Proposal for hand-arm vibration exposure limits adopted for Japanese workers operating hand-held vibrating tools

On the basis of data presented in our previous reports, the current study was undertaken to estimate frequency-weighted hand-arm vibration exposure limits for various daily exposure times. The procedures for the present study were as follows. (1) The prevalence of vibration-induced white finger (VWF) as well as the vibration exposure were investigated in various groups of workers operating hand-held vibrating tools. The vibration magnitude of various tools was measured and the results were presented as the energy-equivalent frequency-weighted root-mean-square (m/s²?rms) acceleration. There was?a statistically significant positive correlation between the prevalence of VWF and the measured vibration magnitude (R ²=0.5, P<0.05). Hence, it was concluded that in decisions concerning quantitative recommendations for vibration exposure, the prevalence of VWF should be considered. (2) By a careful selection of available publications which contain useful information on duration of vibration exposure of ?2?h/day and the occurrence of VWF, a significant correlation between the prevalence of VWF and the vibration magnitude could be observed. The regression equation was estimated as: y=?18.5+4.6 (x), R ²=0.8. On the basis of this equation, it was speculated that the prevalence of VWF in workers using vibrating tools might be restricted to the prevalence of Raynaud’s phenomenon in the Japanese general population if the 2-h daily vibration exposure is about 4.5?m/s²?rms. (3) Regarding this speculation, the equation provided in the documentation of ISO 5349 was used and modified as: [(a _h,w) _eq,t =(a _h,w)_eq,2??(2/t)^1/2 (m/s²?rms)] and then the vibration limit values for daily exposure of 1?min to 8?h were calculated. (4) In order to achieve compatibility with standards of other countries, and to formulate an easy method for using the recommended values presented here, the daily exposure time of 8, 4, 2, 1 and 0.5?h were selected. The correspondence vibration magnitudes were in the range 2.2–9.0?m/s²?rms, and the lower limit (2.2?m/s²?rms) was assumed as the permissible vibration exposure limit for an 8-h working period. The proposed daily vibration limits were then compared with those recommended by other institutions.     

Assessment of hand-arm vibration exposure among traffic police motorcyclists

 The aims of this study were (1) to evaluate subjective symptoms in the hand-arm system of all traffic police motorcyclists of a city located in the central part of Japan and (2) to assess their hand-arm vibration exposure associated with traffic police motorcycle riding. The study population consisted of 119 motorcycling traffic policemen and 49 male controls. By means of a questionnaire, information on the occupational history and the presence of subjective symptoms in the hand-arm system of all subjects was obtained. Vibration was measured on the handlebars of the representative motorcycles and on the hands of the riders. The 4- and 8-h energy-equivalent frequency-weighted acceleration as well as the lifetime vibration dose were calculated for all police motorcyclists. The prevalence of finger blanching in the traffic police motorcyclists was 4.2%, but none of the controls had this symptom. The rates of finger numbness (19.3%), finger stiffness (16.0%), shoulder pain (13.4%), and shoulder stiffness (45.4%) were significantly higher among police motorcyclists as compared with controls. The root-mean-square (rms) frequency-weighted acceleration on the handlebars of police motorcycles was in the range of 2.2–4.9 m/s² rms. The computed 4- and 8-h energy-equivalent frequency-weighted acceleration values were 2.8– 4.5 and 2.0 –3.2 m/s² rms, respectively. A pattern of increasing percentage prevalence with increasing cumulative vibration dose was noticed. The subjects with a lifetime vibration dose of more than 20.1 m² h ³ s^-4 (ln scale) showed significantly higher prevalence rates for symptoms in the fingers and shoulders as compared with the control group. As occupational vibration exposure of traffic police motorcyclists might be considered a risk factor for the development of symptoms in the hand-arm system of the riders, its evaluation and control is needed for prevention methodology evolution. Received: 15 April 1996/Accepted: 8 November 1996     

A longitudinal study of finger systolic blood pressure and exposure to hand-transmitted vibration

Objectives

To investigate prospectively the relation between vibration-induced white finger (VWF), exposure to hand-trasmitted vibration (HTV) and the cold response of digital arteries in users of vibrating tools.

