Comparison of users and non-users of mental health services among depressed, older, urban African Americans.

OBJECTIVE: The authors sought to determine differences between depressed older black residents in an urban community who do and do not use formal mental health services. METHODS: The Treatment Group (TG) consisted of 106 black patients age >or=55 with a diagnosis of depression who were recruited from outpatient psychiatric programs in Brooklyn, NY. The Untreated Community Group (UCG) consisted of 101 cognitively intact black subjects age >or=55 from randomly selected block groups in Brooklyn who met symptom criteria for major or minor depression and had no previous history of psychiatric treatment. RESULTS: In logistic regression analysis, TG persons were significantly more likely than the UCG persons to be female, younger, born in the United States, to have impaired daily functioning, have a family history of mental illness, and believe that environmental factors and religious activities could influence mental illness. TG persons were significantly less likely to have social network members who provided advice, to use spiritualists or their products, to have vision or hearing impairments, and to have depressive symptoms. Although most UCG persons visited their doctor at least three times annually, only 11% reported using these physicians for help with mental health problems. CONCLUSIONS: A combination of demographic and attitudinal factors, family psychiatric history, social supports, and functional impairments were associated with the use of mental health services. Despite reluctance of persons in the UCG to use primary-care physicians for mental health reasons, the latter remain the most feasible intervention point within the existing service system.     

Older offenders, substance abuse, and treatment.

OBJECTIVE: The adoption of more stringent truth-in-sentencing laws and the aging of the United States population in general has led to an increase in the proportion of prison inmates age 55 years and older. Recent judicial rulings require prisoners to receive adequate medical and mental health care. Care for substance abuse is often included to reduce recidivism. However, little systematic research has been conducted on the mental health and substance abuse treatment needs of older prisoners. METHODS: The authors examined age differences in substance abuse history provided by 10,952 offenders as part of their orientation and evaluation on entry into prison. Trained substance abuse counselors interviewed each offender and recorded data in an institutional database. RESULTS: Seventy-one percent of older inmates reported a substance abuse problem. When compared with younger inmates, older offenders were more likely to abuse alcohol only. Those older inmates with abuse problems had used substances for over 40 years, yet more than one-third had never received treatment. CONCLUSION: Like younger inmates, most older offenders would benefit from substance abuse treatment. The treatment may need to be tailored to age and lack of previous treatment experience and should be sensitive to this high-risk group's additional medical needs.     

Age factors in patient-therapist relationship.

This paper reports on the effects of therapist and patient age as factors in the evaluation and treatment of adult psychiatric outpatients. Therapist ratings and patient self-ratings are contrasted in three age groups. Rating scales include symptomatology, motivation, insight, and prognosis. In addition, a chart review follow-up of 68 patients includes disposition and drop-out. The data suggest that older patients are perceived as sicker, but less treatable than younger patients or patients of the same age group as the therapist. Residents express a strong preference for treating younger patients, but more readily develop a treatment relationship with same age patients. Both older and younger patients were significantly less likely to remain in treatment. Age of therapist and patient as a significant, frequent unrecognized factor in psychotherapeutic intervention is discussed and modifications in psychiatric training programs are suggested.     

Irrational ideas. Older vs. younger inpatients

The relationship to age of irrational beliefs among psychiatric inpatients has not been explored using the rational-emotive model. This study addressed the following two questions: 1) Do older and younger psychiatric inpatients differ in irrational beliefs? 2) Do older depressives differ from older nondepressives in irrational beliefs? Upon admission to a large medical center, 58 younger (less than 45 years old) and 54 older (greater than 55 years old) subjects were assessed on a battery of psychological tests, including the Idea Inventory and the Beck Depression Inventory. Results showed that older and younger inpatients did not differ on irrational beliefs. Results also showed that older and younger groups of depressives did not differ on the irrationality scores. When a correlational analysis was used, depression was related to irrationality within the older group but not within the younger group.     

