压力痛阈测试在颞下颌关节病中的应用

压力痛阈测试(pressure pain threshold,PPT)作为定量感觉测试的一项指标已经被用于颞下颌关节病的临床研究,其在揭示疾病疼痛的发生机制、预测疾病发展过程、判断不同治疗的临床效果差异等方面有巨大作用。本文就PPT在颞下颌关节病中的研究进展及其局限性作一综述。     

The reliability and validity of self-reported temporomandibular disorder pain in adolescents

AIMS: To evaluate the reliability and validity of self-reported pain associated with temporomandibular disorders (TMD) in adolescents and to determine how this validity may change over time. The authors' hypothesis was that self-reported pain can be used to reliably and accurately detect adolescents with TMD pain. METHODS: One hundred twenty adolescents, 60 with self-reported TMD pain and 60 age- and gender-matched controls without TMD pain, were examined twice. At the first examination at a Public Dental Service clinic, self-reported TMD pain was recorded for each patient. At the second examination, a clinical examination was completed, blind to the patients' self-report of pain symptoms, after which self-reported TMD pain was again recorded. The clinical examination was based upon the Research Diagnostic Criteria for TMD (RDC/TMD). Self-reported TMD pain in this investigation was based upon the subjects' responses to 2 questions: (1) Do you have pain in your temples, face, temporomandibular joint (TMJ), or jaws once a week or more? and (2) Do you have pain when you open your mouth wide or chew once a week or more? RESULTS: Test-retest reliability of .83 (kappa) was found for the 2 questions. The sensitivity was .98 (95% CI, .90 to 1.0) and specificity was .90 (95% CI, .81 to .95) for comparison of assessments made on the same day. Sensitivity was .96 (95% CI, .85 to .99) and specificity .83 (95% CI, .72 to .90) for assessments made 2 to 4 weeks apart. CONCLUSION: Very good reliability and high validity were found for the self-reported pain questions. A short time interval between the screening question and examination slightly increased the accuracy of the measure. In adolescent populations, the questions in this study can be used to screen for TMD pain.     

Development of a brief and effective temporomandibular disorder pain screening questionnaire: reliability and validity

BackgroundAvailable screening instruments for identifying temporomandibular disorders (TMDs) exhibit methodological or logistic limitations. The authors conducted a study to develop and assess the validity of a self-report instrument in screening patients for pain-related TMDs.MethodsBy using psychometric methods for item selection, the authors developed short (three-item) and long (six-item) versions of the questionnaire and evaluated them for validity among 504 participants.ResultsInternal reliability was excellent, with coefficient α values of 0.87 and 0.93 for the short and long versions, respectively. When the authors dichotomized instrument scores at optimal thresholds, both versions had a sensitivity of 99 percent and a specificity of 97 percent for correct classification of the presence or absence of TMD. The specificity was at least 95 percent in the correct identification of people with nonpainful TMJ disorders or headahce without TMD pain.ConclusionsWith use of appropriate psychometric methodology, the selected items exhibited excellent content validity. The excellent levels of reliability, sensitivity and specificity demonstrate the validity and usefulness of this instrument.Clinical ImplicationsUsing this instrument will allow clinicians to identify more readily—and cost-effectively—most patients with painful TMD conditions for whom early and reliable identification would have a significant effect on diagnosis, treatment and prognosis.     

Amitriptyline treatment of chronic pain in patients with temporomandibular disorders

Randomized clinical trials of amitriptyline will require data from pilot studies to be used for sample size estimates, but such data are lacking. This study investigated the 6-week and 1-year effectiveness of low dose amitriptyline (10-30 mg) for the treatment of patients with chronic temporomandibular disorder (TMD) pain. Based on clinical examination, patients were divided into two groups: myofascial and mixed (myofascial and temporomandibular joint disorders). Baseline pain was assessed by a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) for pain intensity and by the McGill Pain Questionnaire (MPQ). Depression was assessed by the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) short form. Patient assessment of global treatment effectiveness was obtained after 6 weeks and 1 year of treatment by using a five-point ordinal scale: (1) worse, (2) unchanged, (3) minimally improved, (4) moderately improved, (5) markedly improved. The results showed a significant reduction for all pain scores after 6 weeks and 1 year post-treatment. The depression scores changed in depressed but not in non-depressed patients. Global treatment effectiveness showed significant improvement 6 weeks and 1 year post-treatment. However, pain and global treatment effectiveness were less improved at 1 year than at 6 weeks.     

