Micrometastatic bone marrow involvement: detection and prognostic significance

The present review focuses on the methodology and clinical significance of new diagnostic approaches to identify individual cancer cells present in bone marrow, both as a frequent site of metastasis formation and an indicator organ for hematogenous tumor cell dissemination. The steadily increasing number of studies on this issue is characterized by considerable methodological variations of important variables, such as the size of the study population, and the reliability of monoclonal antibodies used for tumor cell detection. Emerging data indicate that this disturbing heterogeneity might be overcome by the use of reliable and specific anti-cytokeratin antibodies (for example, A45-B/B3) as, for the time, standard markers for the detection of micrometastatic tumor cells in bone marrow. Prospective clinical studies have shown that immunoassays based on anti-CK antibodies identify patients' subgroups with a poor clinical prognosis with regard to early metastasis manifestation and reduced overall survival in various epithelial tumor entities, including breast, colon, rectum, stomach, esophagus, prostate, renal, bladder, and non-small cell lung cancer. The immunocytochemical assays may be therefore used to improve tumor staging with potential consequences for adjuvant therapy, because disseminated cells appeared to be dormant, non-cycling (for example Ki-67 antigen-negative) cells, suggesting a resistance to cell-cycle dependent therapy, such as chemotherapy. Therefore, cell-cycle independent antibody-based immunotherapy might be an interesting option to complement chemotherapy. Another promising clinical application is monitoring the response of micrometastatic cells to adjuvant therapies, which, at present, can only be assessed retrospectively after an extended period of clinical follow-up. The outlined current strategies for detection and characterization of cancer micrometastasis might help to design and control new therapeutic strategies for secondary prevention of metastatic relapse in patients with operable primary carcinomas.     

Clinical Relevance of Micrometastatic Disease in Patients with Solid Tumors

Distant metastases are the main cause of cancer-related death. The onset of the metastatic process can now be assessed in cancer patients by the use of sensitive immunocytochemical and molecular methods which allow the identification of single disseminated carcinoma cells or small tumor cell clusters in regional lymph nodes, peripheral blood, or distant organs. Among the distant organs, bone marrow is a common homing organ for disseminated cancer cells derived from various primary sites, and the presence of these cells predicts the occurrence of overt metastases in bone and other organs. The bone marrow is, therefore, a very useful indicator organ for the presence of disseminated cancer cells. The current assays for detection of micrometastatic tumor cells may be used to improve tumor staging with potential consequences for adjuvant therapy. Another promising clinical application is monitoring the response to adjuvant therapies, which, at present, can only be assessed retrospectively after an extended period of clinical follow-up. Moreover, tools recently established in several laboratories allow further insights into the phenotype and genotype of micrometastases. The available data indicate that micrometastatic cells represent a selected population of cancer cells that express a considerable degree of heterogeneity with regard to chromosomal aberrations and phenotypic properties. Identification of the molecular determinants of micrometastatic cells may help to design new strategies to detect and eliminate minimal residual cancer. The present review summarizes the current state of research on micrometastatic disease in patients with solid tumors.     

Clinical significance of occult metastatic cells in bone marrow of breast cancer patients

The early and clinically occult spread of viable tumor cells to the organism is increasingly considered a hallmark in cancer progression, as emerging data suggest that these cells are precursors of subsequent distant relapse. Using monoclonal antibodies to epithelial cytokeratins or tumor-associated cell membrane glycoproteins, individual carcinoma cells can be detected on cytologic bone marrow preparations at frequencies of 10(-5) to 10(-6). Prospective clinical studies have shown that the presence of these immunostained cells in bone marrow, as a frequent site of overt metastases, is prognostically relevant with regard to relapse-free and overall survival. This screening approach may be, therefore, used to improve tumor staging and guide the stratification of patients for adjuvant therapy in clinical trials. Another promising application is monitoring the response of micrometastatic cells to adjuvant therapies, which, at present, can only be assessed retrospectively after an extended period of clinical follow-up. The present review summarizes the current data on the clinical significance of occult metastatic breast cancer cells in bone marrow.     