Methods

Two-hundred and sixteen HTV workers and 133 control men of the same companies underwent initially a medical examination and a standardised cold test with measurement of the change in finger systolic blood pressure (FSBP) after finger cooling from 30 to 10°C. They were re-examined 1 year later. Tool vibration magnitudes were expressed as frequency-weighted and unweighted r.m.s. accelerations. From the vibration magnitudes and exposure durations, alternative measures of cumulative vibration dose were calculated for each HTV worker, according to the expression: $ \text{dose} = \sum a_i^m t_iObjectives To investigate prospectively the relation between vibration-induced white finger (VWF), exposure to hand-trasmitted vibration (HTV) and the cold response of digital arteries in users of vibrating tools. Methods Two-hundred and sixteen HTV workers and 133 control men of the same companies underwent initially a medical examination and a standardised cold test with measurement of the change in finger systolic blood pressure (FSBP) after finger cooling from 30 to 10°C. They were re-examined 1 year later. Tool vibration magnitudes were expressed as frequency-weighted and unweighted r.m.s. accelerations. From the vibration magnitudes and exposure durations, alternative measures of cumulative vibration dose were calculated for each HTV worker, according to the expression: , where a _i is the acceleration magnitude on tool i, t _i is the lifetime exposure duration for tool i, and m = 0, 1, 2 or 4. Results Among the HTV workers, the initial prevalence and the 1-year incidence of VWF were 18.1 and 1.7%, respectively. At the first examination, the HTV workers with moderate or severe score for VWF showed a significantly increased cold reaction in the fingers when compared with the controls and the HTV workers with no vascular symptoms. At the follow-up, the controls, the asymptomatic HTV workers, and the prevalent cases of VWF did not show significant changes in the cold response of digital arteries. A deterioration of cold-induced digital vasoconstriction was found in the incident cases of VWF. In the HTV workers, vibration doses with high powers of acceleration (i.e., with m > 1) were major predictors of the vasoconstrictor response to cold at the follow-up examination. Conclusions The measurement of FSBP after local cooling may be a helpful objective test to monitor prospectively the change in vibration-induced vascular symptoms. The findings of this longitudinal study suggest a dose–effect relationship between cold-induced digital arterial hyperresponsiveness over time and measures of cumulative vibration exposure. In the controls, the cold response of the digital arteries was stable over 1-year follow-up period. Work presented at the second International Workshop 2006 on Diagnosis of Hand–Arm Vibration Syndrome in G?teborg, Sweden.     

Preliminary evaluation of dose-effect relationships for vibration induced white finger in Japan

Summary Habitual use of many vibrating tools has been found to be connected with the appearance of various disorders affecting the blood vessels, nerves, bones, joints, muscles or connective tissues of the hand and forearm. The vibration exposures required to cause these diseases are not known exactly, either with respect to vibration intensity and the vibration frequency spectrum, or with respect to daily exposure time and total exposure period. The purpose of this study is to investigate available data on the physical conditions in Japan that have caused vibration induced white finger (VWF) and attempt to establish approximate relationships between vibration conditions and prevalence of VWF. The vibration conditions were evaluated using the method of vibration assessment recommended by the International Standardized Organization, which uses the weighted vibration level of the frequency weighted, dominant, single axis component of vibration directed into the hand. A clear correlation between level, prevalence of VWF and exposure period can be found. The results also suggest the relationship between the weighted levels and latent intervals. These dose-effect relationships enable the prediction of the average latent interval for a population group and the range of progression of the disorders—all from a measurement of the vibration entering the hands. In Japanese cases, 4, 8, and 15% of VWF prevalence correspond with 10, 20, and 40% of VWF prevalence in the Draft International Standard ISO/DIS 5349 (1982) within the weighted vibration level range of 2 to 50m · s^¨.     