Better palpation of pain: reliability and validity of a new pressure pain protocol in TMD

The purpose of this research was to employ a double-blind placebo control design of iontophoretically administered lidocaine to assess the test-retest reliability and validity of a magnitude matching procedure using a pressure algometer. In studies in the literature on assessment of pain in temporomandibular disorders (TMD), the pressure algometer has been found to be a reliable means of measuring pressure-pain threshold and a sensitive measure of treatment-response in the laboratory. However, previous research with this apparatus has not employed more sophisticated psychophysics. This study employs a magnitude matching psychophysical protocol to obtain a multidimensional pain report. Test-retest reliability over two occasions, 3-8 days apart, was found to be moderate for discriminability (r = .71, p < .01) but poor for response bias (r = .44). The validity study used iontophoresis as an anesthetic in a double-blind placebo and no-treatment control design. Although it was hypothesized that subjects in the anesthesia group would demonstrate reduced discriminability as compared with the control groups, no differences were found among the three groups on this measure. However, differences in response bias were found, with both the placebo control and no-treatment control groups differing from the experimental group but not from each other. Possible explanations and the implications of these findings are discussed.     

Intra- and interrater agreement of pressure pain threshold for masticatory structures in children reporting orofacial pain related to temporomandibular disorders and symptom-free children

AIMS: To determine intra- and interrater agreement of the pressure pain threshold (PPT) values for children reporting orofacial pain related to temporomadibular disorders and symptom-free subjects when the mean of 3 consecutive measurements or the mean of the last 2 consecutive measurements was considered. METHODS: Fourteen children reporting pain in masticatory muscles or the temporomandibular joint and 16 symptom-free children were selected at random from a sample of 100 children. Two trained raters used an algometer to obtain 3 consecutive measurements of PPT of the masticatory system sites. The children were evaluated in 3 sessions after a minimum period of 3 days after the initial evaluation. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was used to evaluate the levels of agreement. RESULTS: Excellent intra- and interrater agreement was observed (ICC > 0.75) for most of the structures evaluated in symptom-free children, and excellent and moderate agreement was obtained for the symptomatic group. Discarding the first of the 3 measurements increased the number of sites with ICC values classified as excellent in both groups. For evaluations performed on different days, this procedure reduced significantly the percentage of sites with ICC values classified as excellent only for the interrater agreement for the symptomatic group. CONCLUSION: The lower levels of reproducibility for the measurements obtained on different days in the children who reported pain may have been related to instability of their clinical signs and symptoms, and a PPT assessment based on the mean of 3 consecutive measurements or the procedure of discarding the first measure should be considered for such evaluations, especially when they are conducted by different raters. Algometry was shown to be a reliable tool for the evaluation of pain threshold in the masticatory structures of children.     

颞下颌关节紊乱病患者疼痛的临床描述分析

目的通过研究颞下颌关节紊乱病（TMD）患者对疼痛的主观描述情况,分析TMD患者疼痛的特点。方法选择以口颌面部疼痛为主诉的TMD患者90例为研究对象,检测患者疼痛的强度和相关功能丧失的程度,记录患者自述的疼痛规律和描述疼痛的词汇。结果90例患者主要为轻到中等强度的疼痛,男女之间以及急、慢性期之间疼痛强度的差异无统计学意义（P>0.05）。TMD疼痛对咀嚼功能的影响最大,其次是对心情状况有比较大的影响。急、慢性期患者下颌静止时疼痛出现率无统计学差异（P>0.05）。急性期患者常用酸痛、隐痛、刺痛和抽着痛来描述疼痛,慢性期患者常用的词汇是钝痛、木痛和胀痛。结论急、慢性期TMD导致的疼痛强度均较低,主要影响患者的咀嚼功能和心理状态。急、慢性TMD疼痛的描述词汇有所不同。     