Detection and clinical relevance of micrometastatic cancer cells

The failure to reduce mortality of epithelial cancer patients is probably a result of the early dissemination of cancer cells to secondary sites, which is usually missed by conventional diagnostic procedures used for tumor staging. Individual carcinoma cells present in regional lymph nodes, blood, or distant organs (eg, bone marrow) can be detected by sensitive immunologic or molecular methods. Because the goal of adjuvant therapy is the eradication of occult micrometastatic tumor cells before metastatic disease becomes clinically evident, the early detection of micrometastases could identify those patients who might benefit from adjuvant therapy. In addition, more sensitive methods for detecting such cells should increase knowledge about the biologic mechanisms of metastasis, which might improve the diagnosis and treatment of micrometastatic disease. In this article, the recent developments in sensitive assays used for the detection of individual micrometastatic cancer cells in patients with epithelial tumors are reviewed.     

Detection and clinical importance of micrometastatic disease.

Metastatic relapse in patients with solid tumors is caused by systemic preoperative or perioperative dissemination of tumor cells. The presence of individual tumor cells in bone marrow and in peripheral blood can be detected by immunologic or molecular methods and is being regarded increasingly as a clinically relevant prognostic factor. Because the goal of adjuvant therapy is the eradication of occult micrometastatic tumor cells before metastatic disease becomes clinically evident, the early detection of micrometastases could identify the patients who are most (and least) likely to benefit from adjuvant therapy. In addition, more sensitive methods for detecting such cells should increase knowledge about the biologic mechanisms of metastasis and improve the diagnosis and treatment of micrometastatic disease. In contrast to solid metastatic tumors, micrometastatic tumor cells are appropriate targets for intravenously applied agents because macromolecules and immunocompetent effector cells should have access to the tumor cells. Because the majority of micrometastatic tumor cells may be nonproliferative (G0 phase), standard cytotoxic chemotherapies aimed at proliferating cells may be less effective, which might explain, in part, the failure of chemotherapy. Thus, adjuvant therapies that are aimed at dividing and quiescent cells, such as antibody-based therapies, are of considerable interest. From a literature search that used the databases MEDLINE(R), CANCERLIT(R), Biosis(R), Embase(R), and SciSearch(R), we discuss the current state of research on minimal residual cancer in patients with epithelial tumors and the diagnostic and clinical implications of these findings.     

Enrichment methods to detect bone marrow micrometastases in breast carcinoma patients: clinical relevance

Introduction  

Improving technologies for the detection and purification of bone marrow (BM) micrometastatic cells in breast cancer patients should lead to earlier prognosis of the risk of relapse and should make it possible to design more appropriate therapies. The technique used has to overcome the challenges resulting from the small number of target cells (one per million hematopoietic cells) and the heterogeneous expression of micrometastatic cell markers. In the present study, we have assessed the clinical relevance of current methods aimed at detecting rare disseminated carcinoma cells.     

Recent advances in the detection of bone marrow micrometastases: A promising area for research or just another false hope? A review of the literature

The presence of early disseminated tumor cells (DTC), otherwise termed micrometastases or minimal residual disease, in the bone marrow (BM), or other secondary compartments, such as the blood and the lymph nodes, is the main reason for recurrence of patients with early stage epithelial cancers after “curative” resection of the primary tumor. There is increasing evidence, that the detection of DTC in BM aspirates may provide additional and independent prognostic information and aid in the stratification of these patients for adjuvant clinical treatment. However, the clinical relevance of micrometastases has not yet been firmly established. In addition, the molecular events and interactions that prevail in early metastatic disease and determine the formation or not of overt metastases remain poorly understood. The methods currently used for the detection of micrometastatic cells include extremely sensitive immunocytochemical and molecular assays, often in conjunction with enrichment techniques for the purification of tumor cells and additional increase of their sensitivity. Nevertheless, the specificity of these methods is mostly inadequate. After the impressive advances of molecular cytogenetics, a highly accurate and global assessment of the genetic status of tumors is now possible. Therefore, the greatest challenge of our time is the application of these novel technologies for the clarification of the key molecular events that initiate metastatic spread. This will further enable us to identify the highly specific and sensitive diagnostic and prognostic markers as well as the therapeutic targets which are so urgently needed.     