Health service utilization in patients with major depression and co-morbid pain

Aims:  Patients with depression often have co-morbid pain symptoms. However, rates of service utilization by psychiatric in-patients with co-morbid pain symptoms are unknown. The purpose of this study is to estimate whether patients with major depression and co-morbid pain access medical treatment for their pain as much as their counterparts with psychiatric diagnoses other than major depression.
Methods:  A total of 103 patients (62 female; 41 male) were assessed for a diagnosis of major depression applying a psychiatric clinical interview followed by a self-report pain questionnaire, which assessed physical pain in psychiatric patients.
Results:  Patients with major depression reported higher rates of pain symptoms in the past 6 and 12 months than their counterparts with a psychiatric diagnosis other than major depression. Analysis of variance showed that patients with depression were less likely to attend medical and specialist services for their pain symptoms than their counterparts. On the contrary, depressed patients with pain attended more frequently general in-patient services than non-depressed patients with pain.
Conclusions:  Patients with depression suffer high rates of pain symptoms, but are at higher risk of not accessing appropriate services suggesting inadequate service utilization. The results have implications for screening and health care delivery for psychiatric patients with pain.     

Mental health treatment preferences of older and younger primary care patients

OBJECTIVE: To compare mental health treatment history and preferences in older and younger primary care patients. METHOD: We surveyed 77 older (60+) and 312 younger adult primary care patients from four outpatient medical clinics about their mental health treatment history and preferences. RESULTS: Older adults were less likely than younger adults to report a history of mental health treatment (29% vs. 51%) or to be currently receiving treatment (11% vs. 23%). They were also less likely to indicate that they currently desire help with emotional problems (25% vs. 50%). Older adults were more likely to hold a belief in self-reliance that could limit their willingness to accept treatment for mental health problems, although they were less likely than younger adults to identify other barriers to treatment. Older adults reported that they were less likely to attend programs in primary care targeting mental health issues (counseling, stress management) than younger adults, although they were as willing as younger adults to attend programs targeting physical health issues (healthy living class, fitness program). Age remained a significant predictor of mental health treatment history and preferences even after controlling for other demographic variables. CONCLUSION: These results suggest that older adults in the primary care setting may be less willing to accept mental health services than younger adults. Results further suggest that perceived barriers may differ for older and younger patients, which may indicate the need for age-specific educational messages and services targeted to older adults in primary care.     

Remission of psychiatric symptoms among drug misusers after drug dependence treatment

The study investigates changes in psychiatric symptoms after drug dependence treatment, and relationships between pretreatment problems, illicit drug use, treatment retention, and changes in psychiatric symptoms. The sample comprised 662 drug-dependent adults recruited at admission to treatment in residential rehabilitation programs (15 agencies) or outpatient methadone treatment (16 methadone maintenance programs and 15 methadone reduction programs). Using a longitudinal, prospective cohort design, data were collected by structured interviews at intake to treatment and at 1-month and 6-month follow-ups. Reductions were found in a range of psychiatric symptoms after admission to drug dependence treatment and among patients treated in outpatient and in residential programs. These reductions occurred rapidly (during the first month) and were maintained at subsequent follow-up. At intake to treatment, 39% of the residential sample met criteria for psychiatric caseness. This figure dropped to 3% at both 1-month and 6-month follow-up. Among methadone patients, 15% met criteria for psychiatric caseness at intake, and this dropped to 5% at 1 month and 3% at 6 months. Improvement in psychiatric symptoms was positively related to treatment retention. Some of the psychiatric symptoms presented by drug-dependent patients at admission to treatment are associated with drug misuse and show rapid remission after substance misuse treatment.     

Affective disorders in older inpatients

BACKGROUND: After dementia the group of depressive disorders is considered to be the second most common psychiatric disorder in the elderly. There is dispute regarding whether depression in the elderly differs from depression in the younger age groups by a longer duration of inpatient treatment, a more frequent occurrence of delusions, more cognitive impairment or by a more frequent co-occurrence of physical disease. This study aimed to compare younger with older inpatients with respect to these aspects. METHODS: Retrospective chart review of all admissions to the psychiatric department of a General University Hospital (n=9400) and review of the documentation of 15 348 psychiatric consultations in the years 1990-1998. The clinical diagnoses were made according to the ICD-10 criteria. RESULTS: 15.5% of the psychiatric inpatients in this period suffered from depressive episodes (ICD-10 F31.3-31.5,32,33). The proportion of depressive episodes increased with age, making up 5.4% in the age group below 30 years and 37.4% in the age group of 70-79 years. On the basis of the ICD-10 criteria for the severity of depressive episodes no significant differences could be demonstrated between the younger (< 65 years) and the older inpatients (>/= 65 years). In particular, no higher frequency of psychotic symptoms with increasing age could be found. The length of inpatient treatment did not significantly differ between both age groups. The elder patients showed less suicidal attempts prior to admission and less psychiatric comorbidity, but a significantly higher rate of concurrent physical illness. In 923 inpatients a psychiatrist was consulted by the other medical departments because of a co-occurrence of physical with affective disorders, making up 8.6% of the total seen by the psychiatric consultation service. Here again, the proportion of depressive episodes increased with age. The pattern of the depressive episodes in these patients did not differ from that seen in the psychiatric inpatients. LIMITATIONS: Only clinical diagnoses made by experienced psychiatrists were evaluated. CONCLUSIONS: According to our results older depressive inpatients differ from younger ones only with regard to concurrent comorbidity but not with respect to the duration of inpatient treatment or the pattern or severity of depressive symptoms. They more frequently suffered from physical illness but less often showed concurrent psychiatric comorbidity.     