Relationship between temporomandibular joint pain and magnetic resonance imaging findings in patients with temporomandibular joint disorders

The purpose of this study was to evaluate abnormal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings related to temporomandibular joint (TMJ) pain. This study included 245 joints of 152 patients with temporomandibular disorders with anterior disc displacement; of these, 129 joints had joint pain whereas 116 joints had no joint pain. MRI was used to evaluate the reduction of anterior disc displacement, joint effusion, mandible condylar morphology, bone marrow oedema of the mandibular condyle, and signal intensity of the posterior disc attachment (PDA) on fat-suppressed T2-weighted images. The odds ratio (OR) for each MRI variable for the pain group versus the no pain group was computed using logistic regression analysis. Univariate logistic regression analysis showed significant correlations between TMJ pain and all MRI findings. Multivariate logistic regression analysis showed significant correlations with joint effusion (P = 0.03, OR 2.21), bone marrow oedema (P < 0.001, OR 11.75), and signal intensity of the PDA (P < 0.001, OR 6.21). These results suggest that bone marrow oedema, high signal intensity of the PDA on fat-suppressed T2-weighted images, and joint effusion, in descending order of influence, are factors related to TMJ pain.     

Primary headaches in patients with temporomandibular disorders: Diagnosis and treatment of central sensitization pain

Objectives: Central sensitization (CS) has been found in patients with temporomandibular disorders (TMD), craniofacial pain (CP) and primary headaches, but its clinical implications remain uncertain. The first aim was to provide a synthesis of the current state of knowledge about the link between CS and TMD associated with primary headaches; the second goal was to find methodologies to assess and treat CS in this subgroup of patients.

Methods: A narrative review of the literature was conducted.

Results: CS is described in literature as an aggravating factor in patients with TMD-related primary headaches. Further studies are required to support this assertion.

Conclusions: The importance of excluding chronic neuropathic pain and recognizing CS as the main component using a top-down approach to target the best pharmacological and non-pharmacological treatments is evident. Some useful tools to discriminate patients with CS from others have become available, but more research is required to enable an appropriate diagnosis.     

The relationship between neck pain and cervical alignment in patients with temporomandibular disorders

ABSTRACT

Objective: To elucidate the impact of neck pain on cervical alignment in patients with TMDs.

Method: Patients diagnosed with TMDs between November 2013 and November 2015 were included. All subjects underwent lateral cervical X-ray evaluation and completed the RDC/TMD Axis II Biobehavioral Questionnaire for TMDs. Patients with neck pain also completed the Neck Pain & Disability Scale (NPDS). Cervical lordosis angle was measured according to C2-C7 Cobb’s method.

Results: The mean cervical lordosis angle of the whole group (n = 60) revealed hypolordosis (10.9 ± 12.7°). Cervical lordosis angle did not differ between patients with (n = 28) and without (n = 32) neck pain (12.2 ± 12.8° versus 9.8 ± 12.7°, respectively; p = 0.46). TMD-related variables were not correlated with cervical alignment but were moderately correlated with NPDS score, with the exception of TMD-associated disability.

Conclusion: Patients with TMDs have hypolordotic cervical malalignment (tendency toward kyphosis) regardless of neck pain.     

Psychosocial factors associated with pain outcomes in patients with painful temporomandibular disorders and headaches

The objective of this study was to assess the association between psychosocial factors (in terms of anxiety, somatization, depression, and optimism) and pain (in terms of headache pain intensity and pain-related disability), in patients with a painful temporomandibular disorder (TMD) and one of the following headache types: migraine, tension-type headache (TTH), or headache attributed to TMD, corrected for the influence of bruxism. A retrospective study was conducted at an orofacial pain and dysfunction (OPD) clinic. Inclusion criteria were painful TMD, with migraine, TTH, and/or headache attributed to TMD. Linear regressions were performed to assess the influence of psychosocial variables on pain intensity and on pain-related disability, stratified per headache type. The regression models were corrected for bruxism and the presence of multiple headache types. A total of 323 patients (61% female; mean age 42.9, SD 14.4 years) were included. Headache pain intensity only had significant associations in TMD-pain patients with headache attributed to TMD, and anxiety showed the strongest relation (β = 0.353) with pain intensity. Pain-related disability was most strongly associated with depression in TMD-pain patients with TTH (β = 0.444), and with somatization in patients with headache attributed to TMD (β = 0.399). In conclusion, the influence of psychosocial factors on headache pain intensity and pain-related disability depends on the headache type presenting.     