HER2 status of bone marrow micrometastasis and their corresponding primary tumours in a pilot study of 27 cases: a possible tool for anti-HER2 therapy management?

Discrepancies have been reported between HER2 status in primary breast cancer and micrometastatic cells in bone marrow. The aim of this study was to assess HER2 gene status in micrometastatic cells in bone marrow and corresponding primary tumour. Micrometastatic cells were detected in bone marrow aspirations in a prospective series of 27 breast cancer patients by immunocytochemistry (pancytokeratin antibody). HER2 status of micrometastatic cells was assessed by fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH), respectively in 24 out of 27. Primary tumour HER2 status was assessed by immunohistochemistry (CB11 antibody) and by FISH in 20 out of 27 of the cases. HER2 was amplified or overexpressed in five out of 27 (18.5%) primary tumours and in four out of 27 (15%) micrometastatic cells. In two cases, HER2 was overexpressed and amplified in primary tumour, but not in micrometastatic cells, whereas, in one case, HER2 presented a low amplification rate (six copies) in micrometastatic cells not found in the primary tumour. We demonstrated that negative and positive HER2 status remained, in the majority of the cases, stable between the bone marrow micrometastasis and the primary tumour. Therefore, the efficiency of anti-HER2 adjuvant therapy could be evaluated, in a clinical trial, by sequential detection of HER2-positive micrometastatic cells within the bone marrow, before and after treatment.     

Clinical relevance of occult metastatic cells in the bone marrow of patients with different stages of breast cancer

Data are emerging about the prognostic relevance of occult metastatic cells in the bone marrow of patients with various solid tumors. Discrepancies among different studies on the prognostic relevance of isolated tumor cells may be caused by tumor cell heterogeneity and the use of different immunoassays. There is increasing evidence that validated anticytokeratin antibodies (e.g., A45-B/B3) represent the present standard for the detection of isolated tumor cells. This immunocytochemical assay allows the identification of patients with occult tumor cell dissemination that cannot be identified by conventional screening methods in tumor staging. According to recent studies, these patients are at higher risk for subsequent development of distant metastases and might therefore benefit from early systemic therapy. At advanced stages of the disease, the micrometastatic tumor load after adjuvant therapy, or at the time of emerging recurrences, appears to reflect the tumor's ability to progress. Therapeutic monitoring and cell-cycle independent antibody-based therapy are among possible implications of this new, promising diagnostic tool. The present review also focuses on state of the art, reliable detection methods of occult metastatic cells in the bone marrow of breast cancer patients and on the prognostic relevance of these cells at different stages of the disease.     

Characterization of disseminated tumor cells.

The most prominent secondary organs screened for the presence of occult disseminated tumor cells are regional lymph nodes and bone marrow. The current data suggest that micrometastatic cells represent a selected population of dormant cancer cells, which still express a considerable degree of heterogeneity. The analysis of micrometastatic cells will open a new avenue to assess the molecular determinants of both early tumor cell dissemination and subsequent outgrowth into overt metastases. Moreover, identifying therapeutic target structures (e.g., HER2), monitoring the elimination of bone marrow micrometastases, and assessing treatment-resistant tumor cell clones may help in understanding the current limitations of adjuvant systemic therapy. This review summarizes the current knowledge on the biological characteristics of micrometastatic cancer cells in bone marrow and lymph nodes of cancer patients.     