Acute effects of continuous and intermittent vibration on finger circulation

Objectives To compare the acute response of finger circulation to continuous and intermittent vibration having the same total duration of vibration exposure and the same energy-equivalent acceleration magnitude.Methods Finger blood flow (FBF) was measured in the middle and little fingers of both hands of ten healthy men. Finger skin temperature (FST) was measured in the middle right finger. With a static load of 10 N, the middle finger of the right hand was exposed to 125 Hz at 44 m s^–2 root mean square (r.m.s.) in five conditions: (1) 30 min continuous exposure, (2) two periods of 15 min, separated by a 15 min period with no vibration, (3) four periods of 7.5 min, separated by 7.5 min periods with no vibration, (4) eight periods of 3.75 min, separated by 3.75 min periods with no vibration, (5) 16 periods of 1.88 min, separated by 1.88 min periods with no vibration. All five exposures correspond to an 8 h energy-equivalent frequency-weighted acceleration magnitude of 1.4 m s^–2 r.m.s. according to International Standard ISO 5349–1 (2001). Finger circulation was measured in all four digits before the application of vibration and at fixed intervals during vibration exposure and during a 45 min recovery period.Results The FST did not change during vibration exposure, whereas all vibration conditions produced significant reductions in FBF of the vibrated finger when compared with the pre-exposure FBF. During vibration exposure, the vibration caused a similar degree of vasoconstriction in the vibrated finger without evidence of cumulative effects during intermittent exposure. After the end of exposure to 30 min of continuous vibration there was a progressive decrease in the FBF, whereas there was no statistically significant reduction following exposure to intermittent vibration.Conclusions For the vibration stimuli investigated (exposure durations varying from 1.88 min to 30 min, with rest periods varying from 1.88 min to 15 min), the reduction of FBF during exposure was the same for continuous and intermittent vibration. The after effect of vibration was greater following the continuous vibration exposure. Although some evidence from this study is consistent with the notion that intermittent vibration has a less severe effect than continuous vibration, this evidence is not yet conclusive.     

Prevalence of Raynaud's phenomenon in different groups of workers operating hand-held vibrating tools

In eight groups of subjects operating various hand-held vibrating tools and aged from 30 to 59 years, the prevalence rates of vibration-induced white finger (VWF) and numbness, pain, or stiffness in the upper and lower extremities were investigated. Hand-transmitted vibration levels (HTVLs) were measured on the back of the hand, by means of unidirectional (x-axis) vibration dosimeters, and the frequency-weighted acceleration levels [(L_h,w)_eq,t] were determined as the vibration levels. The prevalence rates of VWF and numbness of the hands in these subjects were compared to the prevalence rates of Raynaud's phenomenon (RP) and numbness of the hands in 1027 males and 1301 females not occupationally exposed to vibration (age range: 30–59 years). It was observed that in subjects exposed to HTVLs of between 1.1 and 2.5 m/s², the prevalence of VWF was between 0.0% and 4.8%. The prevalence of VWF reached 9.6% in a group of workers exposed to HTVLs of 2.7–5.1 tn/s². The latter group showed a significant difference (P < 0.05) in the prevalence of VWF compared to the 2.7% prevalence of RP in male subjects of the general population. The prevalence of VWF in female subjects exposed to vibration (4.3%) was not significantly different from the prevalence of RP in females of the general population (3.4%). The prevalence rates of numbness of the hands were in the range of 6.5%–30.4% in the exposed groups and in the range of 13.4%–29.5% in the general population. Among the subjective symptoms, only VWF showed a significant positive correlation with HTVLs (R ² = 0.5, P < 0.05). It was concluded that in decisions concerning quantitative recommendations for vibration exposure, the prevalence of VWF should be employed. With a view to decreasing the risk of developing VWF, estimated vibration safety values for 4 h and 2 h daily exposures are discussed.     

