronary disease. Coronary disease is frequently present in patients with calcific aortic stenosis, particularly in those over 60, those with angina, and those with symptoms despite only moderate aortic stenosis. The type of anginal syndrome, the ECG evidence of transmural infarction, and the coronary risk factors provide additional clues for clinical diagnosis.     

Incidence of coronary artery disease in patients with valvular heart disease.

The case notes, cardiac catheterisation data, and coronary arteriograms of 239 patients investigated for valvular heart disease during a five year period were reviewed. Angina present in 13 of 95 patients with isolated mitral valve disease, 43 of 90 patients with isolated aortic valve disease, and 18 of 54 patients with combined mitral and aortic valve disease. Significant coronary artery disease was present in 85 per cent of patients with mitral valve disease and angina, but in only 33 per cent of patients with aortic valve disease and angina. Patients with no chest pain still had a high incidence of coronary artery disease, significant coronary obstruction being present in 22 per cent with mitral valve disease, 22 per cent with aortic valve disease, and 11 per cent with combine mitral and aortic valve disease. Several possible clinical markers of coronary artery disease were examined but none was found to be of practical help. There was, however, a significant inverse relation between severity of coronary artery disease and severity of valve disease in patients with aortic valve disease. Asymptomatic coronary artery disease is not uncommon in patients with valvular heart disease and if it is policy to perform coronary artery bypass grafting in such patients, routine coronary arteriography must be part of the preoperative investigation.     

Significance of angina pectoris in aortic valve stenosis.

Of 60 patients aged 45 to 66 years with aortic valve stenosis, 28 (47 per cent) had angina pectoris. Significant coronary arterial obstruction was shown by selective coronary cineangiography in 14 of them. Systolic pressure gradients across the aortic valve were lower in patients with angina than in those without. In those with angina, systolic gradients were higher in those with normal coronary arteriograms than in those with demonstrable coronary arterial disease. Aortic valve replacement relieved the angina in all patients who had normal coronary arteriograms. When valve replacement was combined with coronary bypass grafting in those with coronary arterial disease, surgical mortality was higher and symptomatic relief less predictable. Incapacitating angina in patients with aortic stenosis was nearly always associated with significant coronary disease. In those with less severe angina it was impossible to predict the state of the coronary arteries. Two patients, who did not have angina and who did not undergo coronary arteriography, died after aortic valve replacement and were found at necropsy to have unsuspected severe coronary disease. We, therefore, suggest that coronary arteriography should be carried out in all patients over the age of 40 years in whom surgery is being considered for aortic stenosis.     

Significance of angina pectoris in aortic valve stenosis.

Of 60 patients aged 45 to 66 years with aortic valve stenosis, 28 (47 per cent) had angina pectoris. Significant coronary arterial obstruction was shown by selective coronary cineangiography in 14 of them. Systolic pressure gradients across the aortic valve were lower in patients with angina than in those without. In those with angina, systolic gradients were higher in those with normal coronary arteriograms than in those with demonstrable coronary arterial disease. Aortic valve replacement relieved the angina in all patients who had normal coronary arteriograms. When valve replacement was combined with coronary bypass grafting in those with coronary arterial disease, surgical mortality was higher and symptomatic relief less predictable. Incapacitating angina in patients with aortic stenosis was nearly always associated with significant coronary disease. In those with less severe angina it was impossible to predict the state of the coronary arteries. Two patients, who did not have angina and who did not undergo coronary arteriography, died after aortic valve replacement and were found at necropsy to have unsuspected severe coronary disease. We, therefore, suggest that coronary arteriography should be carried out in all patients over the age of 40 years in whom surgery is being considered for aortic stenosis.     

Should coronary arteriography be performed routinely before valve replacement?

The implication that coronary atherosclerosis is a common cause of complications and death after prosthetic heart valve replacement has resulted in the performance of routine preoperative coronary arteriography in many clinics. A review of 4 years' experience with such studies at the University of Oregon Medical School Hospital indicates that patients with significant coronary obstruction in conjunction with valvular heart disease always had angina pectoris. None of the postoperative deaths or complications were due to demonstrable coronary artery disease without preexisting angina.It is likely that the increased cardiac work load imposed by valvular heart disease increases myocardial oxygen demands. Significant coronary atherosclerosis is therefore unlikely to remain asymptomatic. Coronary arteriography may be safely omitted before valve replacement in many patients with increased myocardial work who have no symptoms of ischemic heart disease, and who lack risk factors known to increase its incidence.     

Prevalence of significant coronary heart disease in valvular heart disease in Indian patients

Records of 326 patients were analysed to determine the prevalence of coronary heart disease (CHD) in patients with valvular heart disease (VHD) and to identify the group in whom coronary arteriography is essential. Significant CHD (60% or more luminal narrowing) was found in 7 per cent of cases, and its prevalence was 3 per cent in mitral, 10 per cent in aortic, and 6 per cent in combined mitral and aortic valve disease. Angina was present in 14 per cent of patients with mitral, 39 per cent with aortic, and 21 per cent with combined mitral and aortic valve disease. Seventy-three per cent of patients with CHD had angina whereas only 19 per cent with angina had CHD. The prevalence of CHD was higher in patients above 50 years (13%) and in males (98%) as compared to those below 50 years (3%) and females (none). We conclude that the prevalence of CHD is low in our patients with VHD. Routine coronary arteriography is recommended only in males over the age of 50 years.     