Cellular proliferation and prevalence of micrometastatic cells in the bone marrow of patients with clinically localized prostate cancer.

The presence of prostate cancer cells in the bone marrow (BM) of patients with clinically localized disease is associated with an increased chance of disease recurrence; however, not all patients develop recurrence. We therefore sought to determine the phenotype of individual micrometastatic cells as a potential method to better predict disease outcome. Immunostaining was performed on BM cells from 46 patients whose BM RNA fraction had been identified to contain prostate-specific antigen mRNA. The prevalence of micrometastatic cells among BM mononuclear cells was determined using an anticytokeratin antibody. Mib-1 antibody was used to determine the percentage of micrometastatic cells that were proliferating. Micrometastatic cells were found in 96% of patient samples, with a 30-fold variation in prevalence ranging from 0.1-3.26/10(5) BM cells. Prior androgen ablation was associated with a reduced prevalence of micrometastatic cells (P = 0.010). In 68% of patients, some micrometastatic cells were judged to be proliferating at proportions ranging from 1 of 11 (9%) to 4 of 4 (100%). Higher Gleason score of the primary tumor was associated with a higher proliferative proportion of micrometastatic cells (P = 0.038). We conclude that, in patients with clinically localized disease, there is wide variability in the prevalence of micrometastatic cells and the proportion which are proliferating. Long-term follow-up will determine whether the development of clinically obvious metastatic disease is related to higher prevalence of micrometastatic cells in the marrow or the proportion that are proliferating.     

Biological Characteristics of Micrometastatic Cancer Cells in Bone Marrow

There is emerging evidence that epithelial tumor cells are able to disseminate to secondary organs at an early stage of primary tumor development. One of the most prominent secondary organs screened for this type of dissemination is bone marrow. Even in cancer entities where overt skeletal metastases are rare (e.g., colorectal and ovarian cancer), bone marrow is a prognostically relevant indicator organ for the presence of hematogenous micrometastases. The currently available data suggest that bone marrow micrometastases represent a selected population of dormant cancer cells which still express a considerable degree of heterogeneity. The analysis of micrometastatic cells will open a new avenue to assess the molecular determinants of early tumor cell dissemination and subsequent outgrowth into overt metastases. Moreover, monitoring the elimination of bone marrow micrometastases and identification of treatment-resistant tumor cell clones may help to increase the efficacy of adjuvant therapy. This review summarizes the current knowledge on the biological characteristics of micrometastatic cancer cells in bone marrow of patients with solid epithelial malignancies.     

Immunomagnetic detection of micrometastatic cells in bone marrow of colorectal cancer patients.

Detection of micrometastatic cells in bone marrow (BM) may potentially be of prognostic value in colorectal cancer (CRC). In the present study, we have evaluated our immunomagnetic detection method in model experiments and on BM samples from CRC patients. In repeated experiments, 11 of 12 CRC cell lines consistently bound MOC31 antibody-coated magnetic particles with an average of 98% of the cells being rosetted with the beads. When different numbers of CRC cells (20, 100, 200, and 1000) were admixed to 1 x 10(7) mononuclear cells (MNCs) from BM, a mean of 77% of the cancer cells was recovered. In BM samples obtained from CRC patients at primary surgery, rosetted tumor cells were detected in 46 of 275 samples (17%) upon screening of 2 x 10(7) MNCs/sample. The fractions positive were: 10% (5 of 49) in Dukes' A; 17% (20 of 115) in Dukes' B; 23% (18 of 78) in Dukes' C; and 9% (3 of 33) in Dukes' D. Of 206 control samples, three (1.5%) contained cells in BM that formed rosettes with the MOC31 beads. In positive samples, a median of eight tumor cells (range, 2-120) were identified per 20-microl examined fraction, representing about one-tenth of the total sample. The results demonstrate the feasibility of using the immunomagnetic method for detection of micrometastatic CRC cells. Furthermore, that screening of 2 x 10(7) MNCs in a BM sample can be completed in <3 h makes the method an attractive alternative to other techniques.     