Mental health and the timing of Men’s retirement

BACKGROUND: Analysis of the Psychiatric Morbidity Survey of Great Britain showed that the prevalence of common mental disorders was lower amongst men at or above Britain's state pension age of 65, relative to younger men. Retirees below this age had consistently higher rates of mental disorders than working men. In contrast, the low prevalence of mental disorders amongst retirees aged 65 and older was similar to that of their working peers. The aim of this analysis was to investigate this pattern of results in a national sample of Australian men, and the mediating role of socio-demographic factors. METHOD: Data were from the Household, Income and Labour Dynamics (HILDA) in Australia survey (2003). The analyses included men aged 45-74 years who were active in the labour force (n = 1309), or retired (n = 635). Mental health was assessed using the mental health scale from the Short-Form 36 Health Questionnaire. RESULTS: Retirees were more likely to have mental health problems than their working peers, however this difference was progressively smaller across age groups. For retirees above, though not below, the age of 55 this difference was explained by poorer physical functioning. When age at retirement was considered it was found that early retirees who were now at or approaching the conventional retirement age did not display the substantially elevated rates of mental health problems seen in their younger counterparts. Further, men who had retired at age 60 or older did not display an initially elevated rate of mental health problems. CONCLUSIONS: The association between retirement and mental health varies across older adulthood. Retired British and Australian men below the conventional retirement age of 65 are more likely to have mental health problems relative to their working peers, and retirees above this age. However, poor mental health appears to be linked to being retired below this age rather than an enduring characteristic of those who retire early.     

Neurology, age, hospital costs, and DRGs

The DRG payment scheme is causing hospitals to examine the financial consequences of treating various patient populations. The purpose of this study was to examine resource utilization for hospitalized neurology patients treated during a 2-year period at an academic medical center. All patients (N = 1,993) were stratified by payor (Medicare, Medicaid, Blue Cross, and other) and age (0-35 years, 35-65 years, and 65 years and above). Mean hospital cost per patient (exclusive of MD fees) for each payor generally rose with age. Patients 35 years of age and over consumed a disproportionately larger share of resources than younger patients. DRG payment under an all payor system would have produced a substantial deficit for this group of patients. The mean hospital length of stay, number of diagnoses per patient, and mortality, as well as percent of admission through the emergency department generally rose with age. This study demonstrated that neurology patients 35 years of age and older generated higher resource utilization than their younger counterparts and were underpaid by the current DRG reimbursement. In this study, DRG payment appeared to provide significant financial disincentives to treat older neurology patients. If our findings are widespread, the quality of neurologic care and the elderly's access to it could become limited in the future.     

A twelve-week, double-blind, randomized comparison of nortriptyline and paroxetine in older depressed inpatients and outpatients.

Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors may be less efficacious than tricyclic antidepressants in the treatment of severe depression in older patients. The authors compared the 12-week clinical outcome of older depressed patients treated with nortriptyline or paroxetine in a double-blind randomized comparison in 116 psychiatric inpatients and outpatients (mean age: 72+/-8 years) who presented with a major depressive episode or melancholic depression. Discontinuation and response rates were compared in patients who began or who completed treatment. The discontinuation rate due to side effects was significantly higher with nortriptyline than with paroxetine (33% vs. 16%). There were no significant differences between the rates of response in the Intent-to-Treat analysis (nortriptyline: 57% vs. paroxetine: 55% ), or the Completer analysis (nortriptyline: 78% vs. paroxetine: 84%). Although paroxetine appears to be better tolerated than nortriptyline, the efficacy of these two drugs does not appear to differ in the acute treatment of older depressed patients, including hospitalized patients and those with melancholic features.     