Factors associated with temporomandibular disorders pain in adolescents

To gain a better understanding of temporomandibular disorders (TMD) pain in adolescents, it is important to study the factors associated with its presence. Therefore, the aim of this study was to investigate potential predictors for TMD pain in adolescents, thereby including a diversity of factors from the biopsychosocial model to determine the strongest predictors. The sample of this cross‐sectional study consisted of 1094 adolescents. The presence of TMD pain was assessed using the RDC/TMD, Axis I. Apart from demographical characteristics, the roles of parafunctional habits, psychosocial aspects, menarche and other bodily pain complaints were evaluated. Single and multiple logistic regression models were used to identify associations between the predictor variables and TMD pain. Painful TMD had a prevalence of 25·5%. Logistic regression analyses showed that TMD pain was associated with sleep bruxism (OR = 1·8 95% CI = 1·34–2·34), awake bruxism (OR = 2·1 95% CI = 1·56–2·83), other parafunctional habits (OR = 2·2 95% CI = 1·17–4·08) and bodily pain complaints (OR = 5·0 95% CI = 3·48–7·28). Parafunctional habits and other bodily pain complaints may play an important role in the presence of TMD pain in adolescents. Of course, it remains unclear whether the observed associations between the investigated factors and the adolescent's TMD pain have a true causal linkage.     

Pressure-pain threshold determination in the oral mucosa: validity and reliability

Fundamental knowledge of pain in the oral mucosa is lacking. We determined the validity and reliability of the pressure-pain threshold (PPT) measurement in the oral mucosa using a newly developed hand-held pressure algometer. Ten dentulous subjects were recruited, and the PPT was measured at the bilateral buccal (on the attached gingiva apical to the midline of the upper first premolars, 3 mm from the mucogingival junction) and the palatal sites (mid-point between the bilateral upper first molars). The PPT linearly increased with an increase in load-rate (P < 0.0001). The PPT yielded a high intra-individual stability both for the same-day consecutive trials and weekly sessions. The palatal site revealed a 4- to 4.65-fold greater PPT than the buccal sites (Bonferroni, P < 0.0001), whereas no difference was found between the bilateral buccal sites (P=0.663). Despite a great interindividual variation in the PPT, significant intra-individual correlations were found among the measurement sites. This suggested differences in individual sensitivity to pain in the oral mucosa, which may determine overall pain sensation specific to an individual. A pressure algometer described herein reliably assessed the PPT in the oral mucosa and sensitively discriminated PPT differences at different sites and at different load-rates, suggesting the reliability and validity of PPT measurements in the oral mucosa for clinical and research investigations.     

The effects of manual therapy and exercise directed at the cervical spine on pain and pressure pain sensitivity in patients with myofascial temporomandibular disorders

Summary No studies have investigated the effects of the treatments directed at the cervical spine in patients with temporomandibular disorders (TMD). Our aim was to investigate the effects of joint mobilization and exercise directed at the cervical spine on pain intensity and pressure pain sensitivity in the muscles of mastication in patients with TMD. Nineteen patients (14 females), aged 19–57 years, with myofascial TMD were included. All patients received a total of 10 treatment session over a 5‐week period (twice per week). Treatment included manual therapy techniques and exercise directed at the cervical spine. Outcome measures included bilateral pressure pain threshold (PPT) levels over the masseter and temporalis muscles, active pain‐free mouth opening (mm) and pain (Visual Analogue Scale) and were all assessed pre‐intervention, 48 h after the last treatment (post‐intervention) and at 12‐week follow‐up period. Mixed‐model anovas were used to examine the effects of the intervention on each outcome measure. Within‐group effect sizes were calculated in order to assess clinical effect. The 2 × 3 mixed model anova revealed significant effect for time (F = 77·8; P < 0·001) but not for side (F = 0·2; P = 0·7) for changes in PPT over the masseter muscle and over the temporalis muscle (time: F = 66·8; P < 0·001; side: F = 0·07; P = 0·8). Post hoc revealed significant differences between pre‐intervention and both post‐intervention and follow‐up periods (P < 0·001) but not between post‐intervention and follow‐up period (P = 0·9) for both muscles. Within‐group effect sizes were large (d > 1·0) for both follow‐up periods in both muscles. The anova found a significant effect for time (F = 78·6; P < 0·001) for changes in pain intensity and active pain‐free mouth opening (F = 17·1; P < 0·001). Significant differences were found between pre‐intervention and both post‐intervention and follow‐up periods (P < 0·001) but not between the post‐intervention and follow‐up period (P > 0·7). Within‐group effect sizes were large (d > 0·8) for both post‐intervention and follow‐up periods. The application of treatment directed at the cervical spine may be beneficial in decreasing pain intensity, increasing PPTs over the masticatory muscles and an increasing pain‐free mouth opening in patients with myofascial TMD.     