Exposure to vibration and self-reported health complaints of riveters in the aircraft industry

Workers using vibrating tools may experience neurological and vascular symptoms in the fingers and hands. The effect of vibration exposure on bone and joint disorders in the hand, arm and shoulder is less clear. In a cross-sectional study, riveters and controls in an aircraft company were investigated for vibration exposure and health complaints. Vibration measurements showed that frequency-weighted acceleration levels for riveting hammers and bucking bars ranged from 5.5 to 12.3 m s -2. The calculated equivalent frequency-weighted acceleration for a period of 4 h was the questionnaire survey 101 riveters reported statistically significant more complaints of pain and stiffness in their hands and arms when compared with 76 controls with no, or little, exposure to vibration. After 10 years of exposure statistically significant age-adjusted odds ratios (P less than 0.05) were found for vibration-induced white finger (VWF) (1.9) and pain or stiffness of the wrist (3.2). Although they were not statistically significant (0.05 less than P less than 0.10) odds ratios appreciably greater than 1 were found for numbness in fingers (1.6) and pain or stiffness in the elbow (1.6) and the shoulder (1.5), and these complaints were strongly associated with duration of exposure to vibration. With logistic regression the probabilities for a riveter of having symptoms of VWF after 10 and 20 years of exposure was estimated to be P = 0.18 and P = 0.29, respectively, which can be compared with the prevalences predicted by the dose-response relationship for VWF in ISO 5349, which are 10 and 30%. The results of this study suggest that exposure to vibration from working with impact power tools can contribute to complaints of pain and stiffness in the hand, arm and shoulder, and especially in the wrist.     

Effect of vibration magnitude and repetitive exposure on finger blood flow in healthy subjects

In order to study the effect of the magnitude of vibrations and repetitive exposure on finger blood flow, we exposed ten healthy subjects to three experimental conditions: (1) vibration of 3.16 m/s² at 60 Hz, (2) vibration of 31.6 m/s² at 60 Hz, and (3) no vibration, as a control. Under the experimental conditions, the right hand was exposed to 5-min vibration three times, with intervening 5-min rests. Meanwhile, the blood flows of both middle fingers were continuously measured with a blood flow meter based on the thermal diffusion method. Finger blood flow was significantly decreased in both hands with exposure to vibrations of 3.16 m/s² and 31.6 m/s². Increased magnitude of vibration tended to enhance the decrease in finger blood flow in both hands, and repeated exposure to vibration had cumulative effects on the decrease in finger blood flow in the unexposed left hand. Received: 19 May 1999 / Accepted: 20 November 1999     

Transmission of vibration energy to different parts of the human hand-arm system

The aim of this study was to investigate the transmission of vibration energy to three selected points along the hand and arm (knuckle, wrist and elbow) and to compare the energy transmission for two different kinds of vibration exposures, i.e. random and sinusoidal. The transmission of vibration energy was estimated for ten subjects during exposure to random (within the frequency range 20–5000 Hz) and sinusoidal vibration at eight different frequencies (20, 40, 80, 160, 320, 630, 1250 and 1600 Hz). The random and sinusoidal vibrations had a frequency-weighted acceleration level of 3 m/s². The energy transmission was determined by simultaneous vibration measurements at the vibrating handle and in the hand-arm system. The measurements were made with a laser-velocity transducer and specially constructed equipment. The grip and feed forces were held constant at 40 N. The results show that the energy transmission decreases with the distance from the source. The results also show that the energy transmission is dependent on the frequency for the random vibration exposures. No clear frequency dependence of the energy transmission could be found for the sinusoidal vibrations. It may also be concluded that there are differences in the energy transmission due to types of exposure, sinusoidal vibration showing higher transmission of energy to the hand-arm system than random vibration, especially at higher frequencies. Received: 16 October 1996 / Accepted: 7 February 1997     