The prevalence of psychiatric disorders and subsyndromal mental illness in low-income, medically ill elderly

OBJECTIVE: This study estimated the past and current prevalence of psychiatric illness and subsyndromal mental illness (both pre-relapse and new onset) in a sample of low-income, medically ill older adults. METHOD: A convenience sample of 95 public sector medical patients aged 55 and older were assessed for the presence of psychiatric diagnosis and symptoms using the Geriatric Depression Scale, Beck Anxiety Inventory, the Short Michigan Alcohol Screening Test, and the Computerized Diagnostic Interview Schedule (DIS-C). RESULTS: Dysthymia and Major Depression were the most prevalent current disorders and Alcohol Dependence the most prevalent past disorder. Overall, 25 percent met criteria for at least one Axis I disorder. An additional 44 percent of patients had subsyndromal mental illness: 14 percent had subsyndromal depression, 17 percent were significantly anxious, and 30 percent were problem drinkers. A prior model predicting current Axis I disorder in younger people was found to be predictive of current Axis I but did not predict to subsyndromal disorder. CONCLUSIONS: The rates of psychiatric disorders and symptoms in this older, low-income population were similar to those in other samples of older medical patients. The findings from this research suggest the need for larger epidemiological studies of the prevalence of psychiatric disorders in this disadvantaged aging population. The complexities of this type of research are also discussed.     

An age-based comparison of chronic pain clinic patients

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to compare demographic, illness and personality characteristics, and formal rates of mental disorder between younger (< 65 years) and older (>or= 65 years) patients attending a chronic pain clinic. METHOD: Patients with non-malignant pain of > 6 months' duration attending a specialist outpatient clinic were given a structured medical and psychiatric interview, and completed self-report questionnaires assessing disability, personality style and attitudes to illness. RESULTS: Fifty patients (26 of whom were older) participated in the study. None of the older patients had experienced the onset of chronic pain before the age of 50 years. Although current and lifetime major depression were common in both groups, there was no specific association between age and depression. The younger group was more likely to have been injured prior to the onset of pain and to be seeking financial compensation, reported more physical and social disability, and was more likely to be preoccupied with somatic discomfort. The younger group was also more likely to be rated as displaying impulsive personality traits and the older group anxious traits, although there was no difference in neuroticism scores. CONCLUSION: Despite a greater level of multiple medical morbidity and longer duration of pain, older patients with chronic pain were not more likely to suffer from concurrent depression, were less disabled and less somatically preoccupied than younger patients. There were sufficient differences in illness and psychological characteristics to suggest that the older patients represented an aetiologically distinct sub-group, rather than patients with chronic pain of early onset who have simply grown old. Finally, the utility of DSM-IV defined somatoform disorders, in particular pain disorder, is discussed. A model which integrates medical and psychological mechanisms is needed for clinical use.     

Assessment and management of self-harm in older adults attending accident and emergency: a comparative cross-sectional study

OBJECTIVE: Older people who undertake self-harm are at higher suicide risk than are younger patients. This study examines whether this greater risk is reflected in the assessment and after-care that older patients receive when they attend accident and emergency. METHOD: This cross-sectional study, set in the two accident and emergency departments in a large industrial city in Northern England, compared 141 consecutive attendances due to self-harm among older patients (aged 55 years and over) with a random sample of 125 attendances of younger people (aged 15-54) attending because of self-harm. Data were drawn from accident and emergency records and from psychiatric and general hospital casenotes. RESULTS: Compared with the younger group, older patients were significantly more likely to be admitted from accident and emergency to the general hospital, to receive a specialist assessment whilst at the hospital, and to be offered psychiatric after-care-either as a psychiatric in-patient or an out-patient. CONCLUSIONS: Fortunately, older people attending accident and emergency following self-harm seemed likely to receive psychosocial assessment from a mental health specialist, and they were much more likely than younger patients to be offered after-care. Hospitals will need to monitor accident and emergency and other records if they are to check that their services are responding to the high risks seen in older patients.     

Risk factors for needle sharing among methadone-treated patients

OBJECTIVE: This paper examines the sociodemographic and psychiatric characteristics of patients taking methadone who continue to share needles. METHOD: Three hundred twenty-three patients were recruited from four methadone programs. Data were collected by using questionnaires and interviews. Psychiatric symptoms were measured with the SCL-90, the Beck Depression Inventory, and the Addiction Severity Index. RESULTS: Twenty percent of these subjects reported sharing needles within the previous 6 months. Those who shared reported greater difficulty in acquiring new needles, more legal difficulties, more severe drug problems, and higher levels of psychiatric symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: These data suggest that patients who continue to share needles are a more disturbed subgroup of the methadone maintenance population. Efforts designed to reduce needle sharing may need to be more sharply focused on patients who are at greatest risk of infection, and these patients may require more intensive psychiatric services.     