Interexaminer reliability and validity for diagnosis of temporomandibular disorders of visual leg measurements used in dental kinesiology

AIMS: To determine the reliability and the validity of visual leg measurements used in dental kinesiology, which suggests that a masticatory dysfunction, such as occurs in temporomandibular disorders (TMD), can influence the length and the internal rotation of lower limbs. METHODS: The leg-length inequality test and the internal foot-rotation test were performed independently by 3 different examiners on 41 subjects who were also screened for TMD. Data were analyzed by means of kappa statistics and by calculation of sensitivity and specificity values. RESULTS: Chance-corrected reliability was generally poor for both the leg-length inequality test (0.33 < or = k < or = 0.39) and the internal foot-rotation test (0.15 < or = k < or = 0.27). Sensitivity and specificity values of the tests to differentiate TMD and healthy subjects were below acceptable thresholds; they ranged from 0.41 to 0.57. CONCLUSION: Visual evaluations of leg-length inequality and internal foot rotation were unreliable and are not valid for TMD diagnoses. The results of chiropractic visual leg measurement procedures in dentistry should be interpreted with caution, particularly when clinical decisions may lead to nonreversible dental treatment.     

Effect of weather on temporal pain patterns in patients with temporomandibular disorders and migraine

Patients with masticatory muscle pain and migraine typically report that the intensity of pain fluctuates over time and is affected by weather changes. Weather variables, such as ambient temperature and humidity, may vary significantly depending on whether the individual is outdoor or indoor. It is, therefore, important to assess these variables at the individual level using portable monitors, during everyday life. This study aimed to determine and compare the temporal patterns of pain in individuals affected with facial and head pain and to investigate its relation with weather changes. Eleven patients (27·3 ± 7·4 years) with chronic masticatory muscle pain (MP) and twenty (33·1 ± 8·7 years) with migraine headache (MH) were asked to report their current pain level on a visual analogue scale (VAS) every hour over fourteen consecutive days. The VAS scores were collected using portable data‐loggers, which were also used to record temperature, atmospheric pressure and relative humidity. VAS scores varied markedly over time in both groups. Pain VAS scores fluctuate less in the MP group than in the MH group, but their mean, minimum and maximum values were higher than those of migraine patients (all P < 0·05). Pain scores <2 cm were more common in the MH than in the MP group (P < 0·001). Perceived intensity of pain was negatively associated with atmospheric pressure in the MP group and positively associated with temperature and atmospheric in the MH group. Our results reveal that patients with masticatory muscle pain and patients with migraine present typical temporal pain patterns that are influenced in a different way by weather changes.     

Dentists' ability to detect psychological problems in patients with temporomandibular disorders and chronic pain

Do patients with temporomandibular disorders (TMD) have significant psychosocial problems? Research efforts have sought to determine if these problems exist, and if so, how they influence treatment outcome. Even when psychosocial factors do influence treatment outcome, identifying them by formal psychological tests can be time consuming and costly. Dentists' impressions of the psychological status of these patients were tested to determine if they are an effective method for screening psychological factors thought to influence treatment outcome. The results suggested that a screening procedure based on dentists' impressions from an initial examination do not adequately identify psychological problems in patients with TMD.