Risk assessment of vibration exposure and white fingers among platers

Summary The dose-response relationship between vibration exposure and vascular disorders in the hands was examined in platers. The study was based on a cross section of 89 platers and 61 office workers divided according to exposure to vibration into four groups. Vibration exposure was assessed by measuring the acceleration intensity on a sample of tools, together with both subjective rating and objective measurements of the exposure time. The frequency-weighted energy equivalent acceleration for 4 h was 4.6–4.7 m/s². The point prevalence of white fingers was 42% for the plater category currently exposed with an odds ratio of 85. The time laps before contraction of white fingers (latency time) was four years for the 10th percentile, and was shorter than predicted according to the ISO-5349 standard. The prevalence of white finger symptoms staged according to the Taylor-Pelmear scale was comparable to the prevalences according to the Stockholm Workshop Scale. Vibration exposure was the dominant source of white fingers and each year of vibration exposure increased the odds ratio for white fingers by 11%. Distal circulation in the hands was assessed by a timed Allen test. The odds ratio for a positive Allen test was higher for the workers exposed to vibration compared to the non-exposed workers. The use of the timed Allen test is suggested in the clinical examination for vibration white fingers. The observed high risk for contracting white fingers could be prevented by exposure level reduction and/or restriction of exposure duration.     

The mechanism of a human reaction to vibration stress by palmar sweating in relation to autonomic nerve tone

Objectives: To clarify the mechanism of a human reaction to vibration stress by palmar sweating in relation to the autonomic nerve tone. Methods: The autonomic nerve tone was divided into four types by using digital photoelectroplethysmography (PTG) with auditory stimuli: normal (N), hyperreactive (I and D), and hyporeactive (P) types. Palmar sweating and digital PTG were simultaneously measured on the right palm and middle finger, respectively, in 20 healthy men. The left hand gripping the handle with a grasp strength of 49 N was exposed to vibration at a frequency of 125 Hz and acceleration magnitudes of 0 m/s² (as a control), 30 m/s², or 50 m/s² for 3 min. The volume of palmar sweating was recorded before, during, and 30 min after vibration load. Three kinds of drugs related to the autonomic nervous system were orally administered to the subjects. Then 80 min after administration, the experiments were repeated. Results: Of 20 subjects, 17 showed normal autonomic nerve tone (N type), and 3 hyperreactive (I type). The palmar sweating reaction to vibration in I-type subjects was greater and lasted longer than that in N-type subjects. Vibration with an acceleration of 50 m/s² produced the greatest reaction which was about 7 times larger than that at 0 m/s² and 2.5 times that at 30 m/s² (P < 0.01). Sulpiride decreased palmar sweating during vibration, while prazosin and scopolamine inhibited it. Conclusions: The palmar sweating reaction to vibration stress was related to the background level of the autonomic nerve tone. The sweating volume was in direct proportion to the acceleration magnitude of vibration. The reaction of palmar sweating to vibration stress may be mediated through both the adrenergic and cholinergic fibers of the autonomic nervous system. Received: 18 September 1998 / Accepted: 10 July 1999     

Assessment of vibration produced by the grinders used in the shipbuilding industry of Korea

The objective of this study is to estimate the prevalence of finger blanching among the workers in a shipyard of Korea using the dose-response relationship suggested by ISO 5349. The characteristics of vibration exposure produced by six types of grinders were investigated. Vibration measurement was made under the real work conditions. Exposure time was estimated by questionnaire and direct observation. In addition, cold provocation tests were performed, and the results from the tests were compared with the estimated prevalence. As a result, 4 hour-energy-equivalent frequency-weighted accelerations of the finishing grinding (FG) and the prepainting grinding (PG) jobs were 6.23 m/s(2) and 13.39 m/s(2), respectively. The mean exposure time for holding the grinders was 4.64 h per day. Using the ISO 5349 method, it was predicted that after exposure to vibration for 10.79 yr, about a half of the FG workers could develop finger blanching. For the PG workers, the corresponding predicted latency was 5.02 yr. A discrepancy was found between the results from the ISO relationship and those from the cold provocation tests. A linear regression model was suggested employing vibration acceleration and vibration exposure time as explanatory variables for vascular dysfunction.     