Race, age, and back pain as factors in completion of residential substance abuse treatment by veterans

OBJECTIVE: Variables associated with successful completion of residential substance abuse treatment were identified. METHODS: The records of 340 veterans admitted to a 120-day substance abuse treatment program were retrospectively analyzed. The likelihood of successful treatment completion was calculated as a function of race, age, gender, psychiatric diagnosis, past suicide attempts, homelessness, legal history, childhood physical or sexual abuse, parental history of addiction, multiple substance dependence, medical problems, and the race of the therapist. Univariate analysis and logistic regression analysis were used to identify variables that were significant predictors of treatment completion. RESULTS: Overall, 66 percent of veterans completed the program. Eighty-two percent of the veterans admitted to the program were black, and 16 percent were white. The completion rate of black veterans (71 percent) was significantly higher than that of white veterans (49 percent). Veterans completing treatment were significantly more likely to be older, by an average of two years, than those who did not complete treatment. The association between younger age and failure to complete the program was largely accounted for by younger black veterans. Veterans with back pain were significantly less likely to complete treatment than those without back pain. Completion rates did not vary by the other variables examined. In the regression analysis that included age, race, and back pain, each variable, when adjusted by the other variables, was a significant predictor of completion. CONCLUSIONS: White patients were less likely to complete residential substance abuse treatment in a program in which the majority of both therapists and patients were black. Younger black veterans and those with back pain were also less likely to complete treatment.     

Use of general medical services by VA patients with psychiatric disorders

OBJECTIVE: Patients with psychiatric disorders, particularly those with severe mental illnesses, have high rates of undetected and untreated medical problems and substantially elevated mortality rates due to medical illness. The authors sought to develop a better understanding of the demographic, medical, and psychiatric characteristics of this population to inform efforts to improve the medical care of these persons. METHODS: Using Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) databases, the authors examined use of medical services by 175,653 patients who were treated in Southern California and Nevada during fiscal year 2000. Multivariate regression models were used to examine factors affecting receipt of any medical care and the number of medical visits. RESULTS: Patients with psychiatric diagnoses had fewer medical visits than other VA patients; the largest differences were seen for patients with severe mental illnesses. Patients who were younger and male had few visits. Patients with diabetes or hypertension who had been diagnosed as having schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or an anxiety disorder had substantially fewer visits than those who did not have these psychiatric diagnoses. Patients older than 50 years were less likely to have any medical care if they had a diagnosis of a substance use, depressive, bipolar, or anxiety disorder or posttraumatic stress disorder. CONCLUSIONS: Use of medical care varies by psychiatric diagnosis. Young adults with schizophrenia and posttraumatic stress disorder and adults of all ages with bipolar disorder have an especially high risk of not receiving general medical services. Interventions to improve medical care may need to be tailored to the population being targeted.     

Self-reported health functioning in Swedish alcohol-dependent individuals: age and gender perspectives

The aim of this study was to investigate health functioning and drinking patterns in a Swedish alcohol-dependent treatment sample. Gender and two age groups were, respectively, compared in these characteristics. Data for demographic characteristics, substance use and health functioning were collected by a structured interview, using the Addiction Severity Index. A total sample of 125 individuals (30 women and 95 men) was interviewed shortly after arrival to the inpatient treatment. Differences between genders were found in drinking patterns, where men had earlier onset of first drink, earlier onset of problematic alcohol consumption and longer duration of problematic consumption. No differences between genders were found regarding somatic and psychiatric health. When comparing the two age groups (29-47 years and 49-69 years), the younger individuals had more lifetime and current psychiatric symptoms (including depression, anxiety, suicidal ideation etc.), whereas the older individuals had more chronic somatic disorders. The younger individuals had also an earlier onset of first drink of alcohol and had started a problematic consumption at earlier ages. They had also more lifetime experience of illicit drugs (including benzodiazepines and analgesics). The findings from the present study indicate that an age-perspective in treatment planning may be of more importance than a gender perspective, where younger individuals probably need more of psychiatric consultation and their older counterparts need more of consultations by medical professionals.