Prognostic impact of micrometastatic tumor cells in the lymph nodes and bone marrow of patients with completely resected stage I non-small-cell lung cancer.

PURPOSE: This study was designed to substantiate the prognostic impact of occult micrometastatic tumor cells in the lymph nodes (LNs) and bone marrow (BM) in stage I non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients using cytokeratin (CK) as a micrometastatic marker and the relationship between the micrometastases in the LNs and BM. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A total of 2,432 hilar and mediastinal LNs were removed during surgery from 115 patients with completely resected stage I NSCLC. The LNs were analyzed for micrometastasis using immunohistochemistry with the biclonal anti-CK antibody AE1/AE3. BM aspirates from 115 patients were immunocytochemically stained with the monoclonal anti-CK antibody CK2. RESULTS: CK-positive (CK+) cells were detected in 42 (1.7%) of 2,432 LNs, in 32 (27.8%) of 115 patients, and in 32 (27.8%) of 115 BM aspirates. There was no relationship between the frequencies of CK+ cells in the LNs and in the BM. The patients with CK+ cells in the LNs had a poor prognosis by both univariate (P =.008) and multivariate analyses (P =.01), whereas the presence of CK+ cells in the BM did not allow prediction of survival (P =.32). The prognostic impact of LNs micrometastasis was independent even after adjusting for the status of BM micrometastasis. CONCLUSION: The detection of lymph nodal micrometastatic tumor cells provides an accurate assessment of tumor staging and has powerful prognostic implications for completely resected stage I NSCLC patients.     

Differential display analysis of breast carcinoma cells enriched by immunomagnetic target cell selection: gene expression profiles in bone marrow target cells.

The red bone marrow (BM) is an important indicator organ of hematogenous micrometastatic spread of carcinomas. Characterization of biological properties specific for BM micrometastatic cells, however, is technically challenging due to the limited number of target cells usually available for the purpose. This report provides referrals to qualitative gene expression profiling of BM micrometastatic cells enriched by immunomagnetic selection. First, an experimental strategy was used to study regulatory mechanisms involved when BM micrometastatic cells colonize distant organs. The MA-11 cells, originating from BM micrometastases in a breast cancer patient clinically devoid of overt metastatic disease, were injected into immunodeficient rats. Metastatic MA-11 cells were subsequently immunoselected from the resulting in vivo lesions. The selected cell populations were compared to the injected cells by differential display analysis, and several genes possibly involved in tumor cell invasion and proliferation were confirmed as differentially expressed among the various MA-11 cell populations. A direct approach to qualitative gene expression profiling of BM micrometastatic cells was also explored. Carcinoma cells were immunoselected from BM and axillary lymph nodes obtained from breast cancer patients, and the isolated cell populations were compared by differential display analysis. Two candidate genes, identified as factors involved in cellular growth control, appeared as differentially expressed by the target cells from BM. Our study provides detailed information on how to combine an immunomagnetic selection procedure and differential display analysis to reveal gene expression profiles that may characterize BM micrometastatic cells.     

Comparison of different techniques and markers in the detection of neuroblastoma cells in bone marrow and peripheral blood samples: are they really equivalent?

Neuroblastoma (NB) is the most common extracranial tumor in infancy and the fourth in childhood. Metastatic spread involves mainly vascularized tissues such as lymph nodes and bone marrow (BM). The spread of tumor cells to bone marrow is a grim prognostic indicator for patients with NB, which makes the search for BM infiltration of utmost importance for both staging and therapeutic purposes. However, despite the large number of reports concerning the usefulness and prognostic role of different methods and markers in the detection of metastatic NB cells, few papers have addressed the relative sensitivity and specificity of different techniques or different markers in patients’ samples, making the choice of the most suitable technique and/or marker in different clinical settings difficult. Although no conclusive remarks on the choice of the most suitable technique and marker to detect metastatic NB cells in patient samples can be drawn at present, the result of an analysis of literature strongly supports the use of sensitive quantitative methods when efficacy of non-conventional therapies need to be evaluated.     