Studies of combined effects of sinusoidal whole body vibrations and noise of varying bandwidths and intensities on TTS2 in men

Summary This study analyses the data from three laboratory experiments concerning the separate and combined effects on temporary threshold shifts in hearing (TTS2) of sinusoidal low-frequency (5 Hz — 2.12 m/s² and 10 Hz —2.65 m/s²), whole body vibration (along the Z-axis), and continuous (white) noise with eight different bandwidths and intensity levels of 85 dB(A), 90 dB(A) and 98 dB(A). Altogether 370 separate personal experiments were performed using a one-man exposure chamber system. A single experiment consisted of a 30-min pre-exposure period, three 16-min exposure periods, and a 15-min post-exposure period. The data suggested that the TTS₂ induced by noise was increased by vibration. Actually, vibration at a frequency of 5 Hz and noise with bandwidths of 1–4 kHz, 1–8 kHz or 0.2–16 kHz comprised the most significant exposure combinations. After such exposures, the increase in TTS₂ values was defined most clearly for 4 kHz and 6 kHz test frequencies. The increase of thresholds was most marked during the first 16-min exposure period, even though most TTS₂ values determined after the third consecutive exposure period were higher than after the first and second exposures. Figures obtained after the third exposure period proved that exposure to simultaneous vibration and broad band noise (i.e. noise with a bandwidth of 0.2–16 kHz) increased TTS₂ values 1.2–1.5 times more in the 4 kHz audio range than such a broad band noise alone. No single vibration condition induced the same amount of TTS₂.     

Hand-arm vibration syndrome among travertine workers: a follow up study.

In a six year follow up study of the handarm vibration syndrome, 62 stoneworkers operating hand held vibrating tools in 10 travertine quarries and mills were first investigated in 1985 and then in 1991. The frequency weighted acceleration of vibration from the rock drills and stone hammers used by the travertine workers exceeded 20 m/s2, indicating a hazardous work activity according to the proposal of the EC directive for physical agents. A clinical examination and a cold provocation test were repeated with the same procedures as those adopted at the time of the first survey. The stoneworkers were divided into groups according to current work state: active stoneworkers who continued to use powered tools during the follow up (n = 21, median exposure time 22 years), and ex-stoneworkers with retirement vibration free intervals of three years (n = 22, median exposure time 27.5 years) and of six years (n = 19, median exposure time 20 years). In the group of active stoneworkers, a 38% onset a new cases of vibration-induced white finger (VWF) was found during the follow up (p < 0.01). Among the retired stoneworkers affected with VWF (n = 24), one recovered from VWF, one showed improvement, 20 remained stationary, and two deteriorated. The ex-stoneworkers experienced no significant change in sensorineural disturbances and a decrease in musculoskeletal symptoms of the upper limbs. At the cold provocation test, the currently active stoneworkers with VWF showed, on a group basis, a delayed finger rewarming time between the two examinations (p = 0.002). An abnormal response to cold provocation persisted in the fingers of the ex-stoneworkers with VWF, even in those reporting subjective improvement. These findings indicate a tendency towards the irreversibility of sensorineural and VWF symptoms in a group of ex-stoneworkers with prolonged exposure to high vibration levels in the past. The increased occurrence of VWF in the active stone workers after a few extra years of vibrating tool usage argues for an urgent implementation of preventive measures in the stone industry.     

Response of finger circulation to energy equivalent combinations of magnitude and duration of vibration