Prediction of coronary artery disease by left ventricular regional wall motion abnormalities in patients with stenosis of the aortic valve

To identify predictive factors for coronary artery disease in patients with stenosis of the aortic valve the clinical histories, haemodynamic measurements, biplane contrast left ventriculograms, and coronary angiograms of 83 consecutively catheterised patients with valvar aortic stenosis were examined retrospectively. The mean (SD) age was 66.4 (9.1) years and 78% were men. Fifty five patients had significant coronary artery disease (greater than or equal to 50% diameter narrowing). Forty five (82%) of 55 patients with and 23 (82%) of 28 patients without coronary disease had angina. Heart failure occurred in a third of the patients; these patients were on average older, were more likely to be female, and had lower ejection fractions and cardiac outputs than patients in whom failure did not occur. Calculated valve area, transvalvar gradient, and left ventricular end diastolic pressure did not discriminate between patients with and without coronary disease. Syncope was less common than angina and heart failure and was associated with significantly lower valve areas and higher gradients than those found in patients without syncope. Left ventricular regional wall motion abnormalities were equally common in the groups with and without angina and predicted coronary artery disease with 94% accuracy. The absence of regional wall motion abnormality was an insensitive marker of normal coronary arteries as 45% of such patients had coronary disease. Five of the 83 patients had significant coronary disease without angina or regional wall motion abnormality. In patients with aortic stenosis angina did not predict the presence of coronary artery disease; therefore, it is advisable to have the results of coronary angiography before aortic valve replacement in a population such as this. Two of the patients with heart failure and severe aortic stenosis had regional wall motion abnormality with normal coronary arteries. Thus in some patients left ventricular failure produced by increased afterload may itself be a cause of left ventricular regional wall motion abnormality.     

Prediction of coronary artery disease by left ventricular regional wall motion abnormalities in patients with stenosis of the aortic valve.

To identify predictive factors for coronary artery disease in patients with stenosis of the aortic valve the clinical histories, haemodynamic measurements, biplane contrast left ventriculograms, and coronary angiograms of 83 consecutively catheterised patients with valvar aortic stenosis were examined retrospectively. The mean (SD) age was 66.4 (9.1) years and 78% were men. Fifty five patients had significant coronary artery disease (greater than or equal to 50% diameter narrowing). Forty five (82%) of 55 patients with and 23 (82%) of 28 patients without coronary disease had angina. Heart failure occurred in a third of the patients; these patients were on average older, were more likely to be female, and had lower ejection fractions and cardiac outputs than patients in whom failure did not occur. Calculated valve area, transvalvar gradient, and left ventricular end diastolic pressure did not discriminate between patients with and without coronary disease. Syncope was less common than angina and heart failure and was associated with significantly lower valve areas and higher gradients than those found in patients without syncope. Left ventricular regional wall motion abnormalities were equally common in the groups with and without angina and predicted coronary artery disease with 94% accuracy. The absence of regional wall motion abnormality was an insensitive marker of normal coronary arteries as 45% of such patients had coronary disease. Five of the 83 patients had significant coronary disease without angina or regional wall motion abnormality. In patients with aortic stenosis angina did not predict the presence of coronary artery disease; therefore, it is advisable to have the results of coronary angiography before aortic valve replacement in a population such as this. Two of the patients with heart failure and severe aortic stenosis had regional wall motion abnormality with normal coronary arteries. Thus in some patients left ventricular failure produced by increased afterload may itself be a cause of left ventricular regional wall motion abnormality.     

Prevalence of coronary disease in patients with aortic stenosis]

We analyzed a consecutive series of 188 patients, older than 44 years, with significant aortic stenosis, who underwent coronary arteriography (73 women and 115 men). There were 38 patients (20.2%) with coronary artery disease ( or = 50% reduction in the luminal diameter). Sixty-eight patients had typical angina pectoris, 52 atypical angina, and 68 did not have chest pain. We found to have coronary disease in 29.4%, 23.1% and 8.8% respectively. Sensitivity of typical angina to detect coronary disease was 52.6%, with an specificity of 68%, and a negative predictive value of 85%. Inclusion of atypical angina improved the sensitivity to 84.2%, and the negative predictive value to 91.2%, but lessened the specificity to 41.4%. Six patients among the 38 with coronary disease (15.7%), did not have chest pain, and 3 of them were younger than 60 years. We conclude that absence of angina is not enough to exclude coronary artery disease in patients 50 years old with aortic stenosis being considered for aortic valve replacement.     

Coronary Arteriography in Isolated Aortic and Mitral Valve Disease

Abstract: Coronary arteriography in isolated aortic and mitral valve disease. A. Saltups. Aust. N.Z. J. Med., 1982, 12 , pp. 494–497.
Coronary arteriographic findings in 200 patients with isolated aortic and mitral valve disease were reviewed to examine the relationship between obstructive (>50% diameter stenosis) coronary artery disease (CAD) and angina pectoris (AP).
Of 100 patients with aortic valve disease, 30 had CAD of whom 20 gave a history of AP. Thirty-two of 52 patients (61%) with AP did not have CAD and 10 of 48 (21%) had CAD without AP. CAD was evenly distributed among patients with aortic stenosis, incompetence and mixed aortic valve disease.
CAD was found in 23 of 100 patients with mitral valve disease. Sixteen of 32 patients with mitral incompetence had CAD of whom four had AP. Seven of 68 patients with mitral stenosis or mixed mitral valve disease had CAD. AP was noted by four of these seven patients but by none of the 61 with normal coronary arteriograms (p <0.0001). Asymptomatic CAD was more common among patients with mitral incompetence (12/28 vs 3/64 P<0.005).
AP was an unreliable marker for CAD in aortic valve disease or mitral incompetence. Conversely, CAD was uncommon without AP in mitral stenosis or mixed mitral valve disease.
Coronary arteriography seems indicated in the pre-operative assessment of patients aged40 years with aortic valve disease or mitral incompetence. Its value is limited in patients with mitral stenosis or mixed mitral valve disease without AP.