Implications of occult metastatic cells for systemic cancer treatment in patients with breast or gastrointestinal cancer.

The early and clinically occult spread of viable tumour cells to the organism is becoming acknowledged as a hallmark in cancer progression, since abundant clinical and experimental data suggest that these cells are precursors of subsequent distant relapse. Using monoclonal antibodies against epithelial cytokeratins or tumour-associated cell membrane glycoproteins, individual carcinoma cells can be detected in cytological bone marrow preparations at frequencies of 10(-5) to 10(-6). Prospective clinical studies have shown that the presence of such immunostained cells in bone marrow is prognostically relevant with regard to relapse-free and overall survival, even in malignancies that do not preferentially metastasise to bone. As current treatment strategies have resulted in a substantial improvement of cancer mortality rates, it is noteworthy to consider the intriguing options of immunocytochemical screening of bone marrow aspirates for occult metastatic cells. Besides improved tumour staging, such screening offers opportunities for guiding patient stratification for adjuvant therapy trials, monitoring response to adjuvant therapies (which, at present, can only be assessed retrospectively after an extended period of clinical follow-up), and specifically targeting tumour-biological therapies against disseminated tumour cells. The present review summarises the current data on the clinical significance of occult metastatic cancer cells in bone marrow.     

Bone marrow contains melanoma-reactive CD8+ effector T cells and, compared with peripheral blood, enriched numbers of melanoma-reactive CD8+ memory T cells

Circulating melanoma-specific T cells can be frequently detected in patients with melanoma. Effective T-cell immunity and tumor surveillance, however, requires the presence of specific T cells in tissues populated by tumor cells. The bone marrow (BM) is a compartment frequently harboring micrometastatic tumor cells. Here, we compared directly ex vivo in peripheral blood (PB) and BM frequencies and differentiation phenotypes of T cells reactive with the melanoma-associated antigen tyrosinase and with autologous melanoma cells. Using intracellular cytokine and tetramer staining, we detected tyrosinase- and melanoma-reactive CD3+CD8+ T cells in the BM in similar or enhanced frequencies as in PB. Additional characterization of the differentiation subset using CD45RA and CCR7 revealed the presence of specific effector and memory T cells in the BM in all five patients analyzed. Remarkably, the frequency of tyrosinase- and melanoma-specific memory T cells was significantly increased in BM compared with PB. Thus, the BM may be an important compartment for tumor surveillance harboring a tumor-specific memory T-cell pool in addition to effector T cells.     

Molecular determinants of occult metastatic tumor cells in bone marrow

The success of mammographic screening for breast cancer is that it involves increasingly more patients with small primary tumors formerly thought to have an overall excellent prognosis. Yet, only approximately two thirds of these patients actually have this favorable prognosis, while the remaining third develops metastatic disease. Thus, there is emerging evidence that epithelial tumor cells can disseminate into secondary organs at an earlier stage of primary tumor development than appreciated by current risk classifications. Bone marrow is one of the most prominent secondary organs screened for the presence of disseminated tumor cells. The current data suggest that bone marrow micrometastases represent a selected population of dormant and heterogeneous cancer cells. The analysis of micrometastatic cells opens a new avenue by which to assess the molecular determinants of both early tumor cell dissemination and subsequent outgrowth into overt metastases. Moreover, identifying therapeutic target structures (e.g., HER2/neu), monitoring the elimination of bone marrow micrometastases, and assessing treatment-resistant tumor cell clones might help to understand the current limitations of adjuvant systemic therapy. This review summarizes the current knowledge of the biological characteristics of micrometastatic cancer cells in bone marrow of breast cancer patients.