OBJECTIVES—To investigate the acute response of finger circulation to vibration with different combinations of magnitude and duration but with the same "energy equivalent" acceleration magnitude according to current standards for hand transmitted vibration.
METHODS—Finger skin temperature (FST) and finger blood flow (FBF) were measured in the middle fingers of both hands of 10 healthy men who had not used hand held vibrating tools regularly. With a static load of 10 N, the right hand was exposed to 125 Hz vibration with the following unweighted root mean square (rms) acceleration magnitudes and durations of exposure: 44 m/s² for 30 minutes; 62 m/s² for 15 minutes; 88 m/s² for 7.5 minutes; 125 m/s² for 3.75 minutes; and 176 m/s² for 1.88 minutes. These vibration exposures produce the same 8 hour energy equivalent frequency weighted acceleration magnitude (~1.4 m/s² rms) according to international standard ISO 5349 (1986). Finger circulation was measured in both the right (vibrated) and the left (non-vibrated) middle fingers before application of the vibration, and at fixed intervals during exposure to vibration and during a 45 minute recovery period.
RESULTS—The FST did not change during exposure to vibration, whereas vibration with any combination of acceleration magnitude and duration produced significant percentage reductions in the FBF of the vibrated finger compared with the FBF before exposure (from −40.1% (95% confidence interval (95% CI) −24.3% to −57.2%) to −61.4% (95% CI −45.0% to −77.8%). The reduction in FBF during vibration was stronger in the vibrated finger than in the non-vibrated finger. Across the five experimental conditions, the various vibration stimuli caused a similar degree of vasoconstriction in the vibrated finger during exposure to vibration. There was a progressive decrease in the FBF of both fingers after the end of exposure to vibration with acceleration magnitudes of 44 m/s² for 30 minutes and 62 m/s² for 15 minutes. Significant vasoconstrictor after effects were not found in either finger after exposure to any of the other vibration stimuli with greater acceleration magnitudes for shorter durations.
CONCLUSIONS—For the range of vibration magnitudes investigated (44 to 176 m/s² rms unweighted; 5.5 to 22 m/s² rms when frequency weighted according to ISO 5349), the vasoconstriction during exposure to 125 Hz vibration was independent of vibration magnitude. The after effect of vibration was different for stimuli with the same energy equivalent acceleration, with greater effects after longer durations of exposure. The energy equivalent acceleration therefore failed to predict the acute effects of vibration both during and after exposure to vibration. Both central and local vasoregulatory mechanisms are likely to be involved in the response of finger circulation to acute exposures to 125 Hz vibration.


Keywords: finger circulation; energy equivalent acceleration magnitude; vibration frequency; magnitude; and duration     

Hand-arm vibration syndrome and its prevalence in the present status of private forestry enterprises in Japan

Summary Currently there are no limitations on age of employment on private forestries in Japan. Hence, it was hypothesized that in these kind of enterprises, elderly chain saw operators, or those with long-term exposure, might be at higher risk of developing hand-arm vibration syndrome (HAVS). We consequently investigated the prevalence of HAVS in 447 chain saw workers on private forestries in Gifu Prefecture, Japan, with particular reference to age and exposure period. Of this population, 43 (9.6%) had signs and symptoms of vibration-induced white finger (VWF), and among these workers the severity of finger blanching was significantly correlated (P < 0.01) with the exposure period. Classification of all subjects by exposure period showed that workers with 30 years' exposure had higher prevalences of VWF (20.9%) and numbness of the hands (25.4%) compared to other groups. Significant differences (P < 0.01) were found between the functional capacities of workers with VWF and those of control subjects. We concluded that (a) the elderly chain saw operators and those with longer exposure should be moved to other jobs with a lower or no risk of exposure to vibration, and (b) the results of screening tests, even without cold water immersion (which we did not employ, in order to protect workers' hands), could be helpful for the identification of workers with VWF.     

Rheological and immunological findings in dockers with vibration-induced white fingers

Summary The aim of the present study was to characterize theological and immunological features involved in the pathogenesis of vibration-induced white fingers (VWF). Plasma viscosity, at two shear rates (580 s^–1 and 1164 s^–1), levels of immunoglobulins (IgG, IgM, IgA), circulating immune complexes, rheumatoid factor, antinuclear antibodies, fibronectin, fibrinogen, hemoglobin and erythrocyte sedimentation rate were analysed in 30 male dockers with VWF and in 30 healthy male referents unexposed for hand-arm vibrations. Decreased plasma viscosity was observed among the men with VWF, although formal significance (P < 0.05) was only obtained at shear rate 580 s^–1. The decrease was mainly seen among smokers. In the study there were no significant differences between the VWF group and the referents with regard to immunoglobulin levels, autoantibodies and other plasma proteins. From the study it is concluded that workers with VWF may have a decreased plasma viscosity. The biological relevance of this observation is uncertain and deserves further study.     

Time dependence and non-linearity of the impedance of the human hand-arm system while exposed to intense vibration

Summary The object of the investigation was to find out possible nonlinearities and dependencies of the impedance of the hand-arm-system on the exposure time. The measurements were made on four male test persons, with the vibrations being introduced parallel to the forearm axis and in a standing position with the arms stretched. The vibration accelerations were between and the measuring handle had a weight of only 48 g. The impedance decreases in dependence on time at maximum spanning force without pressing force. After 1 min of exposure time, values of about 55% are reached at 40 Hz and values of about 80% at 20 Hz. The impedance with pressing force of 100 N without spanning force increases with time, most distinctly at 25 Hz. No influence of the vibration intensity could be seen. The compression-tension quotient was introduced as characteristic for the non-linearity. It is dependent on the frequency, the vibration acceleration and, with large vibration accelerations, also on the exposure time. The quotient is 1...1.5 at vibration accelerations up to and 3...4 at vibration accelerations up to and after 3 to 5 min exposure time.     

Hand-arm vibration syndrome and dose-response relation for vibration induced white finger among quarry drillers and stonecarvers. Italian Study Group on Physical Hazards in the Stone Industry.

OBJECTIVES--To investigate the occurrence of disorders associated with the hand arm vibration syndrome in a large population of stone workers in Italy. The dose-response relation for vibration induced white finger (VWF) was also studied. METHODS--The study population consisted of 570 quarry drillers and stonecarvers exposed to vibration and 258 control stone workers who performed only manual activity. Each subject was interviewed with health and workplace assessment questionnaires. Sensorineural and VWF disorders were staged according to the Stockholm workshop scales. Vibration was measured on a representative sample of percussive and rotary tools. The 8 h energy equivalent frequency weighted acceleration (A (8)) and lifetime vibration doses were calculated for each of the exposed stone workers. RESULTS--Sensorineural and musculoskeletal symptoms occurred more frequently in the workers exposed to vibration than in the controls, but trend statistics did not show a linear exposure-response relation for these disorders. The prevalence of VWF was found to be 30.2% in the entire group exposed to vibration. Raynaud's phenomenon was discovered in 4.3% of the controls. VWF was strongly associated with exposure to vibration and a monotonic dose-response relation was found. According to the exposure data of this study, the expected percentage of stone workers affected with VWF tends to increase roughly in proportion to the square root of A(8) (for a particular exposure period) or in proportion to the square root of the duration of exposure (for a constant magnitude of vibration). CONCLUSION--Even although limited to a specific work situation, the dose-response relation for VWF estimated in this study suggests a time dependency such that halving the years of exposure allows a doubling of the energy equivalent vibration. According to these findings, the vibration exposure levels currently under discussion within the European Community seem to represent reasonable exposure limits for the protection of workers against the harmful effects of hand transmitted vibration.     

A study on the effects of countermeasures for vibrating tool workers using an impact wrench.

The aims of this study were (1) to measure frequency-weighted vibration acceleration and (2) to study the effects of introducing a vibration-proof impact wrench on VWF in workers. The subject pool was 383 male workers who were regularly using an impact wrench and taking special medical examinations for vibration syndrome in a factory from 1982 to 1999. The prevalence of workers with VWF increased gradually after 1982, reached a peak value (4.8%) in 1986, gradually decreased after 1987, and disappeared in 1994. Sixteen subjects who had had VWF at least one time during the observation period were selected for this study. The stages of VWF were at stage I on the Stockholm Workshop scale in all subjects. After the vibration-proof impact wrench was introduced in 1986, the vibration acceleration of the impact wrench measured on the handle decreased from 8.6-11.1 m/s2 to 5.1-7.1 m/s2. The actual time per day that subjects were assumed to use the impact wrench was 108 minutes. The subjects actually used an impact wrench more than the occupational exposure limit allowed. However, VWF disappeared after the introduction of a vibration-proof impact wrench. This might have resulted from the combined effect of introducing the vibration-proof impact wrench and certain countermeasures that were taken against cold working environments.